Injuries Associated With Subsequent Child Maltreatment Diagnosis: By Age, Race, Gender, and Medicaid Status

Child Maltreatment: A Comparison of Wisconsin Children Identified in Health Care and Child Protective Services (CPS) Records, 2018-2019

CONTEXT

Child Protective Services (CPS) reports and health records (hospital inpatient and emergency department visits) are the primary data sources to measure child maltreatment; yet, they are not linked at the state or national level. Linking provides novel insight into the demographic characteristics of the populations served by one or both agencies, thus informing opportunities for prevention and intervention.

OBJECTIVE

This study compares children identified as maltreated in health records (based on International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision, Clinical Modification [ ICD-10-CM ] codes indicating suspected or confirmed child maltreatment) and/or CPS reports.

DESIGN

Three mutually exclusive comparison groups were created: group 1- children with a nonfatal hospitalization and/or emergency department visit with a maltreatment ICD-10-CM code and an investigated CPS report; group 2- children with a maltreatment ICD-10-CM code in a health record without an investigated CPS report; and group 3- children with an investigated CPS report without a health record with a maltreatment ICD-10-CM code. Descriptive statistics and tests for statistically significant differences were conducted.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

Wisconsin children with maltreatment ICD-10-CM code in health record and/or CPS-investigated report from 2018 to 2019.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Demographic and maltreatment type differences between groups.

RESULTS

Group 1 children were significantly younger than those in other groups ( P <. 001), and group 2 children were significantly more female (69.6%; P < .001). Black children were overrepresented in all groups and most disproportionate among group 1 (39.5%; P < .001). Maltreatment type also differed significantly across groups.

CONCLUSIONS

CPS staff and health providers encounter overlapping and nonoverlapping populations of children experiencing different types of maltreatment. Although interventions may be tailored toward the type of maltreatment and other relevant child characteristics, all populations could benefit from referrals and access to supportive social services. Agency contact provides an opportunity to intervene and support at-risk children and families.

Nonaccidental Pediatric Trauma: Which Traditional Clues Predict Abuse?

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to determine which of the child abuse clues quoted in the literature predict nonaccidental trauma (NAT): history incongruent with injuries found on examination or imaging, old injuries present, history of trauma denied by caregivers, multiple fractures present, changing history, fractures of varied duration, metaphyseal fracture, ear bruise, neck bruise, different history (second historian), and metaphyseal fracture.

METHODS

This is a 4-year retrospective study of all suspected NAT cases referred to our medical center. In addition to the index visit, medical records were searched for visits before the index visit with patient historical or physical findings that might have suggested NAT but were not investigated. The association of diagnostic clues and the outcome were assessed by chi-square and logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

For 48 months, there were 109 cases of suspected NAT referred for evaluation (age range, 1 week to 15 years). After formal investigation by an abuse specialist, 79.3% of the cases were considered "likely abuse". Those historical or physical findings with a univariate association with a final conclusion of likely abuse included history incongruent with injuries, old injuries present, trauma history denied, changed history, and retinal hemorrhage. In multivariate logistic regression, only a history incongruent with injures remained an independent predictor of likely abuse (odds ratio, 8.65; 95% confidence interval, 1.74-43.07; P = 0.0151). After review of prior records, in only 2 of 109 cases (1.8%) was there a prior visit where NAT could have been suspected; however, history was thought to be congruent with the injury at the original visits.

CONCLUSION

In this 4-year study of NAT, the clinical clue that best predicted likely abuse after expert investigation was a history that was incongruent with the injuries found on emergency department evaluation. The incidence of possible early recognition from a prior emergency department visit in this group was very low, <2% of cases.