Delayed reinnervation of unilateral vocal cord paralysis in dogs

Reinnervation of the Canine Posterior Cricoarytenoid Muscle with Sympathetic Preganglionic Neurons

This experiment investigated the reinnervation of the canine posterior cricoarytenoid (PCA) muscle with preganglionic neurons of the sympathetic nervous system. Six dogs had their right recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) sectioned. Four of these dogs had the sympathetic cervical trunk (SCT) implanted into the right PCA muscle, and the two remaining dogs served as denervated controls. Four months later all dogs underwent videolaryngoscopy, electromyography, and electrical stimulation of the SCT. The PCA muscles were excised, sectioned, and stained for glycogen and ATPase. All four experimental PCA muscles demonstrated electrically evoked abduction and tonic electromyographic activity. In two of the specimens, staining (ATPase and PAS) revealed areas of reinnervation with fiber type grouping and glycogen depletion. These results are consistent with the successful reinnervation of the PCA muscle. Further refinement of this technique could be of benefit to patients with bilateral vocal cord paralysis.

Histologic Evaluation of Intracordal Autologous Cartilage Injection in the Paralyzed Canine Vocal Fold at Two and Three Years

OBJECTIVE: Intracordal injection for vocal fold augmentation is easy and simple and does not require a cervical skin incision. We reported previously on the 1-year results of injected autologous auricular cartilage for volumetric augmentation in paralyzed canine vocal cord. This study evaluates the long-term histomorphologic results of injected autologous auricular cartilage for the augmentation of the paralyzed canine vocal fold at 2 and 3 years.

STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: A prospective trial of autologous cartilage augmentation of vocal cord in animal model. Five dogs were operated on. A piece of auricular cartilage was harvested from the ear and minced into tiny chips with a scalpel. Fat was harvested from inguinal area and minced with a scalpel. The minced cartilage and fat-paste (0.2 ml) was injected using a pressure syringe into the paralyzed thyroarytenoid muscle using direct laryngoscopy. Three animals were sacrificed at 2 years, two at 3 years. Each subject underwent laryngectomy and serial coronal sections of paraffin blocks from the posterior vocal fold were made.

RESULTS: There was no significant complications perioperatively or postoperatively. The injected cartilage that seemed to have lost viability existed in the vocalis muscles until 36 months. Fibrotic change was exhibited in the surrounding injected cartilage. There were no differences between 2 and 3 years in histomorphologic results of the injected cartilage.

CONCLUSION: The autologous auricular cartilage graft is well tolerated and may be a very effective material for long-term volumetric augmentation in the paralyzed vocal cord.

Nerve-muscle pedicle implantation facilitates re-innervation of long-term denervated thyroarytenoid muscle in rats

CONCLUSIONS

Nerve-muscle pedicle (NMP) implantation was effective in the recovery from atrophic changes in long-term denervated thyroarytenoid (TA) muscle. Re-innervation occurred via the transferred nerve. However, the effectiveness of the NMP method may decline with increasing duration of denervation.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the effects of NMP implantation on long-term denervated rat TA muscle.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Wistar rats (n=105) were divided into two groups in which the left recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) was transected without (DNV group) or with (NMP group) subsequent NMP implantation, and subgroups of each group were formed depending on the period after RLN transection (immediate to 48 weeks). In the DNV subgroups, we histologically assessed the area of muscle and the number of neuromuscular junctions. In the NMP subgroups, we performed electromyographic, videolaryngoscopic, and histologic assessments. The muscle area and muscle action potentials were evaluated by comparing the treated and untreated sides. The ratio of the number of nerve terminals to that of acetylcholine receptors was also assessed.

RESULTS

The TA muscle area was significantly larger in most of the NMP subgroups compared with the DNV subgroups. Muscle action potentials were present in all NMP animals. All histologic and physiologic assessments revealed degradation as the denervation period in the five NMP subgroups.

Laryngeal reinnervation

Laryngeal reinnervation refers to any of a number of surgical procedures intended to restore neural connections to the larynx, which have usually been lost from some type of trauma (eg, surgical). The nerve function(s) to be restored may be those of the recurrent laryngeal nerve or its subdivisions, those of the superior laryngeal nerve, or both, and they may be motor or sensory. Several different donor nerves are available and have been described. The technique used may be direct end-to-end anastomosis (neurorrhaphy), direct implantation of a nerve ending into a muscle, the nerve-muscle pedicle technique, or muscle-nerve-muscle methods. These nerves and techniques may be combined in many ways. A number of new techniques have been reported in animal studies; however, the animal studies do not always predict the results of analogous surgeries in human patients. The historical and current perspectives on these techniques are discussed in this article.

An experimental comparison of different kinds of laryngeal muscle reinnervation

In this study, we attempted to determine which method was the best for reinnervating the laryngeal adductor muscles by comparing nerve suture, nerve implantation, and nerve-muscular pedicle (NMP) transfer, as well as the length of time that could elapse after denervation and still allow for successful reinnervation with the ansa cervicalis. Reinnervation was performed in 36 dogs, at 6-, 8-, 10-, 12- and 18-month intervals after denervation via the three methods of muscle reinnervation described above. We noted some return of adduction in the cases using nerve suture before a 10-month interval after denervation, and with nerve implantation and NMP transfer before the 8-month intervals. The variable adduction was caused by reinnervation of the adductor muscles from the ansa cervicalis, as demonstrated by laryngeal spontaneous and evoked electromyography, the strength of muscle contraction, and histologic findings. Adduction was not observed in the cases after the above-mentioned intervals but partial improvement of the bulk and strength of the reinnervated vocal cord was still achieved. An analysis of the experimental results showed that nerve suture was superior to nerve implantation and the NMP technique. Little difference was noted between nerve implantation and the NMP technique.

Motor nerve transplantation

The motor nerve transplantation (MNT) technique is used to transfer an intact nerve into a denervated muscle by harvesting a neurovascular pedicle of muscle containing motor endplates from the motor endplate zone of a donor muscle and implanting it into a denervated muscle. Thirty-six adult New Zealand White rabbits underwent reinnervation of the left long peroneal (LP) muscle (fast twitch) with a motor nerve graft from the soleus muscle (slow twitch). The right LP muscle served as a control. Reinnervation was assessed using microstimulatory single-fiber electromyography (SFEMG), alterations in muscle fiber typing and grouping, and isometric response curves. Neurofilament antibody was used for axon staining. The neurofilament studies provided direct evidence of nerve growth from the motor nerve graft into the adjacent denervated muscle. Median motor endplate jitter was 13 microsec preoperatively, and 26 microsec at 2 months, 29.5 microsec at 4 months, and 14 microsec at 6 months postoperatively (p < 0.001). Isometric tetanic tension studies showed a progressive functional recovery in the reinnervated muscle over 6 months. There was no histological evidence of aberrant reinnervation from any source outside the nerve pedicle. Isometric twitch responses and adenosine triphosphatase studies confirmed the conversion of the reinnervated LP muscle to a slow-type muscle. Acetylcholinesterase studies confirmed the presence of functioning motor endplates beneath the insertion of the motor nerve graft. It is concluded that the MNT technique achieves motor reinnervation by growth of new nerve fibers across the pedicle graft into the recipient muscle.

Does intralaryngeal motor nerve sprouting occur following unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis?

Reinnervation of paralyzed intralaryngeal muscles by axonal sprouting from adjacent intact muscles (the phenomenon of muscular neurotization) has been observed, but the source is uncertain. The potential for laryngeal reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle (PCA) from contralateral PCA motor nerve sprouting in a rabbit model was investigated. Unilateral PCA denervation was produced by vagotomy. The rabbits were examined for signs of PCA recovery for up to 6 months, using fiberoptic endoscopy, electromyography (EMG), and histology. No return of vocal cord abduction, EMG activity, or any nerve sprouting across the midline from the intact PCA was found. We conclude that there is no significant spontaneous intralaryngeal muscular neurotization to the paralyzed PCA. The clinical ramifications of our data will be discussed.

Selective reinnervation of the abductor and adductor muscles of the canine larynx after recurrent nerve paralysis

Functional rehabilitation of the larynx after unilateral vocal cord paralysis was attempted in the dog by selective reinnervation of the laryngeal muscles. The intralaryngeal branches of the right recurrent nerve were dissected. The adductor branch was anastomosed with the ansa cervicalis; the abductor branch was anastomosed with the trunk of the phrenic nerve either within the larynx or through the recurrent nerve, the adductor branch of which was sectioned. Results could be analyzed in seven dogs: mobility of the vocal cord was checked, and electromyography, stimulation of the nerves, and histologic studies were performed. Functional reinnervation of both the adductor and abductor muscles was obtained in only one case, with good abduction. Adduction was recorded in five cases. False-positive results emphasize the necessity of collecting several types of data before concluding that functional reinnervation has been accomplished. The reliability of the procedure can and must be improved.

Histochemical study of posterior cricoarytenoid muscle reinnervation by a nerve-muscle pedicle in the cat

Reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid (PCA) muscle with a nerve-muscle pedicle (NMP) has been proposed for patients with bilateral abductor vocal cord paralysis. Since its success has been controversial, a glycogen depletion histochemical technique was used to examine reinnervation. An ansa cervicalis NMP was implanted into the denervated PCA in nine cats. Eight months later, vocal cord activity was evaluated. The NMP nerve was stimulated extensively in seven cats (experimental group). Optical densities of NMP-supplied PCA muscle fibers from experimental and control groups were compared to detect differences in glycogen content. The results demonstrated quantitative evidence of reinnervation in two experimental animals. Electrical stimulation of the NMP produced abduction in one of these two animals, but was never observed during spontaneous respiration or airway occlusion. These observations indicate that reinnervation can occur but abduction requires electrical stimulation. The NMP technique may be more successful with an electrical pacer.

Reinnervation of skeletal muscle: a comparison of nerve implantation with neuromuscular pedicle transfer in an animal model

In recent years there has been increased interest in the possibility of reinnervating paralyzed muscles, particularly the muscles of the face and of the larynx. There has been dispute over the relative effectiveness of different approaches. This study was undertaken to compare direct nerve implantation with the transfer of a neuromuscular pedicle using denervated strap muscles in a rabbit model. Reinnervation was carried out both immediately after denervation and after a delay period. Evidence of return of function was obtained by a method of long-term electromyographic monitoring and was confirmed electrically by evoked electromyography and muscle tension measurement and histologically by brain stem uptake of horseradish peroxidase. Both methods of nerve transfer produced consistently functional neuromuscular units, with physiological activity and muscle strength comparable with those in normally innervated controls. Return of function was apparent within 6 weeks of both nerve implantation and neuromuscular transfer; with this model, neither method showed a clear advantage over the other.

Preliminary observations after facial rehabilitation with the ansa hypoglossi pedicle transfer

Facial paralysis is a very disabling condition, both functionally and cosmetically. Despite the different methods of facial reanimation that have been described, there is no single method that will restore normal facial tone and motion. Of the methods available, primary neurorrhaphy is probably the most effective. The recovery period, however, is prolonged and, as a result, muscle tone and bulk may be lost. The hypoglossal-facial anastomosis is also a very reliable and effective technique but requires necessary interruption of both major cranial nerve trunks. Transfer of a neuromuscular pedicle (based on the ansa hypoglossi) has been offered as a method of facial reanimation that involves neither prolonged recovery nor interruption of the major cranial nerve functions. The application of this technique for reinnervation of a paralyzed larynx was first described by Tucker in 1970, and the technique was applied to facial muscle (in animal models) in 1977. The effectiveness of this technique--and its application in the management of facial paralysis in the human patient--remains controversial. We report our experience with a series of six patients who underwent neuromuscular pedicle transfer in conjunction with other more conventional methods of facial reanimation. The function of the pedicle and its contribution to the overall facial rehabilitation were assessed clinically and electromyographically. Factors influencing the success of the procedure and clinical and experimental evidence to support its application are discussed. While our experience with this technique is limited, it would appear that the neuromuscular pedicle transfer may play a useful adjunctive role in reanimation of the face in selective cases of facial paralysis.

Reinnervation of skeletal muscle with a neuromuscular pedicle

In the past decade the otolaryngologist has become interested in the problem of muscle reinnervation as it relates to laryngeal and facial paralysis. Although reinnervation by neuromuscular pedicle transfer has shown promising results in the laboratory and clinic, some investigators have had difficulty in achieving reliable results with this procedure. To further assess the technique's validity, we investigated the neuromuscular pedicle. This study utilized a strap muscle neuromuscular pedicle transfer to a contralateral strap muscle in the rabbit. The results were analyzed by the use of a number of independent measures, including electrical stimulation of the nerve, muscle contractibility, electromyography, enzyme histochemistry, reduced-silver staining for normal fibers, and the retrograde transport of the enzyme marker horseradish peroxidase. The physiologic and anatomic results demonstrated that morphologic and functional reinnervation of the experimentally isolated muscle by the transferred neuromuscular pedicle occurred. The most convincing data were produced by gross electrical stimulation, twitch and tetanic contraction, and horseradish peroxidase labeling. Electromyographic activity and other histologic findings supported the above conclusions.

Muscle transposition in the rehabilitation of the paralyzed larynx

Muscle transposition of the innervated omohyoid muscle into the tendon of the paralyzed posterior cricoarytenoid muscle was studied in a small series of subhuman primates. A similar procedure was described previously by King for treatment of bilateral recurrent nerve injuries. Our studies confirm that this procedure adequately enlarges the airway to allow normal activity without a tracheostomy. Histologic studies appear to show nerve ingrowth occurring at 6 months as in other neuromuscular pedicle procedures. The procedure is easily performed and causes no other muscle denervation.

Experiments in laryngeal reinnervation

Laryngeal reinnervation surgical procedures were performed in 26 dogs. Nineteen animals comprise the data reported in this thesis. Two different operative procedures were investigated, the ansa hypoglossi neuromuscular pedicle in 5 dogs, and the split phrenic nerve graft in 14 dogs. The studies were designed to evaluate whether either procedure resulted in inspiratory abduction of the vocal cord: and, if so, the mechanism by which abduction was produced. Five dogs in Experiment 1 demonstrated similar results from the ansa hypoglossi neuromuscular pedicle procedure. Apparent vocal cord abduction was seen during hyperpnea from airway obstruction, but was abolished by superior laryngeal nerve transection, or detachment of the sternothyroid muscle. None of the nerves in the neuromuscular pedicles was electrically excitable. Fourteen dogs in Experiment 2 underwent the split phrenic nerve graft operation. Vocal cord abduction, synchronized with inspiration, was noted in 5 animals. Two dogs had inspiratory abduction in quiet respiration. Electromyography, nerve action potentials, endoscopic motion pictures, and histologic study confirmed that posterior cricoarytenoid muscle reinnervation had occurred via the nerve graft from the phrenic nerve. Vocal cord abduction and electromyographic activity in the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle were abolished by transection of the nerve graft or the phrenic nerve. Conclusions of the study include the following: 1. The neuromuscular pedicle procedure does not result in reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle the pedicle's nerve and muscle block. 2. The phrenic procedure may result in reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid via the nerve graft, and inspiratory abduction of the paralyzed vocal cord. Failure of the phrenic procedure to produce reinnervation appeared to be due to a. recurrent laryngeal nerve regeneration, or b. avulsion of the nerve graft due to swallowing and other laryngeal movements.