Letter by Amin et al Regarding Article, "Genetic Modifiers for the Long-QT Syndrome: How Important Is the Role of Variants in the 3' Untranslated Region of KCNQ1?"

To Modify or Not to Modify: Allele‐Specific Effects of 3'UTR‐ KCNQ1 Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms on Clinical Phenotype in a Long QT 1 Founder Population Segregating a Dominant‐Negative Mutation

Background

There are conflicting reports with regard to the allele‐specific gene suppression effects of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the 3'untranslated region (3'UTR) of the KCNQ1 gene in long QT syndrome type 1 (LQT1) populations. Here we assess the allele‐specific effects of 3 previously published 3'UTR‐ KCNQ1 's SNPs in a LQT1 founder population segregating a dominant‐negative mutation.

Methods and Results

Bidirectional sequencing of the KCNQ1 ' s 3'UTR was performed in the p.Y111C founder population (n=232, 147 genotype positive), with a minor allele frequency of 0.1 for SNP1 (rs2519184) and 0.6 for linked SNP2 (rs8234) and SNP3 (rs107980). Allelic phase was assessed in trios aided by haplotype data, revealing a high prevalence of derived SNP2/3 in cis with p.Y111C (89%). Allele‐specific association analyses, corrected using a relatedness matrix, were performed between 3'UTR‐ KCNQ1 SNP genotypes and clinical phenotypes. SNP1 in trans was associated with a significantly higher proportion of symptomatic phenotype compared with no derived SNP1 allele in trans (58% versus 32%, corrected P =0.027). SNP2/3 in cis was associated with a significantly lower proportion of symptomatic phenotype compared with no derived SNP2/3 allele in cis (32% versus 69%, corrected P =0.010).

Conclusions

Allele‐specific modifying effects on symptomatic phenotype of 3'UTR‐ KCNQ1 SNPs rs2519184, rs8234, and rs107980 were seen in a LQT1 founder population segregating a dominant‐negative mutation. The high prevalence of suppressive 3'UTR‐ KCNQ1 SNPs segregating with the founder mutation could contribute to the previously documented low incidence of cardiac events in heterozygous carriers of the p.Y111C KCNQ1 mutation.

Modifier genes for sudden cardiac death

Genetic conditions, even those associated with identical gene mutations, can present with variable clinical manifestations. One widely accepted explanation for this phenomenon is the existence of genetic factors capable of modifying the consequences of disease-causing mutations (modifier genes). Here, we address the concepts and principles by which genetic factors may be involved in modifying risk for cardiac arrhythmia, then discuss the current knowledge and interpretation of their contribution to clinical heterogeneity. We illustrate these concepts in the context of two important clinical conditions associated with risk for sudden cardiac death including a monogenic disorder (congenital long QT syndrome) in which the impact of modifier genes has been established, and a complex trait (life-threatening arrhythmias in acute myocardial infarction) for which the search for genetic modifiers of arrhythmic risk is more challenging. Advances in understanding the contribution of modifier genes to a higher or lower propensity towards sudden death should improve patient-specific risk stratification and be a major step towards precision medicine.