Mechanisms Responsible for Granzyme B–Independent Cytotoxicity

Granzyme B secreted by T cells is involved in anti-bacterial immune response of tilapia

Secreted by natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes, Granzyme B is involved in regulating the adaptive immune response in vertebrates and plays a pivotal role in resisting virus invasion and removing pathogens. Although it had been extensively studied in mammals, the involvement of Granzyme B in adaptive immune response of early vertebrates remained elusive. In this study, we investigated the Granzyme B in Oreochromis niloticus (OnGrB), found that its function domain was conserved. Additionally, OnGrB was widely expressed in various tissues and could respond to T-cell activation in vitro at the transcriptional level. Furthermore, we prepared the recombinant OnGrB (rOnGrB) as an immunogen to develop a mouse anti-OnGrB monoclonal antibody (mAb). Using this anti-OnGrB mAb as a tool, we explored the expression of OnGrB in the adaptive immune response of tilapia. Our findings revealed that T cell was a significant source of OnGrB production, the expression of OnGrB at the protein level and the proportion of OnGrB + T cells increased after both T cell activation in vitro and infection with Edwardsiella piscicida in vivo. More importantly, our findings also preliminarily illuminated that p65 could regulate the transcriptional activity of OnGrB. These results indicated that OnGrB was involved in the adaptive immunity of tilapia and played a critical role in T cell function in teleost. Our study provided theoretical support and new perspectives for understanding adaptive immunity in teleost.

Antigen-specific CD8+ T cell feedback activates NLRP3 inflammasome in antigen-presenting cells through perforin

The connection between innate and adaptive immunity is best exemplified by antigen presentation. Although antigen-presenting cells (APCs) are required for antigen receptor-mediated T-cell activation, how T-cells feedback to APCs to sustain an antigen-specific immune response is not completely clear. Here we show that CD8⁺ T-cell (also called cytotoxic T lymphocytes, CTL) feedback activates the NLRP3 inflammasome in APCs in an antigen-dependent manner to promote IL-1β maturation. Perforin from antigen-specific CTLs is required for NLRP3 inflammasome activation in APCs. Furthermore, such activation of NLRP3 inflammasome contributes to the induction of antigen-specific antitumour immunity and pathogenesis of graft-versus-host diseases. Our study reveals a positive feedback loop between antigen-specific CTLs and APC to amplify adaptive immunity.

Real-time detection of CTL function reveals distinct patterns of caspase activation mediated by Fas versus granzyme B

Activation of caspase-mediated apoptosis is reported to be a hallmark of both granzyme B- and Fas-mediated pathways of killing by CTLs; however, the kinetics of caspase activation remain undefined owing to an inability to monitor target cell-specific apoptosis in real time. We have overcome this limitation by developing a novel biosensor assay that detects continuous, protease-specific activity in target cells. Biosensors were engineered from a circularly permuted luciferase, linked internally by either caspase 3/7 or granzyme B/caspase 8 cleavage sites, thus allowing activation upon proteolytic cleavage by the respective proteases. Coincubation of murine CTLs with target cells expressing either type of biosensor led to a robust luminescent signal within minutes of cell contact. The signal was modulated by the strength of TCR signaling, the ratio of CTL/target cells, and the type of biosensor used. Additionally, the luciferase signal at 30 min correlated with target cell death, as measured by a (51)Cr-release assay. The rate of caspase 3/7 biosensor activation was unexpectedly rapid following granzyme B- compared with Fas-mediated signal induction in murine CTLs; the latter appeared gradually after a 90-min delay in perforin- or granzyme B-deficient CTLs. Remarkably, the Fas-dependent, caspase 3/7 biosensor signal induced by perforin-deficient human CTLs was also detectable after a 90-min delay when measured by redirected killing. Thus, we have used a novel, real-time assay to demonstrate the distinct pattern of caspase activation induced by granzyme B versus Fas in human and murine CTLs.

The adapter protein c-Cbl-associated protein (CAP) protects from acute CVB3-mediated myocarditis through stabilization of type I interferon production and reduced cytotoxicity

c-Cbl-associated protein (CAP), also called Sorbs1 or ponsin, has been described as an essential adapter protein in the insulin-signalling pathway. Here, we describe for the first time a unique protective role for CAP in viral myocarditis. Mortality and heart failure development were increased in CAP(-/-) mice compared to CAP(+/+) littermates after Coxsackievirus (CVB3) infection. Mechanistically, CAP protected from tissue apoptosis because of reduced CD8(+) T and natural killer cell cytotoxicity. Despite reduced cytotoxic elimination of CVB3-infected cells in CAP(+/+) hearts, however, CAP enhanced interferon regulatory factor 3 (IRF3)-dependent antiviral type I interferon production and decreased viral proliferation in vitro by binding to the cytoplasmic RIG-I-like receptor melanoma differentiation-associated protein 5 (MDA5). Taken together, these findings reveal a novel modulatory role for CAP in the heart as a key protein stabilizing antiviral type I interferon production, while protecting from excessive cytotoxic responses. Our study will help to define future strategies to develop treatments to limit detrimental responses during viral heart inflammation.

Mouse granzyme A induces a novel death with writhing morphology that is mechanistically distinct from granzyme B-induced apoptosis

Human and mouse granzyme (Gzm)B both induce target cell apoptosis in concert with pore-forming perforin (Pfp); however the mechanisms by which other Gzms induce non-apoptotic death remain controversial and poorly characterised. We used timelapse microscopy to document, quantitatively and in real time, the death of target cells exposed to primary natural killer (NK) cells from mice deficient in key Gzms. We found that in the vast majority of cases, NK cells from wild-type mice induced classic apoptosis. However, NK cells from syngeneic Gzm B-deficient mice induced a novel form of cell death characterised by slower kinetics and a pronounced, writhing, 'worm-like' morphology. Dying cells initially contracted but did not undergo membrane blebbing, and annexin-V staining was delayed until the onset of secondary necrosis. As it is different from any cell death process previously reported, we tentatively termed this cell death 'athetosis'. Two independent lines of evidence showed this alternate form of death was due to Gzm A: first, cell death was revealed in the absence of Gzm B, but was completely lost when the NK cells were deficient in both Gzm A and B; second, the athetotic morphology was precisely reproduced when recombinant mouse Gzm A was delivered by an otherwise innocuous dose of recombinant Pfp. Gzm A-mediated athetosis did not require caspase activation, early mitochondrial disruption or generation of reactive oxygen species, but did require an intact actin cytoskeleton and was abolished by latrunculin B and mycalolide B. This work defines an authentic role for mouse Gzm A in granule-induced cell death by cytotoxic lymphocytes.

Hepadnaviral infection augments hepatocyte cytotoxicity mediated by both CD95 ligand and perforin pathways

BACKGROUND/AIM

Recently, we documented that hepatocytes can eliminate contacted cells via the CD95 ligand (CD95L)-CD95 pathway and that they are also equipped in perforin and granzyme B and can eradicate other cells via the granule exocytosis mechanism. The aim of this study was to assess whether hepadnaviral infection modifies hepatocyte-mediated cell killing.

METHODS

Primary hepatocytes from woodchucks with progressing or resolved hepadnaviral hepatitis and hepatocyte lines transfected with woodchuck hepatitis virus (WHV) genes were examined for cytotoxic effector activity against cell targets susceptible to CD95L and/or perforin-dependent killing. Hepatocytes from healthy animals served as controls.

RESULTS

Actively progressing and resolved hepadnaviral hepatitis is associated with a significantly greater capacity of hepatocytes to kill contacted cells. Both hepatocyte CD95L- and perforin-dependent cytotoxicity were augmented. Hepatocytes transfected with WHV X gene, but not those with complete WHV genome or virus envelope or core gene, transcribed significantly more CD95L and perforin and killed cell targets more efficiently. Exposure to interferon-gamma profoundly enhanced hepatocyte cell killing.

CONCLUSIONS

Hepatocyte cytotoxic potential is significantly augmented during and following resolution of active hepadnaviral hepatitis. Hepatocyte cytotoxic activity may contribute to both liver physiological functions and the pathogenesis and progression of liver disease, including viral hepatitis.

Hepatocytes can induce death of contacted cells via perforin-dependent mechanism

The liver displays unique immunological properties including the ability to remove aberrant cells and pathogens and to induce peripheral immunotolerance. We have previously demonstrated that hepatocytes can cause cell death by a CD95 ligand-mediated mechanism. Here, we provide evidence that hepatocytes can kill other cells via a perforin-dependent pathway. Using cultured woodchuck hepatocytes and human liver cells as well as freshly isolated woodchuck, mouse, and human hepatocytes, we show that hepatocyte-mediated death of CD95-deficient target cells requires microtubule polymerization, a feature of the granule exocytosis-mediated cytotoxicity. Neutralizing anti-perforin antibodies and short-hairpin RNA directed against perforin messenger RNA confirmed the involvement of perforin in hepatocyte-mediated cell killing.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that hepatocytes express biologically competent perforin capable of killing susceptible cells and emphasizes the role of hepatocytes as cytotoxic effectors. This also is the first demonstration of perforin in a non-lymphoid cell type.

The orphan granzymes of humans and mice

The granzyme/perforin pathway is a central pathway for lymphocyte-mediated killing in both the innate and adaptive immune systems. This pathway is important in a variety of host defenses, including viral clearance and tumor cell killing, and its dysregulation results in several human and rodent diseases. To date, the majority of reports in this field have concentrated on the functions of granzymes A and B. Recent reports, however, suggest that the non-A/non-B 'orphan' granzymes found in both humans and mice are potentially significant. Although the functions of these orphan granzymes have yet to be fully established, initial data suggests their importance in both immune and nonimmune cells.

Differential expression of perforin and granzyme B in the liver of patients with chronic hepatitis C

T lymphocytes have been reported to be the predominant inflammatory cells in the liver of patients with chronic hepatitis C. On activation, CD8+ T lymphocytes can exert their cytolytic activity by releasing their granule components, notably perforin and granzyme B. The aim of the present study was to assess whether the granule cytolytic pathway was used by liver-infiltrating CD8+ T lymphocytes. Immunostaining for perforin and granzyme B was performed in 25 patients with chronic hepatitis C, according to the disease activity and their virologic status. Cells stained for perforin and for granzyme B represented 0.15% and 0.10% of the total liver-infiltrating CD8+ T lymphocytes, respectively. Perforin was expressed mainly by activated CD8+ T lymphocytes located in liver lobules. In contrast, granzyme B was expressed mainly by activated CD8+ T lymphocytes located in interface hepatitis and portal tracts. The results were similar in the different groups of patients, whatever the disease activity. In conclusion, this is the first study showing a differential expression of granule components of CD8+ T lymphocytes in the same tissue in vivo. Perforin and granzyme B may be differently expressed by liver-infiltrating CD8+ T lymphocytes, according to their localization in the different specific compartments of the liver, in patients with chronic hepatitis C.

Lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity

Virtually all of the measurable cell-mediated cytotoxicity delivered by cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells comes from either the granule exocytosis pathway or the Fas pathway. The granule exocytosis pathway utilizes perforin to traffic the granzymes to appropriate locations in target cells, where they cleave critical substrates that initiate DNA fragmentation and apoptosis; granzymes A and B induce death via alternate, nonoverlapping pathways. The Fas/FasL system is responsible for activation-induced cell death but also plays an important role in lymphocyte-mediated killing under certain circumstances. The interplay between these two cytotoxic systems provides opportunities for therapeutic interventions to control autoimmune diseases and graft vs. host disease, but oversuppression of these pathways may also lead to increased viral susceptibility and/or decreased tumor cell killing.

Granzyme A initiates an alternative pathway for granule-mediated apoptosis

Granzyme (gzm) B-deficient cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTL) have a severe defect in the rapid induction of target cell apoptosis that is almost completely corrected by prolonged incubation of the CTL effectors and their targets. We show in this report that perforin-dependent, gzmB-independent cytotoxicity is caused by gzmA (or tightly linked genes). CTL deficient for gzmA and gzmB retain normal perforin function, but these CTL have a cytotoxic defect in vivo that is as severe as perforin-deficient CTL. Collectively, these results suggest that perforin provides target cell access and/or trafficking signals for the gzms, and that the gzms themselves deliver the lethal hits. The gzmA pathway appears to function independently from gzmB and may therefore provide a critical "back-up" system when gzmB is inhibited in the target cell.

Fas-Independent and Nonapoptotic Cytotoxicity Mediated by a Human CD4+ T-Cell Clone Directed Against an Acute Myelogenous Leukemia–Associated DEK-CAN Fusion Peptide

The mechanism underlying the cytotoxicity mediated by a human CD4+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clone directed against a peptide derived from the acute myelogenous leukemia-associated fusion protein, DEK-CAN, was investigated. A DEK-CAN fusion peptide-specific CD4+ Th0 CTL clone, designated HO-1, was established from the peripheral blood lymphocytes of a healthy individual. HO-1 exerted direct but not “innocent bystander” cytotoxicity within 2 hours. The cytotoxicity mediated by HO-1 was completely Ca2+-dependent. Because HO-1 lysed peptide-loaded Fas-deficient target cells derived from a patient with a homozygousFas gene mutation, its cytotoxicity appeared to be mediated by a Fas-independent pathway. In addition, its cytotoxicity was only partially inhibited by treatment with concanamycin A and strontium ions, which are inhibitors of the perforin-based cytotoxic pathway. Although membrane-bound type of tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-) was expressed on HO-1, an anti–TNF- antibody had no effect on HO-1–mediated cytotoxicity. HO-1 expressed mRNA for apoptosis-inducing mediators, including perforin, granzyme B, Fas ligand, TNF-, and lymphotoxin; however, no DNA fragmentation was detected in target cells incubated with HO-1 by 5-[125I]Iodo-2′-deoxyuridine release assay and agarose gel electrophoresis of DNA. Although it has been suggested that the Fas/Fas ligand system is the main pathway by which CD4+ CTL-mediated cytotoxicity is exerted in murine systems, HO-1 produced peptide-specific and HLA-restricted cytotoxicity via a Fas-independent and nonapoptotic pathway. The present study thus describes a novel mechanism of cytotoxicity mediated by CD4+ CTL.

Fas-Independent and Nonapoptotic Cytotoxicity Mediated by a Human CD4+ T-Cell Clone Directed Against an Acute Myelogenous Leukemia–Associated DEK-CAN Fusion Peptide

The mechanism underlying the cytotoxicity mediated by a human CD4+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clone directed against a peptide derived from the acute myelogenous leukemia-associated fusion protein, DEK-CAN, was investigated. A DEK-CAN fusion peptide-specific CD4+ Th0 CTL clone, designated HO-1, was established from the peripheral blood lymphocytes of a healthy individual. HO-1 exerted direct but not “innocent bystander” cytotoxicity within 2 hours. The cytotoxicity mediated by HO-1 was completely Ca2+-dependent. Because HO-1 lysed peptide-loaded Fas-deficient target cells derived from a patient with a homozygousFas gene mutation, its cytotoxicity appeared to be mediated by a Fas-independent pathway. In addition, its cytotoxicity was only partially inhibited by treatment with concanamycin A and strontium ions, which are inhibitors of the perforin-based cytotoxic pathway. Although membrane-bound type of tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-) was expressed on HO-1, an anti–TNF- antibody had no effect on HO-1–mediated cytotoxicity. HO-1 expressed mRNA for apoptosis-inducing mediators, including perforin, granzyme B, Fas ligand, TNF-, and lymphotoxin; however, no DNA fragmentation was detected in target cells incubated with HO-1 by 5-[125I]Iodo-2′-deoxyuridine release assay and agarose gel electrophoresis of DNA. Although it has been suggested that the Fas/Fas ligand system is the main pathway by which CD4+ CTL-mediated cytotoxicity is exerted in murine systems, HO-1 produced peptide-specific and HLA-restricted cytotoxicity via a Fas-independent and nonapoptotic pathway. The present study thus describes a novel mechanism of cytotoxicity mediated by CD4+ CTL.

How do cytotoxic lymphocytes kill their targets?

CD8+ cytotoxic lymphocytes, natural killer cells and lymphokine-activated killer cells depend primarily on the perforin/granzyme system to kill their targets, while CD4+ T cells utilize Fas and other mechanisms to induce cell death. The molecular mechanisms used by these pathways to induce target cell apoptosis may converge on common death substrates.

Involvement of Donor T-Cell Cytotoxic Effector Mechanisms in Preventing Allogeneic Marrow Graft Rejection

Donor CD8 cells play a pivotal role in preventing allogeneic marrow graft rejection, possibly by generating cytotoxic effectors needed to eliminate recipient T cells remaining after the pretransplant conditioning regimen or by producing cytokines needed to support the growth and differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells. In the present study, we assessed the role of donor T-cell cytotoxic effector function as a mechanism for eliminating recipient CD8 cells that cause marrow graft rejection in mice. The ability to prevent rejection was minimally affected by the presence of a defect in Fas ligand binding or by the absence of granzyme B but was severely affected by the absence of perforin. Doubly mutant perforin-deficient, Fas ligand-defective CD8 cells were completely unable to prevent rejection. Our results indicate first that recipient CD8 effectors responsible for causing marrow graft rejection are sensitive to cytotoxicity mediated by both perforin- and Fas-ligand-dependent mechanisms, and second that donor T cells must have at least one functional cytotoxic mechanism to prevent allogeneic marrow graft rejection.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Involvement of Donor T-Cell Cytotoxic Effector Mechanisms in Preventing Allogeneic Marrow Graft Rejection

Donor CD8 cells play a pivotal role in preventing allogeneic marrow graft rejection, possibly by generating cytotoxic effectors needed to eliminate recipient T cells remaining after the pretransplant conditioning regimen or by producing cytokines needed to support the growth and differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells. In the present study, we assessed the role of donor T-cell cytotoxic effector function as a mechanism for eliminating recipient CD8 cells that cause marrow graft rejection in mice. The ability to prevent rejection was minimally affected by the presence of a defect in Fas ligand binding or by the absence of granzyme B but was severely affected by the absence of perforin. Doubly mutant perforin-deficient, Fas ligand-defective CD8 cells were completely unable to prevent rejection. Our results indicate first that recipient CD8 effectors responsible for causing marrow graft rejection are sensitive to cytotoxicity mediated by both perforin- and Fas-ligand-dependent mechanisms, and second that donor T cells must have at least one functional cytotoxic mechanism to prevent allogeneic marrow graft rejection.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Caspase Dependence of Target Cell Damage Induced by Cytotoxic Lymphocytes

Since the CTL secreted granule protease granzyme B can activate multiple target caspases, it has been proposed that this pathway is responsible for CTL-induced cytolysis of Fas-negative targets. However, target lysis via the granule exocytosis pathway is completely resistant to caspase inhibitors. To test the possibility that granzymes trigger a postcaspase cytoplasmic apoptotic pathway leading to lysis, we have examined the caspase dependence of several cytoplasmic changes associated with apoptotic death. Rapid prelytic phosphatidylserine externalization was induced in Jurkat target cells by both the Fas ligand (FasL)/Fas and the granule exocytosis effector pathways. This was specifically blocked by peptide ketone caspase inhibitors when induced by the former, but not by the latter, pathway. A rapid prelytic loss of target mitochondrial ψ was also induced by both CTL effector pathways, and this was also specifically blocked by caspase inhibitors when induced by the FasL/Fas, but not by the granule exocytosis, pathway. Similarly, target membrane blebbing induced by CTL via the FasL/Fas, but not via the granule exocytosis, effector pathway was specifically blocked by caspase inhibitors. In contrast to the above nonnuclear damage, CTL-induced target staining by the lipid probe FM1–43 reflecting plasma membrane endocytosis was blocked by caspase inhibitors. Thus, when caspase activation is blocked, the granule exocytosis pathway triggers several parameters of target apoptotic damage in addition to lysis, suggesting that granzymes directly trigger a postcaspase cytoplasmic apoptotic death pathway.

Residual cytotoxicity and granzyme K expression in granzyme A-deficient cytotoxic lymphocytes

Cytotoxic lymphocytes contain granules that have the ability to induce apoptosis in susceptible target cells. The granule contents include perforin, a pore-forming molecule, and several granzymes, including A and B, which are the most abundant serine proteases in these granules. Granzyme B-deficient cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) have a severe defect in their ability to rapidly induce apoptosis in their targets, but have an intact late cytotoxicity pathway that is in part perforin-dependent. In this report, we have created mice that are deficient for granzyme A and characterized their phenotype. These mice have normal growth and development and normal lymphocyte development, activation, and proliferation. Granzyme A-deficient CTL have a small but reproducible defect in their ability to induce 51Cr and 125I-UdR release from susceptible allogeneic target cells. Since other granzyme A-like tryptases could potentially account for the residual cytotoxicity in granzyme A-deficient CTL, we cloned the murine granzyme K gene, which is linked to granzyme A in humans, and proved that it is also tightly linked with murine granzyme A. The murine granzyme K gene (which encodes a tryptase similar to granzyme A) is expressed at much lower levels than granzyme A in CTL and LAK cells, but its expression is unaltered in granzyme A-/- mice. The minimal cytotoxic defect in granzyme A-/- CTL could be due to the existence of an intact, functional early killing pathway (granzyme B dependent), or to the persistent expression of additional granzyme tryptases like granzyme K.