Bilateral putaminal necrosis associated with the mitochondrial DNA A8344G myoclonus epilepsy with ragged red fibers (MERRF) mutation: an infantile case

MERRF Mutation A8344G in a Four-Generation Family without Central Nervous System Involvement: Clinical and Molecular Characterization

A 53-year-old man approached our Neuromuscular Unit following an incidental finding of hyperckemia. Similar to his mother who had died at the age of 77 years, he was diabetic and had a few lipomas. The patient's two sisters, aged 60 and 50 years, did not have any neurological symptoms. Proband's skeletal muscle biopsy showed several COX-negative fibers, many of which were "ragged red". Genetic analysis revealed the presence of the A8344G mtDNA mutation, which is most commonly associated with a maternally inherited multisystem mitochondrial disorder known as MERRF (myoclonus epilepsy with ragged-red fibers). The two sisters also carry the mutation. Family members on the maternal side were reported healthy. Although atypical phenotypes have been reported in association with the A8344G mutation, central nervous system (CSN) manifestations other than myoclonic epilepsy are always reported in the family tree. If present, our four-generation family manifestations are late-onset and do not affect CNS. This could be explained by the fact that the mutational load remains low and therefore prevents tissues/organs from reaching the pathologic threshold. The fact that this occurs throughout generations and that CNS, which has the highest energetic demand, is clinically spared, suggests that regulatory genes and/or pathways affect mitochondrial segregation and replication, and protect organs from progressive dysfunction.

Leigh Syndrome as a Phenotype of Near-Homoplasmic m.8344 A>G Variant in Children

In the field of mitochondrial medicine, correlation of clinical phenotype with mutation heteroplasmy remains an outstanding question with few, if any, clear thresholds corresponding to a given phenotype. The m.8344A>G mutation is most commonly associated with myoclonus epilepsy and ragged red fiber syndrome (MERRF) at varying levels of heteroplasmy. However, a handful of cases been previously reported in which individuals homoplasmic or nearly homoplasmic for this mutation in the blood have presented with multiple bulbar palsies, respiratory failure, and progressive neurologic decline almost uniformly following a respiratory illness. MRI brain in all affected individuals revealed symmetric T2 hyperintense lesions of subcortical gray matter structures, consistent with Leigh syndrome. Here, we present 3 cases with clinical, biochemical, and neuro-imaging findings with the additional reporting of spinal lesions. This new phenotype supports a heteroplasmy-dependent phenotype model for this mutation and recognition of this can help clinicians with diagnosis and anticipatory clinical guidance.

Pharmacotherapeutic management of epilepsy in MERRF syndrome

INTRODUCTION

Epilepsy is a prominent feature of myoclonic epilepsy with ragged-red fibers (MERRF)-syndrome. The most frequent seizure type is myoclonic seizures, of which the treatment is challenging and empiric.

AREAS COVERED

Herein, the author summarises and discusses previous and recent findings of antiepileptic drug (AED) treatment in MERRF-syndrome.

EXPERT OPINION

MERRF-syndrome is a predominantly maternally inherited, multisystem mitochondrial disorder caused by pathogenic variants predominantly of the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Canonical clinical features of MERRF include myoclonus, epilepsy, ataxia, and myopathy. Additionally, other manifestations in the CNS, peripheral nerves, eyes, ears, heart, gastrointestinal tract, and endocrine organs may occur (MERRF-plus). Today, MERRF is considered rather as myoclonic ataxia than as myoclonic epilepsy. Genotypically, MERRF is due to mutations in 13 mtDNA-located genes and 1 nDNA-located gene. According to the modified Smith-score, the strongest gene-disease relationship exists for MT-TK, MT-TL1, and POLG1. Epilepsy is the second most frequent phenotypic feature of MERRF. Seizure-types associated with MERRF include focal myoclonic, focal clonic, and focal atonic seizures, generalized myoclonic, tonic-clonic, atonic, and myoclonic-atonic seizures, or typical absences. Treatment of myoclonic epilepsy relies on expert judgments recommending levetiracetam, together with clonazepam, or topiramate, zonisamide, or piracetam in monotherapy as the first line AEDs.

Molecular Diagnosis of Myoclonus Epilepsy Associated with Ragged-Red Fibers Syndrome in the Absence of Ragged Red Fibers

Myoclonus epilepsy with ragged-red fibers (MERRFs), an inherited mitochondrial disorder, has characteristic morphological changes of ragged-red fibers (RRFs) in muscle biopsy, in the absence of which mitochondrial etiology is usually not considered in patients with phenotypes suggestive of MERRF. In these circumstances, MERRF can only be diagnosed using genetic analyses. The symptoms, pathological findings, and imaging results being age dependent, we can construct a protocol based on these characteristics to understand the disease’s natural course and to manage patients more effectively. The absence of RRFs should not preclude a MERRF diagnosis.

Neurological Disorders Associated with Striatal Lesions: Classification and Diagnostic Approach

Neostriatal abnormalities can be observed in a very large number of neurological conditions clinically dominated by the presence of movement disorders. The neuroradiological picture in some cases has been described as "bilateral striatal necrosis" (BSN). BSN represents a condition histo-pathologically defined by the involvement of the neostriata and characterized by initial swelling of putamina and caudates followed by degeneration and cellular necrosis. After the first description in 1975, numerous acquired and hereditary conditions have been associated with the presence of BSN. At the same time, a large number of disorders involving neostriata have been described as BSN, in some cases irrespective of the presence of signs of cavitation on MRI. As a consequence, the etiological spectrum and the nosographic boundaries of the syndrome have progressively become less clear. In this study, we review the clinical and radiological features of the conditions associated with MRI evidence of bilateral striatal lesions. Based on MRI findings, we have distinguished two groups of disorders: BSN and other neostriatal lesions (SL). This distinction is extremely helpful in narrowing the differential diagnosis to a small group of known conditions. The clinical picture and complementary exams will finally lead to the diagnosis. We provide an update on the etiological spectrum of BSN and propose a diagnostic flowchart for clinicians.

When should MERRF (myoclonus epilepsy associated with ragged-red fibers) be the diagnosis?

Myoclonic epilepsy associated with ragged red fibers (MERRF) is a rare mitochondrial disorder. Diagnostic criteria for MERRF include typical manifestations of the disease: myoclonus, generalized epilepsy, cerebellar ataxia and ragged red fibers (RRF) on muscle biopsy. Clinical features of MERRF are not necessarily uniform in the early stages of the disease, and correlations between clinical manifestations and physiopathology have not been fully elucidated. It is estimated that point mutations in the tRNALys gene of the DNAmt, mainly A8344G, are responsible for almost 90% of MERRF cases. Morphological changes seen upon muscle biopsy in MERRF include a substantive proportion of RRF, muscle fibers showing a deficient activity of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) and the presence of vessels with a strong reaction for succinate dehydrogenase and COX deficiency. In this review, we discuss mainly clinical and laboratory manifestations, brain images, electrophysiological patterns, histology and molecular findings as well as some differential diagnoses and treatments.

"Myo-cardiomyopathy" is commonly associated with the A8344G "MERRF" mutation

The objective of the study was to better characterize the clinical phenotype associated with the A8344G "MERRF" mutation of mitochondrial DNA. Fifteen mutated patients were extensively investigated. The frequency of main clinical features was: exercise intolerance and/or muscle weakness 67 %, respiratory involvement 67 %, lactic acidosis 67 %, cardiac abnormalities 53 %, peripheral neuropathy 47 %, myoclonus 40 %, epilepsy 40 %, ataxia 13 %. A restrictive respiratory insufficiency requiring ventilatory support was observed in about half of our patients. One patient developed a severe and rapidly progressive cardiomyopathy requiring cardioverter-defibrillator implantation. Five patients died of overwhelming, intractable lactic acidosis. Serial muscle MRIs identified a consistent pattern of muscle involvement and progression. Cardiac MRI showed non-ischemic late gadolinium enhancement in the left ventricle inferolateral part as early sign of myocardial involvement. Brain spectroscopy demonstrated increased peak of choline and reduction of N-acetylaspartate. Lactate was never detected in brain areas, while it could be documented in ventricles. We confirm that muscle involvement is the most frequent clinical feature associated with A8443G mutation. In contrast with previous reports, however, about half of our patients did not develop signs of CNS involvement even in later stages of the disease. The difference may be related to the infrequent investigation of A8344G mutation in 'pure' mitochondrial myo-cardiomyopathy, representing a bias and a possible cause of syndrome's underestimation. Our study highlights the importance of lactic acidosis and respiratory muscle insufficiency as critical prognostic factors. Muscle and cardiac MRI and brain spectroscopy may be useful tools in diagnosis and follow-up of MERRF.

Diagnosis and management of mitochondrial disease: a consensus statement from the Mitochondrial Medicine Society

PURPOSE

The purpose of this statement is to review the literature regarding mitochondrial disease and to provide recommendations for optimal diagnosis and treatment. This statement is intended for physicians who are engaged in diagnosing and treating these patients.

METHODS

The Writing Group members were appointed by the Mitochondrial Medicine Society. The panel included members with expertise in several different areas. The panel members utilized a comprehensive review of the literature, surveys, and the Delphi method to reach consensus. We anticipate that this statement will need to be updated as the field continues to evolve.

RESULTS

Consensus-based recommendations are provided for the diagnosis and treatment of mitochondrial disease.

CONCLUSION

The Delphi process enabled the formation of consensus-based recommendations. We hope that these recommendations will help standardize the evaluation, diagnosis, and care of patients with suspected or demonstrated mitochondrial disease.

Adult onset Leigh syndrome with mitochondrial DNA 8344 A>G mutation

We report a pedigree of adult-onset Leigh syndrome (LS) with mitochondrial mutation 8344 A>G. A 38-year-old woman presented with optic neuropathy, weakness and cognitive impairment. Family history of optic neuropathy and systemic involvement was suggestive of mitochondrial encephalopathy. Genetic and radiologic studies showed m.8344 A>G mutation with characteristics of LS. To our knowledge this is the first case of adult-onset LS demonstrating the m.8344 A>G mutation.

Mitochondrial epilepsy in pediatric and adult patients

Few data are available about the difference between epilepsy in pediatric mitochondrial disorders (MIDs) and adult MIDs. This review focuses on the differences between pediatric and adult mitochondrial epilepsy with regard to seizure type, seizure frequency, and underlying MID. A literature search via Pubmed using the keywords 'mitochondrial', 'epilepsy', 'seizures', 'adult', 'pediatric', and all MID acronyms, was carried out. Frequency of mitochondrial epilepsy strongly depends on the type of MID included and is higher in pediatric compared to adult patients. In pediatric patients, mitochondrial epilepsy is more frequent due to mutations in nDNA-located than mtDNA-located genes and vice versa in adults. In pediatric patients, mitochondrial epilepsy is associated with a syndromic phenotype in half of the patients and in adults more frequently with a non-syndromic phenotype. In pediatric patients, focal seizures are more frequent than generalized seizures and vice versa in adults. Electro-clinical syndromes are more frequent in pediatric MIDs compared to adult MIDs. Differences between pediatric and adult mitochondrial epilepsy concern the onset of epilepsy, frequency of epilepsy, seizure type, type of electro-clinical syndrome, frequency of syndromic versus non-syndromic MIDs, and the outcome. To optimize management of mitochondrial epilepsy, it is essential to differentiate between early and late-onset forms.

Young-onset dementia

Young-onset dementia is a neurologic syndrome that affects behavior and cognition of patients younger than 65 years of age. Although frequently misdiagnosed, a systematic approach, reliant upon attainment of a detailed medical history, a collateral history, neuropsychological testing, laboratory studies, and neuroimaging, may facilitate earlier and more accurate diagnosis with subsequent intervention. The differential diagnosis of young-onset dementia is extensive and includes early-onset forms of adult neurodegenerative conditions including Alzheimer's disease, vascular dementia, frontotemporal dementia, Lewy body dementias, Huntington's disease, and prion disease. Late-onset forms of childhood neurodegenerative conditions may also present as young-onset dementia and include mitochondrial disorders, lysosomal storage disorders, and leukodystrophies. Potentially reversible etiologies including inflammatory disorders, infectious diseases, toxic/metabolic abnormalities, transient epileptic amnesia, obstructive sleep apnea, and normal pressure hydrocephalus also represent important differential diagnostic considerations in young-onset dementia. This review will present etiologies, diagnostic strategies, and options for management of young-onset dementia with comprehensive summary tables for clinical reference.

Mitochondrial myopathy with autophagic vacuoles in patients with the m.8344A>G mutation

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

In mitochondrial myopathy, autophagy is presumed to play an important role in mitochondrial dysfunction. Rimmed vacuoles (RVs), a sign of autophagy, can be seen as a secondary phenomenon in muscle ragged-red fibres (RRFs), whereas the uncommon presentation is that some fibres contain RVs, but without any mitochondrial abnormalities. To investigate the pathogenesis beneath this pathological phenomenon.

METHODS

We reviewed 783 skeletal muscle specimens and selected five obtained from patients with suspected mitochondrial myopathy, characterised by clearly visible autophagic vacuoles in non-RRFs, besides the coexistence of RRFs and cytochrome oxidase-negative fibres. Immunohistochemical staining with LC-3, and electron microscopy studies were performed. Using resequencing microarray and a next-generation sequencing system, the mitochondrial DNA was screened for mutations and the heteroplasmic level was measured in skeletal muscle and blood.

RESULTS

Muscle fibres with RVs and RRFs, as well as some morphologically normal fibres, stained strongly for LC-3. Electron microscopy disclosed significant abnormal mitochondrial proliferation and existence of autophagic vacuoles. After mutation screening, m.8344A>G in the tRNA(Lys) gene was detected in two patients. The heteroplasmy of mutated G was 45.1% in skeletal muscle and 17.8% in blood in patient 1; patient 2 exhibited 80.3% mutated G in skeletal muscle and 25.2% in blood.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings demonstrate a new pathological phenotype for the m.8344A>G mutation- related disease and also provide pathological evidence of a correlation between mitochondrial abnormalities and autophagy.

Reversible parainfectious bilateral "striatal necrosis"

Bilateral striatal necrosis is usually associated with either endogenous or exogenous toxins, and with poor neurodevelopmental outcomes. We describe two patients with acute bilateral striatal clinical syndrome and magnetic resonance signal changes who made a complete clinical and radiologic recovery within 3 months. After an uneventful pregnancy, normal birth, and normal development, both boys presented at ages 3 and 5 years, respectively, after a viral illness with slurring of speech, bradykinesia, and an extrapyramidal movement disorder. On examination, both manifested bilateral cog wheel rigidity, with a broad-based gait and flexor plantar response. Cranial magnetic resonance imaging in both children indicated bilateral, symmetric, high signal changes in the lentiform nucleus, predominately in the putamen, with sparing of the globus pallidi bilaterally. The brain parenchyma was otherwise normal. Neurometabolic investigations produced normal results in both patients. The pathogenesis is uncertain, but could be immune-mediated. Both children, at 3-year and 1-year follow-ups, respectively, are doing well neurologically and academically. Our patients demonstrate that abnormal imaging findings during acute stages do not preclude good clinical and radiologic recovery.

Mitochondrial ataxias

Mitochondrial disorders (MIDs) are an increasingly recognized condition. The second most frequently affected organ in MIDs is the central nervous system. One of the most prevalent clinical CNS manifestations of MIDs is ataxia. Ataxia may be even the dominant manifestation of a MID. This is why certain MIDs should be included in the classification of heredoataxias or at least considered as differentials of classical heredoataxias. MIDs due to mutations of the mitochondrial DNA, which develop ataxia include the MERRF, NARP, MILS, or KSS syndrome. More rarely, ataxia may be a feature of MELAS, LHON, PS, MIDD, or MSL. MIDs due to mutations of the nuclear DNA, which develop ataxia include LS, SANDO, SCAE, AHS, XSLA/A, IOSCA, MIRAS, MEMSA, or LBSL syndrome. More rarely ataxia can be found in AD-CPEO, AR-CPEO, MNGIE, DIDMOAD, CoQ-deficiency, ADOAD, DCMA, or PDC-deficiency. MIDs most frequently associated with ataxia are the non-syndromic MIDs. Syndromic and non-syndromic MIDs with ataxia should be delineated from classical heredoataxias to initiate appropriate symptomatic or supportive treatment.