The Case Mix of Patients Presenting with Full-Thickness Macular Holes and Progression before Surgery: Implications for Optimum Management

PREDICTION OF MACULAR HOLE SIZE PROGRESSION BASED ON BASELINE OPTICAL COHERENCE TOMOGRAPHY FINDINGS

PURPOSE

To quantify the rate of idiopathic macular hole progression from presentation and identify factors that may influence stratification and urgency for surgical listing based on the initial optical coherence tomography scans.

METHODS

The minimal linear diameter (MLD), base diameter (BD), and hole height on nasal and temporal sides of idiopathic macular hole were measured on spectral domain optical coherence tomographies, on initial presentation and just before surgery. Mean hole height, hole height asymmetry (absolute difference between nasal and temporal height), MLD/BD, and MLD change per day (MLD/day) were calculated for each patient. Multivariable linear regression analysis with MLD/day as the dependent variable was performed to identify significant risk factors for MLD progression. Minimal linear diameter was grouped to quintiles: 1: ≤290 µ m, 2: >290 µ m and ≤385 µ m, 3: >385 µ m and ≤490 µ m, 4: >490 µ m and ≤623 µ m, and 5: >623 µ m.

RESULTS

In 161 eyes (157 patients), we report significant associations with MLD/day: 1) MLD/BD ( P = 0.039) (i.e., wide BD relative to MLD lead to faster progression of MLD), 2) hole height asymmetry ( P = 0.006) (larger absolute difference between nasal and temporal hole height lead to faster progression), and 3) days between scans ( P < 0.001) (longer duration between scans had reduced MLD/day, indicating more rapid increase initially then plateaux), and relative to MLD Quintile 1, MLD Quintile 3 ( P = 0.002) and MLD Quintile 4 ( P = 0,008), and MLD Quintile 5 ( P < 0.001) all lead to a reduced MLD/day rate on multivariable regression.

CONCLUSION

In addition to finding that the previously reported initial smaller MLD is a risk factor for rapid MLD progression, we report two novel findings, large hole height asymmetry and a low MLD/BD (wide base relative to MLD), that represent significant risk factors. These factors should be taken into consideration on presentation to stratify timing of surgery.

The Effect of Macular Hole Duration on Surgical Outcomes: An Individual Participant Data Study of Randomized Controlled Trials

TOPIC

To define the effect of symptom duration on outcomes in people undergoing surgery for idiopathic full-thickness macular holes (iFTMHs) by means of an individual participant data (IPD) study of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). The outcomes assessed were primary iFTMH closure and postoperative best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Idiopathic full-thickness macular holes are visually disabling with a prevalence of up to 0.5%. Untreated BCVA is typically reduced to 20/200. Surgery can close holes and improve vision. Symptom duration is thought to affect outcomes with surgery, but the effect is unclear.

METHODS

A systematic review identified eligible RCTs that included adults with iFTMH undergoing vitrectomy with gas tamponade in which symptom duration, primary iFTMH closure, and postoperative BCVA were recorded. Bibliographic databases were searched for articles published between 2000 and 2020. Individual participant data were requested from eligible studies.

RESULTS

Twenty eligible RCTs were identified. Data were requested from all studies and obtained from 12, representing 940 eyes in total. Median symptom duration was 6 months (interquartile range, 3-10). Primary closure was achieved in 81.5% of eyes. There was a linear relationship between predicted probability of closure and symptom duration. Multilevel logistic regression showed each additional month of duration was associated with 0.965 times lower odds of closure (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.935-0.996, P = 0.026). Internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling, ILM flap use, better preoperative BCVA, face-down positioning, and smaller iFTMH size were associated with increased odds of primary closure. Median postoperative BCVA in eyes achieving primary closure was 0.48 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) (20/60). Multilevel logistic regression showed for eyes achieving primary iFTMH closure, each additional month of symptom duration was associated with worsening BCVA by 0.008 logMAR units (95% CI, 0.005-0.011, P < 0.001) (i.e., ∼1 Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study letter loss per 2 months). ILM flaps, intraocular tamponade using long-acting gas, better preoperative BCVA, smaller iFTMH size, and phakic status were also associated with improved postoperative BCVA.

CONCLUSIONS

Symptom duration was independently associated with both anatomic and visual outcomes in persons undergoing surgery for iFTMH. Time to surgery should be minimized and care pathways designed to enable this.

OCULAR FACTORS RELATED TO PREOPERATIVE ENLARGEMENT OF IDIOPATHIC MACULAR HOLE DIAMETER

PURPOSE

To determine the preoperative factors that are significantly correlated with an enlargement of an idiopathic macular hole (MH) during the one-month preoperative period.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cross-sectional study of patients with MH who had undergone vitrectomy in the Kagoshima University Hospital. The stage of the MH was determined by using spectral domain optical coherence tomography. Patients who had optical coherence tomography images at two time points more than 14 days apart before the vitrectomy were studied.

RESULTS

The MH participants were at Stage 2 in 44 eyes, at Stage 3 in 58 eyes, and at Stage 4 in 38 eyes. The rate of increase of the hole diameter was 26.0 ± 42.3% at Stage 2, 5.52 ± 15.5% at Stage 3, and 8.04 ± 18.7% at Stage 4. The rate of change at Stage 2 was significantly greater than that at Stage 3 and Stage 4 (both P < 0.01). In Stage 2, the MH diameter at the initial visit was significantly and negatively correlated with the rate of MH enlargement (r = -0.35, P = 0.021).

CONCLUSION

Patients with Stage 2 MHs, especially eyes with small hole diameter, should be considered for early surgery.

Defining a Cutoff for Progression of Macular Holes

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to determine a cutoff for progression of idiopathic full-thickness macular hole (MH) size.

Methods

Retrospective analysis of consecutive patients waiting 4 weeks for MH surgery. Two observers performed 3 repeat sets of MH size measurements on optical coherence tomography (OCT) high-density radial scans taken at first presentation and 4 weeks later before surgery. Primary outcome was the definition of a cutoff for true enlargement of MH size versus measurement error. Secondary outcomes were risk factors for change in minimum linear diameter (MLD) size and best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA).

Results

Fifty-one patients were included with a mean MH size of 334 µm (±179 µm; range 39 to 793 µm). The cutoff for an increase in MLD size calculated as the outer confidence limit for the 99.73% limits of agreement was 31 µm. This was independent of MH size. Using this cutoff, MLD size increased in 9/34 (26.5%) of patients without and in 14 of 17 (82.4%) of patients with vitreomacular traction (VMT; P < 0.001). Mean BCVA deteriorated in patients in whom the MH had progressed from 0.62 (±0.23) logMAR to 0.82 (±0.29; P < 0.001), whereas there was no significant change in BCVA in patients without MH progression (P = 0.25). In 31% (16/51) of patients, classification of their MHs (small ≤250 µm, medium 251–400 µm, and large >400 µm) changed over the 4-week period.

Conclusions

Using a cutoff discriminates change from measurement error. A significant proportion of MHs progressed by 4 weeks, particularly in the presence of VMT.

Translational Relevance

The established cutoff enables clinicians to differentiate true MH enlargement from measurement error.

The Association between Foveal Floor Measurements and Macular Hole Size

PURPOSE

Determining which factors influence idiopathic macular hole (MH) size is important because it is a major prognostic indicator of treatment success. Foveal pit morphologic features are highly symmetrical within individuals and may influence idiopathic MH size. Using a series of patients with unilateral idiopathic MHs, we examined the foveal floor size of the fellow eye to evaluate its relationship with idiopathic MH size and postoperative outcomes.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational study.

PARTICIPANTS

Two hundred forty-one participants with a unilateral idiopathic MH treated with surgery and a fellow eye with no ocular pathologic features.

METHODS

Both eyes underwent spectral-domain (SD) OCT imaging at the time of surgery. Minimum linear diameter (MLD) and base diameter (BD) defined idiopathic MH size. Foveal floor width (FFW) and minimal foveal thickness defined foveal pit morphologic features of the fellow eye.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Baseline characteristics, SD OCT measurements, and preoperative variables were compared to determine their relationship with idiopathic MH size and postoperative visual acuity (VA) in logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution units.

RESULTS

Foveal floor width was correlated with MLD (r = 0.36; P ≤ 0.001) and BD (r = 0.30; P ≤ 0.001), but not postoperative VA. Minimum linear diameter correlated with preoperative VA (r = 0.49; P ≤ 0.0001) and postoperative VA (r = 0.54; P ≤ 0.0001). A 2-stage regression model was developed to predict postoperative VA (r² = 0.28): preoperative VA (β = 0.36; P = 0.002) explained 13% of variability and MLD (β = 0.29; P = 0.002), and idiopathic MH duration (β = 0.23; P = 0.004) explained a further 16%.

CONCLUSIONS

Foveal floor width of the fellow eye in patients with a unilateral idiopathic MH was correlated significantly with idiopathic MH size and may explain some of the variability in idiopathic MH size observed between individuals. However, FFW could not predict postoperative vision.

Macular hole morphology and measurement using an automated three-dimensional image segmentation algorithm

Objective

Full-thickness macular holes (MH) are classified principally by size, which is one of the strongest predictors of anatomical and visual success. Using a three-dimensional (3D) automated image processing algorithm, we analysed optical coherence tomography (OCT) images of 104 MH of patients, comparing MH dimensions and morphology with clinician-acquired two-dimensional measurements.

Methods and Analysis

All patients underwent a high-density central horizontal scanning OCT protocol. Two independent clinicians measured the minimum linear diameter (MLD) and maximum base diameter. OCT images were also analysed using an automated 3D segmentation algorithm which produced key parameters including the respective maximum and minimum diameter of the minimum area (MA) of the MH, as well as volume and surface area.

Results

Using the algorithm-derived values, MH were found to have significant asymmetry in all dimensions. The minima of the MA were typically approximately 90° to the horizontal, and differed from their maxima by 55 μm. The minima of the MA differed from the human-measured MLD by a mean of nearly 50 μm, with significant interobserver variability. The resultant differences led to reclassification using the International Vitreomacular Traction Study Group classification in a quarter of the patients (p=0.07).

Conclusion

MH are complex shapes with significant asymmetry in all dimensions. We have shown how 3D automated analysis of MH describes their dimensions more accurately and repeatably than human assessment. This could be used in future studies investigating hole progression and outcome to help guide optimum treatments.

Rate of progression of idiopathic full-thickness macular holes before surgery

BACKGROUND

To evaluate the spontaneous change in size over the time of idiopathic full-thickness macular holes (IFTMHs) using optical coherence tomography (OCT).

METHODS

This retrospective observational study included 24 eyes of 24 consecutive patients waiting for IFTMH surgery. On OCT horizontal B-scan passing through the center of the fovea, the minimum linear diameter (MLD), the basal diameter (BD), and the presence of vitreomacular adhesion (VMA) were evaluated. The mean total and daily MLD and BD variations were calculated as both absolute and percentage values.

RESULTS

The MLD and BD size increase was statistically significant (P < 0.0001). The MLD size increase was significantly greater for small (<250 μm) versus both medium (≥250 to ≤400 μm) and large (>400 μm) IFTMHs in all analysis: the total absolute (P = 0.0248), the daily absolute (P = 0.0186), the total percentage (P = 0.0020), and the daily percentage (P = 0.0008) variations. For the BD, the significance between the same groups was achieved only in the daily percentage change (P = 0.0220). The presence of VMA did not influence the amount of MLD and BD increase. The rate of increase was dependent on the size of hole at presentation (MLD: small: 1.67 microns per day; medium: 0.61 microns per day; large: 0.44 microns per day).

CONCLUSIONS

Both MLD and BD increase over the time in IFTMHs. There is a significantly greater rate of increase in hole size in smaller holes compared with larger. Therefore, prioritisation for small IFTMH may be justified.

Epidemiology and morphology of full-thickness macular holes

PURPOSE

To investigate the incidence of full-thickness macular holes (FTMHs) and their morphological features according to the International Vitreomacular Traction Study (IVTS) classification.

METHODS

The clinical records of all new patients with FTMH, referred between 2008 and 2014, were reviewed for demographics, cause of the FTMH, age at diagnosis, symptom duration, laterality, visual acuity (VA), axial length and lens status. A detailed analysis of the patients' spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) images was performed, and the primary FTMHs were classified in clinical stages according to the IVTS classification. From the SD-OCT, accurate macula drawings were made by means of a computer-drawing software. By merging these drawings and displaying them as colour-coded maps, the morphology and shape of the FTMH were visualized.

RESULTS

The study included 177 eyes (152 primary and 25 secondary FTMH) in 166 patients. In primary FTMH, the male-to-female ratio was 1:2.2. The age- and gender-adjusted annual incidences of primary FTMH were 7.9 eyes and 7.4 individuals per 100 000 inhabitants. Mean primary FTMH minimum linear diameter (MLD) and basal diameter (BD) were 435 μm and 872 μm, respectively, and 13% were classified as small, 31% as medium and 55% as large. Vitreomacular traction (VMT) and epiretinal membrane (ERM) were present in 34% and 36% of the eyes, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study provides data on the incidence rates of FTMH adjusted to different standard populations. The morphological analysis and novel computational visualization technique offer new insight into the structural complexity of FTMH and how VMT and ERM significantly influence FTMH configuration.

Predicting macular hole closure with ocriplasmin based on spectral domain optical coherence tomography

PurposeTo assess the preoperative features of patients with idiopathic macular hole (IMH) and vitreomacular adhesion (VMA) treated with ocriplasmin (OCP) that can predict successful closure.MethodData were prospectively collected on all patients with IMH treated with OCP in three British ophthalmic centres. Several preoperative variables were recorded including the IMH base diameter (BD), minimum linear diameter (MLD), and VMA width measured on spectral domain optical coherence tomography. Several other IMH indices were derived including a 'width factor', defined as the BD minus the MLD in μm. The occurrence of VMA release and hole closure were used as the main outcome measures.ResultsThirty-three patients in total with IMH were treated with OCP. Two patients developed rhegmatogenous retinal detachment and were excluded. The mean age of the remaining 31 patients was 71 years, and 71% were female. VMA release occurred in 19 of the 31 (61%) patients and macular hole closure in 11 (35%). Width factor was the most predictive feature for closure on multivariate analysis. The deviance R(2) was 67% (P<0.001). An IMH with a width factor of <60 μm had a 95% certainty of closure, whereas if >290 μm then there was less than a 5% chance of closure. Neither VMA width nor MLD alone was associated with VMA release or closure.ConclusionsPatients with macular holes where the BD was close in size to the MLD had an improved probability of closure than holes with wider base configurations.

Optimal management of idiopathic macular holes

This review evaluates the current surgical options for the management of idiopathic macular holes (IMHs), including vitrectomy, ocriplasmin (OCP), and expansile gas use, and discusses key background information to inform the choice of treatment. An evidence-based approach to selecting the best treatment option for the individual patient based on IMH characteristics and patient-specific factors is suggested. For holes without vitreomacular attachment (VMA), vitrectomy is the only option with three key surgical variables: whether to peel the inner limiting membrane (ILM), the type of tamponade agent to be used, and the requirement for postoperative face-down posturing. There is a general consensus that ILM peeling improves primary anatomical hole closure rate; however, in small holes (<250 µm), it is uncertain whether peeling is always required. It has been increasingly recognized that long-acting gas and face-down positioning are not always necessary in patients with small- and medium-sized holes, but large (>400 µm) and chronic holes (>1-year history) are usually treated with long-acting gas and posturing. Several studies on posturing and gas choice were carried out in combination with ILM peeling, which may also influence the gas and posturing requirement. Combined phacovitrectomy appears to offer more rapid visual recovery without affecting the long-term outcomes of vitrectomy for IMH. OCP is licensed for use in patients with small- or medium-sized holes and VMA. A greater success rate in using OCP has been reported in smaller holes, but further predictive factors for its success are needed to refine its use. It is important to counsel patients realistically regarding the rates of success with intravitreal OCP and its potential complications. Expansile gas can be considered as a further option in small holes with VMA; however, larger studies are required to provide guidance on its use.