Studying the Effects of New Peritoneal Dialysis Solutions on the Peritoneum

♦ Background

Compelling data underscore the bioincompatible nature of glucose-based peritoneal dialysis (PD) solutions and their detrimental effects on peritoneal physiology and morphology. New PD solutions have been formulated to tackle common clinical problems such as inadequate ultrafiltration or malnutrition, and to improve biocompatibility—the latter aimed at preserving the structural and functional integrity of the peritoneum and reducing adverse systemic effects on the patient.

♦ Methods

This article reviews the factors in PD fluids that alter normal peritoneal anatomy and physiology, and the data that illustrate approaches to investigating the local and systemic biocompatibility of new PD solutions.

♦ Results

Chronic exposure of the peritoneal membrane to glucose-based PD solutions results in denudation of the mesothelium, thickened submesothelium, and hyalinization of the vasculature, often resulting in reduced or lost solute and water clearance. Data from in vitro or animal experiments and clinical studies have shown improved bio-compatibility profiles with new PD solutions that are glucose-free (that is, dialysates with amino acids or icodextrin), bicarbonate-buffered, or compartmentalized during heat sterilization to reduce levels of glucose degradation products. Improved biocompatibility is denoted by reduced induction of proinflammatory, profibrotic, or angiogenic growth factors in mesothelial cells and macrophages, or by less perturbation of leukocyte phagocytic function.

♦ Conclusions

Data from in vitro and animal experiments show more favorable biocompatibility profiles with new PD fluids than with glucose-based dialysates. Clinical studies are ongoing to assess the impact of the new PD fluids on peritoneal function, morbidity, and mortality.

Bicarbonate/Lactate Dialysis Solution ImprovesIn VivoFunction of Peritoneal Host Defense in Rats

Objective

To assess the in vivo peritoneal inflammatory reaction in rats dialyzed with neutral, bicarbonatelactate-buffered dialysis fluid.

Methods

Chronic peritoneal dialysis was performed for 4 weeks in Wistar rats with two solutions: (1) 40 mmol/l lactate-buffered fluid, pH 5.2, with a glucose concentration of 2.27 gldl (lac); and, (2) 15 mmolll lactate and 25 mmolll bicarbonate-buffered fluid, pH 7.0 -7.5, with a glucose concentration of 2.27gldl (Bic-lac). After 4 weeks, two peritoneal equilibration tests (PET 1 and PET 2) were performed in all animals with each respective solution. PET 1 was done with test solutions alone, whereas, on a subsequent day, PET 2 was performed with test solutions supplemented with endotoxin [lipopolysaccharide (IPS)] to induce peritonitis.

Results

During PET 1 no consistent differences were detected in peritoneal permeability between the lac and Bic-lac groups. Total dialysate cell count in the Bic-lac animals was lower than in rats treated with lac fluid: that is, at 8 hours, the respective counts were 1858 ± 524 cellslμl versus 2785 ± 1162 cellslμl (p < 0.01). Dialysate from animals dialyzed with Bic-lac contained more macrophages (at 4 hours: 53.6% ± 35.8% versus 35.8% ± 8.8%, p < 0.001) and fewer neutrophils (at 4 hours: 3.6% ± 1.8% versus 15.4%± 6.1%, p < 0.001) as compared to those dialyzed with the lac solution. Concentration of nitrites in 8-hour dwell dialysate samples from Bic-lac rats was lower than that in the lac group (0.98 ± 0.28 μmollml versus 2.32 ± 0.87 μmollml, p < 0.002), but cytokine levels in the dialysates were comparable. During PET 2, the in -crease in peritoneal permeability resulting from the lPS induced inflammatory response was similar for both test solutions. Dialysate cell count was higher in the lac group versus the Bic-lac group (at 8 hours: 8789 ± 4862 cellslμl versus 3961 ± 581 cellslμl, p < 0.001), contained more neutrophils (at 8 hours: 80.0% ± 11.3% versus 54.8% ± 4.4%, p < 0.001) and fewer macrophages (at 8 hours: 6.8% ± 5.6% versus 21.2% ± 3.3%, p < 0.05). During peritonitis, we found a higher overall dialysate concentration of both tumor necrosis factor (TNFα: +53%, p < 0.05) and of interferon gamma (lFN-y: +303%, p < 0.02), in the Bic-lac group than in the lac group.

Conclusions

A lower dialysate cell count, higher percentage of macrophages, and lower percentage of neutrophils in dialysate suggest that Bic-lac fluid induces a diminished nonspecific inflammatory response of the peritoneal cavity during dialysis. However, after in vivo stimulation, peritoneal cells from animals dialyzed with Bic-lac solution possess an augmented ability to produce inflammatory cytokines.

Animal Models in Peritoneal Dialysis Research: A Need for Consensus

The development of an adequate animal model for peritoneal research remains an object of concern. In vivo peritoneal dialysis (PD) research is hampered by the large variety of available models that make interpretation of results and comparison of studies very difficult. Species and strain of experimental animals, method of peritoneal access, study duration, measures of solute transport and ultrafiltration, and sampling for histology differ substantially among the various research groups. A collective effort to discuss the shortcomings and merits of the different experimental models may lead to a consensus on a standardized animal model of PD.

Biocompatibility of a Peritoneal Dialysis Solution with Amino Acids: Histological Evaluation in the Rabbit

Objective

To determine the biocompatibility of a peritoneal dialysis (PD) solution containing amino acids compared to PD solutions containing glucose.

Design

The biocompatibility of three dialysis solutions containing 1.1% amino acids, 1.36% glucose, and 3.86% glucose, respectively, was evaluated in vivo in rabbits.

Methods

After 60 days of PD, peritoneal histological changes in rabbits were investigated by light and transmission electron microscopy. The parameters investigated were: (1) mesothelial damage; (2) submesothelial edema; (3) submesothelial cell infiltration; (4) submesothelial fibrosis; and (5) vascular alterations. Semiquantitative evaluations were performed for all the above alterations; quantitative morphometric evaluation was performed for mesothelial damage (cubic transformation of the mesothelium, areas devoid of mesothelium, submesothelial edema) and thickness of peritoneal arteriole walls.

Results

(1) Mesothelial damage was practically nonexistent in rabbits dialyzed with the solution containing amino acids, and intermediate and severe with low glucose and high-glucose solutions, respectively. Both controls and rabbits dialyzed with amino acid solution showed flat continuous mesothelium; rabbits dialyzed with low-glucose solution showed cubic continuous mesothelium; and rabbits dialyzed with high-glucose solution showed cubic discontinuous mesothelium. Cytopathic mesothelial effects were slight with the solution containing amino acids and severe with both the low and high-glucose solutions. Duplication and thickening of mesothelial basement membrane were never observed. (2) Submesothelial edema showed a worsening trend from controls to rabbits dialyzed with solution containing amino acids, low glucose, and high glucose. (3) No difference in submesothelial infiltration was found between groups. (4) Submesothelial fibrosis was never observed. (5) Vascular alterations were never observed.

Conclusion

These results are evidence that PD solution with amino acids is more biocompatible than high and also low-glucose solutions.

State of the Art on Autologous Mesothelial Transplant in Animals and Humans

Sixteen years ago rabbit and human mesothelial cells were successsfully cultured and autoimplanted. The aim of the study was merely to demostrate that mesothelial implant was possible and interesting not only in peritoneal dialysis, but also in the vaster field of medicine and surgery concerning all the mesothelial districts of the body.

The aim of this paper is to recollect the steps which have led to autolougous mesothelial transplantation and verify if the tecnique has been validated and adopted by others.

Review of the literature published in the last 15 years shows that intraperitoneal transplantation of mesothelial cells has been effective in reducing the formation of peritoneal adhesions, and in remodeling the area of mesothelial denudation. New studies on the mesothelial cell opened the way to costruction of transplantable tissue-engineered artificial peritoneum, to the utilization of mesothelial progenitor cells and to find simple metods to collect autologous mesothelial cells.

Finally mesothelial trasnsplantation may represent a new neovascular therapy in the prevention and treatment of ischemic coronaric heart disease.

Prevention of peritoneal sclerosis: a new proposal to substitute glucose with carnitine dialysis solution (biocompatibility testing in vitro and in rabbits)

AIM

Commercial glucose peritoneal dialysis solutions expose the peritoneum to hyperosmolar glucose containing variable amounts of non-enzymic breakdown products of glucose. These solutions are toxic for the peritoneum. The aim of the present study is to compare in vitro and in vivo characteristics of a new dialysis solution containing carnitine, a naturally occurring compound, as substitute of glucose.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We compared in vitro and in the rabbit a new peritoneal dialysis solution containing carnitine, with two standard bicarbonate glucose peritoneal dialysis solutions and a solution containing icodextrin.

RESULTS

In vitro and in vivo the solution containing carnitine seems to be more biocompatible than standard glucose solutions and those containing icodextrin.

CONCLUSIONS

In our study the peritoneal dialysis solution containing carnitine seems to prevent the mesothelial changes observed with solutions containing glucose. Since carnitine has been extensively studied and seems to be well tolerated by hemodialysis patients, even at high doses for long periods, clinical trials in humans may be planned in the near future.

Peritoneal sclerosis: one or two nosological entities?

The frequency, pathology, animal models, pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, diagnostic criteria, therapy and prevention of peritoneal sclerosis are reviewed. Many of these aspects have a bimodal configuration which suggests that peritoneal sclerosis, usually considered a single pathology in peritoneal dialysis, is actually two distinct nosological entities: simple sclerosis and sclerosing peritonitis. The former is very frequent, with minor anatomical alterations and low clinical impact; it is reproducible in animals by means of peritoneal dialysis, and is clearly due to the poor biocompatibility of peritoneal dialysis solutions. The latter is rare, with radical anatomical alterations and high mortality requiring valid methods of diagnosis, therapy and prevention; it can only be reproduced in animal models by means other than peritoneal dialysis and seems to be due to factors both related and unrelated to peritoneal dialysis.

Experimental models in peritoneal dialysis: a European experience

BACKGROUND

The development of adequate animal models is important for the in vivo study of selected aspects of peritoneal dialysis (PD) that cannot be evaluated by an in vitro model, such as peritoneal membrane transport, the influence of local defense mechanisms, and for testing new osmotic agents and their biocompatibilities.

METHODS

Our experience with animal models for PD, including the acute Stockholm model in non-uremic rats, the acute and chronic Amsterdam model in non-uremic rats, and the chronic Gent model in uremic rats, is described.

RESULTS

The Stockholm model proved to be useful in understanding the normal physiology of peritoneal transport, and for testing new dialysis solutions and their biocompatibilities. It is a rather simple and inexpensive model, and thus is suitable for screening new solutions and additives. The Amsterdam model permits the study of chemokines and mesothelial cell regeneration in vivo, and is applied in a model of chronic peritonitis. The results of the Gent model suggest that chronic peritoneal dialysis in uremic rats is feasible for at least eight weeks. This model is, however, very laborious, time consuming, and expensive.

CONCLUSION

Further improvement of the technique and increase of the dialysis dose should result in a better and more realistic model for peritoneal dialysis. It is hoped that in the future these models will be useful to test the effects of long-term intraperitoneal application of different dialysis solutions and additives in uremic animals.