Outcomes of Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection Cycles for Complete Teratozoospermia: A Case-Control Study Using Paired Sibling Oocytes

The effect of male factors on embryo morphokinetics: a retrospective analysis of 2726 blastocysts

PURPOSE

Male infertility may influence fertilization rates, embryo morphology, and implantation rates in in vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles. Oocyte competence plays a major role in embryo development, but there is a limited understanding of the connection between sperm quality, embryo development, and morphokinetic parameters using donor oocytes. The study evaluated if sperm quality may influence the morphokinetic parameters in IVF cycles.

METHODS

A retrospective multicentric observational cohort study included 747 ICSI cycles using donor oocytes with fresh or frozen sperm. Embryos were cultured in time-lapse incubators until the blastocyst stage. The population was divided into three groups according to sperm concentration, as control group (> 16 mill/mL), severe oligospermia (0-5 mill/mL), and moderate oligospermia group (5-16 mill/mL).

RESULTS

Morphokinetic analysis showed no difference in the time from the 2-cell to 6-cell stage of embryo development. A significant difference was observed on day 3 of embryo development, specifically at the 7-cell stage (t7), severe oligospermia 53.37 ± 9.81, moderate oligospermia 56.95 ± 9.78, and control 55.1 ± 8.85 h post-insemination (hpi) (p = 0.024), and 8-cell stage (t8), severe oligospermia 55.41 ± 10.83, moderate oligospermia 61.86 ± 12.38 hpi (p < 0.001), and control 58.61 ± 11.33. Accordingly, the synchrony of the four cleavages going from 4 to 8 cells (s3) was found statistically different among the groups in the severe oligospermia 8.05 ± 9.99, moderate oligospermia 11.66 ± 11.04 hpi, and control 8.55 ± 8.58 (p = 0.009). Morphokinetic time ranges were obtained for t6, t7, t8, and s3 in order to identify the good-quality blastocysts.

CONCLUSIONS

Poor sperm quality is associated with alterations in morphokinetic parameters on day 3 in IVF cycles with donor oocytes, underlining the important role of spermatozoa during embryo development.

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection versus conventional in vitro fertilisation in couples with males presenting with normal total sperm count and motility

BACKGROUND

Starting over 40 years ago, in vitro fertilisation (IVF) has become the cornerstone for fertility treatment. Since then, in 1992, Palermo and colleagues successfully applied the technique intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to benefit couples where conventional in vitro fertilisation (c-IVF) and sub-zonal insemination (SUZI) proved unsuccessful. After this case report, ICSI has become the treatment of choice for couples with severe male factor subfertility. Over time, ICSI has been used in the treatment of couples with mild male and even unexplained infertility. This review is an update of the review, first published in 1999, comparing ICSI with c-IVF for couples with males presenting with normal total sperm count and motility.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the effectiveness and safety of ICSI relative to c-IVF in couples with males presenting with normal total sperm count and motility.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the following databases and trial registers: Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), Embase (excerpta Medica Database), MEDLINE (Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online) and PsycINFO (Psychological literature database) for articles between January 2010 and 22 February 2023.

SELECTION CRITERIA

We included randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that compared ICSI with c-IVF in couples with males presenting with normal total sperm count and motility.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

We used standard methodical procedures recommended by Cochrane. The primary review outcomes were live birth and adverse events. Secondary outcomes included clinical pregnancy, viable intrauterine pregnancy and miscarriage.

MAIN RESULTS

The original review published in 2003 included one RCT. In this 2023 update, we identified an additional two RCTs totalling a cohort of 1539 couples, comparing ICSI with c-IVF techniques. Two studies reported on live birth. Using the GRADE method, we assessed the certainty of evidence and reported evidence as low-certainty for live birth. We are uncertain of the effect of ICSI versus c-IVF for live birth rates (risk ratio (RR) 1.11, 95% confidence interval (CI 0.94 to 1.30, I2 = 0%, 2 studies, n = 1124, low-certainty evidence). The evidence suggests that if the chance of live birth following c-IVF is assumed to be 32%, the chance of live birth with ICSI would be between 30% and 41%. For adverse events; multiple pregnancy, ectopic pregnancy, pre-eclampsia and prematurity, there was probably little or no difference between the two techniques. No study reported the primary outcome stillbirth. For secondary outcomes, we are uncertain of the effect of ICSI versus c-IVF for clinical pregnancy rates (RR 1.00, 95% CI 0.88 to 1.13, I2 = 45%, 3 studies, n = 1539, low-certainty evidence). Comparison of viable intrauterine pregnancy rates showed probably little or no difference between ICSI and c-IVF (RR 1.00, 95% CI 0.86 to 1.16, I2=75%, 2 studies, n = 1479 couples, moderate-certainty evidence). The high heterogeneity may have been caused by one older study conducted when protocols were less rigorous. The evidence suggests that if the chance of viable intrauterine pregnancy following c-IVF is assumed to be 33%, the chance of viable intrauterine pregnancy with ICSI would be between 28% and 38%. Miscarriage rates also showed probably little or no difference between the two techniques.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

The current available studies that compare ICSI and c-IVF in couples with males presenting with normal total sperm count and motility, show neither method was superior to the other, in achieving live birth, adverse events (multiple pregnancy, ectopic pregnancy, pre-eclampsia and prematurity), also alongside secondary outcomes, clinical pregnancy, viable intrauterine pregnancy or miscarriage.

Effect of early GnRH antagonist administration on assisted reproductive technique outcomes in normal responders

One of the main questions in assisted reproductive techniques is how to prevent premature LH surge using a variety of protocols depending on either pituitary down-regulation, in GnRH agonist protocols, or by receptors blockage, in GnRH protocols. It is possible to say that GnRH protocols are most popular nowadays. The study aimed to assess the effectiveness of early antagonist administration during days ≤6 and later antagonist administration on days >6 on assisted reproductive outcomes. Women admitted to the ART Department at the High Institute for Infertility Diagnosis and ART, Al-Nahrain University, Baghdad, Iraq were included in the study. Reproductive outcomes were evaluated in early ≤6 and late >6 antagonist administration in a total of 44 normal responders, as follows. Sandwich protocols in 14 patients that received antagonists in the first 3 days of the follicular phase and conventional flexible antagonist protocol in 30 patients. We compared the outcomes between the two groups. There were no differences between early antagonist administration ≤6 and late >6 days in the number of MII oocytes, 2PN, the number of transferred embryos, grades of the embryos, and pregnancy rates. However, there were statistically significant differences between the duration of stimulation and the total Gonadotropin dose required. There was no effect of antagonist administration on days ≤6 and >6 on controlled ovarian stimulation on assisted reproductive outcomes.

Assessing the impact of semen quality on embryo development in an egg donation model

OBJECTIVE

To investigate if any of the World Health Organization semen parameters and/or male age are associated with embryo development.

DESIGN

Retrospective chart review between January 2008 and May 2015.

SETTING

Academic fertility practice.

PATIENTS

Anonymous egg donors aged ≤30 years.

INTERVENTIONS

Chart review.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Sperm parameters were evaluated on a continuum and were dichotomized to determine if low values (strict morphology < 4%, concentration < 15 × 106, low motility < 40%) or older age (>50 years) are associated with embryo morphology. Repeated linear regression measures to determine the associations and multivariate testing to determine independent effects for each predictor were performed.

RESULTS

Three hundred eighty-four donors with 574 egg donation cycles were identified, and 205 subjects with 275 cycles were included in the final analysis. The mean donor age was 25.31 ± 2.81 years, with a mean antral follicle count of 28.09 ± 10.5. The mean male age was 43.25 ± 6.65 years. The mean World Health Organization semen parameters at fertilization were 55.8 × 106 ± 44.3 × 106/mL concentration, 44.8% ± 20.2% motility, and 6.9% ± 5.3% strict morphology. Neither male age nor sperm morphology was associated with embryo morphology. A low total motile count was significantly associated with a higher cell number in day-3 embryos and a 1.56-times higher chance of poor day-3 cell symmetry. There was no statistically significant difference in blastocyst formation, clinical pregnancy, or live-birth rates.

CONCLUSIONS

Although statistically significant, the effect of the low total motile count on day-3 cell number and cell symmetry are likely clinically insignificant. Male age, race, or poor sperm morphology were not associated with a poor cycle outcome or impaired embryo development. The use of intracytoplasmic sperm injection likely alleviates the negative effect of diminished semen quality on treatment outcome.

Air-Drying Llama Sperm Affects DNA Integrity

The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of air-drying preservation on llama sperm DNA. Semen collections were carried out using electroejaculation under general anesthesia. A total of 16 ejaculates were processed from 4 males (n = 4, r = 4). Each sample was diluted 4:1 in a collagenase solution in TALP media, then incubated and centrifuged at 800 g for 8 min. The pellet was re-suspended to a concentration of 20 million sperm/ml in TALP. Then the samples were placed onto sterile slides forming lines and were left to dry under laminar flow for 15 min. After this, the slides were placed into Falcon centrifuge tubes and kept at 5°C. Sperm characteristics (motility, membrane function, viability and morphology) were evaluated in raw semen and in the air-dried samples kept at 5°C for 30 min. DNA evaluation (integrity and degree of chromatin condensation) was carried out in raw semen and in the air-dried samples after 30 min, 7, 14, 21, 30, and 60 days after preservation. To compare raw semen to the air-dried samples, a Wilcoxon test was used for all sperm characteristics except for DNA, where a paired Student t-test was applied. A split plot design was used to compare chromatin condensation between the different periods of preservation and a Kruskal Wallis test was used to compare DNA integrity. Motility, membrane function, viability and sperm with intact DNA decreased in the air-dried samples (p < 0.05), while morphology and chromatin condensation were not affected (p > 0.05). No significant differences were observed in the percentage of sperm with condensed chromatin between the different periods of preservation (p > 0.05). On the other hand, a significant decrease in the percentage of sperm with intact DNA was observed as from day 7 of preservation (p < 0.05). In conclusion the air-drying process has a negative effect on llama sperm DNA, hence the media used will need to be improved to protect DNA and be able to implement this technique in this species.

Revisiting aneuploidy profile of surgically retrieved spermatozoa by whole exome sequencing molecular karyotype

Previous studies, including our own, have reported that spermatozoa isolated from the testis have remarkably higher occurrence of aneuploidy once isolated from azoospermic men. This notion, however, did not translate into a lower pregnancy rate nor a greater proportion of miscarriages. Indeed, ICSI offspring generated from surgically retrieved gametes did not suffer from increased karyotypic aneuploidy than children generated from ejaculated specimens. In recent years, aneuploidy assessments on a larger number of cells and utilizing more chromosome probes have reported a progressive decrease in chromosomal aberrations in spermatozoa directly retrieved from the seminiferous tubules. In light of the availability of more accurate molecular genetic techniques, we have decided to challenge the notion that sampling epididymal and testicular tissues yields spermatozoa with higher incidence of aneuploidy than those retrieved in the ejaculate. In a retrospective manner, we have carried out an analysis by FISH with 9 chromosome probes on at least 1000 cells from the ejaculates of 87 consenting men and the specimens of 6 azoospermic men, while spermatozoa of fertile donors were used as control. Aneuploidy by FISH yielded 0.9% for the donor control but rose in the study group to 3.6% in the ejaculated, 1.2% for the epididymal, and 1.1% for testicular spermatozoa. There were no differences in autosomal or gonosomal disomies, nor nullisomies. In this group, once the specimens of these men were used for ICSI, ejaculated spermatozoa yielded a 22% clinical pregnancy rate that resulted in 62.5% pregnancy loss. The surgically retrieved specimens yielded a 50% clinical pregnancy rate that progressed to term. To confirm our findings, in a prospective analysis, DNA sequencing was carried out on the ejaculates and surgical samples of 22 men with various spermatogenic characteristics. In this comparison, the findings were similar with actually a higher incidence of aneuploidy in the ejaculated spermatozoa (n = 16) compared to those surgically retrieved (n = 6) (P<0.0001). For this group, the clinical pregnancy rate for the ejaculated specimens was 47.2% with 29.4% pregnancy loss, while the surgically retrieved yielded a 50% clinical pregnancy rate, all progressing to term. A subsequent prospective combined assessment on ejaculated and surgically retrieved spermatozoa by FISH and NGS was performed on non-azoospermic men with high DNA fragmentation in their ejaculate. The assessment by FISH evidenced 2.8% chromosomal defects in the ejaculated and 1.2% in testicular biopsies while by NGS became 8.4% and 1.3% (P = 0.02), respectively. Interestingly, we evidenced a pregnancy rate of 0% with ejaculated while 100% with the testicular spermatozoa in this latter group. This indicates that improved techniques for assessing sperm aneuploidy on a wider number of cells disproves earlier reports and corroborates the safe utilization of testicular spermatozoa with a positive impact on chances of pregnancy.

Role of Abnormal Sperm Morphology in Predicting Pregnancy Outcomes

The evaluation of strict morphology for predicting successful pregnancy has been controversial, nevertheless remains an essential component of semen analysis. Patients with teratozoospermia (abnormal strict morphology) have traditionally been counseled to undergo assisted reproduction. However, recent studies suggest that patients with abnormal sperm morphology alone should not be precluded from attempting natural conception before undergoing assisted reproduction. The goal of this review is to provide an update on the evaluation of sperm morphology for prognosis in assisted reproductive techniques such as intrauterine insemination and in vitro fertilization with or without intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Additionally, we propose a logical approach to the evaluation of a patient with teratozoospermia seeking fertility treatment.