Mapping genes for polygenic disorders: considerations for study design in the complex trait of inflammatory bowel disease

The genetics of inflammatory bowel disease: diagnostic and therapeutic implications

BACKGROUND

The genetics of inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD) has brought new insight into the spectrum of disease phenotypes that are collectively labeled as either Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis. In concert with the pharmacogenomics of drug therapy, it has led clinicians to develop the notion of a more tailored approach to therapy.

DATA SOURCES

Articles were searched from PubMed (1995-2010) with key words "inflammatory bowel diseases", "Genetics", "pharmacogenomics".

RESULTS

Among all the putative susceptibility loci, the NOD2 gene has been the most studied and linked to an aggressive form of stricturing and perforating disease of the ileum. Other potential gene polymorphisms, including those encoding for the interleukin-23 receptor, have lent themselves to the recent development of potential novel immunosuppressive therapies. While the linkage of a number of autophagy genes with either Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis has provided insight into the innate adaptive immune pathway's response to commensual intestinal bacteria. Pharmacogenetic polymorphisms of azathioprine metabolism have been shown to predict toxicity to anti-metabolite therapy. Patients with absent thiopurine methyl transferase enzyme activity are at risk for irreversible bone marrow suppression, and are not considered good candidates for either 6-mercaptopurine (6-MP) or azathioprine therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultimately, the correlation between these genotypes and clinical phenotype of disease will inevitably lead to an improved understanding of disease natural history and a more tailored approach to therapy. Although there is ongoing debate as to whether these inherent differences in enzyme activity can predict responsiveness to anti-metabolite therapy, some gastroenterologists do find value in 6-MP metabolite testing as a means of monitoring patient compliance and tailoring the dose of anti-metabolite therapy based on a perceived therapeutic window. In the future, patients with IBD will ultimately be categorized based on their genomic imprint to allow for a better delineation of disease phenotype. Furthermore, the application pharmacogenomics of drug therapy into clinical practice will be pivotal in maximizing treatment response while avoiding untoward side-effects.

Familial aggregation of airway responsiveness: a community-based study

PURPOSE

We investigated the familial aggregation of airway hyper-responsiveness (AHR) to methacoline among randomly chosen families in a rural community in Anqing, China.

METHODS

Airway responsiveness (AR) to methacoline and related risk factors were assessed in each subject. We first modeled the within family correlation in AR and demonstrated the familial aggregation of this trait. Furthermore, we examined the effect size (e.g., odds ratio, OR) of this correlation in a "subsequent offspring model."

RESULTS

The correlation coefficient is significantly positive for parent-offspring and offspring-offspring pairs, but not significant in father-mother pairs, suggesting a genetic component. The strength of the relationships is in the order of father-offspring < mother-offspring < offspring-offspring. The OR of a positive AHR test for subsequent offspring who had mothers and an eldest sibling with positive AHR is 4.12 (95% CI, 1.72-9.87), compared with subsequent offspring whose mother and eldest sibling were negative in the test.

CONCLUSION

Our study supports a familial clustering of AHR in a Chinese population, which points to a role for genetic factors.

Inflammatory bowel disease: a complex group of genetic disorders

Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) are complex genetic disorders resulting from the complex interplay between several genetic and environmental risk factors. The number of IBD genes is currently unknown but it is expected to be equal or higher to 8. None of these genes are expected to be neither necessary nor sufficient for disease development. Among the candidate genes investigated to date, only CARD15/NOD2 has been definitively associated with Crohn Disease (CD) but not Ulcerative Colitis (UC). This gene explains about 20% of the genetic predisposition to CD. Because it is involved in the innate immunity, it allows to speculate that CD is the result of a defect in host-bacteria interaction. However, it is not known if CD is caused by specific bacteria or the gut flora as a whole.

Progress in searching for susceptibility gene for inflammatory bowel disease by positional cloning

Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) includes two clinical subtypes: Crohn disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC). The general prevalence is about 1.0%-2.0% in Western countries. It is predominantly regarded as a multifactorial disorder involving environmental factors and polygenic defects. The view was confirmed by a lot of evidences from clinical attributions and animal models, especially from epidemiological investigations. So the etiological study of IBD has been focused on searching for susceptibility genes by positional cloning, which consists of two steps: linkage analysis and association analysis. Linkage analysis has been an important method of searching for susceptibility genes to polygenic diseases as well as single-gene disorders. IBD, as a polygenic disease, has been widely investigated by linkage analysis for susceptibility gene since 1996. The paper reviewed 38 articles, which covered almost all original researches in relation to IBD and linkage analysis. So far, several loci, such as 16q, 12q, 6p and 3p, have been identified by the studies. The most striking is 16q12 (IBD1), which linked only with CD not UC in the majority of studies. Association analysis, as one essential step for positional cloning, is usually carried out by genotyping candidate genes selected by means of linkage analysis or other methods, for figuring out the frequencies of alleles and comparing the frequencies between IBD group and healthy control group to identify the specific allele. It has been established that IBD is implicated in immune disorder. So the studies were centered on the genes of NOD2/CARD15, HLA-II, cytokine, cytokine receptor and adhesion molecule. This paper reviewed 14 original articles on association between NOD2 and IBD that have been published since 2001. All results, with the exception of one report from a Japanese group, provide evidences that the three kinds of variants of NOD2 are susceptibility factors for IBD. This article also comprehensively analyzed 18 original researches of HLA gene polymorphism in IBD. We found extensive discrepancy among the conclusions and a novel hypothesis was put forward to explain the discordance. Most studies published recently on association between IBD and cytokine gene polymorphism were reviewed.

Identification of a quantitative trait locus for ileitis in a spontaneous mouse model of Crohn's disease: SAMP1/YitFc

BACKGROUND & AIMS

The SAMP1/Yit mouse strain develops spontaneous ileitis with histologic features of Crohn's disease. Disease expression in the SAMP1/YitFc subline (SAMP1/Fc) is partially inhibited by outcross to C57BL/6J (B6) mice, suggesting complex genetic control of disease susceptibility with both dominant and recessive determinants. We performed a genetic analysis of a (B6 x SAMP1/Fc)F(2) cross to localize the genes regulating intestinal inflammation in this model.

METHODS

A genome-wide scan was performed using a panel of microsatellite loci determined to be informative for this cross. Quantitative trait loci were identified with Map Manager QT using a serial regression approach. Positional candidate genes were selectively sequenced at the genomic level to identify potential susceptibility genes for functional screening.

RESULTS

A genome-wide scan of (B6 x SAMP1/Fc)F(2) mice identified a SAMP-derived quantitative trait loci with additive effects on chromosome 9 in a region likely to have been inherited from the AKR mouse strain. The candidate interval contains several genes of interest because of their potential role in either immune system function, intestinal epithelial function, or both. Suggestive evidence for additional loci was also observed on chromosomes 6 and X.

CONCLUSIONS

The SAMP1/Fc allele for a locus, designated Ibdq1, promotes inflammation-associated epithelial damage in these mice. Consistent with persistent mild ileitis in (B6 x SAMP1/Fc)F(1) mice, this locus appears to function in an additive fashion. Two genes in this interval, encoding the interleukin 10 receptor alpha chain and interleukin 18, are excellent candidates for Ibdq1.

Pharmacogenetic investigation of the TNF/TNF-receptor system in patients with chronic active Crohn's disease treated with infliximab

Infliximab (anti-TNF-alpha monoclonal antibody) induces remission in 30-40% of Crohn's disease patients. Treatment response is a stable trait. Two cohorts from independent, prospective clinical trials of infliximab in Crohn's disease were studied. Hypotheses were generated in an exploratory cohort (n = 90) and then tested in a confirmatory cohort (n = 444), using a statistical design, which is stable against type 1 and type 2 errors. In the exploratory cohort, the mutant 196Arg allele of TNFR-II (exon 6 polymorphism) and a novel silent polymorphism in exon 2 of TNFR-II were associated with lack of response to infliximab (83.3% in homozygote mutant 196 Arg patients vs 36.9% in heterozygotes and wild-type homozygotes (P = 0.036) and 85.7% in homozygote mutant exon 2 patients vs 36.1% (P = 0.01), respectively). None of the homozygote mutant individuals (0/6) achieved clinical remission, whereas the remission rate was 35.7% (30/84) in wild-type homozygotes and heterozygotes. In the large second cohort, the observed genotype-phenotype associations were not replicated. Other polymorphisms (TNF-alpha promoter -238, -308, -376, -857, -1031, TNF-R-I -609, +36 (exon 1), TNF-R-II 1663, 1690 (3'-UTR)) were not associated with treatment response in both cohorts (P > 0.5). None of the polymorphisms was associated with refractory Crohn's disease itself when compared to healthy controls. In a two-cohort study, a series of polymorphisms in the TNF, the TNF-R-I and in the TNF-R-II genes could be thoroughly excluded as pharmacogenetic markers for a treatment response to infliximab and as etiologic factors for Crohn's disease, respectively. The discrepancy between the two cohorts observed for the TNF-R-II exon 6 and exon 2 polymorphism may point to a weak effect on treatment response but also serves to illustrate the need for a sequential exploratory/confirmatory design in pharmacogenetic studies.

Evidence for a NOD2-independent susceptibility locus for inflammatory bowel disease on chromosome 16p

Heritable predisposition to inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) has been demonstrated by epidemiological and genetic analysis. Linkage of IBD to broad regions of chromosome 16 has been established by analysis of multiple populations. NOD2, located on proximal 16q, was recently identified as an IBD gene. As the linkage regions on chromosome 16 are large, we have investigated the possibility that NOD2 is not the only IBD gene located on this chromosome. A high-density experiment using 39 microsatellite markers was performed to identify additional regions of association, and to indicate areas of interest for further investigation. A triple-peaked configuration of the linkage curve with peak logarithm of odds (lod) scores of 2.7, 3.2, and 3.1 was observed on proximal 16p, proximal 16q, and central 16q, respectively. The cohort was stratified by coding individuals carrying the NOD2 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)8 and SNP13 "unknown." Significance at the central peak, corresponding to the genomic location of NOD2, then decreased from 3.2 to 1.2. The maximal lod scores on the proximal p-arm (lod = 2.1) and central q-arm (lod = 2.6) changed only moderately. An exploratory association analysis (TRANSMIT) yielded a strong lead at D16S3068 (P = 0.00028). The region around this marker was further investigated by using anonymous SNPs. An associated haplotype containing three SNPs was identified (peak significance P = 0.00027, IBD phenotype). On stratification based on NOD2 genotype, this significance increased to P = 0.0001. These results confirm the importance of NOD2 and provide evidence for a second IBD gene located on chromosome 16p.

Identification of novel polymorphisms in the beta7 integrin gene: family-based association studies in inflammatory bowel disease

Linkage studies from five groups worldwide have confirmed the presence of an inflammatory bowel disease susceptibility locus on chromosome 12q. Beta 7 integrin is a strong candidate gene within this region, and is involved in lymphocyte homing to the gut and retention of intra-epithelial lymphocytes. Monoclonal antibodies to beta7 integrin ameliorate colitis in animal models. We obtained genomic sequence for beta7 integrin, and screened all 16 exons and 1.7 kb of 5' promoter region for polymorphisms in 24 individuals. Fourteen single nucleotide polymorphisms were identified in total and, of these, two common (frequency > or =10%) intronic and two amino acid changing polymorphisms were assessed for potential disease associations. Data were available from 102 multiply affected inflammatory bowel disease families (affected sibling pairs) and 362 simplex (one affected proband) families containing 254 ulcerative colitis, 13 indeterminate colitis and 300 Crohn's disease trios (parents + affected child). No significant associations with any disease phenotype were found with the transmission disequilibrium test. Beta 7 integrin is unlikely to be involved in the genetic susceptibility to inflammatory bowel disease, and therefore future studies on chromosome 12 should focus on other positional candidate genes.

Cytokine gene polymorphisms and susceptibility to juvenile idiopathic arthritis. British Paediatric Rheumatology Study Group

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the involvement of candidate cytokine genes in the pathogenesis of juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA).

METHODS

Single nucleotide polymorphisms and intragenic microsatellite markers within 8 candidate cytokine genes (interleukin-1alpha [IL-1alpha], IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, interferon-alpha1 [IFNA1], interferon-gamma [IFNG], and interferon regulatory factor 1 [IRF-1]) were investigated in 417 Caucasian patients with clinically characterized JIA and a panel of 276 unrelated, healthy Caucasian controls, all from the United Kingdom.

RESULTS

A novel 3'-untranslated region (3'UTR) polymorphism in IRF-1 was found to be associated with susceptibility to JIA (corrected P = 0.002). No significant association with IL-1alpha, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, IFNA1, or IFNG was observed.

CONCLUSION

An association between JIA and a previously unreported 3'UTR polymorphism of IRF-1 was observed. This association was not found to be specific to any particular JIA subgroup. This suggests that IRF-1 may contribute to a common pathogenesis shared by all JIA patients, regardless of clinical phenotype. This is most likely to be a genetic contribution to the chronic inflammatory process that underlies JIA pathology.

Genomics and inflammatory bowel disease

Genomic technologies offer new approaches to the investigation of etiology and pathophysiology of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). Several areas of application for these new technologies are possible. One such application is the search for gene variations predisposing to the development of the disorder in multiply-affected families. Genome-wide linkage studies have defined replicated susceptibility regions for IBD on chromosomes 6, 12, and 16. These susceptibility regions are still very large and each contain several hundred positional candidate genes. Efforts are under way at several centers to define the underlying molecular variants using systematic linkage disequilibrium and candidate gene methods. The pharmacogenetic investigation of gene variations may predict response to certain medications to target these therapeutic interventions more precisely. The use of global gene expression technologies may allow the identification of new pathways or molecules in the inflammatory process. This seems to be especially relevant because currently only approximately 8,000 of the estimated 100,000 human genes are characterized. In summary, genomic methodologies will profoundly influence the progress of IBD research and may lead to novel insights into both etiology and pathophysiology of chronic intestinal inflammation.