TR-FRET cellular assays for interrogating posttranslational modifications of histone H3

Continuous Fluorescent Sirtuin Activity Assay Based on Fatty Acylated Lysines

Lysine deacetylases, like histone deacetylases (HDACs) and sirtuins (SIRTs), are involved in many regulatory processes such as control of metabolic pathways, DNA repair, and stress responses. Besides robust deacetylase activity, sirtuin isoforms SIRT2 and SIRT3 also show demyristoylase activity. Interestingly, most of the inhibitors described so far for SIRT2 are not active if myristoylated substrates are used. Activity assays with myristoylated substrates are either complex because of coupling to enzymatic reactions or time-consuming because of discontinuous assay formats. Here we describe sirtuin substrates enabling direct recording of fluorescence changes in a continuous format. Fluorescence of the fatty acylated substrate is different when compared to the deacylated peptide product. Additionally, the dynamic range of the assay could be improved by the addition of bovine serum albumin, which binds the fatty acylated substrate and quenches its fluorescence. The main advantage of the developed activity assay is the native myristoyl residue at the lysine side chain avoiding artifacts resulting from the modified fatty acyl residues used so far for direct fluorescence-based assays. Due to the extraordinary kinetic constants of the new substrates (K_M values in the low nM range, specificity constants between 175,000 and 697,000 M^-1s^-1) it was possible to reliably determine the IC₅₀ and K_i values for different inhibitors in the presence of only 50 pM of SIRT2 using different microtiter plate formats.

Continuous Sirtuin/HDAC (histone deacetylase) activity assay using thioamides as PET (Photoinduced Electron Transfer)-based fluorescence quencher

Histone deacylase 11 and human sirtuins are able to remove fatty acid-derived acyl moieties from the ε-amino group of lysine residues. Specific substrates are needed for investigating the biological functions of these enzymes. Additionally, appropriate screening systems are required for identification of modulators of enzymatic activities of HDAC11 and sirtuins. We designed and synthesized a set of activity probes by incorporation of a thioamide quencher unit into the fatty acid-derived acyl chain and a fluorophore in the peptide sequence. Systematic variation of both fluorophore and quencher position resulted "super-substrates" with catalytic constants of up to 15,000,000 M^-1s^-1 for human sirtuin 2 (Sirt2) enabling measurements using enzyme concentrations down to 100 pM in microtiter plate-based screening formats. It could be demonstrated that the stalled intermediate formed by the reaction of Sirt2-bound thiomyristoylated peptide and NAD⁺ has IC₅₀ values below 200 pM.

Integration of Epigenetic Mechanisms into Non-Genotoxic Carcinogenicity Hazard Assessment: Focus on DNA Methylation and Histone Modifications

Epigenetics involves a series of mechanisms that entail histone and DNA covalent modifications and non-coding RNAs, and that collectively contribute to programing cell functions and differentiation. Epigenetic anomalies and DNA mutations are co-drivers of cellular dysfunctions, including carcinogenesis. Alterations of the epigenetic system occur in cancers whether the initial carcinogenic events are from genotoxic (GTxC) or non-genotoxic (NGTxC) carcinogens. NGTxC are not inherently DNA reactive, they do not have a unifying mode of action and as yet there are no regulatory test guidelines addressing mechanisms of NGTxC. To fil this gap, the Test Guideline Programme of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development is developing a framework for an integrated approach for the testing and assessment (IATA) of NGTxC and is considering assays that address key events of cancer hallmarks. Here, with the intent of better understanding the applicability of epigenetic assays in chemical carcinogenicity assessment, we focus on DNA methylation and histone modifications and review: (1) epigenetic mechanisms contributing to carcinogenesis, (2) epigenetic mechanisms altered following exposure to arsenic, nickel, or phenobarbital in order to identify common carcinogen-specific mechanisms, (3) characteristics of a series of epigenetic assay types, and (4) epigenetic assay validation needs in the context of chemical hazard assessment. As a key component of numerous NGTxC mechanisms of action, epigenetic assays included in IATA assay combinations can contribute to improved chemical carcinogen identification for the better protection of public health.

A sensitive homogeneous enzyme assay for euchromatic histone-lysine-N-methyltransferase 2 (G9a) based on terbium-to-quantum dot time-resolved FRET

Introduction: Histone modifying enzymes include several classes of enzymes that are responsible for various post-translational modifications of histones such as methylation and acetylation. They are important epigenetic factors, which may involve several diseases and so their assay, as well as screening of their inhibitors, are of great importance. Herein, a bioassay based on terbium-to-quantum dot (Tb-to-QD) time-resolved Förster resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) was developed for monitoring the activity of G9a, the euchromatic histone-lysine N-methyltransferase 2. Overexpression of G9a has been reported in some cancers such as ovarian carcinoma, lung cancer, multiple myeloma and brain cancer. Thus, inhibition of this enzyme is important for therapeutic purposes.

Methods: In this assay, a biotinylated peptide was used as a G9a substrate in conjugation with streptavidin-coated ZnS/CdSe QD as FRET acceptor, and an anti-mark antibody labeled with Tb as a donor. Time-resolved fluorescence was used for measuring FRET ratios.

Results: We examined three QDs, with emission wavelengths of 605, 655 and 705 nm, as FRET acceptors and investigated FRET efficiency between the Tb complex and each of them. Since the maximum FRET efficiency was obtained for Tb to QD705 (more than 50%), this pair was exploited for designing the enzyme assay. We showed that the method has excellent sensitivity and selectivity for the determination of G9a at concentrations as low as 20 pM. Furthermore, the designed assay was applied for screening of an enzyme inhibitor, S-(5’-Adenosyl)-L-homocysteine (SAH).

Conclusion: It was shown that Tb-to-QD FRET is an outstanding platform for developing a homogenous assay for the G9a enzyme and its inhibitors. The obtained results confirmed that this assay was quite sensitive and could be used in the field of inhibitor screening.

Terbium-to-quantum dot Förster resonance energy transfer for homogeneous and sensitive detection of histone methyltransferase activity

The development of rapid, simple, and versatile biosensors for monitoring the activity of histone modifying enzymes (HMEs) is needed for the improvement of diagnostic assays, screening of HME inhibitors, and a better understanding of HME kinetics in different environments. Nanoparticles can play an important role in this regard by improving or complementing currently available enzyme detection technologies. Here, we present the development and application of a homogeneous methyltransferase (SET7/9) assay based on time-gated Förster resonance energy transfer (TG-FRET) between terbium complexes (Tb) and luminescent semiconductor quantum dots (QDs). Specific binding of a Tb-antibody conjugate to a SET7/9-methylated Lys4 on a histone H3(1-21) peptide substrate attached to the QD surface resulted in efficient FRET and provided the mechanism for monitoring the SET7/9 activity. Two common peptide-QD attachment strategies (biotin-streptavidin and polyhistidine-mediated self-assembly), two different QD colors (625 and 705 nm), and enzyme sensing with post- or pre-assembled QD-peptide conjugates demonstrated the broad applicability of this assay design. Limits of detection in the low picomolar concentration range, high selectivity tested against non-specific antibodies, enzymes, and co-factors, determination of the inhibition constants of the SET7/9 inhibitors SAH and (R)-PFI-2, and analysis of the co-factor (SAM) concentration-dependent enzyme kinetics of SET7/9 which followed the Michaelis-Menten model highlighted the excellent performance of this TG-FRET HME activity assay.

Chemical probes for protein arginine methyltransferases

Protein arginine methyltransferases (PRMTs) catalyze the transfer of methyl groups to specific arginine residues of their substrates using S-adenosylmethionine as a methyl donor, contributing to regulation of many biological processes including transcription, and DNA damage repair. Dysregulation of PRMT expression is often associated with various diseases including cancers. Different methods have been used to characterize the activities of PRMTs and determine their kinetic parameters including mass spectrometry, radiometric, and antibody-based assays. Here, we present kinetic characterization of PRMTs using a radioactivity-based assay for better comparison along with previously reported values. We also report on full characterization of PRMT9 activity with SAP145 peptide as substrate. We further review the potent, selective and cell-active PRMT inhibitors discovered in recent years to provide a better understanding of available tools to investigate the roles these proteins play in health and disease.

Continuous Activity Assay for HDAC11 Enabling Reevaluation of HDAC Inhibitors

Histone deacetylase 11 (HDAC11) preferentially removes fatty acid residues from lysine side chains in a peptide or protein environment. Here, we report the development and validation of a continuous fluorescence-based activity assay using an internally quenched TNFα-derived peptide derivative as a substrate. The threonine residue in the +1 position was replaced by the quencher amino acid 3'-nitro-l-tyrosine and the fatty acyl moiety substituted by 2-aminobenzoylated 11-aminoundecanoic acid. The resulting peptide substrate enables fluorescence-based direct and continuous readout of HDAC11-mediated amide bond cleavage fully compatible with high-throughput screening formats. The Z'-factor is higher than 0.85 for the 15 μM substrate concentration, and the signal-to-noise ratio exceeds 150 for 384-well plates. In the absence of NAD⁺, this substrate is specific for HDAC11. Reevaluation of inhibitory data using our novel assay revealed limited potency and selectivity of known HDAC inhibitors, including Elevenostat, a putative HDAC11-specific inhibitor.

One-Atom Substitution Enables Direct and Continuous Monitoring of Histone Deacylase Activity

We developed a one-step direct assay for the determination of histone deacylase (HDAC) activity by substituting the carbonyl oxygen of the acyl moiety with sulfur, resulting in thioacylated lysine side chains. This modification is recognized by class I HDACs with different efficiencies ranging from not accepted for HDAC1 to kinetic constants similar to that of the parent oxo substrate for HDAC8. Class II HDACs can hydrolyze thioacylated substrates with approximately 5-10-fold reduced k_cat values, which resembles the effect of thioamide substitution in metallo-protease substrates. Class IV HDAC11 accepts thiomyristoyl modification less efficiently with an ∼5-fold reduced specificity constant. On the basis of the unique spectroscopic properties of thioamide bonds (strong absorption in spectral range of 260-280 nm and efficient fluorescence quenching), HDAC-mediated cleavage of thioamides could be followed by ultraviolet-visible and fluorescence spectroscopy in a continuous manner. The HDAC activity assay is compatible with microtiter plate-based screening formats up to 1536-well plates with Z' factors of >0.75 and signal-to-noise ratios of >50. Using thioacylated lysine residues in p53-derived peptides, we optimized substrates for HDAC8 with a catalytic efficiency of >250000 M^-1 s^-1, which are more than 100-fold more effective than most of the known substrates. We determined inhibition constants of several inhibitors for human HDACs using thioacylated peptidic substrates and found good correlation with the values from the literature. On the other hand, we could introduce N-methylated, N-acylated lysine residues as inhibitors for HDACs with an IC₅₀ value of 1 μM for an N-methylated, N-myristoylated peptide derivative and human HDAC11.

Chemical Biology Approaches for Investigating the Functions of Lysine Acetyltransferases

The side-chain acetylation of lysine residues in histones and non-histone proteins catalyzed by lysine acetyltransferases (KATs) represents a widespread posttranslational modification (PTM) in the eukaryotic cells. Lysine acetylation plays regulatory roles in major cellular pathways inside and outside the nucleus. In particular, KAT-mediated histone acetylation has an effect on all DNA-templated epigenetic processes. Aberrant expression and activation of KATs are commonly observed in human diseases, especially cancer. In recent years, the study of KAT functions in biology and disease has greatly benefited from chemical biology tools and strategies. In this Review, we present the past and current accomplishments in the design of chemical biology approaches for the interrogation of KAT activity and function. These methods and probes are classified according to their mechanisms of action and respective applications, with both strengths and limitations discussed.

A continuous kinetic assay for protein and DNA methyltransferase enzymatic activities

BACKGROUND

Methyltransferases (MTs) catalyze the S-adenosylmethionine (SAM)-dependent methylation of a wide variety of protein and DNA substrates. Methylation of lysine, arginine or cytosine regulates a variety of biological processes including transcriptional activation and gene silencing. Despite extensive studies of the cellular roles of MTs, their quantitative kinetic characterization remains challenging. In the past decade, several assays have been developed to monitor methyl transfer activity utilizing different approaches including radiolabeling, antibodies or mass-spectrometry analysis. However, each approach suffers from different limitation and no easy continuous assay for detection of MT activity exists.

RESULTS

We have developed a continuous coupled assay for the general detection of MTs activity. In this assay, the formation of S-adenosylhomocysteine (SAH) product is coupled NAD(P)H oxidation through three enzyme reactions including glutamate dehydrogenase leading to absorbance changes at 340 nm. The utility and versatility of this assay is demonstrated for SET7/9 and SETD6 with peptides and full length protein substrates and for M.HaeIII with a DNA substrate.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows a simple and robust assay for the continuous monitoring of MT enzymatic activity. This assay can be used for the determination of steady-state kinetic enzymatic parameters (e.g., k cat and K M) for a wide variety of MTs and can be easily adapted for high-throughput detection of MT activity for various applications.

Histone Methyltransferase Activity Assays

Histone methyltransferases (HMTs) methylate either the lysine or arginine residues on histones and other proteins and play a crucial role in epigenetic regulation. Over 70 HMTs are encoded by the human genome, and many have been implicated in the aetiology of cancer, inflammatory diseases, neurodegenerative diseases and other conditions. There are currently about a dozen HMT activity assays available, and many of these assay formats are applicable to other epigenetic factors, such as histone acetyltransferases, histone deacetylases, and histone and DNA demethylases. Many factors need to be considered in selecting an HMT assay for drug discovery studies, including cost, adaptability to high-throughput screening, and rates of false positives and false negatives. This chapter describes the mechanisms of the major assay platforms available for HMT screening and profiling and presents the advantages and limitations associated with each.

Cell-based assays to support the profiling of small molecules with histone methyltransferase and demethylase modulatory activity

Histone methylation is a prevalent and dynamic chromatin modification, executed by the action of histone methyltransferases (HMTs) and demethylases (HDMs). Aberrant activity of many of these enzymes is associated with human disease, hence, there is a growing interest in identifying corresponding small molecule inhibitors with therapeutic potential. To date, most of the technologies supporting the identification of these inhibitors constitute in vitro biochemical assays which, although robust and sensitive, do not study HMTs and HDMs in their native cellular state nor provide information of inhibitor's cell permeability and toxicity. The evident need for complementary cellular approaches has recently propelled the development of cell-based assays that enable screening of HMT and HDM enzymes in a more relevant environment. Here, we highlight current cellular methodologies for HMT and HDM drug discovery support. We anticipate that implementation of these cell-based assays will positively impact the discovery of pharmacologically potent HMT and HDM inhibitors.

Quantification of histone H3 Lys27 trimethylation (H3K27me3) by high-throughput microscopy enables cellular large-scale screening for small-molecule EZH2 inhibitors

EZH2 inhibition can decrease global histone H3 lysine 27 trimethylation (H3K27me3) and thereby reactivates silenced tumor suppressor genes. Inhibition of EZH2 is regarded as an option for therapeutic cancer intervention. To identify novel small-molecule (SMOL) inhibitors of EZH2 in drug discovery, trustworthy cellular assays amenable for phenotypic high-throughput screening (HTS) are crucial. We describe a reliable approach that quantifies changes in global levels of histone modification marks using high-content analysis (HCA). The approach was validated in different cell lines by using small interfering RNA and SMOL inhibitors. By automation and miniaturization from a 384-well to 1536-well plate, we demonstrated its utility in conducting phenotypic HTS campaigns and assessing structure-activity relationships (SAR). This assay enables screening of SMOL EZH2 inhibitors and can advance the mechanistic understanding of H3K27me3 suppression, which is crucial with regard to epigenetic therapy. We observed that a decrease in global H3K27me3, induced by EZH2 inhibition, comprises two distinct mechanisms: (1) inhibition of de novo DNA methylation and (II) inhibition of dynamic, replication-independent H3K27me3 turnover. This report describes an HCA assay for primary HTS to identify, profile, and optimize cellular active SMOL inhibitors targeting histone methyltransferases, which could benefit epigenetic drug discovery.

Epigenetic-based therapies for Friedreich ataxia

Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) is a lethal autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder caused primarily by a homozygous GAA repeat expansion mutation within the first intron of the FXN gene, leading to inhibition of FXN transcription and thus reduced frataxin protein expression. Recent studies have shown that epigenetic marks, comprising chemical modifications of DNA and histones, are associated with FXN gene silencing. Such epigenetic marks can be reversed, making them suitable targets for epigenetic-based therapy. Furthermore, since FRDA is caused by insufficient, but functional, frataxin protein, epigenetic-based transcriptional re-activation of the FXN gene is an attractive therapeutic option. In this review we summarize our current understanding of the epigenetic basis of FXN gene silencing and we discuss current epigenetic-based FRDA therapeutic strategies.

Development of multiple cell-based assays for the detection of histone H3 Lys27 trimethylation (H3K27me3)

Posttranslational modification of histone proteins in eukaryotes plays an important role in gene transcription and chromatin structure. Dysregulation of the enzymes involved in histone modification has been linked to many cancer forms, making this target class a potential new area for therapeutics. A reliable assay to monitor small-molecule inhibition of various epigenetic enzymes should play a critical role in drug discovery to fight cancer. However, it has been challenging to develop cell-based assays for high-throughput screening (HTS) and compound profiling. Recently, two homogeneous cell-based assay kits using the AlphaLISA(®) and LanthaScreen(®) technologies to detect trimethyl histone H3 Lysine 27 have become commercially available, and a heterogeneous cell assay with modified dissociation-enhanced lanthanide fluorescence immunoassay (DELFIA(®)) format has been reported. To compare their pros and cons, we evaluated, optimized, and validated these three assay formats in three different cell lines and compared their activities with traditional Western blot detection of histone methylation inhibition by using commercial and in-house small-molecule inhibitors. Our data indicate that, although all four formats produced acceptable results, the homogeneous AlphaLISA assay was best suited for HTS and compound profiling due to its wider window and ease of automation. The DELFIA and Western blot assays were useful as validation tools to confirm the cell activities and eliminate potential false-positive compounds.

A TR-FRET-based functional assay for screening activators of CARM1

Epigenetics is an emerging field that demands selective cell-permeable chemical probes to perturb, especially in vivo, the activity of specific enzymes involved in modulating the epigenetic codes. Coactivator-associated arginine methyltransferase 1 (CARM1) is a coactivator of estrogen receptor α (ERα), the main target in human breast cancer. We previously showed that twofold overexpression of CARM1 in MCF7 breast cancer cells increased the expression of ERα-target genes involved in differentiation and reduced cell proliferation, thus leading to the hypothesis that activating CARM1 by chemical activators might be therapeutically effective in breast cancer. Selective, potent, cell-permeable CARM1 activators will be essential to test this hypothesis. Here we report the development of a cell-based, time-resolved (TR) FRET assay that uses poly(A) binding protein 1 (PABP1) methylation to monitor cellular activity of CARM1. The LanthaScreen TR-FRET assay uses MCF7 cells expressing GFP-PABP1 fusion protein through BacMam gene delivery system, methyl-PABP1 specific antibody, and terbium-labeled secondary antibody. This assay has been validated as reflecting the expression and/or activity of CARM1 and optimized for high throughput screening to identify CARM1 allosteric activators. This TR-FRET platform serves as a generic tool for functional screening of cell-permeable, chemical modulators of CARM1 for elucidation of its in vivo functions.

Baculovirus: an insect-derived vector for diverse gene transfer applications

Insect-derived baculoviruses have emerged as versatile and safe workhorses of biotechnology. Baculovirus expression vectors (BEVs) have been applied widely for crop and forest protection, as well as safe tools for recombinant protein production in insect cells. However, BEVs ability to efficiently transduce noninsect cells is still relatively poorly recognized despite the fact that efficient baculovirus-mediated in vitro and ex vivo gene delivery into dormant and dividing vertebrate cells of diverse origin has been described convincingly by many authors. Preliminary proof of therapeutic potential has also been established in preclinical studies. This review summarizes the advantages and current status of baculovirus-mediated gene delivery. Stem cell transduction, preclinical animal studies, tissue engineering, vaccination, cancer gene therapy, viral vector production, and drug discovery are covered.

A quantitative TR-FRET plate reader immunoassay for measuring autophagy

Autophagy involves the isolation and targeting of unwanted cellular components to lysosomes for their digestion and reuse. Autophagic dysregulation has recently been implicated in a wide range of disease processes, yet facile methods for quantifying autophagy have been lacking in the field. Here we describe the generation of a quantitative plate reader assay for measuring the autophagic activity of cells. One of the best characterized autophagy markers is the protein LC3B, which normally resides in the cytosol (LC3B-I) but upon induction of autophagy becomes lipidated and embedded in autophagosomal membranes (LC3B-II). To quantify autophagy, we reasoned that GFP-tagged LC3B could serve as a time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) acceptor upon cell lysis in the presence of terbium-labeled LC3B antibodies. Using this TR-FRET immunoassay approach, we screened a panel of LC3B antibodies and identified an antibody that exhibits strong preferential affinity toward autophagosome-associated LC3B-II and thereby facilitates specific detection of autophagic activity. The plate reader format provides both a quantitative and an objective result, thus overcoming some of the key limitations of the traditional immunoblotting and imaging approaches used to monitor autophagy. Moreover, since the assay step requires only a single addition of cell lysis buffer containing the detection antibody its simple workflow is both automation-friendly and scalable, which renders it suitable for high-throughput screening. We demonstrate how this TR-FRET immunoassay for GFP-tagged LC3B-II can be applied to quantitatively detect changes in the autophagy activity of cells, including estimating effects on autophagic flux.

Current chemical biology approaches to interrogate protein methyltransferases

Protein methyltransferases (PMTs) play various physiological and pathological roles through methylating histone and nonhistone targets. However, most PMTs including more than 60 human PMTs remain to be fully characterized. The current approaches to elucidate the functions of PMTs have been diversified by many emerging chemical biology technologies. This review focuses on progress in these aspects and is organized into four discussion modules (assays, substrates, cofactors, and inhibitors) that are important to elucidate biological functions of PMTs. These modules are expected to provide general guidance and present emerging methods for researchers to select and combine suitable PMT-activity assays, well-defined substrates, novel SAM surrogates, and PMT inhibitors to interrogate PMTs.