Transcriptome-wide In Vitro Effects of Aspirin on Patient-derived Normal Colon Organoids

Optimizing single-cell RNA sequencing methods for human colon biopsies: droplet-based vs. picowell-based platforms

Background & Aims

Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA) has empowered many insights into gastrointestinal microenvironments. However, profiling human biopsies using droplet-based scRNA (D-scRNA) is challenging since it requires immediate processing to minimize epithelial cell damage. In contrast, picowell-based (P-scRNA) platforms permit short-term frozen storage before sequencing. We compared P- and D-scRNA platforms on cells derived from human colon biopsies.

Methods

Endoscopic rectosigmoid mucosal biopsies were obtained from two adults and conducted D-scRNA (10X Chromium) and P-scRNA (Honeycomb HIVE) in parallel using an individual's pool of single cells (> 10,000 cells/participant). Three experiments were performed to evaluate 1) P-scRNA with cells under specific storage conditions (immediately processed [fresh], vs. frozen at -20C vs. -80C [2 weeks]); 2) fresh P-scRNA versus fresh D-scRNA; and 3) P-scRNA stored at -80C with fresh D-scRNA.

Results

Significant recovery of loaded cells was achieved for fresh (80.9%) and -80C (48.5%) P-scRNA and D-scRNA (76.6%), but not -20C P-scRNA (3.7%). However, D-scRNA captures more typeable cells among recovered cells (71.5% vs. 15.8% Fresh and 18.4% -80C P-scRNA), and these cells exhibit higher gene coverage at the expense of higher mitochondrial read fractions across most cell types. Cells profiled using D-scRNA demonstrated more consistent gene expression profiles among the same cell type than those profiled using P-scRNA. Significant intra-cell-type differences were observed in profiled gene classes across platforms.

Conclusions

Our results highlight non-overlapping advantages of P-scRNA and D-scRNA and underscore the need for innovation to enable high-fidelity capture of colonic epithelial cells. The platform-specific variation highlights the challenges of maintaining rigor and reproducibility across studies that use different platforms.

Two genome-wide interaction loci modify the association of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs with colorectal cancer

Regular, long-term aspirin use may act synergistically with genetic variants, particularly those in mechanistically relevant pathways, to confer a protective effect on colorectal cancer (CRC) risk. We leveraged pooled data from 52 clinical trial, cohort, and case-control studies that included 30,806 CRC cases and 41,861 controls of European ancestry to conduct a genome-wide interaction scan between regular aspirin/nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) use and imputed genetic variants. After adjusting for multiple comparisons, we identified statistically significant interactions between regular aspirin/NSAID use and variants in 6q24.1 (top hit rs72833769), which has evidence of influencing expression of TBC1D7 (a subunit of the TSC1-TSC2 complex, a key regulator of MTOR activity), and variants in 5p13.1 (top hit rs350047), which is associated with expression of PTGER4 (codes a cell surface receptor directly involved in the mode of action of aspirin). Genetic variants with functional impact may modulate the chemopreventive effect of regular aspirin use, and our study identifies putative previously unidentified targets for additional mechanistic interrogation.

Assessment of Colorectal Cancer Risk Factors through the Application of Network-Based Approaches in a Racially Diverse Cohort of Colon Organoid Stem Cells

Numerous demographic factors have been associated with colorectal cancer (CRC) risk. To better define biological mechanisms underlying these associations, we performed RNA sequencing of stem-cell-enriched organoids derived from the healthy colons of seven European Americans and eight African Americans. A weighted gene co-expression network analysis was performed following RNA sequencing. Module-trait relationships were determined through the association testing of each module and five CRC risk factors (age, body mass index, sex, smoking history, and race). Only modules that displayed a significantly positive correlation for gene significance and module membership were considered for further investigation. In total, 16 modules were associated with known CRC risk factors (p < 0.05). To contextualize the role of risk modules in CRC, publicly available RNA-sequencing data from TCGA-COAD were downloaded and re-analyzed. Differentially expressed genes identified between tumors and matched normal-adjacent tissue were overlaid across each module. Loci derived from CRC genome-wide association studies were additionally overlaid across modules to identify robust putative targets of risk. Among them, MYBL2 and RXRA represented strong plausible drivers through which cigarette smoking and BMI potentially modulated CRC risk, respectively. In summary, our findings highlight the potential of the colon organoid system in identifying novel CRC risk mechanisms in an ancestrally diverse and cellularly relevant population.

Genomic and epigenomic responses to aspirin in human colonic organoids

Aspirin (ASA) is a proven chemoprotective agent for colorectal cancer, though mechanisms underlying these effects are incompletely understood. Human organoids are an ideal system to study genomic and epigenomic host-environment interactions. We use human colonic organoids to profile ASA responses on genome-wide gene expression and chromatin accessibility. Human colonic organoids from one individual were cultured and treated in triplicate with 3 mM ASA or vehicle control (DMSO) for 24 h. Gene expression and chromatin accessibility were measured using RNA- and ATAC-sequencing, respectively. Differentially expressed genes were analyzed using DESeq2. Top genes were validated by qPCR. Gene set enrichment was performed by SetRank. Differentially accessible peaks were analyzed using DiffBind and edgeR. Peak annotation and differential transcription factor motifs were determined by HOMER and diffTF. The results showed robust transcriptional responses to ASA with significant enrichment for fatty acid oxidation and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) signaling that were validated in independent organoid lines. A large number of differentially accessible chromatin regions were found in response to ASA with significant enrichment for Fos, Jun, and Hnf transcription factor motifs. Integrated analysis of epigenomic and genomic treatment responses highlighted gene regions that could mediate ASA's specific effects in the colon including those involved in chemoprotection and/or toxicity. Assessment of chromatin accessibility and transcriptional responses to ASA yielded new observations about genome-wide effects in the colon facilitated by application of human colonic organoids. This framework can be applied to study colonic ASA responses between individuals and populations in future studies.

An Aspirin a Day: New Pharmacological Developments and Cancer Chemoprevention

Chemoprevention refers to the use of natural or synthetic agents to reverse, suppress, or prevent the progression or recurrence of cancer. A large body of preclinical and clinical data suggest the ability of aspirin to prevent precursor lesions and cancers, but much of the clinical data are inferential and based on descriptive epidemiology, case control, and cohort studies or studies designed to answer other questions (e.g., cardiovascular mortality). Multiple pharmacological, clinical, and epidemiologic studies suggest that aspirin can prevent certain cancers but may also cause other effects depending on the tissue or disease and organ site in question. The best-known biological targets of aspirin are cyclooxygenases, which drive a wide variety of functions, including hemostasis, inflammation, and immune modulation. Newly recognized molecular and cellular interactions suggest additional modifiable functional targets, and the existence of consensus molecular cancer subtypes suggests that aspirin may have differential effects based on tumor heterogeneity. This review focuses on new pharmacological developments and innovations in biopharmacology that clarify the potential role of aspirin in cancer chemoprevention.

Insights into Early Onset Colorectal Cancer through Analysis of Normal Colon Organoids of Familial Adenomatous Polyposis Patients

Early onset colorectal cancer (EOCRC) rates have increased in recent decades. While lowering the recommended age for routine colonoscopies to 45 may reduce this burden, such measures do not address those who develop CRC before that age. Additional measures are needed to identify individuals at-risk for CRC. To better define transcriptomic events that precede the development of CRC, we performed RNA-sequencing analysis in colon organoids derived from seven healthy and six familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) patients. This led to the identification of 2635 significant differentially expressed genes (FDR < 0.05). Through secondary analysis of publicly available datasets, we found that these genes were enriched for significant genes also present in FAP CRC and non-hereditary CRC datasets, including a subset that were unique to EOCRC. By exposing FAP colon organoids to a three-day ethanol treatment, we found that two EOCRC-relevant genes were also targets of CRC related lifestyle factors. Our data provides unique insight into the potential, early mechanisms of CRC development in colon epithelial cells, which may provide biomarkers for patient monitoring. We also show how modifiable lifestyle factors may further alter genes relevant to EOCRC, adding weight to the hypothesis that such factors represent an important contributor to increased EOCRC incidence.

DNA methylation analysis of normal colon organoids from familial adenomatous polyposis patients reveals novel insight into colon cancer development

BACKGROUND

Familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP) is an inherited colorectal cancer (CRC) syndrome resulting from germ line mutations in the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) gene. While FAP accounts for less than 1% of all CRC cases, loss of APC expression is seen in > 80% of non-hereditary CRCs. To better understand molecular mechanisms underlying APC-driven CRC, we performed an epigenome-wide analysis of colon organoids derived from normal-appearing colons of FAP patients versus healthy subjects to identify differentially methylated regions (DMRs) that may precede the onset of CRC.

RESULTS

We identified 358 DMRs when comparing colon organoids of FAP patients to those of healthy subjects (FDR < 0.05, |mean beta difference| = 5%). Of these, nearly 50% of DMRs were also differentially methylated in at least one of three CRC tumor and normal adjacent tissue (NAT) cohorts (TCGA-COAD, GSE193535 and ColoCare). Moreover, 27 of the DMRs mapped to CRC genome-wide association study (GWAS) loci. We provide evidence suggesting that some of these DMRs led to significant differences in gene expression of adjacent genes using quantitative PCR. For example, we identified significantly greater expression of five genes: Kazal-type serine peptidase inhibitor domain 1 (KAZALD1, P = 0.032), F-Box and leucine-rich repeat protein 8 (FBXL8, P = 0.036), TRIM31 antisense RNA 1 (TRIM31-AS1, P = 0.036), Fas apoptotic inhibitory molecule 2 (FAIM2, P = 0.049) and (Collagen beta (1-0)galactosyltransferase 2 (COLGALT2, P = 0.049). Importantly, both FBXL8 and TRIM31-AS1 were also significantly differentially expressed in TCGA-COAD tumor versus matched NAT, supporting a role for these genes in CRC tumor development.

CONCLUSIONS

We performed the first DNA methylome-wide analysis of normal colon organoids derived from FAP patients compared to those of healthy subjects. Our results reveal that normal colon organoids from FAP patients exhibit extensive epigenetic differences compared to those of healthy subjects that appear similar to those exhibited in CRC tumor. Our analyses therefore identify DMRs and candidate target genes that are potentially important in CRC tumor development in FAP, with potential implications for non-hereditary CRC.

Stem Cell Models for Breast and Colon Cancer: Experimental Approach for Drug Discovery

The progression of the early stages of female breast and colon cancer to metastatic disease represents a major cause of mortality in women. Multi-drug chemotherapy and/or pathway selective targeted therapy are notable for their off-target effects and are associated with spontaneous and/or acquired chemotherapy resistance and the emergence of premalignant chemo-resistant cancer-initiating stem cells. The stem cell populations are responsible for the evolution of therapy-resistant metastatic disease. These limitations emphasize an unmet need to develop reliable drug-resistant cancer stem cell models as novel experimental approaches for therapeutic alternatives in drug discovery platforms. Drug-resistant stem cell models for breast and colon cancer subtypes exhibit progressive growth in the presence of cytotoxic chemo-endocrine therapeutics. The resistant cells exhibit upregulated expressions of stem cell-selective cellular and molecular markers. Dietary phytochemicals, nutritional herbs and their constituent bioactive compounds have documented growth inhibitory efficacy for cancer stem cells. The mechanistic leads for the stem cell-targeted efficacy of naturally occurring agents validates the present experimental approaches for new drug discovery as therapeutic alternatives for therapy-resistant breast and colon cancer. The present review provides a systematic discussion of published evidence on (i) conventional/targeted therapy for breast and colon cancer, (ii) cellular and molecular characterization of stem cell models and (iii) validation of the stem cell models as an experimental approach for novel drug discovery of therapeutic alternatives for therapy-resistant cancers.

Stem Cell Models for Cancer Therapy

Metastatic progression of female breast and colon cancer represents a major cause of mortality in women. Spontaneous/acquired resistance to conventional and targeted chemo-endocrine therapy is associated with the emergence of drug-resistant tumor-initiating cancer stem cell populations. The cancer-initiating premalignant stem cells exhibit activation of select cancer cell signaling pathways and undergo epithelial-mesenchymal transition, leading to the evolution of a metastatic phenotype. The development of reliable cancer stem cell models provides valuable experimental approaches to identify novel testable therapeutic alternatives for therapy-resistant cancer. Drug-resistant stem cell models for molecular subtypes of clinical breast cancer and for genetically predisposed colon cancer are developed by selecting epithelial cells that survive in the presence of cytostatic concentrations of relevant therapeutic agents. These putative stem cells are characterized by the expression status of select cellular and molecular stem cell markers. The stem cell models are utilized as experimental approaches to examine the stem-cell-targeted growth inhibitory efficacy of naturally occurring dietary phytochemicals. The present review provides a systematic discussion on (i) conceptual and experimental aspects relevant to the chemo-endocrine therapy of breast and colon cancer, (ii) molecular/cellular aspects of cancer stem cells and (iii) potential stem-cell-targeting lead compounds as testable alternatives against the progression of therapy-resistant breast and colon cancer.

Aspirin's effect on kinetic parameters of cells contributes to its role in reducing incidence of advanced colorectal adenomas, shown by a multiscale computational study

Aspirin intake has been shown to lead to significant protection against colorectal cancer, for example with an up to twofold reduction in colorectal adenoma incidence rates at higher doses. The mechanisms contributing to protection are not yet fully understood. While aspirin is an anti-inflammatory drug and can thus influence the tumor microenvironment, in vitro and in vivo experiments have recently shown that aspirin can also have a direct effect on cellular kinetics and fitness. It reduces the rate of tumor cell division and increases the rate of cell death. The question arises whether such changes in cellular fitness are sufficient to significantly contribute to the epidemiologically observed protection. To investigate this, we constructed a class of mathematical models of in vivo evolution of advanced adenomas, parameterized it with available estimates, and calculated population level incidence. Fitting the predictions to age incidence data revealed that only a model that included colonic crypt competition can account for the observed age-incidence curve. This model was then used to predict modified incidence patterns if cellular kinetics were altered as a result of aspirin treatment. We found that changes in cellular fitness that were within the experimentally observed ranges could reduce advanced adenoma incidence by a sufficient amount to account for age incidence data in aspirin-treated patient cohorts. While the mechanisms that contribute to the protective effect of aspirin are likely complex and multi-factorial, our study demonstrates that direct aspirin-induced changes of tumor cell fitness can significantly contribute to epidemiologically observed reduced incidence patterns.

Drug-Resistant Stem Cells: Novel Approach for Colon Cancer Therapy

BACKGROUND

Next to breast cancer, advanced stage metastatic colon cancer represents a major cause for mortality in women. Germline or somatic mutations in tumor suppressor genes or in DNA mismatch repair genes represent risk factors for genetic predisposition of colon cancer that are also detectable in sporadic colon cancer. Conventional chemotherapy for colon cancer includes combination of 5-fluoro-uracil with oxaliplatin and irinotecan or targeted therapy with non-steroid anti-inflammatory drugs and selective cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors. Major limitations of these therapeutic interventions are associated with systemic toxicity, acquired tumor resistance and the emergence of drug resistant stem cells that favor initiation, progression and metastasis of therapy-resistant disease. These limitations emphasize an unmet need to identify tumor stem cell selective testable alternatives. Drug-resistant stem cell models facilitate the identification of new testable alternatives from natural phytochemicals and herbal formulations. The goal of this review is to provide an overview relevant to the current status of conventional/targeted therapy, the role of cancer stem cells and the status of testable alternatives for therapy-resistant colon cancer. Experimental models: Hyper-proliferative and tumorigenic cell lines from genetically predisposed colonic tissues of female mice represent experimental models. Chemotherapeutic agents select drug-resistant phenotypes that exhibit upregulated expressions of cellular and molecular stem cell markers. Mechanistically distinct natural phytochemicals effectively inhibit stem cell growth and downregulate the expressions of stem cell markers.

CONCLUSIONS

The present review discusses the status of colon cancer therapy and inherent limitations, cancer stem cell biology, potential lead compounds and their advantages over chemotherapy. The present experimental approaches will facilitate the identification of pharmacological and naturally-occurring agents as lead compounds for stem cell targeted therapy of colon cancer.

Novel insights into the molecular mechanisms underlying risk of colorectal cancer from smoking and red/processed meat carcinogens by modeling exposure in normal colon organoids

Tobacco smoke and red/processed meats are well-known risk factors for colorectal cancer (CRC). Most research has focused on studies of normal colon biopsies in epidemiologic studies or treatment of CRC cell lines in vitro. These studies are often constrained by challenges with accuracy of self-report data or, in the case of CRC cell lines, small sample sizes and lack of relationship to normal tissue at risk. In an attempt to address some of these limitations, we performed a 24-hour treatment of a representative carcinogens cocktail in 37 independent organoid lines derived from normal colon biopsies. Machine learning algorithms were applied to bulk RNA-sequencing and revealed cellular composition changes in colon organoids. We identified 738 differentially expressed genes in response to carcinogens exposure. Network analysis identified significantly different modules of co-expression, that included genes related to MSI-H tumor biology, and genes previously implicated in CRC through genome-wide association studies. Our study helps to better define the molecular effects of representative carcinogens from smoking and red/processed meat in normal colon epithelial cells and in the etiology of the MSI-H subtype of CRC, and suggests an overlap between molecular mechanisms involved in inherited and environmental CRC risk.