Ratio and difference of the cross-sectional area of median nerve to ulnar nerve in diagnosing carpal tunnel syndrome: a case control study

The Impact of Reference Standard on Diagnostic Testing Characteristics for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: A Systematic Review

Lack of a reliable reference standard for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) diagnosis could impact the diagnostic test characteristics. This systematic review sought to evaluate differences in the accuracy of CTS diagnostic modalities based on the reference standard used.

Methods

A systematic review was performed following PRISMA guidelines to investigate diagnostic modalities used in CTS. A literature search of Embase, PubMed, and Cochrane Reviews was conducted for the years of 2010-2021 for primary data, and 113 studies met final inclusion criteria. Studies were stratified based on the reference standard utilized and diagnostic modality assessed, and the weighted means of the sensitivities and specificities were calculated.

Results

Thirty-five studies used clinical diagnosis alone as a reference standard, and 78 studies used electrodiagnostic study (EDS). The specificity for MRI and ultrasound (US) were substantially lower when EDS was used as the reference standard. MRI was the test most affected by the reference standard used, showing increased sensitivity when using EDS as the reference compared to clinical diagnosis (77.1% versus 60.9%) and decreased specificity (87.6% versus 99.2%). Regardless of the reference standard used, all tests had anticipated false-positive and/or false-negative rates of at least 10%.

Conclusions

Testing characteristics vary greatly based on the choice of reference standard, with the sensitivity of MRI most affected. Regardless of reference standard used, EDS, US, and MRI each had false-positive and/or false-negative rates too great to be appropriate for use as a screening examination.

The cross-sectional morphology of median nerve in carpal tunnel of healthy, adult population: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The cross-section area is a crucial parameter to assess peripheral neuropathy. The ultrasonographic evaluation of cross-section area of median nerve is a low-cost and readily available tool for diagnosis and assessment. However, the intra-nerve dimensional variability and its normative reference value in a healthy subject are missing. The current meta-analysis aims to capture the median nerve cross-section area for healthy subjects and generate a comprehensive ultrasonographic reference data set for each population.

METHODS

The full text of manuscripts were collected after short-listing the abstracts collected from search strategy. A quality assurance tool was used to capture the risk of bias of each study after reviewing the included manuscripts. The pooled estimate of cross-section area was stratified according to anatomical landmarks, sex, and ancestry.

RESULTS

A total of 97 observational studies dealt with 6679 wrists of healthy subjects were included. The pooled estimate of the cross-section area of median nerve at carpal tunnel inlet was 8.54mm² [95% CI: 8.34-8.74mm²]. The same pooled estimate at carpal tunnel outlet was 8.03mm² [95% CI: 7.46-8.60mm²]. Both these pooled estimates have significant correlation with mean age of population. Age and sex were two primary predictors of the cross-section of median nerve. The flattening ratio, circularity, and wrist-forearm ratio of median nerve were also computed.

CONCLUSION

These normative data could serve as a reference for assessing median nerve pathologies, including carpal tunnel syndrome. The ethnic variation of pooled estimate and heterogeneity will guide clinician set up the reference value for diagnostic criteria.

Ultrasound and elastography role in pre- and post-operative evaluation of median neuropathy in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome

Introduction

Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is a common compression neuropathy of the median nerve in the wrist. Early diagnosis of CTS is essential for selecting treatment options and assessing prognosis. The current diagnosis of CTS is based on the patient's clinical symptoms, signs, and an electromyography (EMG) test. However, they have some limitations. Recently, ultrasound has been adopted as an adjunct diagnostic tool for electromyography (EMG). Ultrasound is a non-invasive and cost-effective technique. It provides a dynamic display of morphological changes in the median nerve and an assessment of CTS etiology such as tenosynovitis, mass compression, and tendon disease. This study aimed to investigate the value of conventional ultrasound and real-time shear wave elastography (SWE) in evaluation of median neuropathy in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) before and after surgery.

Methods

First, the Boston Carpal Tunnel Questionnaire (BCTQ) was administered to patients with CTS. All subjects were measured at three levels: the distal 1/3 of the forearm, the carpal tunnel inlet, and the distal carpal tunnel using conventional ultrasound and SWE. Median nerve parameters were examined in patients with CTS 1 week after surgery.

Results

The cross-sectional area (CSA) and stiffness of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet and distal carpal tunnel were significantly higher in patients with CTS than in healthy controls (p < 0.001). The CSA and stiffness of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet were statistically significantly significantly between pre- and postoperative patients with CTS (p < 0.001). The CSA and stiffness of the nerve in patients with CTS had a positive correlation with electrophysiology severity.

Conclusions and discussion

Conventional ultrasound and elastography are valuable in the diagnosis of CTS and are useful in the clinical assessment of patient's nerve recovery after operation.

Ultrasonographical Evaluation of the Median Nerve Mobility in Carpal Tunnel Syndrome: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Diagnostic ultrasound is widely used for evaluating carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), an entrapment neuropathy of the median nerve (MN). Decreased mobility of the MN inside the carpal tunnel has been reported in CTS, and various methods have been used to evaluate MN mobility; however, there is still no conclusive understanding of its connection with CTS. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis of the current published literature on ultrasonographic evaluations of transverse and longitudinal MN displacement and to identify the relationship between MN mobility and CTS. This study was conducted in accordance with the 2020 PRISMA statement and the Cochrane Collaboration Handbook. Comparative studies that investigated differences in MN displacement between CTS patients and healthy controls were retrieved by searching the Cochrane Library, Embase and PubMed. A total of 15 case–control studies were included. Nine of 12 studies evaluating transverse MN displacement and 4 of 5 studies evaluating longitudinal MN gliding showed that the MN was less mobile in CTS patients than in healthy subjects. Despite the large heterogeneity among the 15 included studies, this systematic review and meta-analysis provide evidence that the mobility of the MN is significantly reduced in both transverse and longitudinal planes in CTS patients compared to healthy controls. Five of the 15 included studies reported that a decrease in transverse or longitudinal MN displacement in CTS was correlated with clinical symptoms or with severity as measured by a nerve conduction study (NCS).

Normative Value of the Cross-Sectional Area of the Median Nerve at the Carpal Tunnel Inlet and Distal Forearm in the Singapore Population

Background: Ultrasonography is often used in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). However, we were unable to find normative data regarding the cross-sectional area (CSA) of the median nerve in the Singapore population as measured by ultrasound. The aims of this study were to establish normative values of the CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet in a healthy population, 5 cm proximal to the carpal tunnel inlet, and to determine if the CSA correlated with side, age, gender or race.

Methods: Sixty-nine wrists of 36 healthy subjects with no history of wrist injury or any signs and symptoms of CTS were examined. The CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet and 5 cm proximal to the carpal tunnel inlet was determined using ultrasound by a trained operator.

Results: The mean CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet was 6.41 mm2 (SD 2.18 mm2). These were not significantly different from the values for mean CSA obtained 5 cm proximal to the carpal tunnel inlet. We did not find any correlation between the CSA of the median nerve and age, gender or race.

Conclusions: The mean CSA of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet in normal subjects in Singapore was found to be lower than other Asian populations. Wide variations of the median nerve CSA at the carpal tunnel inlet exists in the literature, and this is probably due to the heterogeneity of the study methodology and population.

Level of Evidence: Level III (Diagnostic)

The role of diagnostic ultrasound in the examination of carpal tunnel syndrome: an update and systematic review

BACKGROUND

Diagnostic ultrasound is becoming more available and has potential for identifying carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), but there is a lack of consensus on optimal measurement parameters and interpretation.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this systematic review was to analyze and summarize recent published data evaluating measurement properties of diagnostic ultrasound for use in individuals with CTS.

METHODS

Five databases were searched to identify studies reporting on diagnostic measurement in individuals ≥18 years of age. Thirty-four studies underwent critical appraisal using Center for Evidence Based Medicine guidelines for diagnostic study accuracy. Each team member independently reviewed and scored the studies and consensus was reached through discussion.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies evaluating 21 unique nerve or tunnel measurements and 9 measurement ratios were included. Measurements of median nerve cross sectional area (CSA) taken at the carpal tunnel inlet consistently demonstrated good to excellent interrater reliability (ICC=0.83-0.93) and good intrarater reliability (r>0.81). All studies supported inlet CSA in differentiating between individuals with and without CTS. Carpal tunnel inlet CSA measurements demonstrated a moderate correlation to the Padua severity classification (r = 0.71), but this varied between studies. Diagnostic accuracy of CSA measured at the carpal tunnel inlet using diagnostic cutoff values ranging from 8.5 mm² to 12.6 mm² resulted in a range sensitivity (63%-96.9%) and specificity (67.9%-100%).

CONCLUSION

The US measurement most supported was the median nerve CSA measured at the carpal tunnel inlet. There was no evidence supporting the routine use of diagnostic US for individuals with suspected CTS, and no additional evidence to support replacement of electrodiagnostic studies by US. More research is needed to determine use of US for classifying CTS severity or as a differential diagnostic tool for conditions that mimic CTS.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

N/A.

Ultrasonography for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome: an umbrella review

BACKGROUND

Numerous sonographic modalities and parameters have been used to diagnose carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), with varying accuracy. Our umbrella review aimed to summarize the evidence from systematic reviews and meta-analyses regarding the use of ultrasound imaging to diagnose CTS.

METHODS

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses meeting the inclusion criteria were searched in PubMed, Embase, Medline, Web of Science, and Cochrane databases from inception to March 2022. Critical appraisal, data extraction, and synthesis were performed in accordance with the criteria for conducting an umbrella review.

RESULTS

Sixteen reviews were included. Three reviews were classified as high quality, one as moderate, four as low, and eight as critically low. The cross-sectional area (CSA) of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet demonstrated the best reliability and diagnostic accuracy among multiple parameters. A cutoff CSA value of 9-10.5 mm² gave the highest diagnostic performance in the general population. The degree of CSA enlargement was correlated with CTS severity. Sonoelastography and Doppler ultrasound might provide additional insights into CTS evaluation as median nerve stiffness and vascularity at the wrist were increased in these patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Sonography is a reliable tool to diagnose CTS, with inlet CSA being the most robust parameter. Sonoelastography and Doppler ultrasound can serve as auxiliary tools to confirm CTS diagnoses. Further studies are needed to expand the use of sonography for diagnosing CTS, especially in the presence of concomitant neuromuscular disease(s).

Minimally Invasive Carpal Tunnel Release: A Technical Note and a 20-Year Retrospective Series

Introduction

The surgical treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) has been enriched, during the last years, by different minimally invasive techniques to decompress the median nerve at the wrist as the endoscopic approaches or modified open technique. However, controversy remains about their safety and complication rate. We present the results of our minimally-invasive technique to median nerve release at the wrist. We will discuss the instrumental preoperative assessment, surgical steps, post-operative management, and complications.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed clinical and neurophysiological data of all patients admitted at our institution between January 2001 and December 2020 for CTS surgery. The technique, performed under local anesthesia, is based on a single, small, linear transverse incision proximal to the wrist fold. After unsharpened dissection of subcutaneous tissues, a grooved guide is inserted in a slightly medial direction towards the fourth finger; this strategy prevents possible damages of nerve branches that could originate at this level. A second small incision over the guide’s tip allows a wide corridor in the context of the ligament. The carpalotome is then inserted into the guide; the two minor wounds are closed with 5-0 prolene sutures. The final result is a wide release of the nerve.

Results

A total of 1568 operations on 1371 patients were performed using the described technique at our institution. The patients’ cohort showed a higher prevalence of women (68%), with a mean age of 56.4 years (range 24-88 years). Paresthesia and numbness of the first three fingers were the most frequent signs and symptoms. All patients were submitted to a preoperative electrophysiological evaluation, which revealed the typical signs of CTS in most patients. The US evaluation of the median nerve at the wrist was a more recent introduction, dating from 2018. In 47 patients, despite an electromyography (EMG) not showing marked neurophysiological signs of severe CTS, the ultrasonographic evaluation was strongly consistent with the clinical diagnosis. In such patients, carpal tunnel release determined the resolution of symptoms. In 99.8% of total cases, we obtained a complete symptoms remission, with the disappearance of acroparesthesia and numbness.

Conclusion

The use of this technique has become widespread at our institution due to fewer local complications, a very low rate of recurrence, faster functional recovery, and reduced surgical time if compared to traditional open surgery and to endoscopic release too.

Cross-sectional Area Ratio of Median-to-Ulnar and Median-to-Superficial Radial Nerve at the Wrist for Diagnosis of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Objectives:

This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic properties for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) of the median-to-ulnar cross-sectional area ratio (MUR) and the median-to-superficial radial cross-sectional area ratio (MRR).

Methods:

A case–control study was conducted. A physiatrist, blinded to the CTS status of the subjects, assessed the cross-sectional area of the median nerve (CSA-m), MUR, and MRR at the distal wrist crease for the CTS and control groups. The relationship of CSA-m, MUR, and MRR with CTS severity was tested using Spearman’s correlation. The overall diagnostic accuracy was determined using the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). The cut-off values to diagnose CTS were chosen to achieve similar values for sensitivity and specificity.

Results:

There were 32 hands in the CTS group and 33 hands in the control group. The correlations of CSA-m, MUR, and MRR with CTS severity were 0.66, 0.56, and 0.34, respectively. The AUCs of CSA-m, MUR, and MRR were 0.86 (95%CI: 0.77–0.95), 0.79 (0.69–0.90), and 0.69 (0.56–0.82), respectively. The cut-off values of CSA-m, MUR, and MRR were 12 mm² (sensitivity, 81.3%; specificity, 81.8%), 2.6 (sensitivity, 68.8%; specificity, 69.7%), and 10 (sensitivity, 65.6%; specificity, 63.6%), respectively.

Conclusions

: MUR and MRR had acceptable diagnostic abilities but did not show superiority over CSA-m for CTS diagnosis.

Median nerve ultrasonography examination correlates with electrodiagnostic studies for the diagnosis of moderate to severe carpal tunnel syndrome

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study was to investigate the associations of cross-sectional area (CSA) of the median nerve measured by ultrasonography, the median to ulnar nerve ratio (MUR), the median to ulnar nerve difference (MUD) and the ratio of CSA of the median nerve to height squared (MHS) in relation to electrodiagnostic classification of moderate and severe carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) and thus to identify patients suitable for surgical treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective study was conducted in patients aged ≥ 18 years who underwent both median and ulnar nerve ultrasonography and electrodiagnostic studies (EDS). 124 wrists of 62 patients were examined. The patients' characteristics were acquired through a questionnaire. CTS was diagnosed using EDS and classified according to the guidelines of the Czech Republic Association of Electrodiagnostic Medicine. The CSA of the median nerve and of the ulnar nerve were measured at the carpal tunnel inlet.

RESULTS

Median nerve CSA at the tunnel inlet ≥ 12 mm² correlates with electrodiagnostic classification of moderate to severe carpal tunnel syndrome. At this cut-off value, the sensitivity of ultrasonography is 82.4%, its specificity is 87.7%, the positive predictive value is 82.4%, the negative predictive value is 87.7%. MUD, MUR and MHS perform worse than the median nerve CSA, as shown by their lower area under the receiver operating characteristic curve.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrasound could help us indicate surgical treatment for CTS, especially in patients with clinical findings. Our results suggest a cut-off value of CSA at the tunnel inlet of ≥ 12mm².

Influence of temperature on sonographic images of the median nerve for the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome: a case control study

Background

In addition to nerve conduction studies (NCSs), ultrasonography has been widely used as an alternative tool for diagnosing carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). Although the results of NCSs are influenced by local skin temperature, few studies have explored the effects of skin temperature on ultrasonography of the median nerve. Since swelling and intraneural blood flow of the median nerve might be influenced by local temperature changes, the aim of this study was to evaluate the cross-sectional area (CSA) and intraneural blood flow of the median nerve under three skin temperatures (30 °C, 32 °C, 34 °C).

Methods

Fifty patients with CTS and 50 healthy volunteers were consecutively recruited from a community hospital. Each participant received physical examinations and NCSs and underwent ultrasonography, including power Doppler, to evaluate intraneural vascularity.

Results

The CSA of the median nerve in the CTS patients was significantly larger than that in the healthy controls at all three temperatures. However, significant differences in the power Doppler signals of the median nerve between the two studied groups were observed only at 30 and 32 °C, not at 34 °C.

Conclusion

The significant difference in the intraneural vascularity of the median nerve between the patients with CTS and the healthy subjects was lost at higher temperatures (34 °C). Therefore, the results of power Doppler ultrasonography in diagnosing CTS should be cautiously interpreted in patients with a high skin temperature or those who reside in warm environments.

Ultrasonographic and electrophysiological outcomes of carpal tunnel syndrome treated with low-level laser therapy: A double-blind, prospective, randomized, sham-controlled study

Objectives

The aim of this study was to investigate the therapeutic effects of low-level laser therapy (LLLT) on clinical, ultrasonographic (US), and electrophysiological findings in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS).

Patients and methods

Between January 2015 and August 2015, 42 patients (7 males, 35 females; mean age: 50.4±8.7 years; range, 32 to 65 years) with mild-to-moderate CTS were randomly assigned to one of two groups: active LLLT (therapy group, n=22) 0.8 J/painful point and sham LLLT groups (n=20). Both groups wore neutral wrist orthoses. The patients were evaluated before and after 15 sessions of therapy (670 nm, 4 J/session over the carpal tunnel). Follow-up parameters included the Boston Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Questionnaire (BCTQ) Symptom Severity Scale (SSS), Functional Status Scale (FSS), nerve conduction studies and US evaluation of the median nerve cross-sectional area (CSA), vascularization (via power Doppler), flattening ratio (FR), and palmar bowing of the flexor retinaculum.

Results

Nocturnal paresthesia improved in both groups; however, pain and patients with a positive Phalen’s test reduced only in the therapy group (p=0.031). The FSS and SSS scores also improved only in the therapy group (p<0.001). Electrophysiologically, median sensory nerve conduction velocities showed a significant improvement only in the therapy group (p=0.002). The CSA, FR, and vascularization of the median nerve showed a significant improvement in the therapy group alone (p<0.001, p=0.048, and p=0.021, respectively).

Conclusion

Improvements in the signs and symptoms of CTS and hand function, the improvements in sensory nerve conduction studies, and reduction in median nerve CSA, FR and vascularity in the LLLT group can be attributed to the anti-inflammatory and analgesic effects of LLLT. This study provides new US data demonstrating efficacy of LLLT along with a clinical and electrophysiological improvement. The LLLT seems to be an easily applied, non-invasive treatment option.

Effects of wrist extension on median nerve and flexor tendon excursions in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome: a case control study

Background

Reduced gliding ability of the median nerve in the carpal tunnel has been observed in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). The purpose of this study was to evaluate the gliding abilities of the median nerve and flexor tendon in patients with CTS and healthy participants in the neutral and 30° extended positions of the wrist and to compare the gliding between the finger flexion and extension phases.

Methods

Patients with CTS and healthy participants were consecutively recruited in a community hospital. All the subjects received the Boston CTS questionnaire, physical examinations, nerve conduction study (NCS), and ultrasonography of the upper extremities. Duplex Doppler ultrasonography was performed to evaluate the gliding abilities of the median nerve and flexor tendon when the subjects continuously moved their index finger in the neutral and 30° extension positions of the wrist.

Results

Forty-nine patients with CTS and 48 healthy volunteers were consecutively recruited. Significant differences in the Boston CTS questionnaire, physical examination and NCS results and the cross-sectional area of the median nerve were found between the patients and the healthy controls. The degree of median nerve gliding and the ratio of median nerve excursion to flexor tendon excursion in the CTS group were significantly lower than those in the healthy control group in both the neutral and 30° wrist extension positions. Significantly increased excursion of both the median nerve and flexor tendon from the neutral to the extended positions were found in the CTS group. The ratio of median nerve excursion to flexor tendon excursion was significantly higher in the finger flexion phase than in the extended phase in both groups, and this ratio had mild to moderate correlations with answers on the Boston CTS Questionnaire and with the NCS results.

Conclusions

Reduced excursion of the median nerve was found in the patients with CTS. The ratio of median nerve excursion to flexor tendon excursion was significantly lower in the patients with CTS than in the healthy volunteers. The median nerve excursion was increased while the wrist joint was extended to 30° in the patients with CTS. Wrist extension may be applied as part of the gliding exercise regimen for patients with CTS to improve median nerve mobilization.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12891-021-04349-8.

Augmented Diagnostic Accuracy of Ultrasonography for Diagnosing Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Using an Optimised Wrist Circumference-Dependent Cross-Sectional Area Equation

Introduction: In diagnosing carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) there is no consensus about the upper limit of normal (ULN) of the cross-sectional area (CSA) of the median nerve at the carpal tunnel inlet. A previous study showed wrist circumference is the most important independent predictor for the ULN. In this study we optimised a wrist circumference-dependent ULN equation for optimal diagnostic accuracy and compared it to the generally used fixed ULN of 11 mm².

Methods: CSA and wrist circumference were measured in a prospective cohort of 253 patients (clinically defined CTS) and 96 healthy controls. An equation for the ULN for CSA was developed by means of univariable regression analysis. We calculated z-scores for all patients and healthy controls, and analysed these scores in a ROC curve and a decision plot. Sensitivity and specificity were determined and compared to fixed ULN values.

Results: We found augmented diagnostic accuracy of our newly developed equation y = 0.88 ^* x −4.0, where y = the ULN of the CSA and x = wrist circumference. This equation has a corresponding sensitivity and specificity of 75% compared to a sensitivity of 70% while using a fixed cut-off value of 11 mm² (p = 0.015).

Conclusion: Optimising the regression equation for wrist circumference-dependent ULN cross-sectional area of the median nerve at the wrist inlet might improve diagnostic accuracy of ultrasonography in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome and seems to be more accurate than using fixed cut-off values.

Comparing Shape Categorization to Circularity Measurement in the Evaluation of Median Nerve Compression Using Sonography

Purpose

This study aimed to develop a subjective categorization of nerve shape and to examine the relationship of shape categorizations to measurement of nerve circularity.

Methods

Wrists were evaluated with sonography in healthy participants. Images of the median nerve were obtained in the transverse plane at the level of pisiform with the fingers resting, gripping, and pinching. Nerves were categorized as ovoid, angular, or irregular, and the cross-sectional area and perimeter were measured to calculate nerve circularity.

Results

Across 167 participants, the median nerve shifted from being primarily ovoid at rest to angular shaped when the fingers were in a full fist or pinching. Approximately three-quarters of subjects exhibited a shape change during dynamic movement. Irregular nerves had the lowest circularity values; however, the majority of nerves had similar circularity measures despite having different shapes.

Conclusions

Subjective categorization of shape has the potential to be a valid technique for evaluation of the median nerve using sonography, and this evaluation may provide additional information regarding nerve compression that is not fully captured by a circularity measure. Further investigation is needed to determine how these two techniques may be best used individually or together to advance clinical diagnosis, prevention, and rehabilitative interventions.