Comparison of quantitative multiple-breath specific ventilation imaging using colocalized 2D oxygen-enhanced MRI and hyperpolarized 3He MRI

Free-Breathing Functional Pulmonary Proton MRI: A Novel Approach Using Voxel-Wise Lung Ventilation (VOLVE) Assessment in Healthy Volunteers and Patients With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease

BACKGROUND

In respiratory medicine, there is a need for sensitive measures of regional lung function that can be performed using standard imaging technology, without the need for inhaled or intravenous contrast agents.

PURPOSE

To describe VOxel-wise Lung VEntilation (VOLVE), a new method for quantifying regional lung ventilation (V) and perfusion (Q) using free-breathing proton MRI, and to evaluate VOLVE in healthy never-smokers, healthy people with smoking history, and people with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).

STUDY TYPE

Prospective pilot.

POPULATION

Twelve healthy never-smoker participants (age 30.3 ± 12.5 years, five male), four healthy participants with smoking history (>10 pack-years) (age 42.5 ± 18.3 years, one male), and 12 participants with COPD (age 62.8 ± 11.1 years, seven male).

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE

Single-slice free-breathing two-dimensional fast field echo sequence at 3 T.

ASSESSMENT

A novel postprocessing was developed to evaluate the MR signal changes in the lung parenchyma using a linear regression-based approach, which makes use of all the data in the time series for maximum sensitivity. V/Q-weighted maps were produced by computing the cross-correlation, lag and gradient between the respiratory/cardiac phase time course and lung parenchyma signal time courses. A comparison of histogram median and skewness values and spirometry was performed.

STATISTICAL TESTS

Kruskal-Wallis tests with Dunn's multiple comparison tests to compare VOLVE metrics between groups; Spearman correlation to assess the correlation between MRI and spirometry-derived parameters; and Bland-Altman analysis and coefficient of variation to evaluate repeatability were used. A P-value <0.05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

Significant differences between the groups were found for ventilation between healthy never-smoker and COPD groups (median XCCV, LagV, and GradV) and perfusion (median XCCQ, LagQ, and GradQ). Minimal bias and no significant differences between intravisit scans were found (P range = 0.12-0.97).

DATA CONCLUSION

This preliminary study showed that VOLVE has potential to provide metrics of function quantification.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2 TECHNICAL EFFICACY: Stage 1.

Assessing the pulmonary vascular responsiveness to oxygen with proton MRI

Ventilation-perfusion matching occurs passively and is also actively regulated through hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction (HPV). The extent of HPV activity in humans, particularly normal subjects, is uncertain. Current evaluation of HPV assesses changes in ventilation-perfusion relationships/pulmonary vascular resistance with hypoxia and is invasive, or unsuitable for patients because of safety concerns. We used a noninvasive imaging-based approach to quantify the pulmonary vascular response to oxygen as a metric of HPV by measuring perfusion changes between breathing 21% and 30%O2 using arterial spin labeling (ASL) MRI. We hypothesized that the differences between 21% and 30%O2 images reflecting HPV release would be 1) significantly greater than the differences without [Formula: see text] changes (e.g., 21-21% and 30-30%O2) and 2) negatively associated with ventilation-perfusion mismatch. Perfusion was quantified in the right lung in normoxia (baseline), after 15 min of 30% O2 breathing (hyperoxia) and 15 min normoxic recovery (recovery) in healthy subjects (7 M, 7 F; age = 41.4 ± 19.6 yr). Normalized, smoothed, and registered pairs of perfusion images were subtracted and the mean square difference (MSD) was calculated. Separately, regional alveolar ventilation and perfusion were quantified from specific ventilation, proton density, and ASL imaging; the spatial variance of ventilation-perfusion (σ2V̇a/Q̇) distributions was calculated. The O2-responsive MSD was reproducible (R2 = 0.94, P < 0.0001) and greater (0.16 ± 0.06, P < 0.0001) than that from subtracted images collected under the same [Formula: see text] (baseline = 0.09 ± 0.04, hyperoxia = 0.08 ± 0.04, recovery = 0.08 ± 0.03), which were not different from one another (P = 0.2). The O2-responsive MSD was correlated with σ2V̇a/Q̇ (R2 = 0.47, P = 0.007). These data suggest that active HPV optimizes ventilation-perfusion matching in normal subjects. This noninvasive approach could be applied to patients with different disease phenotypes to assess HPV and ventilation-perfusion mismatch.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We developed a new proton MRI method to noninvasively quantify the pulmonary vascular response to oxygen. Using a hyperoxic stimulus to release HPV, we quantified the resulting redistribution of perfusion. The differences between normoxic and hyperoxic images were greater than those between images without [Formula: see text] changes and negatively correlated with ventilation-perfusion mismatch. This suggests that active HPV optimizes ventilation-perfusion matching in normal subjects. This approach is suitable for assessing patients with different disease phenotypes.

Review of oxygen-enhanced lung mri: Pulse sequences for image acquisition and T1 measurement

Oxygen-enhanced MR imaging (OE-MRI) is a special proton imaging technique that can be performed without modifying the scanner hardware. Many fundamental studies have been conducted following the initial reporting of this technique in 1996, illustrating the high potential for its clinical application. This review aims to summarise and analyse current pulse sequences and T1 measurement methods for OE-MRI, including fundamental theories, existing pulse sequences applied to OE-MRI acquisition and T1 mapping. Wash-in and wash-out time identify lung function and are sensitive to ventilation; thus, dynamic OE-MRI is also discussed in this review. We compare OE-MRI with the primary competitive technique, hyperpolarised gas MRI. Finally, an overview of lower-field applications of OE-MRI is highlighted, as relatively recent publications demonstrated positive results. Lower-field OE-MRI, which is lower than 1.5 T, could be an alternative modality for detecting lung diseases. This educational review is aimed at researchers who want a quick summary of the steps needed to perform pulmonary OE-MRI with a particular focus on sequence design, settings, and quantification methods.

Quantitative Imaging Metrics for the Assessment of Pulmonary Pathophysiology: An Official American Thoracic Society and Fleischner Society Joint Workshop Report

Multiple thoracic imaging modalities have been developed to link structure to function in the diagnosis and monitoring of lung disease. Volumetric computed tomography (CT) renders three-dimensional maps of lung structures and may be combined with positron emission tomography (PET) to obtain dynamic physiological data. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) using ultrashort-echo time (UTE) sequences has improved signal detection from lung parenchyma; contrast agents are used to deduce airway function, ventilation-perfusion-diffusion, and mechanics. Proton MRI can measure regional ventilation-perfusion ratio. Quantitative imaging (QI)-derived endpoints have been developed to identify structure-function phenotypes, including air-blood-tissue volume partition, bronchovascular remodeling, emphysema, fibrosis, and textural patterns indicating architectural alteration. Coregistered landmarks on paired images obtained at different lung volumes are used to infer airway caliber, air trapping, gas and blood transport, compliance, and deformation. This document summarizes fundamental "good practice" stereological principles in QI study design and analysis; evaluates technical capabilities and limitations of common imaging modalities; and assesses major QI endpoints regarding underlying assumptions and limitations, ability to detect and stratify heterogeneous, overlapping pathophysiology, and monitor disease progression and therapeutic response, correlated with and complementary to, functional indices. The goal is to promote unbiased quantification and interpretation of in vivo imaging data, compare metrics obtained using different QI modalities to ensure accurate and reproducible metric derivation, and avoid misrepresentation of inferred physiological processes. The role of imaging-based computational modeling in advancing these goals is emphasized. Fundamental principles outlined herein are critical for all forms of QI irrespective of acquisition modality or disease entity.

Free-Breathing Phase-Resolved Oxygen-Enhanced Pulmonary MRI Based on 3D Stack-of-Stars UTE Sequence

Compared with hyperpolarized noble gas MRI, oxygen-enhanced lung imaging is a cost-effective approach to investigate lung function. In this study, we investigated the feasibility of free-breathing phase-resolved oxygen-enhanced pulmonary MRI based on a 3D stack-of-stars ultra-short echo time (UTE) sequence. We conducted both computer simulation and in vivo experiments and calculated percent signal enhancement maps of four different respiratory phases on four healthy volunteers from the end of expiration to the end of inspiration. The phantom experiment was implemented to verify simulation results. The respiratory phase was segmented based on the extracted respiratory signal and sliding window reconstruction, providing phase-resolved pulmonary MRI. Demons registration algorithm was applied to compensate for respiratory motion. The mean percent signal enhancement of the average phase increases from anterior to posterior region, matching previous literature. More details of pulmonary tissues were observed on post-oxygen inhalation images through the phase-resolved technique. Phase-resolved UTE pulmonary MRI shows the potential as a valuable method for oxygen-enhanced MRI that enables the investigation of lung ventilation on middle states of the respiratory cycle.

Time to get serious about the detection and monitoring of early lung disease in cystic fibrosis

Structural and functional defects within the lungs of children with cystic fibrosis (CF) are detectable soon after birth and progress throughout preschool years often without overt clinical signs or symptoms. By school age, most children have structural changes such as bronchiectasis or gas trapping/hypoperfusion and lung function abnormalities that persist into later life. Despite improved survival, gains in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV₁) achieved across successive birth cohorts during childhood have plateaued, and rates of FEV₁ decline in adolescence and adulthood have not slowed. This suggests that interventions aimed at preventing lung disease should be targeted to mild disease and commence in early life. Spirometry-based classifications of 'normal' (FEV₁≥90% predicted) and 'mild lung disease' (FEV₁ 70%-89% predicted) are inappropriate, given the failure of spirometry to detect significant structural or functional abnormalities shown by more sensitive imaging and lung function techniques. The state and readiness of two imaging (CT and MRI) and two functional (multiple breath washout and oscillometry) tools for the detection and monitoring of early lung disease in children and adults with CF are discussed in this article.Prospective research programmes and technological advances in these techniques mean that well-designed interventional trials in early lung disease, particularly in young children and infants, are possible. Age appropriate, randomised controlled trials are critical to determine the safety, efficacy and best use of new therapies in young children. Regulatory bodies continue to approve medications in young children based on safety data alone and extrapolation of efficacy results from older age groups. Harnessing the complementary information from structural and functional tools, with measures of inflammation and infection, will significantly advance our understanding of early CF lung disease pathophysiology and responses to therapy. Defining clinical utility for these novel techniques will require effective collaboration across multiple disciplines to address important remaining research questions. Future impact on existing management burden for patients with CF and their family must be considered, assessed and minimised.To address the possible role of these techniques in early lung disease, a meeting of international leaders and experts in the field was convened in August 2019 at the Australiasian Cystic Fibrosis Conference. The meeting entitiled 'Shaping imaging and functional testing for early disease detection of lung disease in Cystic Fibrosis', was attended by representatives across the range of disciplines involved in modern CF care. This document summarises the proceedings, key priorities and important research questions highlighted.

Ventilatory heterogeneity in the normal human lung is unchanged by controlled breathing

Measurement of ventilation heterogeneity with the multiple-breath nitrogen washout (MBW) is usually performed using controlled breathing with a fixed tidal volume and breathing frequency. However, it is unclear whether controlled breathing alters the underlying ventilatory heterogeneity. We hypothesized that the width of the specific ventilation distribution (a measure of heterogeneity) would be greater in tests performed during free breathing compared with those performed using controlled breathing. Eight normal subjects (age range = 23-50 yr, 5 female/3 male) twice underwent MRI-based specific ventilation imaging consisting of five repeated cycles with the inspired gas switching between 21% and 100% O₂ every ~2 min (total imaging time = ~20 min). In each session, tests were performed with free breathing (FB, no constraints) and controlled breathing (CB) at a respiratory rate of 12 breaths/min and no tidal volume control. The specific ventilation (SV) distribution in a mid-sagittal slice of the right lung was calculated, and the heterogeneity was calculated as the full width at half max of a Gaussian distribution fitted on a log scale (SV width). Free breathing resulted in a range of breathing frequencies from 8.7 to 15.9 breaths/min (mean = 11.5 ± 2.2, P = 0.62, compared with CB). Heterogeneity (SV width) was unchanged by controlled breathing (FB: 0.38 ± 0.12; CB: 0.34 ± 0.09, P = 0.18, repeated-measures ANOVA). The imposition of a controlled breathing frequency did not significantly affect the heterogeneity of ventilation in the normal lung, suggesting that MBW and specific ventilation imaging as typically performed provide an unperturbed measure of ventilatory heterogeneity.NEW & NOTEWORTHY By using MRI-based specific ventilation imaging (SVI), we showed that the heterogeneity of specific ventilation was not different comparing free breathing and breathing with the imposition of a fixed breathing frequency of 12 breaths/min. Thus, multiple-breath washout and SVI as typically performed provide an unperturbed measure of ventilatory heterogeneity.

Ventilation/Perfusion Relationships and Gas Exchange: Measurement Approaches

Ventilation-perfusion ( V ˙ A / Q ˙ ) matching, the regional matching of the flow of fresh gas to flow of deoxygenated capillary blood, is the most important mechanism affecting the efficiency of pulmonary gas exchange. This article discusses the measurement of V ˙ A / Q ˙ matching with three broad classes of techniques: (i) those based in gas exchange, such as the multiple inert gas elimination technique (MIGET); (ii) those derived from imaging techniques such as single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), positron emission tomography (PET), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT), and electrical impedance tomography (EIT); and (iii) fluorescent and radiolabeled microspheres. The focus is on the physiological basis of these techniques that provide quantitative information for research purposes rather than qualitative measurements that are used clinically. The fundamental equations of pulmonary gas exchange are first reviewed to lay the foundation for the gas exchange techniques and some of the imaging applications. The physiological considerations for each of the techniques along with advantages and disadvantages are briefly discussed. © 2020 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 10:1155-1205, 2020.

Quantitative Mapping of Specific Ventilation in the Human Lung using Proton Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Oxygen as a Contrast Agent

Specific ventilation imaging (SVI) is a functional magnetic resonance imaging technique capable of quantifying specific ventilation - the ratio of the fresh gas entering a lung region divided by the region's end-expiratory volume - in the human lung, using only inhaled oxygen as a contrast agent. Regional quantification of specific ventilation has the potential to help identify areas of pathologic lung function. Oxygen in solution in tissue shortens the tissue's longitudinal relaxation time (T1), and thus a change in tissue oxygenation can be detected as a change in T1-weighted signal with an inversion recovery acquired image. Following an abrupt change between two concentrations of inspired oxygen, the rate at which lung tissue within a voxel equilibrates to a new steady-state reflects the rate at which resident gas is being replaced by inhaled gas. This rate is determined by specific ventilation. To elicit this sudden change in oxygenation, subjects alternately breathe 20-breath blocks of air (21% oxygen) and 100% oxygen while in the MRI scanner. A stepwise change in inspired oxygen fraction is achieved through use of a custom three-dimensional (3D)-printed flow bypass system with a manual switch during a short end-expiratory breath hold. To detect the corresponding change in T1, a global inversion pulse followed by a single shot fast spin echo sequence was used to acquire two-dimensional T1-weighted images in a 1.5 T MRI scanner, using an eight-element torso coil. Both single slice and multi-slice imaging are possible, with slightly different imaging parameters. Quantification of specific ventilation is achieved by correlating the time-course of signal intensity for each lung voxel with a library of simulated responses to the air/oxygen stimulus. SVI estimations of specific ventilation heterogeneity have been validated against multiple breath washout and proved to accurately determine the heterogeneity of the specific ventilation distribution.