Recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression in the heart rate domain. Identification of coronary artery disease by the rate-recovery loop

Spectrum of clinical applications of interlead ECG heterogeneity assessment: From myocardial ischemia detection to sudden cardiac death risk stratification

Heterogeneity in depolarization and repolarization among regions of cardiac cells has long been recognized as a major factor in cardiac arrhythmogenesis. This fundamental principle has motivated development of noninvasive techniques for quantification of heterogeneity using the surface electrocardiogram (ECG). The initial approaches focused on interval analysis such as interlead QT dispersion and T_peak -T_end difference. However, because of inherent difficulties in measuring the termination point of the T wave and commonly encountered irregularities in the apex of the T wave, additional techniques have been pursued. The newer methods incorporate assessment of the entire morphology of the T wave and in some cases of the R wave as well. This goal has been accomplished using a number of promising vectorial approaches with the resting 12-lead ECG. An important limitation of vectorcardiographic analyses is that they require exquisite stability of the recordings and are not inherently suitable for use in exercise tolerance testing (ETT) and/or ambulatory ECG monitoring for provocative stress testing or evaluation of the influence of daily activities on cardiac electrical instability. The objectives of the present review are to describe a technique that has been under clinical evaluation for nearly a decade, termed "interlead ECG heterogeneity." Preclinical testing data will be briefly reviewed. We will discuss the main clinical findings with regard to sudden cardiac death risk stratification, heart failure evaluation, and myocardial ischemia detection using standard recording platforms including resting 12-lead ECG, ambulatory ECG monitoring, ETT, and pharmacologic stress testing in conjunction with single-photon emission computed tomography myocardial perfusion imaging.

Exercise and pharmacologic stress-induced interlead T-wave heterogeneity analysis to detect clinically significant coronary artery stenosis

BACKGROUND

Despite widespread use of ETT and vasodilator-stress with myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) for noninvasive detection of flow-limiting coronary artery disease, there is continued need to improve diagnostic accuracy. We examined whether measurement of interlead T-wave heterogeneity (TWH) during exercise tolerance testing (ETT) or pharmacologic stress testing improves detection of stenoses in large epicardial coronary arteries.

METHODS

All 137 patients at our institution who underwent diagnostic coronary angiography within 0 to 5 days after ETT (N = 81) or dipyridamole IV infusion (N = 58) in 2016 were studied, including 2 patients with both tests. Cases (N = 93) had angiographically significant stenosis (≥50% of left main or ≥ 70% of an epicardial coronary artery ≥2 mm in diameter); controls (N = 44) did not. TWH, i.e., interlead splay of T waves, was determined by second central moment analysis from precordial leads by an investigator blinded to angiographic results.

RESULTS

At rest, TWH levels were similar for cases and controls. ETT and dipyridamole stress testing increased TWH by 69% (p < 0.0001) and 27% (p < 0.0001), respectively, in cases. In controls, TWH did not change. Areas under the ROC curves for TWH increase for any flow-limiting coronary artery stenosis were 0.737 (p < 0.0001) for ETT and 0.818 (p < 0.0001) for dipyridamole stress testing. By contrast, neither ST-segment changes during ETT (p = 0.12) nor MPI during dipyridamole stress testing (p = 0.60) discriminated cases from controls.

CONCLUSIONS

TWH measurement is a novel method that improves detection of angiographically confirmed flow-limiting stenoses in large epicardial coronary arteries during both ETT and MPI during pharmacologic stress testing with dipyridamole.

ST/HR variables in firefighter exercise ECG - relation to ischemic heart disease

Exercise electrocardiography (ExECG) is regularly performed by Swedish firefighters by law. Heart rate-corrected analysis of ST segment variables (ST/HR) has shown improved prediction of ischemic heart disease (IHD) compared to ST depression alone. This has not previously been extensively studied in asymptomatic persons with a low probability of IHD. We therefore evaluated the predictive performance of ST/HR analysis in firefighter ExECG. ExECG was studied in 521 male firefighters. During 8.4 ± 2.1 years, 2.3% (n = 12) were verified with IHD by catheterization or myocardial scintigraphy (age 51.5 ± 5.5 years) and were compared with firefighters without imaging proof of IHD (44.2 ± 10.1 years). The predictive value of ST depression, ST/HR index, ST/HR slope, and area and rotation of the ST/HR loop was calculated as age-adjusted odds ratios (OR), in 10 ECG leads. Predictive accuracy was analyzed with receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis. ST/HR index ≤-1.6 μV/bpm and ST/HR slope ≤-2.4 μV/bpm were associated with increased IHD risk in three individual leads (all OR > 1.0, P < 0.05). ST/HR loop area lower than the fifth percentile of non-IHD subjects indicated IHD risk in V4, V5, aVF, II, and -aVR (P < 0.05). ST depression ≤-0.1 mV was associated with IHD only in V4 (OR, 9.6, CI, 2.3-40.0). ROC analysis of each of these variables yielded areas under the curve of 0.72 or lower for all variables and leads. Clockwise-rotated ST/HR loops was associated with increased risk in most leads compared to counterclockwise rotation. The limited clinical value of ExECG in low-risk populations was emphasized, but if performed, ST/HR analysis should probably be given more importance.

Gender aspects on exercise-induced ECG changes in relation to scintigraphic evidence of myocardial ischaemia

BACKGROUND

This retrospective study aimed to determine the diagnostic performance of exercise-induced ST response in relation to findings by myocardial perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (MPS), with focus on gender differences, in patients with suspected or established stable ischemic heart disease.

METHODS

MPS findings of 1 021 patients (518 females) were related to the exercise-induced ST response alone (blinded and unblinded to gender) and ST response together with additional exercise stress test (EST) variables (exercise capacity, blood pressure and heart rate response).

RESULTS

Exercise-induced ischaemia by MPS was found in 9% of females and 23% of males. Diagnostic performance of exercise-induced ST response in relation to MPS findings in females versus males was: sensitivity = 48%,70%; specificity = 67%, 64%; PPV = 13%, 38%; NPV = 93%, 87%. Adding more EST variables to the ST response interpretation yielded in females vs males: sensitivity = 44%, 51%; specificity = 84%, 83%; PPV = 22%, 48% and NPV = 93%, 85%.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients who have performed EST in conjunction with MPS, there is a gender difference in the diagnostic performance of ST response at stress, with a significantly lower PPV in females compared to males. For both genders, specificity can be significantly improved, and a higher PPV can be obtained, while the sensitivity might be compromised by considering more EST variables, in addition to the ST response.

ST segment/heart rate hysteresis improves the diagnostic accuracy of ECG stress test for coronary artery disease in patients with left ventricular hypertrophy

BACKGROUND

The exercise electrocardiographic stress test (ExET) is the most widely used non-invasive diagnostic method to detect coronary artery disease. However, the sole ST depression criteria (ST-max) have poor specificity for coronary artery disease in patients with left ventricular hypertrophy. We hypothesised that ST-segment depression/heart rate hysteresis, depicting the relative behaviour of ST segment depression during the exercise and recovery phase of the test might increase the diagnostic accuracy of ExET for coronary artery disease detection in such patients.

METHODS

In three cardiology centres, we studied 113 consecutive patients (mean age 66 ± 2 years; 88% men) with hypertension-related left ventricular hypertrophy at echocardiography, referred to coronary angiography after an ExET. The following ExET criteria were analysed: ST-max, chronotropic index, heart rate recovery, Duke treadmill score, ST-segment depression/heart rate hysteresis.

RESULTS

We detected significant coronary artery disease at coronary angiography in 61 patients (53%). At receiver-operating characteristic analysis, ST-segment depression/heart rate hysteresis had the highest area under the curve value (0.75, P < 0.001 when compared with the 'neutral' receiver-operating characteristic curve value of 0.5). Area under the curve values were 0.68 (P < 0.01) for the chronotropic index, 0.58 (P = NS) for heart rate recovery, 0.57 (P = NS) for ST-max and 0.52 (P = NS) for the Duke treadmill score.

CONCLUSIONS

Among currently available ExET diagnostic variables, ST-segment depression/heart rate hysteresis offers a substantially better diagnostic accuracy for coronary artery disease than conventional criteria in patients with hypertension-related left ventricular hypertrophy.

Impact of advanced exercise ECG analysis on cost of coronary artery disease management

BACKGROUND

Conventional analysis of exercise electrocardiogram (EX-ECG) has limited accuracy. This study aims to evaluate the potential impact of improving EX-ECG accuracy on costs of diagnosis and number of misdiagnoses of coronary artery disease (CAD).

METHODS

A decision-tree model was simulated including sequential application of diagnostic procedures for suspected CAD. The model was structured in two main branches (presence or absence of CAD). A probabilistic sensitivity analysis was then performed for several combinations of improvement in test sensitivity and specificity.

RESULTS

A clear trend in cost reduction was observed at improving EX-ECG specificity (about 8-8.5 million dollars, corresponding to a 5.6-7.6% reduction according to the prevalence level). Wrong diagnoses counted for 9-13% of test. Improvements in test parameters lead to reductions in wrong diagnoses, especially when increasing specificity (8.8-12.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

A proper improvement in EX-ECG sensitivity and specificity would have a relevant impact on the costs of CAD management, while reducing the number of misdiagnoses.

[Comparative study of exercise-induced ischaemia in coronaropathy and aortic stenosis]

OBJECTIVE

To compare exercise and recovery data between a population of patients with proven CAD and patients with pure aortic stenosis (AS).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Exercise testing results (bicycle ergometry) of 45 patients with AS (34 men, 66+/-12 years, 56+/-20 mmHg peak-to-peak gradient and valve area 0.78+/-0.48cm2) were compared to exercise testing results of 50 patients with CAD (41 men, 65+/-9 years, greater or equal to 70% stenosis on one vessel in 62%, two vessels in 30%, three vessels in 8%).

RESULTS

During exercise, 38% patients with AS and 82% patients with CAD had clinical symptoms. In the AS group, exercise duration was longer, heart rate (HR) was higher, maximal systolic and diastolic blood pressure were lower than in CAD group. The increase of systolic blood pressure was lower in the AS group (34+/-21 mmHg versus 47+/-27 mmHg, p<0.02). Maximal load achieved was not significantly different. Exercise ST depression appeared in 76% of AS group and 88% of CAD group (NS). No difference was found in ST depression, Detrano index and ST segment/HR slope. During recovery, no difference was found in HR variations. Clockwise rotation of the ST/HR recovery loop was more frequent in CAD group (35 patients versus 19 patients, p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

Most of the exercise and recovery data are similar in patients with AS and CAD. Significant discriminating criteria were the increase of systolic blood pressure during exercise and ST/HR recovery loop.

Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and the definition of threshold levels to diagnose coronary artery disease on electrocardiographic stress testing. Part II: the use of ROC curves in the choice of electrocardiographic stress test markers of ischaemia

A common problem in diagnostic medicine, when performing a diagnostic test, is to obtain an accurate discrimination between 'normal' cases and cases with disease, owing to the overlapping distributions of these populations. In clinical practice, it is exceedingly rare that a chosen cut point will achieve perfect discrimination between normal cases and those with disease, and one has to select the best compromise between sensitivity and specificity by comparing the diagnostic performance of different tests or diagnostic criteria available. Receiver operating characteristic (or receiver operator characteristic, ROC) curves allow systematic and intuitively appealing descriptions of the diagnostic performance of a test and a comparison of the performance of different tests or diagnostic criteria. This review will analyse the basic principles underlying ROC curves and their specific application to the choice of optimal parameters on exercise electrocardiographic stress testing. Part II will be devoted to the comparative analysis of various parameters derived from exercise stress testing for the diagnosis of underlying coronary artery disease.

Exercise electrocardiography for diagnosis of coronary artery disease: impact of sampling rate on the diagnostic performance of ST/HR-loop based on data from early recovery phase

Quantitative analysis of electrocardiographic ST-segment/heart rate relationship (ST/HR loop) during early recovery phase of exercise stress test provides a sensitive tool for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD). This study evaluates the effect of data sampling frequency on the diagnostic performance of ST/HR loop in 1876 patients undergoing a routine exercise test on a bicycle ergometer. CAD was verified angiographically in 668 patients and excluded by coronary angiography (n = 119), myocardial scintigraphy (n = 250) and on clinical grounds (n = 839) in 1208 patients. The normalized ST/HR loop area was calculated in all cases by integration of ST-segment amplitude difference from the end of exercise to the end of the first 3 min of recovery period over HR and dividing the integral by the HR difference over the integration period. The effect of different sampling rates (one, two and five samples per minute) on the CAD discrimination ability of ST/HR loop area was subsequently evaluated using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. Reduction in ST/HR data sampling frequency from two to one sample per minute resulted in a significantly decreased diagnostic performance of the ST/HR loop whereas no differences in CAD discrimination capacity were observed between sampling frequencies of two and five samples per minute. The choice of ST/HR data sampling frequency may have a significant impact on the CAD diagnostic ability of the ST/HR loop. The use of sampling frequency below two samples per minute results in a significantly diminished diagnostic performance, a fact that should be taken into consideration when employing ST/HR diagnostic procedures.

A new application of the ST-HR loop to evaluate the exercise-induced reversible ischemia in healed anterior wall myocardial infarction

Exercise-induced ST-segment elevation in infarct-related leads is often seen on the treadmill exercise electrocardiogram of patients with anterior wall myocardial infarction. However, the cause of this phenomenon is still a matter of controversy. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the relation between the direction of ST-segment-heart rate (ST-HR) loop rotation and reversible myocardial ischemia in the infarct-related area. A total of 58 patients were enrolled in this study. They had healed anterior wall myocardial infarctions with single-vessel coronary artery disease and exercise-induced ST-segment elevations in the infarct-related leads, as observed on treadmill exercise electrocardiograms. All patients underwent treadmill exercise electrocardiography and dobutamine stress echocardiography at discharge. The direction of rotation of the ST-HR loop constructed from the treadmill exercise electrocardiogram and the dobutamine stress echocardiographic findings in the infarct-related area were compared. Counterclockwise rotation was seen in 26 of 58 patients. Compared with clockwise rotation, patients with counterclockwise rotation had significantly more viable myocardium (92% vs 69%, p = 0.04) and presence of reversible myocardial ischemia (58% vs 6%, p < 0.01). On the basis of the counterclockwise rotation findings, the diagnostic value of the presence of reversible myocardial ischemia was calculated. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy was 88%, 73%, and 77%, respectively. Counterclockwise rotation of ST-HR loops was strongly related to reversible myocardial ischemia in the infarct-related area. In conclusion, our results have shown that analysis of ST-HR loops may be useful in evaluating the cause of exercise-induced ST-segment elevation in infarct-related leads.

Improved capacity of exercise electrocardiography in the detection of coronary artery disease by focusing on diagnostic variables during the early recovery phase

The temporal distribution of the diagnostic information for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD) provided by exercise-induced electrocardiographic (ECG) ST-segment amplitude changes in different ECG leads in men and women has not been fully investigated. To shed further light in this area, 1877 electrocardiograms selected from 8322 patients undergoing a routine exercise test on a bicycle ergometer were evaluated. ST-segment amplitude and the difference between heart rate-matched recovery and exercise ST-segment amplitudes (ST/HR difference) were measured. Coronary artery disease was verified angiographically in 669 patients and excluded in 1208 patients by angiography (n = 119), by myocardial scintigraphy (n = 250), or on clinical grounds (n = 839). The diagnostic performance of the 2 ECG methods used was assessed by constructing receiver operating characteristic curves for each sampling point every 12 seconds during 10 minutes of recovery as well as the last 4 minutes of exercise for the ST-segment amplitude. ST-segment amplitude performed better after exercise than during exercise and best within the first 2 minutes of recovery. Its diagnostic ability did not differ from the ST-amplitude hysteresis assessed by the difference between recovery ST-segment amplitude and exercise ST-segment amplitude at matched heart rate. Both methods performed better in men and the diagnostic information appeared mainly in leads I, -aVR, II, V 4 , V 5 , and V 6 . The best discrimination of CAD is provided by analysis of ST-segment amplitude changes in 6 specific leads early during the recovery phase. This information should be targeted by exercise ECG diagnostic methods.

ST-recovery loop of exercise-induced ST deviation in the identification of coronary artery disease: Which parameters should we measure?

This study aimed to characterize the ST-recovery loop and assess which range of heart rates (HRs) best discriminates between patients with and without significant coronary artery stenosis. Bicycle exercise tests were undertaken in 44 men and 18 women with coronary artery disease (CAD) and in 59 controls (26 men, 33 women) in the same age range with no signs of CAD. The ST level and the ST-segment slope were continuously monitored, and changes from rest to peak exercise and to 4 min after exercise, respectively, were calculated. Plotting the ST level against HR gives the STHR loop, characterized by the normalized area (NA(alpha)) circumscribed by the ST level during and after exercise from alpha% to 100% of the HR range. Eight values of alpha between 20% and 90% were investigated, and chest and extremity leads were investigated separately. Optimal alpha was found to be < or =70% in men and < or =30% in women. Change in ST-segment slope was the only parameter that gave significant additional discriminating power in both men and women once the area had been taken into account. We conclude that NA(alpha) for extremity and chest leads have similar weights, and that a substantial part of the STHR loop should be taken into consideration, especially in women. NA(30) was superior to end-exercise ST-depression and STHR loop orientation (as defined by the sign of NA(90)) in both men and women, and to ST/HR index in men, in identifying CAD.

Coronary artery disease diagnosis based on exercise electrocardiogram indexes from repolarisation, depolarisation and heart rate variability

Several indexes have been reported to improve the accuracy of exercise test electrocardiogram (ECG) analysis in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease (CAD), compared with the classical ST depression criterion. Some of them combine repolarisation measurements with heart rate (HR) information (such as the so-called ST/HR hysteresis); others are obtained from the depolarisation period (such as the Athens QRS score); finally, there are heart rate variability (HRV) indexes that account for the nervous system activity. The aim of this study was to identify the best exercise ECG indexes for CAD diagnosis. First, a method to automatically estimate repolarisation and depolarisation indexes in the presence of noise during a stress test was developed. The method is divided into three stages: first, a preprocessing step, where QRS detection, filtering and baseline beat rejection are applied to the raw ECG, prior to a weighted averaging; secondly, a post-processing step in which potentially noisy averaged beats are identified and discarded based on their noise variance; finally, the measurement step, in which ECG indexes are computed from the averaged beats. Then, a multivariate discriminant analysis was applied to classify patients referred for the exercise test into two groups: ischaemic (positive coronary angiography) and low-risk (Framingham risk index < 5%). HR-corrected repolarisation indexes improved the sensitivity (SE) and specificity (SP) of the classical exercise test (SE = 90%, SP = 79% against SE = 65%, SP = 66%). Depolarisation indexes also achieved an improvement over ST depression measurements (SE = 78%, SP = 81%). HRV indexes obtained the best classification results in our study population (SE = 94%, SP = 92%) by means of the very high-frequency power (VHF) (0.4-1 Hz) at stress peak.

Significance of ST-segment morphology noted on electrocardiography during the recovery phase after exercise in patients with ischemic heart disease as analyzed with simultaneous dual-isotope single photon emission tomography

BACKGROUND

The significance of differences in electrocardiographic morphology that occur during the recovery phase after exercise has not been clarified. We investigated the relationship between postexercise electrocardiographic morphology and the pattern of residual ischemia measured at that time.

METHODS

Exercise dual-isotope single photon emission computed tomography was performed on 171 consecutive patients with chest pain syndrome. After injection of technetium-99m tetrofosmin at peak exercise and thallium-201 at 3 minutes after exercise, dual-isotope single photon emission computed tomographic images were obtained simultaneously. After cross-talk compensation, the extent of ischemia and its localization were measured at both peak exercise and after exercise.

RESULTS

When 64 patients with angiographically and scintigraphically proven ischemic heart disease were grouped by morphology of ST-segment depressions at 3 minutes after exercise, 38 patients with the downsloping type had ischemia localized mainly to the middle and basal levels as compared with the more rapid resolution of ischemia in 12 patients with horizontal type and 14 patients with no ischemic electrocardiographic response (apical level 18.4% [7/38], 8.3% [1/12], and 0% [0/14], P = not significant, middle level 47.4% [18/38], 16.7% [2/12], and 7.1% [1/14], P <.01, basal level 57.9% [22/38], 33.3% [4/12], and 14.3% [2/14], P <.02, respectively) independent of the extent or localization of any ischemia noted during exercise (all levels, P = not significant).

CONCLUSION

Electrocardiographic morphology during the recovery phase of exercise reflects the extent and localization of residual ischemia at that time independent of ischemic changes noted during exercise.

A new method to quantify postexercise ST-deviation--the ST-deficit. A study in men at high and low-risk for coronary heart disease

BACKGROUND

Quantitative heart rate adjusted exercise ST criteria like microV/beats per minute (bpm) improve the diagnostic accuracy of the exercise ECG. However, there are few quantitative HR adjusted postexercise variables available. The aim of the present exercise study was to evaluate a new such variable from computerized averaging of the postexercise ECG.

METHODS

The presence of possible myocardial ischaemia in a population based sample of 74 elderly male hypertensives at high-risk of coronary heart disease, and in 42 age-matched clinically healthy males (reference group) at low-risk was assessed by exercise ECG. All men had a normal resting ECG without signs of ischaemia.

VARIABLES STUDIED

standard ST-criteria, ST/HR slope < or =-2.4 microV. bpm-1, shape of the rate-recovery loop, the latter also with a new quantitative variable, the ST-deficit.

RESULTS

In spite of a normal resting ECG many subjects showed an abnormal ST/HR slope during exercise, 43% in the hypertension group and 26% in the reference group. An abnormal rate-recovery loop (ST-deficit) also contributed substantially to identify patients with possible myocardial ischaemia, 30 vs. 10%, respectively (P<0.02); cumulatively for the two HR adjusted criteria 53% vs. 29%, respectively (P<0.02). Mean ST-deficit was significantly lower in the high-risk group.

CONCLUSIONS

Effort-related myocardial ischaemia is frequently silent in elderly high-risk hypertensives and necessitates testing, preferably with computerized exercise ECG and heart rate adjusted ST criteria. A new quantitative variable to assess the postexercise rate-recovery loop in the time domain, the ST-deficit is described. This variable seems to effectively discriminate between subjects with low and high-risk for coronary heart disease and thus provides new information. Further studies are warranted to validate this variable against myocardial perfusion scintigraphy and coronary angiography.

Exercise electrocardiography test in patients with aortic stenosis. Differential features from that of coronary artery disease

BACKGROUND AND AIM OF THE STUDY

Studies that have been conducted with an exercise test in patients with aortic stenosis (AS) have demonstrated that results of an exercise test can mimic that of coronary artery disease (CAD). The objective of our study was to investigate if there was any differential feature(s) of an exercise test in patients with AS compared to those with CAD.

METHODS

We prospectively studied 42 patients with AS (AS group, age 37 +/- 23, range 8-75) with an averaged maximal gradient of 42 +/- 19 mmHg (range 26-95). All patients had undergone a coronary angiography within 1 week of the exercise test and none had CAD. Another 100 patients with CAD, diagnosis proven with coronary angiography, comprised our second group for the comparison (CAD group). Cornell protocol was used in all patients.

RESULTS

ST-segment depression was observed in all patients (160 +/- 25 microV in AS group and 170 +/- 20 microV in CAD group, P>0.05). Thirty-four (81%) patients in AS group and 88 (88%) patients in CAD group exceeded the classical threshold for the test positivity (P>0.05). ST/HR slopes derived from heart rate adjustment to ST-segment level did not differ between the study groups (3.2 +/- 2.3 and 3.7 +/- 2.2 microV/beat/min, in AS and CAD groups, respectively, P>0.05). Recovery-phase patterns of ST-segment in heart rate domain were quite different between AS and CAD (clockwise loop: 86% vs. 0%; counterclockwise loop: 9% vs. 88% in AS group and CAD group, respectively, both P<0.0001). Percentage of intermediate loop was 5% in AS group and 12% in CAD group (P>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrated that patients with AS could be distinguished from those with CAD with the method of rate-recovery loop analysis.

Usefulness of a quantitative analysis of the recovery phase patterns of the ST-segment depression in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

PURPOSE

To assess the diagnostic value of the recovery phase patterns of the ST-segment depression in patients referred for chest pain.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Continuous plots of ST-segment depression against heart rate during exercise and recovery were constructed within a population of 160 consecutive symptomatic patients who all had undergone catheterization (80 with > or = 1 stenosis > or = 50%). We used a new quantitative method of measurement allowing all kinds of rate recovery loops (even the so-called "intermediate" loops) to be considered for analysis. The measurements of the heart rate (HR)-adjusted ST-segment depression were performed at 20 and 60 ms from the J point, providing two different values of a quantified recovery loop index (RLI): RLI 20 and RLI 60.

RESULTS

Both RLI showed a higher specificity (0.81 +/- 0.04 and 0.74 +/- 0.05, respectively) than did the standard criterion (0.65 +/- 0.10), but the difference was significant regarding RLI 20 only (P = 0.011). As to the sensitivity, no significant differences were found among all of the criteria (0.74 +/- 0.05, 0.80 +/- 0.04, 0.76 +/- 0.05, respectively). The timing of measurements of the RLI within the repolarization phase did not affect their overall accuracy (0.77 +/- 0.03 for both RLI). The values of the receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve areas were significantly greater for both RLI (0.83 +/- 0.06 and 0.84 +/- 0.06 respectively) than for the standard criterion (0.75 +/- 0.07; P < 0.02). Finally, both RLI allowed to differentiate accurately the study subjects according to the number of diseased vessels, whereas the standard criterion could only distinguish between CAD patients and subjects with normal angiograms.

CONCLUSION

The quantitative analysis of the rate recovery phase patterns appears to be useful for the diagnosis of coronary heart disease and the assessment of its severity in symptomatic patients.

Accurate detection of coronary artery disease by integrated analysis of the ST-segment depression/heart rate patterns during the exercise and recovery phases of the exercise electrocardiography test

In this comparative cross-sectional study, we evaluated whether a novel computerized diagnostic variable, ST-segment depression/heart rate ST/HR analysis during both the exercise and postexercise recovery phases of the exercise electrocardiography (ECG) test, can detect coronary artery disease more accurately than methods using either exercise or recovery phase alone. The study population comprised 347 clinical patients referred for a routine bicycle exercise ECG test at Tampere University Hospital, Finland. Of these, 127 had angiographically proven coronary artery disease, whereas 13 had no coronary artery disease according to angiography, 18 had no perfusion defect according to technetium-99m sestamibi single-photon emission computed tomography, and 189 were clinically normal with respect to cardiac diseases. For each patient, the maximum values of the ST/HR hysteresis, ST/HR index, end-exercise ST depression, and recovery ST depression were determined from the Mason-Likar modification of the standard 12-lead exercise electrocardiogram [aVL, aVR, and V1 excluded]. The diagnostic performance of these continuous diagnostic variables was compared by means of receiver-operating characteristic analysis. The area under the receiver-operating characteristic curve of the ST/HR hysteresis was 89%, which was significantly larger than that of the end-exercise ST depression (76%, p < or = 0.0001), recovery ST depression (84%, p = 0.0063), or ST/HR index (83%, p = 0.0023), indicating superior diagnostic performance of the ST/HR hysteresis independent of the partition value selection. In conclusion, computerized analysis of the HR-adjusted ST depression pattern during the exercise phase, integrated with the HR-adjusted ST depression pattern during the recovery phase after exercise, can significantly improve the diagnostic performance and clinical utility of the exercise ECG test for the detection of coronary artery disease.

Diagnosis of silent myocardial ischemia using ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring with pedometer, analysis of heart rate, and ST loop in ambulatory electrocardiogram

BACKGROUND

It has been suggested that episodes of silent myocardial ischemia (SMI) might influence the prognosis of patients with ischemic heart disease, as its consequences are similar to those of myocardial ischemia accompanied by pain. Ambulatory electrocardiogram (ECG) is generally employed in diagnosis as well as in evaluation of clinical efficacy in patients with SMI, but problems related to its application remain because of the difficulty in differentiating between nonischemic and ischemic ST-segment depressions and because of the absence of data concerning body movement.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We developed a method for simultaneously recording onto magnetic tape both the ECG chart and pedometer count, as well as a program which enables semi-automatic analysis of the heart rate (HR)-ST relationship. This new method was employed to record ambulatory ECG along with pedometer count for a total of 70 patients, consisting of 53 with coronary heart disease who were shown to have ischemic heart disease, and 17 with various heart diseases in whom coronary angiography revealed no coronary stenosis. The HR-ST relationship was assessed for periods during which steps were recorded by the pedometer, that is, when patients were confirmed to have been under exertion effort. Patients demonstrating the following findings were diagnosed as true positive for SMI: the ST segment level did not decline until HR increased to a certain threshold, and the rate of change in the ST-segment level noted thereafter was -0.025 mm/beats/min or lower; or the ST-segment depression induced by effort continued even after discontinuation of exercise, after which time HR began to decrease, and the HR-ST loop consequently described a counterclockwise rotation. Evaluation of the HR-ST relationship based on these criteria revealed excellent results, as demonstrated by values of 79.2% for sensitivity and 94% for specificity.

CONCLUSION

Our newly developed method of assessment of the HR-ST relationship via analysis of simultaneous data from an ambulatory ECG and a pedometer appears to be time saving, highly objective, and useful with regard to the diagnosis of SMI and evaluation of the therapeutic effect of drugs in patients with ischemic heart disease.

Prognostic value of heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST segment depression in the multiple risk factor intervention trial

OBJECTIVES

We sought to assess the effect of heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression on risk stratification for the prediction of death from coronary artery disease.

BACKGROUND

Standard analysis of the ST segment response to exercise based on a fixed magnitude of horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression has demonstrated only limited diagnostic sensitivity for the detection of coronary artery disease and has variable test performance in predicting coronary artery disease mortality. Heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of ST segment depression has been proposed as an alternative approach to increase the diagnostic and prognostic accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG).

METHODS

Exercise ECGs were performed in 5,940 men from the Usual Care Group of the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial at entry into the study. An abnormal ST segment response to exercise was defined according to standard criteria as > or = 100 micro V of additional horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression at peak exercise. The ST segment/heart rate index was calculated by dividing the change in ST segment depression from rest to peak exercise by the exercise-induced change in heart rate. An abnormal ST segment/heart rate index was defined as >1.60 micro V/beats per min.

RESULTS

After a mean follow-up of 7 years there were 109 coronary artery disease deaths. Using a Cox proportional hazards model, a positive exercise ECG by standard criteria was not predictive of coronary mortality (age-adjusted relative risk [RR] 1.5, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.6 to 3.6, p = 0.39). In contrast, an abnormal ST segment/heart rate index significantly increased the risk of death from coronary artery disease (age-adjusted RR 4.1, 95% CI 2.7 to 6.0, p < 0.0001). Excess risk of death was confined to the highest quintile of ST segment/heart rate index values, and within this quintile, risk was directly related to the magnitude of test abnormality. After multivariate adjustment for age, diastolic blood pressure, serum cholesterol and cigarettes smoked per day, the ST segment/heart rate index remained a significant independent predictor of coronary death (RR 3.6, 95% CI 2.4 to 5.4, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Simple heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of ST segment depression improves the prediction of death from coronary artery disease in relatively high risk, asymptomatic men. These findings strongly support the use of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST segment depression to improve the predictive value of the exercise ECG.

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression and performance of the exercise electrocardiogram: a critical evaluation

Analysis of the rate-related change in exercise-induced ST segment depression using the exercise ST segment/heart rate slope and ST segment/heart rate index can improve the accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) for the identification of patients with coronary artery disease, recognition of patients with anatomically or functionally severe coronary obstruction and detection of patients at increased risk for future coronary events. These methods provide a more physiologic approach to analysis of the ST segment response to exercise by adjusting the apparent severity of ischemia for the corresponding increase in myocardial oxygen demand, which in turn can be linearly related to increasing heart rate. Solid-angle theory provides a model for the linear relation of ST segment depression to heart rate during exercise and a framework for understanding the relation of the ST segment/heart rate slope to the presence and extent of coronary artery disease. False positive and false negative test results of the heart rate-adjusted methods are well known in selected populations and require further clarification. Application of these methods is also highly dependent on the type of exercise protocol, number of ECG leads examined, timing of ST segment measurement relative to the J point and accuracy and precision of ST segment measurement. These methodologic details have been an important limitation to test application when traditional protocols and measurement procedures are required. When applied with attention to required details, the heart rate-adjusted methods can improve the usefulness of the exercise ECG in a range of clinically relevant populations.

The importance of assessing time-course behaviour of abnormal ST/T changes after exercise

Routine stress electrocardiography has been criticised for yielding too many so-called 'false-positive' results because ST/T changes that develop during and after exercise are prevalent. Recent studies in our institution indicate, however, that the time-course behaviour patterns of these ST/T configurational 'abnormalities' after exercise are different from those reflecting myocardial ischaemia due to epicardial coronary artery disease (CAD). Time-course analysis increases the predictive value of exercise testing and has dramatically decreased the number of asymptomatic subjects or symptomatic patients at low risk of having CAD being subjected to coronary arteriography in our institution. Our method of assessing post-exercise time course patterns of abnormal ST/T are described in detail. Ischaemic ST/T abnormalities have late onset, early offset or early onset, late offset whereas those ST/T changes associated with normal epicardial coronary arteries have late onset, late offset or early onset, early offset post-exercise time course patterns.

Application of computerized exercise ECG digitization. Interpretation in large clinical trials

The authors report on a semiautomated program that incorporates both visual identification of fiducial points and digital determination of the ST-segment at 60 ms and 80 ms from the J point, ST slope, changes in R wave, and baseline drift. The off-line program can enhance the accuracy of detecting electrocardiographic (ECG) changes, as well as reproducibility of the exercise and postexercise ECG, as a marker of myocardial ischemia. The analysis program is written in Microsoft QuickBASIC 2.0 for an IBM personal computer interfaced to a Summagraphics mm1201 microgrid II digitizer. The program consists of the following components: (1) alphanumeric data entry, (2) ECG wave form digitization, (2) calculation of test results, (4) physician overread, and (5) editor function for remeasurements. This computerized exercise ECG digitization-interpretation program is accurate and reproducible for the quantitative assessment of ST changes and requires minimal time allotment for physician overread. The program is suitable for analysis and interpretation of large volumes of exercise tests in multicenter clinical trials and is currently utilized in the TIMI II, TIMI III, and BARI studies sponsored by the National Institutes of Health.

Identifying coronary artery disease in women by heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression and improved performance of linear regression over simple averaging method with comparison to standard criteria

Performance of exercise electrocardiography for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD) in women has been limited by relatively poor sensitivity and specificity of standard test criteria. Recent studies suggest that diagnostic methods incorporating heart rate (HR) adjustment of ST-segment depression during exercise may improve the accuracy of exercise testing in women, but the relative performance of different rate-adjusted methods for this purpose is unknown. To assess the effect of gender on relative test performance of the ST-segment/HR (ST/HR) slope, the simple ST/HR index, the HR-recovery loop, and standard ST-depression criteria for the identification of CAD, the exercise electrocardiograms of 254 patients with known or suspected CAD (67 women and 187 men) and of 150 clinically normal subjects (29 women and 121 men) were analyzed. Specificity of each method was comparable in men and women: ST/HR slope 98% (118 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), ST/HR index 97% (117 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), and HR-recovery loop 96% (116 of 121) vs 93% (27 of 29). In contrast, although there was no difference in sensitivity of the ST/HR slope (95% [177 of 187] vs 93% [62 of 67]; p = not significant [NS]) or HR-recovery loop (90% [168 of 187] vs 87% [58 of 67]; p = NS) between men and women, the ST/HR index was less sensitive for CAD in women than in men (82% [55 of 67] vs 93% [173 of 187]; p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A combination of electrocardiographic methods represents a further step toward the noninvasive identification of patients with syndrome X

Identification of patients with angina but normal coronary arteriograms (syndrome X) using noninvasive means would be desirable. The ability of four established exercise electrocardiographic methods to identify angina patients with and without coronary artery disease was compared with that of a method based on a combination of the above (combined method). A treadmill score, a multivariate method, the ST segment recovery loop, the ST/heart rate adjustment, and the combined method were applied to 112 patients who had typical exertional angina and positive exercise tests (greater than 1 mm ST segment depression); 90 had documented coronary artery disease and 22 had syndrome X. The combined method and the treadmill score had a significantly higher diagnostic accuracy (both 81%, as 91 of the 112 patients were correctly identified by both methods) than the multivariate (66%) and ST segment recovery loop (64%) methods (p less than 0.05). The ST/heart rate adjustment had a lower sensitivity for syndrome X than any other method (1 of 22). Thus methods that involve the assessment of both ST and non ST segment variables have greater accuracy in separating syndrome X and coronary artery disease patients than methods relying more heavily on ST segment changes.

Recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression in the heart rate domain cannot distinguish between anginal patients with coronary artery disease and patients with syndrome X

Continuous plots of ST segment depression related to heart rate during exercise and recovery (heart rate recovery loops) can differentiate patients with coronary artery disease from clinically normal subjects. To assess whether this method can also distinguish patients with angina and coronary artery disease from those with syndrome X (angina, positive exercise tests, and normal coronary arteries), we studied 75 patients with coronary artery disease and 30 patients with syndrome X. The average heart rate recovery loops for coronary artery disease and syndrome X patients followed similar counterclockwise loop rotations. Individual data analysis, however, showed that in coronary artery disease patients the loop rotation was counterclockwise in 66 (88%) and intermediate in nine (12%), while none had a clockwise loop nine (30%), and intermediate in nine (30%). Thus heart rate recovery loops cannot distinguish patients with angina and coronary artery disease from those with syndrome X.

Duration of ST segment depression after exercise-induced myocardial ischemia is influenced by body position during recovery but not by type of exercise

To assess whether the duration of ischemic ST segment depression after exercise can be modified by changes in body position during recovery or with different types of exercise, 18 patients with chronic stable angina, positive exercise test results, and documented coronary artery disease were prospectively studied. Every patient underwent testing with three different exercise protocols: (1) Bruce (Bruce-standing recovery), (2) abrupt onset of exercise (abrupt), and (3) modified Bruce protocol preceded by a 10-minute warm-up period (warm-up). After exercise test patients recovered in a sitting position. In addition, all patients performed a fourth exercise (Bruce protocol), but this time they recovered in the supine position (Bruce-supine recovery). Time and heart rate-blood pressure product at 1 mm ST segment depression were similar for Bruce-standing recovery, abrupt, and Bruce-supine recovery protocols (5.1 +/- 2, 4.4 +/- 2, and 5.2 +/- 2 minutes and 20.8 +/- 4, 21.3 +/- 4, and 20.4 +/- 4 beats/min x mm Hg x 10(-3), respectively. Heart rate and heart rate-blood pressure product at peak exercise did not differ in Bruce-standing recovery, abrupt, and Bruce-supine recovery. Maximal ST segment depression was -2.0, -1.9, and -2.0 mm with Bruce-standing recovery, abrupt, and Bruce-supine recovery exercise, respectively, and -1.5 mm with warm-up exercise (p less than 0.05). Duration of ST segment depression into recovery was significantly prolonged after Bruce-supine recovery exercise (9.4 + 5 minutes) compared with Bruce-standing recovery, abrupt, and warm-up protocols (6.8 + 3, 5.9 + 4, and 5.0 + 3 minutes, respectively; p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)