Induction of tolerance to human factor VIII in mice

Pharmacokinetic analysis identifies a factor VIII immunogenicity threshold after AAV gene therapy in hemophilia A mice

Advances in the development of novel treatment options for hemophilia A are prevalent. However, the anti-factor VIII (FVIII) neutralizing antibody (inhibitor) response to existing FVIII products remains a major treatment challenge. Although some novel products are designed to function in the presence of inhibitors, they do not specific address the immunogenicity risk or mechanistic causes of inhibitor development, which remain unclear. Furthermore, most preclinical studies supporting clinical gene therapy programs have reported immunogenicity signals in animal models, especially at higher vector doses and sometimes using multiple vector designs. In these settings, immunogenicity risk factor determination, comparative immunogenicity of competing vector designs, and the potential for obtaining meaningful prognostic data remain relatively unexplored. Additionally, there remains the opportunity to investigate clinical gene therapy as an alternative to standard immune tolerance induction therapy. The current study was designed to address these issues through longitudinal dose-response evaluation of 4 adeno-associated viral (AAV) vector candidates encoding 2 different FVIII transgenes in a murine model of hemophilia A. Plasma FVIII activity and anti-FVIII antibody data were used to generate a pharmacokinetic model that (1) identifies initial AAV-FVIII product expression kinetics as the dominant risk factor for inhibitor development, (2) predicts a therapeutic window where immune tolerance is achieved, and (3) demonstrates evidence of gene therapy-based immune tolerance induction. Although there are known limitations to the predictive value of preclinical immunogenicity testing, these studies can uncover or support the development of design principles that can guide the development of safe and effective genetic medicines.

High-Dose IV Administration of Rasburicase Suppresses Anti-rasburicase Antibodies, Depletes Rasburicase-Specific Lymphocytes, and Upregulates Treg Cells

Therapeutic proteins can be potent agents for treating serious diseases, but in many patients these proteins provoke antibody responses that blunt therapeutic efficacy. Intravenous administration of high doses of some proteins induces immune tolerance, but the mechanisms underlying this effect are poorly understood. As a model to study tolerance induction in mice, we used rasburicase, a commercial recombinant uricase used for the treatment of hyperuricemia. Intraperitoneal (i.p.) injection of rasburicase without or with alum adjuvants induced a clear anti-rasburicase antibody response, but intravenous (i.v.) injection did not. The lack of response to i.v. rasburicase was apparently due to active immune suppression since i.v.-treated mice showed blunted antibody and reduced T cell responses to subsequent i.p. injections of rasburicase. This blunted response was associated with a decrease in rasburicase-specific B cell and T cell responses and an increase in proportion of CD4⁺ FoxP3⁺ regulatory T cells (Treg) in the spleen. We examined the number of lymphocytes in peripheral blood after rasburicase i.v. injection. Rasburicase caused a transient reduction in B and T cells, but a robust and sustained depletion of rasburicase-specific B cells. Further experiments showed that rasburicase i.v. injection decreased the number of lymphocytes and was associated with apoptosis of both B cells and activated T cells and that the enhanced percentage of Treg cells was likely mediated by a macrophage-dependent pathway. Thus, our data suggest that apoptosis and depletion of antigen-specific B lymphocytes and upregulation of Treg cells may play important roles in the immune suppression induced by intravenous administration of a therapeutic protein.

Assessment of a passive immunity mouse model to quantitatively analyze the impact of neutralizing antibodies on adeno-associated virus-mediated gene transfer

Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) are common infective agents of primates. As such, healthy primates carry a large pool of AAV-specific neutralizing antibodies (NAbs), which inhibit AAV-mediated gene transfer therapeutic strategies. Thus, a clinical method to screen patient candidates for AAV-specific NAbs prior to treatment, especially with the frequently used AAV8 capsid component, will facilitate individualized treatment design and enhance therapeutic efficacy. In this study, we evaluated the efficacy and sensitivity of a passive immunity mouse model to quantitatively assess anti-AAV8 NAb titers, as compared to an in vitro immunoassay. The passive transfer model was established in C57BL/6 mice by tail vein injection of pre-defined sera from 23 male rhesus monkeys. The mice were then administered low dose (3e10 GC/mouse) self-complementary (sc) AAV8. The in vitro NAb assay indicated that 69.57% of the rhesus donors had pre-existing anti-AAV8 NAb. The in vivo NAb assay, however, was better able to detect low NAb titer (≤ 1:5), which can mediate neutralization in vivo. Indeed, 17 rhesus donors (74.0%) had pre-existing anti-AAV8 neutralization by in vivo NAb assay. Our findings indicated that the in vivo NAb assay is superior to the in vitro assay for detecting low NAb titers.

Engineering Factor Viii for Hemophilia Gene Therapy

Current treatment of hemophilia A by intravenous infusion of factor VIII (fVIII) concentrates is very costly and has a potential adverse effect of developing inhibitors. Gene therapy, on the other hand, can potentially overcome these limitations associated with fVIII replacement therapy. Although hemophilia B gene therapy has achieved promising outcomes in human clinical trials, hemophilia A gene therapy lags far behind. Compared to factor IX, fVIII is a large protein which is difficult to express at sustaining therapeutic levels when delivered by either viral or non-viral vectors. To improve fVIII gene delivery, numerous strategies have been exploited to engineer the fVIII molecule and overcome the hurdles preventing long term and high level expression. Here we reviewed these strategies, and discussed their pros and cons in human gene therapy of hemophilia A.

Minicircle DNA-based gene therapy coupled with immune modulation permits long-term expression of α-L-iduronidase in mice with mucopolysaccharidosis type I

Mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS I) is a lysosomal storage disease characterized by mutations to the α-L-iduronidase (IDUA) gene resulting in inactivation of the IDUA enzyme. The loss of IDUA protein results in the progressive accumulation of glycosaminoglycans within the lysosomes resulting in severe, multi-organ system pathology. Gene replacement strategies have relied on the use of viral or nonviral gene delivery systems. Drawbacks to these include laborious production procedures, poor efficacy due to plasmid-borne gene silencing, and the risk of insertional mutagenesis. This report demonstrates the efficacy of a nonintegrating, minicircle (MC) DNA vector that is resistant to epigenetic gene silencing in vivo. To achieve sustained expression of the immunogenic IDUA protein we investigated the use of a tissue-specific promoter in conjunction with microRNA target sequences. The inclusion of microRNA target sequences resulted in a slight improvement in long-term expression compared to their absence. However, immune modulation by costimulatory blockade was required and permitted for IDUA expression in MPS I mice that resulted in the biochemical correction of pathology in all of the organs analyzed. MC gene delivery combined with costimulatory pathway blockade maximizes safety, efficacy, and sustained gene expression and is a new approach in the treatment of lysosomal storage disease.

Gene therapy strategies for hemophilia: benefits versus risks

Hemophilia is an inherited bleeding disorder caused by a deficiency of functional clotting factors VIII or IX in the blood plasma. The drawbacks of the classical protein substitution therapy fueled interest in alternative treatments by gene therapy. Hemophilia has been recognized as an ideal target disease for gene therapy because a relatively modest increase in clotting factor levels can result in a significant therapeutic benefit. Consequently, introducing a functional FVIII or FIX gene copy into the appropriate target cells could ultimately provide a cure for hemophilic patients. Several cell types have been explored for hemophilia gene therapy, including hepatocytes, muscle, endothelial and hematopoietic cells. Both nonviral and viral vectors have been considered for the development of hemophilia gene therapy, including transposons, γ-retroviral, lentiviral, adenoviral and adeno-associated viral vectors. Several of these strategies have resulted in stable correction of the bleeding diathesis in hemophilia A and B murine as well as canine models, paving the way towards clinical trials. Although clotting factor expression has been detected in hemophilic patients treated by gene therapy, the challenge now lies in obtaining prolonged therapeutic FVIII or FIX levels in these patients. This review highlights the benefits and potential risks of the different gene therapy strategies for hemophilia that have been developed.

Neonatal helper-dependent adenoviral vector gene therapy mediates correction of hemophilia A and tolerance to human factor VIII

Neonatal gene therapy is a promising strategy for treating a number of congenital diseases diagnosed shortly after birth as expression of therapeutic proteins during postnatal life may limit the pathologic consequences and result in a potential "cure." Hemophilia A is often complicated by the development of antibodies to recombinant protein resulting in treatment failure. Neonatal administration of vectors may avoid inhibitory antibody formation to factor VIII (FVIII) by taking advantage of immune immaturity. A helper-dependent adenoviral vector expressing human factor VIII was administered i.v. to neonatal hemophilia A knockout mice. Three days later, mice produced high levels of FVIII. Levels declined rapidly with animal growth to 5 wk of age with stable factor VIII expression thereafter to >1 y of age. Decline in factor VIII expression was not related to cell-mediated or humoral responses with lack of development of antibodies to capsid or human factor VIII proteins. Subsequent readministration and augmentation of expression was possible as operational tolerance was established to factor VIII without development of inhibitors; however, protective immunity to adenovirus remained.

Enhanced factor VIII heavy chain for gene therapy of hemophilia A

Hemophilia A gene therapy using recombinant adenovirus-associated virus (AAV) vectors has been hampered by the size of the factor VIII (FVIII) cDNA. Previously, splitting the FVIII coding sequence into a heavy-chain (HC) fragment and a light-chain (LC) fragment for dual recombinant AAV vector delivery has been successfully explored. However, the main disadvantage of this approach is a "chain imbalance" problem in which LC secretion is approximately 1-2 logs higher than that of HC, and therefore, the majority of protein synthesized is nonfunctional. To improve HC secretion, we constructed alternate FVIII HCs based on our observation that LC facilitates HC secretion. To our surprise, most of the new HC molecules exhibited enhanced expression over the traditional HC molecule (HC(745)). The optimized HC mutein, HC(HL), including additional acidic-region-3 (ar3) sequences, exhibited three- to fivefold higher activity in both enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT) assay in in vitro testing. Further characterization suggested ar3 sequences increased HC secretion, rather than promoting HC synthesis. Intravenous delivery of AAV8-HC(HL)+AAV8-LC or AAV8-HC(745)+AAV8-LC achieved phenotypic correction in hemophilia A mice. Mice receiving AAV8-HC(HL)+AAV8-LC achieved three- to fourfold higher HC expression than AAV8-HC(745)+AAV8-LC, consistent with the FVIII functional assays. HC(HL) should be substituted for HC(745) in a dual AAV vector strategy due to its enhanced expression.

Antigen-specific tolerance of human alpha1-antitrypsin induced by helper-dependent adenovirus

As efficient and less toxic virus-derived gene therapy vectors are developed, a pressing problem is to avoid immune response to the therapeutic gene product. Secreted therapeutic proteins potentially represent a special problem, as they are readily available to professional antigen-presenting cells throughout the body. Some studies suggest that immunity to serum proteins can be avoided in some mouse strains by using tissue-specific promoters. Here we show that expression of human alpha1-antitrypsin (AAT) was nonimmunogenic in the immune-responsive strain C3H/HeJ, when expressed from helper-dependent (HD) vectors using ubiquitous as well as tissue-specific promoters. Coadministration of less immunogenic HD vectors with an immunogenic first-generation vector failed to immunize, suggesting immune suppression rather than immune stealth. Indeed, mice primed with HD vectors were tolerant to immune challenge with hAAT emulsified in complete Freund's adjuvant. Such animals developed high-titer antibodies to coemulsified human serum albumin, showing that tolerance was antigen specific. AAT-specific T cell responses were depressed in tolerized animals, suggesting that tolerance affects both T and B cells. These results are consistent with models of high-dose tolerance of B cells and certain other suppressive mechanisms, and suggest that a high level of expression from HD vectors can be sufficient to induce specific immune tolerance to serum proteins.

Urgent inhibitor issues: targets for expanded research

Although up to 80% of high-responding inhibitors in patients with severe factor VIII deficiency can be eliminated using heterogeneous regimens for immune tolerance induction, the residual morbidity in this population of haemophilic patients is far from trivial. There is an exigent need for focussed basic, translational and clinical research to extend our understanding of the pathogenesis of haemophilic inhibitor development. In this article, we identify four key research needs, including (i) whether presently available clotting factor concentrates (CFCs) have differential antigenicity, giving rise to clinically relevant immunogenicity; (ii) the interplay of quantitative and qualitative (e.g. age at first exposure) influences of CFCs as well as host-environmental factors (e.g. vaccination effects) on inhibitor development; (iii) the therapeutic role (if any) that concurrent immune tolerance with suppressive or immune-competitive therapeutic strategies play in inhibitor eradication and (iv) pending any major therapeutic advances, alternative or enhanced strategies for treating acute haemorrhage and for preventing chronic haemorrhagic events in these patients.

Multiyear therapeutic benefit of AAV serotypes 2, 6, and 8 delivering factor VIII to hemophilia A mice and dogs

Hemophilia A, a deficiency of functional coagulation factor VIII (FVIII), is treated via protein replacement therapy. Restoring 1% to 5% of normal blood FVIII activity prevents spontaneous bleeding, making the disease an attractive gene therapy target. Previously, we have demonstrated short-term activity of a liver-specific AAV2 vector expressing canine B-domain-deleted FVIII (cFVIII) in a hemophilia canine model. Here, we report the long-term efficacy and safety of AAV-cFVIII vectors of serotypes 2, 5, 6, and 8 in both hemophilia A mice and dogs. AAV6-cFVIII and AAV8-cFVIII restored physiologic levels of plasma FVIII activity in hemophilia A mice. The improved efficacy is attributed to more efficient gene transfer in liver compared with AAV2 and AAV5. However, supraphysiologic cFVIII levels correlated with the formation of cFVIII-neutralizing antibodies in these mice. Of importance, hemophilia A dogs that received AAV2-cFVIII, AAV6-cFVIII, and AAV8-cFVIII have persistently expressed therapeutic levels of FVIII, without antibody formation or other toxicities, for more than 3 years. However, liver transduction efficiencies are similar between AAV2, AAV6, and AAV8 serotypes in hemophilia A dogs, in contrast to mice. In summary, this is the first report demonstrating multiyear therapeutic efficacy and safety of multiple AAV-cFVIII vectors in hemophilia A dogs and provides the basis for human clinical studies.

Widespread correction of lysosomal storage following intrahepatic injection of a recombinant adeno-associated virus in the adult MPS VII mouse

Mucopolysaccharidosis type VII is a lysosomal storage disease caused by deficiency of the acid hydrolase beta-glucuronidase. MPS VII mice develop progressive lysosomal accumulation of glycosaminoglycans within multiple organs, including the brain. Using this animal model, we investigated whether gene transfer mediated by a recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) type 2 vector is capable of reversing the progression of storage in adult mice. We engineered an rAAV2 vector to carry the murine beta-glucuronidase cDNA under the transcriptional direction of the human elongation factor-1alpha promoter. Intrahepatic administration of this vector in adult MPS VII mice resulted in stable hepatic beta-glucuronidase expression (473 +/- 254% of that found in wild-type mouse liver) for at least 1 year postinjection. There was widespread distribution of vector genomes and beta-glucuronidase within extrahepatic organs. The level of enzyme activity was sufficient to reduce lysosomal storage within the liver, spleen, kidney, heart, lung, and brain. Within selected regions of the brain, neuronal, glial, and perivascular cells had histopathologic evidence of reduced storage. Also, brain alpha-galactosidase and beta-hexosaminidase enzyme levels, secondarily elevated by the storage abnormality, were normalized. These data demonstrate that peripheral administration of an rAAV2 vector in adult MPS VII mice can lead to transgene expression levels sufficient for improvements in both the peripheral and the central manifestations of this disease.

Tolerance induction by viral in vivo gene transfer

Treatment of genetic disease by protein or gene replacement therapy is hampered by immune responses to the therapeutic protein. An excellent example is formation of inhibitory antibodies to coagulation factors in treatment of the X-linked bleeding disorder hemophilia. Experiments in murine and canine models of hemophilia B (deficiency in factor IX) have demonstrated sustained therapeutic levels of factor IX transgene expression following hepatic adeno-associated viral gene transfer in animals with deletion and nonsense mutations in the factor IX gene. This article reviews experimental evidence for induction of immune tolerance to the factor IX transgene product by hepatic adeno-associated viral gene transfer, which has been shown to limit T helper cell responses and to substantially reduce the risk of antibody responses. Tolerance induction is associated with activation of regulatory CD4(+) T cells capable of suppressing antibody formation to factor IX protein. Hepatic administration of adeno-associated viral vector expressing ovalbumin in mice transgenic for a T cell receptor specific for this antigen provided direct evidence for induction of CD4(+) T cell tolerance, including T cell anergy and clonal deletion. Taken together, these data indicate the potential for viral in vivo gene transfer not only to provide sustained systemic expression, but moreover to induce immunological hypo-responsiveness to the therapeutic gene product.

Preclinical and clinical gene therapy for haemophilia

The goal of all haemophilia therapy is to prevent bleeding and its associated complications. Replacement by factor concentrates can only ever be suboptimum, and efforts are being made to correct the genetic cause of the disorder. Haemophilia is an ideal candidate for gene therapy, as it is caused by mutations in a single gene. A number of vectors have been used in an attempt to obtain therapeutic levels of factor VIII and factor IX in animal models, with some success. A number of phase 1 clinical trials have been conducted, and, although connection of the bleeding disorder was neither complete nor long-lasting, they do offer hope for a permanent gene-therapy cure for the disease.

Gene therapy of the hemophilias

Development of hemophilia gene therapy depends on testing gene transfer vectors in hemophilic and nonhemophilic animals. Available animal models include factor VIII or factor IX knockout mice as well as dogs with spontaneous hemophilia A or B. Large animals (particularly dogs) more closely replicate the requirements for correction of human hemophilia than do mice. Small animals are more convenient to maintain and require significantly less vector for testing than do large animals. Nonhemophilic animals (mice or nonhuman primates), whose endogenous factor VIII and factor IX complicate analysis of the human proteins, have utility for safety testing of vectors; some assays can discriminate between human coagulation factors and the endogenous coagulation factors. Most animal models suffer the limitations imposed by the immune response to human factor VIII or IX protein. Clinical trials have failed to achieve significant factor VIII expression in hemophilia A patients, while one clinical trial in hemophilia B patients showed only transient therapeutic increments of factor IX expression. Gene therapy remains an investigational method with many obstacles to overcome before it can be widely used as treatment for hemophilia.

Inhibitors in hemophilia A

Factor VIII (FVIII) replacement therapy remains the mainstay in hemophilia A care. The major complication of replacement therapy is formation of antibodies, which inhibit FVIII activity, thus dramatically reducing treatment efficiency. The present review summarizes the accumulated knowledge on epitopes of FVIII inhibitors and mechanisms of their inhibitory effects. FVIII inhibitors most frequently target the A2, C2 and A3 domains of FVIII and interfere with important interactions of FVIII at various stages of its functional pathway; a class of FVIII inhibitors inactivates FVIII by proteolysis. We discuss therapeutic approaches currently used for treatment of hemophilia A patients with inhibitors and analyze the factors that influence the outcome. The choice between options should depend on the level of inhibitors and consideration of efficacy, safety, and availability of particular regimens. Advances of basic science open avenues for alternative targeted, specific and long-lasting treatments, such as the use of peptide decoys for blocking FVIII inhibitors, bypassing them with human/porcine FVIII hybrids, neutralizing FVIII-reactive CD4 T cells with anti-clonotypic antibodies, or inducing immune tolerance to FVIII with the use of universal CD4 epitopes or by genetic approaches.

A nonproliferating parvovirus vaccine vector elicits sustained, protective humoral immunity following a single intravenous or intranasal inoculation

An ideal vaccine delivery system would elicit persistent protection following a single administration, preferably by a noninvasive route, and be safe even in the face of immunosuppression, either inherited or acquired, of the recipient. We have exploited the unique life cycle of the autonomous parvoviruses to develop a nonproliferating vaccine platform that appears to both induce priming and continually boost a protective immune response following a single inoculation. A crippled parvovirus vector was constructed, based on a chimera between minute virus of mice (MVM) and LuIII, which expresses Borrelia burgdorferi outer surface protein A (OspA) instead of its coat protein. The vector was packaged into an MVM lymphotropic capsid and inoculated into naive C3H/HeNcr mice. Vaccination with a single vector dose, either intravenously or intranasally, elicited high-titer anti-OspA-specific antibody that provided protection from live spirochete challenge and was sustained over the lifetime of the animal. Both humoral and cell-mediated Th(1) immunity was induced, as shown by anti-OspA immunoglobulin G2a antibody and preferential gamma interferon production by OspA-specific CD4(+) T cells.

Sustained transgene expression by human cord blood derived CD34+ cells transduced with simian immunodeficiency virus agmTYO1-based vectors carrying the human coagulation factor VIII gene in NOD/SCID mice

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy is being studied as the next generation therapy for hemophilia and several clinical trials have been carried out, albeit with limited success. To explore the possibility of utilizing autologous bone marrow transplantation of genetically modified hematopoietic stem cells for hemophilia gene therapy, we investigated the efficacy of genetically engineered CD34+ cell transplantation to NOD/SCID mice for expression of human factor VIII (hFVIII).

METHODS

CD34+ cells were transduced with a simian immunodeficiency virus agmTYO1 (SIV)-based lentiviral vector carrying the enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) gene (SIVeGFP) or the hFVIII gene (SIVhFVIII). CD34+ cells transduced with SIV vectors were transplanted to NOD/SCID mice. Engraftment of transduced CD34+ cells and expression of transgenes were studied.

RESULTS

We could efficiently transduce CD34+ cells using the SIVeGFP vector in a dose-dependent manner, reaching a maximum (99.6 +/- 0.1%) at MOI of 5 x 10(3) vector genome/cell. After transducing CD34+ cells with SIVhFVIII, hFVIII was produced (274.3 +/- 20.1 ng) from 10(6) CD34+ cells during 24 h in vitro incubation. Transplantation of SIVhFVIII-transduced CD34+ cells (5-10 x 10(5)) at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 50 vector genome/cell into NOD/SCID mice resulted in successful engraftment of CD34+ cells and production of hFVIII (minimum 1.2 +/- 0.9 ng/mL, maximum 3.6 +/- 0.8 ng/mL) for at least 60 days in vivo. Transcripts of the hFVIII gene and the hFVIII antigen were also detected in the murine bone marrow cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of ex vivo transduced hematopoietic stem cells by non-pathogenic SIVhFVIII without exposure of subjects to viral vectors is safe and potentially applicable for gene therapy of hemophilia A patients.

Induction of megakaryocytes to synthesize and store a releasable pool of human factor VIII

von Willebrand factor (VWF) is a complex plasma glycoprotein that modulates platelet adhesion at the site of a vascular injury, and it also serves as a carrier protein for factor (F)VIII. As megakaryocytes are the only hematopoietic lineage to naturally synthesize and store VWF within alpha-granules, this study was performed to determine if expression of a FVIII transgene in megakaryocytes could lead to trafficking and storage of FVIII with VWF in platelet alpha-granules. Isolex selected CD34+ cells from human G-CSF mobilized peripheral blood cells (PBC) and murine bone marrow were transduced with a retrovirus encoding the B-domain deleted form of human FVIII (BDD-FVIII). Cells were then induced with cytokines to form a population of multiple lineages including megakaryocytes. Chromogenic analysis of culture supernatant from FVIII-transduced human cells demonstrated synthesis of functional FVIII. Treatment of cells with agonists of platelet activation (ADP, epinephrine, and thrombin receptor-activating peptide) resulted in the release of VWF antigen and active FVIII into the supernatant from transduced cells. Immunofluorescence analysis of cultured human and murine megakaryocytes revealed a punctate pattern of staining for FVIII that was consistent with staining for VWF. Electron microscopy of transduced megakaryocytes using immunogold-conjugated antibodies colocalized FVIII and VWF within the alpha-granules. FVIII retained its association with VWF in human platelets isolated from the peripheral blood of NOD/SCID mice at 2-6 weeks post-transplant of transduced human PBC. These results suggest feasibility for the development of a locally inducible secretory pool of FVIII in platelets of patients with hemophilia A.

Recombinant factor VIII expression in hematopoietic cells following lentiviral transduction

Autologous transplantation of gene-modified hematopoietic stem cells may provide a therapeutic strategy for several monogeneic disorders. In previous studies, retroviral gene transfer of coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) into FVIII(-/-) mouse bone marrow (BM) cells did not result in detectable plasma FVIII levels. However, specific immune tolerance was achieved against neo-antigenic FVIII. Here, we used lentiviral vectors to study the ability of various hematopoietic cell types to synthesize and secrete recombinant FVIII. Several myeloid, monocytic and megakaryocytic cell lines (K-562, TF-1, Monomac-1, Mutz-3, Meg-01) expressed FVIII at 2-12 mU/10(4) cells. In contrast, two lymphatic cell lines, BV-173 and Molt-4, were less-efficiently transduced and did not express detectable FVIII. Similarly, peripheral blood-derived primary monocytes were transduced efficiently and expressed up to 20 mU/10(4) cells, whereas primary lymphocytes did not express FVIII. Although human and canine CD34(+) cells were transduced efficiently, the cells expressed very low levels of FVIII (up to 0.8 mU/10(4) cells). Following xenotransplantation of transduced CD34(+) into NOD/SCID mice, ELISA failed to detect FVIII in the plasma of engrafted mice. However, NOD/SCID repopulating cell (SRC)-derived human monocytes isolated from BM of these mice secreted functional recombinant FVIII after culture ex vivo. Again, SRC-derived human lymphocytes did not secrete FVIII. Therefore, certain hematopoietic cell types are able to synthesize and secrete functional recombinant FVIII. Our results show for the first time that transplantation of transduced CD34(+) progenitors may give rise to differentiated hematopoietic cells secreting a nonhematopoietic recombinant protein.

Total correction of hemophilia A mice with canine FVIII using an AAV 8 serotype

Despite the popularity of adeno-associated virus 2 (AAV2) as a vehicle for gene transfer, its efficacy for liver-directed gene therapy in hemophilia A or B has been suboptimal. Here we evaluated AAV serotypes 2, 5, 7, and 8 in gene therapy of factor VIII (FVIII) deficiency in a hemophilia A mouse model and found that AAV8 was superior to the other 3 serotypes. We expressed canine B domain-deleted FVIII cDNA either in a single vector or in 2 separate AAV vectors containing the heavy- and light-chain cDNAs. We also evaluated AAV8 against AAV2 in intraportal and tail vein injections. AAV8 gave 100% correction of plasma FVIII activity irrespective of the vector type or route of administration.

Sustained phenotypic correction of canine hemophilia A using an adeno-associated viral vector

Gene therapy for hemophilia A requires efficient delivery of the factor VIII gene and sustained protein expression at circulating levels of at least 1% to 2% of normal. Adeno-associated viral type 2 (AAV2) vectors have a number of advantages over other viral vectors, including an excellent safety profile and persistent gene expression. However, a major disadvantage is their small packaging capacity, which has hampered their use in treating diseases such as hemophilia A, cystic fibrosis, and muscular dystrophy, which are caused by mutations in large genes. Here we demonstrate that this can be overcome by using small regulatory elements to drive expression of a B-domain-deleted form of FVIII. The use of this vector for hepatic gene transfer in a canine model of hemophilia A resulted in the sustained (> 14 months) expression of biologically active FVIII. FVIII activity levels of 2% to 4% were achieved. These levels correlated with a partial correction in the whole-blood clotting time and cuticle bleeding time. In addition, immunoprecipitation analysis demonstrated the expression of canine FVIII of the predicted size in the plasma of injected animals. These data support the use of AAV2 vectors in human clinical trials to treat hemophilia A patients.

Gene therapy for the hemophilias

Significant progress has recently been made in the development of gene therapy for the treatment of hemophilia A and B. These advances parallel the development of improved gene delivery systems. Long-term therapeutic levels of factor (F) VIII and FIX can be achieved in adult FVIII- and FIX-deficient mice and in adult hemophiliac dogs using adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors, high-capacity adenoviral vectors (HC-Ad) and lentiviral vectors. In mouse models, some of the highest FVIII or FIX expression levels were achieved using HC-Ad vectors with no or only limited adverse effects. Encouraging preclinical data have been obtained using AAV vectors, yielding long-term FIX levels above 10% in primates and in hemophilia B dogs, which prevented spontaneous bleeding. Non-viral ex vivo gene therapy approaches have also led to long-term therapeutic levels of coagulation factors in animal models. Nevertheless, the induction of neutralizing antibodies (inhibitors) to FVIII or FIX sometimes precludes stable phenotypic correction following gene therapy. The risk of inhibitor formation varies depending on the type of vector, vector serotype, vector dose, expression levels and promoter used, route of administration, transduced cell type and the underlying mutation in the hemophilia model. Some studies suggest that continuous expression of clotting factors may induce immune tolerance, particularly when expressed by the liver. Several gene therapy phase I clinical trials have been initiated in patients suffering from severe hemophilia A or B. Some subjects report fewer bleeding episodes and occasionally have low levels of clotting factor activity detected. Further improvement of the various gene delivery systems is warranted to bring a permanent cure for hemophilia one step closer to reality.

Immune responses to adeno-associated virus and its recombinant vectors

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors have emerged as highly promising for use in gene transfer for a variety of reasons, including lack of pathogenicity and wide host range. In addition, all virus-encoded genes have been removed from standard rAAV vectors, resulting in their comparatively low intrinsic immunogenicity. For gene replacement strategies, transgenes encoded by rAAV vectors may induce less robust host immune responses than other vectors in vivo. However, under appropriate conditions, host immune responses can be generated against rAAV-encoded transgenes, raising the potential for their use in vaccine development. In this review, we summarize current understanding of the generation of both undesirable and beneficial host immune responses directed against rAAV and encoded transgenes, and how they might be exploited for optimal use of this promising vector system.

Gene therapy progress and prospects: gene therapy for the hemophilias

Recent gene transfer trials for hemophilia A and B, bleeding disorders lacking either functional factor VIII or IX, respectively, have produced tantalizing results, suggesting that the potential to correct these bleeding disorders at a molecular level may be at hand. Genetic correction of the hemophilias represents a model system to develop a basic understanding of how gene therapy will be achieved. The goals for hemophilia gene transfer require the long-term therapeutic production of the coagulant protein without stimulating an immune response to the transgene product or the vector. Based on a scientific understanding of the molecular and cellular defects, leading to the bleeding phenotype, impressive strides have been made in the last 2 years.

Immunity to adenovirus and adeno-associated viral vectors: implications for gene therapy

Viral vectors have provided effective methods for in vivo gene delivery for therapeutic purposes. The ability of viruses to infect a wide variety of cell types in vivo has been exploited for several applications, such as liver, lung, muscle, brain, eye and many others. Immune responses directed towards the viral capsids and the transgene products have severely affected the ability of these vectors to induce long-term gene expression. This paper reviews the influence of viral vectors on antigen-presenting cells (APC), which are central to the induction of innate as well as adaptive immune responses. In this respect, we have focused on adenovirus and adeno-associated viruses because of the polar responses these vector systems induce in vivo. While adenovirus vector can induce significant inflammatory responses, adeno-associated viral vectors are characterized by their inability to consistantly induce immune responses to the transgene product. Understanding the mechanism of infection, transduction and activation of APC by viral vectors will provide strategies to develop safe vectors and prevent immune responses in gene therapies.

Induction of immune tolerance to coagulation factor IX antigen by in vivo hepatic gene transfer

Gene replacement therapy is an attractive approach for treatment of genetic disease, but may be complicated by the risk of a neutralizing immune response to the therapeutic gene product. There are examples of humoral and cellular immune responses against the transgene product as well as absence of such responses, depending on vector design and the underlying mutation in the dysfunctional gene. It has been unclear, however, whether transgene expression can induce tolerance to the therapeutic antigen. Here, we demonstrate induction of immune tolerance to a secreted human coagulation factor IX (hF.IX) antigen by adeno-associated viral gene transfer to the liver. Tolerized mice showed absence of anti-hF.IX and substantially reduced in vitro T cell responses after immunization with hF.IX in adjuvant. Tolerance induction was antigen specific, affected a broad range of Th cell subsets, and was favored by higher levels of transgene expression as determined by promoter strength, vector dose, and mouse strain. Hepatocyte-derived hF.IX expression induced regulatory CD4(+) T cells that can suppress anti-hF.IX formation after adoptive transfer. With a strain-dependent rate of success, tolerance to murine F.IX was induced in mice with a large F.IX gene deletion, supporting the relevance of these data for treatment of hemophilia B and other genetic diseases.

Efficient production of human FVIII in hemophilic mice using lentiviral vectors

Lentiviral vectors (LV) have the ability to integrate their proviral DNA containing a therapeutic gene into the host cell's genome. Therefore, these vectors have a great potential for gene therapy especially in the treatment of hereditary diseases like hemophilia A, which require lifelong expression of the transgene. We constructed an HIV-1-based LV containing human B-domain-deleted factor VIII (FVIII) cDNA under the control of a promoter consisting of the chicken beta-actin promoter, CMV enhancers, and a large synthetic intron (CAG), which is a robust transcription promoter. High levels of FVIII expression from this vector could be demonstrated in vitro in 293T cells, primary liver cells, and hematopoietic progenitor cells. To test whether this viral vector was able to correct the bleeding disorder of C57BL/6 FVIII knockout mice, we transduced these mice with the FVIII LV either by intraperitoneal injection or by transplantation with transduced syngeneic bone marrow. FVIII production was analyzed in the blood plasma for a period of 3 months; however, only low levels of FVIII (<50 mU), which were below 5% of normal FVIII levels of 1000 mU, could be detected. Further analysis revealed that the low levels of FVIII activity present in the blood plasma were due to the presence of neutralizing antibodies to FVIII and not due to lack of expression of FVIII from the viral vector. FVIII expression could be detected in the tissues of the transduced mice by Western blot analysis and in ex vivo cultures. These data demonstrate that LVs are able to produce therapeutic levels of FVIII in knockout mice when administered by ip infection or by transduced hematopoietic cells. The challenge is to overcome the immune barriers to the therapeutic gene product.

Adenoassociated virus vectors for genetic immunization

Genetic immunization has initiated a new era of vaccine research, which provides a stable and long-lived source of the protein antigen. Such a vaccine is a simple, robust, and effective means of eliciting both antibody- and cell-mediated immune responses compared with protein or peptide vaccines. Although naked DNA vaccines are relatively simple to produce and handle without significant toxicity or host immunity, those using viral vectors have shown greater efficacy in gene transfer and in inducing both protective and therapeutic immunity in preclinical models. However, clinical translation of results obtained in animal studies with viral vectors has not met with anticipated success so far because of inherent limitations of the vector-associated immunity and antigen specificity. Thus, understanding the requirements for the elicitation of target-specific immunity in host requires that a major cellular arm be unraveled, and modifications of the existing viral vectors and testing of newer ones encompass the technological arm of vaccine research. In this article, I give a comprehensive account of the potential of adenoassociated virus, a nonpathogenic human parvovirus in vaccine development.

Dual vectors expressing murine factor VIII result in sustained correction of hemophilia A mice

Hemophilia A is a sex-linked disorder that results from a deficiency of functional factor VIII and is currently treated by protein replacement therapies. Within the past decade, gene therapy efforts have come to the forefront of novel therapeutics. In this work, a dual-vector approach was employed in which recombinant adeno-associated viral (rAAV) vectors expressing the heavy and light chains of the murine factor VIII gene were delivered either intramuscularly or intravenously to a mouse model of hemophilia A. From in vitro work, it was determined that coinfection with both vectors is required as heterodimerization of the heavy and light chains occurs intracellularly. In vivo, therapeutic levels of factor VIII expression were achieved throughout the duration of the study (22 weeks). Intravenous and intramuscular delivery resulted in a maximal average expression of 31.4 +/- 6.4 and 29 +/- 6.5% of normal murine factor VIII levels, respectively. Western blots of cryoprecipitate as well as immunostaining of injection sites with an anti-murine factor VIII light chain antibody also confirmed the expression of factor VIII. Because the murine form of the gene was used in the mouse model, less than 1 Bethesda unit of inhibitors was noted. This work demonstrates the feasibility of using rAAV vectors for the long-term treatment of hemophilia A.

Bone marrow mesenchymal cells for haemophilia A gene therapy using retroviral vectors with modified long-terminal repeats

Bone marrow (BM) cells are attractive target cells for ex vivo gene therapy of genetic diseases, including haemophilia A. However, BM-derived haematopoietic stem/progenitor cells (HSCs) transduced with factor VIII (FVIII) retroviral vectors, failed to express FVIII in vivo. To overcome the limitations of HSCs for haemophilia gene therapy, BM-derived mesenchymal cells were explored as alternative target cells. The BM mesenchymal cell population contains self-renewing mesenchymal stem/progenitor cells that give rise to different mesenchymal lineages and have been used safely in phase I gene-marking trials. Human BM mesenchymal cells were transduced in vitro with an improved retroviral vector encoding a human B-domain deleted FVIII (hFVIIIdeltaB) cDNA (MND-MFG-hFVIIIdeltaB). This vector contains multiple modifications in the cis-acting elements within the MoMLV long-terminal repeats (LTR) that prevent the binding of repressive transcription factors. These modifications were previously shown to increase and prolong gene expression in embryonic stem (ES) cells and HSCs. Transduction of BM mesenchymal cells with the MND-MFG-hFVIIIdeltaB retroviral vector resulted in high levels of functional human FVIII in vitro, ranging between 300 +/- 50 SD and 700 +/- 100 SD mU per 106 cells per 24 h. Following xenografting of the transduced human BM cells into immunodeficient NOD-SCID mice, therapeutic hFVIII levels of 12 +/- 10 ng mL-1 were detected in the plasma. Polymerase chain reaction analysis demonstrated long-term engraftment (>3 months) of the human BM mesenchymal cells. The long-term persistence of BM mesenchymal cells in the absence of myelo-ablative conditioning and the therapeutic FVIII levels in vivo underscore the potential usefulness of BM-derived mesenchymal cells for haemophilia gene therapy, as opposed to BM-derived HSCs. Despite the modifications of the MoMLV LTR, FVIII expression declined, which coincided with a decrease in FVIII mRNA transcription levels, indicating that the salutary effect of the LTR modification on transgene expression is not universally applicable to all cell types.

Dangerous liaisons: the role of "danger" signals in the immune response to gene therapy

Recent studies in gene transfer suggest that the innate immune system plays a significant role in impeding gene therapy. In this review, we examine factors that might influence the recruitment and activation of the innate system in the context of gene therapy. We have adopted a novel model of immunology that contends that the immune system distinguishes not between self and nonself, but between what is dangerous and what is not dangerous. In taking this perspective, we provide an alternative and complementary insight into some of the failures and successes of current gene therapy protocols.

Safety of adeno-associated virus gene therapy vectors: a current evaluation

An increasing number of strategies for molecular treatment of disease rely on the adeno-associated virus (AAV) as a therapeutic gene delivery vector. One of the most attractive features of this viral DNA vector is the perceived safety of AAV gene delivery. Recent applications in human clinical trials support the safety record established in preclinical trials, with evidence of gene transfer in the absence of cellular immune responses or tissue disturbance. Nevertheless, many aspects of the biology of the wild type AAV and its derivatives are still being explored. While the therapeutic potential of novel recombinant AAV therapeutics appears promising, recent insights suggest aspects of their pharmacokinetics, biodistribution and toxicity that require consideration to achieve the safest application of these molecular medicines.

Gene therapy for the hemophilias

Recent advances in the field of gene transfer are producing tantalizing results suggesting that the potential to correct disease at a molecular level may be at hand. Genetic correction of the hemophilias--bleeding disorders that stem from the deficiency of functional factor VIII or IX--represent models for the development of a basic understanding of how gene therapy will be achieved. The goals for hemophilia gene transfer are to produce therapeutic amounts of the coagulant protein while minimizing an immune response or antibody inhibitor. This requires the use of nontoxic vectors to deliver genes that express the protein in a functional form for the life of the patient. Based on a scientific understanding of the molecular and cellular defects leading to the bleeding phenotype, gene transfer studies at the laboratory and clinic have produced exciting results. The author here provides a critical assessment of the state of hemophilia gene transfer and its relevance to the field as a whole.

Adenovirus-mediated factor VIII gene expression results in attenuated anti-factor VIII-specific immunity in hemophilia A mice compared with factor VIII protein infusion

Hemophilia A patients are typically treated by factor VIII (FVIII) protein replacement, an expensive therapy that induces FVIII-specific inhibitors in approximately 30% of patients with severe hemophilia. FVIII gene therapy has the potential to improve the current treatment protocols. In this report, we used a hemophilia A mouse model to compare the humoral and cellular immune responses between an E1/E2a/E3-deficient adenovirus expressing human FVIII directed by a liver-specific albumin promoter and purified recombinant FVIII protein infusion. Adenovirus-mediated FVIII expression did not elicit detectable CD4+ or CD8+ T cell responses and induced a weak antibody immune response to FVIII. In contrast, FVIII protein administration resulted in a potent anti-FVIII antibody response and moderate CD4+ T cell response. Furthermore, hemophiliac mice preimmunized with FVIII protein infusion to induce anti-FVIII immunity, and subsequently treated by adenovirus-mediated FVIII gene therapy, expressed therapeutic levels of FVIII despite the presence of low levels of anti-FVIII antibodies. No FVIII was detected in the plasma of mice with intermediate or high antibody levels, although anti-FVIII antibody levels in some vector-treated animals declined. The data support the hypothesis that liver-specific gene therapy-mediated expression of FVIII may be less immunogenic than traditional protein replacement therapy.