Early newborn discharge: a tale of two hospitals

Factors associated with neonatal intensive care follow-up appointment compliance

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

Our goal was to identify factors that affect neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) follow-up appointment compliance. Compliant and noncompliant infants discharged from the NICU over 1 year and scheduled for follow-up (133) were compared retrospectively; a prospective telephone survey of noncompliant families was also undertaken.

RESULTS

Maternal drug use (odds ratio [OR] = 0.049, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.005-0.506), multiple gestation pregnancy (OR = 0.163, 95% CI = 0.050-0.533), male sex (OR = 0.308, 95% CI = 0.112-0.850), and greater distance from the hospital (OR = 0.987, 95% CI = 0.976-0.999) were independently associated with lower appointment compliance. A greater number of days on oxygen was associated with greater odds of compliance (OR = 1.057, 95% CI = 0.976-0.999). Shorter NICU stays (P = .047) and less chronic lung disease (P = .026) were significantly associated with noncompliance by bivariate analysis only. Distance from the hospital and travel expense were the most often self-cited reasons for appointment noncompliance.

CONCLUSION

Understanding factors associated with NICU follow-up noncompliance is a starting point for providing targeted intervention.

Evaluation of a community intervention for promotion of safe motherhood in Eritrea

INTRODUCTION

We evaluated a community-based intervention to promote safe motherhood, focusing on knowledge and behaviors that may reduce maternal mortality and birth complications. The intervention aimed to increase women's birth preparedness, knowledge of birth danger signs, use of antenatal care services, and birth at a health care facility.

METHODS

Volunteers from a remote rural community in Northern Eritrea were trained to lead participatory educational sessions on safe motherhood with women and men. The evaluation used a quasiexperimental design (nonequivalent group pretest-posttest) including cross-sectional surveys with postpartum women (pretest n = 466, posttest n = 378) in the intervention area and in a similar remote rural comparison area.

RESULTS

Women's knowledge of birth danger signs increased significantly in the intervention area but not in the comparison area. There was a significant increase in the proportion of women who had the recommended 4 or more antenatal care visits during pregnancy in the intervention area (from 18% to 80%, P < .001), although this proportion did not change significantly in the comparison area (from 53% to 47%, P = .194). There was a greater increase in birth in a health care facility in the intervention area.

DISCUSSION

Participatory sessions led by community volunteers can increase safe motherhood knowledge and encourage use of essential maternity services.

A 1999 quality improvement initiative-reassessment in 2004

We obtained a longitudinal overview of physician compliance with the American Academy of Pediatrics Policy RE9539 regarding early newborn discharge between 1999 and 2004. In previous studies we reported the results of a Quality Improvement/Feedback (QI/F) initiative at one community hospital (intervention) in 1999, during which time physician education occurred at a grand rounds and the hospital QI department reviewed all newborn charts for a 1-year period, notifying physicians of any deviations from the policy. We also assessed the very same physicians at another community hospital (control), which did not have this initiative and found significant changes in physician behavior only at the intervention hospital. In this study we reassessed the same physicians in the year 2004 and compared their performance with that in 2000, after the intervention was well established, once again at both the intervention and control hospitals. Physicians caring for newborns at the intervention hospital continued to demonstrate improvement in compliance with the Early Newborn Discharge Policy (p = 0.0036), whereas there was no significant change in physician performance over time at the control hospital (p = 0.6874). We conclude, similarly to the first study, that improvement in physician practice continued, but there was still no overall change in physician culture.

Does making newborn follow-up appointments from the hospital improve compliance?

OBJECTIVE

To test a system of arranging the first newborn follow-up appointments made from the hospital prior to discharge.

METHODS

Prospective randomized study of 328 term healthy newborns divided into control and intervention groups. As there were multiple practices, we checked for clustering in the two groups and then compared them for patient compliance with the first newborn appointment. We also compared the control and intervention groups for compliance with regard to insurance status.

RESULTS

There was difference between the control and intervention group in timeliness for the first appointment (control, 84.9%, intervention group, 94.2%, p=0.0062). There was also improvement in privately insured patients (control 89.1%, intervention 96.5%, p=0.0263), as well as in Medicaid+noninsured patients (control 64.7%, intervention 90.2%, p=0.0245).

DISCUSSION

We conclude that arranging for follow-up appointments from the hospital is a worthwhile inexpensive intervention that could significantly improve patient compliance with the first newborn visit.

Patient compliance with the first newborn visit appointment

OBJECTIVE

To analyze patient compliance regarding the first newborn visit after hospital discharge.

STUDY DESIGN

We selected at random 640 charts over a 1-year period from two community hospitals of healthy term newborns who were cared for by four practices in Kalamazoo, MI. We collected demographic data from the hospital chart and recorded the discharge order for time of posthospital follow-up. We then accessed the individual clinics' appointment logs to determine when the patient came for the first visit. Lateness was defined as appearance for appointment >24 hours after the time stated on the hospital discharge order. We studied patient lateness with respect to the clinic, maternal age, insurance status, and distance from the patient's home to the medical facility, using both univariate and multivariate analyses.

RESULTS

We demonstrated a significant difference in lateness of the first appointment between Medicaid and non-Medicaid patients in both the univariate (p<0.001) and multivariate (p=0.0003) analyses. We also demonstrated significant differences in the univariate analysis in patient lateness among the different practices (p<0.001) as well as lateness with regard to maternal age (p=0.0009). We did not attain significance in either analysis for patient lateness with regard to distance of home from the medical facility, or the hospital in which the baby was born.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated a need to improve upon newborn follow-up from the hospital and suggest strategies for other communities to analyze the process and improve upon patient and practice compliance with that first appointment.