Bone marrow iron scoring in healthy and clinically ill dogs with and without evidence of iron-restricted erythropoiesis

BACKGROUND

There are few reports in dogs that have evaluated the utility of semi-quantitative scoring of bone marrow iron stores in conjunction with reticulocyte hemoglobin (CHr) to identify iron-restricted erythropoiesis due to absolute iron deficiency or iron sequestration.

OBJECTIVES

An established system for scoring iron stores in human bone marrow samples was applied to dogs. The objectives were to evaluate interobserver agreement (Κ_ω ), determine marrow iron scores in dogs without detectable hematologic abnormalities, and assess combined interpretation of iron scores and CHr to evaluate for iron-restricted erythropoiesis.

METHODS

Four blinded observers independently scored iron in 139 Prussian blue-stained canine marrow samples from 0 (none) to 6 (very heavy), including healthy controls (n = 12), clinically ill dogs with (n = 100) and without (n = 16) detectable hematologic abnormalities, and dogs with experimental nutritional iron deficiency (n = 11). Additional medical record data were available for 118 dogs to evaluate for other evidence of iron deficiency (abnormal CHr, RBC indices, serum iron variables, external blood loss, or nutritional deficiencies).

RESULTS

Mean Κ_ω was 0.69 (substantial agreement) for all samples but was 0.44 (moderate agreement) for samples with iron scores <3, indicating distinguishing scores 0-2 may not be reliable. Dogs without detectable hematologic abnormalities had scores from 3-5. Dogs with scores <3 and decreased CHr often had more indicators of iron deficiency vs dogs only having low iron scores or low CHr.

CONCLUSIONS

Evaluation of dogs with marrow iron score <3 for external blood loss or nutritional deficiencies is likely clinically worthwhile, particularly if there is also decreased CHr.

Comparison of iron staining and scoring methods on canine bone marrow aspirates

BACKGROUND

Insufficient iron for erythropoiesis can occur in multiple conditions, including absolute iron deficiency, which is often caused by chronic external hemorrhage in dogs. Distinguishing this from other causes of iron-restricted erythropoiesis allows appropriate intervention. Decreased marrow iron assessed by Prussian blue staining is a method to diagnose absolute iron deficiency, but scoring systems for marrow iron are not validated in dogs.

OBJECTIVES

Our objectives were to (a) evaluate the technical performance of two bone marrow iron scoring systems used in human medicine and (b) examine the effects of destaining and restaining on iron stores after Wright-stained marrow slides are destained and restained with a Prussian blue stain.

METHODS

Two marrow aspirate slides were included from each of 12 ill dogs in which marrow was collected during clinical evaluation. One slide was directly stained with Prussian blue. The other was first stained with Wright stain, then destained and restained with Prussian blue. Three blinded observers scored the presence of iron in each of the 24 randomized slides using the Gale (scale 0-6) and sideroblast methods (percentage score). Slides were then re-randomized and rescored.

RESULTS

For the Gale method, interobserver agreement was fair, and intraobserver agreement was substantial to perfect. There was less agreement using the sideroblast method, with a significant observer effect. Iron scores were significantly lower in destained slides compared with those stained directly.

CONCLUSIONS

Interobserver and intraobserver agreements were acceptable for the Gale method, but the sideroblast method should be used cautiously. A destaining procedure before Prussian blue staining could decrease marrow iron scores.

The utility of diagnostic tests for immune-mediated hemolytic anemia

BACKGROUND

A definitive diagnosis of immune-mediated hemolytic anemia (IMHA) can be difficult to make. However, it is critical to differentiate IMHA from other causes of anemia due to the impact on prognosis and outcome for IMHA patients. Recently published American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine recommendations for the diagnosis of IMHA should be followed to concurrently confirm ongoing anemia, verify in vivo hemolysis, and detect anti-erythrocyte antibodies. The reliability of immunologic IMHA tests varies depending on which test is used and how it is performed.

OBJECTIVES

Our aims were to determine which tests are currently used in veterinary medicine to diagnose IMHA and review the utility of assays that have historically been used to diagnose IMHA.

METHODS

A short survey was designed to see which diagnostic tests for IMHA were currently being used by veterinary practices. The survey was distributed via list-serves to veterinarians and veterinary technologists. A literature review was performed to report the utility of diagnostic tests for the diagnosis of IMHA.

RESULTS

Survey respondents indicated a variability in test protocols used to diagnose IMHA. Most respondents perform saline agglutination or Coombs' tests to detect anti-erythrocyte antibodies. Additional tests that can be used to support a diagnosis of IMHA are discussed in this review.

CONCLUSIONS

A standardized diagnostic approach should be followed to differentiate IMHA from other causes of anemia. Test methodology can vary from one laboratory to another, and clinicians should be familiar with the procedures used by their laboratory.