Development and application of a high-throughput screening assay for HIV-1 integrase enzyme activities

In vitro methods for testing antiviral drugs

Despite successful vaccination programs and effective treatments for some viral infections, humans are still losing the battle with viruses. Persisting human pandemics, emerging and re-emerging viruses, and evolution of drug-resistant strains impose continuous search for new antiviral drugs. A combination of detailed information about the molecular organization of viruses and progress in molecular biology and computer technologies has enabled rational antivirals design. Initial step in establishing efficacy of new antivirals is based on simple methods assessing inhibition of the intended target. We provide here an overview of biochemical and cell-based assays evaluating the activity of inhibitors of clinically important viruses.

Biochemical screening assays to identify HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) integrase is, in addition to reverse transcriptase and protease, an important enzymatic target for antiretroviral drug development. Integrase plays a critical role in the HIV-1 life cycle coordinating the integration of the reverse-transcribed viral DNA into the host genome. This integration step is the net result of two consecutive integrase-related processes. First, integrase removes a dinucleotide from the 3' viral DNA ends in a process called 3'-processing. Next, in a process called strand transfer, the viral DNA is integrated into the host genomic DNA. Early on, biochemical assays have played a critical role in understanding the function of HIV-1 integrase and the discovery of small-molecule inhibitors. In this chapter we describe two biochemical assays to identify inhibitors of the 3'-processing and strand transfer process of HIV-1 integrase.

Reporter gene expression from LTR-circles as tool to identify HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

Early HIV-1 integrase inhibitors, such as compounds containing a β-diketo acid moiety, were identified by extensive high-throughput screening campaigns. Traditionally, in vitro biochemical assays, measuring the catalytic activities of integrase, have been used for this purpose. However, these assays are confounded by the absence of cellular processes or cofactors that play a role in the integration of HIV-1 DNA in the cellular genome. In contrast to regular cell-based virus inhibition assays, which targets all steps of the viral replication cycle, a novel cellular screening assays was developed to enable the specific identification of integrase inhibitors, employing a readout that is linked with the inhibition of integrase activity. Therefore, a HIV-1 lentiviral vector equipped with the enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) reporter gene was used to detect expression from extrachromosomal viral DNA (1- or 2-long terminal repeat circles), formed when integration of vector DNA into the cellular genome is prevented by an integrase inhibitor. In this assay, eGFP expression from the low residual level of transcriptional activity of extrachromosomal DNA was measured via high-throughput flow cytometry. An algorithm for analysis of eGFP expression histograms enabled the specific identification of integrase inhibitors. This assay is amenable for high throughput screening to identify inhibitors of HIV-1 integrase.

A high-throughput assay for HIV-1 integrase 3'-processing activity using time-resolved fluorescence

HIV-1 integrase (HIV-1 IN), a well-validated antiviral drug target, catalyzes multistep reactions to incorporate viral DNA into the genome of the host cell; these include both a 3'-processing (3'P) reaction and a strand transfer reaction. These enzymatic activities can be measured in vitro with short DNA oligonucleotides that mimic a single viral LTR DNA end and purified IN. A highly sensitive and reproducible time-resolved fluorescence (TRF)-based assay for HIV-1 IN 3'P activity is now reported. This assay was optimized with respect to time and concentrations of metal ions, substrate and enzyme. The assay has now been used successfully to measure HIV-1 IN 3'P activity and has been shown to detect the anti-IN activity of several known 3'P inhibition compounds accurately. This assay, which is amenable to high-throughput screening, will be useful for identification of additional HIV-1 IN 3'P inhibitors.

A novel high-throughput cellular screening assay for the discovery of HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

The discovery of HIV-1 integrase inhibitors has been enabled by high-throughput screening and rational design of novel chemotypes. Traditionally, biochemical assays focusing on the strand transfer activity of integrase have been used to screen compound libraries for identification of novel inhibitors. In contrast, cellular screening assays enable a phenotypic or multi-target approach, and may result in identification of compounds inhibiting integrase in its natural context, the pre-integration complex. Furthermore, a cellular assay encompassing 3' processing, strand transfer and nuclear import may lead to the identification of compounds with novel mechanisms of action targeting cellular and viral factors. Therefore, a cellular screening assay was developed, which focused on integrase activity, where infection of MT4 cells with an HIV-1 based lentiviral vector was synchronized by temporary arrest at the reverse transcriptase step and subsequent release to enable integration. The assay was validated using a panel of antivirals and proved to be a robust cellular screening assay for the identification of novel integrase inhibitors.

Visualization of human immunodeficiency virus protease inhibition using a novel Förster resonance energy transfer molecular probe

The in vivo high-throughput screening (HTS) of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) protease inhibitors is a significant challenge because of the lack of reliable assays that allow the visualization of HIV targets within living cells. In this study, we developed a new molecular probe that utilizes the principles of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) to visualize HIV-1 protease inhibition within living cells. The probe is constructed by linking two fluorescent proteins: AcGFP1 (a mutant green fluorescent protein) and mCherry (a red fluorescent protein) with an HIV-1 protease cleavable p2/p7 peptide. The cleavage of the linker peptide by HIV-1 protease leads to separation of AcGFP1 from mCherry, quenching FRET between AcGFP1 and mCherry. Conversely, the addition of a protease inhibitor prevents the cleavage of the linker peptide by the protease, allowing FRET from AcGFP1 to mCherry. Thus, HIV-1 protease inhibition can be determined by measuring the FRET signal's change generated from the probe. Both in vitro and in vivo studies demonstrated the feasibility of applying the probe for quantitative analyses of HIV-1 protease inhibition. By cotransfecting HIV-1 protease and the probe expression plasmids into 293T cells, we showed that the inhibition of HIV-1 protease by inhibitors can be visualized or quantitatively determined within living cells through ratiometric FRET microscopy imaging measurement. It is expected that this new probe will allow high-content screening (HCS) of new anti-HIV drugs.

A nonradioactive plate-based assay for stimulators of nonspecific DNA nicking by HIV-1 integrase and other nucleases

Retroviral integrase enzymes have a nonspecific endonuclease activity that is stimulated by certain compounds, suggesting that integrase could be manipulated to damage viral DNA. To identify integrase stimulator (IS) compounds as potential antiviral agents, we have developed a nonradioactive assay that is suitable for high-throughput screening. The assay uses a 49-mer oligonucleotide that is 5'-labeled with a fluorophore, 3'-tagged with a quencher, and designed to form a hairpin that mimics radioactive double-stranded substrates in gel-based nicking assays. Reactions in 384-well plates are analyzed on a real-time PCR machine after a single heat denaturation and subsequent cooling to a point between the melting temperatures of unnicked substrate and nicked products (no cycling is required). Under these conditions, unnicked DNA reforms the hairpin and quenches fluorescence, whereas completely nicked DNA yields a large signal. The assay was linear with time, stimulator concentration, and amount of integrase, and 20% concentrations of the solvent used for many chemical libraries did not interfere with the assay. The assay had an excellent Z' factor, and it reliably detected known IS compounds. This assay, which is adaptable to other nonspecific nucleases, will be useful for identifying additional IS compounds to develop the novel antiviral strategy of stimulating integrase to destroy retroviral DNA.

Comparison of metal-dependent catalysis by HIV-1 and ASV integrase proteins using a new and rapid, moderate throughput assay for joining activity in solution

Background

HIV-1 integrase (IN) is an attractive target for the development of drugs to treat AIDS, and inhibitors of this viral enzyme are already in the clinic. Nevertheless, there is a continuing need to devise new approaches to block the activity of this viral protein because of the emergence of resistant strains. To facilitate the biochemical analysis of wild-type IN and its derivatives, and to measure the potency of prospective inhibitory compounds, a rapid, moderate throughput solution assay was developed for IN-catalyzed joining of viral and target DNAs, based on the detection of a fluorescent tag.

Results

A detailed, step-by-step description of the new joining assay is provided. The reactions are run in solution, the products captured on streptavidin beads, and activity is measured by release of a fluorescent tag. The procedure can be scaled up for the analysis of numerous samples, and is substantially more rapid and sensitive than the standard radioactive gel methods. The new assay is validated and its utility demonstrated via a detailed comparison of the Mg⁺⁺- and Mn⁺⁺-dependent activities of the IN proteins from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and the avian sarcoma virus (ASV). The results confirm that ASV IN is considerably more active than HIV-1 IN, but with both enzymes the initial rates of joining, and the product yields, are higher in the presence of Mn⁺⁺ than Mg⁺⁺. Although the pH optima for these two enzymes are similar with Mn⁺⁺, they differ significantly in the presence of Mg⁺⁺, which is likely due to differences in the molecular environment of the binding region of this physiologically relevant divalent cation. This interpretation is strengthened by the observation that a compound that can inhibit HIV-1 IN in the presence of either metal cofactors is only effective against ASV in the presence of Mn⁺⁺.

Conclusion

A simplified, assay for measuring the joining activity of retroviral IN in solution is described, which offers several advantages over previous methods and the standard radioactive gel analyses. Based on comparisons of signal to background ratios, the assay is 10–30 times more sensitive than gel analysis, allows more rapid and accurate biochemical analyses of IN catalytic activity, and moderate throughput screening of inhibitory compounds. The assay is validated, and its utility demonstrated in a comparison of the metal-dependent activities of HIV-1 and ASV IN proteins.

Oligonucleotide-based assays for integrase activity

Oligonucleotide assays have been invaluable for elucidation of the molecular mechanisms of retroviral integrases. A suite of rapid and sensitive fluorescence assays to measure the DNA binding, processing, and joining activities of integrase (IN) is described here. The assays are especially useful for characterizing the major activities of the enzyme, and for handling large numbers of samples efficiently. They can greatly facilitate further biochemical and structural analyses for HIV-1 and other IN proteins. The assays can also be adapted for moderate-high throughput testing of various inhibitory compounds.

A novel high-throughput format assay for HIV-1 integrase strand transfer reaction using magnetic beads

AIM

To develop a novel high-throughput format assay to monitor the integrase (IN) strand transfer (ST) reaction in vitro and apply it to a reaction character study and the identification of antiviral drugs.

METHODS

The donor DNA duplex, with a sequence identical to the U5 end of HIV-1 long terminal repeats, is labeled at its 5' end with biotin (BIO). The target DNA duplex is labeled at its 3' end with digoxin (DIG). IN mediates the integration of donor DNA into target DNA and results in a 5' BIO and 3' DIG-labeled duplex DNA product. Streptavidin-coated magnetic beads were used to capture the product, and the amount of DIG was measured as the ST reaction product. The assay was optimized in 96-well microplate format for high-throughput screening purpose. Moreover, the assay was applied in a ST reaction character study, and the efficiency of the assay in the identification of antiviral compounds was tested.

RESULTS

The end-point values, measured as absorbance at 405 nm was approximately 1.5 for the IN-mediated ST reaction as compared with no more than 0.05 of background readings. The ST reaction character and the half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) values of 2 known IN inhibitors obtained in our assay were similar to previously reported results using other assays. The evaluation parameter Z' factor for this assay ranged from 0.6 to 0.9.

CONCLUSION

The assay presented here has been proven to be rapid, sensitive, and specific for the detection of IN ST activity, the reaction character study, as well as for the identification of antiviral drugs targeting IN.

High-throughput real-time assay based on molecular beacons for HIV-1 integrase 3'-processing reaction

AIM

To develop a high-throughput real-time assay based on molecular beacons to monitor the integrase 3'-processing reaction in vitro and apply it to inhibitor screening.

METHODS

The recombinant human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1 integrase (IN) is incubated with a 38 mer oligonucleotide substrate, a sequence identical to the U5 end of HIV-1 long terminal repeats (LTR). Based on the fluorescence properties of molecular beacons, the substrate is designed to form a stem-loop structure labeled with a fluorophore at the 5' end and a quencher at the 3' end. IN cleaves the terminal 3'-dinucleotide containing the quencher, resulting in an increase in fluorescence which can be monitored on a spectrofluorometer. To optimize this assay, tests were performed to investigate the effects of substrates, enzyme and the metal ion concentrations on the IN activity and optimal parameters were obtained. Moreover, 2 IN inhibitors were employed to test the performance of this assay in antiviral compound screening.

RESULTS

The fluorescent intensity of the reaction mixture varies linearly with time and is proportional to the velocity of the 3'-processing reaction. Tests were performed and the results showed that the optimal rate was obtained for a reaction mixture containing 50 mg/L recombinant HIV-1 IN, 400 nmol/L substrate, and 10 mmol/L Mn(2+). The IN 3'-processing reaction under the optimal conditions showed a more than 18-fold increase in the fluorescence intensity compared to the enzyme-free control. The IC50 values of the IN inhibitors obtained in our assay were similar to the values obtained from a radiolabeled substrate assay.

CONCLUSION

Our results demonstrated that this is a fast, reliable, and sensitive method to monitor HIV IN 3'-processing reaction and that it can be used for inhibitor screening.

Strategies for identification of HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

HIV-1 integrase, which catalyzes the joining of viral DNA to the host cell DNA, has attracted considerable attention as a target for the design and screening of novel anti-HIV drugs as it is essential for virus replication and the establishment of persistent infection. Progress in the identification of different classes of compounds that block integrase activity has been summarized recently in several excellent reviews. Here, we present a brief overview of integrase inhibition, highlighting some of the unusual properties of this protein and important considerations in searching for potential new inhibitors and their evaluation.

Synthesis and biological evaluation of purine derivatives incorporating metal chelating ligands as HIV integrase inhibitors

Because of its essential role in HIV replication and lack of human counterpart, HIV integrase is an attractive target for the development of novel anti-AIDS agents. Among the recently developed integrase inhibitors, only the alpha,gamma-diketo acid (DKA) compounds were biologically validated as potent and selective integrase inhibitors. The general structure of DKAs contains a diketo acid moiety as the Mg(2+) chelating pharmacophore, and an adjacent aryl group to provide selectivity. Numerous structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies on DKAs have been conducted, which generally involved substituting the carboxylate group or the aryl group. Our objective was to investigate the SARs of the DKA molecule by incorporating a purine ring in the aryl moiety and replacing the labile diketo acid moiety with other divalent metal (Me(2+)) chelating ligands. A series of amide substituted purine derivatives were synthesized via palladium-catalyzed amidation reactions, and their biological activities against HIV integrase were evaluated. These purine derivatives showed anti-integrase activity at low micromolar range. The biological results indicated that the type of Me(2+) ligands, two-point ligand picolinamide or three-point ligand 8-hydroxy-quinoline-7-carboxamide, affected inhibitory potency depending on the substitution position of the para-fluorobenzyl group. The C(6)-,C(8)-dipicolinamide substituted purine (32) exhibited the best potency among this series.

Conformationally restrained carbazolone-containing α,γ-diketo acids as inhibitors of HIV integrase

Since alpha,gamma-diketo acid (DKA) compounds were identified as potent and selective inhibitors for HIV integrase, numerous structural modification studies have been carried out to search for a clinical candidate as a supplement for the highly active antiretroviral therapy regimen. Due to the lack of structural information on inhibitor-integrase interactions, a comprehensive structure-activity relationship study is necessary. Most of the reported modification studies on the key alpha,gamma-diketo acid pharmacophore focused on substituting the carboxylate moiety with its bioisosteres or other electron-pair bearing heterocycles. We were interested in studying the conformation and geometry of the central diketo moiety. A series of carbazolone-containing alpha,gamma-diketo acids were designed and synthesized by applying conformational restraint onto the open-chain form of the diketo acid. These compounds showed anti-integrase activity in the low micromolar range, and integrase assay results indicated that the geometry of the diketo acid moiety is crucial to potency. Carbazol-1-one containing DKA analogs (7-8) showed a 2- to 3-fold increase in activity compared with those of carbazol-4-one containing DKA analogs (5 and 6). Alkylation of carbazol-4-one DKA nitrogen (6a-c) led to a loss of activity, suggesting this nitrogen atom may directly interact with the active site of integrase. The halogens (7b-d) and para-fluorobenzyl substituents (8a-d) on carbazol-1-one ring had little effect on potency.