Comparison of Outcomes in Patients With Generalized Ligamentous Laxity and Without Generalized Laxity in the Arthroscopic Modified Broström Operation for Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability

Arthroscopic Anterior Talofibular Ligament Repair Combined With All-Inside Suture Tape Augmentation for Treatment of Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability With Generalized Joint Laxity

BACKGROUND

To analyze the feasibility and clinical results of the modified Broström operation (MBO) combined with suture tape augmentation under arthroscopy for chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) in patients with generalized joint laxity (GJL).

METHODS

From October 2019 to October 2021, a total of 111 patients (111 ankles) treated with MBO combined with suture tape augmentation under arthroscope were retrospectively divided into a GJL group (29 patients) and a control group (82 patients). Mechanical stability of the affected ankle joint was evaluated radiographically preoperatively, at 6 months postoperatively, and the last follow-up. Complications and surgical failures, as well as visual analog scale (VAS) score, the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM), and the Karlsson score were also recorded. All statistical analyses were completed using SPSS 20.0.

RESULTS

The average follow-up time was 21.7 ± 5.2 months for the GJL group, and 20.9 ± 5.3 months for the control group. Pain and symptoms in both groups were effectively relieved by the procedure reflected by decreased VAS scores, improved FAAM and Karlsson scores at 6 months postoperatively, and the final follow-up (P < .05). Preoperative talar tilt angle and anterior talar translation were significantly greater in the GJL group than those in the control group (P < .05). Postoperatively, both talar tilt angle and anterior talar translation were reduced in both groups at 6 months postoperatively and the last follow-up (P < .05), and we found no significant difference between the two groups (P > .05). Furthermore, we found no significant difference in VAS, FAAM, and Karlsson scores between the 2 groups 6 months postoperatively and at the last follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Arthroscopic MBO combined with suture tape augmentation is a reliable procedure for treating CLAI with GJL. At short-term follow-up, we found that the GJL group achieved an equivalent level of stability compared with the control group.

Biomechanical improvement of anterior talofibular ligament by augmentation repair of ligament advance reinforcement system: a cadaver study

BACKGROUND

Ankle sprain are one of the most frequent sports injuries. Some individuals will develop chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) after ankle sprain and suffer from recurrent ankle sprain. Current surgical treatment of CAI with anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) rupture fails to restore the stability of the native ATFL. Ligament Advance Reinforcement System (LARS) augmentation repair of ATFL was developed to improve its primary stability after repaired.

METHODS

This study was performed to evaluate whether LARS augmentation repair of ATFL had similar stability as the modified Broström repair and the intact ATFL to maintain ankle construct stability. Standardized surgical techniques were performed on eighteen fresh frozen cadaver ankle specimens. The intact ATFL group has just undergone an ATFL exploratory surgery. The modified Broström procedure is based on anatomical repair of the ATFL with a 2.9 mm suture anchor, and the LARS procedure is an augmentation procedure of the ATFL using LARS ligaments based on the modified Broström procedure. A dynamic tensile test machine was used to assess load-to-failure testing in the three groups. The ultimate failure load and stiffness were calculated and reported from the load-displacement curve. A one-way analysis of variance was used to detect significant differences (p < 0.05) between the LARS augmentation repair, the modified Broström repair and the intact ATFL, followed by least significant difference (LSD) post-hoc tests.

RESULTS

The LARS augmentation repair group showed an increased in ultimate failure to load and stiffness compared to the other two groups. There were no significant differences in ultimate failure to load and stiffness between the modified Broström and the intact ATFL, the LARS ligament for ATFL augmentation allows for improved primary stability after repair and reduced stress on the repaired ATFL, which facilitates healing of the remnant ligament.

CONCLUSIONS

The LARS augmentation repair of ATFL represents a stable technique that may allow for the ankle stability to be restored in patients with CAI after surgery.

Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability: Can We Get Even Better with Surgical Treatment?

Lateral ligament attenuation may occur after repetitive ankle sprains, creating instability. Management of chronic ankle instability requires a comprehensive approach to mechanical and functional instability. Surgical treatment, however, is indicated when conservative treatment is not effective. Ankle ligament reconstruction is the most common surgical procedure to resolve mechanical instability. Anatomic open Broström-Gould reconstruction is the gold standard for repairing affected lateral ligaments and returning athletes to sports. Arthroscopy may also be beneficial for identifying associated injuries. In severe and long-standing instability, reconstruction with tendon augmentation could be necessary.

Current Definitions of Failure in Lateral Ankle Instability Surgery: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

"Failure" is a term that is frequently used to describe an unfavorable outcome for patients who undergo surgical treatment for lateral ankle instability (LAI). A standard definition of failure for the surgical treatment of ankle instability has not been established by clinicians and researchers.

PURPOSE

To identify the definitions of ankle instability treatment failure that are currently in the literature and to work toward the standardization of the definition.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

A systematic search of MEDLINE, SPORTDiscus, CINAHL, Embase, and Web of Science was conducted to identify clinical studies that included patients who underwent surgical treatment for LAI and included information about surgical failure. Studies with level of evidence 1 to 4 were included in this review. Animal studies, biomechanical studies, cadaveric studies, review articles, and expert opinions were excluded. The included studies were then reviewed for definitions of failure of any surgical procedure that was performed to correct LAI.

RESULTS

Of the 1200 studies found, 3.5% (42/1200) published between 1984 and 2021 met the inclusion criteria and were analyzed. After reviewing the data, we found numerous definitions were reported in the literature for LAI surgical failure. The most common was recurrent instability (40% [17/42]), followed by rerupture (19% [8/42]). For the original surgical procedure, the anatomic Broström-Gould technique was used most frequently (57% [24/42]). The failure rate of the Broström-Gould technique ranged from 1.1% to 45.2% depending on the definition of failure.

CONCLUSION

There were multiple definitions of failure for the surgical treatment of LAI, which is one of the reasons why the rate of failure can vary greatly. The literature would benefit greatly from the standardization of the definition of ankle instability treatment failure. This definition should include specific, objective physical examination findings that eliminate the ambiguity surrounding failure.

EFEITOS DO EXERCÍCIO DE REABILITAÇÃO ACELERADA DEPOIS DE TBM SOBRE A FUNÇÃO E A FORÇA NA INSTABILIDADE DO TORNOZELO

RESUMO Introdução: Os atletas de taekwondo com instabilidade lateral crônica do tornozelo (ILCT) podem apresentar dificuldades com propriocepção e força muscular do tornozelo. Depois da cirurgia, um programa de exercícios de reabilitação convencional pode ser ineficaz, porque a propriocepção ou a força muscular podem não se restaurar e, portanto, resultar em melhora mínima. Objetivos: Este estudo teve como objetivo avaliar os efeitos de um programa de ERA depois de TBM sobre a propriocepção, força isocinética e resistência do tornozelo. Métodos: Trinta atletas com diagnóstico de ILCT foram submetidos à TBM. Eles foram divididos em grupo ERA (n=15) e grupo controle CON (n = 15). O grupo ERA realizou exercícios ERA precoces seis vezes por semana durante 4 semanas. Os parâmetros aplicados para testar a força muscular do tornozelo foram velocidade angular de 30°/s e 180°/s (inversão: Inv e eversão: Eve, respectivamente). A propriocepção foi medida pela capacidade de sentir a posição articular de 15° de Inv e 5° de Eve Resultados: Foram observadas diferenças significativas entre os grupos ERA e CON na força do tornozelo 30°/s (Inv: p < 0,001, Eve: p < 0,001), 180°/s (Inv: p < 0,001, Eve: p < 0,001), e propriocepção a 15° (Inv: p < 0,001) e 5° (Eve: p < 0,001). Conclusões: Registramos efeitos de curto prazo significativos com ERA precoce em atletas de taekwondo com ILCT depois da TBM. Os resultados fornecem dados de referência para o reabilitador esportivo ou ATC (Certified athletic trainer) na avaliação da fase de reabilitação e informar os pacientes sobre as expectativas depois da TBM em termos de condições de desempenho e momento de retorno ao esporte. Nível de evidência III; Estudos terapêuticos – Investigação dos resultados do tratamento - Estudo de caso-controle.

EFFECTS OF ACCELERATED REHABILITATION EXERCISE AFTER MBO ON ANKLE FUNCTION AND STRENGTH IN ANKLE INSTABILITY

ABSTRACT Background: Taekwondo athletes with lateral chronic ankle instability (LCAI) may experience difficulties with proprioception and ankle muscle strength. After surgery, a conventional rehabilitation exercise program can be ineffective, as it may not restore proprioception or muscle strength and, thus, result in minimal improvement. Objective: This study aimed to assess the effects of an ARE program following MBO on the proprioception, isokinetic strength, and endurance of ankle. Methods: Thirty athletes diagnosed with LCAI underwent MBO. They were divided into the ARE group (n=15) and the control group (CON, n=15). The ARE group performed early ARE exercises six times per week for 4 weeks. The parameters applied to test ankle muscle strength were angular speed of 30°/sec and 180°/sec (inversion: Inv. and eversion: Eve., respectively). Proprioception was measured as being able to sense a joint position of 15° of Inv. and 5° of Eve. Results: Significant differences were observed between the ARE and CON groups in ankle strength 30°/sec (Inv.: p<0.001, Eve.: p<0.001), 180°/sec (Inv.: p<0.001, Eve.: p<0.001), and proprioception at 15° (Inv.: p<0.001) and 5° (Eve.: p<0.001). Conclusions: We recorded significant short-term effects from early ARE in Taekwondo athletes with LCAI after MBO. The results provide reference data for the sports rehabilitator or ATC in evaluating the rehabilitation phase and informing patients about expectations after MBO in terms of performance status and the timing of return to sports. Level of evidence III; Therapeutic studies–Investigation of treatment outcomes - Case-control Study.

Determining the Feasibility of Arthroscopic Anterior Talofibular Ligament Repair Utilizing a Novel Classification System

The purposes of this study were to classify anterior talofibular ligament injuries (ATFL), to find out the feasibility of arthroscopic ATFL repair according to injury type and to investigate the diagnostic validity of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of ATFL injuries by comparing MRI and arthroscopic findings. The 197 ankles (93 right, 104 left, and 12 bilateral) of 185 patients (90 men and 107 women; mean age, 33.5 years, range: 15-68 years) were treated by arthroscopic modified Broström procedure after a diagnosis of chronic lateral ankle instability. ATFL injuries were classified according to their grade and location (type P: partial rupture, type C1: fibular detachment, type C2: talar detachment, type C3: midsubstance rupture, type C4: absence of ATFL, type C5: os subfibulare). Among the 197 injured ankles, according to ankle arthroscopy, 67 were type P (34%), 28 were type C1 (14%), 13 were type C2 (7%), 29 were type C3 (15%), 26 were type C4 (13%), and 34 were type C5 (17%). The kappa value for the agreement between the arthroscopic findings and MRI findings was also high (0.85; 95% confidence interval, 0.79-0.91). Our results also supported the use of MRI for diagnosing ATFL injuries and showed that it is an informative tool during the preoperative period.

The anterior talofibular ligament ratio was greater in young men with generalized joint laxity than in those without generalized joint laxity

PURPOSE

This study aimed to evaluate the relationship between generalized joint laxity (GJL) and stress ultrasonographic (US) findings of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) of healthy young men.

METHODS

The ATFL lengths of healthy young men were consecutively measured in the stress and nonstress positions. The ATFL ratio was calculated as an indicator of lateral ankle laxity. GJL was evaluated using the Beighton score (BS), and a BS of ≥ 5 was considered GJL. The manual anterior drawer test (ADT) was also performed. The results of stress US and ADT were compared between subjects with and without GJL, and the correlation between GJL and US findings was examined.

RESULTS

A total of 13 subjects with GJL and 95 without GJL were included in the study. The mean BSs in the GJL and no-GJL groups were 5.9 ± 0.9 and 1.1 ± 1.3, respectively (p < 0.0001). The GJL group showed a higher grade of ADT than the no-GJL group (p < 0.0001). Significant differences were found in the stress ATFL length (23.6 ± 1.8 mm vs. 21.7 ± 1.8 mm, p = 0.002) and ATFL ratio (1.15 ± 0.06 vs. 1.07 ± 0.03, p < 0.0001) between the GJL and no-GJL groups. Spearman's correlation coefficients showed a moderate correlation between the BS and ATFL ratio (r = 0.45, p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The present study showed significant differences in the ATFL ratio and stress ATFL length between young men with and without GJL. The BS was moderately correlated with the lateral ankle laxity in this population.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Ligament Augmentation Reconstruction System (LARS) for Ankle Lateral Ligament Reconstruction in Higher-Risk Patients: A 5-Year Prospective Cohort Study

Background:

The modified Broström-Gould (MBG) procedure is the gold standard for patients with chronic ankle instability (CAI), but it is relatively contraindicated for patients with higher body weight or generalized ligamentous laxity (GLL). The use of the ligament augmentation reconstruction system (LARS) is an alternative.

Hypothesis:

It was hypothesized that clinical outcomes would be similar in patients with increased body weight (>90 kg) or GLL, relative to controls.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods:

A total of 66 patients satisfying the inclusion criteria were invited to participate and were divided into 3 groups: controls (no risk factors for inferior clinical outcome), patients with body weight >90 kg, and patients with GLL (Beighton score, ≥5 of 9). All patients underwent imbrication of the lateral collateral ligament complex augmented with the LARS. Primary outcomes of interest were Tegner activity scale (TAS) and Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS) subscale scores. Secondary outcomes were recurrence of ankle instability, the need for further surgery, and/or complications. Patients were reviewed at 2 and 5 years postoperatively, and outcomes between groups were compared using repeated-measures analysis of variance.

Results:

Complete data were available for 63 patients (21 patients in each group). TAS improved in all groups from preoperatively to 2 years and 5 years postoperatively (P < .001 for all). Relative to the controls, the TAS scores were lower in the >90-kg group at 2 years and 5 years (P < .001 for both periods), while the GLL group had similar scores to controls at both postoperative periods. Both the >90-kg and the GLL groups showed no significant difference in improvement on any FAOS subscale scores relative to the controls, at both 2 and 5 years postoperatively. There were no recurrences, repeat surgeries, or major complications.

Conclusion:

Relative to controls, patients with body weight >90 kg or GLL had similar FAOSs, and TAS scores were lower in the >90-kg group, at 2 and 5 years, after the use of the LARS to augment lateral collateral ligament imbrication for CAI. Use of the LARS in this manner is a viable option in patients for whom the MBG procedure is relatively contraindicated.

Association between the Beighton Score and Stress Ultrasonographic Findings of the Anterior Talofibular Ligament in Healthy Young Women: A Cross-Sectional Study

The Beighton score (BS) is widely used to evaluate generalized joint laxity. However, the association between the BS and lateral ankle laxity is unclear. This study compared the ultrasonographic (US) findings of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) between high- (≥6) and low- (≤3) BS groups of healthy young women. The ATFL lengths of healthy young women were measured in the stress and nonstress positions using the previously reported technique from March 2021 to January 2022. The ATFL ratio (ratio of stress to nonstress ATFL length) was used as an indicator of lateral ankle laxity. The anterior drawer test (ADT) was performed. The correlation between the BS and US findings was also examined. A total of 20 (high-BS group) and 61 (low-BS group) subjects with a mean age of 23.8 ± 1.0 years were included. The high-BS group showed a higher grade of ADT than the low-BS group. No significant differences were found in the nonstress and stress ATFL lengths and ATFL ratio (1.10 ± 0.05 vs. 1.09 ± 0.05, p = 0.19) between the groups. No correlation was found between the BS and US findings. In conclusion, this study did not detect significant differences in the US findings of the ATFL between the high- and low-BS groups.

The Ratio of Stress to Nonstress Anterior Talofibular Ligament Length on Ultrasonography: Normative Values

Background:

Stress ultrasonography (US) has been shown to be a valid procedure for evaluating chronic anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) injury. The ratio of stress/nonstress ATFL length (ATFL ratio) as measured on US is clinically useful; however, there are no published normative data concerning this ratio.

Purpose:

To report a normative value of the ATFL ratio on US and evaluate the relationships between sex, generalized joint laxity (GJL), and the grade of anterior drawer test (ADT).

Study Design:

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

The ATFL lengths were prospectively measured in the stress and nonstress positions (manual maximal anterior drawer position) for participants with noninjured ankles from March 2020 to March 2021. GJL was defined as a Beighton score ≥4. A manual ADT was also performed. The ATFL ratio was calculated, and the relationships between sex, GJL, and ADT grade were evaluated.

Results:

A total of 333 ankles in 184 participants (mean age, 24.5 ± 2.7 years; range, 20-33 years) were eligible for the analysis. GJL was found in 69 ankles (20.7%). The mean ATFL ratio was 1.08 ± 0.04 (95% CI, 1.08-1.09; range, 1.01-1.24), and there was a significant difference between male (1.07 ± 0.04; 95% CI, 1.07-1.08; range, 1.02-1.23) and female (1.09 ± 0.04; 95% CI, 1.08-1.10; range, 1.01-1.24) ankles (P = .001). In male ankles, the ATFL ratio was significantly greater in participants with GJL (1.11 ± 0.06 vs 1.07 ± 0.03; P = .02) or a higher grade of ADT (grade 2 vs grade 1: 1.11 ± 0.06 vs 1.07 ± 0.03, P = .002). These findings were not observed in female ankles.

Conclusion:

The normative value of the ATFL ratio on stress US was 1.07 ± 0.04 in men and 1.09 ± 0.04 in women. The ATFL ratio was affected by the presence of GJL in men but not in women. These findings will be useful for future studies seeking to establish the cutoff value of the ATFL ratio for diagnosing chronic lateral ankle stability on stress US.

Biomechanics Following Anatomic Lateral Ligament Repair of Chronic Ankle Instability: A Systematic Review

One of the most common orthopedic injuries in the general population, particularly among athletes, is ankle sprain. We investigated the literature to evaluate the known pre- and postoperative biomechanical changes of the ankle after anatomic lateral ligament repair in patients suffering from chronic ankle instability. In this systematic review, studies published till January 2020 were identified by using synonyms for "kinetic outcomes," "kinematic outcomes," "Broström procedure," and "lateral ligament repair." Included studies reported on pre- and postoperative kinematic and/or kinetic data. Twelve articles, including 496 patients treated with anatomic lateral ligament repair, were selected for critical appraisal. Following surgery, both preoperative talar tilt and anterior talar translation were reduced similarly to the values found in the uninjured contralateral side. However, 16 of 152 (10.5%) patients showed a decrease in ankle range of motion after the surgery. Despite the use of these various techniques, there were no identifiable differences in biomechanical postoperative outcomes. Anatomic lateral ligament repair for chronic ankle instability can restore ankle biomechanics similar to that of healthy uninjured individuals. There is currently no biomechanical evidence to support or refute a biomechanical advantage of any of the currently used surgical ligament repair techniques mentioned among included studies.

Evaluation of the uninjured anterior talofibular ligament by ultrasound for assessing generalized joint hypermobility

BACKGROUND

Most clinicians use the Beighton score to assess generalized joint hypermobility (GJH) when deciding on the treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). The purpose of the study was to evaluate anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) status by ultrasound and correlate these values with Beighton scores and the manual anterior drawer test (ADT).

METHODS

The participants were divided into two groups, those without GJH (24 ankles) and with GJH (20 ankles). For the investigation of ATFL, resting and stress ultrasonography was performed to assess the length, height (degree of loosening) and thickness. Beighton scores, manual ADT grades and ultrasound parameters of participants with and without GJH were compared. The correlation coefficients among those values were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean ATFL length, resting height, stress height and mean difference in height between resting and stress ATFL were all significantly different between the two groups (P < .05). The resting and stress ATFL length, height, and difference in height between resting and stress ATFL showed a positive linear relationship with Beighton scores and manual ADT grades (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

The ATFL stress ultrasound parameters showed significant differences between participants with high and low Beighton scores and were correlated with Beighton scores and manual ADT grades.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Cross-sectional cohort study; Level of evidence IV.

Is generalized ligamentous laxity a contraindication for a modified Broström operation to treat chronic lateral ankle instability? A systematic review

BACKGROUND

To investigate whether generalized ligamentous laxity (GLL) really is a contraindication for use of the modified Broström operation to treat chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI).

METHODS

Case series and cohort studies of the clinical outcomes of the use of the modified Broström operation to treat patients with CLAI and GLL were systematically reviewed and a meta-analysis conducted.

RESULTS

A total of 447 patients (458 ankles) from 2 case series and 3 cohort studies were systematically analyzed, with mean follow-up times that ranged from 12 to 108 months. Postoperative foot and ankle values analyzed included foot and ankle outcome scores, foot and ankle ability measurements, Karlsson-Peterson ankle scores, American orthopedic foot and ankle society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot scores, Tegner activity level scores, anterior talar translations (ATT), talar tilt angles (TTA) and adverse events. Reliable postoperative ankle stability was achieved in CLAI patients with GLL in the 2 case series without major complications. Suture-tape augmentation combined with a modified Broström operation was employed in 1 case series, and the modified Broström operation was only performed in CLAI patients with GLL if the contralateral uninjured ankle showed normal TTA and ATT in another case series. In the 3 cohort studies, 2 reported poorer outcomes and a significantly greater failure rate in patients with GLL compared with those without GLL, and 1 reported equivalent clinical results. In the further pooled data analysis, there was a significant difference in the postoperative TTA value between the GLL and non-GLL groups (SMD: 0.885, 95% CI [0.599-1.171], P = 0.000; I² = 98%, P = 0.000). The incidence of postoperative recurrent instability was significantly higher in the GLL group (RR: 6.265, 95% CI [2.563-15.309], P = 0.000; I² = 0%, P = 0.985). Two studies reported the preoperative Beighton score in 7 ankles with postoperative recurrent instability, 6 of which had a preoperative Beighton score ≥7.

CONCLUSIONS

GLL may not be a contraindication to the modified Broström operation being used to treat CLAI. However, some augmentation operations may be combined with the classic modified Broström operation, especially for those patients with preoperative Beighton scores ≥7, or with abnormal ATT and TTA in the contralateral ankle. This assertion should be further confirmed by a prospective, large-sample cohort and control study focused on this special population who are at a higher risk of developing postoperative instability.

LEVEL OF CLINICAL EVIDENCE

Level 3.

Comparison of the effects of reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments using peroneus longus and peroneus brevis tendon graft

Peroneus longus and peroneus brevis tendon grafts have been frequently used to reconstruct the lateral ankle ligaments. However, there is no literature comparing the effect of the 2 methods. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of 2 autologous tendon transplants on ankle joint activity.This retrospective study included 100 adult patients with chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) who underwent surgery from January 2014 to December 2017. Group A (50 patients): Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments using the anterior half of peroneus longus tendon graft; Group B (50 patients): Using the anterior half of peroneus brevis tendon graft. Outcomes were assessed by comparing pre- and postoperative AOFAS scores, VAS pain scores, and Karlsson scores, and the radiographic assessment included talar tilt and anterior talar translation. A sensitive dynamometer was used before and after surgery to assess inversion, valgus, plantarflexion, and dorsiflexion strength to evaluate changes in muscle strength in the patients feet.Postoperatively, 88 patients were followed up for 12 to 24 months, including 46 cases in group A and 42 in group B. No severe complications were recorded in the 2 groups. There were significant pre- to post-operative differences between the groups. No significant differences were observed in the postoperative scores and muscle strength changes between the groups. However, the number of patients with decreased valgus strength in group B was statistically significant compared with group A.Both methods can improve the stability of the ankle joint, but the peroneus longus tendon has little effect on the postoperative muscle strength of the foot and should be used as the preferred surgical treatment for the treatment of CLAI.

Functional Comparison of Horizontal Mattress Suture Versus Free-Edge Suture in the All-Inside Arthroscopic Broström-Gould Procedure for Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability

Objective

To compare the clinical outcomes of horizontal mattress suture vs free‐edge suture in the all‐inside arthroscopic Broström–Gould procedure.

Methods

This retrospective cohort study included 68 chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) patients who underwent either a horizontal mattress suture or a free‐edge suture all‐inside arthroscopic Broström–Gould procedure from January 2014 to January 2017. Patients were divided into two groups based on the suture fashion during the all‐inside arthroscopic Broström–Gould procedure. In the horizontal mattress suture group (n = 31), anchor sutures were used to suture the ATFL, capsule, and inferior extensor retinaculum in horizontal mattress suture fashion. In the free‐edge suture group (n = 37), anchor sutures were used to suture the ATFL, capsule, and inferior extensor retinaculum in free‐edge suture fashion. The Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) score, the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Karlsson Ankle Functional Score (KAFS), Anterior Talar Translation (ATT), the rate of return to sports, and ankle proprioceptive recovery were compared in both groups.

Results

The operative times and duration of hospitalization between the two groups were comparable (all P > 0.05). The VAS, AOFAS, ATT, the rate of return to sports, and ankle proprioceptive recovery were comparable between the horizontal mattress suture and free‐edge suture groups at 1 and 2 years after surgery. Patients of the free‐edge suture group achieved better KAFS 1 and 2 years after the surgery compared with those of the horizontal mattress suture group. In both groups, incisions were healed by first intention, and complications such as infection, implant reactions, tendon injury, and nervous or vascular injuries were not observed. The ankle proprioceptive recovery in horizontal mattress suture and free‐edge suture groups showed no significant differences at 1 and 2 years after surgery. The mean time of the return to full activity for patients in the horizontal mattress suture group was 10.38 ± 2.02 (range 8 to 12) weeks vs 8.63 ± 2.31 (range 8 to 12) weeks for those in the free‐edge suture group (P = 0.001, power = 0.907). The exercise participation rates were comparable between groups (P > 0.05). At the 2‐year follow‐up, all patients regained normal activities and ankle stability, and no recurrence of CLAI or revision surgery was recorded.

Conclusion

All‐inside arthroscopic Broström–Gould surgery for the treatment of CLAI ensures a better functional effect (KAFS) and better recovery time when free‐edge suture is used instead of horizontal mattress suture.

Functional deficits in chronic mechanical ankle instability

BACKGROUND

The interaction of functional and mechanical deficits in chronic ankle instability remains a major issue in current research. After an index sprain, some patients develop sufficient coping strategies, while others require mechanical support. This study aimed to analyze persisting functional deficits in mechanically unstable ankles requiring operative stabilization.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the functional testing of 43 patients suffering from chronic, unilateral mechanical ankle instability (MAI) and in which long-term conservative treatment had failed. Manual testing and arthroscopy confirmed mechanical instability. The functional testing included balance test, gait analysis, and concentric-concentric, isokinetic strength measurements and was compared between the non-affected and the MAI ankles.

RESULTS

Plantarflexion, supination, and pronation strength was significantly reduced in MAI ankles. A sub-analysis of the strength measurement revealed that in non-MAI ankles, the peak pronation torque was reached earlier during pronation (maximum peak torque angle at 20° vs. 14° of supination, p < 0.001). Furthermore, active range of motion was reduced in dorsiflexion and supination. In balance testing, patients exhibited a significant increased perimeter for the injured ankle (p < 0.02). During gait analysis, we observed an increased external rotation in MAI (8.7 vs. 6.8°, p<0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

This study assesses functional deficits existent in a well-defined population of patients suffering from chronic MAI. Impairments of postural sway, gait asymmetries, and asymmetric isokinetic strength can be observed despite long-term functional treatment. The finding that pronation strength is particularly reduced with the foot in a close-to-accident position indicates potential muscular dysfunction in MAI. Possibly, these deficits alongside the underlying mechanical instability characterize patients requiring mechanical stabilization.

Evaluation modalities for the anatomical repair of chronic ankle instability

PURPOSE

Several evaluation modalities are reported in the literature dealing with the operative treatment of chronic ankle instability (CAI) both to establish the CAI diagnosis leading to the surgical indication and to assess the effectiveness of ankle stabilisation procedure. The purpose of this study is to present an overview of the pre- and postoperative evaluation modalities reported in the literature dealing with CAI operative treatment. The comprehensive analysis of the different modalities chosen by researchers is expected to suggest critical points in current evaluation ability of CAI surgical treatment.

METHODS

Systematic review of the literature on surgical treatment of CAI through anatomic procedures. Pubmed, Embase and Cochrane electronic databases were analysed, from 2004 to 2018.

RESULTS

One-hundred-and-four studies met inclusion in this systematic review. 88 out of 104 studies analysed preoperative mechanical laxity of the ankle to depict the ligamentous insufficiency related to the subjective feeling of functional instability. Stress radiographs and manual stress examination of the ankle were the two most common modalities to evaluate joint laxity, reported in 67 and 53 studies, respectively. Clinical Outcome Measurement Scales (COMs) is the most common evaluation modality (102 out of 104 studies) to assess CAI surgical outcome. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Ankle-Hindfoot scale (AOFAS) and the Karlsson score are the most frequent COMs, reported in the 66% and 33%, respectively of the included literature. The radiographic analysis of ankle laxity after stabilisation procedures is the second most frequent postoperative evaluation modality, reported in 55 out 104 studies.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a lack of standardization among researchers related to both the criteria to establish the CAI diagnosis leading to the surgical indication and the modality chosen to evaluate the effectiveness of surgical treatment. Future standardization of evaluation modalities in the CAI population is desirable to increase consistency of reported data.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, review of level I, II, III and IV studies.

Peroneal tendon irritation after arthroscopic modified Broström procedure: A case report

RATIONALE

With the development of ankle arthroscope techniques and procedures, the number of arthroscopic modified Broström procedures (MBPs) is increasing. All-inside arthroscopic MBP was developed recently, with good to excellent results. However, several complications have been reported in patients after arthroscopic MBP. This case report describes a rare complication of arthroscopic MBP.

PATIENT CONCERNS

A 34-year-old woman presented with severe pain in her right ankle and underwent arthroscopic MBP for lateral ankle instability. About 6 months postoperatively, she presented with severe pain on the lateral aspect of the right ankle, especially while walking.

DIAGNOSIS

In physical examinations, there was marked swelling around the ankle and focal tenderness in the posterolateral malleolar area. Ankle ultrasonography showed a diffuse low-echoic mass-like lesion at the distal fibula between the fibular tip and peroneus tendon. T1-weighted sagittal magnetic resonance imaging images showed an irregularly shaped mass-like lesion with a heterogeneous signal near the distal fibula posteriorly where the anchor protruded.

INTERVENTIONS

The suture anchor in the posterior distal fibula area, which had irritated the peroneus tendon, was removed with debridement of the granulomatous lesion.

OUTCOMES

At the 3-month follow-up, the patient was almost asymptomatic and had a nearly full range of motion. No complications or recurrent symptoms were noted at the 1-year follow-up.

LESSONS

Three-dimensional computed tomography studies of the appropriate fibular depth and position of suture anchors are needed to standardize the procedure and reduce complications.

Clinical Guidelines for the Surgical Management of Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability: A Consensus Reached by Systematic Review of the Available Data

Background:

The surgical management of chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) has evolved since the 1930s, but for the past 50 years, the modified Broström technique of ligament repair has been the gold standard. However, with the development of arthroscopic techniques, significant variation remains regarding when and how CLAI is treated operatively, which graft is the optimal choice, and which other controversial factors should be considered.

Purpose:

To develop clinical guidelines on the surgical treatment of CLAI and provide standardized guidelines for indications, surgical techniques, rehabilitation strategies, and assessment measures for patients with CLAI.

Study Design:

A consensus statement of the Chinese Society of Sports Medicine.

Methods:

A total of 14 physicians were queried for their input on guidelines for the surgical management of CLAI. After 9 clinical topics were proposed, a comprehensive systematic search of the literature published since 1980 was performed for each topic through use of China Biology Medicine (CBM), China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library. The recommendations and statements were drafted, discussed, and finalized by all authors. The recommendations were graded as grade 1 (strong) or 2 (weak) based on the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation) concept. Based on the input from 28 external specialists independent from the authors, the clinical guidelines were modified and finalized.

Results:

A total of 9 topics were covered with regard to the following clinical areas: surgical indications, surgical techniques, whether to address intra-articular lesions, rehabilitation strategies, and assessments. Among the 9 topics, 6 recommendations were rated as strong and 3 recommendations were rated as weak. Each topic included a statement about how the recommendation was graded.

Conclusion:

This guideline provides recommendations for the surgical management of CLAI based on the evidence. We believe that this guideline will provide a useful tool for physicians in the decision-making process for the surgical treatment of patients with CLAI.

Presence of Subfibular Ossicle Does Not Affect the Outcome of Arthroscopic Modified Broström Procedure for Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability

PURPOSE

To evaluate the clinical and radiological outcomes of the all-inside, arthroscopic, modified Broström procedure (MBP) used to treat chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) according to subfibular ossicle (SFO) status.

METHODS

Between January 2013 and September 2016, we retrospectively analyzed CLAI patients who underwent the arthroscopic MBP. When performing the arthroscopic MBP, SFO was removed with all inside technique regardless of size. Patients who were not followed for more than a minimum of 12 months after surgery were excluded. The patients were divided into 2 groups: ankles with SFOs were assigned to the SFO group and the others to the non-SFO (NSFO) group. The evaluation tools used included the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hind foot score, a pain visual analog scale, and the talar tilt angle.

RESULTS

Following the inclusion criteria, we included 125 patients (125 ankles) in this study. The SFO group consisted of 26 patients and the NSFO group consisted of 99 patients. The preoperative scores in the 2 groups shows no significant difference except for AOFAS scores. The final AOFAS scores in both groups improved compared with the preoperative scores (18.4 ± 16.3 and 22.1 ± 21.6 for the SFO and NSFO groups, respectively). The final follow-up visual analog scale scores also improved in both groups (5.0 ± 1.7 and 5.2 ± 1.4, respectively). The mean ± standard deviation talar tilt improved from 8.7 ± 5.0° preoperatively to 4.6 ± 3.6° at the final follow-up in the SFO group, and from 7.3 ± 4.4° preoperatively to 3.2 ± 3.0° at the final follow-up in the NSFO group. Neither the preoperative nor final talar tilt angle differed between the 2 groups (P = .300 and P = .072, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

All-inside arthroscopic MBP after SFO resection was as successful as the same surgery without SFO resection. The clinical outcomes of the SFO and NSFO groups did not differ. Both groups achieved successful radiological outcomes at the last follow-up. All-inside arthroscopic MBP is a reliable treatment for CLAI patients regardless of SFO status.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective comparative study.