Evaluating laryngotracheal stenosis in a canine model with virtual bronchoscopy

The role of tracheal wall injury in the development of benign airway stenosis in rabbits

To investigate the role of tracheal wall injury in the development of benign airway stenosis in rabbits. Prospective study. We injured the tracheal walls of 28 New Zealand white rabbits using four different methods. Experimental group: Group A (n = 7, mild injury of tracheal mucosa by ordinary brush under bronchoscopy); Group B (n = 7, severe injury of tracheal mucosa by nylon brush under tracheotomy); Group C (n = 7, tracheal cartilage was injured by vascular clamp after tracheotomy); Group D (n = 7, the tracheal cartilage was injured with vascular forceps and the tracheal mucosa was injured with a nylon brush after tracheotomy). Bronchoscopy was performed on each experimental rabbit at 1, 2, 3 and 4 weeks after operation. High-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) and endobronchial optical coherence tomography (EB-OCT) were performed at 4 weeks, and the rabbits were sacrificed after the examination. Their gross and histological findings were comparatively determined whether the experimental rabbit stenosis was established. No airway stenosis was observed in group A. In group B, 28.57% of experimental rabbits developed tracheal stenosis (granulation tissue proliferation was observed in rabbits No. 2 and No. 6 at 1, 2 and 3 weeks after operation, and the tracheal scar contracture was observed in No.6 rabbit at 4 weeks after operation). Fourteen rabbits in group C and group D had tracheal stenosis caused by granulation tissue proliferation at 1, 2 and 3 weeks after operation. At the fourth week after operation, 71.43% of experimental rabbits had tracheal stenosis due to granulation tissue hyperplasia, 7.14% of experimental rabbits had tracheal stenosis due to scar contracture and granulation hyperplasia, and 21.43% of experimental rabbits had tracheal stenosis due to scar contracture. EB-OCT scan showed that the cartilage layer with low signal reflection band was discontinuous. The injury of cartilage is the key factor of benign airway stenosis. Acute injury of airway mucosa alone is unlikely to cause airway stenosis, but combined with cartilage injury may aggravate airway stenosis. EB-OCT can clearly identify the airway layers of rabbits, which is helpful to evaluate the damage of tracheal cartilage and mucosa. The diagnostic potential of this technique makes EB-OCT a promising approach for the study and monitoring of airway diseases.

A canine model of tracheal stenosis induced by cuffed endotracheal intubation

Postintubation tracheal stenosis is a complication of endotracheal intubation. The pathological mechanism and risk factors for endotracheal intubation-induced tracheal stenosis remain not fully understood. We aimed to establish an animal model and to investigate risk factors for postintubation tracheal stenosis. Beagles were intubated with 4 sized tubes (internal diameter 6.5 to 8.0 mm) and cuff pressures of 100 to 200 mmHg for 24 hr. The status of tracheal wall was evaluated by bronchoscopic and histological examinations. The model was successfully established by cuffed endotracheal intubation using an 8.0 mm tube and an intra-cuff pressure of 200 mmHg for 24 hr. When the intra-cuff pressures were kept constant, a larger sized tube would induce a larger tracheal wall pressure and more severe injury to the tracheal wall. The degree of tracheal stenosis ranged from 78% to 91% at 2 weeks postextubation. Histological examination demonstrated submucosal infiltration of inflammatory cells, hyperplasia of granulation tissue and collapse of tracheal cartilage. In summary, a novel animal model of tracheal stenosis was established by cuffed endotracheal intubation, whose histopathological feathers are similar to those of clinical cases of postintubation tracheal stenosis. Excessive cuff pressure and over-sized tube are the risk factors for postintubation tracheal stenosis.

Comparison of virtual bronchoscopy to fiber-optic bronchoscopy for assessment of inhalation injury severity

PURPOSE

Compare virtual bronchoscopy (VB) to fiberoptic bronchoscopy (FOB) for scoring smoke inhalation injury (SII).

METHODS

Swine underwent computerized tomography (CT) with VB and FOB before (0) and 24 and 48 h after SII. VB and FOB images were scored by 5 providers off line.

RESULTS

FOB and VB scores increased over time (p<0.001) with FOB scoring higher than VB at 0 (0.30±0.79 vs. 0.03±0.17), 24 h (4.21±1.68 vs. 2.47±1.50), and 48h (4.55±1.83 vs. 1.94±1.29). FOB and VB showed association with PaO2-to-FiO2 ratios (PFR) with areas under receiver operating characteristic curves (ROC): for PFR≤300, VB 0.830, FOB 0.863; for PFR≤200, VB 0.794, FOB 0.825; for PFR≤100, VB 0.747, FOB 0.777 (all p<0.001). FOB showed 80.3% specificity, 77% sensitivity, 88.8% negative-predictive value (NPV), and 62.3% positive-predictive value (PPV) for PFR≤300 and VB showed 67.2% specificity, 85.5% sensitivity, 91.3% NPV, and 53.4% PPV.

CONCLUSIONS

VB provided similar injury severity scores to FOB, correlated with PFR, and reliably detected airway narrowing. VB performed during admission CT may be a useful screening tool specifically to demonstrate airway narrowing induced by SII.

A model of canine tracheal stenosis induced by radiofrequency cauterization

OBJECTIVE

The current methods of management of tracheal stenosis have disadvantages and are controversial, therefore ideal experimental animal models for the further studies are required. The aim of this study was to establish a new model of canine tracheal stenosis by radiofrequency cauterization.

METHODS

The tracheal cartilage ring was injured by radiofrequency at the level of the sixth tracheal ring in 12 mongrel dogs. A fibrolaryngoscope was used to guide the procedure. The animals were observed after operation and examined after euthanasia. Endoscopic and histological examinations were undertaken to evaluate the progress of stenosis. The degree of stenosis was calculated using the formula: degree of stenosis=(initial lumen area-final lumen area)/initial lumen area × 100%.

RESULTS

Tracheal stenosis had developed in all dogs by the 21st day post operation. Costal retraction was observed in all dogs after the 18th day post operation. At the end of the study, gross and endoscopic examinations showed that stenosis had been induced to a satisfactory degree and without any complications. The median of the degree of stenosis was 92%, with a range of 84-94%. Histological examination showed that cartilage was damaged and that granulation tissue and collagen fibres had formed.

CONCLUSIONS

The model of canine tracheal stenosis induced by radiofrequency cauterization is a relatively simple, reliable, and reproducible animal model. This model may be useful in the development of new methods of treatment for tracheal stenosis.

Role of spiral computed tomography with 3-dimensional reconstruction in cases with laryngeal stenosis--a radioclinical correlation

PURPOSE

To study the efficacy of spiral computed tomography with 3-dimensional reconstruction (SCT-3DI) and endoscopy in cases with laryngeal stenosis with regard to site, type, grade, and length of stenosis and to determine the correlation among the findings of SCT-3DI, endoscopy, and surgery.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This prospective study on 30 cases of laryngotracheal stenosis (acquired = 28 cases, congenital = 2 cases) was conducted in the Department of Otorhinolaryngology and Head Neck Surgery, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India, from 2001 to 2003. All patients were evaluated by SCT-3DI and rigid endoscopy. Twenty-three patients underwent open surgical procedure, and 7 patients underwent endoscopic dilatation. Correlation was established among the findings of SCT-3DI, endoscopy, and surgery by Pearson correlation coefficient (r), paired t test, and chi(2) test.

RESULTS

Findings of SCT-3DI, endoscopy, and surgery were found to well correlate with each other. SCT-3DI was found to be less accurate in measuring the exact length of stenosis but could measure the length of stenosis in all cases, whereas by endoscopy, the measurements could be made accurately in 14 cases (46.6%). The endoscopy was more accurate in diagnosing the site and grade of stenosis (P < .01). SCT-3DI gave 18.6% false-positive result regarding involvement of glottis in stenosis. A significant difference was found between endoscopy and SCT-3DI for grade III and IV stenoses (P < .01), and SCT-3DI found to give false-positive result in 19.2% cases for grade IV stenosis. SCT-3DI was found to be a better diagnosing modality in differentiating the circumferential Gupta and Parida. SCT-3DI was found to give a false-positive result in 19.2% cases for grade IV stenosis. SCT-3DI was found to be better a diagnosing modality in differentiating the circumferential and eccentric stenosis (P < .01) and to detect the cricoid and thyroid cartilage fracture, double stenosis, and laryngocele. A false-positive rate of 33.3% was seen in diagnosing fracture of cricoid cartilage on radiology.

CONCLUSION

The findings of SCT-3DI, endoscopy, and surgery well correlated with each other. Findings of SCT-3DI and rigid endoscopy are complementary to each other for a better surgical planning and outcome.