Embracing Heterogeneity in The Multicenter Stroke Preclinical Assessment Network (SPAN) Trial

Reliable infarction of the middle cerebral artery territory in C57BL/6 mice using pterygopalatine artery ligation and filament optimization - The PURE-MCAo model

Current techniques for inducing intraluminal filamentous middle cerebral artery occlusion (fMCAo) in mice produce highly variable results and often cause additional infarcts in the posterior cerebral artery (PCA) territory. The aim of the current study was to develop a novel procedure to overcome these shortcomings. Male C57BL/6 mice were subjected to 60 min of fMCAo with cerebral blood flow monitored by laser Doppler flowmetry. The influence of the length of the occlusion filament coating and the combination of common carotid artery (CCA) or pterygopalatine artery (PPA) ligation on lesion volume and functional outcome 24 h after reperfusion was evaluated. The use of appropriate filament and PPA ligation while maintaining CCA perfusion prevented the development of infarcts in the PCA area, resulted in pure MCA infarcts (68.3 ± 14.5 mm3) and reduced the variability of infarct volumes by more than half (from 26-38% to 14% standard deviation/mean). Using an improved fMCAo procedure, we were able to produce PCA area-unaffected reproducible (PURE) infarcts exclusively in the MCA territory. Thus PURE-MCAo reduced outcome variability by more than 50%. Our results may thus help to reduce the number of animals in preclinical stroke research and to increase the reproducibility of the fMCAo model.

Stroke of Consistency: Streamlining Multicenter Protocols for Enhanced Reproducibility of Infarct Volumes in Preclinical Stroke Research

BACKGROUND

The discrepancy between experimental research and clinical trial outcomes is a persistent challenge in preclinical studies, particularly in stroke research. A possible factor contributing to this issue is the lack of standardization across experimental stroke models, leading to poor reproducibility in multicenter studies. This study addresses this gap by aiming to enhance reproducibility and the efficacy of multicenter studies through the harmonization of protocols and training of involved personnel.

METHODS

We established a set of standard operating procedures for various stroke models and the Neuroscore. These standard operating procedures were implemented across multiple research centers, followed by specialized, in-person training for all participants. We measured the variability in infarct volume both before and after the implementation of these standardized protocols and training sessions.

RESULTS

The standardization process led to a significant reduction in variability of infarct volume across different stroke models (40%-50% reduction), demonstrating the effectiveness of our harmonized protocols and training. Additionally, the implementation of the Neuroscore system across centers showed low variability and consistent results up to 28 days poststroke, underscoring its utility in chronic phase evaluations.

CONCLUSIONS

The harmonization of protocols and surgeon training significantly reduced variability in experimental outcomes across different centers. This improvement can increase the comparability of data between research groups and enhance the statistical power of multicenter studies. Our findings also establish the Neuroscore as a reliable tool for long-term assessment in stroke research, paving the way for more consistent and impactful multicenter preclinical studies.

Biological and Procedural Predictors of Outcome in the Stroke Preclinical Assessment Network (SPAN) Trial

BACKGROUND

The SPAN trial (Stroke Preclinical Assessment Network) is the largest preclinical study testing acute stroke interventions in experimental focal cerebral ischemia using endovascular filament middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAo). Besides testing interventions against controls, the prospective design captured numerous biological and procedural variables, highlighting the enormous heterogeneity introduced by the multicenter structure that might influence stroke outcomes. Here, we leveraged the unprecedented sample size achieved by the SPAN trial and the prospective design to identify the biological and procedural variables that affect experimental stroke outcomes in transient endovascular filament MCAo.

METHODS

The study cohort included all mice enrolled and randomized in the SPAN trial (N=1789). Mice were subjected to 60-minute MCAo and followed for a month. Thirteen biological and procedural independent variables and 4 functional (weight loss and 4-point neuroscore on days 1 and 2, corner test on days 7 and 28, and mortality) and 3 tissue (day 2, magnetic resonance imaging infarct volumes and swelling; day 30, magnetic resonance imaging tissue loss) outcome variables were prospectively captured. Multivariable regression with stepwise elimination was used to identify the predictors and their effect sizes.

RESULTS

Older age, active circadian stage at MCAo, and thinner and longer filament silicone tips predicted higher mortality. Older age, larger body weight, longer anesthesia duration, and longer filament tips predicted worse neuroscores, while high-fat diet and blood flow monitoring predicted milder neuroscores. Older age and a high-fat diet predicted worse corner test performance. While shorter filament tips predicted more ipsiversive turning, longer filament tips appeared to predict contraversive turning. Age, sex, and weight interacted when predicting the infarct volume. Older age was associated with smaller infarcts on day 2 magnetic resonance imaging, especially in animals with larger body weights; this association was most conspicuous in females. High-fat diet also predicted smaller infarcts. In contrast, the use of cerebral blood flow monitoring and more severe cerebral blood flow drop during MCAo, longer anesthesia, and longer filament tips all predicted larger infarcts. Bivariate analyses among the dependent variables highlighted a disconnect between tissue and functional outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Our analyses identified variables affecting endovascular filament MCAo outcome, an experimental stroke model used worldwide. Multiple regression refuted some commonly reported predictors and revealed previously unrecognized associations. Given the multicenter prospective design that represents a sampling of real-world conditions, the degree of heterogeneity mimicking clinical trials, the large number of predictors adjusted for in the multivariable model, and the large sample size, we think this is the most definitive analysis of the predictors of preclinical stroke outcome to date. Future multicenter experimental stroke trials should standardize or at least ensure a balanced representation of the biological and procedural variables identified herein as potential confounders.

Now that the door is open: an update on ischemic stroke pharmacotherapeutics for the neurointerventionalist

The last 10 years have seen a major shift in management of large vessel ischemic stroke with changes towards ever-expanding use of reperfusion therapies (intravenous thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy). These strategies 'open the door' to acute therapeutics for ischemic tissue, and we should investigate novel therapeutic approaches to enhance survival of recently reperfused brain. Key insights into new approaches have been provided through translational research models and preclinical paradigms, and through detailed research on ischemic mechanisms. Additional recent clinical trials offer exciting salvos into this new strategy of pairing reperfusion with neuroprotective therapy. This pairing strategy can be employed using drugs that have shown neuroprotective efficacy; neurointerventionalists can administer these during or immediately after reperfusion therapy. This represents a crucial moment when we emphasize reperfusion, and have the technological capability along with the clinical trial experience to lead the way in multiprong approaches to stroke treatment.

Angiotensin II Type 2 Receptor Agonism Alleviates Progressive Post-stroke Cognitive Impairment in Aged Spontaneously Hypertensive Rats

Hypertension and aging are leading risk factors for stroke and vascular contributions to cognitive impairment and dementia (VCID). Most animal models fail to capture the complex interplay between these pathophysiological processes. In the current study, we examined the development of cognitive impairment in 18-month-old spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) before and following ischemic stroke. Sixty SHRs were housed for 18 months with cognitive assessments every 6 months and post-surgery. MRI scans were performed at baseline and throughout the study. On day 3 post-stroke, rats were randomized to receive either angiotensin II type 2 receptor (AT2R) agonist Compound 21 (C21) or plain water for 8 weeks. SHRs demonstrated a progressive cognitive decline and significant MRI abnormalities before stroke. Perioperative mortality within 72 h of stroke was low. Stroke resulted in significant acute brain swelling, chronic brain atrophy, and sustained sensorimotor and behavioral deficits. There was no evidence of anhedonia at week 8. C21 enhanced sensorimotor recovery and ischemic lesion resolution at week 8. SHRs represent a clinically relevant animal model to study aging and stroke-associated VCID. This study underscores the importance of translational disease modeling and provides evidence that modulation of the AT2R signaling via C21 may be a useful therapeutic option to improve sensorimotor and cognitive outcomes even in aged animals.

Immune-Neurovascular Interactions in Experimental Perinatal and Childhood Arterial Ischemic Stroke

Emerging clinical and preclinical data have demonstrated that the pathophysiology of arterial ischemic stroke in the adult, neonates, and children share similar mechanisms that regulate brain damage but also have distinct molecular signatures and involved cellular pathways due to the maturational stage of the central nervous system and the immune system at the time of the insult. In this review, we discuss similarities and differences identified thus far in rodent models of 2 different diseases-neonatal (perinatal) and childhood arterial ischemic stroke. In particular, we review acquired knowledge of the role of resident and peripheral immune populations in modulating outcomes in models of perinatal and childhood arterial ischemic stroke and the most recent and relevant findings in relation to the immune-neurovascular crosstalk, and how the influence of inflammatory mediators is dependent on specific brain maturation stages. Finally, we discuss the current state of treatments geared toward age-appropriate therapies that signal via the immune-neurovascular interaction and consider sex differences to achieve successful translation.

CNS Drug Delivery in Stroke: Improving Therapeutic Translation From the Bench to the Bedside

Drug development for ischemic stroke is challenging as evidenced by the paucity of therapeutics that have advanced beyond a phase III trial. There are many reasons for this lack of clinical translation including factors related to the experimental design of preclinical studies. Often overlooked in therapeutic development for ischemic stroke is the requirement of effective drug delivery to the brain, which is critical for neuroprotective efficacy of several small and large molecule drugs. Advancing central nervous system drug delivery technologies implies a need for detailed comprehension of the blood-brain barrier (BBB) and neurovascular unit. Such knowledge will permit the innate biology of the BBB/neurovascular unit to be leveraged for improved bench-to-bedside translation of novel stroke therapeutics. In this review, we will highlight key aspects of BBB/neurovascular unit pathophysiology and describe state-of-the-art approaches for optimization of central nervous system drug delivery (ie, passive diffusion, mechanical opening of the BBB, liposomes/nanoparticles, transcytosis, intranasal drug administration). Additionally, we will discuss how endogenous BBB transporters represent the next frontier of drug delivery strategies for stroke. Overall, this review will provide cutting edge perspective on how central nervous system drug delivery must be considered for the advancement of new stroke drugs toward human trials.

Prediction of Stroke Outcome in Mice Based on Noninvasive MRI and Behavioral Testing

BACKGROUND

Prediction of poststroke outcome using the degree of subacute deficit or magnetic resonance imaging is well studied in humans. While mice are the most commonly used animals in preclinical stroke research, systematic analysis of outcome predictors is lacking.

METHODS

We intended to incorporate heterogeneity into our retrospective study to broaden the applicability of our findings and prediction tools. We therefore analyzed the effect of 30, 45, and 60 minutes of arterial occlusion on the variance of stroke volumes. Next, we built a heterogeneous cohort of 215 mice using data from 15 studies that included 45 minutes of middle cerebral artery occlusion and various genotypes. Motor function was measured using a modified protocol for the staircase test of skilled reaching. Phases of subacute and residual deficit were defined. Magnetic resonance images of stroke lesions were coregistered on the Allen Mouse Brain Atlas to characterize stroke topology. Different random forest prediction models that either used motor-functional deficit or imaging parameters were generated for the subacute and residual deficits.

RESULTS

Variance of stroke volumes was increased by 45 minutes of arterial occlusion compared with 60 minutes. The inclusion of various genotypes enhanced heterogeneity further. We detected both a subacute and residual motor-functional deficit after stroke in mice and different recovery trajectories could be observed. In mice with small cortical lesions, lesion volume was the best predictor of the subacute deficit. The residual deficit could be predicted most accurately by the degree of the subacute deficit. When using imaging parameters for the prediction of the residual deficit, including information about the lesion topology increased prediction accuracy. A subset of anatomic regions within the ischemic lesion had particular impact on the prediction of long-term outcomes. Prediction accuracy depended on the degree of functional impairment.

CONCLUSIONS

For the first time, we developed and validated a robust tool for the prediction of functional outcomes after experimental stroke in mice using a large and genetically heterogeneous cohort. These results are discussed in light of study design and imaging limitations. In the future, using outcome prediction can improve the design of preclinical studies and guide intervention decisions.

Evolving Clinical-Translational Investigations of Cerebroprotection in Ischemic Stroke

Ischemic stroke is a highly morbid disease, with over 50% of large vessel stroke (middle cerebral artery or internal carotid artery terminus occlusion) patients suffering disability despite maximal acute reperfusion therapy with thrombolysis and thrombectomy. The discovery of the ischemic penumbra in the 1980s laid the foundation for a salvageable territory in ischemic stroke. Since then, the concept of neuroprotection has been a focus of post-stroke care to (1) minimize the conversion from penumbra to core irreversible infarct, (2) limit secondary damage from ischemia-reperfusion injury, inflammation, and excitotoxicity and (3) to encourage tissue repair. However, despite multiple studies, the preclinical-clinical research enterprise has not yet created an agent that mitigates post-stroke outcomes beyond thrombolysis and mechanical clot retrieval. These translational gaps have not deterred the scientific community as agents are under continuous investigation. The NIH has recently promoted the concept of cerebroprotection to consider the whole brain post-stroke rather than just the neurons. This review will briefly outline the translational science of past, current, and emerging breakthroughs in cerebroprotection and use of these foundational ideas to develop a novel paradigm for optimizing stroke outcomes.

A multi-disciplinary commentary on preclinical research to investigate vascular contributions to dementia

Although dementia research has been dominated by Alzheimer's disease (AD), most dementia in older people is now recognised to be due to mixed pathologies, usually combining vascular and AD brain pathology. Vascular cognitive impairment (VCI), which encompasses vascular dementia (VaD) is the second most common type of dementia. Models of VCI have been delayed by limited understanding of the underlying aetiology and pathogenesis. This review by a multidisciplinary, diverse (in terms of sex, geography and career stage), cross-institute team provides a perspective on limitations to current VCI models and recommendations for improving translation and reproducibility. We discuss reproducibility, clinical features of VCI and corresponding assessments in models, human pathology, bioinformatics approaches, and data sharing. We offer recommendations for future research, particularly focusing on small vessel disease as a main underpinning disorder.

Preclinical models of middle cerebral artery occlusion: new imaging approaches to a classic technique

Stroke remains a major burden on patients, families, and healthcare professionals, despite major advances in prevention, acute treatment, and rehabilitation. Preclinical basic research can help to better define mechanisms contributing to stroke pathology, and identify therapeutic interventions that can decrease ischemic injury and improve outcomes. Animal models play an essential role in this process, and mouse models are particularly well-suited due to their genetic accessibility and relatively low cost. Here, we review the focal cerebral ischemia models with an emphasis on the middle cerebral artery occlusion technique, a "gold standard" in surgical ischemic stroke models. Also, we highlight several histologic, genetic, and in vivo imaging approaches, including mouse stroke MRI techniques, that have the potential to enhance the rigor of preclinical stroke evaluation. Together, these efforts will pave the way for clinical interventions that can mitigate the negative impact of this devastating disease.