Presbyopia and Glaucoma: Two Diseases, One Pathophysiology? The 2017 Friedenwald Lecture

Ultrasound biomicroscopy analysis of ciliary muscle dynamics and its relation to intra-ocular pressure after phacoemulsification in dogs

Introduction

This study investigates the relationship between ciliary muscle dynamics, thickness, and the regulation of intraocular pressure (IOP), focusing on the progression of cataracts and changes post-phacoemulsification. It explores how these factors impact canine ocular health, particularly in the context of cataract development and subsequent surgical intervention.

Materials and methods

Data was collected using Ultrasound Biomicroscopy (UBM) from dogs at the Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital of Chungbuk National University, Korea. The study involved 57 eyes from 35 dogs, categorized into five groups: 13 normal eyes, 14 with incipient cataracts, 12 with immature cataracts, 6 with mature cataracts, and 12 post-phacoemulsification. UBM measurements assessed various ciliary muscle parameters including ciliary body axial length (CBAXL), ciliary process-sclera angle (CPSA), longitudinal fibers of ciliary muscle thickness (Lf-CMT), and longitudinal and radial fibers of ciliary muscle thickness (LRf-CMT).

Results

Findings indicated a decrease in CBAXL and an increase in Lf-CMT as cataracts progressed in severity. Post-phacoemulsification, there was a notable increase in CBAXL and a decrease in CPSA, Lf-CMT, and LRf-CMT, compared to both cataractous and normal eyes. Regression analysis revealed a significant positive association between CBAXL and IOP, alongside a negative association between Lf-CMT and IOP. These findings suggest that variations in ciliary muscle dynamics and thickness, as influenced by cataract progression and phacoemulsification, have distinct impacts on intraocular pressure.

Discussion

The study proposes that phacoemulsification leads to ciliary muscle contraction, causing an inward and anterior movement of the ciliary muscle. This movement results in the narrowing of the ciliary cleft and constriction of the unconventional outflow pathway, potentially causing an increased risk of glaucoma post-surgery. Our research contributes to understanding the anatomical and physiological changes in the canine eye following cataract surgery and underscores the importance of monitoring IOP and ciliary muscle dynamics in these patients.

Symptomatic Presbyopia may Develop Earlier in Patients With Glaucoma-A Cross-Sectional Retrospective Cohort Study

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to explore risk factors for symptomatic presbyopia, defined as near add power ≥1.50 diopters, in patients with glaucoma.

Methods

Treated glaucoma (n = 56), untreated glaucoma (n = 21), and control individuals (n = 376), aged 40 to 55 years at first visit, were enrolled in the study, and near add power, retinal thickness, and visual field were examined. The association between near add power and ocular parameters and the odds ratios (ORs) for symptomatic presbyopia were investigated. Survival analysis for symptomatic presbyopia was conducted.

Results

Age, astigmatic power, mean deviation, and ganglion cell complex thickness were associated with near add power. The OR for symptomatic presbyopia was significant for age (OR = 1.51), astigmatism (OR = 1.01), mean deviation (OR = 0.72), ganglion cell complex thickness (OR = 0.98), treated and untreated glaucoma (OR = 2.09), and use of glaucoma eye drops (OR = 3.33). Survival analysis showed that the treated glaucoma group reached the near add power endpoint of ≥1.50 D (symptomatic presbyopia) significantly earlier than the other two groups, and there was no difference between the control and untreated glaucoma groups.

Conclusions

Glaucoma patients treated with eye drops may start near correction earlier.

Translational Relevance

Symptomatic presbyopia may develop earlier in patients with glaucoma, and our findings could further contribute to better management and understanding of presbyopia with glaucoma.

A Review of Lens Biomechanical Contributions to Presbyopia

Purpose: Presbyopia-the progressive loss of near focus with age-is primarily a result of changes in lens biomechanics. In particular, the shape of the ocular lens in the absence of zonular tension changes significantly throughout adulthood. Contributors to this change in shape are changes in lens biomechanical properties, continuous volumetric growth lens, and possibly remodeling of the lens capsule. Knowledge in this area is growing rapidly, so the purpose of this mini-review was to summarize and synthesize these gains.Methods: We review the recent literature in this field.Results: The mechanisms governing age-related changes in biomechanical properties remains unknown. We have recently shown that lens growth may be driven by zonular tension. The same mechanobiological mechanism driving lens growth may also lead to remodeling of the capsule, though this remains to be demonstrated.Conclusions: This mini-review focuses on identifying mechanisms which cause these age-related changes, suggesting future work which may elucidate these mechanisms, and briefly discusses ongoing efforts to develop a non-surgical approach for therapeutic management of presbyopia. We also propose a simple model linking lens growth and biomechanical properties.

The effect of atropine 0.01% eyedrops on relative peripheral refraction in myopic children

BACKGROUND

Relative peripheral refraction (RPR) is a significant factor that participates in myopic development. Here, we evaluated the effects of atropine 0.01% eyedrops, as an antimyopia drug, on RPR.

METHODS

Seventy-three children were enrolled from a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-0.01% atropine eyedrops cross-over trial. The study group had used the placebo for one year and then crossed over to atropine 0.01% eyedrops for half a year. The control group had used 0.01% atropine for one year and then crossed over to placebo eyedrops for half a year. Central and horizontal peripheral refractions (15° and 30° at the temporal and nasal retina) were measured under non-cycloplegia and cycloplegia.

RESULTS

No significant differences in age, gender, and central refraction were identified between the two groups (P > 0.05). Under non-cycloplegia, the control group showed significant relative hyperopia in the temporal 30° retina and the nasal retina (P = 0.031; P < 0.001; P < 0.001). In the study group, the relative hyperopia in the temporal 30° retina disappeared (P = 0.983). After cycloplegia, the control group had less myopia in central refractions and less hyperopia in temporal RPR (P < 0.001; P = 0.039; P < 0.001). The study group did not present significant changes in central refractions and temporal RPR (P = 0.122; P = 0.222; P = 0.475).

CONCLUSIONS

For myopic children, atropine 0.01% eyedrops can alleviate relative hyperopia in the temporal retina and the hyperopic shift before cycloplegia. The effect might participate in myopia control.

Glaucoma - 'A Stiff Eye in a Stiff Body'

Glaucoma is a progressive, age-related optic neuropathy, whereby the prevalence increases sharply over the age of 60 and is associated with increased systemic tissue stiffness. On a molecular basis, this is associated with increased deposition of collagen and loss of elastin structure, resulting in aberrant biomechanical compliance and reduced tissue elasticity. Increased tissue stiffness is a known driver of myofibroblast activation and persistence, especially in chronic cellular injuries via mechanotransduction pathways mediated by integrins and focal adhesion kinases. Evidence from histological and imaging studies plus force measurements of glaucomatous eyes show that several ocular tissues are stiffer than normal, healthy age-matched controls including the trabecular meshwork, Schlemm's canal, cornea, sclera and the lamina cribrosa. This is associated with increased extracellular matrix deposition and fibrosis. This review reports on the evidence to support the concept that glaucoma represents 'a stiff eye in a stiff body' and addresses potential mechanisms to attenuate this.

Aging Effects on Optic Nerve Neurodegeneration

Common risk factors for many ocular pathologies involve non-pathologic, age-related damage to the optic nerve. Understanding the mechanisms of age-related changes can facilitate targeted treatments for ocular pathologies that arise at any point in life. In this review, we examine these age-related, neurodegenerative changes in the optic nerve, contextualize these changes from the anatomic to the molecular level, and appreciate their relationship with ocular pathophysiology. From simple structural and mechanical changes at the optic nerve head (ONH), to epigenetic and biochemical alterations of tissue and the environment, multiple age-dependent mechanisms drive extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling, retinal ganglion cell (RGC) loss, and lowered regenerative ability of respective axons. In conjunction, aging decreases the ability of myelin to preserve maximal conductivity, even with "successfully" regenerated axons. Glial cells, however, regeneratively overcompensate and result in a microenvironment that promotes RGC axonal death. Better elucidating optic nerve neurodegeneration remains of interest, specifically investigating human ECM, RGCs, axons, oligodendrocytes, and astrocytes; clarifying the exact processes of aged ocular connective tissue alterations and their ultrastructural impacts; and developing novel technologies and pharmacotherapies that target known genetic, biochemical, matrisome, and neuroinflammatory markers. Management models should account for age-related changes when addressing glaucoma, diabetic retinopathy, and other blinding diseases.

Novel Discoveries of the Relationship Between the Vitreous Zonule and the Anterior Segment Characteristics in Eyes With Primary Angle-Closure Disease

Purpose

To investigate the presence of the vitreous zonule (VZ) in different subtypes of primary angle-closure disease (PACD) and to explore the relationship between VZ and anterior chamber angle characteristics.

Methods

Patients with clinical diagnoses of acute primary angle-closure (PAC)/PAC glaucoma (APAC[G]) or chronic PAC/PAC glaucoma (CPAC[G]) and healthy subjects were enrolled. A total of 300 eyes of 180 subjects were included. Anterior segment parameters and the presence of the VZ were assessed by ultrasound biomicroscopy. The presence of VZ was compared among different subtypes of PACD. Anterior segment parameters were compared between eyes in vitreous zonule group (VZG) and no vitreous zonule group (NVZG). Logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify factors associated with the presence of VZ.

Results

APAC(G) eyes had lower VZ presence compared to the fellow eyes of APAC(G) (P < 0.001). VZ was more likely to be seen in the eyes of healthy subjects and PAC suspect than in the eyes of PAC and PAC glaucoma (PACG) (P < 0.05). NVZG had shorter angle opening distance 500/750 (P < 0.001), smaller trabecular iris angle 500/750 (P < 0.001), smaller trabecular-iris space area 500/750 (P < 0.001), smaller trabecular-ciliary angle (P = 0.009), smaller iris area (P = 0.010), and greater lens vault (P = 0.004) compared to VZG. Greater lens vault (LV) was independently associated with absence of VZ (odds ratio = 0.253; 95% confidence interval, 0.109-0.586; P = 0.001).

Conclusions

VZ was less likely to be observed in PAC/PACG eyes. PACD eyes with less VZ had narrower angle, more anteriorly rotated ciliary body, and greater LV.

Accommodative movements of the choroid in the optic nerve head region of human eyes, and their relationship to the lens

The ciliary muscle (CM) powers the accommodative response, and during accommodation the CM pulls the choroid forward in the region of the ora serrata. Our goal was to elucidate the accommodative movements of the choroid in the optic nerve region in humans and to determine whether these movements are related to changes in the lens dimensions that occur with aging, in the unaccommodated and accommodated state. Both eyes of 12 human subjects (aged 18-51 yrs) were studied. Homatropine (1 drop/5%) was used to relax the ciliary muscle (unaccommodated or "resting" eye) and pilocarpine was used to induce the maximum accommodative response (2 drops/4%) (accommodated eye). Images of the fundus and choroid were collected in the region of the optic nerve (ON) via Spectralis OCT (infrared and EDI mode), and choroidal thickness was determined. Ultrasound biomicroscopy (UBM; 50 MHz, 35 MHz) images were collected in the region of the lens/capsule and ciliary body. OCT and UBM images were collected in the resting and accommodated state. The unaccommodated choroidal thickness declined significantly with age (p = 0.0073, r = 0.73) over the entire age range of the subjects studied (18-51 years old). The choroidal thickness was significantly negatively correlated with lens thickness in the accommodated (p = 0.01) and the unaccommodated states (p = 0.005); the thicker the lens the thinner the choroid. Choroid movements around the optic nerve during accommodation were statistically significant; during accommodation the choroid both thinned and moved centrifugally (outward/away from the optic nerve head). The accommodative choroid movements did not decline significantly with age and were not correlated with accommodative amplitude. Measurement of the choroidal thickness is possible with the Spectralis OCT instrument using EDI mode and can be used to determine the accommodative changes in choroidal thickness. The choroidal thickness decreased with age and during accommodation. It may be that age-related choroidal thinning is due to changes in the geometry of the accommodative apparatus to which it is attached (i.e., ciliary muscle/lens complex) such that when the lens is thicker, the choroid is thinner. Accommodative decrease in choroidal thickness and stretch of the retina/choroid may indicate stress/strain forces in the region of the optic nerve during accommodation and may have implications for glaucoma.

Intraocular accommodative movements in monkeys; relationship to presbyopia

Our goal was to quantify the age-related changes in the dynamic accommodative movements of the vitreous and aqueous humor in iridic, aniridic, phakic and aphakic primate eyes. Six bilaterally iridic and four bilaterally iridectomized rhesus monkeys, ranging in age from 6 to 25 years, received a stimulating electrode in the midbrain Edinger-Westphal nucleus to induce accommodation, measured by a Hartinger coincidence refractometer. One of the four iridectomized monkeys underwent unilateral extracapsular and another monkey underwent intracapsular lens extraction. Eyes were imaged utilizing specialized techniques and contrast agents to resolve intraocular structures. During accommodation the anterior hyaloid membrane and the posterior lens capsule bowed backward. Central vitreous fluid and structures/strands moved posteriorly toward the optic nerve region as peripheral vitreous, attached to the vitreous zonule, was pulled forward by ciliary muscle contraction. Triamcinolone particles injected intravitreally were also observed in the anterior chamber and moved from the anterior chamber toward the cleft of the anterior hyaloid membrane and then further posteriorly into the vitreous-filled cleft between the vitreous zonule and the ciliary body pars plana. These accommodative movements occurred in all eyes, and declined with age. There are statistically significant accommodative movements of various intravitreal structures. The posterior/anterior fluid flow between the anterior chamber and the vitreous compartments during accommodation/disaccommodation represents fluid displacement to allow/facilitate lens thickening. The posterior accommodative movement of central vitreous fluid may result from centripetal compression of the anterior tips of the cistern-like structure attached to the vitreous zonule, and posterior displacement of the central trunk of the cistern during ciliary muscle contraction and centripetal muscle movement. The findings may have implications for presbyopia.

The Relationship Between Age and the Morphology of the Crystalline Lens, Ciliary Muscle, Trabecular Meshwork, and Schlemm's Canal: An in vivo Swept-Source Optical Coherence Tomography Study

Purpose: To evaluate the effects of age on the morphologies of the crystalline lens, ciliary muscle (CM), Schlemm’s canal (SC), and trabecular meshwork (TM) using swept-source optical coherence tomography (SS-OCT).

Methods: Images of the crystalline lens and iridocorneal angle were obtained in healthy participants’ eyes using SS-OCT. Morphological parameters of the crystalline lens, CM, and TM/SC were measured, and the relationship between these parameters and age was evaluated.

Results: A total of 62 healthy participants were enrolled, with an age range of 7–79 years. With adjustments for the effects of axial length and sex, both the nasal and temporal SC cross-sectional areas (CSA) and the cross-sectional area of the CM (CMA), distance from the scleral spur to the inner apex of the ciliary muscle (IA-SS), and nasal SC volume were negatively correlated with age (P ≤ 0.041). Meanwhile, the lens thickness (LT) (P < 0.001) and lens vault (LV) (P < 0.001) were positively correlated with age, and the radius of the curvature of the anterior lens (ALR) was negatively correlated with age (P < 0.001).

Conclusion: Increasing age was associated with a thicker crystalline lens, a steeper anterior lens curvature, an anteriorly located and smaller CM, and a narrower SC.

Clinical Trial Registration:https://register.clinicaltrials.gov/prs/app/action/Select Protocol?sid=S000A3JZ&selectaction=Edit&uid=U00019K7&ts=4&cx=-c5xxp8, identifier [NCT04576884].

In vivo measurement of the attenuation coefficient of the sclera and ciliary muscle

We acquired 1325 nm OCT images of the sclera and ciliary muscle of human subjects. The attenuation coefficients of the sclera and ciliary muscle were determined from a curve fit of the average intensity profile of about 100 A-lines in a region of interest after correction for the effect of beam geometry, using a single scattering model. The average scleral attenuation coefficient was 4.13 ± 1.42 mm-1 with an age-related decrease that was near the threshold for statistical significance (p = 0.053). The average ciliary muscle attenuation coefficient was 1.72 ± 0.88 mm-1, but this value may be an underestimation due to contributions from multiple scattering. Overall, the results suggest that inter-individual variations in scleral attenuation contribute to variability in the quality of transscleral OCT images of the ciliary muscle and the outcome of transscleral laser therapies.

Ocular Accommodation, Intraocular Pressure, Development of Myopia and Glaucoma: Role of Ciliary Muscle, Choroid and Metabolism

Ocular accommodation is not just a mechanism for altering curvature of the crystalline lens of the eye, it also enables aqueous humor outflow through the trabecular meshwork, influencing intraocular pressure (IOP). Long term stress on the ciliary muscle from sustained near focusing may initiate myopic eye growth in children and primary open angle glaucoma in presbyopic adults. Multi-factorial studies of ocular accommodation that include measures of IOP, ciliary muscle morphology, anterior chamber depth and assessment of nutritional intake and metabolic markers may elucidate etiology and novel strategies for management of both myopia and chronic glaucoma. Anatomy of the ciliary fibers from anterior insertion in the fluid drainage pathway to their posterior consanguinity with the vascular choroid, alters ocular parameters such as micro-fluctuations of accommodation and pulsatile ocular blood flow that are driven by cardiac contractions conveyed by carotid arteries. Stretching of the choroid has consequences for thinning of the peripheral retina, sclera and lamina cribrosa with potential to induce retinal tears and optic nerve cupping. Early metabolic interventions may lead to prevention or reduced severity of myopia and glaucoma. Finally, it might improve quality of life of patients and decrease disability from visual impairment and blindness.