Relative contributions of systemic hemodynamic variables to cerebral autoregulation during orthostatic stress

A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression amalgamating the driven approaches used to quantify dynamic cerebral autoregulation

Numerous driven techniques have been utilized to assess dynamic cerebral autoregulation (dCA) in healthy and clinical populations. The current review aimed to amalgamate this literature and provide recommendations to create greater standardization for future research. The PubMed database was searched with inclusion criteria consisting of original research articles using driven dCA assessments in humans. Risk of bias were completed using Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network and Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies. Meta-analyses were conducted for coherence, phase, and gain metrics at 0.05 and 0.10 Hz using deep-breathing, oscillatory lower body negative pressure (OLBNP), sit-to-stand maneuvers, and squat-stand maneuvers. A total of 113 studies were included, with 40 of these incorporating clinical populations. A total of 4126 participants were identified, with younger adults (18-40 years) being the most studied population. The most common techniques were squat-stands (n = 43), deep-breathing (n = 25), OLBNP (n = 20), and sit-to-stands (n = 16). Pooled coherence point estimates were: OLBNP 0.70 (95%CI:0.59-0.82), sit-to-stands 0.87 (95%CI:0.79-0.95), and squat-stands 0.98 (95%CI:0.98-0.99) at 0.05 Hz; and deep-breathing 0.90 (95%CI:0.81-0.99); OLBNP 0.67 (95%CI:0.44-0.90); and squat-stands 0.99 (95%CI:0.99-0.99) at 0.10 Hz. This review summarizes clinical findings, discusses the pros/cons of the 11 unique driven techniques included, and provides recommendations for future investigations into the unique physiological intricacies of dCA.

Static autoregulation in humans

The process by which cerebral blood flow (CBF) remains approximately constant in response to short-term variations in arterial blood pressure (ABP) is known as cerebral autoregulation. This classic view, that it remains constant over a wide range of ABP, has however been challenged by a growing number of studies. To provide an updated understanding of the static cerebral pressure-flow relationship and to characterise the autoregulation curve more rigorously, we conducted a comprehensive literature research. Results were based on 143 studies in healthy individuals aged 18 to 65 years. The mean sensitivities of CBF to changes in ABP were found to be 1.47 ± 0.71%/% for decreased ABP and 0.37 ± 0.38%/% for increased ABP. The significant difference in CBF directional sensitivity suggests that cerebral autoregulation appears to be more effective in buffering increases in ABP than decreases in ABP. Regression analysis of absolute CBF and ABP identified an autoregulatory plateau of approximately 20 mmHg (ABP between 80 and 100 mmHg), which is much smaller than the widely accepted classical view. Age and sex were found to have no effect on autoregulation strength. This data-driven approach provides a quantitative method of analysing static autoregulation that can be easily updated as more experimental data become available.

Cerebrovascular regulation in patients with vasovagal syncope and autonomic failure due to familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy

INTRODUCTION

While there is strong evidence for autonomic involvement in cerebrovascular function acutely, long-term role of autonomic nervous system in cerebrovascular function has been controversial. We assessed autoregulation in 10 healthy individuals, nine patients with vasovagal syncope (VVS), and nine with Familial Amyloidotic Polyneuropathy (FAP), in response to head-up tilt test (HUTT).

METHODS

Arterial blood pressure heart rate, cardiac output, and bilateral cerebral blood flow velocity (CBFV) at the M1 segment of middle cerebral artery (transcranial Doppler ultrasound) were recorded during supine rest and 70° HUTT. Autoregulation was quantified using a validated nonlinear and nonparametric approach based on projection pursuit regression. Plasma adrenaline and noradrenaline were also measured at rest and during HUTT.

RESULTS

During supine rest and HUTT, plasma noradrenaline content was lower in FAP patients. During HUTT, VVS patients had a hyperadrenergic status; CBFV decreased in all groups, which was greater in FAP patients (p < 0.01). Healthy controls responded to HUTT with a reduction in CBFV responses to increases (p = 0.01) and decreases (p < 0.01) in arterial pressure without any change in the range or effectiveness of autoregulation. VVS patients responded to HUTT with a reduction in falling (p = 0.02), but not rising slope (p = 0.40). Autoregulatory range (p < 0.01) and effectiveness increased (p = 0.09), consistent with the rapid increase in levels of catecholamines. In FAP patients, the level of increase in range of autoregulation was significantly related to the magnitude of increase in plasma noradrenaline in response to HUTT (R² = 0.26, p = 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Autonomic dysfunction affects the cerebral autoregulatory response orthostatic to challenge.

Does oscillation size matter? Impact of added resistance on the cerebral pressure-flow Relationship in females and males

Sinusoidal squat-stand maneuvers (SSM) without resistance have been shown to produce ~30-50 mmHg swings in mean arterial pressure which are largely buffered in the brain via dynamic cerebral autoregulation (dCA). This study aimed to further elucidate how this regulatory mechanism is affected during SSM with added resistance (~20% bodyweight). Twenty-five participants (sex/gender: 13 females/12 males) completed two bouts of 5-min SSM for both bodyweight and resistance conditions (10% bodyweight in each arm) at frequencies of 0.05 Hz (20-s squat/stand cycles) and 0.10 Hz (10-s squat/stand cycles). Middle and posterior cerebral artery (MCA/PCA) cerebral blood velocities were indexed with transcranial Doppler ultrasound. Beat-to-beat blood pressure (BP) was quantified via finger photoplesmography. Transfer function analysis was employed to quantify dCA in both cerebral arteries across the cardiac cycle (diastole, mean, and systole). Two-by-two Analysis of Variance with generalized eta squared effect sizes were utilized to determine differences between resistance vs. bodyweight squats and between sexes/genders. Absolute mean and diastolic BP were elevated during the resistance squats (p < 0.001); however, only the BP point-estimate power spectrum densities were augmented at 0.10 Hz (p < 0.048). No differences were noted for phase and gain metrics between bodyweight and resistance SSM (p > 0.067); however, females displayed attenuated systolic regulation (p < 0.003). Despite augmented systemic BP during resistance SSM, the brain was effective at buffering the additional stress to mitigate overperfusion/pressure. Females displayed less dCA regulation within the systolic aspect of the cardiac cycle, which may be associated with physiological underpinnings related to various clinical conditions/presentations.

Prenatal exercise and cardiovascular health (PEACH) study: impact of acute and chronic exercise on cerebrovascular hemodynamics and dynamic cerebral autoregulation

We performed a randomised controlled trial measuring dynamic cerebral autoregulation (dCA) using a sit-to-stand maneuver before (SS1) and following (SS2) an acute exercise test at 16-20 weeks gestation (trimester 2; TM2) and then again at 34-37 weeks gestation (third trimester; TM3). Following the first assessment, women were randomised into exercise training or control (standard care) groups; women in the exercise training group were prescribed moderate intensity aerobic exercise for 25-40 minutes on 3-4 days per week for 14±1weeks. Resting seated mean blood velocity in the middle cerebral artery (MCAv_mean) was lower in TM3 compared to TM2 but not impacted by exercise training intervention. dCA was not impacted by gestational age, or exercise training during SS1. During SS2, dCA was altered such that there were greater absolute and relative decreases in mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) and MCAv_mean, but this was not impacted by the intervention. There was also no difference in the relationship between the decrease in MCAv_mean compared to the decrease in MAP (%/%), or the onset of the regulatory response with respect to acute exercise, gestational age, or intervention; however, rate of regulation was faster in women in the exercise group following acute exercise (interaction effect, p=0.048). These data highlight the resilience of the cerebral circulation in that dCA was well maintained or improved in healthy pregnant women between TM2 and TM3. However, future work addressing the impact of acute and chronic exercise on dCA in women who are at risk for cardiovascular complications during pregnancy is needed.

Intermittent Sequential Pneumatic Compression Improves Coupling between Cerebral Oxyhaemoglobin and Arterial Blood Pressure in Patients with Cerebral Infarction

This study aims to explore the effect of intermittent sequential pneumatic compression (ISPC) intervention on the coupling relationship between arterial blood pressure (ABP) and changes in oxyhaemoglobin (Δ [O₂Hb]). The coupling strength between the two physiological systems was estimated using a coupling function based on dynamic Bayesian inference. The participants were 22 cerebral infarction patients and 20 age- and sex-matched healthy controls. Compared with resting state, the coupling strength from ABP to Δ [O₂Hb] oscillations was significantly lower in the bilateral prefrontal cortex (PFC), sensorimotor cortex (SMC), and temporal lobe cortex (TLC) during the ISPC intervention in cerebral infarction patients in interval II. Additionally, the coupling strength was significantly lower in the bilateral SMC in both groups in interval III. These findings indicate that ISPC intervention may facilitate cerebral circulation in the bilateral PFC, SMC, and TLC in cerebral infarction patients. ISPC may promote motor function recovery through its positive influences on motor-related networks. Furthermore, the coupling between Δ [O₂Hb] and ABP allows non-invasive assessments of autoregulatory function to quantitatively assess the effect of rehabilitation tasks and to guide therapy in clinical situations.

Preliminary Evidence of Orthostatic Intolerance and Altered Cerebral Vascular Control Following Sport-Related Concussion

Concussions have been shown to result in autonomic dysfunction and altered cerebral vascular function. We tested the hypothesis that concussed athletes (CA) would have altered cerebral vascular function during acute decreases and increases in blood pressure compared to healthy controls (HC). Ten CA (age: 20 ± 2 y, 7 females) and 10 HC (age: 21 ± 2 y, 6 females) completed 5 min of lower body negative pressure (LBNP; −40 mmHg) and 5 min of lower body positive pressure (LBPP; 20 mmHg). Protocols were randomized and separated by 10 min. Mean arterial pressure (MAP) and middle cerebral artery blood velocity (MCAv) were continuously recorded. Cerebral vascular resistance (CVR) was calculated as MAP/MCAv. Values are reported as change from baseline to the last minute achieved (LBNP) or 5 min (LBPP). There were no differences in baseline values between groups. During LBNP, there were no differences in the change for MAP (CA: −23 ± 18 vs. HC: −21 ± 17 cm/s; P = 0.80) or MCAv (CA: −13 ± 8 vs. HC: −18 ± 9 cm/s; P = 0.19). The change in CVR was different between groups (CA: −0.08 ± 0.26 vs. HC: 0.18 ± 0.24 mmHg/cm/s; P = 0.04). Total LBNP time was lower for CA (204 ± 92 s) vs. HC (297 ± 64 s; P = 0.04). During LBPP, the change in MAP was not different between groups (CA: 13 ± 6 vs. HC: 10 ± 7 mmHg; P = 0.32). The change in MCAv (CA: 7 ± 6 vs. HC: −4 ± 13 cm/s; P = 0.04) and CVR (CA: −0.06 ± 0.27 vs. HC: 0.38 ± 0.41 mmHg/cm/s; P = 0.03) were different between groups. CA exhibited impaired tolerance to LBNP and had a different cerebral vascular response to LBPP compared to HC.

Determinants of cerebral blood flow velocity change during squat-stand maneuvers

The large changes in mean arterial blood pressure (MABP) and cerebral blood flow velocity (CBFV) induced by squat-stand maneuvers (SSM) make this approach particularly suited for studying dynamic cerebral autoregulation (CA). However, the role of other systemic determinants of CBFV has not been described and could provide alternative physiological interpretations of SSM results. In 32 healthy subjects (16 female), continuous recordings of MABP (Finometer), bilateral CBFV (transcranial Doppler, MCA), end-tidal CO₂ (EtCO₂; capnography), and heart rate (HR; electrocardiogram) were performed for 5 min standing at rest, and during 15 SSM at the frequency of 0.05 Hz. A time-domain, multivariate dynamic model estimated the CBFV variance explained by different inputs, corresponding to significant contributions from MABP (P < 0.00001), EtCO₂ (P < 0.0001), and HR (P = 0.041). The autoregulation index (ARI; range 0-9) was estimated from the CBFV response to a step change in MABP. At rest, ARI values (typically 5.7) were independent of the number of model inputs, but during SSM, ARI was reduced compared with baseline (P < 0.0001), and the three input model yielded lower values for the right and left MCA (3.4 ± 1.2, 3.1 ± 1.3) when compared with the single-input MABP-CBFV model (4.1 ± 1.1, 3.9 ± 1.0; P < 0.0001). The high coherence of the MABP-CBFV transfer function at 0.05 Hz (typically 0.98) was considerably reduced (around 0.71-0.73; P < 0.0001) when the contribution of CBFV covariates was taken into account. Not taking into consideration other determinants of CBFV, in addition to MABP, could be misleading and introduce biases in physiological and clinical studies.

Revisiting human cerebral blood flow responses to augmented blood pressure oscillations

KEY POINTS

Cerebral autoregulation is most effective in buffering against pressure fluctuations slower than 0.03 Hz (∼30 s). This suggests that frequency bands for characterizing cerebral autoregulation should be redefined Low cross-spectral coherence below 0.03 Hz highlights the limitations of transfer function approaches Haemodynamic changes induced by lower body pressure could not fully explain the differences in autoregulation estimated from spontaneous vs. augmented fluctuations, and thus, observations of spontaneous fluctuations should not be relied on whenever possible.

ABSTRACT

There is currently little empirical basis for time scales that are considered to be most significant in cerebrovascular counter-regulation of changes in arterial pressure. Although it is well established that cerebral autoregulation behaves as a 'high-pass' filter, recommended frequency bands have been largely arbitrarily determined. To test effectiveness of cerebral autoregulation, we refined oscillatory lower body pressure (LBP) to augment resting pressure fluctuations below 0.1 Hz by a factor of two in 13 young male volunteers, and thoroughly characterized the time and frequency responses of cerebral autoregulation. We observed that despite a threefold increase in arterial pressure power <0.03 Hz with oscillatory LBP, there was no change in cerebral blood flow power, indicating near perfect counter-regulation. By contrast, in the range 0.03-0.10 Hz, both cerebral blood flow and arterial pressure power more than doubled. Our data demonstrate that cerebral autoregulation is most effective in buffering against pressure fluctuations slower than 0.03 Hz (∼30 s). This suggests that frequency bands of interest should be redefined and recording length should be increased considerably to account for this. Furthermore, low cross-spectral coherence below 0.03 Hz, even when pressure fluctuations were augmented, highlights the uncertainty in transfer function approaches and the need to either report precision or use non-linear approaches. Finally, haemodynamic changes induced by LBP could not fully explain the differences in autoregulation estimated from spontaneous vs. augmented fluctuations, and thus, observations of spontaneous fluctuations should not be relied on whenever possible.

Cerebral blood flow changes during tilt table testing in healthy volunteers, as assessed by Doppler imaging of the carotid and vertebral arteries

•

Extracranial cerebral artery Doppler imaging show CBF changes during tilt testing.

•

Total CBF during tilt testing decreases 6% in healthy volunteers.

•

Flow decrease of internal carotid and vertebral arteries during tilting is similar.

Objectives

Using different techniques, reduction of cerebral blood flow (CBF) during orthostatic stress were demonstrated. One study reported flow reduction of the right internal carotid (ICA) and vertebral (VA) artery during orthostatic stress by Doppler imaging, with different effects on the 2 vessels. Global CBF changes, using this technique, have not been reported. Therefore, flow of the ICA, VA and global CBF were measured during head-up tilt testing.

Methods

33 healthy volunteers underwent tilt testing. At three time points (supine, half way and at the end of the test) Doppler imaging of the ICA and VA was performed, as well as PetCO2 measurements.

Results

Global CBF was significantly reduced by 4.5 ± 2.8% halfway the test and by 6.0 ± 3.4% at the end. All 4 artery flows were significantly reduced during the tilt, without differences between them. Despite small changes in PetCO2 there was a significant relation between de CBF decrease and PetCO2 decrease (p < 0.05).

Conclusions

Orthostatic stress in HV results in a small but significant reduction of CBF by a homogenous reduction in the four cerebral vessels and is modulated by PetCO2 changes.

Significance

CBF changes can be measured during tilt testing using Doppler VA and ICA imaging.

Human cerebrovascular function in health and disease: insights from integrative approaches

Background

The marked increase in the size of the brain, and consequently, in neural processing capability, throughout human evolution is the basis of the higher cognitive function in humans. However, greater neural, and thus information processing capability, comes at a significant metabolic cost; despite its relatively small size, the modern human brain consumes almost a quarter of the glucose and oxygen supply in the human body.

Fortunately, several vascular mechanisms ensure sufficient delivery of glucose and oxygen to the active neural tissue (neurovascular coupling), prompt removal of neural metabolic by-products (cerebral vasoreactivity), and constant global blood supply despite daily variations in perfusion pressure (cerebral autoregulation). The aim of this review is to provide an integrated overview of the available data on these vascular mechanisms and their underlying physiology. We also briefly review modern experimental approaches to assess these mechanisms in humans, and further highlight the importance of these mechanisms for humans’ evolutionary success by providing examples of their healthy adaptations as well as pathophysiological alterations.

Conclusions

Data reviewed in this paper demonstrate the importance of the cerebrovascular function to support humans’ unique ability to form new and different interactions with each other and their surroundings. This highlights that there is much insight into the neural and cognitive functions that could be gleaned from interrogating the cerebrovascular function.