Summary of Japanese clinical practice guidelines for Bell's palsy (idiopathic facial palsy) - 2023 update edited by the Japan Society of Facial Nerve Research

OBJECTIVE

The "Summary of Japanese clinical practice guidelines for Bell's palsy (idiopathic facial palsy) - 2023 update edited by the Japan Society of Facial Nerve Research" aims to review the latest evidence regarding the treatment of Bell's palsy and to provide appropriate recommendations.

METHOD

Regarding the treatment of Bell's palsy, a guideline panel identified key clinical questions using an analytic PICO framework. The panel produced recommendations following the standards for trustworthy guidelines and the GRADE approach. The panel considered the balance of benefits, harm, and preferences when making recommendations.

RESULTS

The panel identified nine key clinical questions: systemic (high/standard dose) corticosteroids, intratympanic corticosteroids, systemic antivirals, decompression surgery, acupuncture, physical therapy, botulinum toxin, and reanimation surgery.

CONCLUSION

These guidelines strongly recommend systemic standard-dose corticosteroids for the clinical management of Bell's palsy. Other treatments are weakly recommended due to insufficient evidence. The absolute risk reduction of each treatment differed according to the disease severity. Therefore, physicians and patients should decide on treatment based on the disease severity.

Immediate lengthening temporalis myoplasty for facial palsy reconstruction following facial nerve inclusive total parotidectomy

Immediate lengthening temporalis myoplasty (Labbé procedure) for immediate dynamic facial reanimation after nerve-inclusive parotidectomy in the elderly population is undocumented in the literature. The aim of this work was to determine whether the Labbé approach could achieve immediate, good functional and static results in elderly patients with acquired facial palsy. A retrospective analysis of five patients with parotid malignancies involving the facial nerve who underwent parotidectomy and an immediate Labbé procedure was performed. The House-Brackmann and Sunnybrook scores for facial palsy were used as objective measurements of the functional outcome. All patients underwent total parotidectomy, neck dissection, Labbé procedure, immediate temporary tarsorrhaphy, brow lift, and postoperative radiotherapy. Mean patient age was 83 (range 73-87) years. The average resected tumour size was 3.54 cm. The mean duration of surgery was 324 min and length of hospital stay 4 days. All patients experienced an improvement in House-Brackmann of one grade postoperative (grade V to IV in four, grade VI to V in one); the Sunnybrook score improved by 31 points on average (mean preoperative 3.8 vs postoperative 34.8). An immediate Labbé procedure following ablative parotid malignancy resection is a reliable and safe reconstructive procedure in a carefully selected elderly population, providing acceptable immediate static and dynamic hemifacial mimetic function and eliminating an additional facial palsy correction procedure.

Quality of life after surgical treatments for facial palsy: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Facial palsy profoundly affects patients' quality of life (QoL). We evaluated the effect of various surgical procedures on QoL using patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) to provide evidence-based recommendations for improved care.

METHODS

Embase, Medline, Web of Science, Cochrane, and CINAHL were searched for studies on QoL in patients with facial palsy who had undergone reconstructive surgery with preoperative and postoperative data from validated PROMs. After conducting the quality assessment, data were subtracted from the articles. Meta-analyses of subgroups were performed when study outcomes where compatible.

RESULTS

Incorporating 24 studies (522 patients), our systematic review revealed consistent and significant QoL improvements following diverse reconstructive surgical procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

Our systematic review and meta-analysis showed the positive effects of different reconstructive surgical procedures on QoL of patients with facial palsy. These results support clinicians to better inform patients about their potential outcomes, optimizing informed and shared decision-making and ultimately improving overall QoL in patients with facial palsy.

Oral competence following facial nerve paralysis: Functional and quality of life measures

PURPOSE

Oral competence refers to the maintenance of lip closure with sufficient strength to prevent anterior spillage of saliva, food and fluid, and to clearly articulate labial sounds. Despite facial nerve paralysis having an impact on eating, drinking and communicating, little research has been done in this area.

METHOD

Studies examining oral competence associated with a diagnosis of facial nerve paralysis were considered using Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) statement checklists and evaluated for their risk of bias using the RevMan Risk of Bias Tool.

RESULT

44 articles were examined. There was an over-representation of case-series and cohort studies. All studies carried a high risk of bias due to lack of (a) validated outcome measures, (b) comparison group and (c) blinding or randomised assessors and participants. Studies primarily examined facial nerve intervention for the purpose of restoring smiling or facial aesthetics rather than oral competence.

CONCLUSION

Whilst oral competence is often compromised after a facial nerve paralysis, it is inconsistently measured, managed and described. Further studies are required to examine the (a) incidence, (b) severity and (c) impact on quality of life relating to oral incompetence using validated measures at consistent time intervals.

Twenty-Five-Year Outcomes of Treatment of Irreversible Facial Paralysis with Gillies and McLaughlin Techniques

INTRODUCTION

Data on treatment outcomes of surgical correction of irreversible facial paralysis is rare and long-term outcomes are scarce in the literature, making treatment choices difficult for operating surgeons.

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated 25-year outcomes of treatment of irreversible facial paralysis with Gillies and McLaughlin techniques with a focus on general functional and age-related functional outcomes.

METHODS

Data of all patients who underwent surgical correction of facial paralysis using either Gillies or McLaughlin procedure between 1994 and 2018 were included in the analysis of this retrospective, single-centre study (n = 154).

RESULTS

Gillies surgery was performed on 12 and McLaughlin technique on 33 patients. Gillies and McLaughlin surgeries were associated with high patient satisfaction (75-86%), low complication rates (8-24%), and achievement of full or partial eyelid closure in 75% as well as smile reanimation in 97% of patients operated. Achievement of resting facial symmetry was low for both techniques and ranged from 27 to 46%. Age-related functional outcomes were generally superior in middle-aged patients (21-59 years) with fewer complications and reoperations compared to younger and older patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical correction with Gillies or McLaughlin dynamic muscle support techniques yielded good clinical results with high patient satisfaction and should, therefore, be included as a treatment option for facial reanimation of irreversible facial paralysis. Patient age may play a role in treatment outcomes and reoperation and complication rates and should be taken into careful consideration during treatment planning.

Dynamic smile reanimation in facial nerve palsy

Objectives

Long-term facial paralysis results in degeneration of the distal nerve segment and atrophy of the supplied muscles. Options for these patients include free muscle transfer, temporalis myoplasty, and botulinum toxin injections for smile reanimation. In this study we aimed to evaluate the subjective and objective outcomes of these procedures.

Materials and Methods

In our study, we retrospectively analyzed smile symmetry in patients with facial palsy (n=8) who underwent facial reanimation procedures.

Results

Subjective analysis showed high satisfaction in seven out of eight patients. Objective analysis showed statistically significant improvement postoperatively in both vertical and horizontal smile symmetry at rest and during maximum smile (P<0.001).

Conclusion

Choosing the ideal procedure for the patients is the most critical aspect for facial reanimation. Though free muscle transfer is considered gold standard procedure, temporalis myoplasty also gives satisfactory results. Residual synkinesis which can lead to disturbing aesthetic deformity can be effectively treated with botulinum toxin.

Long-term outcomes of Gillies and McLaughlin's dynamic muscle support in irreversible facial paralysis: A retrospective single-centre study with 25-year follow-up

The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term outcomes of Gillies and McLaughlin's dynamic muscle support with regard to functional outcomes and assess possible effects of comorbidities on both functional outcomes and reoperation and complication rates. A retrospective single-centre study was conducted in all patients (n = 154) who underwent surgical correction of irreversible facial paralysis from 1994 to 2018. Patients with either Gillies procedure or McLaughlin's dynamic muscle support or a combination of these techniques were included in the analysis. Data on reoperations, comorbidities, complications, functional outcomes and patient satisfaction were analysed. Sixty-nine patients had Gillies and McLaughlin combination, 12 patients had Gillies and 33 patients had McLaughlin procedure alone. Patient satisfaction was generally high (>80%) and highest when McLaughlin procedure alone was performed and in patients without comorbidities. Reoperations were performed in 80 patients (70%; mean 2.2 ± 1.7) and complications affected 16 patients (14%). Smile ability and movement control of the corner of the mouth were achieved in >85% of patients operated, whereas complete eyelid closure and facial symmetry at rest were attained in only 46%‒68% of patients. Patients with no underlying medical conditions were able to smile more often, had motor control of the corner of the mouth, better facial symmetry at rest and fewer complications. Although newer surgical techniques are offered in many centres, this study shows that conventional facial reanimation of irreversible facial paralysis with Gillies or McLaughlin's dynamic muscle support or a combination of both produces yield good results and, therefore, continues to be a viable treatment option for many patients.

Suprazygomatic Aponeurotic McLaughlin Myoplasty for Facial Reanimation

BACKGROUND

Suprazygomatic aponeurotic McLaughlin (SAM) myoplasty technique for facial reanimation is based on the classical McLauglin's lengthening temporalis myoplasty with a series of new modifications. A comprehensive review of previously described other orthodromic temporalis myoplasty techniques is also included to give a succinct comparison.

METHODS

Twelve adult patients of facial palsy underwent SAM myoplasty for a period of 4 years. Three had congenital facial palsy, 4 patients had facial palsy secondary to acoustic neuromas, 3 were posttraumatic, and 2 patients had Bell's palsy.

RESULTS

Range of modiolus excursion achieved as measured at 3 months postoperatively on reanimation in our patients was 5 mm to 20 mm with an average of 12.6 mm. With SAM myoplasty technique, we were able to achieve excellent result in 4 patients and good results in 8 patients as evaluated with May and Druker scoring system.

CONCLUSIONS

Suprazygomatic aponeurotic McLaughlin myoplasty for facial reanimation demonstrates a successful modification of the classical McLaughlin lengthening temporalis myoplasty, making it more customizable, simple, and predictable by taking the level of transection to the temporalis aponeurosis without the need for zygomatic osteotomy. A new classification of orthodromic temporalis myoplasty based on level of transections is also proposed for the first time. Good to excellent outcomes coupled with high patient satisfaction and low morbidity should make this technique popular among the facial reanimation surgeons.