Sequence analysis and idiotypic relationships of BEG-2, a human fetal antibody reactive with DNA

Systematic analysis of sequences of anti-DNA antibodies--relevance to theories of origin and pathogenicity

Sequence analysis of anti-DNA antibodies is important in determining the molecular features which distinguish potentially pathogenic antibodies from those which are less likely to be pathogenic. Previous analysis of murine anti-DNA antibody sequences suggested that particular murine immunoglobulin genes are used preferentially to encode such antibodies and that somatic mutations to arginine, asparagine and lysine may be important in the creation of DNA binding sites. In this paper, a systematic analysis of published human anti-DNA sequences shows no strong evidence for preferential usage of particular human V(H) or V(L) genes in anti-DNA antibodies. Somatic mutations in IgG and IgA antibodies are clustered in the complementarity determining regions (CDRs) due to the effect of antigen drive. This process contributes to an excess of arginine, asparagine and lysine residues in these CDRs, some of which are likely to play an important role in binding to DNA. Computer modeling and in-vitro expression experiments are likely to help define the roles played by these residues in antigen binding and pathogenicity more clearly.

Immunoglobulin variable region sequences of human monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies

OBJECTIVE

Anti-DNA antibodies are believed to be important in the pathogenesis of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Antibodies that bind specifically and with high affinity to dsDNA are most closely involved in tissue damage. Analysis of the sequences of the variable regions of human monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies is useful in defining the structural features that give rise to these binding properties. This article systematically reviews the evidence derived from such sequences.

METHOD

Previous reviews of this subject have been hampered by incomplete knowledge of the human immunoglobulin variable region repertoire. In this article, the original sequence data from reports of over 50 human monoclonal antibodies (mAb) are reinterpreted by alignment to the most similar alleles of the most similar germline genes. This allows accurate estimation of the site and nature of somatic mutations.

RESULTS

Human IgG monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies generally carry more mutations than IgM. In many cases these have been selected by an antigen-driven process. In many of the more specific, higher affinity dsDNA binders, there is an accumulation of basic residues in the complementarity determining regions. However, many exceptions to this rule exist, particularly among IgM mAb.

CONCLUSIONS

Unlike murine anti-DNA antibodies, these human mAb show little evidence for preferential use of particular V(H), V(K) and V(lambda) genes or families to encode antibodies of this specificity.

The production, binding characteristics and sequence analysis of four human IgG monoclonal antiphospholipid antibodies

Antiphospholid antibodies (APL) have a notable association with recurrent miscarriages, arterial and venous thrombosis and thrombocytopenia. Analysis of the potential pathogenic effects of such human antibodies has been hampered by the considerable difficulty in producing IgG as opposed to IgM monoclonal immunoglobulins. We have developed four human monoclonal IgG APL (LJ1, AH2, DA3 and UK4) by fusing the peripheral blood lymphocytes of three patients with SLE with a mouse human heteromyeloma cell line, CB-F7. These antibodies bind to a variety of anionic phospholipids, two (LJ1 and AH2) bind total histones but none binds to ssDNA or dsDNA. Binding to beta 2 GPI is non-specific. UK4 alone demonstrates lupus anticoagulant activity. All four have lambda light chains, two are IgG1 (AH2 and UK4) and two are IgG3 (LJ1 and DA3). These APL utilize VH genes present in the fetally restricted repertoire and multiple somatic mutations in the CDR suggest an antigen-driven process. In contrast, there is no restriction in V lambda gene usage and only one lambda chain is extensively mutated. Two clonally related hybridomas were isolated from a single patients. This supports the theory that clonal expansion is the mechanism whereby antigen selects high affinity mutations.

Analysis of three new idiotypes on human monoclonal autoantibodies

We have identified and characterised three new idiotypes on human IgM McAbs generated from the splenocytes of a SLE patient with active disease. RT-6, which binds H1 and Sm/RNP, expresses essentially a private Id. Its expression is limited to a small number of human McAbs and the sera from patients with infectious diseases. In contrast RT-72Id and RT-84Id, expressed on McAbs which are polyreactive for two or more antigens, have a public distribution. RT-72Id and RT-84Id are found on McAbs from murine and human adult, and foetal tissues. In sera, significant numbers of SLE, RA and patients with other autoimmune diseases are positive for both Ids. RT-84Id is also elevated in SLE relatives and spouses, and in patients with Klebsiella infection. No correlation with disease activity, IgM or IgG levels was observed with either Id. However, RT-72Id was significantly associated with anti-ssDNA antibodies and RhF. RT-6Id and RT-72Id are located on the framework regions of the mu heavy chain, whereas RT-84Id is present on the kappa light chain, within the binding site. The McAbs are encoded by mainly germline genes: heavy chains of RT-6, RT-72 and RT-84 are encoded by the genes VH26, VH4.22 and VH4.21, respectively, and the light chain sequences of RT-6 and RT-72 are derived from DPL11 and HK102. Immunofluorescent staining revealed the presence of RT-72Id and RT-84Id positive immunoglobulin deposits in 18% and 45%, respectively, of the lupus renal sections compared with none in the disease control group, suggesting that these Ids may contribute to the pathology of the disease.

Expression of a human fetal anti-DNA antibody idiotype BEG-2 beta in the families of patients with rheumatoid arthritis

BEG-2 is a monoclonal antibody produced by the human-human hybridoma technique from a 12 weeks old human fetus. A polyclonal antiserum was raised in an (NZW x Half-lop hybrid) rabbit against BEG-2 and the anti-BEG-2 anti-idiotype was purified and characterised. Using this rabbit reagent the expression of the BEG-2 beta idiotype was analysed in 12 patients with active rheumatoid arthritis and their close family members (n = 54). Twenty five sera from healthy controls were analysed to establish a normal range. Ten of 12 patients (83%) with rheumatoid arthritis expressed the BEG-2 idiotype as well as 11 of 54 healthy unaffected relatives (20%).

Serological and genetic characterization of a human monoclonal immunoglobulin G anti-DNA idiotype

This study analyzed the distribution of an idiotype, B3-Id, in patients with active SLE, classified according to organ involvement, normal controls, and other autoimmune rheumatic diseases. A polyclonal anti-idiotype was raised by immunizing a rabbit with a monoclonal IgG anti-double-stranded (ds) DNA antibody, B3, generated from a patient with SLE who had active arthritis. The idiotype is present on the lambda chain and is at or near the binding site for double-stranded DNA. The lambda chain, which was characterized by nucleotide sequencing, was 90% homologous to the V lambda 2.1 germline, which is known to be involved in coding for nephritogenic anti-DNA antibodies carrying the 8.12 idiotype. There were four changes to positively charged amino acids, known to be involved in DNA binding, in the complementarity determining regions of B3 lambda chain compared with a non-DNA binding, 8.12 positive antibody, PV11. Only one change to a positively charged amino acid occurs in the heavy chain of B3, which is 93.5% homologous to VH-26. The B3-Id was present on IgG antibodies in the serum of 20% of patients with SLE but was not found in the normal controls. Within the SLE group, there is a statistically significant association of B3-Id on IgG in the arthritis group (42%) compared to the other manifestations (9%) (P < 0.001). In four B3-Id-positive SLE patients tested serially, the level of B3-Id reflected the arthritis disease activity more closely than the overall disease activity (P < 0.05). The B3-Id was also present on IgM antibodies in one third of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. This idiotype is the first to be derived from a human monoclonal anti-DNA antibody of the IgG class, the isotype associated with active disease. Sequence analysis shows that positively charged amino acids on the lambda chain may contribute to DNA binding.

Sequence analysis and fine specificity of two human monoclonal antibodies to histone H1

Two human IgM lambda monoclonal antibodies (MAb) derived from the splenic lymphocytes of patients with idiopathic thrombocytopenia (Ben) and systemic lupus erythematosus (Wri) were studied. BEN-27 and WRI-170 hybridoma supernatants were screened for binding to ssDNA, dsDNA, poly (ADP-ribose), cardiolipin, histone subclasses and Klebsiella K30 cell wall antigen. Of this panel of antigens, BEN-27 and WRI-170 antibodies reacted only with histone H1. Their fine specificity was defined by direct and inhibition ELISA with synthetic peptides of the major human H1b variant. Antibody WRI-170 was shown to bind to both the N- and C-terminal peptides encompassing residues 1-16 and 204-218 of H1b whereas BEN-27 reacted only with peptide 204-218. To analyse the genetic origin of these autoantibodies, we determined the nucleotide sequence of the heavy (H) and light (L) chain variable regions of these two hybridomas. BEN-27 and WRI-170 MAbs were found to use VH1-DN1-JH4/V lambda 3-J lambda 2 and VH3-DIR2-D21/9-JH1/V lambda 2-J lambda 2 gene segment combinations respectively. Between 70 and 95% homology was demonstrated when the mRNA sequences for BEN-27 and WRI-170 were compared with published VH and V lambda germline sequences. This finding suggests that BEN-27 heavy and light chains and WRI-170 light chain use unidentified VH and V lambda germline gene segments whereas WRI-170 heavy chain derives from a VH gene segment recently identified. It is noteworthy that the CDRs of the two MAbs contain several negatively charged amino acids which are assumed to be of critical importance in antigen binding. Moreover, striking similarities are observed between BEN-27 heavy chain CDR2 and a previously described murine anti-H1 Ab heavy chain CDR2.

Identification and characterization of a new human DNA reactive monoclonal antibody and a common idiotype, WRI 176 Id beta

We describe a human monoclonal antibody designated WRI 176 beta and a common idiotype that it carries. This antibody was derived from the spleen of a patient with SLE. WRI 176 is an IgM kappa monoclonal reacting with ssDNA, dsDNA, poly(dT) and it is likely that mAb WRI 176 beta is a representative of the so-called natural autoantibodies. The common Id designated WRI 176 Id beta is located on the heavy chain of the mAb WRI 176 beta molecule and appears to be located outside the binding site. Sequence analysis of the WRI 176 beta heavy chain showed it to be highly homologous (97.3%) with a germline gene 56PI derived from a human fetus. In a retrospective analysis, although 44% of SLE patients had raised levels of the WRI 176 beta no correlation was found with the activity of the disease. The idiotype was also expressed frequently in a range of autoimmune rheumatic and infectious diseases and in some healthy first-degree relatives of SLE patients.

Expression and relationships of seven public idiotypes of DNA-binding autoantibodies on monoclonal antibodies and serum immunoglobulins

Many studies have shown that DNA-reactive autoantibodies share cross-reactive public idiotypes that are defined, usually, by single anti-idiotype reagents. Because anti-idiotype antibodies or antisera will be limited in their ability to detect all the idiotopes of a particular antibody, their use will tend to underestimate the full extent of idiotype sharing between different antibodies. In order to define more comprehensively the extent of idiotype sharing in DNA autoantibodies, a panel of DNA-binding monoclonal autoantibodies from lupus mice was examined with a range of anti-idiotype antisera prepared in rabbits (five sera), guinea pigs (four sera) and a sheep. Each idiotype was detected on more antibodies than its original reference monoclonal antibody, and idiotopes of each were also present on serum immunoglobulins from lupus mice. Of 23 monoclonal antibodies 65% reacted with one or more of the anti-idiotype reagents. On these criteria, all the idiotypes were public; none was private in its expression. In about half the cases the idiotypes were located in or near the antigen-binding sites of the antibodies, but a direct relationship to specificity was not obvious except in the case of Id.228 present on antibodies with a relatively high affinity for single-stranded DNA. In other cases there was no obvious relationship between idiotype and specificity. Antibodies from the same mouse did not each express the same array of idiotopes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Specificity and idiotope expression of IgM produced by CD5+ and CD5- cord blood B-cell clones

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-immortalized monoclonal B-cell lines were established from CD5+ and CD5- cord-blood B cells. IgM from many of both CD5+ and CD5- clones reacted with IgG-Fc, ssDNA, and a variety of other autoantigens. More CD5+ B cells that used light chains of the kappa isotype reacted with IgG-Fc and ssDNA than kappa-bearing CD5- B cells. Because many of the clones reacted with IgG-Fc, they were analyzed for the expression of cross-reactive idiotypes (CRI) associated with rheumatoid factor and cold agglutinin paraproteins using murine antibodies (mAb) recognizing V kappa and VH subgroup-associated determinants. Expression of the V kappa IIIb sub-subgroup-associated idiotope recognized by 17.109 mAb was expressed at significantly higher frequency (32%; p less than 0.05) and IgM antibodies derived from the CD5+ compared with the CD5- clones (5%). Both CD5+ and CD5- clones expressed the RF paraprotein-associated idiotope recognized by G8 mAb to the same extent. Similar results were obtained using binding to SpA as a marker of VH III family usage. Furthermore, no differences in frequency of expression of RF paraprotein-associated idiotopes recognized by B6 and/or D12, and characteristic of some antibodies using VH III family genes, were found between the CD5+ and CD5- populations. Although a higher than expected frequency of VH IV-gene expression was demonstrated (around 30%) in both CD5+ and CD5- cells, there were differences in expression of CRI recognized by mAb Lc1 and R2.1A2 with specificities for two VH IV subfamilies. While some CD5+ and CD5- clones were identified in which their IgM reacted with mAb Lc1, only CD5+ clones were recognized by another mAb R2.1A2. Analysis of the relationships between antigen specificities and V kappa- and VH-family gene usage indicated that auto- or polyreactivity was not associated with V kappa III nor any particular VH family. The higher frequency of the V kappa IIIb sub-subgroup-associated idiotope recognized by 17-109 in the CD5+ clones and the association of CD5+ B cells with the VH IV subfamily recognized by mAb R2.1A2 and 9G4 may suggest that CD5+ B cells in cord blood are expanded as a result of recruitment within the fetal environment.