One-Year Chromaffin Cell Allograft Survival in Cancer Patients with Chronic Pain: Morphological and Functional Evidence

Cell transplantation as a pain therapy targets both analgesia and neural repair

Cell transplantation is a potentially powerful approach for the alleviation of chronic pain. The strategy of cell transplantation for the treatment of pain is focused on cell-based analgesia and neural repair. (1) Adrenal medullary chromaffin cells and the PC12 cell line have been used to treat cancer pain and neuropathic pain in both animal models and human cases. As biological or living minipumps, these cells produce and secrete pain-reducing neuroactive substances if administered directly into the spinal subarachnoid space. (2) Cell implantation for pain neurorestorative therapy is a new concept and an emerging research field for pain control along with neural repair. Possible neurorestorative mechanisms include neuroprotective, neurotrophic, neuroreparative, neuroregenerative, neuromodulation, or neuroconstructive interventions, as well as immunomodulation and enhancing the microcirculation. These factors may ultimately restore the damaged or irritated condition of the lesioned nerves. The growing preclinical and clinical data show that neural stem/progenitor cells, olfactory ensheathing cells, mesenchymal stromal cells, and CD34(+) cells have the capacity to manage intractable pain and improve neurological functions. Cell delivery routes include local, intrathecal, or intravascular implants. Although these strategies are still in their infancy phase for pain neurorestoratology, cell-based therapies could open up new avenues for the relief of pain. In this review, these aspects are critically analyzed based on our own investigations. This manuscript is published as part of the International Association of Neurorestoratology (IANR) supplement issue of Cell Transplantation.

Targeted cell reprogramming produces analgesic chromaffin-like cells from human mesenchymal stem cells

Transplantation of allogeneic adrenal chromaffin cells demonstrated the promise of favorable outcomes for pain relief in patients. However, there is a very limited availability of suitable human adrenal gland tissues, genetically well-matched donors in particular, to serve as grafts. Xenogeneic materials, such as porcine and bovine adrenal chromaffin cells, present problems; for instance, immune rejection and possible pathogenic contamination are potential issues. To overcome these challenges, we have tested the novel approach of cell reprogramming to reprogram human bone marrow (BM)-derived mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) using cellular extracts of porcine chromaffin cells. We produced a new type of cell, chromaffin-like cells, generated from the reprogrammed hMSCs, which displayed a significant increase in expression of human preproenkephalin (hPPE), a precursor for enkephalin opioid peptides, compared to the inherent expression of hPPE in naive hMSCs. The resultant chromaffin-like cells not only expressed the key molecular markers of adrenal chromaffin cells, such as tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) and methionine enkephalin (Met-enkephalin), but also secreted opioid peptide Met-enkephalin in culture. In addition, intrathecal injection of chromaffin-like cells in rats produced significant analgesic effects without using immunosuppressants. These results suggest that analgesic chromaffin-like cells can be produced from an individual's own tissue-derived stem cells by targeted cell reprogramming and also that these chromaffin-like cells may serve as potential autografts for chronic pain management.

Cellular therapies for treating pain associated with spinal cord injury

Spinal cord injury leads to immense disability and loss of quality of life in human with no satisfactory clinical cure. Cell-based or cell-related therapies have emerged as promising therapeutic potentials both in regeneration of spinal cord and mitigation of neuropathic pain due to spinal cord injury. This article reviews the various options and their latest developments with an update on their therapeutic potentials and clinical trialing.

Tyrosine hydroxylase, chromogranin A, and steroidogenic acute regulator as markers for successful separation of human adrenal medulla

Progress in high throughput "-omic" techniques now allows the simultaneous measurement of expression levels of thousands of genes and promises the improved understanding of the molecular biology of diseases such as cancer. Detection of the dysfunction of molecular pathways in diseases requires healthy control tissue. This is difficult to obtain from pheochromocytomas (PHEOs), rare chromaffin tumors derived from adrenal medulla. The two options for obtaining adrenal tissue are: (1) whole organ removal post-mortem or during radical nephrectomy; (2) removal during PHEO surgery. Access to high quality normal adrenal tissue is limited. Removal of whole adrenals during nephrectomy is rare, because of improved surgical techniques. For adrenals removed post-mortem, the lag time to proper organ perfusion causes uncontrolled tissue degradation. Adjacent normal adrenal tissue can almost never be obtained from resected PHEOs, because they often replace the entire medulla or are well-encapsulated. If a margin of normal adrenal is attached to a resected PHEO, it seldom contains any medulla. The clean separation of medulla and cortex is further complicated, because their border is convoluted, and because adult adrenal consists of approximately 90% cortex. Thus, the quality of separation has to be evaluated with specific medullary and cortical markers. We describe the successful dissection of highly pure, medullary tissue from adrenals snap-frozen upon resection during radical nephrectomy or after brain death. Separation quality has been verified by quantitative reverse transcription with polymerase chain reaction for the medullary enzymes, tyrosine hydroxylase, and chromogranin A, and for the cortical enzyme, steroidogenic acute regulator.

Electrical Stimulation-Induced Release of β-Endorphin from Genetically Modified Neuro-2a Cells

The quantity of therapeutic gene products released from genetically engineered cells can be controlled externally at different levels. The widely used approach of controlling expression, however, generally has the disadvantage that chemical substances must be applied for stimulation. An alternative strategy aims at controlling gene products at posttranslational levels such as secretion. The secretion of a therapeutic agent can be regulated if the agent is targeted to the regulated secretory pathway and stored in the secretory granules until its release. In this article we address the question of whether the release of β-endorphin, an opioid with a potent analgesic effect, could be induced by electrically stimulating stably transfected Neuro-2a cells. Throughout this study we used the human proopiomelanocortin (POMC) gene, which is the precursor molecule for human β-endorphin. We analyzed its subcellular localization and found it in the regulated secretory pathway in Neuro-2a cells. Using electrical field stimulation we were able to identify a stimulation pattern that significantly increased the release of β-endorphin-immunoreactive material, although to a limited extent. This result indicates that electrical stimulation of secretion could be used to manipulate the amount of a therapeutic agent released from transplanted cells.

Deafferentation Pain Resulting from Cervical Posterior Rhizotomy is Alleviated by Chromaffin Cell Transplants into the Rat Spinal Subarachnoid Space

OBJECTIVE

Deafferentation pain is common after posttraumatic brachial plexus avulsion in humans. Alleviation of such pain is poorly achieved by most therapeutic interventions; the only efficient neurosurgical procedure currently available is lesioning of the dorsal root entry zone. Previous work has demonstrated that adrenal medullary transplants into the lumbar spinal subarachnoid space can alleviate neuropathic pain behavior resulting from peripheral nerve or spinal cord injury. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the potential effects of adrenal medullary transplants on brachial plexus deafferentation pain.

METHODS

The cervical posterior rhizotomy model was selected as an upper segmental deafferentation model because it mimics the pathological situation after traumatic brachial plexus avulsion in humans. Animals underwent a right posterior cervical rhizotomy extending from C5 to T1 and received either adrenal medullary transplants or control striated muscle transplants into the cervical subarachnoid space. The clinical evolution was evaluated daily for self-directed behaviors indicative of ongoing pain, including onset, dermatomal extent, and severity.

RESULTS

In animals with muscle control transplants, self-directed behaviors appeared in 83.3% of the group, with a mean delay between rhizotomy and onset of self-directed behaviors of 8 days. In contrast, only 30.8% of the animals implanted with chromaffin cells exhibited any signs of self-directed behaviors, and these had a mean onset delay of 14 days.

CONCLUSION

The suppression of self-directed behaviors by adrenal medullary transplants is similar to that observed after dorsal root entry zone lesioning and suggests that this approach may offer a nonablative alternative in the management of deafferentation pain resulting from dorsal root avulsion.

Intrathecal grafting of porcine chromaffin cells reduces formalin-evoked c-Fos expression in the rat spinal cord

Chromaffin cells from the adrenal gland secrete a combination of neuroactive compounds including catecholamines, opioid peptides, and growth factors that have strong analgesic effects, especially when administered intrathecally. Preclinical studies of intrathecal implantation with xenogeneic bovine chromaffin cells in rats have provided conflicting data with regard to analgesic effects, and recent concern over risk of prion transmission has precluded their use in human clinical trials. We previously developed a new, safer source of adult adrenal chromaffin cells of porcine origin and demonstrated an in vivo antinociceptive effect in the formalin test, a rodent model of tonic pain. The goal of the present study was to confirm porcine chromaffin cell analgesic effects at the molecular level by evaluating neural activity as reflected by spinal cord c-Fos protein expression. To this end, the expression of c-Fos in response to intraplantar formalin injection was evaluated in animals following intrathecal grafting of 10(6) porcine or bovine chromaffin cells. For the two species, adrenal chromaffin cells significantly reduced the tonic phases of the formalin response. Similarly, c-Fos-like immunoreactive neurons were markedly reduced in the dorsal horns of animals that had received injections of xenogeneic chromaffin cells. This reduction was observed in both the superficial (I-II) and deep (V-VI) lamina of the dorsal horn. The present study demonstrates that both xenogeneic porcine and bovine chromaffin cells transplanted into the spinal subarachnoid space of the rat can suppress formalin-evoked c-Fos expression equally, in parallel with suppression of nociceptive behaviors in the tonic phase of the test. These findings confirm previous reports that adrenal chromaffin cells may produce antinociception by inhibiting activation of nociceptive neurons in the spinal dorsal horn. Taken together these results support the concept that porcine chromaffin cells may offer an alternative xenogeneic cell source for transplants delivering pain-reducing neuroactive substances.

No detectable analgesic effects in the formalin test even with one million bovine adrenal chromaffin cells

The present experiments were conducted to identify analgesic agents for transfection into immortalized adrenal chromaffin cell lines to maximize their analgesic potential. Analgesic agents known to be produced by adrenal chromaffin cells were infused intrathecally at a low dose (0.2 microg) which might conceivably be attained by adrenal chromaffin cell transplants. Numerous agents, administered individually and in two-factor combinations, produced significant analgesic effects in the formalin test. Before assessing the potential additive or synergistic effects of these analgesic agents with adrenal chromaffin cells, studies were conducted to demonstrate analgesic effects with adrenal chromaffin cells alone. Analgesic effects were previously reported in the literature with 80-100k intrathecal bovine adrenal chromaffin (BAC) cells; but in the present study 500k purified BAC cells failed to produce detectable analgesic effects. One million purified BAC cells also failed to produce analgesic effects in the formalin test. In a final study, even nicotine-stimulated release from one million purified BAC cells failed to produce analgesic effects in the formalin test. The fact that even one million nicotine-stimulated BAC cells failed to demonstrate therapeutic potential in these blinded experiments under conditions which were clearly sensitive to the analgesic agents produced by BAC cells, raises serious questions about the clinical utility of this experimental treatment.

Human chromaffin cell graft into the CSF for cancer pain management: a prospective phase II clinical study

A number of pre-clinical studies have demonstrated the value of adrenal medullary allografts in the management of chronic pain. The present longitudinal survey studied 15 patients transplanted for intractable cancer pain after failure of systemic opioids due to the persistence of undesirable side-effects. Before inclusion, all the patients had their pain controlled by daily intrathecal (I-Th) morphine administration. The main evaluation criteria of analgesic activity of the chromaffin cell allograft was the complementary requirement of analgesics and in particular the consumption of I-Th morphine required to maintain effective pain control. Out of the 12 patients who profited from enhanced analgesia with long-term follow-up (average 4.5 months), five no longer required the I-Th morphine (with prolonged interruption of systemic opioids as well), two durably decreased I-Th morphine intake and five were stabilized until the end of their follow-up. Durable decline and stabilization were interpreted as indicative of analgesic activity by comparison with the usual dose escalation observed during disease progression. In most cases, we noted a relationship between analgesic responses and CSF met-enkephalin levels. The results of this phase II open study demonstrate the feasibility and the safety of this approach using chromaffin cell grafts for long-term relief of intractable cancer pain. However, while analgesic efficacy was indicated by the reduction or stabilization in complementary opioid intake, these observations will need to be confirmed in a controlled trial in a larger series of patients.

Intrathecal grafting of unencapsulated adrenal medullary tissue can bring CD4 T lymphocytes into CSF: a potentially deleterious event for the graft

Adrenal medullary tissue including chromaffin cells was grafted intrathecally in cancer patients to relieve intractable pain. The central nervous system (CNS) is considered an immune privileged site. Therefore, non-HLA-matched and unencapsulated tissue was grafted in 15 patients and 1 sham control in a series of at least 20 grafts. We observed an increase in CSF lymphocyte counts in 15/20 allografts (75%). In contrast to peripheral blood, CD4 T cells predominated in the CSF, but failed to exhibit an activated phenotype (CD25+ CD45RO+ HLA-DR+). The positive effect of graft on pain, the high met-enkephalin levels, the absence of any increase in CSF cytokine levels particularly for IFN-gamma or IL-2 (but not IL-10 and IL-6), indirectly indicated that the graft was tolerated despite the presence of CSF lymphocytes. The single treatment failure and three of four cases of partial efficacy occurred in grafts where CSF lymphocytes were present. Moreover, when assayed (n = 7), the CD4+ CSF lymphocytes still retained the capacity to exhibit ex vivo a normal or enhanced frequency of T CD4 cells producing IFN-gamma and IL-2. Taken together, our observations indicate that impairment of the local immunosuppressive balance can lead to activation of those CSF CD4 T cells and drive a rejection process. This study suggests further work on the purification and/or the immunoisolation of tissues grafted in the CNS will be necessary, particularly when the possibility of long-term and repeated grafting is considered.