Timing between Cortical Slow Oscillations and Heart Rate Bursts during Sleep Predicts Temporal Processing Speed, but Not Offline Consolidation

Effect of Propofol on Heart Rate and Its Coupling to Cortical Slow Waves in Humans

BACKGROUND

Propofol causes significant cardiovascular depression and a slowing of neurophysiological activity. However, literature on its effect on the heart rate remains mixed, and it is not known whether cortical slow waves are related to cardiac activity in propofol anesthesia.

METHODS

The authors performed a secondary analysis of electrocardiographic and electroencephalographic data collected as part of a previously published study where n = 16 healthy volunteers underwent a slow infusion of propofol up to an estimated effect-site concentration of 4 µg/ml. Heart rate, heart rate variability, and individual slow electroencephalographic waves were extracted for each subject. Timing between slow-wave start and the preceding R-wave was tested against a uniform random surrogate. Heart rate data were further examined as a post hoc analysis in n = 96 members of an American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status II/III older clinical population collected as part of the AlphaMax trial.

RESULTS

The slow propofol infusion increased the heart rate in a dose-dependent manner (mean ± SD, increase of +4.2 ± 1.5 beats/min/[μg ml-1]; P < 0.001). The effect was smaller but still significant in the older clinical population. In healthy volunteers, propofol decreased the electrocardiogram R-wave amplitude (median [25th to 75th percentile], decrease of -83 [-245 to -28] μV; P < 0.001). Heart rate variability showed a loss of high-frequency parasympathetic activity. Individual cortical slow waves were coupled to the heartbeat. Heartbeat incidence peaked about 450 ms before slow-wave onset, and mean slow-wave frequency correlated with mean heart rate.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors observed a robust increase in heart rate with increasing propofol concentrations in healthy volunteers and patients. This was likely due to decreased parasympathetic cardioinhibition. Similar to non-rapid eye movement sleep, cortical slow waves are coupled to the cardiac rhythm, perhaps due to a common brainstem generator.

EDITOR’S PERSPECTIVE

Slow oscillations promote long-range effective communication: The key for memory consolidation in a broken-down network

This work introduces a noninvasive approach to understanding information processing during sleep. Our results demonstrate that slow oscillations (SOs) provide the temporal-topographical event framework whereby long-range information flow increases dramatically compared to the relatively local activity patterns of the rest of sleep. The findings represent a conceptual leap in understanding how SOs unlock memory consolidation in a broken-down network, which is by promoting long-range, effective communication. This research will promote further investigations of understanding how brain oscillations alone and in nested rhythms promote network communication, as well as investigate how these properties vary and predict patterns of deficits in clinical populations and aging humans.

A prominent and robust finding in cognitive neuroscience is the strengthening of memories during nonrapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, with slow oscillations (SOs;<1Hz) playing a critical role in systems-level consolidation. However, NREM generally shows a breakdown in connectivity and reduction of synaptic plasticity with increasing depth: a brain state seemingly unfavorable to memory consolidation. Here, we present an approach to address this apparent paradox that leverages an event-related causality measure to estimate directional information flow during NREM in epochs with and without SOs. Our results confirm that NREM is generally a state of dampened neural communication but reveals that SOs provide two windows of enhanced large-scale communication before and after the SO trough. These peaks in communication are significantly higher when SOs are coupled with sleep spindles compared with uncoupled SOs. To probe the functional relevance of these SO-selective peaks of information flow, we tested the temporal and topographic conditions that predict overnight episodic memory improvement. Our results show that global, long-range communication during SOs promotes sleep-dependent systems consolidation of episodic memories. A significant correlation between peaks of information flow and memory improvement lends predictive validity to our measurements of effective connectivity. In other words, we were able to predict memory improvement based on independent electrophysiological observations during sleep. This work introduces a noninvasive approach to understanding information processing during sleep and provides a mechanism for how systems-level brain communication can occur during an otherwise low connectivity sleep state. In short, SOs are a gating mechanism for large-scale neural communication, a necessary substrate for systems consolidation and long-term memory formation.

Autonomic Central Coupling during Daytime Sleep Differs between Older and Younger People

Decreased functioning in the elderly is mirrored by independent changes in central and autonomic nervous systems. Additionally, recent work suggests that the coupling of these systems may also serve an important role. In young adults, Autonomic and Central Events (ACEs), measured in the temporal coincidence of heart rate bursts (HRBs) and increased slow-wave-activity (SWA, 0.5-1Hz) and sigma activity (12-15Hz), followed by parasympathetic surge (RR_HF) during non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, predicted cognitive improvements. However, ACEs have not been examined in the elderly. Thus, the current study compared ACEs during wake and daytime sleep in older and younger adults and examined associations with working memory improvement before and after a nap. Compared to youngers, older adults showed lower amplitude of ACEs during NREM sleep, but not during wake. Furthermore, while younger adults demonstrated a parasympathetic surge after HRBs, older adults showed an earlier rise and longer maintenance of the RRHF. Taken together, our results demonstrate that autonomic-central coupling declines with age. Pathological aging implicates independent roles for decreased autonomic and central nervous system functioning, the current findings suggest that the coupling of these systems may also deserve attention.

Links between the brain and body during sleep: implications for memory processing

Sleep is intimately related to memory processes. The established view is that the transformation of experiences into long-term memories is linked to sleep-related CNS function. However, there is increasing evidence that the autonomic nervous system (ANS), long recognized to modulate cognition during waking, can impact memory processing during sleep. Here, we review human research that examines the role of autonomic activity and sleep in memory formation. We argue that autonomic activity during sleep may set the stage for the CNS dynamics associated with sleep and memory stability and integration. Further, we consider how the link between ANS activity and polysomnographic markers of sleep may help elucidate both healthy and pathological cognitive aging in humans.

Co-ordination of brain and heart oscillations during non-rapid eye movement sleep

Oscillatory activities of the brain and heart show a strong variation across wakefulness and sleep. Separate lines of research indicate that non‐rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep is characterised by electroencephalographic slow oscillations (SO), sleep spindles, and phase–amplitude coupling of these oscillations (SO–spindle coupling), as well as an increase in high‐frequency heart rate variability (HF‐HRV), reflecting enhanced parasympathetic activity. The present study aimed to investigate further the potential coordination between brain and heart oscillations during NREM sleep. Data were derived from one sleep laboratory night with polysomnographic monitoring in 45 healthy participants (22 male, 23 female; mean age 37 years). The associations between the strength (modulation index [MI]) and phase direction of SO–spindle coupling (circular measure) and HF‐HRV during NREM sleep were investigated using linear modelling. First, a significant SO–spindle coupling (MI) was observed for all participants during NREM sleep, with spindle peaks preferentially occurring during the SO upstate (phase direction). Second, linear model analyses of NREM sleep showed a significant relationship between the MI and HF‐HRV (F = 20.1, r² = 0.30, p < 0.001) and a tentative circular‐linear correlation between phase direction and HF‐HRV (F = 3.07, r² = 0.12, p = 0.056). We demonstrated a co‐ordination between SO–spindle phase–amplitude coupling and HF‐HRV during NREM sleep, presumably related to parallel central nervous and peripheral vegetative arousal systems regulation. Further investigating the fine‐graded co‐ordination of brain and heart oscillations might improve our understanding of the links between sleep and cardiovascular health.

Autonomic/central coupling benefits working memory in healthy young adults

Working memory (WM) is an executive function that can improve with training. However, the precise mechanism for this improvement is not known. Studies have shown greater WM gains after a period of sleep than a similar period of wake, and correlations between WM improvement and slow wave activity (SWA; 0.5-1 Hz) during slow wave sleep (SWS). A different body of literature has suggested an important role for autonomic activity during wake for WM. A recent study from our group reported that the temporal coupling of Autonomic/CentralEvents (ACEs) during sleep was associated with memory consolidation. We found that heart rate bursts (HR bursts) during non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep are accompanied by increases in SWA and sigma (12-15 Hz) power, as well as increases in the high-frequency (HF) component of the RR interval, reflecting vagal rebound. In addition, ACEs predict long-term, episodic memory improvement. Building on these previous results, we examined whether ACEs also contribute to gains in WM. We tested 104 young adults in an operation span task (OSPAN) in the morning and evening, with either a nap (n = 53; with electroencephalography (EEG) and electrocardiography (ECG)) or wake (n = 51) between testing sessions. We identified HR bursts in the ECG and replicated the increases in SWA and sigma prior to peak of the HR burst, as well as vagal rebound after the peak. Furthermore, we showed sleep-dependent WM improvement, which was predicted by ACE activity. Using regression analyses, we discovered that significantly more variance in WM improvement could be explained with ACE variables than with overall sleep activity not time-locked with ECG. These results provide the first evidence that coordinated autonomic and central events play a significant role in sleep-related WM improvement and implicate the potential of autonomic interventions during sleep for cognitive enhancement.