New model of superior semicircular canal dehiscence with reversible diagnostic findings characteristic of patients with the disorder

Background

Third window syndrome is a vestibular-cochlear disorder in humans in which a third mobile window of the otic capsule creates changes to the flow of sound pressure energy through the perilymph/endolymph. The nature and location of this third mobile window can occur at many different sites (or multiple sites); however, the most common third mobile window is superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD). There are two essential objective diagnostic characteristics needed to validate a model of SSCD: the creation of a pseudoconductive hearing loss and cVEMP increased amplitude and decreased threshold.

Methods

Adult Mongolian gerbils (n = 36) received surgical fenestration of the superior semicircular canal of the left inner ear. ABR and c+VEMP testing were carried out prior to surgery and over acute (small 1 mm SSCD, 1-10 days) or prolonged (large 2 mm SSCD, 28 days) recovery. Because recovery of function occurred quickly, condenser brightfield stereomicroscopic examination of the dehiscence site was carried out for the small SSCD animals post-hoc and compared to both ABRs and c+VEMPs. Micro-CT analysis was also completed with representative samples of control, day 3 and 10 post-SSCD animals.

Results

The SSCD created a significant worsening of hearing thresholds of the left ear; especially in the lower frequency domain (1-4 kHz). Left (EXP)/right (CTL) ear comparisons via ABR show significant worsening thresholds at the same frequency representations, which is a proxy for the human pseudoconductive hearing loss seen in SSCD. For the c+VEMP measurements, increased amplitude of the sound-induced response (N1 2.5 ms and P1 3.2 ms) was observed in animals that received larger fenestrations. As the bone regrew, the c+VEMP and ABR responses returned toward preoperative values. For small SSCD animals, micro-CT data show that progressive osteoneogenesis results in resurfacing of the SSCD without bony obliteration.

Conclusion

The large (2 mm) SSCD used in our gerbil model results in similar electrophysiologic findings observed in patients with SSCD. The changes observed also reverse and return to baseline as the SSCD heals by bone resurfacing (with the lumen intact). Hence, this model does not require a second surgical procedure to plug the SSCD.

The Impact of Superior Canal Dehiscence on Power Absorbance, Otoacoustic Emissions, and Hearing in Fat Sand Rats

BACKGROUND

Superior Semicircular Canal Dehiscence (SSCD) may lead to vestibular and auditory impairments.

OBJECTIVE

To study the effects of power absorbance (PA), Distortion Product Otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE), and hearing thresholds in normal ears of fat sand rats, after a bullotomy, creation and patching.

METHODS

SSCD was performed unilaterally in eight normal hearing animals while the contra-lateral un-operated ear was used as a control. Measures included auditory brain stem responses thresholds for air and bone conduction stimuli, DPOAEs and PA at peak pressure.

RESULTS

The normal PA pattern of the animals grossly resembled that of human ears. A bullotomy generated specific, large and significant (p < 0.0001) changes in PA without altering hearing thresholds. SSCD significantly decreased PA at low (p < 0.02) and increased at high frequencies (p < 0.03), but on a smaller scale than the bullotomy. SSCD, induced a mean air-bone gaps of 24.3 for clicks, and 31.2 dB for 1 kHz TB. SSCD also increased the DPOAEs levels by mean of 10.1 dB SPL (p < 0.03). Patching the dehiscence, reversed partially the PA changes, the auditory threshold shifts, and the DPOAEs levels to pre-SSCD values.

CONCLUSIONS

SSCD affects both incoming and emitting sounds from the ear, probably due to its effect on cochlear impedance and stiffness of the middle and inner ear. The presence of DPOAEs and ABGs indicated a "third window" disease, i.e., SSCD. Due to similar PA patterns after bullotomy and SCCD, PA alone has limited diagnostic yield for patients with SCCD.

Superior Canal Dehiscence Similarly Affects Cochlear Pressures in Temporal Bones and Audiograms in Patients

OBJECTIVES

The diagnosis of superior canal dehiscence (SCD) is challenging and audiograms play an important role in raising clinical suspicion of SCD. The typical audiometric finding in SCD is the combination of increased air conduction (AC) thresholds and decreased bone conduction thresholds at low frequencies. However, this pattern is not always apparent in audiograms of patients with SCD, and some have hearing thresholds that are within the normal reference range despite subjective reports of hearing impairment. In this study, we used a human temporal bone model to measure the differential pressure across the cochlear partition (PDiff) before and after introduction of an SCD. PDiff estimates the cochlear input drive and provides a mechanical audiogram of the temporal bone. We measured PDiff across a wider frequency range than in previous studies and investigated whether the changes in PDiff in the temporal bone model and changes of audiometric thresholds in patients with SCD were similar, as both are thought to reflect the same physical phenomenon.

DESIGN

We measured PDiff across the cochlear partition in fresh human cadaveric temporal bones before and after creating an SCD. Measurements were made for a wide frequency range (20 Hz to 10 kHz), which extends down to lower frequencies than in previous studies and audiograms. PDiff = PSV- PST is calculated from pressures measured simultaneously at the base of the cochlea in scala vestibuli (PSV) and scala tympani (PST) during sound stimulation. The change in PDiff after an SCD is created quantifies the effect of SCD on hearing. We further included an important experimental control-by patching the SCD, to confirm that PDiff was reversed back to the initial state. To provide a comparison of temporal bone data to clinical data, we analyzed AC audiograms (250 Hz to 8kHz) of patients with symptomatic unilateral SCD (radiographically confirmed). To achieve this, we used the unaffected ear to estimate the baseline hearing function for each patient, and determined the influence of SCD by referencing AC hearing thresholds of the SCD-affected ear with the unaffected contralateral ear.

RESULTS

PDiff measured in temporal bones (n = 6) and AC thresholds in patients (n = 53) exhibited a similar pattern of SCD-related change. With decreasing frequency, SCD caused a progressive decrease in PDiff at low frequencies for all temporal bones and a progressive increase in AC thresholds at low frequencies. SCD decreases the cochlear input drive by approximately 6 dB per octave at frequencies below ~1 kHz for both PDiff and AC thresholds. Individual data varied in frequency and magnitude of this SCD effect, where some temporal-bone ears had noticeable effects only below 250 Hz.

CONCLUSIONS

We found that with decrease in frequency the progressive decrease in low-frequency PDiff in our temporal bone experiments mirrors the progressive elevation in AC hearing thresholds observed in patients. This hypothesis remains to be tested in the clinical setting, but our findings suggest that that measuring AC thresholds at frequencies below 250 Hz would detect a larger change, thus improving audiograms as a diagnostic tool for SCD.

Mechanisms of Hearing Loss in a Guinea Pig Model of Superior Semicircular Canal Dehiscence

Defective acoustic transmission in the cochlea is closely related with various auditory and vestibular symptoms. Among them, semicircular canal dehiscence (SCD) with a defective semicircular bone is typical. Currently, the pathogenesis of SCD is usually explained by the third window hypothesis; however, this hypothesis fails to explain the variability in the symptoms and signs experienced by superior SCD (SSCD) patients. We evaluated the mechanism of hearing loss in a guinea pig model of bony dehiscence with various sizes and locations along the superior semicircular canal. Auditory brainstem responses (ABRs) and laser Doppler velocimetry were used to measure hearing loss and vibration changes before and after fenestration, as well as after restorative patching. ABR thresholds at low frequencies (e.g., 1000 Hz) increased after fenestration and decreased back to the normal range after we repaired the defect. Energy leakage from the surgically introduced third window was detected in the range of 300–1500 Hz, accompanied by increased vibration at the umbo, stapes head, and the dehiscence site, while decreased vibration was observed at the round window membrane in the same frequency range. After the patching procedure, the deviant vibrations were recovered. The degree of postfenestration energy leakage was proportional to the size of fenestration and the proximity of the fenestration site to the oval window. These results suggest that the bony fenestration of the superior semicircular canal mimics the hearing loss pattern of patients with SSCD. The decrease in perilymph wave impedance likely accounts for the auditory changes.

Superior semicircular canal dehiscence syndrome

Superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD) syndrome is an increasingly recognized cause of vestibular and/or auditory symptoms in both adults and children. These symptoms are believed to result from the presence of a pathological mobile "third window" into the labyrinth due to deficiency in the osseous shell, leading to inadvertent hydroacoustic transmissions through the cochlea and labyrinth. The most common bony defect of the superior canal is found over the arcuate eminence, with rare cases involving the posteromedial limb of the superior canal associated with the superior petrosal sinus. Operative intervention is indicated for intractable or debilitating symptoms that persist despite conservative management and vestibular sedation. Surgical repair can be accomplished by reconstruction or plugging of the bony defect or reinforcement of the round window through a variety of operative approaches. The authors review the etiology, pathophysiology, presentation, diagnosis, surgical options, and outcomes in the treatment of this entity, with a focus on potential pitfalls that may be encountered during clinical management.

Pattern of hearing loss following cochlear implantation

Cochlear implantation is associated with deterioration in hearing. Despite the fact that the damage is presumed to be of sensory origin, residual hearing is usually assessed by air-conduction thresholds alone. This study sought to determine if surgery may cause changes in air- and bone-conduction thresholds producing a mixed-type hearing loss. The sample included 18 patients (mean age 37 years) with an air-bone gap of 10 dB over three consecutive frequencies and measurable masked and reliable bone-conduction thresholds of operated and non-operated ears who underwent cochlear implant surgery. All underwent comprehensive audiologic and otologic assessment and imaging before and after surgery. The air-bone gap in the treated ears was 17-41 dB preoperatively and 13-59 dB postoperatively over 250-4,000 Hz. Air-conduction thresholds in the treated ears significantly deteriorated after surgery, by a mean of 10-21 dB. Bone-conduction levels deteriorated nonsignificantly by 0.8-7.5 dB. The findings indicate that the increase in air-conduction threshold after cochlear implantation accounts for most of the postoperative increase in the air-bone gap. Changes in the mechanics of the inner ear may play an important role. Further studies in larger samples including objective measures of inner ear mechanics may add information on the source of the air-bone gap.

Effect of cochlear window fixation on air- and bone-conduction thresholds

HYPOTHESIS

In the absence of patent cochlear windows, cochlear fluid inertia depends on the presence of a "third window" as a major component of the bone-conduction response.

BACKGROUND

Studies have shown conflicting results regarding changes in air and bone conduction whenever, the round window, oval window, or both windows were occluded.

METHOD

The study was performed in a tertiary university-affiliated medical center. Auditory brain responses to clicks and 1-kHz tone bursts delivered by air and bone conduction were tested in 5 adult-size fat sand rats. The round window membrane (total, 7 ears) was sealed with Super Glue, and auditory brain response testing was repeated. Thereafter, the stapes footplate was firmly fixated, and auditory brain responses were recorded for a third time.

RESULTS

Round-window fixation induced a significant increase in air-conduction thresholds to clicks from 36.4 ± 0.9 to 69.3 ± 4.1 dB SPL, with no significant change in bone-conduction thresholds. When the stapes footplate was immobilized as well, air conduction increased by another 20 dB, on average, with no change in bone conduction. A similar deterioration was seen in response to 1 kHz stimulus.

CONCLUSION

These findings support and complement earlier studies in the same animal model, suggesting that when the pressure outlet through the cochlear windows are abolished, still bone conduction displaces the cochlear partition probably because of a functioning "third window."

Superior-semicircular-canal dehiscence: effects of location, shape, and size on sound conduction

The effects of a superior-semicircular-canal (SSC) dehiscence (SSCD) on hearing sensitivity via the air-conduction (AC) and bone-conduction (BC) pathways were investigated using a three-dimensional finite-element (FE) model of a human middle ear coupled to the inner ear. Dehiscences were modeled by removing a section of the outer bony wall of the SSC and applying a zero-pressure condition to the fluid surface thus exposed. At each frequency, the basilar-membrane velocity, vBM, was separately calculated for AC and BC stimulation, under both pre- and post-dehiscence conditions. Hearing loss was calculated as the difference in the maximum magnitudes of vBM between the pre- and post-dehiscence conditions representing a change in hearing threshold. In this study, BC excitations were simulated by applying rigid-body vibrations to the model along the directions of the (arbitrarily defined) x, y, and z axes of the model. Simulation results are consistent with previous clinical measurements on patients with an SSCD and with results from earlier lumped-element electrical-circuit modeling studies, with the dehiscence decreasing the hearing threshold (i.e., increasing vBM) by about 35 dB for BC excitation at low frequencies, while for AC excitation the dehiscence increases the hearing threshold (i.e., decreases vBM) by about 15 dB. A new finding from this study is that the initial width (defined as the width of the edge of the dehiscence where the flow of the fluid-motion wave from the oval window meets it for the first time) on the vestibular side of the dehiscence has more of an effect on vBM than the area of the dehiscence. Analyses of dehiscence effects using the FE model further predict that changing the direction of the BC excitation should have an effect on vBM, with vBM being about 20 dB lower due to BC excitation parallel to the longitudinal direction of the BM in the hook region (the x direction) as compared to excitations in other directions (y and z). BC excitation in the x direction and with a 'center' dehiscence located midway along the length of the SSC causes a reduction in the anti-symmetric component of the fluid pressure across the BM, as compared to the other directions of BC excitation, which results in a decrease in vBM at high frequencies. This article is part of a special issue entitled "MEMRO 2012".

Hearing outcomes after surgical plugging of the superior semicircular canal by a middle cranial fossa approach

OBJECTIVE

To determine postoperative hearing outcomes after surgical plugging via middle cranial fossa approach for superior semicircular canal dehiscence syndrome (SCDS).

STUDY DESIGN

Clinical review.

SETTING

Tertiary care medical center.

PATIENTS

Forty-three cases of SCDS based on history, physical examination, vestibular function testing, and computed tomography imaging confirming the presence of a dehiscence. All patients underwent surgical plugging of the superior semicircular canal via middle cranial fossa approach.

INTERVENTION

Pure tone audiometry was performed preoperatively and at 7 days and at least 1 month postoperatively.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Change in air-bone gap (ABG) and pure tone average (PTA).

RESULTS

Preoperative average ABG across 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 kHz was 16.0 dB (standard deviation [SD], 7.5 dB). At 7 days postoperatively, average ABG was 16.5 dB (SD, 11.1; p = 0.42), and at greater than 1 month was 8.1 dB (SD, 8.4; p < 0.001). 53% (95% confidence interval, 33-69) of affected ears had greater than 10 dB increase in their 4-frequency (0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz) PTA measured by bone-conduction (BC) threshold 7 days postoperatively and 25% (95% confidence interval, 8-39) at greater than 1 month postoperatively. Mean BC PTA of affected ears was 8.4 dB hearing loss (HL) (SD, 10.4) preoperatively. Compared with baseline, this declined to 19.2 dB HL (SD, 12.6; p < 0.001) at 7 days postoperatively and 16.4 dB HL (SD, 18.8; p = 0.01) at greater than 1 month. No significant differences in speech discrimination score were noted (F = 0.17).

CONCLUSION

Low-frequency air-bone gap decreases after surgical plugging and seems to be due to both increased BC thresholds and decreased AC thresholds. Surgical plugging via a middle cranial fossa approach in SCDS is associated with mild high-frequency sensorineural hearing loss that persists in 25% but no change in speech discrimination.