Simultaneous sulfur hexafluoride and nitrogen multiple-breath washout (MBW) to examine inherent differences in MBW outcomes

Multiple breath washout and oscillometry after allogenic HSCT: a scoping review

Pulmonary chronic graft-versus-host disease (cGVHD) is a substantial cause of pulmonary morbidity and mortality post-haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). Current spirometry-based monitoring strategies have significant limitations. Understanding the utility of novel peripheral airway function tests - multiple breath washout (MBW) and oscillometry - is critical in efforts to improve detection, facilitate earlier intervention and improve outcomes. In this scoping review, we identified 17 studies investigating MBW or oscillometry, or both, after allogenic HSCT. Despite small study numbers limiting the ability to draw firm conclusions, several themes were evident. Detectable peripheral airway abnormality in MBW occurred in a substantial proportion prior to HSCT. MBW indices post-HSCT were more frequently abnormal than spirometry when reporting group data and among those with extrapulmonary cGVHD and pulmonary cGVHD. Changes in MBW indices over time may be more indicative of pulmonary complications than absolute values at any given time point. Oscillometry indices were often normal at baseline, but more frequently abnormal in those who developed pulmonary cGVHD. Pooling currently available individual participant data across these studies may improve our ability to formally compare their respective sensitivity and specificity at specific time points and assess the trajectory of MBW and oscillometry indices over time.

In children with primary ciliary dyskinesia, which type of lung function test is the earliest determinant of decline in lung health: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Primary ciliary dyskinesia is a rare genetic disorder characterized by recurrent sinopulmonary infections and worsening obstructive lung disease. Kidney and brain involvement is less common and is associated with overlapping ciliopathies/syndromes. The lungs are impacted early in the course of the disease, so it is vital to monitor lung function and recognize any decline by doing appropriate lung function tests. This systematic review compares different lung function tests and analyzes which one becomes abnormal earlier in the disease.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted following the methodology in the "Cochrane Handbook on Systematic Reviews for diagnostic tests." The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses were used to report the results. The risk of bias assessment was done using "The Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews tool for interventional studies." A meta-analysis was not performed due to the small sample size. All studies were analyzed by using Joanna Briggs Institute's critical appraisal tool.

RESULTS

After screening for the duplication of results and applying inclusion and exclusion criteria, 14 studies were assessed by reading the full texts. Out of these, eight were finally included in this systematic review. The total sample size from all studies was 165, including 80 males. All the studies used spirometry as a lung function test, whereas multiple breath washout was used in five studies. Other tests used for comparison were computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), cardiopulmonary exercise testing, 6-min walk test, DLCO, maximal inspiratory pressure, maximal expiratory pressure, and PaO₂ . Lung clearance index (LCI) by multiple breath washout had a stronger association with the structural changes on CT/MRI than spirometry indices like forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) and forced expiratory flow at 25% to 75% of lung volume (FEF 25-75).

CONCLUSIONS

Based on the evidence from this systematic review, LCI becomes abnormal earlier than FEV1 or FEF 25-75 and positively correlates with the findings on high-resolution CT. It has limitations like the lack of reference values and a complex technique to perform the test.

Critical functional lung volumes in neonatal intensive care: evidence and clinical applications

Respiratory disease is common in premature and sick newborn infants and can often necessitate the initiation of intensive care. Newborn infants often suffer from conditions that are associated with decreased lung volumes that occur as a result of abnormal or incomplete lung development. Such conditions are prematurity and respiratory distress syndrome, preterm premature rupture of membranes and the ensuing pulmonary hypoplasia and congenital lung anomalies such as congenital diaphragmatic hernia. These diseases have a structural component manifesting with lower lung volumes and a functional component that can present with increased oxygen and ventilatory requirements. The corresponding decreased functional lung volume is possibly responsible for some unfavourable pulmonary outcomes. Some infants are unable to wean off invasive respiratory support and, in extreme cases, unable to sustain independent breathing that can lead to long-term invasive ventilation or subsequent death. The aim of this review is to summarise the available evidence behind the concept of a critical functional lung volume in neonatal intensive care and describe the clinical implications that arise from decreased functional lung volumes in the main high-risk populations of newborn infants. IMPACT: Newborn infants suffer from diseases such as respiratory distress syndrome, pulmonary hypoplasia and congenital diaphragmatic hernia that are associated with a decrease in the total lung volume and impaired lung function. Critically decreased functional lung volumes during neonatal care are associated with failure to wean off invasive respiratory support, increased mortality and possibly longer-term respiratory complications.

Multiple breath washout lung function reveals ventilation inhomogeneity unresponsive to mechanical assisted cough in patients with neuromuscular disease

BACKGROUND

Respiratory involvement defines the clinical outcome of neuromuscular diseases (NMD). The lung clearance index (LCI) is a marker of lung ventilation inhomogeneity and indicates small airway disease. It is determined by mulitple breath washout lung function (MBW). The merit of LCI is undisputed for primary lung diseases like cystic fibrosis, but its role in NMD is unclear.

METHODS

We investigated the role of MBW in patients with NMD and the effect of two different tracer gases and cough assist devices on the LCI. Patients and controls performed MBW with nitrogen (N2) and sulfur hexafluoride (SF6), whereas the latter analysis was repeated after the use of a cough assist device in the NMD group. LCI was compared to forced vital capacity (FVC) and peak cough flow (PCF).

RESULTS

24 NMD patients (12 Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy, 8 Spinal Muscular Atrophy, 4 other NMDs) and 15 healthy controls were enrolled. In the NMD group, overall LCI N2 was higher than LCI SF6 (9.67 ± 1.56 vs. 8.71 ± 1.47; mean ± SD; p < 0.033). In controls, LCI N2 did not differ significantly from LCI SF6 (7.03 ± 0.37 vs. 7.05 ± 0.67; p = 0.882). Both LCI N2 and LCI SF6 were significantly higher in NMD patients as in controls (9.67 ± 1.56 vs. 7.03 ± 0.37, p < 0.001, and 8.71 ± 1.478.65 vs. 7.05 ± 0.67, p < 0.001). In the NMD group, both LCI N2 and LCI SF6 showed a negative correlation to FVC (r = - 0.525; p = 0.008 and r = - 0.526; p = 0.008, respectively) and PCF (r = - 0.590; p = 0.002 and r = - 0.641; p = 0.001, respectively). LCI N2 and LCI SF6 correlated well in the NMD group. LCI SF6 did not change significantly after the use of the cough assist in NMD patients (n = 22; 8.65 ± 1.52 pre vs. 8.79 ± 2.03 post, p = 0.667).

CONCLUSION

Lung involvement of patients with neuromuscular diseases goes beyond weakness of respiratory muscles. MBW with both N2 and SF6 is suitable to detect ventilation inhomogeneity in NMD patients with respiratory impairment. Cough assist devices with low to moderate pressure levels do not immediately improve the LCI.

Nitrogen-based lung clearance index: a valid physiological biomarker for the clinic

Multiple breath washout (MBW) testing is increasingly used as a physiological measurement in the clinic, due in part to the availability of commercial equipment and reference values for MBW indices. Commercial N₂ washout devices are usually based on indirect measurement of N₂ concentration (C_N2), by directly measuring either molar mass and O₂ and CO₂, or molar mass and CO₂. We aim to elucidate the role of two potential pitfalls associated with N₂-MBW testing that could override its physiological content: indirect N₂ measurement and blood-solubility of N₂. We performed MBW in 12 healthy adult subjects using a commercial device (MBW_indirect) with simultaneous direct gas concentration measurements by mass spectrometry (MBW_direct) and compared C_N2 between MBW_direct and MBW_indirect. We also measured argon concentration during the same washouts to verify the maximal effect gas solubility can have on N₂-based functional residual capacity (FRC) and lung clearance index (LCI). Continuous N₂ concentration traces were very similar for MBW_indirect and MBW_direct, resulting in comparable breath-by-breath washout plots of expired concentration and in no significant differences in FRC_N2, LCI_N2, S_cond, and S_acin between the two methods. Argon washouts were slightly slower than N₂ washouts, as expected for a less diffusive and more soluble gas. Finally, comparison between LCI_N2 and LCI_Ar indicates that the maximum impact from blood-tissue represents less than half a LCI unit in normal subjects. In conclusion, we have demonstrated by direct measurement of N₂ and twice as soluble argon, that indirect N₂ measurement can be safely used as a meaningful physiological measurement.NEW & NOTEWORTHY The physiological content of N₂ multibreath washout testing has been questioned due to N₂ indirect measurement accuracy and N₂ blood solubility. With direct measurement of N₂ and twice as soluble argon, we show that these effects are largely outweighed by ease of use.

Contemporary N2 and SF6 multiple breath washout in infants and toddlers with cystic fibrosis

INTRODUCTION

Multiple breath washout (MBW) is used for early detection of cystic fibrosis (CF) lung disease, with SF₆ MBW commonly viewed as the reference method. The use of N₂ MBW in infants and toddlers has been questioned for technical and physiological reasons, but a new correction of the N₂  signal has minimized the technical part. The present study aimed to assess the remaining differences and the contributing mechanisms for the differences between SF₆ and N₂ MBW,corrected-such as tidal volume reduction during N₂ washout with pure O₂ .

METHOD

This was a longitudinal multicenter cohort study. SF₆ MBW and N₂ MBW were performed prospectively at three CF centers in the same visits on 154 test occasions across 62 children with CF (mean age: 22.7 months). Offline analysis using identical algorithms to the commercially available program provided outcomes of N_2,original and N_2,corrected for comparison with SF₆ MBW.

RESULTS

Mean functional residual capacity, FRC_N2,corrected was 14.3% lower than FRC_{N2, original} , and 1.0% different from FRC_SF6 . Lung clearance index, LCI_N2,corrected was 25.2% lower than LCI_N2,original , and 7.3% higher than LCI_SF6 . Mean (SD) tidal volume decreased significantly during N₂ MBW_corrected , compared to SF₆ MBW (-13.1 ml [-30.7; 4.6], p < 0.0001, equal to -12.0% [-25.7; 1.73]), but this tidal volume reduction did not correlate to the differences between LCI_N2,corrected and LCI_SF6 . The absolute differences in LCI increased significantly with higher LCI_SF6 (0.63/LCI_SF6 ) and (0.23/LCI_SF6 ), respectively, for N_2,original and N_2,corrected , but the relative differences were stable across disease severity for N_2,corrected , but not for N_2,original .

CONCLUSION

Only minor residual differences between FRC_N2,corrected and FRC_SF6 remained to show that the two methods measure gas volumes very similar in this age range. Small differences in LCI were found. Tidal volume reduction during N₂ MBW did not affect differences. The corrected N₂ MBW can now be used with confidence in young children with CF, although not interchangeably with SF₆ .

Multiple breath washout: measuring early manifestations of lung pathology

The multiple breath washout (MBW) test measures the efficiency of gas mixing in the lungs and has gained significant interest over the past 20 years. MBW outcomes detect early lung function impairment and peripheral airway pathology, through its main outcome measure lung clearance index (LCI). LCI measures the number of lung turnovers required to washout an inert tracer gas. MBW is performed during normal (tidal) breathing, making it particularly suitable for young children or those who have trouble performing forced manoeuvres. Additionally, research in chronic respiratory disease populations has shown that MBW can detect acute clinically relevant changes before conventional lung function tests, such as spirometry, thus enabling early intervention. The development of technical standards for MBW and commercial devices have allowed MBW to be implemented in clinical research and potentially routine clinical practice. Although studies have summarised clinimetric properties of MBW indices, additional research is required to establish the clinical utility of MBW and, if possible, shorten testing time. Sensitive, feasible measures of early lung function decline will play an important role in early intervention for people living with respiratory diseases.

Educational aim

To describe the multiple breath washout test, its applications to lung pathology and respiratory disease, as well as directions for future research.

Correction of sensor crosstalk error in Exhalyzer D multiple-breath washout device significantly impacts outcomes in children with cystic fibrosis

RATIONALE

Nitrogen multiple-breath washout is an established technique to assess functional residual capacity and ventilation inhomogeneity in the lung. Accurate measurement of gas concentrations is essential for the appropriate calculation of clinical outcomes.

OBJECTIVES

We investigated the accuracy of oxygen and carbon dioxide gas sensor measurements used for the indirect calculation of nitrogen concentration in a commercial multiple-breath washout device (Exhalyzer D, Eco Medics AG, Duernten, Switzerland) and its impact on functional residual capacity and lung clearance index.

METHODS

High precision calibration gas mixtures and mass spectrometry were used to evaluate sensor output. We assessed the impact of corrected signal processing on multiple-breath washout outcomes in a dataset of healthy children and children with cystic fibrosis using custom analysis software.

RESULTS

We found inadequate correction for the cross sensitivity of the oxygen and carbon dioxide sensors in the Exhalyzer D device. This results in an overestimation of expired nitrogen concentration, and consequently multiple-breath washout outcomes. Breath-by-breath correction of this error reduced the mean (SD) cumulative expired volume by 19.6 (5.0)%, functional residual capacity by 8.9 (2.2)%, and lung clearance index by 11.9 (4.0)%. It also substantially reduced the level of the tissue nitrogen signal at the end of measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

Inadequate correction for cross sensitivity in the oxygen and carbon dioxide gas sensors of the Exhalyzer D device leads to an overestimation of functional residual capacity and lung clearance index. Correction of this error is possible and could be applied by re-analyzing the measurements in an updated software version.

Longitudinal assessment of lung clearance index to monitor disease progression in children and adults with cystic fibrosis

Background

Lung clearance index (LCI) is a valuable research tool in cystic fibrosis (CF) but clinical application has been limited by technical challenges and uncertainty about how to interpret longitudinal change. In order to help inform clinical practice, this study aimed to assess feasibility, repeatability and longitudinal LCI change in children and adults with CF with predominantly mild baseline disease.

Methods

Prospective, 3-year, multicentre, observational study of repeated LCI measurement at time of clinical review in patients with CF >5 years, delivered using a rapid wash-in system.

Results

112 patients completed at least one LCI assessment and 98 (90%) were still under follow-up at study end. The median (IQR) age was 14.7 (8.6–22.2) years and the mean (SD) FEV₁ z-score was −1.2 (1.3). Of 81 subjects with normal FEV₁ (>−2 z-scores), 63% had raised LCI (indicating worse lung function). For repeat stable measurements within 6 months, the mean (limits of agreement) change in LCI was 0.9% (−18.8% to 20.7%). A latent class growth model analysis identified four discrete clusters with high accuracy, differentiated by baseline LCI and FEV₁. Baseline LCI was the strongest factor associated with longitudinal change. The median total test time was under 19 min.

Conclusions

Most patients with CF with well-preserved lung function show stable LCI over time. Cluster behaviours can be identified and baseline LCI is a risk factor for future progression. These results support the use of LCI in clinical practice in identifying patients at risk of lung function decline.

Improved agreement between N2 and SF6 multiple-breath washout in healthy infants and toddlers with improved EXHALYZER D sensor performance

Recent studies indicate limited utility of nitrogen multiple-breath washout (N₂MBW) in infancy and advocate for using sulfur hexafluoride (SF₆) MBW in this age-group. Modern N₂MBW systems, such as EXHALYZER D (ECO MEDICS AG, Duernten, Switzerland), use O₂ and CO₂ sensors to calculate N₂ concentrations (in principle, N₂% = 100 - CO₂% - O₂%). High O₂ and CO₂ concentrations have now been shown to significantly suppress signal output from the other sensor, raising apparent N₂ concentrations. We examined whether improved EXHALYZER D N₂ signal, accomplished after thorough examination of this CO₂ and O₂ interaction on gas sensors and its correction, leads to better agreement between N₂MBW and SF₆MBW in healthy infants and toddlers. Within the same session, 52 healthy children aged 1-36 mo [mean = 1.30 (SD = 0.72) yr] completed SF₆MBW and N₂MBW recordings (EXHALYZER D, SPIROWARE version 3.2.1) during supine quiet sleep. SF₆ and N₂ SPIROWARE files were reanalyzed offline with in-house software using identical algorithms as in SPIROWARE with or without application of the new correction factors for N₂MBW provided by ECO MEDICS AG. Applying the improved N₂ signal significantly reduced mean [95% confidence interval (CI)] differences between N₂MBW and SF₆MBW recorded functional residual capacity (FRC) and lung clearance index (LCI): for FRC, from 26.1 (21.0, 31.2) mL, P < 0.0001, to 1.18 (-2.3, 4.5) mL, P = 0.5, and for LCI, from 1.86 (1.68, 2.02), P < 0.001, to 0.44 (0.33, 0.55), P < 0.001. Correction of N₂ signal for CO₂ and O₂ interactions on gas sensors resulted in markedly closer agreement between N₂MBW and SF₆MBW outcomes in healthy infants and toddlers.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Modern nitrogen multiple-breath washout (N₂MBW) systems such as EXHALYZER D use O₂ and CO₂ sensors to calculate N₂ concentrations. New corrections for interactions between high O₂ and CO₂ concentrations on the gas sensors now provide accurate N₂ signals. The correct N₂ signal led to much improved agreement between N₂MBW and sulfur hexafluoride (SF₆) MBW functional residual capacity (FRC) and lung clearance index (LCI) in 52 sleeping healthy infants and toddlers, suggesting a role for N₂MBW in this age-group.

The differing physiology of nitrogen and tracer gas multiple-breath washout techniques

Background

Multiple-breath washout techniques are increasingly used to assess lung function. The principal statistic obtained is the lung clearance index (LCI), but values obtained for LCI using the nitrogen (N₂)-washout technique are higher than those obtained using an exogenous tracer gas such as sulfur hexafluoride. This study explored whether the pure oxygen (O₂) used for the N₂ washout could underlie these higher values.

Methods

A model of a homogenous, reciprocally ventilated acinus was constructed. Perfusion was kept constant, and ventilation adjusted by varying the swept volume during the breathing cycle. The blood supplying the acinus had a standard mixed-venous composition. Carbon dioxide and O₂ exchange between the blood and acinar gas proceeded to equilibrium. The model was initialised with either air or air plus tracer gas as the inspirate. Washouts were conducted with pure O₂ for the N₂ washout or with air for the tracer gas washout.

Results

At normal ventilation/perfusion (V′/Q′) ratios, the rate of washout of N₂ and exogenous tracer gas was almost indistinguishable. At low V′/Q′, the N₂ washout lagged the tracer gas washout. At very low V′/Q′, N₂ became trapped in the acinus. Under low V′/Q′ conditions, breathing pure O₂ introduced a marked asymmetry between the inspiratory and expiratory gas flow rates that was not present when breathing air.

Discussion

The use of pure O₂ to washout N₂ increases O₂ uptake in low V′/Q′ units. This generates a background gas flow into the acinus that opposes flow out of the acinus during expiration, and so delays the washout of N₂.

Differences in lung clearance index between nitrogen and exogenous tracer gas multiple-breath washout tests can be explained by the oxygen used to wash out nitrogen generating convective flows of gas into low ventilation/perfusion unitshttps://bit.ly/3l0xq0G

Nitrogen offset in N2 multiple washout method

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to the correspondence by J.G. Nielsen from Innovision about our recent paper [1]. We would like to respond with a few points to address any concerns that may have arisen from his comments amongst colleagues at cystic fibrosis centres using the Exhalyzer D (Eco Medics, Dürnten, Switzerland).

Addressing concerns with use of the Exhalyzer D multiple breath washout devicehttp://bit.ly/2ug0fAi

Lung clearance index in healthy volunteers, measured using a novel portable system with a closed circuit wash-in

Introduction

Lung clearance index (LCI) is a sensitive measure of early lung disease, but adoption into clinical practice has been slow. Challenges include the time taken to perform each test. We recently described a closed-circuit inert gas wash-in method that reduces overall testing time by decreasing the time to equilibration. The aim of this study was to define a normative range of LCI in healthy adults and children derived using this method. We were also interested in the feasibility of using this system to measure LCI in a community setting.

Methods

LCI was assessed in healthy volunteers at three hospital sites and in two local primary schools. Volunteers completed three washout repeats at a single visit using the closed circuit wash-in method (0.2% SF₆ wash-in tracer gas to equilibrium, room air washout).

Results

160 adult and paediatric subjects successfully completed LCI assessment (95%) (100 in hospital, 60 in primary schools). Median coefficient of variation was 3.4% for LCI repeats and 4.3% for FRC. Mean (SD) LCI for the analysis cohort (n = 53, age 5–39 years) was 6.10 (0.42), making the upper limit of normal LCI 6.8. There was no relationship between LCI and multiple demographic variables. Median (interquartile range) total test time was 18.7 (16.0–22.5) minutes.

Conclusion

The closed circuit method of LCI measurement can be successfully and reproducibly measured in healthy volunteers, including in out-of-hospital settings. Normal range appears stable up to 39 years. With few subjects older than 40 years, further work is required to define the normal limits above this age.

Feasibility and clinical applications of multiple breath wash-out (MBW) testing using sulphur hexafluoride in adults with bronchial asthma

Ventilation heterogeneity is frequent in bronchial asthma and can be assessed using multiple breath wash-out testing (MBW). Most data is available in paediatric patients and using nitrogen as a tracer gas. We aimed to evaluate sulphur hexafluoride (SF₆) MBW in adult asthmatics. Spirometry, whole-body plethysmography, impulse oscillometry and SF₆-MBW were prospectively performed. MBW parameters reflecting global (lung clearance index, LCI), acinar (S_acin) and conductive (S_cond) ventilation heterogeneity were derived from three consecutive wash-outs. LCI was calculated for the traditional 2.5% and an earlier 5% stopping point that has the potential to reduce wash-out times. 91 asthmatics (66%) and 47 non-asthmatic controls (34%) were included in final analysis. LCI_2.5 and LCI₅ were higher in asthmatics (p < 0.001). Likewise, S_acin and S_cond were elevated (p < 0.001 and p < 0.01). Coefficient of variation was 3.4% for LCI_2.5 and 3.5% for LCI₅ in asthmatics. Forty-one asthmatic patients had normal spirometry. ROC analysis revealed an AUC of 0.906 for the differentiation from non-asthmatic controls exceeding diagnostic performance of individual and conventional parameters (AUC = 0.819, p < 0.05). SF₆-MBW is feasible and reproducible in adult asthmatics. Ventilation heterogeneity is increased as compared to non-asthmatic controls persisting in asthmatic patients with normal spirometry. Diagnostic performance is not affected using an earlier LCI stopping point while reducing wash-out duration considerably.

Nitrogen offset in N2 multiple washout method

In a recent study of the nitrogen multiple breath washout (MBW) method to measure lung clearance index (LCI) using the Exhalyzer device (Eco Medics AG, Dürnten, Switzerland), Bayfieldet al. [1] reported an N₂ offset signal of ∼1.4%, slightly higher than reported in several previous studies. There was no similar offset using sulfur hexafluoride as the tracer gas measured with the Innocor device (Innovision ApS, Glamsbjerg, Denmark), a finding that is in line with previous reports. The results of this and other studies are extremely important as the Exhalyzer is the device that is currently used in ≥100 cystic fibrosis centres in the European Cystic Fibrosis Society Clinical Trial Network and the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation Therapeutics Development Network in various drug trials [2].

An offset in the nitrogen signal significantly affects LCI measured by the N₂ MBW methodhttp://bit.ly/35hwOuH