Histopathology of the Human Inner Ear in the p.L114P COCH Mutation (DFNA9)

Evaluating cochlear implant outcomes in DFNA9 subjects: a comprehensive study on cerebral white matter lesions and vestibular abnormalities

PURPOSE

This study assessed whether the Fazekas score could account for the variability in cochlear implantation (CI) outcomes among individuals with DFNA9 and evaluated signal loss in the semicircular canals (SCCs) on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) among individuals with DFNA9.

METHOD

This retrospective cross-sectional study included CI recipients with DFNA9. Pre-implantation MRI-scans were reviewed to determine the Fazekas score, localizing and grading cerebral white matter lesions (WML), and identify abnormalities in the SCCs. CI performance was assessed by evaluating phoneme scores one year post-implantation. The function of the SCCs was evaluated using rotatory chair testing with electronystagmography (ENG) and the video Head Impulse Test (vHIT).

RESULTS

Forty-five subjects (49 ears) were enrolled. The phoneme scores significantly improved from 35% (IQR 11-50) pre-implantation to 84% (IQR 76-90) one year post-implantation. No correlation was observed between the Fazekas score and the one-year post-implantation phoneme score (rsp=0.003, p = 0.986). Signal loss in at least one SCCs was detected in 97.7% of subjects and 77.8% of ears. There was no correlation between vestibular test results and fluid signal loss in the SCCs on MRI.

CONCLUSION

Most individuals with DFNA9 show improved speech recognition with CI. The observed variability in CI outcomes was not linked to the Fazekas score. Additionally, our study confirms a high prevalence of focal sclerosis in DFNA9. Recognizing the limitations of this study, further research is needed to explore the predictive role of the Fazekas score on CI outcomes and its relationship with vestibular function.

A Novel COCH p.D544Vfs*3 Variant Associated with DFNA9 Sensorineural Hearing Loss Causes Pathological Multimeric Cochlin Formation

COCH (coagulation factor C homology) is one of the most frequently mutated genes of autosomal dominant non-syndromic hearing loss. Variants in COCH could cause DFNA9, which is characterized by late-onset hearing loss with variable degrees of vestibular dysfunction. In this study, we report a Chinese family with a novel COCH variant (c.1687delA) causing p.D544Vfs*3 in the cochlin. Comprehensive audiometric tests and vestibular function assessments were taken to acquire the phenotypic profile of the subjects. Next-generation sequencing was conducted and segregation analysis was carried out using Sanger sequencing. The proband presented mild vestibular symptoms and normal functional assessment results in almost every test, while the variant co-segregated with hearing impairment in the pedigree. The variant was located beyond the vWFA2 domain, which was predicted to affect the post-translational cleavage of the cochlin via molecular modeling analysis. Notably, in the overexpressing study, by transient transfecting the HEK 293T cells, we found that the p.D544Vfs*3 variant increased the formation of multimeric cochlin. Our result enriched the spectrum of DFNA9-linked pathological COCH variants and suggested that variants, causative of cochlin multimerization, could be related to DFNA9 with sensorineural hearing loss rather than serious vestibular symptoms.

Radiologic Features in Cochlear Implant Candidates: A Prospective Study Comparing Candidates Carrying the p.Pro51Ser Mutation in Coagulation Factor C Homology With Noncarriers

BACKGROUND

DFNA9 is a form of autosomal progressive sensorineural hearing loss, caused by more than 30 variants in the COCH gene. p.Pro51Ser (p.P51S) variant is characterized by late-onset functional deterioration toward bilateral severe hearing loss and vestibulopathy. Focal sclerosis on computed tomography (CT) and T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) signal loss of semicircular canals are presumably radiologic biomarkers of advanced otovestibular deterioration.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to investigate whether these biomarkers are more frequent in cochlear implant candidates carrying the p.P51S mutation versus noncarriers. Second, the correlation between the hearing and vestibular function and carrier status was studied. Finally, the relationship between the presence of these radiologic features and the degree of hearing and vestibular deterioration was investigated.

METHODS

A prospective cohort study was performed on 38 candidates for cochlear implantation in a tertiary referral center. Patients underwent pure tone audiometry, videonystagmography, video head impulse tests and vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials. In addition, three dizziness questionnaires were used. All subjects were administered CT, MRI, and molecular genetic analysis.

RESULTS

Sixteen of 38 patients were carriers of the p.P51S COCH mutation. Radiologic lesions were almost exclusively observed in carriers. MRI was more sensitive in showing lesions than CT. Furthermore, p.P51S carriers showed significantly lower function on most vestibular tests, including questionnaires, than noncarriers. Patients with imaging abnormalities showed more pronounced vestibulopathy.

CONCLUSION

The present study supplements previous data that endorse the hypothesis that focal sclerosis of semicircular canals are biomarkers of advanced vestibular deterioration, especially in DFNA9.

AudioGene: refining the natural history of KCNQ4, GSDME, WFS1, and COCH-associated hearing loss

Autosomal dominant non-syndromic hearing loss (ADNSHL) displays gene-specific progression of hearing loss, which is amenable to sequential audioprofiling. We sought to refine the natural history of ADNSHL by examining audiometric data in 5-year increments. 2175 audiograms were included from four genetic causes of ADNSHL-KCNQ4 (DFNA2), GSDME (DFNA5), WFS1 (DFNA6/14/38), and COCH (DFNA9). Annual threshold deterioration (ATD) was calculated for each gene: for the speech-frequency pure tone average, the ATD, respectively, was 0.72 dB/year, 0.94 dB/year, 0.53 dB/year, and 1.41 dB/year, with the largest drops occurring from ages 45-50 (0.89 dB/year; KCNQ4), 5-10 (1.42 dB/year; GSDME), 40-45 (0.83 dB/year; WFS1), and 50-55 (2.09 dB/year; COCH). 5-year interval analysis of audiograms reveals the gene specific natural history of KCNQ4, GSDME, WFS1 and COCH-related progressive hearing loss. Identifying ages at which hearing loss is most rapid informs clinical care and patient expectations. Natural history data are also essential to define outcomes of clinical trials that test novel therapies designed to correct or ameliorate these genetic forms of hearing loss.

Does Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex (VOR) Gain Correlate With Radiological Findings in the Semi-Circular Canals in Patients Carrying the p.Pro51Ser (P51S) COCH Variant Causing DFNA9? Relationship Between the Three-Dimensional Video Head Impulse Test (vHIT) and MR/CT Imaging

OBJECTIVE

The primary aim was to determine whether 3D video-head-impulse-test vestibulo-ocular reflex (vHIT VOR)-gains correlate with computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance (MR) lesions in a series of carriers of the p.(Pro51Ser)-variant (P51S) in the COCH-gene (DFNA9). Secondary aim was to compare routine imaging with second peer review radiologic lecture.

STUDY DESIGN

Analytical cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Secondary referral center.

PATIENTS

Twenty-four p.P51S carriers with MR and CT images. Eighteen carriers were selected of whom both 3D-vHIT and imaging data were available within a time interval of 24 months.

INTERVENTIONS

All imaging data were reassessed by two independent neuroradiologists. vHIT VOR-gains were correlated with semi-circular canal (SCC) lesions.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Correlation between vHIT VOR-gains and SCC lesions, and additional lesions detected during scientific lecture of imaging data.

RESULTS

The average gain of the ipsilateral labyrinth was significantly lower when positive CT (0.3215; p = 0.0122) and MR results (0.3215; p = 0.0134).92% of ears presented MR lesions on at least one SCC, whereas this was 75% on CT. The posterior SCC is the most frequently affected on MR and CT. Second lecture led to nine additional MR and 16 CT lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Significant correlation was observed between radiological lesions at any SCC and lower average gain of the three ipsilateral SCC. The substantially larger number of lesions during scientific assessment stresses the need to fully inform radiologists concerning differential diagnosis to facilitate accurate diagnosis when planning imaging. Focal sclerosis and narrowing of SCC in DFNA9 represent a possible biomarker of advanced stages of otovestibular deterioration.

Genotype-Phenotype Correlations of Pathogenic COCH Variants in DFNA9: A HuGE Systematic Review and Audiometric Meta-Analysis

Pathogenic missense variants in COCH are associated with DFNA9, an autosomal dominantly inherited type of progressive sensorineural hearing loss with or without vestibular dysfunction. This study is a comprehensive overview of genotype-phenotype correlations using the PRISMA and HuGENet guidelines. Study characteristics, risk of bias, genotyping and data on the self-reported age of onset, symptoms of vestibular dysfunction, normative test results for vestibular function, and results of audiovestibular examinations were extracted for each underlying pathogenic COCH variant. The literature search yielded 48 studies describing the audiovestibular phenotypes of 27 DFNA9-associated variants in COCH. Subsequently, meta-analysis of audiometric data was performed by constructing age-related typical audiograms and by performing non-linear regression analyses on the age of onset and progression of hearing loss. Significant differences were found between the calculated ages of onset and progression of the audiovestibular phenotypes of subjects with pathogenic variants affecting either the LCCL domain of cochlin or the vWFA2 and Ivd1 domains. We conclude that the audiovestibular phenotypes associated with DFNA9 are highly variable. Variants affecting the LCCL domain of cochlin generally lead to more progression of hearing loss when compared to variants affecting the other domains. This review serves as a reference for prospective natural history studies in anticipation of mutation-specific therapeutic interventions.

Screening Strategies for Deafness Genes and Functional Outcomes in Cochlear Implant Patients

OBJECTIVES

To review the current state of knowledge about the influence of specific genetic mutations that cause sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) on cochlear implant (CI) functional outcomes, and how this knowledge may be integrated into clinical practice. A multistep and sequential population-based genetic algorithm suitable for the identification of congenital SNHL mutations before CI placement is also examined.

DATA SOURCES, STUDY SELECTION

A review was performed of the English literature from 2000 to 2019 using PubMed regarding the influence of specific mutations on CI outcomes and the use of next-generation sequencing for genetic screening of CI patients.

CONCLUSION

CI is an effective habilitation option for patients with severe-profound congenital SNHL. However, it is well known that CI outcomes show substantial inter-patient variation. Recent advances in genetic studies have improved our understanding of genotype-phenotype relationships for many of the mutations underlying congenital SNHL, and have explored how these relationships may account for some of the variance seen in CI performance outcomes. A sequential genetic screening strategy utilizing next-generation sequencing-based population-specific gene panels may allow for more efficient mutation identification before CI placement. Understanding the relationships between specific mutations and CI outcomes along with integrating routine comprehensive genetic testing into pre-CI evaluations will allow for more effective patient counseling and open the door for the development of mutation-specific treatment strategies.

On the pathophysiology of DFNA9: Effect of pathogenic variants in the COCH gene on inner ear functioning in human and transgenic mice

DeaFNess Autosomal Dominant 9 (DFNA9) is a dominant hereditary non-syndromic form of progressive sensorineural hearing loss often associated with vestibular dysfunction. DFNA9 is caused by pathogenic variants in the COCH gene. This gene encodes for cochlin, a protein that is abundantly expressed in the spiral ligament and spiral limbus of the inner ear but the function of cochlin is still not fully understood. There are 22 known pathogenic variants located in different domains of the COCH gene that can cause DFNA9, all expressing slightly different phenotypes. It is believed that COCH mutations affect the intracellular trafficking of cochlin which could explain the characteristic pathology seen in temporal bones of DFNA9 patients. This pathology involves a widespread accumulation of acellular eosinophilic deposits throughout the labyrinth. To gain a better understanding of the pathology underlying DFNA9, different mouse models were developed. The objective of this review is to describe the different pathogenic variants in the COCH gene and their effect on intracellular trafficking, associated phenotypes and histopathological findings in both patients and mouse models.

The Price of Immune Responses and the Role of Vitamin D in the Inner Ear

OBJECTIVE

In this review the authors discuss evidence from the literature concerning vitamin D and temporal bone diseases (benign paroxysmal positional vertigo [BPPV], Menière's disease [MD], vestibular neuritis, idiopathic facial paralysis, idiopathic acute hearing loss). Common features shared by Menière's disease, glaucoma, and the possible influence by vitamin D are briefly discussed.

DATA SOURCES, STUDY SELECTION

Publications from 1970 until recent times have been reviewed according to a keyword search (see above) in PubMed.

CONCLUSIONS

MD, BPPV, vestibular neuritis, idiopathic facial paralysis, idiopathic acute hearing loss may all have several etiological factors, but a common feature of the current theories is that an initial viral infection and a subsequent autoimmune/autoinflammatory reaction might be involved. Additionally, in some of these entities varying degrees of demyelination have been documented. Given the immunomodulatory effect of vitamin D, we postulate that it may play a role in suppressing an eventual postviral autoimmune reaction. This beneficial effect may be enhanced by the antioxidative activity of vitamin D and its potential in stabilizing endothelial cells. The association of vitamin D deficiency with demyelination has already been established in other entities such as multiple sclerosis and experimental autoimmune encephalitis. Mice without vitamin D receptor show degenerative features in inner ear ganglia, hair cells, as well as otoconia. The authors suggest further studies concerning the role of vitamin D deficiency in diseases of the temporal bone. Additionally, the possible presence and degree of demyelination in these entities will have to be elucidated more systematically in the future.

Contemporary techniques in human otopathology and promise for the future

Contemporary histopathology of the ear is based on an evolution of equipment and histological techniques over the last 500 years, including the invention of the light microscope and protocols for fixation, embedment, sectioning, and staining of tissue samples, and visual documentation of findings. Several recent techniques which can be utilized in otopathology hold promise for significant improvement in methods and a better understanding of pathologic processes in diseases of the ear.

Cochlear histopathology in human genetic hearing loss: State of the science and future prospects

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is an extraordinarily common disability, affecting 466 million people across the globe. Half of these incidents are attributed to genetic mutations that disrupt the structure and function of the cochlea. The human cochlea's interior cannot be imaged or biopsied without damaging hearing; thus, everything known about the morphologic correlates of hereditary human deafness comes from histopathologic studies conducted in either cadaveric human temporal bone specimens or animal models of genetic deafness. The purpose of the present review is to a) summarize the findings from all published histopathologic studies conducted in human temporal bones with known SNHL-causing genetic mutations, and b) compare the reported phenotypes of human vs. mouse SNHL caused by the same genetic mutation. The fact that human temporal bone histopathologic analysis has been reported for only 22 of the nearly 200 identified deafness-causing genes suggests a great need for alternative and improved techniques for studying human hereditary deafness; in light of this, the present review concludes with a summary of promising future directions, specifically in the fields of high resolution cochlear imaging, intracochlear fluid biopsy, and gene therapy.

Preservation of Cells of the Organ of Corti and Innervating Dendritic Processes Following Cochlear Implantation in the Human: An Immunohistochemical Study

HYPOTHESIS

This study evaluates the degree of preservation of hair cells, supporting cells, and innervating dendritic processes after cochlear implantation in the human using immunohistochemical methods.

BACKGROUND

Surgical insertion of a cochlear implant electrode induces various pathologic changes within the cochlea including insertional trauma, foreign body response, inflammation, fibrosis, and neo-osteogenesis. These changes may result in loss of residual acoustic hearing, adversely affecting the use of hybrid implants, and may result in loss of putative precursor cells, limiting the success of future regenerative protocols.

METHODS

Twenty-eight celloidin-embedded temporal bones from 14 patients with bilateral severe to profound sensorineural hearing loss and unilateral cochlear implants were studied. Two sections including the modiolus or basal turn from each temporal bone were stained using antineurofilament, antimyosin-VIIa, and antitubulin antibodies in both the implanted and unimplanted ears.

RESULTS

Inner and outer hair cells: Immunoreactivity was reduced throughout the implanted cochlea and in the unimplanted cochlea with the exception of the apical turn.Dendritic processes in the osseous spiral lamina: Immunoreactivity was significantly less along the electrode of the implanted cochlea than in the other segments.Inner and outer pillars, inner and outer spiral bundles, and Deiters' cells: Immunoreactivity was similar in the implanted and unimplanted cochleae.

CONCLUSION

Insertion of a cochlear implant electrode may significantly affect the inner and outer hair cells both along and apical to the electrode, and dendritic processes in the osseous spiral lamina along the electrode. There was less effect on pillar cells, Deiters' cells, and spiral bundles.

Audiovestibular Phenotypes and Advanced Magnetic Resonance Imaging Features of Cochlin Gene Mutation Carriers

OBJECTIVE

To describe clinical and imaging findings in a group of patients affected by nonsyndromic deafness A9 (DFNA9), using advanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with 3-dimensional (3D) fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequence.

METHOD

A retrospective case review was conducted in a tertiary referral center in Italy. Four sequential adult DFNA9-affected patients, who had undergone MRI at our Department between January 2017 and June 2018, were enrolled (male = 2, female = 2; median age: 65.6 years; 8 diseased ears analyzed). Three patients were relatives; the fourth was unrelated. The main outcome measures - age, sex, records of audiological and vestibular testing, genetic assessment, MRI findings - were analyzed.

RESULTS

All subjects suffered from bilateral progressive sensorineural hearing loss, more severely at the high frequencies and with a typical clinical pattern of bilateral chronic degenerative cochleovestibular deficit. Aural fullness was reported at the onset of the disease. All patients revealed a pathogenic heterozygous mutation in the Limulus factor C, Coch-5b2 and Lgl1 domain of cochlin. None of the patients showed a significant vestibular and cochlear endolymphatic hydrops at MRI, while high bilateral contrast enhancement on 4-h delayed postcontrast 3D FLAIR sequence was observed in all ears.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased perilymph enhancement on 4-h delayed postcontrast 3D FLAIR sequence is the common imaging feature of DFNA9 ears, suggesting that blood-labyrinthine barrier breakdown may play the main role in the pathophysiology of this disease. Significant hydrops has been excluded by MRI. This finding might be clinically useful in differentiating DFNA9 disease from other pathologies with similar clinical findings like Ménière's disease.

Contributions of Contemporary Human Temporal Bone Histopathology to Clinical Otology

Contemporary techniques have greatly enhanced the contributions of human temporal bone (HTB) histopathology to our understanding of the mechanisms of human otologic disease and disease treatment. Herein, we review some of the most salient contributions of this research to disease management. The field of HTB histopathology is challenged by limited resources as applies to trained investigators, infrastructure, and well-equipped laboratories. This research provides insights into clinical otology that cannot be obtained by any other means. Measures should be taken to preserve and extend the contributions of HTB research.

Focal Degeneration of Vestibular Neuroepithelium in the Cristae Ampullares of Three Human Subjects

BACKGROUND

We report a unique pattern of focal degeneration of the neuroepithelium of cristae ampullares, thick subepithelial extracellular deposits, and neural degeneration in three humans.

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the pattern of vestibular degeneration and measure the thickness of subepithelial deposits in these three cases and controls.

METHODS

The subepithelial deposits of vestibular end organs in three subject cases and controls were studied using hematoxylin and eosin, periotic acid-Schiff, Gomori trichrome staining, and immunostaining for antineurofilament, antimyosin VIIa, and anticollagen 4a1. The thickness of deposit as measured by light microscopy was compared with that of control groups (age-matched controls, patients with unilateral Menière's disease, vestibular neuritis, cupulolithiasis, severe nonfocal degeneration of the vestibular neuroepithelium, and Alport syndrome). The correlation of thickness of deposits with age from 0 to 100 years was also investigated.

RESULTS

Focal loss of hair cells in the neuroepithelium, thick subepithelial deposits, and degeneration of subepithelial dendrites and Scarpa's ganglion were found in all three cristae of three subject cases. Immunostaining demonstrated a decrease of afferent neural fibers in the cristae and focal fragmentation of the basement membrane adjacent to the deposits. The thickness of the subepithelial deposits in three cristae of three subject cases was significantly greater than that of all controls. In the three cristae of normal controls, the thickness of deposits demonstrated a positive correlation with age.

CONCLUSION

Although both age and degeneration of the vestibular neuroepithelium may be associated with the thickness of the subepithelial deposits, in this unique pattern of degeneration, the thickness of the subepithelial deposits was significantly greater than that in all controls.

Does Otovestibular Loss in the Autosomal Dominant Disorder DFNA9 Have an Impact of on Cognition? A Systematic Review

Background and Purpose: Cognitive impairment has been observed in patients with bilateral vestibular loss (BVL) and in patients with sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). DFNA9 is an autosomal dominant disorder that causes a combination of both sensory deficits by the 3rd to 5th decade. We therefore hypothesize a combined detrimental effect on cognition. The aim of this systematic review was to identify studies related to DFNA9 in general and its relationship with cognitive impairment more specifically.

Materials and Methods: Several databases including Medline, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, ISI Web of Knowledge, and Web of Science were searched to accumulate information about DFNA9-mutations, including phenotype, genotype, pathophysiology, quality of life (QOL), and imaging in general and cognitive function more specifically. A qualitative analysis was performed on the 55 articles that qualified.

Results: The clinical features of DFNA9 are different along the 24 COCH mutations, described up to now. Vestibular symptoms generally present themselves a few years after SNHL onset in mutations associated with the vWFA-domain although they can precede SNHL onset in other mutations associated with the LCCL-domain. QoL has not been studied extensively in DFNA9, although scarce work is available on the positive impact of cochlear implantation to rehabilitate hearing. No studies were found evaluating cognition in DFNA9 patients.

Conclusion: Although cognitive impairment has been demonstrated in patients with hearing loss as well as in patients with BVL, no studies have been reported on the combination of both sensory deficits, such as in DFNA9. Further research is warranted to correlate otovestibular status with cognition.

JB. Evidence of Osteoclastic Activity in the Human Temporal Bone

Bone remodeling within the otic capsule has been reported to be inhibited especially at or near the cochlea, except under some pathological conditions such as otosclerosis, Paget's disease, or mastoiditis, when bone remodeling can occur. Microcavitations found in periosteal and endosteal layers of human temporal bone specimens without otosclerosis, Paget's disease, or inflammation as reported in the current study are consistent with osteoclastic bone resorption. Thirty-three temporal bones from 33 patients were prepared for light microscopy and classified into 4 groups: histologically proven dehiscence of the superior semicircular canal (SSCD) (n = 3, group 1), age 20 years or younger (n = 10, group 2), age 90 years or older and with otosclerosis (n = 10, group 3), and age 90 years or older without otosclerosis (n = 10, group 4). Microcavitation was seen at 7 anatomic locations in the temporal bone in all 4 groups, but not in the cochlea or vestibule. Microcavitation within the temporal bone is likely due to osteoclastic activity, and it is seen in both young and old patients, patients with and without otosclerosis, and in cases with SSCD.

Immunohistochemical techniques for the human inner ear

In this review, we provide a description of the recent methods used for immunohistochemical staining of the human inner ear using formalin-fixed frozen, paraffin and celloidin-embedded sections. We also show the application of these immunohistochemical methods in auditory and vestibular endorgans microdissected from the human temporal bone. We compare the advantages and disadvantages of immunohistochemistry (IHC) in the different types of embedding media. IHC in frozen and paraffin-embedded sections yields a robust immunoreactive signal. Both frozen and paraffin sections would be the best alternative in the case where celloidin-embedding technique is not available. IHC in whole endorgans yields excellent results and can be used when desiring to detect regional variations of protein expression in the sensory epithelia. One advantage of microdissection is that the tissue is processed immediately and IHC can be made within 1 week of temporal bone collection. A second advantage of microdissection is the excellent preservation of both morphology and antigenicity. Using celloidin-embedded inner ear sections, we were able to detect several antigens by IHC and immunofluorescence using antigen retrieval methods. These techniques, previously applied only in animal models, allow for the study of numerous important proteins expressed in the human temporal bone potentially opening up a new field for future human inner ear research.