Compartmental Innervation of the Superior Oblique Muscle in Mammals

Functional anatomy of the orbit in strabismus surgery: Connective tissues, pulleys, and the modern surgical implications of the "arc of contact" paradigm

Oculomotricity is a multidimensional domain characterised by a delicate interplay of anatomical structures and physiological processes. This manuscript meticulously dissects the nuances of this interplay, bringing to the fore the integral role of the extraocular muscles (EOMs) and their intricate relationship with the myriad orbital connective tissues as it harmoniously orchestrates binocular movements, ensuring synchronised and fluid visual tracking. Historically, the peripheral oculomotor apparatus was conceptualised as a rudimentary system predominantly driven by neural directives. While widely accepted, this perspective offered a limited view of the complexities inherent in ocular movement mechanics. The twentieth century heralded a paradigm shift in this understanding. With advances in anatomical research and imaging techniques, a much clearer picture of the gross anatomy of the EOMs emerged. This clarity challenged traditional viewpoints, suggesting that the inherent biomechanical properties of the EOMs, coupled with their associated tissue pulleys, play a pivotal role in dictating eye movement dynamics. Central to this revised understanding is the "arc of contact" paradigm. This concept delves deep into the mechanics of eye rotation, elucidating the significance of the point of contact between the EOMs and the eyeball. The arc of contact is not just a static anatomical feature; its length and orientation play a crucial role in determining the effective torque generated by a muscle, thereby influencing the amplitude and direction of eye rotation. The dynamic nature of this arc, influenced by the position and tension of the muscle pulleys, offers a more comprehensive model for understanding ocular kinematics. Previously overlooked in traditional models, muscle pulleys have now emerged as central players in the biomechanics of eye movement. These anatomical structures, formed by dense connective tissues, guide the paths of the EOMs, ensuring that their pulling angles remain optimal across a range of gaze directions. The non-linear paths resulting from these pulleys provide a more dynamic and intricate understanding of eye movement, challenging two-dimensional, linear models of orbital anatomy. The implications of these revelations extend beyond mere theoretical knowledge. The insights garnered from this research promise transformative potential in the realm of strabismus surgery. Recognising the pivotal role of muscle pulleys and the "arc of contact" paradigm allows for more precise surgical interventions, ensuring better post-operative outcomes and minimising the risk of complications. Surgical procedures that previously relied on basic mechanical principles now stand to benefit from a more nuanced understanding of the underlying anatomical and physiological dynamics. In conclusion, this manuscript serves as a testament to the ever-evolving nature of scientific knowledge. Challenging established norms and introducing fresh perspectives pave the way for more effective and informed clinical interventions in strabismus surgery.

Investigation of Selective Innervation of Extraocular Muscle Compartments

Purpose

Recent magnetic resonance imaging studies have suggested that extraocular muscles (EOM) are further divided into transverse compartments that behave differentially and often unexpectedly during eye movements. Selective innervation of EOM compartments may explain the observation that certain horizontal recti compartments contribute to specific vertical eye movements and that some cyclovertical EOM compartments do not contribute to vertical vergence. We investigated the discharge characteristics of extraocular motoneurons during these eye movement tasks where EOM compartments behaved differentially for evidence of selective innervation.

Methods

We recorded from all six extraocular motoneuron populations in the abducens, oculomotor, and trochlear nuclei as two non-human primates performed vertical vergence and vertical smooth-pursuit. The relationship between motoneuron firing rate, horizontal and vertical eye parameters of the innervated eye during each task was determined using multiple linear regression.

Results

All 26 medial rectus motoneurons recorded showed no significant modulation during vertical smooth-pursuit and vertical vergence. Twenty-eight of 30 abducens motoneurons showed no significant modulation during vertical vergence, and all 30 cells did not modulate during vertical smooth-pursuit. For the cyclovertical motoneurons, 147 of the 149 cells (44/46 inferior rectus, 27/27 superior oblique, 41/41 superior rectus and 35/35 inferior oblique) modulated significantly during vertical vergence.

Conclusions

Extraocular motoneuron activity during vertical vergence and vertical smooth-pursuit does not support the theory that EOM compartments are selectively innervated. The observed differential behavior of EOM compartments is likely not driven by oculomotor control and could be due to passive change in EOM cross-sectional area.

Can Binocular Alignment Distinguish Hypertropia in Sagging Eye Syndrome From Superior Oblique Palsy?

Purpose

Although the three-step test (3ST) is typically used to diagnose superior oblique palsy (SOP), sagging eye syndrome (SES) has clinical similarities. We sought to determine if alignment measurements can distinguish unilateral SOP from hypertropia in SES.

Methods

We studied hypertropic subjects who underwent surface-coil magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrating either SO cross-section reduction indicative of congenital or acquired palsy (SOP group) or lateral rectus muscle sag (SES group). Alignment was measured by Hess screen and prism-cover testing. Multiple supervised machine learning methods were employed to evaluate diagnostic accuracy. Rectus pulley coordinates were determined in SES cases fulfilling the 3ST.

Results

Twenty-three subjects had unilateral SOP manifested by SO atrophy. Eighteen others had normal SO size but MRI findings of SES. Maximum cross-section of the palsied SO was much smaller than contralaterally and in SES (P < 2 × 10-5). Inferior oblique cross-sections were similar in SOP and SES. In both SOP and SES, hypertropia increased in contralateral and decreased in ipsilateral gaze and was greater in ipsilateral than contralateral head tilt. In SES, nine subjects (50%) fulfilled the 3ST and had greater infraplacement of the lateral than medial rectus pulleys in the hypotropic orbit. Supervised machine learning of alignment data distinguished the diagnoses with areas under the receiver operating curves up to 0.93, representing excellent yet imperfect differential diagnosis.

Conclusions

Because the 3ST is often positive in SES, clinical alignment patterns may confound SES with unilateral SOP, particularly acquired SOP. Machine learning substantially but imperfectly improves classification accuracy.

Surgical Outcomes of Nonadjustable Modified Harada-Ito Surgery

Purpose

This study aimed to investigate the surgical outcomes of nonadjustable Harada-Ito surgery under general anesthesia.

Methods

Twenty-two patients who underwent nonadjustable modified Harada-Ito surgery under general anesthesia were reviewed retrospectively. Among them, 21 out of the 22 patients who were followed up for 6 months after surgery were included in this study. Subjective cyclotorsion (double Maddox rod test) and objective cyclotorsions (fundus photography) were measured. Success of the surgery was defined as follows: success (the patients do not acknowledge diplopia at any direction), partial (the patients feel diplopia at a specific direction, but they do not feel discomfort in routine life), and fail (the patients feel diplopia in primary gaze, hence requiring a thorough investigation).

Results

The mean age of the patients (18 male and 3 female) was 56.5 years (range, 40–77 years). Based on the alternate prism cover test, the patients had 4.2 ± 3.0 prism diopters of vertical deviation. The corrected amounts of cyclotorsion based on the double Maddox rod test and fundus photography were 14.8° ± 7.5° and 9.8° ± 7.9°, respectively, and were significantly different between the two methods (p = 0.006). After the surgery, 20 out of the 21 patients (95.2%) completely recovered from diplopia in the primary gaze. However, among the 20 patients, seven complained of diplopia in the secondary gaze (down gaze, four patients; head tilt gaze, three patients). The success group had a smaller preoperative subjective excyclotorsion than the partial and fail groups (12.6° ± 2.5° and 21.0° ± 8.9°, respectively; p = 0.046).

Conclusions

Nonadjustable modified Harada-Ito surgery under general anesthesia has favorable success rate, and preoperative subjective excyclotorsion can be a prognostic factor in patients with bilateral superior oblique palsy.

The oblique extraocular muscles in cetaceans: Overall architecture and accessory insertions

The oblique extraocular muscles (EOMs) were dissected in 19 cetacean species and 10 non-cetacean mammalian species. Both superior oblique (SO) and inferior oblique (IO) muscles in cetaceans are well developed in comparison to out-groups and have unique anatomical features likely related to cetacean orbital configurations, swimming mechanics, and visual behaviors. Cetacean oblique muscles originate at skeletal locations typical for mammals: SO, from a common tendinous cone surrounding the optic nerve and from the medially adjacent bone surface at the orbital apex; IO, from the maxilla adjacent to lacrimal and frontal bones. However, because of the unusual orbital geometry in cetaceans, the paths and relations of SO and IO running toward their insertions onto the temporal ocular sclera are more elaborate than in humans and most other mammals. The proximal part of the SO extends from its origin at the apex along the dorsomedial aspect of the orbital contents to a strong fascial connection proximal to the preorbital process of the frontal bone, likely the cetacean homolog of the typical mammalian trochlea. However, the SO does not turn at this connection but continues onward, still a fleshy cylinder, until turning sharply as it passes through the external circular muscle (ECM) and parts of the palpebral belly of the superior rectus muscle. Upon departing this "functional trochlea" the SO forms a primary scleral insertion and multiple accessory insertions (AIs) onto adjacent EOM tendons and fascial structures. The primary SO scleral insertions are broad and muscular in most cetacean species examined, while in the mysticete minke whale (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) and fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus) the muscular SO bellies transition into broad fibrous tendons of insertion. The IO in cetaceans originates from an elongated fleshy attachment oriented laterally on the maxilla and continues laterally as a tubular belly before turning caudally at a sharp bend where it is constrained by the ECM and parts of the inferior rectus which form a functional trochlea as with the SO. The IO continues to a fleshy primary insertion on the temporal sclera but, as with SO, also has multiple AIs onto adjacent rectus tendons and connective tissue. The multiple IO insertions were particularly well developed in pygmy sperm whale (Kogia breviceps), minke whale and fin whale. AIs of both SO and IO muscles onto multiple structures as seen in cetaceans have been described in humans and domesticated mammals. The AIs of oblique EOMs seen in all these groups, as well as the unique "functional trochleae" of cetacean SO and IO seem likely to function in constraining the lines of action at the primary scleral insertions of the oblique muscles. The gimble-like sling formed by SO and IO in cetaceans suggest that the "primary" actions of the cetacean oblique EOMs are not only to produce ocular counter-rotations during up-down pitch movements of the head during swimming but also to rotate the plane containing the functional origins of the rectus muscles during other gaze changes.

Functional Anatomy of Muscle Mechanisms: Compensating Vertical Heterophoria

PURPOSE

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of extraocular muscle function was used to evaluate the role of newly recognized mechanisms underlying compensation of large heterophoria by vertical fusional vergence (VFV).

DESIGN

Prospective case series.

METHODS

At one academic center, 8 adults with large hyperphoria and supernormal VFV underwent MRI during monocular and binocular fixation of a centered, near target. Contractility of the rectus and superior oblique (SO) extraocular muscles in hypertropic and hypotropic eyes was determined from changes in posterior partial volume (PPV).

RESULTS

Five of 8 patients could sustain binocular fusion in the scanner. In those patients, VFV corrected approximately 5-degree misalignment, approximately 5-fold greater than normal VFV. Vertical strabismus was compensated mainly by significant contractility of the lateral more than the medial compartment of the inferior rectus (IR) in both eyes (P < .005). The superior rectus (SR) and inferior oblique muscles had no significant contractile contribution, although the hypotropic SO relaxed significantly. The IR lateral compartment and SR medial compartment significantly co-relaxed when binocular fusion was attained from monocular target fixation (P < .01).

CONCLUSIONS

Although VFV protects patients from small muscle imbalances over the lifespan, even enhanced VFV may be inadequate to avert diplopia. Compensation of hyperphoria by VFV is accomplished mainly by IR muscle relaxation in the hypotropic eye, principally in its selectively innervated lateral compartment, whereas the SO contributes little. Fusion involves compartmentally selective co-relaxation in hypotropic eye vertical rectus muscles. Taken together, these overall findings suggest a physiologic basis to prefer therapeutic surgical weakening of the medial IR in the hypotropic eye.

Modified Anterior Superior Oblique Tuck: A Case Series

PURPOSE

Selection of the ideal procedure to correct symptomatic excyclotropia depends on several factors including the degree of torsion and associated vertical, horizontal and pattern deviation. Selective tuck of the anterior temporal torsional fibers of the superior oblique (SO) tendon is an alternative procedure to the classical Harada-Ito. The purpose of this study is to report its stability and results.

METHODS

Retrospective review of all consecutive patients with symptomatic excyclotorsion of at least 5º (degrees) treated by selectively splitting and tucking the anterior temporal fibers of the SO tendon. Torsion in primary position was measured using the double Maddox Rods. Patients with additional symptomatic vertical or horizontal diplopia underwent simultaneous surgery on other extraocular muscles.

RESULTS

Five patients were studied. Mean age was 60 ± 8 years (47-67). Mean postoperative follow-up was 10 ± 8 months (3-21). The mean preoperative torsion of 11º±4º (7º-15º) significantly decreased to 3º±2º (p = .03) at the first postoperative visit (16 ± 9 days) and 3 ± 2º during the last visit (P = .03). The procedure corrected 1.4º±0.9º per mm of tuck. Postoperatively no patient complained of torsion. No undesirable vertical or horizontal deviations were noted.

CONCLUSION

This technique is a simple alternative to manage symptomatic excyclotorsion, with significant and stable relief of moderate amounts of torsion and without inducing unexpected vertical or horizontal deviation.

Intramuscular Nerves of the Inferior Rectus Muscle: Distribution and Characteristics

PURPOSE

Knowledge of the distribution of intramuscular nerves of the extraocular muscles is crucial for understanding their function. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the intramuscular distribution of the oculomotor nerve within the inferior rectus muscle (IRM) using Sihler's staining.

METHOD

Ninety-three IRM from 50 formalin-embalmed cadavers were investigated. The IRM including its branches of the oculomotor nerve was finely dissected from its origin to the point where it inserted into the sclera. The intramuscular nerve course was investigated after performing Sihler's whole-mount nerve staining technique that stains the nerves while rendering other soft tissues either translucent or transparent.

RESULTS

The oculomotor nerve enters the IRM around the distal one-fourth of the muscle and then divides into multiple smaller branches. The intramuscular nerve course finishes around the distal three-fifth of the IRM in gross observations. The types of branching patterns of the IRM could be divided into two subcategories based on whether or not topographic segregation was present: (1) no significant compartmental segregation (55.9% of cases) and (2) a several-zone pattern with possible segregation (44.1% of cases). Possible compartmentalization was less clear for the IRM, which contained overlapping mixed branches between different trunks.

CONCLUSION

Sihler's staining is a useful technique for visualizing the gross nerve distribution of the IRM. The new information about the nerve distribution and morphological features provided by this study will improve the understanding of the biomechanics of the IRM, and could be useful for strabismus surgery.

Compartmental Strabismus

Recent reports confirm innervational compartments of select rectus extraocular muscles as well as the superior oblique.¹ Histopathological and orbital imaging studies demonstrate well defined compartmental innervation of the horizontal rectus muscles with less differentiation in the vertical rectus muscles. Acquired vertical misalignment not associated with cyclovertical muscle dysfunction has been associated with horizontal rectus muscle compartment dysfunction. Pattern and other forms of strabismus have been associated with segmental or compartmental abnormal innervation of the extraocular muscles. Taking advantage of segmental function and innervation, selective weakening and strengthening procedures have been used to treat patients with incomitant near/distance disparities, incomitant vertical and torsional strabismus, and patients with A- and V-pattern strabismus.

Intramuscular Nerve Distribution of the Inferior Oblique Muscle

Purpose: The intramuscular nerve distribution in the extraocular muscles is important for understanding their function. This study aimed to determine the intramuscular nerve distribution of the oculomotor nerve within the inferior oblique muscle (IO) using Sihler's staining.Method: Seventy-two IOs from 50 formalin-embalmed cadavers were investigated. The IO including its branch of the oculomotor nerve was finely dissected from its origin to its insertion point into the sclera. The total length of the muscle and its width were measured. The intramuscular nerve course was investigated after performing Sihler's staining, which is a whole-mount nerve-staining technique that stains the nerves while rendering other soft tissues either translucent or transparent.Results: The total length of the muscle and muscle width were 30.0 ± 2.8 mm (mean±standard deviation), 8.8 ± 1.2 mm, respectively. The oculomotor nerve enters the IO around the middle of the muscle and then divides into multiple smaller branches without distinct subdivisions. The intramuscular nerve distribution within the IO has a root-like arborization and supplies the entire width of the muscle. The Sihler's stained intramuscular nerve course (covering a length of 7.6 ± 1.2 mm) finishes around the distal one-third of the IO in gross observations.Conclusion: Sihler's staining is a useful technique for visualizing the gross nerve distribution of the IO. This new information about the nerve distribution and morphological features will improve the understanding of the biomechanics of the IO.

Detailed anatomy of the trochlear nerve in the superior oblique muscle

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to elucidate the detailed anatomy of the trochlear nerve in the superior oblique muscle (SOM) and the intramuscular innervation pattern using Sihler staining.

METHODS

SOMs were dissected from their origin to the insertion in 28 eyes of 14 cadavers. The following distances were determined: from the SOM insertion to the trochlear, from the trochlear to the entry site of the anterior branch or posterior branch, and the widths of the main trunk and anterior and posterior branches. Sihler staining was then performed.

RESULTS

The trochlear nerve traveled straight ahead medially and divided. Eighteen of 28 (64.3%) orbits showed two anterior and posterior branches, six (21.4%) showed three branches, and four (14.3%) showed no branching. The most distally located intramuscular nerve ending was observed at 62.4 ± 2.4% of the length of each muscle (35.8 mm from insertion when considering that the length of the SOM was 57.4 mm) and at 29.9 ± 3.2% of the length of each muscle (17.2 mm from the trochlear). Additionally, the length of the intramuscular arborization part was 9.4 ± 1.1% of the length of the SOM (5.4 mm when considering that the length of the SOM was 57.4 mm). Nonoverlap between two intramuscular arborizations of the nerve was detected in 20 of 28 cases (71.4%). Eight cases (28.6%) showed a definite overlap of two zones.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provided a good understanding of the anatomy of the trochlear nerve in the SOM.

Vertical vergence in nonhuman primates depends on horizontal gaze position

The goal of this study was to compare vertical fusion capability at different orbital eye positions in normal nonhuman primates and attempt to use this information to isolate the extraocular muscles (EOMs) that mediate vertical vergence. Scleral search coils were used to record movements of both eyes as two normal nonhuman primates (M1, M2) performed a vertical vergence task at different horizontal eye positions. In a control experiment, M1 was also tested at different angles of horizontal vergence. To elicit vertical vergence, a 50° x 50° stimulus comprising a central fixation cross and random dots elsewhere was presented separately to each eye under dichoptic viewing conditions. Vertical disparity was introduced by slowly displacing the stimulus for one eye vertically. Vertical fusion amplitude (maximum disparity that the monkey was able to fuse) and vertical vergence (maximum difference in vertical position of the two eyes) were measured. Vertical fusion capability differed at different orbital eye positions. Monkey M1 had significantly smaller vertical fusion capabilities when the right eye (RE) was abducted than left eye (LE) while M2 had significantly smaller vertical fusion capabilities when the RE was adducted and LE abducted. M1 also showed greater vertical fusion capability for near gaze. M1 data suggested that the vertical recti mediated vertical vergence in the RE and the oblique muscles in the LE while M2 data suggested that the oblique muscles mediated vertical vergence in the RE and the vertical recti in the LE. The variable results within the same animal and across animals suggest that EOM involvement during vertical fusional vergence is idiosyncratic and likely a weighted combination of multiple cyclovertical muscles.

Translation and eccentric rotation in ocular motor modeling

Current models of ocular mechanics do not fully account for potentially large globe translations associated with eye rotation. Such combined motion can be measured using magnetic resonance imaging in axial planes. We imaged orbits of normal volunteers fixating horizontally eccentric targets. These data indicate that the human eye acts as if it rotates eccentrically about a varying point typically anterior to the geometric globe center, but significantly lateral in abduction and medial in adduction. Assumed eccentricity of the ocular rotational center would vary the torque lever arms for the horizontal rectus muscles, with an appreciably smaller relative lever arm for the medial rectus muscle in adduction than would be the case for oculocentric rotation. Such variation in ocular rotational center might alter muscle torque without commensurate change in muscle tension, as appears to happen in convergence.

Functional anatomy of extraocular muscles during human vergence compensation of horizontal heterophoria

We employed magnetic resonance imaging to quantify human extraocular muscle (EOM) contractility during intermittent convergent and divergent strabismus with each eye viewing monocularly at 20 cm compared with centered target fusion. Contractility, indicated by posterior partial volume change, was analyzed in transverse rectus and in medial and lateral superior oblique (SO) muscle compartments. In five subjects with intermittent esotropia, abduction of the deviated eye to monocular target fixation was associated with significant whole lateral rectus (LR) contraction, but with medial rectus (MR) relaxation that was significantly greater in the superior than inferior compartment. Esotropic eye abduction to binocular fusion was associated with similar relaxation in the two MR compartments, but with greater contraction in the LR's superior than inferior compartment. The whole diverging eye SO muscle relaxed. In three subjects with intermittent exotropia, converging eye fusional adduction was associated with significant whole LR relaxation and with MR contraction attributable to significantly greater contraction in the superior than inferior compartment. In adduction of the exotropic eye to monocular target fixation but not fusional adduction, the whole SO exhibited significant relaxation. Rectus pulley positions were not significantly altered by fusion of either form of intermittent strabismus. Globe rotational axis was eccentric in intermittent strabismus, rolling the eye so that rectus EOM lever arms facilitated vergence. These results confirm, and extend to fusion of intermittent horizontal strabismus, differential compartmental function in horizontal rectus EOMs and suggest a novel role for the SO in compensation of both intermittent esotropia and exotropia. NEW & NOTEWORTHY Disjunctive eye movements normally permit binocular fixation in near visual space but also compensate for mechanical imbalances in binocular alignment developing over the life span. Magnetic resonance imaging of the extraocular muscles demonstrates important differential function in muscle compartments during compensation of large-angle intermittent convergent and divergent strabismus in humans. Eye translation during rotation also enhances vergence compensation of intermittent strabismus.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Globe-Tendon Interface for Extraocular Muscles: Is There an "Arc of Contact"?

PURPOSE

To determine if the "arc of contact" is an accurate approximation of the globe-tendon interface for the biomechanical modeling of extraocular muscle (EOM) force transfer onto the globe.

METHODS

At a single academic institution, 18 normal and 14 strabismic subjects were prospectively recruited for surface-coil enhanced magnetic resonance imaging at 312- or 390-μm resolution in axial planes for horizontal EOMs (23 subjects, 26 orbits) and sagittal planes for vertical EOMs (13 subjects, 22 orbits) during large ipsiversive ductions. The measured angle at insertion and the predicted angle assuming an "arc of contact" were compared using paired t tests.

RESULTS

For normal EOMs, the measured angle at insertion was significantly greater than predicted assuming an "arc of contact" for the medial rectus (MR) (5.0 ± 4.8 degrees vs 0.0 ± 0.0 degrees, P = .03), lateral rectus (LR) (4.9 ± 3.0 degrees vs 0.0 ± 0.0 degrees, P = .02), inferior rectus (7.4 ± 4.8 degrees vs 1.2 ± 2.6 degrees, P = .00003), and superior rectus (0.6 ± 1.1 degrees vs 0.0 ± 0.0 degrees, P = .04). In strabismic subjects, the measured angle was significantly greater for the MR in abducens palsy (9.9 ± 4.3 degrees vs 0.5 ± 0.7 degrees, P = .0007) and after MR resection (9.0 ± 6.9 degrees vs 1.2 ± 2.4 degrees, P = .02), but not after LR recession (2.9 vs 0.0 degrees). Single subjects had comparable angles after MR recession, but markedly different angles after MR and LR posterior fixation.

CONCLUSIONS

Contrary to the "arc of contact" biomechanical model, normal and postsurgical EOMs are significantly non-tangent to the globe at their scleral insertions. The "arc of contact" should be replaced in biomechanical modeling by the experimentally measured angles at tendon insertions. NOTE: Publication of this article is sponsored by the American Ophthalmological Society.

The role of imaging in strabismus

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To review the most recent literature regarding the clinical experience of imaging modalities in strabismus.

RECENT FINDINGS

MRI of extraocular muscles (EOMs) has elucidated the roles of variation in compartmental contraction of EOMs and further evidence of EOM pulley heterotopy in various strabismus patterns, which may contribute to the clinical and surgical management of patients as this mode of imaging becomes more readily available. Ultrasound biomicroscopy (UBM) and anterior-segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) may play a role in determining the location of EOMs which could also aid in devising a preoperative surgical plan, especially in those who have had prior strabismus surgery.

SUMMARY

Although MRI, UBM, and AS-OCT show promise in the formulation of a treatment plan in complex strabismus, more research regarding the role and limitations of these imaging modalities is required before they become the mainstay of strabismus evaluation.

Extraocular Muscle Compartments in Superior Oblique Palsy

Purpose

To investigate changes in volumes of extraocular muscle (EOM) compartments in unilateral superior oblique (SO) palsy using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

Methods

High-resolution, surface-coil MRI was obtained in 19 patients with unilateral SO palsy and 19 age-matched orthotropic control subjects. Rectus EOMs and the SO were divided into two anatomic compartments for volume analysis in patients with unilateral SO palsy, allowing comparison of total compartmental volumes versus controls. Medial and lateral compartmental volumes of the SO muscle were compared in patients with isotropic (round shape) versus anisotropic (elongated shape) SO atrophy.

Results

The medial and lateral compartments of the ipsilesional SO muscles were equally atrophic in isotropic SO palsy, whereas the lateral compartment was significantly smaller than the medial in anisotropic SO palsy (P = 0.01). In contrast to the SO, there were no differential compartmental volume changes in rectus EOMs; however, there was significant total muscle hypertrophy in the ipsilesional inferior rectus (IR) and lateral rectus (LR) muscles and contralesional superior rectus (SR) muscles. Medial rectus (MR) volume was normal both ipsi- and contralesionally.

Conclusions

A subset of patients with SO palsy exhibit selective atrophy of the lateral, predominantly vertically acting SO compartment. Superior oblique atrophy is associated with whole-muscle volume changes in the ipsilesional IR, ipsilesional LR, and contralesional SR; however, SO muscle atrophy is not associated with compartmentally selective volume changes in the rectus EOMs. Selective compartmental SO pathology may provide an anatomic mechanism that explains some of the variability in clinical presentations of SO palsy.

Isolated schwannoma involving extraocular muscles

BACKGROUND

Progressive strabismus initially considered idiopathic may be caused by isolated schwannomas of motor nerves to extraocular muscles, detectable only on careful imaging. This study reviewed clinical experience of a referral practice in identifying schwannomas on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

METHODS

We reviewed 647 cases imaged for strabismus to identify presumed cranial nerve schwannomas, identified by gadodiamide-enhanced, high-resolution surface coil orbital MRI and thin-section cranial MRI. Clinical features and management were correlated with MRI.

RESULTS

Schwannomas were identified as fusiform intraneural enlargements in 8 cases: 1 affecting the trochlear nerve; 2, the abducens nerve; and 5 the oculomotor nerve. Involved muscles were atrophic. Both abducens schwannomas, 1 superior oblique, and 1 oculomotor schwannoma were subarachnoid; 3 were intraorbital, and bilateral oculomotor lesions of 1 case extended from cavernous sinus to orbit. Associated strabismus progressed for 3-17 years. Abducens schwannoma caused esotropia; trochlear schwannoma caused hypertropia and cyclotropia. Intracranial oculomotor schwannoma caused mydriasis and exotropia. Intraorbital schwannoma caused exotropia with or without hypertropia. Since lesion diameters were 3-9 mm, 6 had been previously missed on routine MRI.

CONCLUSIONS

Progressive, acquired strabismus may be caused by isolated cranial nerve schwannomas, representing about 1% of strabismus cases in this study, involving the oculomotor more than abducens nerve. Because most schwannomas are small and deep in the orbit, findings could be readily missed by routine imaging, leading to a possible diagnosis of idiopathic strabismus. Schwannomas should be suspected when extraocular muscles are atrophic, but the causative lesions themselves are identifiable only using targeted, high resolution MRI.

Rectus Pulley Displacements without Abnormal Oblique Contractility Explain Strabismus in Superior Oblique Palsy

PURPOSE

Using high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), we investigated whether rectus pulleys are significantly displaced in superior oblique (SO) palsy and whether displacements account for strabismus patterns.

DESIGN

Prospective case-control study.

PARTICIPANTS

Twenty-four patients diagnosed with SO palsy based on atrophy of the SO muscle on MRI and 19 age-matched orthotropic control subjects.

METHODS

High-resolution, surface coil MRI scans were obtained in multiple, contiguous, quasicoronal planes during monocular central gaze fixation. Pulley locations in oculocentric coordinates in the following subgroups of patients with SO palsy were compared with normal results in subgroups of patients with SO palsy: unilateral versus bilateral, congenital versus acquired, and isotropic (round) versus anisotropic (elongated) SO atrophy. Expected effects of pulley displacements were modeled using Orbit 1.8 (Eidactics, San Francisco, CA) computational simulation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Rectus pulley positions and ocular torsion.

RESULTS

Rectus pulleys typically were displaced in SO palsy. In unilateral SO palsy, on average the medial rectus (MR) pulley was displaced 1.1 mm superiorly, the superior rectus (SR) pulley was displaced 0.8 mm temporally, and the inferior rectus (IR) pulley was displaced 0.6 mm superiorly and 0.9 mm nasally from normal. Displacements were similar in bilateral SO palsy, with the SR pulley additionally displaced 0.9 mm superiorly. However, the lateral rectus pulley was not displaced in either unilateral or bilateral SO palsy. The SR and MR pulleys were displaced in congenital SO palsy, whereas the IR and MR pulleys were displaced in acquired palsy. Pulley positions did not differ between isotropic and anisotropic palsy or between patients with cyclotropia of less than 7° versus cyclotropia of 7° or more. Simulations predicted that the observed pulley displacements alone could cause patterns of incomitant strabismus typical of SO palsy, without requiring any abnormality of SO or inferior oblique strength.

CONCLUSIONS

Rectus pulley displacements alone, without abnormal oblique muscle contractility, can create the clinical patterns of incomitant strabismus in SO palsy. This finding supports accumulating evidence that clinical binocular misalignment patterns are not reliable indicators of contractile function of the SO muscle. Ocular torsion does not correlate with and thus cannot account for pulley displacements in SO palsy.

Functional morphometry demonstrates extraocular muscle compartmental contraction during vertical gaze changes

Anatomical studies demonstrate selective compartmental innervation of most human extraocular muscles (EOMs), suggesting the potential for differential compartmental control. This was supported by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrating differential lateral rectus (LR) compartmental contraction during ocular counterrolling, differential medial rectus (MR) compartmental contraction during asymmetric convergence, and differential LR, inferior rectus (IR), and superior oblique (SO) compartmental contraction during vertical vergence. To ascertain possible differential compartmental EOM contraction during vertical ductions, surface coil MRI was performed over a range of target-controlled vertical gaze positions in 25 orbits of 13 normal volunteers. Cross-sectional areas and partial volumes of EOMs were analyzed in contiguous, quasi-coronal 2-mm image planes spanning origins to globe equator to determine morphometric features correlating best with contractility. Confirming and extending prior findings for horizontal EOMs during horizontal ductions, the percent change in posterior partial volume (PPV) of vertical EOMs from 8 to 14 mm posterior to the globe correlated best with vertical duction. EOMs were then divided into equal transverse compartments to evaluate the effect of vertical gaze on changes in PPV. Differential contractile changes were detected in the two compartments of the same EOM during infraduction for the IR medial vs. lateral (+4.4%, P = 0.03), LR inferior vs. superior (+4.0%, P = 0.0002), MR superior vs. inferior (-6.0%, P = 0.001), and SO lateral vs. medial (+9.7%, P = 0.007) compartments, with no differential contractile changes in the superior rectus. These findings suggest that differential compartmental activity occurs during normal vertical ductions. Thus all EOMs may contribute to cyclovertical actions.