Comparison of cardiovascular responses to static-dynamic effort and dynamic effort alone in patients with chronic ischemic heart disease

The safety of isometric exercise: Rethinking the exercise prescription paradigm for those with stage 1 hypertension

Few studies have investigated the relative safety of prescribing isometric exercise (IE) to reduce resting blood pressure (BP). This study aimed to ascertain the safety of the hemodynamic response during an IE wall squat protocol.Twenty-six hypertensive (BP of 120-139 mm Hg systolic and/or 80-90 mm Hg diastolic) males (45 ± 8 years; 1.78 ± 0.07 m; 89.7 ± 12.3 kg; mean ± SD), visited the laboratory on 2 separate occasions. Heart rate (HR) and BP were measured at rest and continuously throughout exercise. In visit 1, participants completed a continuous incremental isometric wall squat exercise test, starting at 135° of knee flexion, decreasing by 10° every 2 minutes until 95° (final stage). Exercise was terminated upon completion of the test or volitional fatigue. The relationship between knee joint angle and mean HR was used to calculate the participant-specific knee joint angle required to elicit a target HR of 95% HRpeak. This angle was used to determine exercise intensity for a wall squat training session consisting of 4 × 2 minute bouts (visit 2).Systolic BPs during the exercise test and training were 173 ± 21 mm Hg and 171 ± 19 mm Hg, respectively, (P > .05) and were positively related (r = 0.73, P < .05) with ratio limits of agreement (LoA) of 0.995 ×/÷ 1.077. Diastolic BPs were 116 ± 14 mm Hg and 113 ± 11 mm Hg, respectively, (P > .05) and were positively related (r = 0.42, P < .05) with ratio LoA of 0.99 ×/÷ 1.107. No participant recorded a systolic BP > 250 mm Hg. Diastolic BP values > 115 mm Hg were recorded in 12 participants during the incremental test and 6 participants during the training session. Peak rate pressure product was 20681 ± 3911 mm Hg bpm during the IE test and was lower (18074 ± 3209 mm Hg bpm) during the IE session (P = .002). No adverse effects were reported.Based on the current ACSM guidelines for aerobic exercise termination, systolic BP does not reach the upper limit during IE in this population. Diastolic BP exceeds 115 mm Hg in some during the IE protocol, which may suggest the need to individualise IE training prescription in some with suboptimal BP control. Future research is required to ascertain if IE requires modified BP termination guidelines.

American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Exercise and hypertension

Hypertension (HTN), one of the most common medical disorders, is associated with an increased incidence of all-cause and cardiovascular disease (CVD) mortality. Lifestyle modifications are advocated for the prevention, treatment, and control of HTN, with exercise being an integral component. Exercise programs that primarily involve endurance activities prevent the development of HTN and lower blood pressure (BP) in adults with normal BP and those with HTN. The BP lowering effects of exercise are most pronounced in people with HTN who engage in endurance exercise with BP decreasing approximately 5-7 mm HG after an isolated exercise session (acute) or following exercise training (chronic). Moreover, BP is reduced for up to 22 h after an endurance exercise bout (e.g.postexercise hypotension), with greatest decreases among those with highest baseline BP. The proposed mechanisms for the BP lowering effects of exercise include neurohumoral, vascular, and structural adaptations. Decreases in catecholamines and total peripheral resistance, improved insulin sensitivity, and alterations in vasodilators and vasoconstrictors are some of the postulated explanations for the antihypertensive effects of exercise. Emerging data suggest genetic links to the BP reductions associated with acute and chronic exercise. Nonetheless, definitive conclusions regarding the mechanisms for the BP reductions following endurance exercise cannot be made at this time. Individuals with controlled HTN and no CVD or renal complications may participated in an exercise program or competitive athletics, but should be evaluated, treated and monitored closely. Preliminary peak or symptom-limited exercise testing may be warranted, especially for men over 45 and women over 55 yr planning a vigorous exercise program (i.e. > or = 60% VO2R, oxygen uptake reserve). In the interim, while formal evaluation and management are taking place, it is reasonable for the majority of patients to begin moderate intensity exercise (40-<60% VO2R) such as walking. When pharmacological therapy is indicated in physically active people it should be, ideally: a) lower BP at rest and during exertion; b) decrease total peripheral resistance; and, c) not adversely affect exercise capacity. For these reasons, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors (or angiotensin II receptor blockers in case of ACE inhibitor intolerance) and calcium channel blockers are currently the drugs of choice for recreational exercisers and athletes who have HTN. Exercise remains a cornerstone therapy for the primary prevention, treatment, and control of HTN. The optimal training frequency, intensity, time, and type (FITT) need to be better defined to optimize the BP lowering capacities of exercise, particularly in children, women, older adults, and certain ethnic groups. based upon the current evidence, the following exercise prescription is recommended for those with high BP: Frequency: on most, preferably all, days of the week. Intensity: moderate-intensity (40-<60% VO2R). Time: > or = 30 min of continuous or accumulated physical activity per day. Type: primarily endurance physical activity supplemented by resistance exercise.

Left Ventricular Function During Strength Testing and Resistance Exercise in Patients With Left Ventricular Dysfunction

PURPOSE

Deterioration in left ventricular function is a more sensitive marker of myocardial ischemia during exercise than ST segment depression. The current study was designed to evaluate left ventricular function during one-repetition-maximum (1-RM) strength testing and resistance exercise in cardiac patients with moderate left ventricular dysfunction.

METHODS

Using echocardiographic methods, left ventricular function was evaluated in 15 patients with left ventricular dysfunction (age, 65 +/- 6.5 years; ejection fraction, 42.1 +/- 5.8). Measurements were performed during 1-RM testing and resistance exercise (20%, 40%, and 60% of 1-RM using 10 to 15 repetitions) on the one-arm biceps curl (BIC) and bilateral knee extension exercises and compared with measurements of left ventricular function during the symptom-limited graded exercise test (SL-GXT).

RESULTS

During the knee extension exercise, there was a slight but significant reduction (P< or =.05) in ejection fraction values at the end of 60% 1-RM, as compared with rest and previous workloads. Significant increases in systolic blood pressure and left ventricular end-systolic volume ratio values (P< or =.05) from rest to exercise were observed across test modes and for all workloads. The prevalence of new wall motion abnormalities during knee extension and BIC 1-RM strength testing was comparable with that observed during SL-GXT. The greatest increase in new wall motion abnormalities was seen during 60% 1-RM of knee extension exercise, as compared with prior workloads, BIC exercises, and SL-GXT.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite an increase in occurrence of ischemic changes during the highest resistance exercise workloads and with larger muscle mass, the findings are small in magnitude and do not suggest reduced cardiac performance.

Cardiovascular response to combined static-dynamic exercise of patients with myocardial infarction

BACKGROUND

Graded dynamic exercise-stress testing of patients with acute myocardial infarction prior to discharge from hospital has an important diagnostic and prognostic implication. Although many daily tasks involve combinations of static and dynamic exercise, little is known about cardiovascular responses during combined static-dynamic exercise.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the difference between cardiovascular responses during two types of combined static-dynamic exercise (a 10 kg weight in one hand, and a 10 kg weight bearing on the shoulder).

METHODS

We studied 27 male patients who had recently suffered myocardial infarction using ear densitography. The patients were divided into two groups: group 1 was comprised of 14 patients with resting left ventricular end-diastolic volumes > or = 140 ml, and group 2 was comprised of 13 patients with left ventricular end-diastolic volumes < 140 ml.

RESULTS

For eight patients in group 1 we detected positive electrocardiographic changes during one-hand weight-carrying exercise, but for none of these patients was there an electrocardiographic change during weight-bearing exercise. All the patients in group 2 completed both types of exercise without significant ST-segment change. Although there were no significant differences between values of any of the indices measured for the two groups during weight-bearing exercise, patients in group 1 had significantly shorter diastolic times/min (21.8 +/- 2.1 versus 25.1 +/- 2.4 s/min, P < 0.01) during one-hand weight carrying.

CONCLUSIONS

In addition to decrease in subendocardial coronary blood flow associated with increase in left ventricular end-diastolic volume, shortening of diastolic perfusion time during one-hand weight-carrying exercise for patients in group 1 can potentially contribute to subendocardial ischemia, which was favorably altered by bearing a weight on the shoulder.

Role of resistance training in heart disease

Since the mid-1980s resistance training has become an accepted part of the exercise rehabilitation process for patients eligible for traditional cardiac rehabilitation programs. A growing number of studies have demonstrated the safety of resistance training in Phase III/IV programs (Phase III--community based, beginning 6-12 wk posthospital discharge; a typical patient would be clinically stable with a functional capacity of > or = 5 METs; Phase IV--long-term maintenance) and more recently in Phase II (beginning within 3 wk posthospital discharge and lasting up to 3 months). Evidence is consistent that this form of training provokes fewer signs and symptoms of myocardial ischemia than aerobic testing and training, perhaps because of a lower heart rate (HR) and higher diastolic pressure combining to produce improved coronary artery filling. The major role of resistance training in heart disease patients is to promote increased dynamic muscle strength. Increases in muscular strength have been associated with increased peak exercise performance, improved submaximal endurance, and reduced ratings of perceived leg effort. Two studies show that resistance training may result in improved self-efficacy for strength and exercise tasks and improved quality of life parameters such as total mood disturbance, depression/dejection, fatigue/inertia, and emotional health domain scores. The data on risk factor modification are somewhat equivocal. Studies on blood lipid profiles have mostly been contaminated by confounders, and the effects on blood pressure (BP) are inconsistent. There are encouraging reports that resistance training may increase glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity, independent of changes in body fat or aerobic capacity. Future studies are needed in patients with congestive heart failure and orthotopic heart transplantation; muscle weakness is common in these groups and makes them excellent candidates to benefit from this form of exercise.

A controlled trial of circuit weight training on aerobic capacity and myocardial oxygen demand in men after coronary artery bypass surgery

BACKGROUND

Cardiovascular benefits of resistance training in cardiac patients have been suggested but not studied in a randomized, controlled trial of circuit weight training (CWT) without an aerobic exercise component. The purpose of the current study was to examine the effects of 10 weeks of CWT on muscular strength, peak oxygen consumption (peak VO2), and myocardial oxygen demand (mVO2) in men after coronary artery bypass surgery.

METHODS

Twenty-six, post-coronary bypass male subjects (mean 19 months after bypass), aged 60 +/- 8.5 years, were randomly allocated to 10 weeks of CWT at 40 to 60% of maximum voluntary contraction (n = 12) or to a control group (n = 14). Muscular strength was assessed using a modified one repetition maximum technique. Peak VO2 was recorded during symptom-limited treadmill exercise. Rate pressure product, as an indirect measure of mVO2, was measured during isometric, isodynamic, and dynamic exercise.

RESULTS

No ischemic symptoms nor electrocardiographic changes were recorded during testing or training. Strength increased by 18% (P < 0.005) in five out of seven exercises in the training group, but was unchanged in the control group. Training did not improve peak VO2. Rate pressure product during isometric and isodynamic exercise decreased from pre- to post-testing (P < 0.05) but was equivalent to that seen in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Moderate intensity CWT is safe and can improve strength in selected low-risk patients after coronary artery bypass surgery. However, it does not significantly increase peak VO2 nor reduce mVO2 during isometric, isodynamic, and dynamic exercise.

Safe load carrying after uncomplicated myocardial infarction: a simple prescriptive method

Measuring maximal handgrip strength at the time of hospital discharge provides a simple method for prescribing load holding and load carrying and patients who have had myocardial infarction.

Resistance training guidelines for individuals with diabetes mellitus

Resistance/strength training is added to an exercise regimen to create a well-rounded program that enhances muscular conditioning and improves health, physical fitness, and/or athletic performance. This article presents resistance training guidelines for individuals with diabetes mellitus, with and without vascular complications. The existing literature concerning exercise prescription and the acute and chronic physiological responses to resistive-type exercise is discussed. The educator is provided with principles that govern resistance training so that safe and effective programs can be prescribed for individuals with diabetes.

Attenuation of exercise-induced ST depression during combined isometric and dynamic exercise in coronary artery disease

ST-segment depression was measured during submaximal dynamic (treadmill) and combined isometric-dynamic (isodynamic) exercise at comparable rate-pressure products in 11 patients (mean age 63 years) with stable coronary artery disease who were participating in an exercise training program. Each patient completed 3 separate trials. Trial 1 (baseline) was a submaximal treadmill exercise test to determine the threshold heart rate-systolic blood pressure (rate-pressure product) for ST-segment depression (greater than or equal to 1.0 mm). During trials 2 and 3, patients performed (in random order) dynamic treadmill exercise and isodynamic exercise (treadmill walking 1.5 to 2.0 mph carrying 15 to 25 kg) until threshold rate-pressure product was achieved. During trial 1, each patient showed significant ST depression (mean 1.7 mm) at target rate-pressure product (mean 18,200). Subsequent dynamic exercise trials 2 and 3 showed similar mean ST depression (1.5 mm) and rate-pressure product (18,000). During isodynamic exercise trials 2 and 3, subjects showed only minimal ST depression (mean 0.4 mm) at a rate-pressure product similar to dynamic exercise (mean 18,590). Heart rates were significantly lower (-10/min) and systolic (+20 mm Hg) and diastolic (+25 mm Hg) pressure was higher during isodynamic exercise (p less than 0.05). The rate-pressure product is not a valid index of ST response during isodynamic exercise in stable exercise-trained cardiac patients. Attenuation of ST depression during isodynamic exercise may be attributed to a combination of increased diastolic perfusion pressure, decreased heart rate and possibly to reductions in venous return and ventricular diastolic wall tension due to increased intrathoracic and abdominal pressure.

Pharmacologic intervention as an alternative to exercise stress

Although thallium exercise imaging has served an important role in clinical cardiology, it is significantly limited by suboptimal sensitivity and specificity, particularly in asymptomatic man. The increasing recognition of silent myocardial ischemia, the significant prevalence of coronary artery disease in asymptomatic middle age men, and the frequent occurrence of myocardial infarction without preceding symptoms in 60% of cases emphasizes the need for a more definitive, noninvasive diagnostic test for the presence of coronary artery disease suitable for screening in asymptomatic or symptomatic patients. Intravenous dipyridamole combined with handgrip stress provides a potent stimulus for purposes of diagnostic perfusion imaging. Although planar and single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging also have played an important role, these techniques are seriously hindered by their inability to quantitate radiotracer uptake or image modest differences in maximum relative flow caused by coronary artery stenosis. Accordingly, the combination of dipyridamole-handgrip stress with positron imaging of myocardial perfusion has become a powerful diagnostic tool suitable for routine clinical use. With the availability of generator-produced rubidium-82, dedicated clinically oriented positron cameras, the routine application of positron imaging to clinical cardiology has become feasible. Based on published literature, the current clinical indications for positron imaging that may be carried out economically on a routine clinical basis include assessment of myocardial perfusion utilizing rubidium-82 or N-13 ammonia for purposes of reliable, accurate, noninvasive screening for coronary artery disease in symptomatic or asymptomatic patients; assessing noninvasively the physiologic severity of coronary stenoses; myocardial infarct imaging; assessing myocardial viability of reversibly injured or ischemic cells using N-13 ammonia combined with fluorine-18-deoxy-glucose or Rubidium-82 alone in experimental animals; assessing regional or global left ventricle (LV) function by 3-dimensional gated blood pool imaging and/or wall thickening by ECG gating; and assessing the functional significance of collaterals in man.

The circulatory response to lifting and carrying and its modification by beta-adrenoceptor blockade

The circulatory effects of lifting and holding weighted suitcases of 5, 10 and 15 kg, and carrying the same suitcases at two different walking speeds were evaluated in 6 normal subjects before and after beta-adrenoceptor blockade with 160 mg oxprenolol. Lifting and holding induced significant weight-induced increments in systolic and diastolic blood pressure which were not attenuated by beta-blockade. There was a significant increase in heart rate only on lifting the 15 kg weight which was attenuated by oxprenolol. Dynamic exercise (walking) with the same weighted suitcases resulted in rate and speed related increase in systolic pressure and heart rate, the magnitude of which was greater than that of lifting alone. The isometric pressor response was attenuated when walking and carrying at 2 mph, but completely abolished by the metabolic and heat induced vasodilatation when walking at 4 mph. Following beta-blockade both the absolute blood pressure and the systolic pressor and heart rate responses to combined lifting and carrying were attenuated. The diastolic pressor response induced by lifting, which was offset in the control period by the vasodilation induced by dynamic exercise was progressively attenuated proportionate to the load carried following beta-blockade; presumably this reflected systemic vasoconstriction to maintain mean perfusion pressure in the presence of central beta-blockade. These observations suggest that the isometric component which predominates at slow walking speeds when carrying weights between 5 and 15 kg is completely suppressed by the vasodilatation at fast walking speeds. Beta-blockade, while reducing heart rate and systolic pressor response to the same stimuli, leads to an augmented systemic vascular resistance which is particularly evident at high metabolic workloads.

Isometric Exercise and the Cardiovascular System

In brief: There is little evidence that isometric exercise benefits the cardiovascular system, and many physicians believe that it imposes undue demands on the myocardium, so they prohibit such exercises for middle-aged or coronary disease patients. This review article examines the validity of this conclusion by summarizing the effects of isometric exercise on heart rate, blood pressure, myocardial demand, cardiac output, peripheral blood flow, and left ventricular function. Dr. Fardy concludes that isometric exercise is less hazardous than has been presumed and says guidelines should be established according to each patient's history.

Hexamethonium modification of cardiovascular adjustments during combined static-dynamic arm exercise in monkeys

In weight lifting and rowing, essentially the same groups of muscles contract in isometric (static) and isotonic (dynamic) fashion. To approximate the combined static-dynamic arm movements involved in rowing or lifting weights, four rhesus monkeys were trained to pull a T-bar and thereby avoid tail shock. Each animal received 8 daily test sessions in which loads (0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6 kg), total pulls (3, 6, 9, 12 at a constant pull frequency, 0.5 Hz) and alternate sessions of pulling after injection of hexamethonium chloride (7 mg/kg) or saline were factorially combined. Our data indicate that heart rate in this model is primarily influenced by the duration of the dynamic exercise component (number of pulls) in this specific exercise task whereas both dynamic and static components affect systolic and diastolic blood pressure. After ganglionic blockade, heart rate and diastolic pressure do not change appreciably during T-bar pulling while the rise in systolic pressure is attenuated and varies primarily as a function of the static exercise component. The clinical implications of these experiments are discussed.