Chronic reduction of myocardial ischemia does not attenuate coronary collateral development in miniswine

Mechanistic, technical, and clinical perspectives in therapeutic stimulation of coronary collateral development by angiogenic growth factors

Stimulation of collateral vessel development in the heart by angiogenic growth factor therapy has been tested in animals and humans for almost two decades. Discordance between the outcome of preclinical studies and clinical trials pointed to the difficulties of translation from animal models to patients. Lessons learned in this process identified specific mechanistic, technical, and clinical hurdles, which need to be overcome. This review summarizes current understanding of the mechanisms leading to the establishment of a functional coronary collateral network and the biological processes growth factor therapies should stimulate even under conditions of impaired natural adaptive vascular response. Vector delivery methods are recommended to maximize angiogenic gene therapy efficiency and reduce side effects. Optimization of clinical trial design should include the choice of clinical end points which provide mechanistic proof-of-concept and also reflect clinical benefits (e.g., surrogates to assess increased collateral flow reserve, such as myocardial perfusion imaging). Guidelines are proposed to select patients who may respond to the therapy with high(er) probability. Both short and longer term strategies are outlined which may help to make therapeutic angiogenesis (TA) work in the future.

The coronary circulation in exercise training

Exercise training (EX) induces increases in coronary transport capacity through adaptations in the coronary microcirculation including increased arteriolar diameters and/or densities and changes in the vasomotor reactivity of coronary resistance arteries. In large animals, EX increases capillary exchange capacity through angiogenesis of new capillaries at a rate matched to EX-induced cardiac hypertrophy so that capillary density remains normal. However, after EX coronary capillary exchange area is greater (i.e., capillary permeability surface area product is greater) at any given blood flow because of altered coronary vascular resistance and matching of exchange surface area and blood flow distribution. The improved coronary capillary blood flow distribution appears to be the result of structural changes in the coronary tree and alterations in vasoreactivity of coronary resistance arteries. EX also alters vasomotor reactivity of conduit coronary arteries in that after EX, α-adrenergic receptor responsiveness is blunted. Of interest, α- and β-adrenergic tone appears to be maintained in the coronary microcirculation in the presence of lower circulating catecholamine levels because of increased receptor responsiveness to adrenergic stimulation. EX also alters other vasomotor control processes of coronary resistance vessels. For example, coronary arterioles exhibit increased myogenic tone after EX, likely because of a calcium-dependent PKC signaling-mediated alteration in voltage-gated calcium channel activity in response to stretch. Conversely, EX augments endothelium-dependent vasodilation throughout the coronary arteriolar network and in the conduit arteries in coronary artery disease (CAD). The enhanced endothelium-dependent dilation appears to result from increased nitric oxide bioavailability because of changes in nitric oxide synthase expression/activity and decreased oxidant stress. EX also decreases extravascular compressive forces in the myocardium at rest and at comparable levels of exercise, mainly because of decreases in heart rate and duration of systole. EX does not stimulate growth of coronary collateral vessels in the normal heart. However, if exercise produces ischemia, which would be absent or minimal under resting conditions, there is evidence that collateral growth can be enhanced. While there is evidence that EX can decrease the progression of atherosclerotic lesions or even induce the regression of atherosclerotic lesions in humans, the evidence of this is not strong due to the fact that most prospective trials conducted to date have included other lifestyle changes and treatment strategies by necessity. The literature from large animal models of CAD also presents a cloudy picture concerning whether EX can induce the regression of or slow the progression of atherosclerotic lesions. Thus, while evidence from research using humans with CAD and animal models of CAD indicates that EX increases endothelium-dependent dilation throughout the coronary vascular tree, evidence that EX reverses or slows the progression of lesion development in CAD is not conclusive at this time. This suggests that the beneficial effects of EX in CAD may not be the result of direct effects on the coronary artery wall. If this suggestion is true, it is important to determine the mechanisms involved in these beneficial effects.

Coronary collateral growth and its therapeutic application to coronary artery disease

There is a tremendous body of data concerning the coronary collateral circulation in both experimental animals and humans. The functional importance of a well-developed coronary collateral circulation has now been documented. The paradigm regarding the principal stimulus for coronary collateral growth has shifted from myocardial ischemia to increased shear stress at the site of pre-existing collateral arterioles. Numerous experimental and clinical studies have contributed to elucidation of the mechanisms of coronary collateral growth. Stimulation of coronary collateral growth is an alternative therapeutic approach to patients with intractable angina pectoris who are not indicated for percutaneous coronary intervention and/or coronary artery bypass grafting. Pharmacological and mechanical modulations accelerating coronary collateral growth have been challenged. Because it is conceivable that a well-developed coronary collateral circulation attenuates myocardial ischemia upon exercise, further research addressing coronary collateral growth is needed in both experimental models of myocardial ischemia and human coronary artery disease.

Determinants of collateral development in patients with acute myocardial infarction

BACKGROUND

The presence or absence of collateral circulation to the infarct-related coronary artery in acute myocardial infarction (AMI) significantly impacts on infarct size and resulting left ventricular function. However, the determinants of collateral development have not been clarified.

HYPOTHESIS

The purpose of this study was to elucidate the determinants of collateral development in humans.

METHODS

The study group consisted of 248 patients (178 men, 70 women; mean age 63 years) undergoing coronary angiography within 12 h after the onset of a first AMI. All patients exhibited complete occlusion of the infarct-related artery. The extent of collateral circulation to the area perfused by the infarct-related artery was graded as none, or poorly or well developed, depending on the degree of opacification of the occluded coronary artery on the contralateral injection of contrast.

RESULTS

Well-developed collateral circulation was observed in 92 of the 248 patients (37.1%). The prevalence of well-developed collaterals was 57% in patients with a history of angina pectoris prior to AMI, which was significantly (p < 0.0001) higher than the 26% in those without a history of angina. Multivariate stepwise logistic regression analysis was then applied to identify predictors of collateral development. Possible determinants of collateral development were long-standing preinfarction angina, severity of coronary artery disease, age, gender, and coronary risk factors (hypertension, diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, smoking). This analysis revealed that only the presence of a history of angina pectoris prior to AMI was a significant predictor of collateral development (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

A history of angina pectoris prior to AMI is a clinical marker for coronary stenoses. Since severe coronary stenoses can provide stimuli that lead to collateral development, it is reasonable that a history of angina would also be a clinical marker for collateral vessels.

Regulation of Coronary Blood Flow During Exercise

Exercise is the most important physiological stimulus for increased myocardial oxygen demand. The requirement of exercising muscle for increased blood flow necessitates an increase in cardiac output that results in increases in the three main determinants of myocardial oxygen demand: heart rate, myocardial contractility, and ventricular work. The approximately sixfold increase in oxygen demands of the left ventricle during heavy exercise is met principally by augmenting coronary blood flow (∼5-fold), as hemoglobin concentration and oxygen extraction (which is already 70–80% at rest) increase only modestly in most species. In contrast, in the right ventricle, oxygen extraction is lower at rest and increases substantially during exercise, similar to skeletal muscle, suggesting fundamental differences in blood flow regulation between these two cardiac chambers. The increase in heart rate also increases the relative time spent in systole, thereby increasing the net extravascular compressive forces acting on the microvasculature within the wall of the left ventricle, in particular in its subendocardial layers. Hence, appropriate adjustment of coronary vascular resistance is critical for the cardiac response to exercise. Coronary resistance vessel tone results from the culmination of myriad vasodilator and vasoconstrictors influences, including neurohormones and endothelial and myocardial factors. Unraveling of the integrative mechanisms controlling coronary vasodilation in response to exercise has been difficult, in part due to the redundancies in coronary vasomotor control and differences between animal species. Exercise training is associated with adaptations in the coronary microvasculature including increased arteriolar densities and/or diameters, which provide a morphometric basis for the observed increase in peak coronary blood flow rates in exercise-trained animals. In larger animals trained by treadmill exercise, the formation of new capillaries maintains capillary density at a level commensurate with the degree of exercise-induced physiological myocardial hypertrophy. Nevertheless, training alters the distribution of coronary vascular resistance so that more capillaries are recruited, resulting in an increase in the permeability-surface area product without a change in capillary numerical density. Maintenance of α- and ß-adrenergic tone in the presence of lower circulating catecholamine levels appears to be due to increased receptor responsiveness to adrenergic stimulation. Exercise training also alters local control of coronary resistance vessels. Thus arterioles exhibit increased myogenic tone, likely due to a calcium-dependent protein kinase C signaling-mediated alteration in voltage-gated calcium channel activity in response to stretch. Conversely, training augments endothelium-dependent vasodilation throughout the coronary microcirculation. This enhanced responsiveness appears to result principally from an increased expression of nitric oxide (NO) synthase. Finally, physical conditioning decreases extravascular compressive forces at rest and at comparable levels of exercise, mainly because of a decrease in heart rate. Impedance to coronary inflow due to an epicardial coronary artery stenosis results in marked redistribution of myocardial blood flow during exercise away from the subendocardium towards the subepicardium. However, in contrast to the traditional view that myocardial ischemia causes maximal microvascular dilation, more recent studies have shown that the coronary microvessels retain some degree of vasodilator reserve during exercise-induced ischemia and remain responsive to vasoconstrictor stimuli. These observations have required reassessment of the principal sites of resistance to blood flow in the microcirculation. A significant fraction of resistance is located in small arteries that are outside the metabolic control of the myocardium but are sensitive to shear and nitrovasodilators. The coronary collateral system embodies a dynamic network of interarterial vessels that can undergo both long- and short-term adjustments that can modulate blood flow to the dependent myocardium. Long-term adjustments including recruitment and growth of collateral vessels in response to arterial occlusion are time dependent and determine the maximum blood flow rates available to the collateral-dependent vascular bed during exercise. Rapid short-term adjustments result from active vasomotor activity of the collateral vessels. Mature coronary collateral vessels are responsive to vasodilators such as nitroglycerin and atrial natriuretic peptide, and to vasoconstrictors such as vasopressin, angiotensin II, and the platelet products serotonin and thromboxane A2. During exercise, ß-adrenergic activity and endothelium-derived NO and prostanoids exert vasodilator influences on coronary collateral vessels. Importantly, alterations in collateral vasomotor tone, e.g., by exogenous vasopressin, inhibition of endogenous NO or prostanoid production, or increasing local adenosine production can modify collateral conductance, thereby influencing the blood supply to the dependent myocardium. In addition, vasomotor activity in the resistance vessels of the collateral perfused vascular bed can influence the volume and distribution of blood flow within the collateral zone. Finally, there is evidence that vasomotor control of resistance vessels in the normally perfused regions of collateralized hearts is altered, indicating that the vascular adaptations in hearts with a flow-limiting coronary obstruction occur at a global as well as a regional level. Exercise training does not stimulate growth of coronary collateral vessels in the normal heart. However, if exercise produces ischemia, which would be absent or minimal under resting conditions, there is evidence that collateral growth can be enhanced. In addition to ischemia, the pressure gradient between vascular beds, which is a determinant of the flow rate and therefore the shear stress on the collateral vessel endothelium, may also be important in stimulating growth of collateral vessels.

Translational physiology: porcine models of human coronary artery disease: implications for preclinical trials of therapeutic angiogenesis

"Therapeutic angiogenesis" describes an emerging field of cardiovascular medicine whereby new blood vessels are induced to grow to supply oxygen and nutrients to ischemic cardiac or skeletal muscle. Various methods of producing therapeutic angiogenesis have been employed, including mechanical means, gene therapy, and the use of growth factors, among others. The use of appropriate large-animal models is essential if these therapies are to be critically evaluated in a preclinical setting before their use in humans, yet little has been written comparing the various available models. Over the past decade, swine have been increasingly used in studies of chronic ischemia because of their numerous similarities to humans, including minimal preexisting coronary collaterals as well as similar coronary anatomy and physiology. Consequently, this review describes the most commonly used swine models of chronic myocardial ischemia with special attention to regional myocardial blood flow and function and critically evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of each model in terms of utility for preclinical trials of angiogenic therapies.

Vasomotor function of pig coronary arteries after chronic coronary occlusion

Placement of an ameroid constrictor in large-conduit pig coronary arteries causes progressive stenosis and distal myocardial ischemia. Blood perfusion in the ischemic region is partly dependent on vasomotor responses to neural and humoral factors distal to the occlusion site. To ascertain the degree of impairment of vascular function in pigs, the authors induced myocardial ischemia by placing an ameroid constrictor in the left circumflex coronary artery and examined vascular reactivity and histopathology distal to the constriction site. The sensitivity of the distal left circumflex coronary and nonoccluded control left anterior descending arteries to PGF(2alpha) was similar. After nitric oxide blockade using Nw-nitro-l-arginine methylester (l-NAME), the sensitivity and maximal contraction to PGF(2alpha) were significantly increased in both the left circumflex coronary (EC50: 5.86 +/- 0.74 vs. 3.28 +/- 0.84 microM; C(max): 4.63 +/- 0.28 vs. 6.25 +/- 0.30 g, P < 0.01) and left anterior descending (EC50: 6.57 +/- 0.73 vs. 2.78 +/- 0.16 microM; C(max): 5.09 +/- 0.37 vs. 6.95 +/- 0.39 g, P < 0.01) arteries. Substance P-induced relaxation (100 pM) was blocked to a larger degree in the distal left circumflex coronary artery when compared with the left anterior descending artery (76.9 +/- 4.2% vs. 56.4 +/- 3.1%, P < 0.05). Endothelium-independent relaxation to sodium nitroprusside was similar in the left circumflex coronary and left anterior descending arteries before and after nitric oxide blockade. Histopathologic examination showed no major differences between distal left circumflex coronary artery segments and left anterior descending artery controls. However, scanning electron microscopy showed endothelial hypertrophy and activation in specimens from the left circumflex coronary arteries. In summary, as a result of the major hemodynamic changes induced by a chronic constriction and eventual occlusion of a large coronary artery, distal segments underwent adaptive compensatory changes. Such compensation may be related to an increased nitric oxide production by the hypertrophic endothelium in response to alterations in coronary hemodynamics.

Shunt between the ventricular chamber and coronary arteries preserves left ventricular function in acute myocardial infarction

It is controversial whether newly created channels made by transmyocardial laser revascularization are functionally significant, so the present study evaluated the shunt flow from the left ventricular (LV) cavity to the ischemic myocardium in 51 patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) caused by complete occlusion of the proximal left anterior descending coronary artery. All patients underwent left heart catheterization within 24 h of onset and all underwent successful coronary reperfusion using primary coronary angioplasty with no angiographic restenosis on follow-up coronary angiography (CAG). The presence of the LV shunt flow was evaluated by selective left CAG after successful reperfusion. The LV global ejection fraction (EF) and regional function (centerline method) were analyzed by ventriculography in both the acute and chronic phases. The patients were divided into the 3 groups (Group A, no LV shunt without collaterals, n=20; Group B, no LV shunt with collaterals, n=24; Group C, LV shunt with collaterals, n=7). There was no difference in the grade of collateral circulation between Groups B and C. The improvements in LVEF and regional function from the acute phase to the chronic phase were significantly greater in Group C than in Groups A and B. Not only collateral circulation but also LV shunt contributes to the functional recovery of infarct myocardium in patients with AMI.

Na-H exchange inhibition with cariporide limits functional impairment caused by repetitive ischemia

Intracellular calcium ([Ca]i) overload on reperfusion may be one of the mechanisms responsible for ischemia-induced regional myocardial dysfunction. Because inhibiting the Na-H exchanger (NHE) limits intracellular sodium ([Na]i) and subsequent [Ca]i accumulation, we hypothesized that NHE inhibition would attenuate regional dysfunction in response to 25 cycles of ischemia (I, 2-min) and reperfusion (R, 8-min) of the left circumflex coronary artery (LCx) in conscious swine. Six animals were instrumented to measure arterial pressure, regional myocardial blood flow (colored microspheres), systolic wall thickening (WTh) in the normally perfused (left anterior descending, LAD) and LCx regions (sonomicrometry), LCx blood flow velocity (Doppler), and to reversibly occlude the LCx (hydraulic occluder). Each animal completed three protocols separated by 7 days: ISC, 25 I/R cycles; CAR, 25 I/R cycles + NHE inhibition (cariporide); and VEH, vehicle administration for 4.2 h. Regional myocardial blood flow was measured during LCx occlusion in the first protocol and 10 min after I/R 25 in all protocols. Systemic hemodynamics were similar among and within each protocol. Blood flow measured during LCx occlusion confirmed that perfusion was reduced (p < 0.05) to this compared with the LAD region. During ISC, LCx WTh was reduced (p < 0.05) after five IR cycles, and a stable reduction (approximately 55% of baseline; p < 0.05) was present after 20 I/R cycles. During CAR, LCx systolic WTh was reduced (p < 0.05) only after 15 and 25 I/R cycles (approximately 80 and 72%, respectively). The decrease in LCx WTh was greater in ISC than in CAR (p < 0.05). LCx WTh was not altered during VEH, while LAD WTh was similar within and among all protocols. Regional blood flow measured after 25 I/R cycles was not different among protocols. Our results indicate that NHE inhibition delays the onset and limits the degree of regional dysfunction in response to repeated bouts of ischemia and reperfusion.

Effects of angiotensin II receptor blockade during exercise: comparison of losartan and saralasin

Previous studies indicate that angiotensin II (ANG II) plays a minor role in the hemodynamic responses during dynamic exercise. However, nonspecific effects associated with methods used to block its production [e.g., angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors] or receptors (e.g., saralasin) may have contributed to these findings. Losartan is a nonpeptide ANG II receptor antagonist that is devoid of such nonspecific effects. We hypothesized that the contribution of ANG II to the cardiovascular response to dynamic exercise is characterized more precisely with losartan than with saralasin. On separate days, 6 miniswine performed treadmill running at 80% of their maximal heart rate (HR) reserve (HRR) in the presence of vehicle (0.9% saline), saralasin (10 or 20 micrograms/kg/min intraleft arterially, i.a.), or losartan (15 or 20 mg/kg i.a.). Cardiac output (CO), HR, and myocardial contractility were similar among all exercise conditions. As compared with the vehicle, losartan decreased mean arterial pressure (MAP) and systemic vascular resistance (SVR) during exercise, whereas no differences occurred between the vehicle and saralasin conditions. Both receptor antagonists increased blood flow and/or decreased vascular resistance during exercise in the myocardium, stomach, small intestine, and colon. As compared with that during treadmill running with vehicle infusion, renal blood flow (RBF) was increased by losartan and decreased by saralasin. We conclude that the contribution of ANG II to the cardiovascular response to dynamic exercise is demonstrated more clearly with losartan than with saralasin.

Hemodynamic and regional blood flow responses to nicotine at rest and during exercise

We hypothesized that nicotine compromises cardiovascular responses to dynamic exercise. Hemodynamic variables were measured in conscious miniswine before and at 2 min of nicotine infusion (20 micrograms.kg-1.min-1; i.a.; N = 6) during resting conditions. Mean arterial pressure elevations (MAP; 14%) and plasma nicotine concentrations (49 +/- 7 ng.ml-1) were similar to those elicited by cigarette smoking in humans. In addition, nicotine increased systemic vascular resistance (SVR; 56%), the heart rate x systolic blood pressure product (RPP; 11%), and regional vascular resistance in the left-ventricular, renal, and splanchnic circulations, while cardiac output decreased (CO; 23%) and skeletal muscle blood flow and vascular resistance were unaffected. Plasma norepinephrine and epinephrine increased by approximately 30% and 90%, respectively. On separate days, the same hemodynamic responses were measured before and at 20 min of treadmill running during vehicle or nicotine infusion for the last 2 min of exercise (N = 10). Nicotine increased MAP (6%), SVR (14%), and RPP (3%), and elevated vascular resistance in the proximal colon and pancreas. Moreover, compared to exercise + vehicle, norepinephrine and epinephrine increased by approximately 13% and 24%, respectively, during exercise + nicotine infusion. These findings suggest that the detrimental effects of nicotine observed at rest are minimized during exercise. Nicotine's effects may be reduced during exercise by competition from local vasodilators in the heart and active musculature, and/or by differing activation of sympathetic nerve activity.

Late preconditioning against myocardial stunning. An endogenous protective mechanism that confers resistance to postischemic dysfunction 24 h after brief ischemia in conscious pigs

Conscious pigs underwent a sequence of 10 2-min coronary occlusions, each separated by 2 min of reperfusion, for three consecutive days (days 1, 2, and 3 of stage I). The recovery of systolic wall thickening (WTh) after the 10th reperfusion was markedly improved on days 2 and 3 compared with day 1, indicating that the myocardium had become preconditioned against "stunning." 10 d after stage I, pigs underwent again a sequence of 10 2-min coronary occlusions for two consecutive days (days 1 and 2 of stage II). On day 1 of stage II, the recovery of WTh after the 10th reperfusion was similar to that noted on day 1 of stage I; on day 2 of stage II, however, the recovery of WTh was again markedly improved compared with day 1. Blockade of adenosine receptors with 8-p-sulfophenyl theophylline failed to prevent the development of preconditioning against stunning. Northern blot analysis demonstrated an increase in heat stress protein (HSP) 70 mRNA 2 h after the preconditioning ischemia; at this same time point, immunohistochemical analysis revealed a concentration of HSP70 in the nucleus and an overall increase in staining for HSP70. 24 h after the preconditioning ischemia, Western dot blot analysis demonstrated an increase in HSP70. This study indicates the existence of a new, previously unrecognized cardioprotective phenomenon. The results demonstrate that a brief ischemic stress induces a powerful, long-lasting (at least 48 h) adaptive response that renders the myocardium relatively resistant to stunning 24 h later (late preconditioning against stunning). This adaptive response disappears within 10 d after the last ischemic stress but can be reinduced by another ischemic stress. Unlike early and late preconditioning against infarction, late preconditioning against stunning is not blocked by adenosine receptor antagonists, and therefore appears to involve a mechanism different from that of other forms of preconditioning currently known. The increase in myocardial HSP70 is compatible with, but does not prove, a role of HSPs in the pathogenesis of this phenomenon.

Determinants of collateral development in a canine model with repeated coronary occlusion

It is now accepted that repetitive 2-min coronary occlusion can develop collateral vessels to the area perfused by the occluded coronary artery. However, which factors influence collateral development has yet to be fully elucidated. The goal of the present study was to identify the determinants of the rate of coronary collateral development in dogs undergoing repeated coronary occlusion. The study was conducted in 19 conscious dogs instrumented for measurements of a subendocardial segment length in the area perfused by the left circumflex coronary artery (LCCA), LCCA flow, and left ventricular pressure. An externally inflatable pneumatic occluder was placed around the LCCA. After the recovery from surgery, 2-min LCCA occlusions were conducted eight times daily. Following 141 +/- 61 (SD) LCCA occlusions (20 +/- 7 days), an LCCA occlusion produced no reduction in segment shortening and negligible reactive hyperemia. The total number of LCCA occlusions needed for adequate collateral development (the rate of collateralization) correlated well with the severity of myocardial ischemia during the first occlusion, which was determined mainly by the extent of postsurgical initial collateral circulation. On the other hand, the response to the ischemic stimulus in the later stage of collateral development was independent of the extent of development of the initial postsurgical collaterals. It is concluded that the overall rate of collateral development is slower in dogs with initially poorer collaterals; however, the response of each dog to the ischemic stimulus in the later stage of collateral development was similar among dogs regardless of the extent of the initial collaterals.

Effect of coronary collateral circulation on myocardial ischemia and ventricular dysfunction

Although a functional role of coronary collaterals has been continuously debated, we observed the following facts in our studies during intracoronary thrombolytic therapy: (a) Myocardial ischemia is important for the development of collateral circulation, (b) collaterals can perfuse the infarcted myocardium, and (c) the presence of collaterals prevents the left ventricular aneurysm formation in acute myocardial infarction, even when the amount of the salvaged tissue is small. Thus, coronary collaterals are not merely markers of severe ischemia but help to preserve the functional integrity of the myocardium in the presence of coronary obstruction. We then attempted to promote collateralization to treat patients with angina pectoris. Patients with chronic stable effort angina were treated with heparin followed by treadmill exercise twice a day for 10 days. Treadmill capacity was found to improve in association with an increase in coronary collateral circulation. Heparin treatment of ischemic patients was found to be a noninvasive alternative to percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty and coronary bypass surgery for patients who are not candidates for invasive procedures.