Single-molecule detection technologies in miniaturized high throughput screening: binding assays for g protein-coupled receptors using fluorescence intensity distribution analysis and fluorescence anisotropy

A Modular, Fully Integrated Ultra-High-Throughput Screening System Based on Confocal Fluorescence Analysis Techniques

The rapid increase in size of compound libraries, as well as new targets emerging from the Human Genome Project, require progress in ultra-high-throughput screening (uHTS) systems. In a joint effort with scientists and engineers from the biotech and the pharmaceutical industry, a modular, fully integrated system for miniaturized uHTS was developed. The goal was to achieve high data quality in small assay volumes (1-4 μL) combined with reliable and unattended operation. Two new confocal fluorescence readers have been designed. One of the instruments is a 4-channel confocal fluorescence reader, measuring with 4 objectives in parallel. The fluorescence readout is based on single-molecule detection methods, allowing high sensitivity at low tracer concentrationsand delivering an information-rich output. The other instrument isa confocal fluorescence im aging reader, where the imagesare analyzed in terms of generic patternsand quantified in units of intensity per pixel. Both readers are spanning the application range from assays with isolated targets in homogenous solution or membrane vesiclebased assays (4-channel reader) to cell-based assays (imaging reader). Results from a comprehensive test on these assay types demonstrate the high quality and robustness of this screening system.

Fluorescent approaches for understanding interactions of ligands with G protein coupled receptors

G protein coupled receptors are responsible for a wide variety of signaling responses in diverse cell types. Despite major advances in the determination of structures of this class of receptors, the underlying mechanisms by which binding of different types of ligands specifically elicits particular signaling responses remain unclear. The use of fluorescence spectroscopy can provide important information about the process of ligand binding and ligand dependent conformational changes in receptors, especially kinetic aspects of these processes that can be difficult to extract from X-ray structures. We present an overview of the extensive array of fluorescent ligands that have been used in studies of G protein coupled receptors and describe spectroscopic approaches for assaying binding and probing the environment of receptor-bound ligands with particular attention to examples involving yeast pheromone receptors. In addition, we discuss the use of fluorescence spectroscopy for detecting and characterizing conformational changes in receptors induced by the binding of ligands. Such studies have provided strong evidence for diversity of receptor conformations elicited by different ligands, consistent with the idea that GPCRs are not simple on and off switches. This diversity of states constitutes an underlying mechanistic basis for biased agonism, the observation that different stimuli can produce different responses from a single receptor. It is likely that continued technical advances will allow fluorescence spectroscopy to play an important role in continued probing of structural transitions in G protein coupled receptors. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Structural and biophysical characterisation of membrane protein-ligand binding.

Biophysical characterization of G-protein coupled receptor-peptide ligand binding

G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) are ubiquitous membrane proteins allowing intracellular responses to extracellular factors that range from photons of light to small molecules to proteins. Despite extensive exploitation of GPCRs as therapeutic targets, biophysical characterization of GPCR-ligand interactions remains challenging. In this minireview, we focus on techniques that have been successfully used for structural and biophysical characterization of peptide ligands binding to their cognate GPCRs. The techniques reviewed include solution-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, solid-state NMR, X-ray diffraction, fluorescence spectroscopy and single-molecule fluorescence methods, flow cytometry, surface plasmon resonance, isothermal titration calorimetry, and atomic force microscopy. The goal herein is to provide a cohesive starting point to allow selection of techniques appropriate to the elucidation of a given GPCR-peptide interaction.

Escaping the flatlands: new approaches for studying the dynamic assembly and activation of GPCR signaling complexes

Despite significant recent advances in molecular and structural studies of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), an understanding of transmembrane signal transduction with chemical precision requires new approaches. Simple binary receptor-ligand or receptor-G protein complex models cannot adequately describe the relevant macromolecular signaling machineries. GPCR signalosomes undergo complex dynamic assembly-disassembly reactions to create allosteric signaling conduits whose properties cannot necessarily be predicted from individual elements alone. The combinatorial possibilities inherent in a system with hundreds of potential components suggest that high-content miniaturized experimental platforms and computational approaches will be required. To study allosteric effects involved in signalosome reaction pathways, a bottom-up approach using multicolor single-molecule detection fluorescence experiments in biochemically defined systems and complemented by molecular dynamics models of macromolecular complexes is proposed. In bridging the gap between molecular and systems biology, this synthetic approach suggests a way forward from the flatlands to multi-dimensional data collection.

Pharmacology under the microscope: the use of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to determine the properties of ligand-receptor complexes

Recent years have revealed a high degree of structural organisation in the way in which cell-surface receptors and their associated signalling complexes interact at a molecular level. Fluorescence-based techniques have been at the forefront of methodologies used to investigate this organisation and dissect the pharmacology of drug–receptor interactions at the single-cell level. One such technique, fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), in conjunction with a fluorescent ligand or receptor, is capable of providing quantitative information about the number of receptors and their mobilities within small areas of the cell membrane that approach the size of some signalling domains. This article describes the use of FCS to perform subcellular quantitative pharmacology, with particular reference to G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). In conjunction with other forms of fluctuation analysis, such as two-colour cross-correlation FCS and molecular brightness analysis, FCS provides the first opportunity to investigate the domain-specific nature of GPCR pharmacology.

A microfluidic-FCS platform for investigation on the dissociation of Sp1-DNA complex by doxorubicin

The transcription factor (TF) Sp1 is a well-known RNA polymerase II transcription activator that binds to GC-rich recognition sites in a number of essential cellular and viral promoters. In addition, direct interference of Sp1 binding to DNA cognate sites using DNA-interacting compounds may provide promising therapies for suppression of cancer progression and viral replication. In this study, we present a rapid, sensitive and cost-effective evaluation of a GC intercalative drug, doxorubicin (DOX), in dissociating the Sp1–DNA complex using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) in a microfluidic system. FCS allows assay miniaturization without compromising sensitivity, making it an ideal analytical method for integration of binding assays into high-throughput, microfluidic platforms. A polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)-based microfluidic chip with a mixing network is used to achieve specific drug concentrations for drug titration experiments. Using FCS measurements, the IC₅₀ of DOX on the dissociation of Sp1–DNA complex is estimated to be 0.55 μM, which is comparable to that measured by the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA). However, completion of one drug titration experiment on the proposed microfluidic-FCS platform is accomplished using only picograms of protein and DNA samples and less than 1 h total assay time, demonstrating vast improvements over traditional ensemble techniques.

Dynamics of the gp130 cytokine complex: a model for assembly on the cellular membrane

Cytokines of the interleukin-6 (IL-6)-type family all bind to the glycoprotein gp130 on the cell surface and require interaction with two gp130 or one gp130 and another related signal transducing receptor subunit. In addition, some cytokines of this family, such as IL-6, interleukin-11, ciliary neurotrophic factor, neuropoietin, cardiotrophin-1, and cardiotrophin-1-like-cytokine, interact with specific ligand binding receptor proteins. High- and low-affinity binding sites have been determined for these cytokines. So far, however, the stoichiometry of the signaling receptor complexes has remained unclear, because the formation of the cytokine/cytokine-receptor complexes has been analyzed with soluble receptor components in solution, which do not necessarily reflect the situation on the cellular membrane. Consequently, the binding affinities measured in solution have been orders of magnitude below the values obtained with whole cells. We have expressed two gp130 extracellular domains in the context of a Fc-fusion protein, which fixes the receptors within one dimension and thereby restricts the flexibility of the proteins in a fashion similar to that within the plasma membrane. We measured binding of IL-6 and interleukin-b receptor (IL-6R) by means of fluorescence-correlation spectroscopy. For the first time we have succeeded in recapitulating in a cell-free condition the binding affinities and dynamics of IL-6 and IL-6R to the gp130 receptor proteins, which have been determined on whole cells. Our results demonstrate that a dimer of gp130 first binds one IL-6/IL-6R complex and only at higher ligand concentrations does it bind a second IL-6/IL-6R complex. This view contrasts with the current perception of IL-6 receptor activation and reveals an alternative receptor activation mechanism.

High-throughput screening of interactions between G protein-coupled receptors and ligands using confocal optics microscopy

Interactions of extracellular ligands with proteins in the cellular plasma membrane are the starting point for various intracellular signaling cascades. In the pharmaceutical industry, particular attention has been paid to G protein- coupled receptors (GPCRs), which are involved in various disease processes. In so-called high-throughput screening (HTS) campaigns, large medicinal chemistry compound libraries were searched for bioactive molecules that would either induce or inhibit the activity of a specific disease-relevant GPCR. In the respective drug discovery assays, the test compound typically competes with the physiological ligand for a binding site on the receptor. The transmembrane receptor is prepared in the form of membrane fragments or, as described here, in so-called virus-like particles (VLiPs). As hundreds of thousands of test compounds must be analyzed, there is a strict need for low volume binding assays to save the expensive bioreagents, and to reduce the consumption of the test compounds. In this chapter, we describe the application of confocal optics microscopy to measure GPCR ligand interactions in low microliter assay volumes.

Quick tour of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy from its inception

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was originally developed in the early 1970s as a way to measure the kinetics of chemical reactions under zero perturbation conditions. At its inception, the measurement was difficult due to experimental limitations and was primarily used during the 1970s and 1980s to characterize diffusion. More recently, as a result of technological advances, FCS measurements have become easier and more versatile. In addition to measurements of diffusion both in solution and in cells, FCS is now also used to measure not only chemical reaction kinetics but also extents of molecular aggregation, the dynamics of photophysical processes, conformational fluctuations, molecular interactions in solution and in cells, and has even found application as a pharmaceutical screening method. From its inception to the present, the contributions of Webb and his coworkers have had a central and defining role in the development and applications of FCS.

Single-molecule detection technologies in miniaturized high-throughput screening: fluorescence intensity distribution analysis

Single-molecule detection technologies are becoming a powerful readout format to support ultra-high-throughput screening. These methods are based on the analysis of fluorescence intensity fluctuations detected from a small confocal volume element. The fluctuating signal contains information about the mass and brightness of the different species in a mixture. The authors demonstrate a number of applications of fluorescence intensity distribution analysis (FIDA), which discriminates molecules by their specific brightness. Examples for assays based on brightness changes induced by quenching/dequenching of fluorescence, fluorescence energy transfer, and multiple-binding stoichiometry are given for important drug targets such as kinases and proteases. FIDA also provides a powerful method to extract correct biological data in the presence of compound fluorescence.

A homogeneous high throughput nonradioactive method for measurement of functional activity of Gs-coupled receptors in membranes

A method is described for measuring the activity of G(s)-coupled receptors in a nonradioactive homogeneous membrane-based assay. This method has several major advantages over currently used methods for measuring functional activity of G(s)-coupled receptors. The assay is high throughput (>150,000 data points/day using a single reader). Dimethyl sulfoxide tolerance is high ( approximately 10%). Compared to complex cell-based assays, there is limited potential for nonspecific compound action. This resulted in low compound hit rates in robustness screening, where hit rates from a simulated screen were 1.0% (antagonist screen) and 0.1% (agonist screen). No continuous cell culture is required for the assay, reducing cell culture overheads and allowing the screen to run every day. Automation is simple and requires no temperature- or humidity-controlled incubation. No radioactivity is required. The method relies on measurement of cyclic AMP (cAMP) generation by fluorescence polarization assay using commercially available reagents. Membranes (1-2 microg protein per well, containing anti-cAMP antibody) are transferred to 384-well plates containing 1 microl test compound. For antagonist screens, agonist is added 15 min later. After 30 min incubation at room temperature, one further assay reagent (fluorescein-cAMP in a buffer containing detergent) is added. The signal may be read after 1 h and is stable for greater than 12 h. Typical Z' for the assay is approximately 0.5.

Real experiences of uHTS: a prototypic 1536-well fluorescence anisotropy-based uHTS screen and application of well-level quality control procedures

This paper describes, for the first time, a true ultra-high throughput screen (uHTS) based upon fluorescence anisotropy and performed entirely in 1536-well assay plates. The assay is based upon binding and displacement of a BODIPY-FL-labeled antibiotic to a specific binding site on 70S ribosomes from Escherichia coli (Kd approximately 15 nM). The screen was performed at uHTS rates (i.e., >100,000 assay wells/24 h) using entirely commercially available equipment. In order to examine the reproducibility of detection of test compound effects, assays were performed in duplicate. Both overall assay statistics and reproducibility for individual compound results were excellent, at least equivalent to conventional HTS assays. Interference artifacts occurred mainly as a result of autofluorescence from test compounds. Well-level quality control procedures were developed to detect, eliminate, or even correct for such effects. Moreover, development of a brighter, longer wavelength probe (based upon Cy3B) markedly reduced such interferences. Overall, the data demonstrate that fluorescence anisotropy-based uHTS is now a practical reality.

Ligand binding to transmembrane receptors on intact cells or membrane vesicles measured in a homogeneous 1-microliter assay format

We have developed homogeneous miniaturized assays to measure ligand binding to either intact cells or receptor-containing membrane fragments by analysis of particle brightness. As an example, the affinities and inhibition constants of fluorescently labeled interleukin-8 (IL-8) and a low-molecular-weight antagonist toward the receptors CXCR1 and CXCR2, which belong to the superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), were determined. Although the results were generally comparable between the two approaches, the cell-based measurements revealed a more complex pattern of both ligand and inhibitor titration curves, pointing to the influence of intracellular regulatory events. Both the vesicle- and cell-based membrane receptor assays were successfully miniaturized to a total volume of 1 microl without compromising their sensitivity, indicating that screening of transmembrane receptors in these formats is feasible. This is the first report of a cellular ligand-binding assay performed in such low volumes. The resulting savings in reagent could potentially enable the use of primary cells for future HTS/ultra-HTS efforts.