An in vitro splicing assay reveals the pathogenicity of a novel intronic variant in ATP6V0A4 for autosomal recessive distal renal tubular acidosis

The Contribution of COL4A5 Splicing Variants to the Pathogenesis of X-Linked Alport Syndrome

X-linked Alport syndrome (XLAS) is caused by pathogenic variants in COL4A5 and is characterized by progressive kidney disease, hearing loss, and ocular abnormalities. Recent advances in genetic analysis and further understanding of genotype-phenotype correlations in affected male patients raises the importance of detecting splicing variants in COL4A5. Aberrant splicing of COL4A5 is caused not only by canonical splice site variants but also non-canonical splice site variants such as deep intronic changes or even substitutions in exons. Patients with splicing variants account for ~15% of all cases in XLAS. In addition, it has been shown that there is a significant difference in kidney survival depending on the aberrant splicing patterns of transcripts- in particular in-frame or out-of-frame nucleotide changes in transcripts. Therefore, cDNA analysis of patient mRNA is necessary to determine the impact of splice site variants and to confirm a diagnosis of XLAS and to predict the kidney prognosis. However, it is usually difficult to amplify COL4A5 transcripts extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes. For these cases, in vitro minigene assays or RNA sequence extracted from urine derived cells can confirm aberrant splicing patterns. Moreover, controlling aberrant splicing by nucleic acids or small molecular compounds in genetic diseases are attracting attention as a potential therapeutic strategy. Here, we review the frequency of splicing variants in COL4A5, the latest diagnostic strategies, and the prospects for new therapeutic approaches.

Systematic Review of Genotype-Phenotype Correlations in Frasier Syndrome

Introduction

Frasier syndrome (FS) is a rare inherited kidney disease caused by intron 9 splicing variants of WT1. For wild-type WT1, 2 active splice donor sites in intron 9 cause a mixture of 2 essential transcripts (with or without lysine-threonine-serine [+/KTS or −KTS]), and imbalance of the +KTS/−KTS ratio results in the development of FS. To date, 6 causative intron 9 variants have been identified; however, detailed transcript analysis has not yet been conducted and the genotype-phenotype correlation also remains to be elucidated.

Methods

We conducted an in vitro minigene splicing assay for 6 reported causative variants and in vivo RNA sequencing to determine the +KTS/−KTS ratio using patients’ samples. We also performed a systematic review of reported FS cases with a description of the renal phenotype.

Results

The in vitro assay revealed that although all mutant alleles produced −KTS transcripts only, the wild-type allele produced both +KTS and −KTS transcripts at a 1:1 ratio. In vivo RNA sequencing showed that patients’ samples with all heterozygous variants produced similar ratios of +KTS to −KTS (1:3.2−1:3.5) and wild-type kidney showed almost a 1:1 ratio (1:0.85). A systematic review of 126 cases clarified that the median age of developing ESKD was 16 years in all FS patients, and there were no statistically significant differences between the genotypes or sex chromosome karyotypes in terms of the renal survival period.

Conclusion

Our study suggested no differences in splicing pattern or renal survival period among reported intron 9 variants causative of FS.

Usefulness of functional splicing analysis to confirm precise disease pathogenesis in Diamond-Blackfan anemia caused by intronic variants in RPS19

Diamond-Blackfan anemia (DBA) is mainly caused by pathogenic variants in ribosomal proteins and 22 responsible genes have been identified to date. The most common causative gene of DBA is RPS19 [NM_001022.4]. Nearly 180 RPS19 variants have been reported, including three deep intronic variants outside the splicing consensus sequence (c.72-92A > G, c.356 + 18G > C, and c.411 + 6G > C). We also identified one case with a c.412-3C > G intronic variant. Without conducting transcript analysis, the pathogenicity of these variants is unknown. However, it is difficult to assess transcripts because of their fragility. In such cases, in vitro functional splicing assays can be used to assess pathogenicity. Here, we report functional splicing analysis results of four RPS19 deep intronic variants identified in our case and in previously reported cases. One splicing consensus variant (c.411 + 1G > A) was also examined as a positive control. Aberrant splicing with a 2-bp insertion between exons 5 and 6 was identified in the patient samples and minigene assay results also identified exon 6 skipping in our case. The exon 6 skipping transcript was confirmed by further evaluation using quantitative RT-PCR. Additionally, minigene assay analysis of three reported deep intronic variants revealed that none of them showed aberrant splicing and that these variants were not considered to be pathogenic. In conclusion, the minigene assay is a useful method for functional splicing analysis of inherited disease.

Genotypic and phenotypic analysis in 51 Chinese patients with primary distal renal tubular acidosis

The aim of this study was to analyze the genetic variants of 51 Chinese patients with distal renal tubular acidosis (dRTA) and explore the correlation between their genotype and phenotype. Eight variants of SLC4A1, 19 variants of ATP6V0A4, and 16 variants of ATP6V1B1 have been identified, and of which 14 were novel ones. Eleven patients with autosomal dominant dRTA, and four patients with autosomal recessive dRTA were caused by genetic defects in SLC4A1; 18 and nine patients with recessive dRTA were resulted by defects in ATP6V0A4 and ATP6V1B1 respectively; no causal gene was identified in seven patients. Mutation frequency of SLC4A1 in Chinese populations was more common than Europeans. The incidence of deafness in ATP6V0A4 and ATP6V1B1 groups was 16.7% and 54.5%, respectively. The frequency of CKD in adults, children and infants was 100%, 51%, and 3%, separately. Our study will further expand the mutation spectrum of primary dRTA and provide valuable references to genetic counseling of Chinese populations.

Exon-Trapping Assay Improves Clinical Interpretation of COL11A1 and COL11A2 Intronic Variants in Stickler Syndrome Type 2 and Otospondylomegaepiphyseal Dysplasia

Stickler syndrome (SS) is a hereditary connective tissue disorder affecting bones, eyes, and hearing. Type 2 SS and the SS variant otospondylomegaepiphyseal dysplasia (OSMED) are caused by deleterious variants in COL11A1 and COL11A2, respectively. In both genes, available database information indicates a high rate of potentially deleterious intronic variants, but published evidence of their biological effect is usually insufficient for a definite clinical interpretation. We report four previously unpublished intronic variants in COL11A1 (c.2241 + 5G>T, c.2809 − 2A>G, c.3168 + 5G>C) and COL11A2 (c.4392 + 1G>A) identified in type 2 SS/OSMED individuals. The pathogenic effect of these variants was first predicted in silico and then investigated by an exon-trapping assay. We demonstrated that all variants can induce exon in-frame deletions, which lead to the synthesis of shorter collagen XI α1 or 2 chains. Lacking residues are located in the α-triple helical region, which has a crucial role in regulating collagen fibrillogenesis. In conclusion, this study suggests that these alternative COL11A1 and COL11A2 transcripts might result in aberrant triple helix collagen. Our approach may help to improve the diagnostic molecular pathway of COL11-related disorders.

Dual Fluorescence Splicing Reporter Minigene Identifies an Antisense Oligonucleotide to Skip Exon v8 of the CD44 Gene

Splicing reporter minigenes are used in cell-based in vitro splicing studies. Exon skippable antisense oligonucleotide (ASO) has been identified using minigene splicing assays, but these assays include a time- and cost-consuming step of reverse transcription PCR amplification. To make in vitro splicing assay easier, a ready-made minigene (FMv2) amenable to quantitative splicing analysis by fluorescence microscopy was constructed. FMv2 was designed to encode two fluorescence proteins namely, mCherry, a transfection marker and split eGFP, a marker of splicing reaction. The split eGFP was intervened by an artificial intron containing a multicloning site sequence. Expectedly, FMv2 transfected HeLa cells produced not only red mCherry but also green eGFP signals. Transfection of FMv2CD44v8, a modified clone of FMv2 carrying an insertion of CD44 exon v8 in the multicloning site, that was applied to screen exon v8 skippable ASO, produced only red signals. Among seven different ASOs tested against exon v8, ASO#14 produced the highest index of green signal positive cells. Hence, ASO#14 was the most efficient exon v8 skippable ASO. Notably, the well containing ASO#14 was clearly identified among the 96 wells containing randomly added ASOs, enabling high throughput screening. A ready-made FMv2 is expected to contribute to identify exon skippable ASOs.

Functional analysis of suspected splicing variants in CLCN5 gene in Dent disease 1

Background

In recent years, the elucidation of splicing abnormalities as a cause of hereditary diseases has progressed. However, there are no comprehensive reports of suspected splicing variants in the CLCN5 gene in Dent disease cases. We reproduced gene mutations by mutagenesis, inserted the mutated genes into minigene vectors, and investigated the pathogenicity and onset mechanisms of these variants.

Methods

We conducted functional splicing assays using a hybrid minigene for six suspected splicing variants (c.105G>A, c.105+5G>C, c.106−17T>G, c.393+4A>G, c.517−8A>G, c.517−3C>A) in CLCN5. We extracted information on these variants from the Human Gene Mutation Database. We reproduced minigene vectors with the insertion of relevant exons with suspected splicing variants. We then transfected these minigene vectors into cultured cells and extracted and analyzed the mRNA. In addition, we conducted in silico analysis to confirm our minigene assay results.

Results

We successfully determined that five of these six variants are pathogenic via the production of splicing abnormalities. One showed only normal transcript production and was thus suspected of not being pathogenic (c.106−17T>G).

Conclusion

We found that five CLCN5 variants disrupted the original splice site, resulting in aberrant splicing. It is sometimes difficult to obtain mRNA from patient samples because of the fragility of mRNA or its low expression level in peripheral leukocytes. Our in vitro system can be used as an alternative to in vivo assays to determine the pathogenicity of suspected splicing variants.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s10157-020-01876-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Molecular Diagnosis and Identification of Genetic Variants Underlying Distal Renal Tubular Acidosis in Pakistani Patients Using Whole Exome Sequencing

Introduction: Primary distal renal tubular acidosis (dRTA) is a rare genetic disorder characterized by an impaired urinary acidification process in distal nephrons that results in the production of alkaline urine. Loss of function variants in any of the three genes, ATP6V0A4, ATP6V1B1, or SLC4A1, which all play a role in normal acidification of urine by kidneys, may lead to dRTA. Objective: This study was designed to identify genetic variants underlying dRTA in Pakistani patients using whole exome sequencing, followed by confirmatory Sanger sequencing. Materials and Methods: Patients were identified following presentation with characteristic clinical features of dRTA including vomiting, dehydration, and highly alkaline urine with metabolic acidosis during the first few days of life. Whole exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing were employed for genetic analyses of the patients. In silico analyses of the identified variants were performed using web-based bioinfomatics programs. Results: Through whole exome sequencing, we identified two splice site variants (c.2257 + 1G>A and c.722 + 5G>A) in the ATP6V0A4 gene that likely underly the disease phenotype in the two families. Multiple in silico tools predicted these variants to affect the respective splice sites supporting their likely role in pathogenesis. Conclusion: The study extends the spectrum of ATP6V0A4 variants associated with dRTA and should benefit the genetic counseling and prenatal diagnosis of the affected families.

Determination of the pathogenicity of known COL4A5 intronic variants by in vitro splicing assay

X-linked Alport syndrome (XLAS) is a congenital renal disease caused by mutations in COL4A5. In XLAS cases suspected of being caused by aberrant splicing, transcript analysis needs to be conducted to determine splicing patterns and assess the pathogenicity. However, such analysis is not always available. We conducted a functional splicing assay using a hybrid minigene for seven COL4A5 intronic mutations: one was identified by us and six were found in the Human Gene Mutation Database. The minigene assay revealed exon skipping in four variants, exon skipping and a 10-bp insertion in one variant, and no change in one variant, which appeared not to be pathogenic. For one variant, our assay did not work. The results of all three cases for which transcript data were available were consistent with our assay results. Our findings may help to increase the accuracy of genetic test results and clarify the mechanisms causing aberrant splicing.

Functional splicing analysis in an infantile case of atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome caused by digenic mutations in C3 and MCP genes

Pathogenic variants in specific complement-related genes lead to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS). Some reports have indicated that patients with digenic variants in these genes might present severer phenotypes. Upon detecting novel intronic variants, transcriptional analysis is necessary to prove pathogenicity; however, when intronic variants are located in intron 1 and, as a result, no transcript is produced, no appropriate method had been established to reveal the pathogenicity. Recently, the minigene assay was used to assess the pathogenicity of intronic variants. Here, we report an infantile case of aHUS caused by digenic mutations in two different complement-related genes, C3 and MCP. Targeted sequencing detected a known variant in C3 and a novel variant in the intron 1 splicing donor site of MCP. To assess the pathogenicity of this intronic variant, we conducted functional splicing assay using a minigene construct and quantitative PCR analysis of the MCP transcript, revealing the pathogenicity of the intronic variant. In conclusion, the minigene assay revealed the pathogenicity of the intron 1 splicing donor site variant for the first time. This case showed a severe phenotype of infantile-onset aHUS associated with digenic variants in two complement-related genes.