Healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care: a systematic review with meta-analysis

Candid insights and overlooked facets: what medical students write about patient-centeredness in diaries on longitudinal patient contacts

Despite students' exposure to patient-centered care principles, their dedication to patient-centeredness often experiences a wane throughout their academic journey. The process of learning patient-centeredness is complex and not yet fully understood. Therefore, in our study, we sought to explore what aspects of patient-centeredness students spontaneously document in their diaries during interactions with actual patients. This investigation will help to identify gaps in the current educational practices and better prepare future clinicians to deliver patient-centered healthcare. We analyzed 92 diaries of 28 third-year undergraduate medical students at UMC Utrecht in the Netherlands who participated in an educational intervention, following four patients each as companions over a two-year period early in their clerkships. We conducted thematic analysis, using inductive and deductive coding, within a social-constructionist paradigm. We identified four key themes: communication, the person behind the patient, collaboration and organization in healthcare, and students' professional development. Within these themes, we observed that students spontaneously documented 9 of 15 dimensions of patient-centeredness as outlined in the model of Scholl : 'clinician-patient communication', 'patient as unique person', 'biopsychological perspective', 'essential characteristics of the clinician', 'clinician-patient relationship', 'involvement of family and friends', 'patient-information', 'emotional support' and 'coordination and continuity of care' (mainly principles of patient-centeredness). Conversely, we noted that students underreported six other dimensions (enablers and activities): 'access to care', 'integration of medical and non-medical care', 'teamwork and teambuilding', 'patient involvement in care', 'patient empowerment' and 'physical support'. Throughout their longitudinal journey of following patients as non-medical companions, students spontaneously documented some aspects of patient-centeredness in their diaries. Additionally, students reflected on their own professional development. Our findings suggest that incorporating education on the broadness of the concept of patient-centeredness coupled with enhanced guidance, could potentially enable students to learn about the complete spectrum of patient-centeredness within their medical education.

Exploring facilitators and barriers for delivering person-centered care in a socio-economically diverse context: Perspectives of speech-language pathologists and audiologists

OBJECTIVE

The study aimed to explore facilitators and barriers in delivering person-centered care from the perspective of speech-language pathologists and audiologists in a socio- economically diverse workplace across micro, meso, and macro levels.

METHOD

A national cross-sectional e-survey was conducted among pooled speech-language pathologists and/or audiologists from South Africa. The e-survey included quantitative components to describe participant demographics which was analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics. The qualitative data was analyzed using metaphor and thematic analysis approaches to describe respondents' perspectives of barriers and facilitators in delivering person-centered care.

RESULTS

The e-survey was completed by 63 clinicians (36.5% Audiologists; 36.5% Speech-Language Therapists; 27.0% dually qualified Speech-Language Therapists and Audiologists) mostly between the ages of 26 to 35 years old (33.3%). Respondents were working in various settings including the public sector (41.3%), private sector (44.4%) and in academia (14.3%). Facilitators and barriers were identified within all three systems (macro, meso and micro). The metaphor analysis resulted in six categories: uncertainty of Person centered care; its essential nature; associated challenges; relational aspect; analogies referring to animals; and food-related analogies. Thematic analysis of open-ended questions revealed five barriers, with three relating to micro systems; i) clinician factors, ii) client factors, iii) clinician and client interaction, and two related to factors within the meso system; iv) resources, and v) workplace. Only two themes were identified as facilitators towards PCC, clinician factors (mirco) and workplace factors (meso).'

CONCLUSIONS

Insights gained from exploring Speech-Language Pathologists' and Audiologists' perceptions of implementing PCC in a socio-economically diverse setting highlight the need to address contextual (meso and macro systems) and personal (micro system) factors to promote and deliver PCC effectively. Notably, for the public sector, resources emerged as a major concern and barrier on the macro system level. Despite these challenges, the investigation revealed two noteworthy facilitators: clinician factors, at the micro level, and workplace factors, at the meso level. This nuanced understanding emphasizes the necessity of tailored interventions targeting both individual and systemic aspects to enhance the successful implementation of person-centered care.

PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS

Strategies should focus on enhancing clinicians' communication skills, collaboration, and teamwork, as well as addressing resource limitations through the adaptation of tools and implementation of PCC ISO standards.

Lebanese nursing students' perceptions of barriers to the implementation of person-centered care in clinical settings: A qualitative study

AIM

This study aims to investigate how Lebanese nursing students perceive the challenges of implementing person-centered care in clinical settings.

DESIGN

A qualitative descriptive design was adopted for this study.

METHODS

At one of Lebanon's top universities, a qualitative descriptive study design was used with 18 nursing students from various academic levels. Content analysis was used to generate the results after three focus group discussions. The Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research were used to report this study.

RESULTS

The content analysis gave rise to four main themes, namely, "overload", "challenges with education", "unawareness", "establishing connection", and "lack of initiatives related to policy". The results showed a number of obstacles that Lebanese nursing students believed were in the path of providing person-centered care. These obstacles included organisational issues like time restraints and an intense workload, as well as interaction difficulties with patients and healthcare teams, and educational issues like insufficient instruction in person-centered care concepts during nursing programs.

Attitudes toward Patient-Centred Care, Empathy, and Assertiveness among Students in Rehabilitation Areas: A Longitudinal Study

This study assessed attitudes toward patient-centred care, empathy, assertiveness, and subjective perception of communication skills and technical knowledge among Portuguese undergraduate students in healthcare. These students may develop rehabilitation activities with patients in their person-oriented or technique-oriented professions. Portuguese nursing and allied health students from two public higher education schools completed questionnaires in the first and third academic years: Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale, Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy, Scale for Interpersonal Behaviour, and a subjective perception of technical knowledge and communication skills. A total of 183 students completed the surveys. In the first year, students showed moderate to high scores on patient-centredness attitudes, empathy, and assertiveness and perceived themselves as having good communication skills. Students from person-oriented programmes significantly improved their Total and shared patient-centred attitudes in the third year compared with students attending technique-oriented professions. Significant differences in empathy were found between groups in the third year. Distress associated with assertive behaviours increased significantly across time in students from technique-oriented programmes compared with their peers in person-oriented programmes. The results suggest that the health profession's orientation and the programmes' specific curriculum might have a role in how some dimensions evolved in the two groups of students. The increasing assertiveness-related discomfort highlighted the importance of assessing and monitoring students' emotional wellbeing during their initial interactions with patients.

Patient-centred care attitudes and knowledge: a national study of BDS students in New Zealand

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the attitudes and knowledge towards patient-centred care among Bachelor of Dental Surgery (BDS) students in New Zealand.

METHOD

The study was a mixed methods cross-sectional national study of the BDS students in New Zealand. All 2021 BDS students at the New Zealand's National Centre for Dentistry, New Zealand, were recruited in the study. The Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale (PPOS) questionnaire was used to evaluate the dental students' attitudes and knowledge of patient centred care. The students' perspectives on the BDS curriculum regarding patient-centred care were also collected. ANOVA and the Student's T-test were used to compare the difference among the BDS years, gender, and background.

RESULTS

A total of N = 277 (277/346; 80% response rate) students completed the study. Female students had higher scores than male students for sharing (difference = 0.19, 95% CI 0.04-0.34, P = 0.01), caring (difference = 0.15, 95% CI 0.01-0.29, P = 0.03) and PPOS (difference = 0.17, 95% CI 0.05-0.30, P < 0.01). Domestic students had higher scores than international students for caring (difference = 0.35, 95% CI 0.21-0.50, P < 0.01) and PPOS (difference = 0.22, 95% CI 0.08-0.35, P < 0.01). Three main themes of patient-centred care were extracted from the qualitative analysis of students' perspectives: (1) Understanding of the concept of patient-centred care, (2) Perception of the importance of patient-centred care in dentistry, and (3) Perspective on the curriculum about patient-centred care.

CONCLUSION

Most dental students favoured a patient-centred approach. According to dental students, the patient-centred care component of their education should be increased.

Person-centered care: preferences and predictors in speech-language pathology and audiology practitioners

Introduction

Increasingly person-centered care (PCC) is being recognized as an important aspect of speech-language pathology and audiology (SLP/A) service delivery. This study aimed to (i) identify preferences toward PCC; (ii) determine predictors of these preferences; and (iii) describe the understanding and views of PCC among SLP/A in South Africa.

Methods

A mixed-method design was followed utilizing an online survey and four focus group discussions. The survey included demographic questions, the modified Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale (mPPOS), the Ten-Item-Personality-Inventory (TIPI) and an open-ended question. The focus group discussions included prompting questions which facilitated an open-ended discussion.

Results

A total of 91 practitioners (39.6% speech-language pathologists) completed the online survey, with nine (44.4% audiologists) participating in the focus group discussions. A high preference toward PCC was noted, with a total mean mPPOS score of 4.6 (0.6 SD). Quantile regression analysis revealed four predictors (age, home language, sector, and personality trait openness) associated with PCC preferences. Three main categories emerged from the open-ended question and focus group discussions: (i) Positive experiences with PCC; (ii) restrictions toward PCC, and (iii) PCC exposure.

Discussion

Positive (age and personality trait openness) and negative (home language and sector of employment) predictors toward PCC exist among speech-language pathologists and audiologists, with an overall general preference toward PCC. Practitioners experience facilitators and barriers toward implementing PCC including the extent of personal experiences, available resources and tools as well as workplace culture. These aspects require further investigation.

Attitudes of Family Medicine Trainees Towards Patient-Centeredness Practice

Objective

The interaction between physicians and patients is essential in clinical practice. Patient-centered care (PCC) is becoming popular in healthcare and provides an approach to deliver high-quality healthcare to yield positive clinical outcomes. This study explores family medicine residents' attitudes toward the physician-patient relationship and patient-centered care and the possible influence of demographic characteristics, level of training, school of graduation, and previous training.

Methods

A cross-sectional study was conducted among family medicine residents in Riyadh. They were invited to enroll in a web-based survey that includes demographic data, training details, and the "Patient Practitioner Orientation Scale (PPOS).".

Results

A total of 114 family medicine residents completed the survey. There were 68 (59.6%) males and 46 (40.4%) female residents. The overall PPOS was 4.23 ± 0.53. The mean score for sharing domain was 3.97 ± 0.66. The caring domain scored 4.49 ± 0.57. No correlations were found between the residents' demographic data and other included variables, and the means of sharing domain, caring domain, and overall score.

Conclusion

Family medicine residents were found to have positive attitudes toward patient-centeredness. Integrating patient-centered training early in the curriculum can improve healthcare students' and trainees' attitudes toward patient-centered care. Future research can explore the possible interventions in systematic assessment and training programs that can improve PCP.

Impact of service-learning placement on pharmacy student knowledge, attitudes, and confidence in helping patients navigate Medicare Part D

INTRODUCTION

Pharmacists are in a prime position to empower patients to navigate Medicare Part D. This study aimed to determine if service-learning has a place in pharmacy student Medicare education. The primary objective of the study was to assess knowledge, attitudes, and confidence of first-year pharmacy students at Medicare focused service-learning sites compared to students at alternative sites.

METHODS

First-year pharmacy students at the University of Pittsburgh School of Pharmacy were assessed on their knowledge, attitudes, and confidence of Medicare Part D after a semester of service-learning either at a State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) or at an alternative site not focused on Medicare (control). All students attended a four-part lecture series on Medicare before starting service-learning. Students were surveyed at baseline and after their service-learning experience.

RESULTS

A total of 110 (94.8%) students successfully completed both the pre- and post-survey. Knowledge improved significantly in the SHIP group (P = .01) and did not increase significantly in the control group (P = .06). Attitudes toward Medicare Part D, assessed on a Likert scale, became less favorable in the control group (-0.40, P < .001). Student confidence in the ability to counsel patients on Medicare part D improved in the SHIP group (0.42, P < .001) and decreased in the control group (-0.80, P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Combining a didactic lecture series on Medicare Part D with service-learning involving Medicare counseling may solidify student knowledge of Medicare as well as students' confidence in helping patients navigate Medicare Part D.

Healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care: a systematic review with meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Patient centred care is commonly recommended in clinical practice guidelines to improve patient outcomes and reduce healthcare costs. Identifying measurement tools used to assess healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centered care and determining their attitudes is the first step to ensuring patient centred care is provided in the future. The primary aim of this review was to describe the measurement tools used to assess healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care. The secondary aim was to quantify healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care.

METHODS

An electronic database search was conducted in MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL from inception until March 1, 2021, with combined terms relating to 'patient centred care', 'attitudes', and 'healthcare students'. Studies that quantitatively assessed healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care were included. Measurement tools used in the included studies were qualitatively described. Meta-analysis was conducted to quantify healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care and assess the respective influence of gender, profession, and study geographical location on healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care.

RESULTS

The electronic search identified 3948 total studies. One hundred twenty-nine full texts were screened, and 49 studies were included. There were 16 measurement tools used to assess healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centered care. Most studies (53%, n = 26) used the Patient-Practitioner Orientation Scale (PPOS) to assess patient centered care. Meta-analyses of 20 studies with 26 total groups resulted in a pooled mean PPOS score of 4.16 on a 0-6 scale (95% Confidence Interval [CI]: 3.95, 4.37), indicating low attitudes towards patient centered care. Additional analyses found that women have significantly higher attitudes towards patients centred care than men (pooled effect 0.14 [95% CI: 0.05, 0.23], n = 8 studies) and mean PPOS scores appear similar among sub-groups of only medical students (pooled mean 4.13, 95% CI: 3.85, 4.42, n = 13 studies) and only American healthcare students (pooled mean 4.49, 95% CI: 4.35, 4.64, n = 5 studies).

CONCLUSIONS

Several different measurement tools have been used to assess healthcare students' attitudes towards patient centred care, but the most commonly used is the PPOS. Our results indicate that healthcare students have low attitudes towards patient centred care. Future studies should evaluate if attitudes towards patient centred care can be improved during healthcare education.