Population screening for haemochromatosis: a unifying analysis of published intervention trials

Perspectives in Pediatric Pathology, Chapter 21. Testicular Pathology in Heritable Metabolic Disease

Inborn errors of metabolism have wide and profound effects in many or all organs, and especially so in those with endocrine functions. The testes are greatly affected by systemic metabolic disorders, leading to specific histological findings that generally reveal the nature of the underlying disorder. Here we describe the main testicular changes seen in the setting of metabolic disease.

Interventions for hereditary haemochromatosis: an attempted network meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Hereditary haemochromatosis is a genetic disorder related to proteins involved in iron transport, resulting in iron load and deposition of iron in various tissues of the body. This iron overload leads to complications including liver cirrhosis (and related complications such as liver failure and hepatocellular carcinoma), cardiac failure, cardiac arrhythmias, impotence, diabetes, arthritis, and skin pigmentation. Phlebotomy (venesection or 'blood letting') is the currently recommended treatment for hereditary haemochromatosis. The optimal treatment of hereditary haemochromatosis remains controversial.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the comparative benefits and harms of different interventions in the treatment of hereditary haemochromatosis through a network meta-analysis and to generate rankings of the available treatments according to their safety and efficacy. However, we found only one comparison. Therefore, we did not perform the network meta-analysis and we assessed the comparative benefits and harms of different interventions using standard Cochrane methodology.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), MEDLINE, Embase, Science Citation Index Expanded, World Health Organization International Clinical Trials Registry Platform, and randomised clinical trials registers to March 2016 to identify randomised clinical trials on treatments for hereditary haemochromatosis.

SELECTION CRITERIA

We included only randomised clinical trials (irrespective of language, blinding, or publication status) in participants with hereditary haemochromatosis. We excluded trials which included participants who had previously undergone liver transplantation. We considered any of the various interventions compared with each other or with inactive treatment.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

We used standard methodological procedures expected by Cochrane. We calculated the odds ratio (OR) and rate ratio with 95% confidence intervals (CI) using both fixed-effect and random-effects models with RevMan 5 based on available-participant analysis. We assessed risk of bias according to Cochrane, controlled risk of random errors with Trial Sequential Analysis, and assessed the quality of the evidence using GRADE.

MAIN RESULTS

Three trials with 146 participants met the inclusion criteria of this review. Two parallel group trials with 100 participants provided information on one or more outcomes. The remaining trial was a cross-over trial, with no usable data for analysis. All the trials were at high risk of bias. Overall, all the evidence was of very low quality. All three trials compared erythrocytapheresis (removal of red cells only, instead of whole blood) versus phlebotomy. Two of the trials shared the same first author. The mean or median age in the three trials ranged from 42 to 55 years. None of the trials reported whether the included participants were symptomatic or asymptomatic or a mixture of both. Two trials were conducted in people who were haemochromatosis treatment-naive. The trial that provided most data for this review excluded people with malignancy, heart failure, and serious cardiac arrhythmias. We found no trials assessing iron-chelating agents.Only one of the trials with 38 participants reported no short-term mortality and no serious adverse events at the end of the short-term follow-up (eight months). Two trials reported the proportion of people with adverse events: 10/49 (20.4%) in the erythrocytapheresis group versus 11/51 (21.6%) in the phlebotomy group. One of these two trials provided data on adverse event rates (42.1 events per 100 participants with erythrocytapheresis versus 52.6 events per 100 participants with phlebotomy). There was no evidence of differences in the proportion of people with adverse events and the number of adverse events (serious and non-serious) between the groups (proportion of people with adverse events: OR 0.93, 95% CI 0.36 to 2.43; participants = 100; trials = 2; number of adverse events: rate ratio 0.80, 95% CI 0.32 to 2.03; participants = 38; trial = 1). There was no difference between the groups regarding short-term health-related quality of life (mean difference (MD) 1.00, 95% CI -10.80 to 12.80; participants = 38; trials = 1). This outcome was measured using EQ-VAS (range: 0 to 100 where a higher score indicates better health-related quality of life). None of the trials reported mortality beyond one year, health-related quality of life beyond one year, liver transplantation, decompensated liver disease, cirrhosis, hepatocellular carcinoma, diabetes, or cardiovascular complications during the long-term follow-up.The two trials that provided data for this review were funded by parties with no vested interest in the results; the source of funding of the third trial was not reported.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

There is currently insufficient evidence to determine whether erythrocytapheresis is beneficial or harmful compared with phlebotomy. Phlebotomy has less equipment requirements and remains the treatment of choice in people with hereditary haemochromatosis who require blood letting in some form. However, it should be noted that there is no evidence from randomised clinical trials that blood letting in any form is beneficial in people with hereditary haemochromatosis. Having said this, a trial including no treatment is unlikely to be conducted. Future trials should compare different frequencies of phlebotomy and erythrocytapheresis versus phlebotomy with and without different iron-chelating agents compared with each other, and with placebo. Such trials should include long-term follow-up of participants (e.g. using national record linkage databases) to determine whether treatments are beneficial or harmful in terms of clinical outcomes such as deaths, health-related quality of life, liver damage and its consequences, heart damage and its consequences, and other outcomes that are of importance to people with hereditary haemochromatosis.

Iranian hereditary hemochromatosis patients: baseline characteristics, laboratory data and gene mutations

BACKGROUND

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is the most common autosomal recessive disorder in white people, characterized by highly abnormal uptake of iron from the gastrointestinal tracts. Recently, mutation studies have focused to detect the genes responsible for HH.

MATERIAL/METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, 12 HH patients were recruited, who were referred to Firoozgar Hospital, Tehran, Iran. In addition to the clinical assessments, a complete laboratory evaluation, imaging modalities, histopathologic assessment, atomic absorption spectrophotometry and gene mutation study were performed. The genetic study for HFE gene mutation was examined for all of the patients since 2006, while non-HFE mutation was conducted since December 2010 (only for 1 of them).

RESULTS

Twelve patients were evaluated consisting of 11 men and 1 woman, with the mean age of 39.58±12.68 yr. The average of atomic iron loads was 13.25±4.83-fold higher than normal standards. Four patients had heterozygotic mutation of H63D (33.3%). There was no significant difference in either the iron load of liver (P=0.927) and heart (P=0.164) or serum concentration of ferritin (P=0.907) and TIBC (P=0.937) between the HFE-mutant and without HFE mutation HH cases.

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to other studies, C282Y mutation was not detected in any of our Iranian HH patients. Heterozygotic mutations of H63D (HFE) and TFR2 (non-HFE) genes were found to be more common in these patients. Similar to previous reports, these mutations were not found to be significantly associated with severity of presentation in HH patients.

Hereditary hemochromatosis and diabetes mellitus: implications for clinical practice

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is a genetic condition that can lead to unregulated absorption of iron from the gut with resultant iron overload. The most common form of HH is caused by mutations in the HFE gene, with most cases of HH presenting in patients who are homozygous for the Cys282Tyr mutation. The prevalence of HFE gene mutations in persons of Northern European ancestry is fairly high (0.3-0.7% homozygous and 9-14% heterozygous for the Cys282Tyr mutation), but the penetrance of the disease is considered fairly low and is quite variable. While routine screening of the general population is not recommended, a targeted approach to screening in symptomatic patients and in those with a family member with iron overload is warranted. Untreated, iron overload can lead to considerable morbidity including liver cirrhosis, arthritis and diabetes mellitus, and increased mortality. The pathophysiology of diabetes mellitus in HH is thought to be due primarily to defects in the early insulin response to glucose. An Hfe(-/-) mouse model of HH has demonstrated defects in beta-cell function and beta-cell apoptosis that may be mediated by increased oxidative stress. Fortunately, these defects seem to be reversible if phlebotomy treatment is initiated before the development of cirrhosis or diabetes mellitus in patients. Further research into the long-term effects of treatment on prevention of diabetes mellitus in HH is needed.

UGT1A1 gene polymorphism as a potential factor inducing iron overload in the pathogenesis of type 1 hereditary hemochromatosis

Aim Hereditary hemochromatosis is a common genetic disorder characterized by iron overload and subsequent organ damage. It is caused in most cases by HFE gene mutations which penetrance can be affected by many factors. The aim of this study was to establish the role of UGT1A1 gene polymorphism and serum bilirubin concentration in the pathogenesis of hereditary hemochromatosis. Methods Biochemical, histopathological and genetic data indicating iron excess and serum total bilirubin concentration were determined in 32 patients with the type 1 hereditary hemochromatosis. Fluorescent molecular probes assays were used for genotyping of UGT1A1*28 and UGT1A1*60 mutations in these individuals. Results High incidence and a significant correlation of UGT1A1 gene mutations with increased serum bilirubin level and lower grades of liver tissue inflammatory activity were observed in study participants. UGT1A1*28 and UGT1A1*60 mutations were strongly linked together. Two of the subjects presented very rare genotypes of UGT1A1 gene: (TA)(5/7) and c.-64G>C heterozygotes. Conclusions UGT1A1 gene polymorphism and as its consequence of high serum bilirubin level may promote iron accumulation in hemochromatosis patients by reducing the activity of inflammation. We proposed a possible mechanism of this interaction.

Increased capacity of lymphocytes from hereditary hemochromatosis patients homozygous for the C282Y HFE mutation to respond to the genotoxic effect of diepoxybutane

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is a common autosomal recessive disorder characterized by systemic iron overload with consequent tissue damage. The vast majority of HH patients are homozygous for the C282Y mutation in HFE, a non-classical MHC class-I gene located in chromosome 6, whose role in the regulation of systemic iron metabolism is still not completely understood. Iron enhances the formation of reactive oxygen species, with increasing risk of DNA damage induced by oxidative stress, and consequently an increased susceptibility to chromosome instability. In the present work we examined spontaneous and diepoxybutane (DEB)-induced chromosome instability in PHA-stimulated lymphocyte cultures from 23 HH patients, all homozygous for the C282Y HFE mutation, in comparison to 29 normal controls. In addition, three patients with secondary forms of iron overload, not related to HFE, were studied as controls to test the role of iron overload on DEB-induced chromosome instability. Our results show a significantly higher frequency of spontaneous chromosome breaks in lymphocytes from the HH patients, when compared with lymphocytes from normal controls (p<0.0001). In addition, there is a significant correlation between the percentage of cells with spontaneous chromosomal breaks and the transferrin saturation (r=0.53, p=0.0041) or serum-ferritin levels (r=0.66, p=0.0001) in patients. Surprisingly, the frequency of DEB-induced chromosome breaks was significantly lower in lymphocytes from HH patients than in lymphocytes from both controls and patients with secondary forms of hemochromatosis (p=0.0029). No correlation was observed between the percentage of cells with DEB-induced chromosome breaks and the transferrin saturation or serum-ferritin values. These results suggest that lymphocytes from HH patients may have an increased capacity to respond to DEB-induced chromosome breakage, and that this capacity is somehow related to the presence of the C282Y HFE mutation.

Results communication and patient education after screening for possible hemochromatosis and iron overload: experience from the HEIRS Study of a large ethnically and linguistically diverse group

PURPOSE

We assessed the effectiveness of educational interventions for conveying clinical findings and information about hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) and iron overload (IO) to individuals evaluated clinically after initial screening for HH/IO with serum ferritin (SF) concentration, transferrin saturation (TS), and HFE genotyping.

METHODS

A questionnaire mailed to 2300 cases and controls 1 month after a letter summarizing clinical findings measured understanding of results and recommendations, knowledge of HH/IO, and satisfaction with information received.

RESULTS

Of 1622 (70.5%) participants completing relevant items, 83.6% were satisfied with receiving initial screening results by mail, 93.4% found information clear and easy to understand, 89.2% generally felt they got enough information, but 47.5% still had questions. C282Y/C282Y homozygosity with normal TS/SF predicted the best understanding of genetic results. Many with no mutations thought relatives were at risk. Iron levels created most confusion, and a third incorrectly recalled treatment recommendations. Having any abnormal result, lower education, older age, and being non-white, and/or non-English speaking predicted lower understanding.

CONCLUSIONS

Combining genotypic and phenotypic screening for HH/IO creates additional difficulties in communicating results-particularly to those with low health literacy. Explaining aberrant iron TS and SF levels and low-risk genotypes, follow-up recommendations, and risk to relatives will need creative, culturally appropriate strategies.

Prevalence of Three Hereditary Hemochromatosis Mutant Alleles in the Michigan Caucasian Population

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the prevalence in the Michigan non-Hispanic Caucasian population of the C282Y, H63D and S65C mutations in the HFE gene associated with hereditary hemochromatosis.

METHODS

Polymerase chain reaction and restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis were performed on 3,532 blood samples from newborn screening cards provided by the state of Michigan.

RESULTS

More than 30% of Michigan Caucasians carry one HFE mutation, while 6% have two mutations. The allele frequency of the C282Y mutation is 5.7%, significantly higher than expected (p < 0.05), while the frequency of the H63D mutation is 14%, significantly lower than expected (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first publication to examine HFE allele frequencies in an unbiased sample of the Caucasian population. Results indicate that the C282Y mutation may be more common in the non-Hispanic Caucasian population than previously reported, and medical problems related to iron overload may be a health concern for Michigan non-Hispanic Caucasians. Additional studies of penetrance for the C282Y allele are required to fully understand the impact of this information.

Factors affecting the uptake of screening: a randomised controlled non-inferiority trial comparing a genotypic and a phenotypic strategy for screening for haemochromatosis

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Haemochromatosis provides an example where a novel pragmatic genotypic screening strategy may be compared with a phenotypic strategy assessing factors affecting uptake, feasibility and cost.

METHODS

A randomised controlled 'non-inferiority' trial testing the hypothesis that the uptake of testing in the genotypic strategy would not be inferior to the uptake in a phenotypic screening strategy. Three thousand individuals aged 30-70 were randomly selected and randomly allocated (stratified by age and sex) to one of two screening strategies. Phenotypic-transferrin saturation on blood sample taken at GP surgery or genotypic-saliva sample taken at home; followed in screen positive individuals with assessment of iron status and genotyping.

RESULTS

The difference in uptake between the two strategies was 3.4% (95% CI=0.5-6.8). Uptake was low (32%) and least in young men from socially deprived areas. Phenotypic screening was least costly.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, investigating the uptake of screening for a treatable disease in primary care, the uptake of screening with the genotypic strategy was not inferior to that in the phenotypic strategy. The poor uptake in younger men would further limit the effectiveness of screening for haemochromatosis and may have implications for other screening programmes targeted to this group.

Impact of HFE genetic testing on clinical presentation of hereditary hemochromatosis: new epidemiological data

Background

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is a common inherited disorder of iron metabolism in Northern European populations. The discovery of a candidate gene in 1996 (HFE), and of its main mutation (C282Y), has radically altered the way to diagnose this disease. The aim of this study was to assess the impact of the HFE gene discovery on the clinical presentation and epidemiology of HH.

Methods

We studied our cohort of 415 patients homozygous for the C282Y allele and included in a phlebotomy program in a blood centre in western Brittany, France.

Results

In this cohort, 56.9% of the patients were male and 21.9% began their phlebotomy program before the implementation of the genetic test. A significant decrease in the sex ratio was noticed following implementation of this DNA test, from 3.79 to 1.03 (p < 10^-5), meaning that the proportion of diagnosed females relatives to males greatly increased. The profile of HH patients at diagnosis changed after the DNA test became available. Serum ferritin and iron values were lower and there was a reduced frequency of clinical signs displayed at diagnosis, particularly skin pigmentation (20.1 vs. 40.4%, OR = 0.37, p < 0.001) and hepatomegaly (11.0 vs. 22.7%, OR = 0.42, p = 0.006). In contrast, fatigue became a more common symptom at diagnosis (68.0 vs. 51.2%, OR = 2.03, p = 0.004).

Conclusion

This study highlights the importance of the HFE gene discovery, which has simplified the diagnosis of HH and modified its clinical presentation and epidemiology. This study precisely measures these changes. Enhanced diagnosis of HFE-related HH at an early stage and implementation of phlebotomy treatment are anticipated to maintain normal life expectancy for these patients.

Population genetic screening programmes: principles, techniques, practices, and policies

This paper examines the professional and scientific views on the principles, techniques, practices, and policies that impact on the population genetic screening programmes in Europe. This paper focuses on the issues surrounding potential screening programmes, which require further discussion before their introduction. It aims to increase, among the health-care professions and health policy-makers, awareness of the potential screening programmes as an issue of increasing concern to public health. The methods comprised primarily the review of the existing professional guidelines, regulatory frameworks and other documents related to population genetic screening programmes in Europe. Then, the questions that need debate, in regard to different types of genetic screening before and after birth, were examined. Screening for conditions such as cystic fibrosis, Duchenne muscular dystrophy, familial hypercholesterolemia, fragile X syndrome, hemochromatosis, and cancer susceptibility was discussed. Special issues related to genetic screening were also examined, such as informed consent, family aspects, commercialization, the players on the scene and monitoring genetic screening programmes. Afterwards, these questions were debated by 51 experts from 15 European countries during an international workshop organized by the European Society of Human Genetics Public and Professional Policy Committee in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 19-20, November, 1999. Arguments for and against starting screening programmes have been put forward. It has been questioned whether genetic screening differs from other types of screening and testing in terms of ethical issues. The general impression on the future of genetic screening is that one wants to 'proceed with caution', with more active impetus from the side of patients' organizations and more reluctance from the policy-makers. The latter try to obviate the potential problems about the abortion and eugenics issues that might be perceived as a greater problem than it is in reality. However, it seems important to maintain a balance between a 'professional duty of care' and 'personal autonomy'.

Hemochromatosis mutations in the general population: iron overload progression rate

The progression rate of iron overload in hereditary hemochromatosis in individuals in the general population is unknown. We therefore examined in the general population iron overload progression rate in C282Y homozygotes. Using a cohort study of the Danish general population, The Copenhagen City Heart Study, we genotyped 9174 individuals. The 23 C282Y homozygotes identified were matched to 2 subjects each of 5 other HFE genotypes with respect to sex, age, and alcohol consumption. As a function of biologic age, transferrin saturation increased from 50% to 70% from 25 to 85 years of age and from 70% to 80% from 35 to 80 years of age in female and male C282Y homozygotes, respectively. Equivalently, ferritin levels increased from 100 to 500 microg/L and decreased from 800 to 400 microg/L in female and male C282Y homozygotes. As a function of 25 years follow-up irrespective of age, transferrin saturation and ferritin levels increased slightly in male and female C282Y homozygotes. None of the C282Y homozygotes developed clinically overt hemochromatosis. In conclusion, individuals in the general population with C282Y homozygosity at most demonstrate modest increases in transferrin saturation and ferritin levels, and clinically overt hemochromatosis is rare. Therefore, C282Y homozygotes identified during population screening, and not because of clinically overt hemochromatosis, at most need to be screened for manifestations of hemochromatosis every 10 to 20 years.

Hereditary hemochromatosis: perspectives of public health, medical genetics, and primary care

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HHC) is a condition characterized by excess iron in body tissues, resulting in complications such as cirrhosis, cardiomyopathy, diabetes, and arthritis. These complications usually manifest during adulthood. Two methods of screening for the detection of early stage of HHC are available: serum iron measures and molecular testing to detect mutations in the gene. These phenotypic and genotypic screening tests are of particular interest because a simple treatment-periodic phlebotomy-can be used to prevent iron accumulation and clinical complications. HHC might represent the first adult-onset genetic disorder for which universal population-based screening would be appropriate. Therefore, HHC has been proposed as a paradigm for the introduction of adult genetic diseases into clinical and public health practice. However, universal screening for HHC has not been recommended because of the uncertainty about the natural history of the iron overload or HHC and, in particular, uncertainty about the prevalence of asymptomatic iron overload and the likelihood that it will progress to clinical complications. If universal screening is not appropriate based on current data, what other measures might reduce the disease burden of iron overload? New studies provide more systematic information about the penetrance of the C282Y mutation and shed further light on the natural history of the disorder. The authors review these data and consider their implications for public health, medical genetics, and primary care.

Public health aspects of genetic screening for hereditary haemochromatosis in Australia

Hereditary haemochromatosis (HH) is an inherited disorder of iron absorption. It meets several of the key public health principles for population-based screening and is considered to be a test-case for public health genetics. However, there has been relatively little debate in the public health or wider community regarding the merits of population-based genetic screening for HH. Genetic susceptibility to HH occurs in about 1:200 people and although mortality is low (age-standardised rate 2.75/million), there are potentially serious clinical manifestations of iron overload. Regular venesection is a simple and effective treatment for early stage iron overload. DNA-based testing is available and iron overload may be identified using serum transferrin saturation and ferritin tests. However, there are important gaps in knowledge relevant to screening for HH. The limited data on penetrance of HFE genotypes, and thus the uncertain probability that genetically susceptible individuals will develop clinically significant disease, is a major impediment to population-based genetic screening. Clinical evidence supports treating early-stage disease but no randomised controlled trials of the effectiveness of screening in reducing the burden of disease have been conducted. In addition, the natural history of early stages of HH and factors that may modify progression are unclear. Two intemational consensus panels on HH concluded that there is insufficient evidence for population-based screening at present. We present recommendations to advance the debate on screening for HH in Australia.

Genetic testing for HFE hemochromatosis in Australia: the value of testing relatives of simple heterozygotes

BACKGROUND

It is unclear whether screening of relatives of C282Y and H63D heterozygotes (other than compound heterozygotes) for hemochromatosis will detect sufficient numbers of cases to justify introduction of this screening strategy.

METHODS

Conditional probabilities were determined using published Australian allele frequencies and penetrance data to determine the detection rate of hemochromatosis by testing the siblings and offspring of heterozygotes (subjects with only one HFE mutation).

RESULTS

The number of individuals who are at risk of developing increased body iron stores because of HFE mutations is substantially higher (1 in 80) than previously estimated. In addition, 33% of the Australian population are heterozygous for either C282Y or H63D. Based on population estimates, the relative risk to the offspring of C282Y and H63D heterozygotes of developing increased iron stores is 4.1 and 1.5, respectively, while the relative risk to each sibling is 2.3 and 1, respectively. The risk of developing clinical features of hemochromatosis or hepatic fibrosis is likely to be substantially lower.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the detection rate from testing the families of unaffected heterozygotes is low, this can be justified as a clinically useful screening strategy. At the present time this strategy should be restricted to first-degree relatives of heterozygotes. Further studies are recommended to determine if cascade genetic screening is a cost-effective alternative to general population screening.

Prevalence of hemochromatosis-related symptoms among individuals with mutations in the HFE gene

OBJECTIVE

To determine the prevalence of hemochromatosis-related symptoms in homozygotes for the HFE mutation C282Y compared with controls without HFE mutations identified through a large screening program of subjects attending a health appraisal center.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Presence of symptoms commonly associated with clinical hemochromatosis was ascertained by self-report on a written questionnaire among C282Y homozygotes and HFE wild-type subjects of white or Hispanic ethnicity identified from screening 41,599 adult subjects between March 1999 and August 2001. A subset of C282Y homozygotes and wild-type subjects identified from 12,756 subjects attending the center in the final year of the study completed a standardized double-blind interview with a physician regarding the presence, duration, and severity of a larger set of symptoms. Prevalence of symptoms among C282Y homozygotes and wild-type controls ascertained by written questionnaire and interview were compared by chi2 analysis or Fisher exact test. Symptoms among subjects with other combinations of the C282Y and H63D HFE mutations were also assessed by questionnaire.

RESULTS

The 124 C282Y homozygotes who filled out the written questionnaire and the 17 C282Y homozygotes who completed the physician double-blind interview reported no significantly higher rates of arthritis or joint pain, abdominal pain, arrhythmias, darkening of skin, or other symptoms traditionally associated with hemochromatosis compared with the 22,429 wild-type controls who filled out the written questionnaire and 29 wild-type controls who completed the double-blind interview. The only symptom reported more frequently by C282Y homozygotes was loss of body hair, reported by 5 C282Y/C282Y female subjects compared with 1 wild-type male subject (P=.02) in the physician interview. Symptoms among subjects with other HFE genotypes were similar to symptoms of wild-type subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

Results of this study indicate that many of the symptoms associated with hemochromatosis are common among HFE wild types and that clinical penetrance of the C282Y/C282Y genotype in regard to these symptoms is low.

Penetrance of 845G--> A (C282Y) HFE hereditary haemochromatosis mutation in the USA

BACKGROUND

There has been much interest in screening populations for disease-associated mutations. A favoured candidate has been the HFE gene, mutations of which are the most common cause of haemochromatosis in the European population. About five people in 1000 are homozygotes for the 845G-->A mutation, but little is known of how many have mutation-caused clinical manifestations.

METHODS

We screened 41038 individuals attending a health appraisal clinic in the USA for the 845G--> A and 187C-->G HFE mutations, and analysed laboratory data and data on signs and symptoms of haemochromatosis as elicited by questionnaire.

FINDINGS

The most common symptoms of haemochromatosis, including poor general health, diabetes, arthropathies, arrhythmias, impotence, and skin pigmentation were no more prevalent among the 152 identified homozygotes than among the controls. The age distribution of homozygotes and compound heterozygotes did not differ significantly from that of controls: there was no measurable loss of such individuals from the population during ageing. However, there was a significantly increased prevalence of a history of hepatitis or "liver trouble" among homozygotes and in the proportion of homozygotes with increased concentrations of serum aspartate aminotransferase and collagen IV; these changes were not related to iron burden or to age. Only one of the 152 homozygotes had signs and symptoms that would suggest a diagnosis of haemochromatosis.

INTERPRETATION

The normal age distribution of people with the haemochromatosis genotype, and the lack of symptoms in patients of all ages, indicate that the penetrance of hereditary haemochromatosis is much lower than generally thought. The clinical penetrance of a disorder is an essential consideration in screening for genetic disease; disorders with low penetrance are more expensive candidates for screening than disorders with high penetrance. Our best estimate is that less than 1% of homozygotes develop frank clinical haemochromatosis.

Screening for hemochromatosis

BACKGROUND

Hereditary hemochromatosis is the most common autosomal recessive disorder in populations of northern European descent.

ISSUES

Many experts consider hemochromatosis to be an almost ideal disease for population screening because it essentially fulfills almost all the criteria for screening proposed by the WHO. However, others disagree and suggest that more data are required particularly with regard to the natural history and penetrance of the disease. There is also disagreement about the best diagnostic/screening test for the disease and the performance of these tests in the context of screening. Other concerns are the variability and lack of standardization in screening test measurements, the selection of screening threshold values and the identification of false positive cases. The advent of a genetic test for the condition has brought other worries with regard to informed consent and the ethical, legal and social implications of screening particularly in relation to medical and general discrimination. Other important issues include compliance, cost effectiveness and the evidence that screening has lessened the burden of disease in the community.

CONCLUSIONS

At the present time, we believe that further data regarding both the exact disease burden and the outcomes of screening studies particularly in the general community are required before widespread population screening is introduced.

Estimating the efficacy and efficiency of cascade genetic screening

Screening for genetic variants that predispose individuals or their offspring to disease may be performed at the general population level or may instead be targeted at the relatives of previously identified carriers. The latter strategy has come to be known as "cascade genetic screening." Since the carrier risk of close relatives of known carriers is generally higher than the population risk, cascade screening is more efficient than population screening, in the sense that fewer individuals have to be genotyped per detected carrier. The efficacy of cascade screening, as measured by the overall proportion of carriers detected in a given population, is, however, lower than that of population-wide screening, and the respective inclusion rates vary according to the population frequency and mode of inheritance of the predisposing variants. For dominant mutations, we have developed equations that allow the inclusion rates of cascade screening to be calculated in an iterative fashion, depending upon screening depth and penetrance. For recessive mutations, we derived only equations for the screening of siblings and the children of patients. Owing to their mathematical complexity, it was necessary to study more extended screening strategies by simulation. Cascade screening turned out to result in low inclusion rates (<1%) when aimed at the identification of heterozygous carriers of rare recessive variants. Considerably higher rates are achievable, however, when screening is performed to detect covert homozygotes for frequent recessive mutations with reduced penetrance. This situation is exemplified by hereditary hemochromatosis, for which up to 40% of at-risk individuals may be identifiable through screening of first- to third-degree relatives of overt carriers (i.e., patients); the efficiency of this screening strategy was found to be approximately 50 times higher than that of population-wide screening. For dominant mutations, inclusion rates of cascade screening were estimated to be higher than for recessive variants. Thus, some 80% of all carriers of the factor V Leiden mutation would be detected if screening were to be targeted specifically at first- to third-degree relatives of patients with venous thrombosis. The relative cost efficiency of cascade as compared with population-wide screening (i.e., the overall savings in the extra managerial cost of the condition) is also likely to be higher for dominant than for recessive mutations. This notwithstanding, once screening has become cost-effective at the population level, it can be expected that cascade screening would only transiently represent an economically viable option.

Clinical and genetic heterogeneity in hereditary haemochromatosis: association between lymphocyte counts and expression of iron overload

To identify a new marker of expression of disease, independent of HFE genotype in patients with hereditary haemochromatosis (HHC), the total peripheral blood lymphocyte counts were analysed according to iron status in two groups of subjects with HFE mutations. The groups consisted of 38 homozygotes for C282Y, and 107 heterozygotes for the C282Y or compound heterozygotes for C282Y and H63D. For control purposes, total lymphocyte counts and iron status were also examined in 20 index patients with African dietary iron overload, a condition not associated with HFE mutations, and in 144 members of their families and communities. Mean lymphocyte numbers were lower in C282Y homozygous HHC index subjects with cirrhosis and higher iron stores than in those without cirrhosis and with lower iron burdens [(1.65 +/- 0.43) x 10(6)/mL vs. (2.27 +/- 0.49) x 10(6)/mL; p = 0.008]. Similarly, mean lymphocyte counts were significantly lower in C282Y heterozygotes and C282Y/H63D compound heterozygotes with iron overload and increased serum ferritin concentrations compared to those with normal serum ferritin concentrations (p < 0.05). Statistically significant negative correlations were found, in males, between lymphocyte counts and the total body iron stores, either in C282Y homozygous HHC patients (p = 0.031 in a multiple regression model dependent on age) and in C282Y heterozygotes or C282Y/H63D compound heterozygotes with iron overload (p = 0.029 in a simple linear model). In contrast, lymphocyte counts increased with increasing serum ferritin concentrations among the index subjects with African iron overload (r = 0.324, not statistically significant) and among the members of their families and communities (r = 0.170, p = 0.042). These results suggest that a lower peripheral blood lymphocyte count is associated with a greater degree of iron loading in HFE haemochromatosis but not in African iron overload, and they support the notion that the lymphocyte count may serve as a marker of a non-HFE gene that influences the clinical expression of HFE haemochromatosis.

The roles of iron in health and disease

Iron is vital for almost all living organisms by participating in a wide variety of metabolic processes, including oxygen transport, DNA synthesis, and electron transport. However, iron concentrations in body tissues must be tightly regulated because excessive iron leads to tissue damage, as a result of formation of free radicals. Disorders of iron metabolism are among the most common diseases of humans and encompass a broad spectrum of diseases with diverse clinical manifestations, ranging from anemia to iron overload and, possibly, to neurodegenerative diseases. The molecular understanding of iron regulation in the body is critical in identifying the underlying causes for each disease and in providing proper diagnosis and treatments. Recent advances in genetics, molecular biology and biochemistry of iron metabolism have assisted in elucidating the molecular mechanisms of iron homeostasis. The coordinate control of iron uptake and storage is tightly regulated by the feedback system of iron responsive element-containing gene products and iron regulatory proteins that modulate the expression levels of the genes involved in iron metabolism. Recent identification and characterization of the hemochromatosis protein HFE, the iron importer Nramp2, the iron exporter ferroportin1, and the second transferrin-binding and -transport protein transferrin receptor 2, have demonstrated their important roles in maintaining body's iron homeostasis. Functional studies of these gene products have expanded our knowledge at the molecular level about the pathways of iron metabolism and have provided valuable insight into the defects of iron metabolism disorders. In addition, a variety of animal models have implemented the identification of many genetic defects that lead to abnormal iron homeostasis and have provided crucial clinical information about the pathophysiology of iron disorders. In this review, we discuss the latest progress in studies of iron metabolism and our current understanding of the molecular mechanisms of iron absorption, transport, utilization, and storage. Finally, we will discuss the clinical presentations of iron metabolism disorders, including secondary iron disorders that are either associated with or the result of abnormal iron accumulation.

Contribution of different HFE genotypes to iron overload disease: a pooled analysis

PURPOSE

To determine the contribution of the C282Y and H63D mutations in the HFE gene to clinical expression of hereditary hemochromatosis.

METHODS

Pooled analysis of 14 case-control studies reporting HFE genotype data, to evaluate the association of different HFE genotypes with iron overload. In addition, we used data from the pooled analysis and published data to estimate the penetrance of the C282Y/C282Y genotype.

RESULTS

Homozygosity for the C282Y mutation carried the largest risk for iron overload (OR = 4383, 95% CI 1374 to >10,000) and accounted for the majority of hemochromatosis cases (attributable fraction (AF) = 0.73). Risks for other genotypes were much smaller: OR = 32 for genotype C282Y/H63D (95% CI 18.5 to 55.4, AF = 0.06); OR = 5.7 for H63D/H63D (95% CI 3.2 to 10.1, AF = 0.01); OR = 4.1 for C282Y heterozygosity (95% CI 2.9 to 5.8, with heterogeneity in study results, making this association uncertain); and OR = 1.6 for H63D heterozygosity (95% CI 1 to 2.6, AF = 0.03). Estimates of penetrance for the C282Y/C282Y genotype were highly sensitive to estimates of the prevalence of iron overload disease. At a prevalence of 2.5 per 1000 or less, penetrance of the C282Y/C282Y genotype is unlikely to exceed 50%. Penetrance of other HFE genotypes is much lower.

CONCLUSIONS

C282Y homozygosity confers the highest risk for iron overload but the H63D mutation is also associated with increased risk. Our data indicate a gradient of risk associated with different HFE genotypes and thus suggest the presence of other modifiers, either genetic or environmental, that contribute to the clinical expression of hemochromatosis.

Hereditary hemochromatosis: impact of molecular and iron-based testing on the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of a common, chronic disease

OBJECTIVE

To review the current state-of-the-art regarding the role of iron- and DNA-based testing on the detection, treatment, and prevention of hereditary hemochromatosis (HH), the most common single-gene disorder in white people.

SOURCES

Review of the medical literature, with particular emphasis on recent reports of the impact of DNA-based testing on the detection of symptomatic and presymptomatic patients with HH.

CONCLUSIONS

Hereditary hemochromatosis, a common autosomal recessive iron overload disorder (with a population prevalence of 0.3%-0.8%), is a common cause of preventable liver, heart, joint, and endocrine disease. Since the associated clinical signs and symptoms are nonspecific, an accurate HH diagnosis demands both a high index of suspicion and the direct laboratory demonstration of elevated iron parameters. The substantial public health burden of HH as a common, deadly, detectable, and treatable chronic disease has led the College of American Pathologists to recommend that "systematic screening for hemochromatosis is warranted for all persons over the age of 20 years." The recent discovery that most HH cases are the result of a single well-conserved homozygous missense mutation (C282Y) within a novel transferrin-receptor binding protein (HFE) has given rise to diagnostic clinical tests for the DNA-based detection of this pathologic mutation. This direct HFE mutation test can now be used not only to confirm the diagnosis of HH in those with symptomatic disease, but also, perhaps more importantly, to detect those with presymptomatic iron overload in whom future disease manifestations may be prevented (with phlebotomy therapy).

Screening for hereditary hemochromatosis: are DNA-based tests the answer?

Universal screening for hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) has been proposed by many experts, with understandable enthusiasm: HH can cause fatal complications, which are preventable with early treatment. The disorder involves excess iron accumulation that can result in tissue iron overload, with secondary cirrhosis, diabetes, heart failure, impotence and arthritis. These complications are preceded by years of iron accumulation, and most are believed to be preventable by removal of excess iron by phlebotomy. Thus, early identification and treatment - the quintessential functions of health screening - seem to make sense for HH. However, the available screening tests are imperfect. While they can identify many persons at increased risk from HH, the proportion that will develop serious clinical manifestations related to iron overload is not known with certainty. DNA-based tests do not provide a simple resolution to these questions.

Population-based screening for hemochromatosis using phenotypic and DNA testing among employees of health maintenance organizations in Springfield, Missouri

BACKGROUND

Hemochromatosis reportedly affects 3 to 8 persons per 1,000 and is associated with an elevated risk of morbidity and mortality. We sought to ascertain its prevalence in a community and to assess the association between phenotype and genotype.

METHODS

All health maintenance organization employees were invited to participate in hemochromatosis screening using a repeated elevation of the transferrin saturation test as the case definition (> or = 50% in women and > or = 60% in men with no other cause). Iron overload from hemochromatosis was defined as serum ferritin concentration > or = 95th percentile and mobilizable iron > or = 99th percentile for age and sex, or hepatic iron index > or = 1.9. The HFE gene was analyzed for mutations.

RESULTS

Participation among employees was 28% (1,653 of 6,000); 83% were women. The prevalence of hemochromatosis was 8 per 1,000 (13 of 1,653), and the prevalence of iron overload from hemochromatosis was 4 per 1,000 (5 of 1,653). Compared with those who had no HFE mutation, the relative risk (RR) for hemochromatosis was greatest for C282Y homozygotes (RR = 147), compound heterozygotes (RR = 19), and H63D homozygotes (RR = 9). Overall, 38% of participants had at least one HFE mutation. Screening based on an initial elevated transferrin saturation test had the best sensitivity, whereas DNA testing offered the best specificity and predictive value positive for iron overload disease.

CONCLUSIONS

In this population, we found a greater than expected prevalence of hemochromatosis and demonstrated a clear association with the HFE genotype. Promotion of screening is complicated by controversies in case definition and the large number of persons who will be detected before they have clinically significant iron loading, in whom the risk of clinical disease is unknown. Larger screening studies in more diverse populations are necessary to characterize the burden of disease and to follow those at risk (based on HFE or iron status measures) to establish the natural history of hemochromatosis.

A survey of 2,851 patients with hemochromatosis: symptoms and response to treatment

PURPOSE

Hemochromatosis is a genetic disorder of iron absorption that affects 5 per 1,000 persons and is associated with reduced health and quality of life. We sought to determine the type and frequency of symptoms that patients experienced before the diagnosis and the treatments that they received.

METHODS

We mailed a questionnaire to 3,562 patients with hemochromatosis who were located using patient advocacy groups, physicians, blood centers, newsletters, and the Internet.

RESULTS

Of the 2,851 respondents, 99% were white and 62% were men. Circumstances that led to diagnosis of hemochromatosis included symptoms (35%), an abnormal laboratory test (45%), and diagnosis of a family member with hemochromatosis (20%). The mean (+/- SD) age of symptom onset was 41 +/- 14 years. Symptoms had been present for an average of 10 +/- 10 years before the diagnosis was made. Among the 58% of patients with symptoms, 65% had physician-diagnosed arthritis and 52% had liver disease. The most common and troublesome symptoms were extreme fatigue (46%), arthralgia (44%), and loss of libido (26%). Physician instructions to patients included treatment with phlebotomy (90%), testing family members (75%), and avoiding iron supplements (65%).

CONCLUSIONS

The diagnosis of hemochromatosis in most patients was delayed. Physician education is needed to increase the detection of patients with the disease and to improve its management.

Screening for hemochromatosis. A public health perspective

CONTEXT

The discovery of the HFE gene in 1996 has introduced DNA testing as a possible tool for screening and diagnosis of hemochromatosis and increased interest in the disorder. Population screening using transferrin saturation has been advocated by experts to permit early detection and treatment with phlebotomy before the onset of clinical disease.

METHODS

Based on a literature review, we consider the relative risks and merits of two screening tests as part of a broader look at the evidence required for the recommendation of universal screening for hemochromatosis.

RESULTS

Several questions must be answered before universal screening can be recommended. Uncertainties remain about the penetrance and preventable disease burden, laboratory standardization, and optimal strategies to minimize potential risks of screening for hemochromatosis.

CONCLUSIONS

As a common genetic disorder with simple, effective therapy, hemochromatosis offers a model for other genetically influenced chronic diseases that some day may have interventions to improve prognosis. Resolution of questions related to prevention of chronic diseases from hemochromatosis, therefore, will have broad usefulness in the future.

Hereditary hemochromatosis. Preventing chronic effects of this underdiagnosed disorder

Hereditary hemochromatosis, once thought to be rare, is the most common genetic disorder in the United States. Nonetheless, the condition often goes undetected and untreated until its severe effects have become apparent. What clues can lead you to the diagnosis, and how can you spot them in your patients, before significant morbidity has occurred? In this article, Drs McDonnell and Witte discuss the diagnosis and management of this underrecognized problem as well as the various issues involved in screening. An illustrative case of hemochromatosis is also included.

Population screening for haemochromatosis: expectations based on a study of relatives of symptomatic probands

OBJECTIVES

The frequency of symptomatic haemochromatosis in the general population and the potential efficacy of population screening is uncertain. Data from family members of clinically diagnosed index cases were used to estimate the frequency of the haemochromatosis genotype, the proportion of homozygous individuals with clinical manifestations, and the efficacy of transferrin saturation and serum ferritin measurements as screening tests.

SETTING

English language studies from Europe, North America, and Australia.

METHODS

Haemochromatosis zygosity was classified only by HLA haplotyping, the most reliable available method. All subsequent analyses were based on family members classified in this way.

RESULTS

An estimated 53 individuals per 10,000 are homozygous for haemochromatosis. Overall, 67% of male and 41% of female family members display at least one clinical manifestation; for men, the frequency increases with age. Transferrin saturation levels are 70% or above in an estimated 72% of homozygous men, along with three per 1000 heterozygous or unaffected men. Transferrin saturation levels are 60% or above in an estimated 67% of homozygous women, along with six per 1000 heterozygous or unaffected women. Serum ferritin levels, but not transferrin saturation levels, are associated with clinical manifestations.

CONCLUSIONS

This information can be used to compare expected versus actual screening performance for intervention trials aimed at detecting haemochromatosis in the general population.