Short stature before puberty: which children should be screened for SHOX deficiency?

Body proportions in patients with Turner syndrome on growth hormone treatment

BACKGROUND

: In this cross-sectional study, we aimed to evaluate auxological measurements and detailed body proportions of recombinant human growth hormone (GH)-treated patients with Turner syndrome (TS) and compare them with a group of healthy females.

METHODS

We evaluated 42 patients with TS who received GH treatment and 20 healthy controls. Anthropometric measurements were taken and target height, body mass index (BMI), arm span-height difference, extremity-to-trunk ratio, and Manouvrier's skelic index were calculated.

RESULTS

: The median (min-max) age of the patients at the time of evaluation was 13.6 (4.3-20.7) years, and the control group was 12.9 (3.8-23.7) years. Height, sitting height, and arm span of TS patients were significantly lower than those of the control group. Sitting height/height ratio (SHR) was in normal ranges in both groups and BMI was significantly higher in TS patients when compared to the control group. According to Manouvrier's skelic index, TS patients had shorter legs than the control group (p = 0.001). The extremity-trunk ratio was significantly decreased in TS patients compared to healthy controls (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference between the karyotype groups in terms of these indexes.

DISCUSSION

TS patients had short stature, increased BMI and waist circumference, normal head circumference, and decreased extremity-trunk ratio. Sitting height and leg length were short; however, the SHR standard deviation score (SDS) was in the normal range. Despite being treated with GH, TS patients had disproportionate short stature. The disproportion in TS patients was similar to short-stature homeobox-containing gene (SHOX) deficiency, which is considered to be SHOX haploinsufficiency in the etiopathogenesis of short stature.

Pubertal boy presenting with mild disproportionate short stature

A boy aged 12 years was referred with short stature. He was born at term, of adequate weight (10-25th centile) and length (10-25th centile), which settled to just below the third centile from 18 months of age, with a growth deceleration in the last 6 months (growth velocity -2.1 standard deviation score, according to Tanner charts). He was otherwise asymptomatic. His mother's height was 155 cm, and father's height 158 cm, and he was growing near his target height centile (-2.26 SDS, <3rd centile).On examination, his height was -2.22 SDS, with normal weight and body mass index (BMI). Pubertal stage corresponded to Tanner 2, with a testicular volume of 4 mL. His legs and forearms appeared shorter, with arm span/height ratio 0.93 (normal value >0.965) and sitting height/height ratio 0.56 (slightly above the normal upper value of 0.55). He resembled his father, whose wrists were abnormally curved (figure 1). The patient's hand X-ray showed that bone age was similar to chronological age.

Detection of SHOX Gene Variations in Patients with Skeletal Abnormalities with or without Short Stature

OBJECTIVE

SHOX gene mutations constitute one of the genetic causes of short stature. The clinical phenotype includes variable degrees of growth impairment, such as Langer mesomelic dysplasia (LMD), Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis (LWD) or idiopathic short stature (ISS). The aim of this study was to describe the clinical features and molecular results of SHOX deficiency in a group of Turkish patients who had skeletal findings with and without short stature.

METHODS

Forty-six patients with ISS, disproportionate short stature or skeletal findings without short stature from 35 different families were included. SHOX gene analysis was performed using Sanger sequencing and multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification analysis.

RESULTS

Three different point mutations (two nonsense, one frameshift) and one whole SHOX gene deletion were detected in 15 patients from four different families. While 4/15 patients had LMD, the remaining patients had clinical features compatible with LWD. Madelung’s deformity, cubitus valgus, muscular hypertrophy and short forearm were the most common phenotypic features, as well as short stature. Additionally, hearing loss was detected in two patients with LMD.

CONCLUSION

This study has presented the clinical spectrum and molecular findings of 15 patients with SHOX gene mutations or deletions. SHOX deficiency should be especially considered in patients who have disproportionate short stature or forearm anomalies with or without short stature. Although most of the patients had partial or whole gene deletions, SHOX gene sequencing should be performed in suspected cases. Furthermore, conductive hearing loss may rarely accompany these clinical manifestations.

Short stature and SHOX (Short stature homeobox) variants-efficacy of screening using various strategies

Background

SHOX mutations have previously been described as causes of Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis (LWD), Langer mesomelic dysplasia (LMD), and idiopathic short stature. The loss of X chromosome—Turner syndrome or mosaic 45,X/46,XX or 46,XY—also leads to the heterozygous loss of SHOX in patients with short stature only or with features similar to LWD. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of the targeted screening for SHOX variants, which involved different methods in the laboratory analysis of short stature. We determined the significance and positive predictive value of short stature for the detection of SHOX variants.

Methods

Targeted screening for variants in SHOX involving MLPA, sequencing, karyotyping and FISH was performed in the short stature cohort (N = 174) and control cohort (N = 91). The significance of short stature and particular characteristics for the detection of SHOX variants was determined by Fisher’s exact test, and the probability of SHOX mutation occurrence was calculated using a forward/stepwise logistic regression model.

Results

In total, 27 and 15 variants influencing SHOX were detected in the short stature and control cohorts, respectively (p > 0.01). Sex chromosome aberrations and pathogenic CNV resulting in diagnosis were detected in eight (4.6%) and five (2.9%) patients of the short stature group and three (3.3%) and one (1.1%) individuals of the control group. VUS variants were discovered in 14 (8.0%) and 11 (12.1%) individuals of the short stature and control groups, respectively. MLPA demonstrated the detection rate of 13.22%, and it can be used as a frontline method for detection of aberrations involving SHOX. However, only mosaicism of monosomy X with a higher frequency of monosomic cells could be reliably discovered by this method. Karyotyping and FISH can compensate for this limitation; their detection rates in short stature group were 3.55% and 13.46% (N = 52), respectively. FISH proved to be more effective than karyotyping in the study as it could reveal cryptic mosaics in some cases where karyotyping initially failed to detect such a clone. We suggest adding FISH on different tissue than peripheral blood to verify sex-chromosome constitution, especially in cases with karyotypes: 45,X; mosaic 45,X/46,XX or 46,XY; 46,Xidic(Y) detected from blood; in children, where mosaic 45,X was detected prenatally but was not confirmed from peripheral blood. The correlation of short stature with the occurrence of SHOX mutations was insignificant and short stature demonstrates a low positive predictive value-15.5% as unique indicator for SHOX mutations. The typical skeletal signs of LWD, including Madelung deformity and disproportionate growth, positively correlate with the findings of pathogenic SHOX variants (p < 0.01) by Fisher’s exact test but not with the findings of VUS variants in SHOX which are more prevalent in the individuals with idiopathic short stature or in the individuals with normal height.

Clinical and Genetic Characteristics of 23 Korean Patients with Haploinsufficiency of the Short-stature Homeobox-containing Gene

BACKGROUND

The short-stature homeobox-containing gene (SHOX) is one of the major growth genes in humans. The clinical spectrum of SHOX haploinsufficiency ranges from Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis to idiopathic short stature. Herein, we describe the clinical and genetic characteristics of 23 Korean patients with SHOX deficiency disorders.

METHODS

Medical records of 23 patients (19 females and 4 males) from 15 unrelated families who were genetically confirmed to have SHOX deficiency were retrospectively reviewed. SHOX gene deletions or mutations were determined by sequence analyses using multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, chromosomal microarray, and/or Sanger sequencing methods.

RESULTS

In the 15 families, 9 probands were de novo cases. All 23 patients showed mesomelia. Madelung deformity and tibia vara were observed in 13 (56.5%) and 3 (13.1%) patients, respectively. Genetically, 11 (73.3%) of the 15 families showed SHOX deletions of various sizes, and the other 4 families harboured SHOX sequence variants. Four patients had undergone orthopaedic surgeries (3 for tibia vara and 1 for Madelung deformity). Among 7 patients who had received growth hormone treatment for ≥1 year, 5 showed good responses, with a median first-year change-in-height standard deviation score of +0.6. There were no significant differences in the clinical characteristics of the deletion and point mutation groups.

CONCLUSIONS

A high index of suspicion and the genetic confirmation of SHOX deficiency are helpful for the timely management of the condition and are needed to provide genetic counselling to the family members of the patients.

Novel Clinical Criteria Allow Detection of Short Stature Homeobox-Containing Gene Haploinsufficiency Caused by Either Gene or Enhancer Region Defects

INTRODUCTION

Short stature homeobox-containing gene (SHOX) haploinsufficiency is associated with short stature, Madelung deformity and mesomelia. Current clinical screening tools are based on patients with intragenic variants or deletions. However, recent discoveries showed that deletions of the enhancer elements are quite common. The majority of these patients show less body disproportion and respond better to recombinant human growth hormone treatment. We redefined clinical criteria for genetic analysis to facilitate detection of the full spectrum of SHOX haploinsufficiency.

METHODS

We analyzed 51 children with SHOX variants or deletions and 25 children with a deletion in its enhancer region. Data were compared to 277 children referred for suspicion of growth failure without endocrine or genetic pathology.

RESULTS

Only half of the patients with an enhancer region deletion fulfilled any of the current screening criteria. We propose new clinical criteria based on sitting height to height ratio >1 SDS or arm span ≥3 cm below height, with a sensitivity of 99%. When these criteria are combined with obligatory short stature, the sensitivity to detect SHOX haploinsufficiency is 68.1%, the specificity 80.6%, and the number needed to screen 21 patients.

CONCLUSION

Novel clinical criteria for screening for SHOX haploinsufficiency allow the detection of patients within the full genetic spectrum, that is, intragenic variants and enhancer region deletions.

Improving clinical diagnosis in SHOX deficiency: the importance of growth velocity

BackgroundThe aim of this study was to estimate the prevalence of haploinsufficiency of short stature homeobox containing gene (SHOX) deficiency (SHOXD) in a population of short-statured children, and to analyze their phenotype and the performance of clinical scores.MethodsScreening for SHOXD was performed in 281 children with short stature by direct sequencing and multiplex ligation probe-dependent amplification. Subjects with SHOXD were compared with 117 matched short patients without SHOXD. We calculated the cutoff of growth velocity associated with the highest sensitivity and specificity as a screening test for SHOXD by receiver operating characteristic curves.ResultsThe prevalence of SHOXD was 6.8%. Subjects with SHOXD showed a lower growth velocity (P<0.05) and a higher prevalence of dysmorphic signs. The best cutoff for growth velocity was -1.5 standard deviation score (SDS) both in the whole population and in subjects with a Rappold score <7 and <4 points. Growth velocity was ≤-1.5 SDS or Rappold score was >7/>4 points in 17/17 of 19 children with SHOXD and in 49/65 of 117 subjects without SHOX mutations.ConclusionsGrowth rate ≤-1.5 SDS, even with negative Rappold score, may be useful to detect precociously children with SHOXD. Selecting children deserving the genetic test by using growth velocity or the Rappold score significantly increases the sensitivity in detecting mutations and decreases the specificity.

SHOX deficiency in short Taiwanese children: A single-center experience

BACKGROUND

SHOX deficiency is a common cause of idiopathic short stature. The aim of this study was to describe the clinical characteristics and molecular findings of patients with SHOX deficiency in Taiwan.

METHODS

A phenotype scoring system was used to evaluate several anthropometric measures in patients with idiopathic short stature. Twenty-three patients with a phenotype score >7 were enrolled for SHOX gene analysis by MLPA and sequencing. Another patient with a deletion/insertion of the short arm of the X chromosome containing the SHOX gene was enrolled for the assessment.

RESULTS

SHOX deficiency was detected in 26% of short children with a phenotype score >7. The arm-span-to-height ratio was significantly lower in SHOX-D patients than in non-SHOX-D patients. In patients with SHOX deficiency, an arm-span-to-height ratio <96.5% and short forearm were the most common characteristics. Three patients also exhibited typical radiological findings. A molecular analysis of the SHOX gene revealed five patients with intragenic deletions, one with a deletion in the regulatory region, and one with a missense mutation at exon 5.

CONCLUSION

The phenotype scoring system is useful to select children with SHOX deficiency in Taiwan. Family history and radiological image of the radius are also of value for the diagnosis. This study may aid physicians in the early diagnosis of children with SHOX deficiency.

Genotype-Phenotype Relationship in Patients and Relatives with SHOX Region Anomalies in the French Population

BACKGROUND

The aim of our study was to describe a large population with anomalies involving the SHOX region, responsible for idiopathic short stature and Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis (LWD), and to identify a possible genotype/phenotype correlation.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective multicenter study on French subjects with a SHOX region anomaly diagnosed by multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification or Sanger sequencing. Phenotypes were collected in each of the 7 genetic laboratories practicing this technique for SHOX analysis.

RESULTS

Among 205 index cases and 100 related cases, 91.3% had LWD. For index cases, median age at evaluation was 11.7 (9.0; 15.9) years and mean height standard deviation score was -2.3 ± 1.1. A deletion of either SHOX or PAR1 or both was found in 74% of patients. Duplications and point mutations/indels affected 8 and 18% of the population, respectively. Genotype-phenotype correlation showed that deletions were more frequently associated with Madelung deformity and mesomelic shortening in girls, as well as with presence of radiologic anomalies, than duplications.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results highlight genotype-phenotype relationships in the French population with a SHOX defect and provide new information showing that clinical expression is milder in cases of duplication compared to deletions.

Safety Outcomes and Near-Adult Height Gain of Growth Hormone-Treated Children with SHOX Deficiency: Data from an Observational Study and a Clinical Trial

BACKGROUND/AIMS

To assess auxological and safety data for growth hormone (GH)-treated children with SHOX deficiency.

METHODS

Data were examined for GH-treated SHOX-deficient children (n = 521) from the observational Genetics and Neuroendocrinology of Short Stature International Study (GeNeSIS). For patients with near-adult height information, GeNeSIS results (n = 90) were compared with a clinical trial (n = 28) of SHOX-deficient patients. Near-adult height was expressed as standard deviation score (SDS) for chronological age, potentially increasing the observed effect of treatment.

RESULTS

Most SHOX-deficient patients in GeNeSIS had diagnoses of Leri-Weill syndrome (n = 292) or non-syndromic short stature (n = 228). For GeNeSIS patients with near-adult height data, mean age at GH treatment start was 11.0 years, treatment duration 4.4 years, and height SDS gain 0.83 (95% confidence interval 0.49-1.17). Respective ages, GH treatment durations and height SDS gains for GeNeSIS patients prepubertal at baseline (n = 42) were 9.2 years, 6.0 years and 1.19 (0.76-1.62), and for the clinical trial cohort they were 9.2 years, 6.0 years and 1.25 (0.92-1.58). No new GH-related safety concerns were identified.

CONCLUSION

Patients with SHOX deficiency who had started GH treatment before puberty in routine clinical practice had a similar height gain to that of patients in the clinical trial on which approval for the indication was based, with no new safety concerns.

Awareness Campaign for the Early Detection of Growth Disorders in Public School Children in North Lebanon

OBJECTIVE

To detect and screen growth anomaly among children in North Lebanon, raise awareness on the importance of regular height check, and establish recommendations for the authorities.

DESIGN

18-month campaign.

SETTING

230 public schools in North Lebanon.

PARTICIPANTS

41,347 children, aged 5-15 years.

INTERVENTIONS

Weight was measured using a standardized stadiometer and compared with French curves of height-for-age. Awareness was raised by promoting early detection of growth disorders in Lebanon. The follow-up phase was intended to secure referral and treatment of the detected short stature children.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Age, sex, height, societal issues.

RESULTS

40,023 students were recruited from 228 schools; of these, 63.7% of the screened children were aged 5-10 years. Four percent (1,631 children) of the screened population presented short stature, of whom 50% were aged 5-10 years and 41% were more severely affected and referred to specialists; 59% were first directed to the school physician/pediatrician. The follow-up phase was not achieved because of the patients' low socioeconomic level. We also found that many children were too old for the attended level at school, mainly because of low socioeconomic levels and educational backwardness.

CONCLUSIONS

Our screening campaign confirms the need for more awareness on the importance of early detection of growth retardation in Lebanon. It highlights the need for making efforts to reduce poverty and its consequences in North Lebanon. Our future goal is to expand our campaign throughout Lebanon and cooperate with health authorities to lower the cost of work-up on the patient.

Short Stature in Isodicentric Y Chromosome and Three Copies of the SHOX Gene: Clinical Report and Review of Literature

Short stature homeobox gene (SHOX) mutations and pseudoautosomal region 1 (PAR1) deletions encompassing SHOX are known causes of Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis and isolated short stature, while 3 copies of SHOX in cases with triple sex chromosome constitution are responsible for tall stature. Duplications involving SHOX have been rarely reported, and they were found in individuals with short, normal and tall stature. An adopted boy with short stature, isodicentric Y chromosome and 3 copies of SHOX is described. Normal growth hormone (GH) secretion and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1) increase during an IGF1 generation test were found, ruling out impaired GH-IGF1 axis. No other organic or psychiatric causes of impaired growth were found. GH treatment improved linear growth, as reported in children with SHOX haploinsufficiency. This new report and the review of literature support that SHOX duplication may cause short stature, especially in those children with duplications of the 5'SHOX regulatory elements. Chromosome analysis and detailed molecular characterization of the duplicated region should be warranted in individuals with SHOX duplications in order to investigate the presence of occult chromosome imbalance. Additional reports and follow-up till adult height are needed to give conclusions on long-term efficacy and safety of GH treatment in short children with SHOX duplication.

Skeletal Deformity Associated with SHOX Deficiency

SHOX haploinsufficiency due to mutations in the coding exons or microdeletions involving the coding exons and/or the enhancer regions accounts for approximately 80% and 2-16% of genetic causes of Leri-Weill dyschondrosteosis and idiopathic short stature, respectively. The most characteristic feature in patients with SHOX deficiency is Madelung deformity, a cluster of anatomical changes in the wrist that can be attributed to premature epiphyseal fusion of the distal radius. Computed tomography of SHOX-deficient patients revealed a thin bone cortex and an enlarged total bone area at the diaphysis of the radius, while histopathological analyses showed a disrupted columnar arrangement of chondrocytes and an expanded hypertrophic layer of the growth plate. Recent studies have suggested that perturbed programmed cell death of hypertrophic chondrocytes may underlie the skeletal changes related to SHOX deficiency. Furthermore, the formation of an aberrant ligament tethering the lunate and radius has been implicated in the development of Madelung deformity. Blood estrogen levels and mutation types have been proposed as phenotypic determinants of SHOX deficiency, although other unknown factors may also affect clinical severity of this entity.