Lack of dominant-negative effects of a truncated gamma(c) on retroviral-mediated gene correction of immunodeficient mice

Leukemia Cells and the Cytokine Network: Therapeutic Prospects

The network and balance of cytokines is of major importance in maintaining proper homeostasis of hematopoiesis. Abnormalities in this network may result in a variety of blood disorders; however, the role of this network is not clear in leukemia. The use of antineoplastic agents has improved the survival rate of some types of leukemia, and adjunctive therapy with cytokines may be helpful. Chemotherapeutic approaches are no longer the best choice because cytotoxicity may affect normal and leukemic cells, and leukemic cells may develop resistance to the chemotherapeutic agent. Induction of differentiation to a mature phenotype and the control of apoptotic-gene expression have provided other possible alternative therapies. Combined effects of cytokines and vitamin derivatives such as retinoic acid (RA) and 1, 25 dihydroxyvitamin D3 (VD3) were found more beneficial than any of these agents individually. These agents exhibit cooperative effects, potentiate each other's effects, or both. Therefore, understanding the hematopoietic actions of these agents, their interactions with their receptors, and their differentiation signaling pathways may result In the design of new therapies. However, the role of cytokines in apoptosis is controversial because in some cases they were found to increase tumor cell resistance to apoptosis-inducing agents. Recent studies in the molecular biology of gene regulation, transcription factors, and repressors have led to new possible approaches such as differentiation therapy for the treatment of leukemia. In addition, the development of drugs that act on the molecular level such as imatinib is just the beginning of a new era in molecular targeted therapy in which the drug acts specifically on the leukemic cell. There are many possible combinations of cytokines, retinoids, and VD3, and perhaps the best therapeutic combination is yet to be described. This minireview is an update on the role of cytokines and the therapeutic potential of combinations with agents such as RA, VD3, and other chemotherapeutic agents.

Gene therapy model of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency using a modified foamy virus vector

X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID-X1) is an inherited genetic immunodeficiency associated with mutations in the common cytokine receptor γ chain (γc) gene, and characterized by a complete defect of T and natural killer (NK) cells. Gene therapy for SCID-X1 using conventional retroviral (RV) vectors carrying the γc gene results in the successful reconstitution of T cell immunity. However, the high incidence of vector-mediated T cell leukemia, caused by vector insertion near or within cancer-related genes has been a serious problem. In this study, we established a gene therapy model of mouse SCID-X1 using a modified foamy virus (FV) vector expressing human γc. Analysis of vector integration in a human T cell line demonstrated that the FV vector integration sites were significantly less likely to be located within or near transcriptional start sites than RV vector integration sites. To evaluate the therapeutic efficacy, bone marrow cells from γc-knockout (γc-KO) mice were infected with the FV vector and transplanted into γc-KO mice. Transplantation of the FV-treated cells resulted in the successful reconstitution of functionally active T and B cells. These data suggest that FV vectors can be effective and may be safer than conventional RV vectors for gene therapy for SCID-X1.

Implications for gene therapy-limiting expression of IL-2R gamma c delineate differences in signaling thresholds required for lymphocyte development and maintenance

X-linked SCID patients are deficient in functional IL-2Rgamma(c) leading to the loss of IL-2/IL-4/IL-7/IL-9/IL-15/IL-21 signaling and a lack of NK and mature T cells. Patients treated with IL-2Rgamma(c) gene therapy have T cells develop; however, their NK cell numbers remain low, suggesting antiviral responses may be compromised. Similarly, IL-2Rgamma(c)(-/-) mice reconstituted with IL-2Rgamma(c) developed few NK cells, and reconstituted T cells exhibited defective proliferative responses suggesting incomplete recovery of IL-2Rgamma(c) signaling. Given the shift toward self-inactivating long terminal repeats with weaker promoters to control the risk of leukemia, we assessed NK and T cell numbers and function in IL-2Rgamma(c)(-/-) mice reconstituted with limiting amounts of IL-2Rgamma(c). Reconstitution resulted in lower IL-2/-15-mediated STAT5 phosphorylation and proliferation in NK and T cells. However, TCR costimulation restored cytokine-driven T cell proliferation to wild-type levels. Vector modifications that improved IL-2Rgamma(c) levels increased cytokine-induced STAT5 phosphorylation in both populations and increased NK cell proliferation demonstrating that IL-2Rgamma(c) levels are limiting. In addition, although the half-lives of both NK and T cells expressing intermediate levels of IL-2Rgamma(c) are reduced compared with wild-type cells, the reduction in NK cell half-live is much more severe than in T cells. Collectively, these data indicate different IL-2Rgamma(c) signaling thresholds for lymphocyte development and proliferation making functional monitoring imperative during gene therapy. Further, our findings suggest that IL-2Rgamma(c) reconstituted T cells may persist more efficiently than NK cells due to compensation for suboptimal IL-2Rgamma(c) signaling by the TCR.

Gene therapy: therapeutic gene causing lymphoma

The development of T-cell leukaemia following the otherwise successful treatment of three patients with X-linked severe combined immune deficiency (X-SCID) in gene-therapy trials using haematopoietic stem cells has led to a re-evaluation of this approach. Using a mouse model for gene therapy of X-SCID, we find that the corrective therapeutic gene IL2RG itself can act as a contributor to the genesis of T-cell lymphomas, with one-third of animals being affected. Gene-therapy trials for X-SCID, which have been based on the assumption that IL2RG is minimally oncogenic, may therefore pose some risk to patients.

Gene therapy for severe combined immunodeficiency

Studies of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID), a group of rare monogenic disorders, have provided key findings about the physiology of immune system development. The common characteristic of these diseases is the occurrence of a block in T cell differentiation, always associated with a direct or indirect impairment of B cell immunity. The resulting combined immunodeficiency is responsible for the clinical severity of SCID, which, without treatment, leads to death within the first year of life. Eleven distinct SCID phenotypes have been identified to date. Mutations of ten genes have been found to cause SCID. Identifying the pathophysiological basis of most SCID conditions has led to the possibility of molecular therapy as an alternative to allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. This review discusses recent developments in SCID identification and treatment.

Gene therapy for immunodeficiency diseases

Primary immunodeficiency diseases represent good targets for hematopoietic stem cell-targeted gene therapy. Severe combined immunodeficiencies (SCID) have been the first examples of successful gene therapy based on the ex vivo usage of retroviral vectors. New advances in the technology of gene transfer should further promote gene therapy as a safe and effective therapeutic strategy of immunodeficiency diseases.

Chance or necessity? Insertional mutagenesis in gene therapy and its consequences

Recently, unusual forms of leukemias have developed as complications following retroviral transfer of potentially therapeutic genes into hematopoietic cells. A crucial component in the pathogenesis of these complications was the upregulation of a cellular proto-oncogene by random insertion of the retroviral gene transfer vector. These findings have great implications for the genetic manipulation of somatic stem cells in medicine. This review discusses the extent to which the random oncogene activation may have required disease-specific stimuli of the transgene and the hematopoietic milieu to become leukemogenic. Based on these considerations, we propose approaches to risk prediction and prevention.

In vivo retroviral gene transfer by direct intrafemoral injection results in correction of the SCID phenotype in Jak3 knock-out animals

Efficient retroviral gene transfer to pluripotential hematopoietic stem cells (PHSCs) requires ex vivo culture in multiple hematopoietic growth factors (HGFs) to promote cell division. While treatment of PHSCs with HGF can render stem cells viable targets for retroviral infection, HGFs can promote differentiation, loss of self-renewal potential, and affect the homing/engraftment capacity of PHSCs. To avoid the negative impacts observed with ex vivo transduction protocols, we developed a murine model for in vivo retroviral infection by direct intrafemoral injection (DII), thus abolishing the need for removal of cells from their native microenvironment and the signals necessary to maintain their unique physiology. Using this approach we have demonstrated in vivo retroviral gene transfer to colony-forming units-c (CFU-c), short-term reconstituting cells, and PHSCs. Moreover, direct intrafemoral injection of Jak3 knock-out mice with retroviral particles encoding the Jak3 gene resulted in reconstitution of normally deficient lymphocyte populations concomitant with improved immune function. In addition, DII can be used to target the delivery of other gene therapy vectors including adenoviral vectors to bone marrow cells in vivo. Taken together, these results demonstrate that in vivo retroviral gene transfer by direct intrafemoral injection may be a viable alternative to current ex vivo gene transfer approaches.

Gene transfer into rabbit keratocytes using AAV and lipid-mediated plasmid DNA vectors with a lamellar flap for stromal access

Development of gene transfer methods that can precisely deliver therapeutic genes to the localized or targeted tissue(s) would be highly beneficial in developing new gene therapy approaches and may also extend animal models for studying in vivo gene function and regulation at molecular levels in the selected tissues. We investigated lipid- and AAV-mediated gene transfer in rabbit cornea using a lamellar flap-technique. The goals of this study were to (1) analyze methods for in situ gene transfer into keratocytes, (2) identify efficient and suitable vectors for gene transfer into keratocytes, and (3) characterize times of first detectable expression, localization and duration of transgene expression in keratocytes with different vectors. A lamellar flap was produced in the rabbit cornea with a microkeratome. Recombinant adeno-associated viral vector (rAAV) expressing either beta-galactosidase (rAAV-beta-gal) or chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (rAAV-CAT) reporter genes, or plasmid-cationic lipid complexes expressing CAT (pMP6-CAT) or beta-galactosidase (pTR-beta-gal) were applied beneath the lamellar flap for two minutes. The flap was repositioned and eyelids sutured overnight. Corneas were removed at 4hr, 12hr, 36hr, 3 days, 7 days, or 10 days after application and either fixed in 2% formaldehyde, cryosectioned and stained for beta-galactosidase activity or homogenized and measured for CAT levels by ELISA. Corneas infected with rAAV-beta-gal vector showed positive beta-gal staining in the center and periphery of the flap interface in whole corneas and corneal beds at 3, 7, and 10 days, but not at earlier time points. Corneas treated with pTR-beta-gal plasmid vector showed positive beta-gal expression at the interface at 4, 12 and 36hr, but not at 3 or 7 days. The posterior surface of the lamellar interface where the vector was applied showed more expression than the overlying anterior surface with both plasmid and viral vectors. The level of gene expression was less with plasmid vector than viral vector monitored using beta-gal staining. CAT-ELISA confirmed expression of the CAT reporter gene with either the plasmid or rAAV vector. These results demonstrate that foreign genes can be introduced into keratocytes with plasmid or viral vectors using a lamellar flap to gain access to the stroma. The expression profile of the reporter genes depended on the vector. Transfection of keratocytes with plasmid vectors produced rapid expression of the reporter genes, but for a short duration. Reporter gene expression following transduction by rAAV vector was delayed several days, but was at higher levels and for a longer duration. This is the first report to demonstrate selective gene transfer into keratocytes and would be highly useful in studying function and regulation of genes in vivo and may eventually furnish a tool for the treatment of corneal dystrophies.

Gene therapy in infants with severe combined immunodeficiency

Severe combined immunodeficiencies (SCID) are rare disorders that represent paediatric medical emergencies, as the outcome for affected patients can easily be fatal unless proper treatment is performed. The only curative treatment for SCID is reconstitution of the patient's immunity. For more than 30 years, allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) has been extremely successful for SCID. However, BMT often results in only incomplete restoration of B cell function in treated patients, especially when haploidentical donors are used. In addition, BMT can be associated with severe complications such as graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Alternative forms of therapy for SCID are therefore desirable. Genetic correction of peripheral T lymphocytes and/or haematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) by retrovirally mediated gene transfer has been attempted for patients with SCID due to adenosine deaminase deficiency, the first genetic disease targeted in clinical gene therapy trials with very limited success, overall. After these pioneer trials, recent progress has led to significant improvement of gene transfer techniques and better understanding of HSC biology which has culminated in the recent success of a gene therapy trial for patients affected with X-linked SCID (X-SCID). In this trial, patients with X-SCID received autologous bone marrow stem/progenitor cells which had been retrovirally transduced with a therapeutic gene. Based on the current follow-up, the overall efficacy of this gene therapy procedure is to be considered similar to or even better than that achievable by allogeneic BMT, because patients were not exposed to the risks of GVHD. Although these exciting results have clearly demonstrated that gene therapy is a feasible therapeutic option for X-SCID, they have also raised important questions regarding the long-term outcome of this experimental procedure and the possibility of translating this success into applications for other forms of SCID.

Signal-transducing adaptor molecules STAM1 and STAM2 are required for T-cell development and survival

We previously reported that the STAM family members STAM1 and STAM2 are phosphorylated on tyrosine upon stimulation with cytokines through the gammac-Jak3 signaling pathway, which is essential for T-cell development. Mice with targeted mutations in either STAM1 or STAM2 show no abnormality in T-cell development, and mice with double mutations for STAM1 and STAM2 are embryonically lethal; therefore, here we generated mice with T-cell-specific double mutations for STAM1 and STAM2 using the Cre/loxP system. These STAM1(-/-) STAM2(-/-) mice showed a significant reduction in thymocytes and a profound reduction in peripheral mature T cells. In proliferation assays, thymocytes derived from the double mutant mice showed a defective response to T-cell-receptor (TCR) stimulation by antibodies and/or cytokines, interleukin-2 (IL-2) and IL-7. However, signaling events downstream of receptors for IL-2 and IL-7, such as activations of STAT5, extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), and protein kinase B (PKB)/Akt, and c-myc induction, were normal in the double mutant thymocytes. Upon TCR-mediated stimulation, prolonged activations of p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase and Jun N-terminal protein kinase were seen, but activations of ERK, PKB/Akt, and intracellular calcium flux were normal in the double mutant thymocytes. When the cell viability of cultured thymocytes was assessed, the double mutant thymocytes died more quickly than controls. These results demonstrate that the STAMs are indispensably involved in T-cell development and survival in the thymus through the prevention of apoptosis but are dispensable for the proximal signaling of TCR and cytokine receptors.

Gene therapy of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency

Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) conditions appear to be the best possible candidates for a gene therapy approach. Transgene expression by lymphocyte precursors should confer to these cells a selective growth advantage that gives rise to long-lived T-lymphocytes. This rationale was used as a basis for a clinical trial of the SCID-X1 disorder caused by common gamma (gamma c) gene mutations. This trial consists of ex vivo retroviral-mediated (MFG-B2 gamma c vector) gammac gene transfer into marrow CD34+ cells in CH-296 fibronectin fragment-coated bags. Up to now, 9 patients with typical SCID-X1 diagnosed within the first year of life and lacking an HLA-identical donor have been enrolled. More than 2 years' assessment of 5 patients and more than 1 year for 7 patients provide evidence for full development of functional, mature T-cells in the absence of any adverse effects. Functional transduced natural killer cells are also detectable, although in low numbers. All but 1 patient with T-cell immunity have also developed immunoglobulin production, which has alleviated the need for intravenous immunoglobulin substitution despite a low detection frequency of transduced B-cells. These 8 patients are doing well and living in a normal environment. This yet successful gene therapy demonstrates that in a setting where transgene expression provides a selective advantage, a clinical benefit can be expected.

Reconstitution of lymphoid development and function in ZAP-70-deficient mice following gene transfer into bone marrow cells

Mutations in the ZAP-70 protein tyrosine kinase gene result in a severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) characterized by a selective inability to produce CD8(+) T cells and a signal transduction defect in peripheral CD4(+) cells. Transplantation of genetically modified hematopoietic progenitor cells that express the wild-type ZAP-70 gene may provide significant benefit to some of these infants. The feasibility of stem cell gene correction for human ZAP-70 deficiency was assessed using a ZAP-70 knock-out model. ZAP-70-deficient murine bone marrow progenitor cells were transduced with a retroviral vector expressing the human ZAP-70 gene. Engraftment of these cells in irradiated ZAP-70-deficient animals resulted in the development of mature CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. In marked contrast, both populations were absent in ZAP-70(-/-) mice undergoing transplantation with bone marrow progenitor cells transduced with a control vector. Importantly, ZAP-70-reconstituted T cells proliferated in response to T-cell receptor stimulation. Moreover, these ZAP-70-expressing T cells demonstrated a diverse T-cell receptor repertoire as monitored by the relative usage of each T-cell receptor beta chain hypervariable region subfamily. The presence of ZAP-70 in B cells did not affect either lipopolysaccharide- or lipopolysaccharide/interleukin-4-mediated immunoglobulin isotype switching. Altogether, these data indicate that retroviral-mediated gene transfer of the ZAP-70 gene may prove to have a therapeutic benefit for patients with ZAP-70-SCID.

Gene therapy for primary immune deficiencies

Primary immunodeficiency diseases have been important targets of corrective gene transfer approaches since the very early days of gene therapy. The potential for selective survival advantage of gene-corrected cells over populations carrying the mutated, causative gene translates into the possibility of obtaining clinical meaningful results in patients with primary immunodeficiency diseases even if levels of gene transfer are low. This critical prospect has fueled the interest of researchers since the mid-1980s and has recently determined the success of a clinical trial of gene therapy for X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency.