Perceptual, aerodynamic and acoustic outcomes of surgical technique for sulcus vocalis patients: A systematic review and meta analysis

BACKGROUND

Sulcus Vocalis (SV) is a voice disorder characterized by the parallel invagination of the vocal fold epithelium that adheres to the vocal ligament. This condition disrupts the vibratory function, leading to glottal incompetence, hoarseness, and vocal impairment. Despite various proposed surgical techniques, a standardized treatment approach remains elusive.

METHODS

We conducted a comprehensive search across PubMed/Medline, Embase, Web of Science, Scholar, and the Cochrane Library for studies on SV treatment. The inclusion criteria comprised original studies comparing pre- and post-treatment vocal outcomes in SV patients, published in English. We excluded case reports, reviews, studies without continuous data, and patients with vocal scar/atrophy.

RESULTS

Fifteen observational studies were included (361 patients, 53.73 % male, average age 41.64 years). 80 % of these studies employed self-reported outcomes, while 81.25 % analyzed acoustic/aerodynamic data. The follow-up period varied from 4 to 44 months. All techniques significantly improved Voice Handicap Index (VHI) scores (p < 0.001). Dissective and combined techniques exhibited greater reductions in VHI-30/10 (p < 0.001). Maximum Phonation Time (MPT) improved significantly across all techniques (p < 0.001), with dissective techniques demonstrating superior MPT outcomes (p < 0.001). Jitter improved significantly for dissective and injective techniques (p < 0.001), as did Shimmer for all techniques (p < 0.001). Notably, combined techniques displayed the most significant reductions (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical treatments significantly improve subjective, aerodynamic, and acoustic outcomes in SV patients. Dissective and combined dissective/injective techniques appear to yield better perceptual and phonatory outcomes compared to injective techniques alone. Further research is necessary to establish the optimal treatment approach for SV.

Evaluating Interventions for Sulcus Vocalis or Vocal Fold Scar: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Sulcus vocalis reflects varying degrees of vocal cord lamina propria (LP) damage. Many interventions have been discussed in the literature for addressing sulcus vocalis, but there is no universally accepted gold standard for its management.

AIM

We aim in our study to collectively evaluate the effectiveness of different relevant interventions in the literature used for sulcus vocalis or vocal fold scar.

METHODS

We searched five electronic databases to collect all relevant studies. Records were screened for eligibility. Data were extracted from the included studies independently. Our continuous outcomes were pooled in our single-arm meta-analysis as mean change (MC) and with 95% confidence interval (CI).

RESULTS

Our systematic review and meta-analysis included 43 studies encompassing 1302 patients. The jitter parameter indicated that laser degeneration and LP regeneration/scar degradation led to the highest improvements compared to their baseline, with pooled MC of -0.897 and -0.893, respectively. Graft interposition showed a MC of -0.848, while medialization and dissection had less pronounced changes at -0.200. Shimmer parameter results were similar, with medialization and laser degeneration leading to MC of -2.129 and -2.123, while LP regeneration/scar degradation and graft interposition showed smaller changes MC -1.530 and -1.217. For the noise-to-harmonic ratio (NHR) parameter, LP regeneration/scar degradation demonstrated MC = -0.028. In aerodynamics outcomes, graft interposition and LP regeneration/scar degradation showed the highest MCs in mean phonatory time (MPT) (4.214 and 3.467, respectively). Endoscopic outcomes for mucosal wave showed high improvements in medialization and graft interposition (MC = 10.40 and 10.18, respectively). Perceptual outcomes favored graft interposition in various parameters, while laser degeneration performed well in most categories. Graft interposition and LP regeneration/scar degradation had a high voice handicap index (VHI) (MC = -27.195 and -19.269, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Laser degeneration and LP regeneration/scar degradation were particularly effective in improving acoustic parameters. In aerodynamics, graft interposition and LP regeneration/scar degradation improved vocal efficiency compared to their baselines. Medialization and laser degeneration had the largest impact compared to their baseline on shimmer and MPT. Endoscopic assessments showed that medialization and graft interposition had high improvement in mucosal waves, and perceptual outcomes were generally high with graft interposition and laser degeneration.

Platelet-Rich Plasma for Vocal Fold Scar: A Preliminary Report of Concept

INTRODUCTION

Vocal fold atrophy and scar can lead to loss of normal superficial lamina propria, negatively affecting the vibratory function of the vocal fold. These changes can lead to dysphonia, vocal fatigue, decreased volume, and altered pitch. Treatment options for these conditions are limited. Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) consists of platelets, growth factors, and cytokines derived from the patient's own blood and is believed to activate tissue regeneration. The purpose of this study was to review the technical aspects of collecting PRP and injecting it into the vocal fold injection - based on our initial experience with this procedure.

CASE

A patient with vocal fold scar was identified and enrolled in an ongoing prospective clinical trial study of a series of 4 monthly subepithelial vocal fold PRP injections, which was temporarily halted due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Patient underwent a single injection of autologous PRP into the left vocal fold. There were no adverse events during the study period. Subjective improvement in voice was noted at 1 month after injection with subsequent return to baseline over the next 4 months. Videostroboscopy performed on postinjection day 1 and day 7 and demonstrated no concerning exam changes. Compared to the preinjection baseline, the patient-reported voice-handicap index-10 (VHI-10) and voice catastrophization index were similar at 4 months following injection (20 to 20 and 4 to 3, respectively). Independent perceptual analysis of voice showed improvement at 4 months postinjection, compared to baseline consensus auditory-perceptual evaluation of voice 60 to 44.

CONCLUSIONS

This preliminary report was part of a prospective trial investigating the use of PRP to treat vocal fold atrophy and scar. This work highlights the technical considerations for injecting PRP into the vocal fold. Planned prospective enrollment in this study will help to validate the safety and efficacy of PRP injections.

Vocal fold sulci - what are the current options for and outcomes of treatment?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Sulcus vocalis is a benign condition of the vocal folds that, according to its severity, can affect the quality of the voice of those who have it. Voice symptoms can range from mild to severe, affecting the quality of life of patients with this condition. Although different surgical and no surgical options have been described, no gold standard treatment has been described.

RECENT FINDINGS

New evidence supports congenital, inflammatory, and acquired theories for sulcus vocalis. Also, recent literature demonstrated the role of the epithelium in the pathogenesis, which makes the absence of superficial lamina propria no longer the only accepted hypothesis. Technological developments improved the in-office diagnostics capabilities for this condition, but vocal fold palpation remains the gold standard. Different benign laryngeal conditions are associated with sulcus vocalis and knowing when to treat those is very important. Different treatment options are available for sulcus vocalis, however, results are diverse and no strong recommendations for one over the other can be made.

SUMMARY

Progress continues to be made in our understanding of sulcus vocalis from diagnosis to treatment. Novel and promising therapeutic strategies have been recently developed for this condition; however, more data and investigations are needed to improve their accuracy and reproducibility.

Autologous Adipose Tissue Injection of Vocal Cords in Presbyphonia

OBJECTIVE

This series evaluates the long-term results of autologous adipose injection (AAI) in patients older than 65 years with presbyphonia.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Academic secondary medical center.

METHODS

This was a retrospective study with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. All patients underwent AAI for atrophy of both vocal folds due to presbyphonia. We measured subjective parameters as Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI-10) or GRBAS scale (grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, strain) and objective measures such as maximum phonation time (MPT) or square pixel closure defect. We reviewed the medical records of patients undergoing AAI during the 2011-2018 period. An analysis of the demographic variables of the group was performed, as well as the values of VHI-10, GRBAS, and MPT, and the minimum closure defect measured in square pixels and the number of closed frames in the glottal cycle before and after the intervention.

RESULTS

At 12 months, 17 of 18 patients reported subjective and VHI-10 improvement. The mean preoperative VHI-10 (26.7) was significantly higher than the postoperative value (14.4), and the GRBAS scale had a preoperative mean of 8.7 and a postoperative mean of 4.3, both with statistical significance. MPT increased from 7.7 to 12.4 seconds (P < .0001). The minimum closure defect measurements obtained in square pixels changed from 305 to 124, achieving complete closure in 3 patients. The closed phase of the glottal cycle change from 14.3% to 38.2% after the AAI.

CONCLUSIONS

AAI improves long-term vocal fold closure, demonstrating utility in patients with presbyphonia.

A Systematic Review on Surgical Treatments for Sulcus Vocalis and Vocal Fold Scar

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Vocal fold sulcus and scars are benign vocal fold lesions that present as a challenge to the laryngologist. A number of different surgical techniques have been proposed, aiming at restoring the lamina propria (LP), closing the glottal gap, or both. This study aimed to provide a systematic review of surgical treatment for sulcus and scar and to propose a new classification for these techniques.

STUDY DESIGN

A literature search using MEDLINE and Google Scholar through August 2020.

METHODS

Data on study design were retrieved and outcomes were classified as acoustic, aerodynamic, self-reported, perceptual, and stroboscopic. Methodological quality was assessed using the MINORs criteria. Each technique was classified as direct, indirect, or combined.

RESULTS

Our search included 31 studies with a total of 617 patients. Direct techniques included dissection, graft interposition, or LP regeneration/scar degradation while indirect techniques aimed for glottal gap closure. Only one article performed a comparison between different types of techniques and only eight studied the five types of outcomes. No superiority of any technique was noted in our analysis. Self-reported outcomes were the most frequently improved.

CONCLUSIONS

There seems to not exist a one-fits-all treatment for this clinical picture and no clear decision-making pattern. A recent trend toward sequential approaches, starting with less invasive procedures, can be observed. Laryngoscope, 2021.

Short-Term Voice Improvement after Repeated Office-Based Platelet-Rich Plasma PRP Injection in Patients with Vocal Fold Scar, Sulcus, and Atrophy

INTRODUCTION

Improving the voice of patients with vocal atrophy, scar, and sulcus vocalis remains challenging. Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) is an autologous biological suitable for regenerative medicine. Office-based injections of PRP may serve as a source of improved wound healing.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty two office based injections of PRP were performed in 14 patients with scar, sulcus, and vocal atrophy (12 scars, 1 sulcus, and 1 atrophy). PRP was prepared using 20 cc blood draw and double centrifugation method. Injection laryngoplasty was performed using trans cervical or indirect trans oral technique (10 trans cervical, 22 trans-oral). Volume of PRP use was 0.5-0.7 cc per side. Injections varied from 1 to 3 injections at monthly intervals. Videostroboscopy, Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10), and an objective analysis of the voice using Cepstral Peak Prominence (Cepstral Spectral Index of Dysphonia) were recorded. An expert rater speech pathologist rated the audio and stroboscopy results.

RESULTS

Median follow-up was 15 months. No patients were made worse. The mean VHI-10 before the injection was 23. VHI-10 after the injection was 12.5 (P < 0.01). The mean Cepstral Spectral Index of Dysphonia score for CAPE-V sentence was 42.5 before the injection and 23.5 (P < 0.01) after the injection. The expert rater thought the post treatment was better (9/14 acoustic, 10/14 stroboscopy). Eleven of the 14 patients thought the intervention was worthwhile to repeat. The other 3 patients thought the improvement was transient.

CONCLUSION

Office PRP injection into the vocal fold of patients with scar, sulcus, and atrophy may result in short term voice improvements. It is a biological worth considering.

Medialization Laryngoplasty: A Review for Speech-Language Pathologists

Purpose The purpose of this study is to familiarize speech-language-pathologists with the current state of the science regarding medialization laryngoplasty in the treatment of voice disorders, with emphasis on current evidence-based practice, voice outcomes, and future directions for research. Method A literature review was performed in PubMed and Embase using the keywords vocal fold/cord and laryngoplasty, thyroplasty, augmentation, or laryngeal framework. Articles published between 2010 and 2020 were reviewed for data about clinical applications, technical approach, voice-related outcomes, and basic science or clinical innovations with the potential to improve patient care. A synthesis of data was performed from articles meeting the outlined search criteria. Conclusions As key members in the multidisciplinary care of voice disorders, speech-language pathologists need to be informed of current research in medialization laryngoplasty, a procedure commonly used for patients with glottic insufficiency. Advances in anesthetic technique, office-based procedures, and the development of materials with increased bio-tolerability over the past decade have led to innovations in treatment and improved patient outcomes. Recent applications of computational and bioengineering approaches have the potential to provide new directions in the refinement of currently available techniques and the improvement of patient-based treatment outcomes.