The biomechanics and histopathology of chemically processed patellar tendon allografts for anterior cruciate ligament replacement

Current trends in graft choice for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction - part I: anatomy, biomechanics, graft incorporation and fixation

Graft selection in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction is critical, as it remains one of the most easily adjustable factors affecting graft rupture and reoperation rates. Commonly used autografts, including hamstring tendon, quadriceps tendon and bone-patellar-tendon-bone, are reported to be biomechanically equivalent or superior compared to the native ACL. Despite this, such grafts are unable to perfectly replicate the complex anatomical and histological characteristics of the native ACL. While there remains inconclusive evidence as to the superiority of one autograft in terms of graft incorporation and maturity, allografts appear to demonstrate slower incorporation and maturity compared to autografts. Graft fixation also affects graft properties and subsequent outcomes, with each technique having unique advantages and disadvantages that should be carefully considered during graft selection.

The protective effect of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on articular cartilage: a systematic review of animal studies

OBJECTIVE

It is unclear if anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction can prevent the onset of degenerative changes in the knee. Previous studies were inconclusive on this subject. The aim of this study was to systematically review all studies on the effect of ACL reconstruction on articular cartilage in animals.

DESIGN

Pubmed and Embase were searched to identify all original articles concerning the effect of ACL reconstruction on articular cartilage compared with both its positive (ACL transection) and negative (sham and/or non-operated) control in animals. Subsequently a Risk of bias and meta analysis was conducted based on five outcomes (gross macroscopic assessment, medical imaging, histological histochemical grading, histomophometrics and biomechanical characterization) related to articular cartilage.

RESULTS

From the 19 included studies, 29 independent comparisons could be identified which underwent ACL reconstruction with an average timing of data collection of 23 weeks (range 1-104 weeks). Due to limited data availability meta-analysis could only be conducted for gross macroscopic damage. ACL reconstruction caused significant gross macroscopic damage compared with intact controls (SMD 2.0 [0.88; 3.13]). These findings were supported by individual studies reporting on histomorphometrics, histology and imaging. No significant gross macroscopic damage was found when ACL reconstruction was compared with ACL transection (SMD -0.64 [-1.85; 0.57]).

CONCLUSION

This systematic review with an average follow up of included studies of 23 weeks (range 1-104 weeks) demonstrates that, in animals, ACL reconstruction does not protect articular cartilage from degenerative changes. The consistency of the direction of effect, provides some reassurance that the direction of effect in humans might be the same.

What Factors Influence the Biomechanical Properties of Allograft Tissue for ACL Reconstruction? A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Allograft tissue is used in 22% to 42% of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions. Clinical outcomes have been inconsistent with allograft tissue, with some series reporting no differences in outcomes and others reporting increased risk of failure. There are numerous variations in processing and preparation that may influence the eventual performance of allograft tissue in ACL reconstruction. We sought to perform a systematic review to summarize the factors that affect the biomechanical properties of allograft tissue for use in ACL reconstruction. Many factors might impact the biomechanical properties of allograft tissue, and these should be understood when considering using allograft tissue or when reporting outcomes from allograft reconstruction.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

What factors affect the biomechanical properties of allograft tissue used for ACL reconstruction?

METHODS

We performed a systematic review to identify studies on factors that influence the biomechanical properties of allograft tissue through PubMed and SCOPUS databases. We included cadaveric and animal studies that reported on results of biomechanical testing, whereas studies on fixation, histologic evaluation, and clinical outcomes were excluded. There were 319 unique publications identified through the search with 48 identified as relevant to answering the study question. For each study, we recorded the type of tissue tested, parameters investigated, and the effects on biomechanical behavior, including load to failure and stiffness. Primary factors identified to influence allograft tissue properties were graft tissue type, sterilization methods (irradiation and chemical processing), graft preparation, donor parameters, and biologic adjuncts.

RESULTS

Load to failure and graft stiffness varied across different tissue types, with nonlooped tibialis grafts exhibiting the lowest values. Studies on low-dose irradiation showed variable effects, whereas high-dose irradiation consistently produced decreased load to failure and stiffness values. Various chemical sterilization measures were also associated with negative effects on biomechanical properties. Prolonged freezing decreased load to failure, ultimate stress, and ultimate strain. Up to eight freeze-thaw cycles did not lead to differences in biomechanical properties of cadaveric grafts. Regional differences were noted in patellar tendon grafts, with the central third showing the highest load to failure and stiffness. Graft diameter strongly contributed to load-to-failure measurements. Age older than 40 years, and especially older than 65 years, negatively impacted biomechanical properties, whereas gender had minimal effect on the properties of allograft tissue. Biologic adjuncts show potential for improving in vivo properties of allograft tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

Future clinical studies on allograft ACL reconstruction should investigate in vivo graft performance with standardized allograft processing and preparation methods that limit the negative effects on the biomechanical properties of tissue. Additionally, biologic adjuncts may improve the biomechanical properties of allograft tissue, although future preclinical and clinical studies are necessary to clarify the role of these treatments.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Based on the findings of this systematic review that emphasize biomechanical properties of ACL allografts, surgeons should favor the use of central third patellar tendon or looped soft tissue grafts, maximize graft cross-sectional area, and favor grafts from donors younger than 40 years of age while avoiding grafts subjected to radiation doses > 20 kGy, chemical processing, or greater than eight freeze-thaw cycles.

Engineering Tendon: Scaffolds, Bioreactors, and Models of Regeneration

Tendons bridge muscle and bone, translating forces to the skeleton and increasing the safety and efficiency of locomotion. When tendons fail or degenerate, there are no effective pharmacological interventions. The lack of available options to treat damaged tendons has created a need to better understand and improve the repair process, particularly when suitable autologous donor tissue is unavailable for transplantation. Cells within tendon dynamically react to loading conditions and undergo phenotypic changes in response to mechanobiological stimuli. Tenocytes respond to ultrastructural topography and mechanical deformation via a complex set of behaviors involving force-sensitive membrane receptor activity, changes in cytoskeletal contractility, and transcriptional regulation. Effective ex vivo model systems are needed to emulate the native environment of a tissue and to translate cell-matrix forces with high fidelity. While early bioreactor designs have greatly expanded our knowledge of mechanotransduction, traditional scaffolds do not fully model the topography, composition, and mechanical properties of native tendon. Decellularized tendon is an ideal scaffold for cultivating replacement tissue and modeling tendon regeneration. Decellularized tendon scaffolds (DTS) possess high clinical relevance, faithfully translate forces to the cellular scale, and have bulk material properties that match natural tissue. This review summarizes progress in tendon tissue engineering, with a focus on DTS and bioreactor systems.

Histological study of fresh versus frozen semitendinous muscle tendon allografts

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to histologically analyze allografts from cadaveric semitendinous muscle after cryopreservation at -80 degrees C in comparison to a control group kept at only -4 degrees C to test the hypothesis that the histological characteristics of the tissue are maintained when the tendons are kept at lower temperatures.

METHODS

In a tissue bank, 10 semitendinous tendons from 10 cadavers were frozen at -80 degress C as a storage method for tissue preservation. They were kept frozen for 40 days, and then a histological study was carried out. Another 10 tendon samples were analyzed while still "fresh".

RESULTS

There was no histological difference between the fresh and frozen samples in relation to seven variables.

CONCLUSIONS

Semitendinous muscle tendon allografts can be submitted to cryopreservation at -80 degrees C without suffering histological modifications.

Good preservation of initial mechanical properties in lipid-extracted, disinfected, freeze-dried sheep patellar tendon grafts

Patellar tendon allografts can be used for anterior cruciate reconstruction to avoid morbidity of autografts on the donor side. Secondary processing of allografts is important for reducing immunological reactions, bacterial contamination and improving storage. We analyzed the effects of processing on the mechanical properties of patellar tendon grafts in 20 sheep. Group I (n = 10) was deep-frozen at -80 degrees C. Group II (n = 10) was processed by a lipid extraction/ freeze-drying method, including iodoacetic acid disinfection. The contralateral tendons, freeze-dried by dehydration in a vacuum at -50 degrees C for 3 hours, served as controls. We measured failure stress: group I (53, SD 14 MPa), control (26, SD 15 MPa) (p = 0.04); group II (49, SD 13 MPa), control (28, SD 5 MPa) (p = 0.08). Failure strain, normalized stiffness, and energy to failure were similar in the groups. Our method of extended processing did not change the properties of the deep-frozen patellar tendons. Therefore in vivo experiments can be used when studying the effects of transplantation on mechanical properties.

Tissue engineering of the anterior cruciate ligament: a new method using acellularized tendon allografts and autologous fibroblasts

INTRODUCTION

The availability of autogenous tendons (middle part of patellar tendon, semitendinosus/gracilis, or quadriceps tendon) for cruciate ligament reconstructions is restricted and related to withdrawal morbidity. Allografts and synthetic ligament materials often show problems regarding long-term stability and immunological reactions. Therefore, the aim of this study was to develop and characterize a new scaffold based on acellular allografts seeded with autologous cells for tissue engineering of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Semitendinosus tendons of New Zealand White (NZW) rabbits were harvested and acellularized using the detergent sodium dodecyle sulfate (SDS) as the main ingredient. After that, cultured (37 degrees C, 5% CO(2), medium) dermal fibroblasts were injected into the tendons. These constructs were further cultivated for 4, 7, or 14 days under the same culture conditions. Native, acellular, and seeded tendons underwent biomechanical testing (ultimate load to failure [N], stiffness [N/mm], and elongation [%], each n = 9] and histological hematoxylin-eosin (H.E.) staining. Detailed immunohistochemical (collagen I, III, IV, VI, pro-collagen I, versican, and vimentin) analyses were conducted to detect changes in the composition and structure of the extracellular matrix (ECM) after acellularization.

RESULTS

Histologically, a cell-free, crimped slack tendon structure after acellularization and a good integration of the cells after injection (4, 7, and 14 days) were seen. Metabolic activity of the seeded cells was demonstrated by positive immunohistochemical staining for pro-collagen I, which was negative in nonseeded constructs. Major differences in staining patterns of the various other ECM components were not observed. Biomechanically, the maximum load to failure of these tendons was comparable to native tendons (P = 0.429; native 134.5 +/- 12.9 N; acellular 118.5 +/- 7.3 N; seeded 132.3 +/- 5.6 N). Stiffness and elongation were comparable between native and acellular tendons, but differed significantly after seeding (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The described method is suitable to make tendons completely cell free without changing their major biomechanical properties. Preservation of the ECM and of the collagen fiber structure by this method should give an ideal environment for autologous cell integration and metabolic activity in contrast to other approaches for tissue acellularization. The cell disruption and extraction of cell detritus should minimize adverse immunogenic reactions.

Estudo comparativo de propriedades biomecânicas da porção central do tendão calcâneo congelado e a fresco

Métodos de armazenamento de aloenxertos podem alterar certas características mecânicas dos tecidos. Com o objetivo de analisar a influência do fenômeno de congelamento e do tempo de armazenamento sobre as propriedades biomecânicas de tendões, os autores estudaram 40 tendões calcâneos obtidos de 20 cadáveres humanos com idade média de 41,95 anos, variando de 31 a 54 anos, sendo 17 do sexo masculino e três do sexo feminino. De cada cadáver foram retirados dois tendões, sendo que um foi testado a fresco e o contralateral congelado a - 85º C em freezer elétrico, durante um período de seis ou 12 semanas. Os corpos de prova foram submetidos a ensaios de tração em uma máquina de ensaios mecânicos Kratos K5002, fornecendo gráficos força-deformação. Foram analisados os parâmetros de força no limite de resistência máxima, rigidez, tensão no limite de resistência máxima, deformação relativa e módulo de elasticidade. Os resultados foram comparados e a analisados estatisticamente pelo método de "t-student", com índice de significância de 0,05, sendo que não houve diferença significativa nos valores obtidos entre os grupos. Concluímos que o congelamento a - 85º C não altera as propriedades biomecânicas de tendões, a despeito do tempo de armazenamento.

A model of soft-tissue graft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in sheep

INTRODUCTION

Since there is to our knowledge no clinically valid and reproducible animal model of soft-tissue anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction currently available, we developed one in sheep, in terms of graft suitability, postsurgical recovery, and knee stability.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To find a suitable graft, anatomical dissections of the hind limbs of 7 sheep were performed. After a pilot study in 3 sheep, we reconstructed the ACL with an ipsilateral, longitudinally split, superficial digital flexor tendon autograft and anatomic graft fixation in 42 sheep (study 1) and with a full, superficial digital flexor tendon autograft and extracortical graft fixation in 48 sheep (study 2). Follow-up examinations ranged from 6 to 104 weeks (study 1) and 3 to 24 weeks (study 2).

RESULTS

All animals tolerated the graft harvest well and returned to physiological movement after about 4 weeks. Only 1 out of 93 ACL reconstructions failed. At final follow-up, the anteroposterior (AP) drawer displacement in both studies had almost regained the value of the intact contralateral knee. Maximum load-to-failure improved over time in both studies but was significantly lower at all time points compared with the intact ACL and the graft tissues. Tensile stress was significantly lower at final follow-up in both studies compared with the intact ACL and graft tissues. It attained 43.3% of the intact ACL and 58.3% of the graft tissue in study 1 and 28.9% and 22.8% in study 2, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The flexor tendon is suitable, and sheep appear to be an appropriate animal model for soft-tissue graft ACL reconstruction. They tolerate the graft harvest well and quickly return to full weight-bearing and physiological movement. Their knees become stable without showing signs of macroscopically evident osteoarthritis.

The progression of anterior translation after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a caprine model

Large post-operative anterior-posterior translations are frequently reported after quadruped anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions. To determine when the translation increases occur and the mechanism responsible, we followed the anterior and posterior translation limits in 18 goat knees for six months. Reconstructions were performed using grafts 4 or 7 mm wide placed in initially tight or lax positions. The anterior and posterior translation limits at 50 N were monitored using Roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis. Graft bone block stability and soft tissue segment lengths were also assessed. Large (> 2 mm) increases in anterior translation were noted in 71% of the subjects at two weeks, and in 88% at eight weeks. The translations in the lax and tight groups were indistinguishable after two weeks. Joints with wide grafts had less anterior translation compared to narrow grafts at all time periods, but were significant different only at 26 weeks. The posterior translation limit moved anteriorly over the 26 weeks. Eight of nine joints had stable graft bone markers and/or increases in graft soft tissue lengths. In conclusion, increased anterior translation occurred soon after ACL reconstruction, was associated with graft soft tissue changes, and appeared to be reduced by larger grafts. A post-surgical decrease in posterior translation limit was also observed.

The effects of graft width and graft laxity on the outcome of caprine anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

We studied how initial graft size and initial graft laxity affected the biomechanics of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction at six months. Sixteen goats had bilateral reconstructions staged eight weeks apart. Autografts 4 and 7 mm wide were taken from the central patellar tendon (PT). Lax grafts were created by adding 4 mm slack to the graft before fixing. We reconstructed each joint using a combination of width and laxity treatments. Both factors were changed for the contralateral joint and all combinations appeared with equal frequency. At six months we measured the joint extension limit, anterior-posterior (AP) translation, and osteoarthritic changes. The grafts were then tested to failure to determine their mechanical properties. After six months the difference in initial treatments had disappeared: there was no difference in graft cross-section due to the different initial widths and there was no difference in joint AP translation due to the initial graft laxity. We did observe that wide grafts were associated with a block to extension, decreased joint AP translation, and increased articular cartilage damage and osteophyte formation. While AP translation was reduced, it was correlated with decreased extension, possibly indicating an increase in scar tissue formation rather than a more functional graft. Neither graft width nor graft laxity produced differences in any graft mechanical properties. This suggests that the use of larger grafts to prevent increased AP translation has undesirable complications. Ultimately, we conclude that neither of these surgical treatments strongly affects the biomechanical result of caprine ACL reconstruction.

Tendon healing in a bone tunnel. Part I: Biomechanical results after biodegradable interference fit fixation in a model of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in sheep

PURPOSE

Interference fit fixation of soft-tissue grafts has recently raised strong interest because it allows for anatomic graft fixation that may increase knee stability and graft isometry. Although clinical data show promising results, no data exist on how tendon healing progresses using this fixation. The purpose of the present study was to investigate anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction biomechanically using direct tendon-to-bone interference fit fixation with biodegradable interference screws in a sheep model.

TYPE OF STUDY

Animal study.

METHODS

Thirty-five mature sheep underwent ACL reconstruction with an autologous Achilles tendon split graft. Grafts were directly fixed with poly-(D,L-lactide) interference screws. Animals were euthanized after 6, 9, 12, 24, and 52 weeks and standard biomechanical evaluations were performed.

RESULTS

All grafts at time zero failed by pullout from the bone tunnel, whereas grafts at 6 and 9 weeks failed intraligamentously at the screw insertion site. At 24 and 52 weeks, grafts failed by osteocartilaginous avulsion. At 24 weeks, interference screws were macroscopically degraded. At 6 and 9 weeks tensile stress was only 6.8% and 9.6%, respectively, of the graft tissue at time zero. At 52 weeks, tensile stress of the reconstruction equaled 63.8% and 47.3% of the Achilles tendon graft at time zero and the native ACL, respectively. A complete restitution of anterior-posterior drawer displacement was found at 52 weeks compared with the time-zero reconstruction.

CONCLUSIONS

It was found that over the whole healing period the graft fixation proved not to be the weak link of the reconstruction and that direct interference fit fixation withstands loads without motion restriction in the present animal model. The weak link during the early healing stage was the graft at its tunnel entrance site, leading to a critical decrease in mechanical properties. This finding indicates that interference fit fixation of a soft-tissue graft may additionally alter the mechanical properties of the graft in the early remodeling stage because of a possible tissue compromise at the screw insertion site. Although mechanical properties of the graft tissue had not returned to normal at 1 year compared with those at time zero, knee stability had returned to normal at that time. There was no graft pullout after 24 weeks, indicating that screw degradation does not compromise graft fixation.

Biomechanical properties and vascularity of an anterior cruciate ligament graft can be predicted by contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. A two-year study in sheep

Magnetic resonance imaging has been used to determine graft integrity and study the remodeling process of anterior cruciate ligament grafts morphologically in humans. The goal of the present study was to compare graft signal intensity and morphologic characteristics on magnetic resonance imaging with biomechanical and histologic parameters in a long-term animal model. Thirty sheep underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with an autologous Achilles tendon split graft and were sacrificed after 6, 12, 24, 52, or 104 weeks. Before sacrifice, all animals underwent plain and contrast-enhanced (gadolinium-diethylenetriamine pentacetic acid) magnetic resonance imaging (1.5 T, proton density weighted, 2-mm sections) of their operated knees. The signal/noise quotient was calculated and data were correlated to the maximum load to failure, tensile strength, and stiffness of the grafts. The vascularity of the grafts was determined immunohistochemically by staining for endothelial cells (factor VIII). We found that high signal intensity on magnetic resonance imaging reflects a decrease of mechanical properties of the graft during early remodeling. Correlation analyses revealed significant negative linear correlations between the signal/noise quotient and the load to failure, stiffness, and tensile strength. In general, correlations for contrast-enhanced measurements of signal intensity were stronger than those for plain magnetic resonance imaging. Immunohistochemistry confirmed that contrast medium enhancement reflects the vascular status of the graft tissue during remodeling. We conclude that quantitatively determined magnetic resonance imaging signal intensity may be a useful tool for following the graft remodeling process in a noninvasive manner.

Effect of chemical treatments on tendon cellularity and mechanical properties

Removal of cells may decrease the antigenicity and risk of disease transmission associated with tendon allografts and xenografts. An ideal cell removal method would not compromise graft structure and mechanical properties. This study compared the effects of three extraction chemicals [t-octyl-phenoxypolyethoxyethanol (Triton X-100), tri(n-butyl)phosphate (TnBP), and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)] on tendon cellularity, structure, nativity, and mechanical properties. Rat tail tendons were soaked in extraction solutions for various time periods (12-48 h) and concentrations (0.5-2%), then they were rinsed with distilled water and ethyl alcohol. Histological analysis and tensile tests were performed on control and chemically treated tendons. Changes in collagen nativity were estimated by mechanical testing following incubation in a trypsin solution. Treatment of tendons with 1% Triton X-100 for 24 h disrupted the collagen fiber structure and did not remove cells. Treatment with 1% SDS for 24 h or 1% TnBP for 48 h resulted in an acellular tendon matrix with retention of near normal structure and mechanical properties. Consistent with previous studies demonstrating cell removal from other tissue types using SDS and TnBP, our preliminary results suggest these treatments are potentially useful for removing cells from tendon allografts or xenografts without compromising the graft structure or mechanical properties.