Cerebellar tonsil ectopia measurement in type I Chiari malformation patients show poor inter-operator reliability

Preoperative Predictors of Foramen Magnum Decompression with Dural Splitting for Amelioration of Syringomyelia Associated with Chiari Type 1 Malformation

OBJECTIVE

Among several procedures for syringomyelia associated with Chiari type 1 malformation (CM-1), foramen magnum decompression (FMD) with dural splitting is one of the treatment choices with low complication rates. However, some meta-analyses have suggested that FMD with dural splitting may be inferior to FMD with duraplasty based on clinical outcomes; therefore, a predictor of a good surgical outcome with dural splitting is essential. This study aimed to clarify the preoperative parameters for good outcomes in patients with FMD with dural splitting, including the volumetric perspective.

METHODS

We reviewed the cases of patients diagnosed with CM-1 and syringomyelia who underwent FMD with dural splitting at our institution. We included patients who underwent magnetic resonance imaging from 6 months to 1 year after surgery and measured radiological parameters using preoperative computed tomography and preoperative/follow-up magnetic resonance imaging.

RESULTS

Thirty-one patients were enrolled. Among all radiological parameters, the volume of the herniated tonsils (Vtonsil) in improved group was significantly smaller, and the difference between the expected volume increment and Vtonsil (Vincr-Vtonsil) in improved group was significantly larger than those in non-improved group. To predict the improvement of the syrinx, Vincr-Vtonsil of 0.77 mL was the optimal cutoff value and yielded 100% sensitivity and 48.0% specificity.

CONCLUSIONS

Vtonsil and Vincr-Vtonsil, which are novel predictors based on the volumetric perspective, might be the optimal predictors for improvement of the syrinx associated with CM-1 by 1 year after surgery.

Chiari I Deformity: Beyond 5 mm below the Foramen Magnum

Although originally described as a consecutive series of pathologic changes, Chiari syndrome represents a spectrum of disease divided into two subsets: development deformities of the paraxial mesoderm manifesting after birth (types 0-1.5) and true congenital malformations due to failure of neural tube closure present in utero (types 2-5). Heterogeneity among patients with a Chiari deformity and incomplete understanding of its pathophysiologic characteristics have led to inconsistency in radiologic reporting and difficulty in defining appropriate management strategies tailored to an individual patient's condition. The radiologist is tasked with going beyond the criteria for cerebellar tonsillar herniation to define an individual patient's disease state, determine candidacy for surgery, and assist in selecting the proper surgical approach. In addition, the radiologist must be able to identify conditions that result in cerebellar tonsillar herniation that are not related to Chiari deformity to avoid inappropriate surgery. Last, the radiologist must be able to interpret postoperative imaging examinations to assess for adequacy of treatment and complications. The authors summarize recent literature regarding the pathophysiologic basis of Chiari 1 and related deformities and detail the ideal morphologic and physiologic imaging assessment, focusing on Chiari 1 and related deformities (Chiari 0, 0.5, and 1.5). Also discussed are surgical techniques and "pearls" of postsurgical imaging, including complications that must be recognized. This review provides clarity to a commonly encountered but less understood condition to optimize outcomes for patients with Chiari 1 and related deformities. ©RSNA, 2024 Supplemental material is available for this article. See the invited commentary by Huisman in this issue.

Cognition in Chiari Malformation Type I: an Update of a Systematic Review

Chiari malformation has been classified as a group of posterior cranial fossa disorders characterized by hindbrain herniation. Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) is the most common subtype, ranging from asymptomatic patients to those with severe disorders. Research about clinical manifestations or medical treatments is still growing, but cognitive functioning has been less explored. The aim of this systematic review is to update the literature search about cognitive deficits in CM-I patients. A literature search was performed through the following electronic databases: MEDLINE, PsychINFO, Pubmed, Cochrane Library, Scopus, and Web of Science. The date last searched was February 1, 2023. The inclusion criteria were as follows: (a) include pediatric or adult participants with a CM-I diagnosis, (b) include cognitive or neuropsychological assessment with standardized tests, (c) be published in English or Spanish, and (d) be empirical studies. Articles that did not report empirical data, textbooks and conference abstracts were excluded. After the screening, twenty-eight articles were included in this systematic review. From those, twenty-one articles were focused on adult samples and seven included pediatric patients. There is a great heterogeneity in the recruited samples, followed methodology and administered neurocognitive protocols. Cognitive functioning appears to be affected in CM-I patients, at least some aspects of attention, executive functions, visuospatial abilities, episodic memory, or processing speed. However, these results require careful interpretation due to the methodological limitations of the studies. Although it is difficult to draw a clear profile of cognitive deficits related to CM-I, the literature suggests that cognitive dysfunction may be a symptom of CM-I. This suggest that clinicians should include cognitive assessment in their diagnostic procedures used for CM-I. In summary, further research is needed to determine a well-defined cognitive profile related to CM-I, favoring a multidisciplinary approach of this disorder.

Geometric morphometric analysis of the brainstem and cerebellum in Chiari I malformation

Background

Chiari I malformation (CMI) is characterized by inferior descent of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum and is associated with headache and neck pain. Many morphometric research efforts have aimed to describe CMI anatomy in the midsagittal plane using classical measurement techniques such as linear dimensions and angles. These methods are less frequently applied to parasagittal features and may fall short in quantifying more intricate anatomy with fewer distinct homologous landmarks.

Methods

Landmark-based geometric morphometric techniques were used to asses CMI morphology in five anatomical planes of interest.

Results

Significant shape differences between CMI and age/sex-matched controls were found in the midsagittal (Pseudo-F = 5.4841, p = 0.001) and axial planes through the rostral medulla (Pseudo-F = 7.6319, p = 0.001). In addition to tonsillar descent, CMI principal component 1 (PC1) scores in the midsagittal protocol were associated with marked anterior concavity of the brainstem and generalized verticality of the cerebellum with anterior rotation of its anterior lobe. In the axial medulla/cerebellum protocol, CMI PC1 scores were associated with greater anterior-posterior (A-P) dimension with loss of medial-lateral (M-L) dimension.

Discussion

These results suggest that CMI is associated with greater curvature of the brainstem and spinal cord, which may perturb normal neural activities and disrupt cerebrospinal fluid movements. Previous reports on the A-P diameter of the posterior fossa in CMI have conflicted; our findings of greater A-P cerebellar dimensionality with concomitant loss of width alludes to the possibility that more caudal aspects of the posterior cranial fossa are more bowl-like (homogenous in axial dimensions) and less trough-like or elongated in the M-L direction.

Surgical Outcomes in Chiari 1 and Chiari 1.5 Malformation Treated by Posterior Fossa Reconstruction: A Comprehensive Analysis of 110 Pediatric Cases and Literature Review

Background/Objectives: The management of Chiari malformations (CMs) remains a clinical challenge and a topic of great controversy. Results may vary between children and adults. The purpose of the current single-center study is to critically assess the one-year surgical outcomes of a cohort of 110 children with CM-1 or CM-1.5 who were treated using "posterior fossa reconstruction" (PFR), a surgical technique described in 1994 that has since been used in both adults and children. We also review the literature and discuss the possible causes of the drawbacks and pitfalls in children in whom PFR was ineffective in controlling the disease. Methods: The present cohort was selected from a prospective registry of adults and children with CMs collected since 2006. Patients included in this study were selected from a group of children with CMs who were operated on in our Pediatric Neurosurgical Unit between 1 January 2007 and 31 November 2023. Surgical outcome was defined based on clinical and neuroradiological results as very good, good, or bad. Results: The mean age of our child cohort was 9.9 ± 4.7 years, with 54 girls (49%) and 56 boys (51%). Sixty-six children had CM-1 (60%) while forty-four had CM-1.5 (40%). Following surgery, there was no neurological worsening or death among the children. Most children (70%) had an uneventful recovery and were discharged home on average one week after surgery. However, in 33 children (30%), we recorded at least one postoperative adverse event. Aseptic meningitis syndrome was the most frequent adverse event (n = 25, 22.7%). The final surgical outcome was evaluated one year after PFR by using both clinical and neuroradiological results. The one-year surgical outcome was excellent in 101 children (91.9%), good in 5 (4.5%), and bad in 4 (3.6%). Conclusions: PFR significantly enlarges the volume of the posterior fossa and recreates a CSF environment that generates buoyancy of the cerebellum, with a high percentage of excellent and good clinical results evaluated one year post-surgery.

Evaluating the Need for Durotomy and Duraplasty in Adults Undergoing Suboccipital Craniectomy for Chiari Decompression: A Case Series Analysis of Radiographic and Clinical Outcomes

Background Suboccipital craniectomy (SOC) in conjunction with dura opening and duraplasty for posterior fossa decompression is an effective treatment for symptomatic Chiari 1 malformations (CM1), primarily carried out in the pediatric population. However, dural opening and reconstruction are associated with an increased risk of complications, and their necessity in the adult population has not yet been robustly demonstrated. Given differences in clinical presentation and disease severity between the pediatric and adult patients, we aimed to identify if SOC alone with intraoperative ultrasound confirmation of adequate restoration of pulsatile motion of cerebellar tonsil is sufficient to treat symptomatic CM1 while mitigating surgical risks. Methods We identified a retrospective, institutional cohort of adult patients who underwent SOC for Chiari decompression between 2014 and 2023. Demographic, clinical, and radiographic features were extracted for each patient. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Chicago Chiari Outcome Scale (CCOS) and Motor-Sensory-Sphincter signs score (Clinical Sign Score (CSS)). Radiographic outcomes assessed cerebellar ectopia and associated syrinx characteristics. Results A total of 15 patients were identified, with an average follow-up period of three years. Eight patients underwent SOC with duraplasty, whereas seven patients underwent SOC only without duraplasty. Both groups of patients were of similar age at surgery and had similar nature and duration of symptoms prior to surgery. On pre-operative radiographic evaluation, both groups of patients had similar lengths of cerebellar ectopia (9.9±11.0 mm to 11.1±5.7 mm, p=0.591), and associated syrinxes (75% vs. 42.9%, p=0.205). Intraoperatively, both groups had similar estimated blood losses, though the length of surgery was significantly shorter when durotomy was spared (202±58.3 minutes to 116.3±47.8 minutes, p=0.011). The length of ICU stay was also significantly longer in the durotomy group (1.1±0.6 days to 0.0 days, p<0.001). Neither group reported any post-operative complications. On follow-up, both groups demonstrated similar reductions in cerebellar ectopia and syrinx characteristics. Clinically, the CCOS and CSS scores were similar between the two cohorts at follow-up, with no repeat surgery required in either group. Conclusion Our cohort suggests that for adult CM1 patients, SOC decompression alone without dural reconstruction might lead to comparable clinical and radiographic outcomes to SOC decompression with durotomy/duraplasty, especially if intraoperative ultrasound confirms good cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow after SOC. Notably, sparing durotomy and duraplasty is also associated with decreased operative time and decreased ICU stay.

A genetic component in Chiari I malformation: Chiari 1 malformation in all five family members

Under certain classifications, a Chiari type I (CMI) malformation can be characterized as a herniation of the cerebellar tonsils greater than 3 mm. Patients with CMI often have a smaller posterior fossa volume, which results in a smaller amount of space for the cerebellum, leading to the herniation of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum. Although inheritable factors such as posterior fossa volume can be traced to specific genes, there has not been a gene that can be attributed to directly causing CMI. However, several cases of CMI have exhibited a familial inheritance pattern. There are mixed findings regarding the exact nature of its inheritance, with some papers arguing in favor of an autosomal dominant pattern. In this case series, we detail a mother, father, and all 3 of their children diagnosed with CMI. Previous literature has not included both a mother and father with CMI.

Evaluation and Treatment of Patients with Small Posterior Cranial Fossa and Chiari Malformation, Types 0 and 1

The diagnosis of Chiari I malformation is straightforward in patients with typical signs and symptoms of Chiari I malformation and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) confirming ≥5 mm of cerebellar tonsillar ectopia, with or without a syrinx. However, in many cases, Chiari I malformation is discovered incidentally on MRI to evaluate global headache, cervical radiculopathy, or other conditions. In those cases, the clinician must consider if cerebellar tonsillar ectopia is related to the presenting symptoms. Surgical decompression of the cerebellar tonsils and foramen magnum in patients with symptomatic Chiari I malformation effectively relieves suboccipital headache, reduces syrinx distension, and arrests syringomyelia progression. Neurosurgeons must avoid operative treatments decompressing incidental tonsillar ectopia, not causing symptoms. Such procedures unnecessarily place patients at risk of operative complications and tissue injuries related to surgical exploration. This chapter reviews the typical signs and symptoms of Chiari I malformation and its variant, Chiari 0 malformation, which has <5 mm of cerebellar tonsillar ectopia and is often associated with syringomyelia. Chiari I and Chiari 0 malformations are associated with incomplete occipital bone development, reduced volume and height of the posterior fossa, tonsillar ectopia, and compression of the neural elements and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pathways at the foramen magnum. Linear, angular, cross-sectional area, and volume measurements of the posterior fossa, craniocervical junction, and upper cervical spine identify morphometric abnormalities in Chiari I and Chiari 0 malformation patients. Chiari 0 patients respond like Chiari I patients to foramen magnum decompression and should not be excluded from surgical treatment because their tonsillar ectopia is <5 mm. The authors recommend the adoption of diagnostic criteria for Chiari 0 malformation without syringomyelia. This chapter provides updated information and guidance to the physicians managing Chiari I and Chiari 0 malformation patients and neuroscientists interested in Chiari malformations.

A Critical Update of the Classification of Chiari and Chiari-like Malformations

Chiari malformations are a group of craniovertebral junction anomalies characterized by the herniation of cerebellar tonsils below the foramen magnum, often accompanied by brainstem descent. The existing classification systems for Chiari malformations have expanded from the original four categories to nine, leading to debates about the need for a more descriptive and etiopathogenic terminology. This review aims to examine the various classification approaches employed and proposes a simplified scheme to differentiate between different types of tonsillar herniations. Furthermore, it explores the most appropriate terminology for acquired herniation of cerebellar tonsils and other secondary Chiari-like malformations. Recent advances in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) have revealed a higher prevalence and incidence of Chiari malformation Type 1 (CM1) and identified similar cerebellar herniations in individuals unrelated to the classic phenotypes described by Chiari. As we reassess the existing classifications, it becomes crucial to establish a terminology that accurately reflects the diverse presentations and underlying causes of these conditions. This paper contributes to the ongoing discussion by offering insights into the evolving understanding of Chiari malformations and proposing a simplified classification and terminology system to enhance diagnosis and management.

Reliability and Agreement in the Cerebellar Tonsil Tip Localization: Two Methods Using the McRae Line Concept in MRI

BACKGROUND

The cerebellar tonsil tip position (TP) is a common parameter used for the radiologic diagnosis of Chiari malformation type 1 (CM1). However, these paramedian structures are usually not properly visualized in the midsagittal section. Such mismatch may be a source of bias in TP measurements based on the McRae line (ML) traced between median craniometric points. This study aims to evaluate the intraoperator and interoperator reliability and agreement of 2 protocols to trace the ML in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the cerebellar tonsil tip localization, adding a 3-dimensional multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) approach to the midsagittal plane.

METHODS

Sixty-two T1-weighted head MRIs were obtained for 32 CM1 patients and 30 controls. Two operators independently applied 2 TP measurement protocols, one considering only the visualization of the sagittal plane and the other using MPR. The intraclass correlation coefficient was used to assess intraoperator and interoperator reliability, and the Bland-Altman graphical method was used to evaluate the agreement between the measurement protocols.

RESULTS

The sagittal method significantly underestimated ML and tonsillar herniation when compared with the MPR method. The MPR method provided better reliability of the ML measurement when compared to the sagittal method, but this did not influence the reliability of the TP. Analysis of the Bland-Altman plot showed that the limits of agreement were close to acceptable for the ML, but not for measures of TP.

CONCLUSIONS

The standardization of the LM tracing by the MPR method improves the acquisition of data regarding the position of the tonsils.

Headache characteristics and postoperative course in Chiari I malformation

Background

Chiari I malformation typically presents with cough headache. However, migraine-like or tension-type-like headaches may also occur. There are limited publications on Chiari I malformation-associated headache semiologies and the effect of foramen magnum decompression on different headache types.

Methods

A retrospective analysis complemented by structured phone interviews was performed on 65 patients with Chiari I malformation, treated at our hospital between 2010 and 2021. Headache semiology (according to ICHD-3), frequency, intensity, and radiological characteristics were evaluated pre- and postoperatively.

Results

We included 65 patients. 38 patients were female and 27 male. Mean age was 43.9 ± 15.7 years. Headache was predominant in 41 patients (63.0%). Twenty-one patients had cough headache and 20 had atypical headache (12 migrainous, eight tension-type headache-like). Thirty-five patients with headache underwent surgery. Frequency, intensity, and analgesic use was significantly reduced in cough headache (p < 0.001). Atypical headaches improved less (p = 0.004 to 0.176). Exploratory analysis suggested that larger preoperative tonsillar descent correlated with larger postoperative headache intensity relief (p = 0.025).

Conclusion

Decompression was effective in Chiari I malformation-related cough headache. Atypical headache responded less well, and the causal relation with Chiari I malformation remains uncertain. For atypical headache, decompression should only be considered after failed appropriate preventive therapy and within an interdisciplinary approach involving a neurologist.

Use of deep learning in the MRI diagnosis of Chiari malformation type I

Purpose

To train deep learning convolutional neural network (CNN) models for classification of clinically significant Chiari malformation type I (CM1) on MRI to assist clinicians in diagnosis and decision making.

Methods

A retrospective MRI dataset of patients diagnosed with CM1 and healthy individuals with normal brain MRIs from the period January 2010 to May 2020 was used to train ResNet50 and VGG19 CNN models to automatically classify images as CM1 or normal. A total of 101 patients diagnosed with CM1 requiring surgery and 111 patients with normal brain MRIs were included (median age 30 with an interquartile range of 23–43; 81 women with CM1). Isotropic volume transformation, image cropping, skull stripping, and data augmentation were employed to optimize model accuracy. K-fold cross validation was used to calculate sensitivity, specificity, and the area under receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) for model evaluation.

Results

The VGG19 model with data augmentation achieved a sensitivity of 97.1% and a specificity of 97.4% with an AUC of 0.99. The ResNet50 model achieved a sensitivity of 94.0% and a specificity of 94.4% with an AUC of 0.98.

Conclusions

VGG19 and ResNet50 CNN models can be trained to automatically detect clinically significant CM1 on MRI with a high sensitivity and specificity. These models have the potential to be developed into clinical support tools in diagnosing CM1.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00234-022-02921-0.

Diagnostic utility of parasagittal measurements of tonsillar herniation in Chiari I malformation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Although the cerebellar tonsils are parasagittal structures, the extent of tonsillar herniation (ETH) in Chiari I malformation (CMI) is currently measured in the midsagittal plane. We measured the ETH of each cerebellar tonsil in the parasagittal plane and assessed their diagnostic utility by comparing them to the midsagittal ETH measurements in predicting cough-associated headache (CAH), an indicator of clinically significant disease in CMI.

METHODS

Eighty-five CMI patients with 3D-MPRAGE images were included. Neurosurgeons determined the presence of CAH. Sagittal images were used to measure ETH in the midsagittal (MS_ETH) and parasagittal planes (by locating tonsillar tips on each side on reformatted coronal images). Given the parasagittal ETH (PS_ETH) asymmetry in the majority of cases, they were considered Smaller_PS_ETH or Larger_PS_ETH. The accuracy of ETH measurements was assessed by the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.

RESULTS

Of 85 patients, 46 reported CAH. ROC analysis showed an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.78 for Smaller_PS_ETH significantly better than 0.65 for MS-ETH in predicting CAH (p = 0.001). An AUC of 0.68 for Larger_PS_ETH was not significantly different from MS_ETH. The sensitivity and specificity of predicting CAH were 87% and 28% for MS_ETH >6 mm versus 90% and 46% for Smaller_PS_ETH >6 mm, and 52% and 67% for MS_ETH >9 mm versus 48% and 87% for Smaller_PS_ETH >9 mm. At ETH >15 mm, no differences were seen between the measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

Diagnostic utility of ETH measurements in detecting clinically significant CMI can be improved by parasagittal measurements of the cerebellar tonsillar herniation.

Is there a morphometric cause of Chiari malformation type I? Analysis of existing literature

Although many etiologies have been proposed for Chiari malformation type I (CM-I), there currently is no singular known cause of CM-I pathogenesis. Advances in imaging have greatly progressed the study of CM-I. This study reviews the literature to determine if an anatomical cause for CM-I could be proposed from morphometric studies in adult CM-I patients. After conducting a literature search using relevant search terms, two authors screened abstracts for relevance. Full-length articles of primary morphometric studies published in peer-reviewed journals were included. Detailed information regarding methodology and symptomatology, craniocervical instability, syringomyelia, operative effects, and genetics were extracted. Forty-six studies met inclusion criteria, averaging 93.2 CM-I patients and 41.4 healthy controls in size. To obtain measurements, 40 studies utilized MRI and 10 utilized CT imaging, whereas 41 analyzed parameters within the posterior fossa and 20 analyzed parameters of the craniovertebral junction. The most commonly measured parameters included clivus length (n = 30), tonsillar position or descent (n = 28), McRae line length (n = 26), and supraocciput length (n = 26). While certain structural anomalies including reduced clivus length have been implicated in CM-I, there is a lack of consensus on how several other morphometric parameters may or may not contribute to its development. Heterogeneity in presentation with respect to the extent of tonsillar descent suggests alternate methods utilizing morphometric measurements that may help to identify CM-I patients and may benefit future research to better understand underlying pathophysiology and sequelae such as syringomyelia.

Chiari 1 malformation and exome sequencing in 51 trios: the emerging role of rare missense variants in chromatin-remodeling genes

Type 1 Chiari malformation (C1M) is characterized by cerebellar tonsillar herniation of 3–5 mm or more, the frequency of which is presumably much higher than one in 1000 births, as previously believed. Its etiology remains undefined, although a genetic basis is strongly supported by C1M presence in numerous genetic syndromes associated with different genes. Whole-exome sequencing (WES) in 51 between isolated and syndromic pediatric cases and their relatives was performed after confirmation of the defect by brain magnetic resonance image (MRI). Moreover, in all the cases showing an inherited candidate variant, brain MRI was performed in both parents and not only in the carrier one to investigate whether the defect segregated with the variant. More than half of the variants were Missense and belonged to the same chromatin-remodeling genes whose protein truncation variants are associated with severe neurodevelopmental syndromes. In the remaining cases, variants have been detected in genes with a role in cranial bone sutures, microcephaly, neural tube defects, and RASopathy. This study shows that the frequency of C1M is widely underestimated, in fact many of the variants, in particular those in the chromatin-remodeling genes, were inherited from a parent with C1M, either asymptomatic or with mild symptoms. In addition, C1M is a Mendelian trait, in most cases inherited as dominant. Finally, we demonstrate that modifications of the genes that regulate chromatin architecture can cause localized anatomical alterations, with symptoms of varying degrees.

Triangular-Shaped Odontoid Process With Chiari 1 Malformation Patient

Several anatomical variations of osseous structures around the craniovertebral junction (CVJ) have been observed in those presenting with Chiari 1 malformation (CM-1) due to the junction’s unique embryology and its pivotal role in neck stability. During a clinic visit, a 14-year-old female presented with the classic symptoms of CM-1. Upon follow-up imaging and confirmation of the inferiorly displaced cerebellar tonsils, a unique triangular-shaped odontoid process was identified. To our knowledge, this osseous malformation of the dens has not been reported in the current literature. This unique deviation may cause ligamentous instability and decreased motion capacity and predispose a patient to axial fractures. Thus, we aim to further discuss this case, cervical vertebrae axis (C2) embryology, and the resulting clinical significance of this observed odontoid process variant.

Correlation of a new hydrodynamic index with other effective indexes in Chiari I malformation patients with different associations

This study aimed to find a new CSF hydrodynamic index to assess Chiari type I malformation (CM-I) patients’ conditions and examine the relationship of this new index with morphometric and volumetric changes in these patients and their clinical symptoms. To this end, 58 CM-I patients in four groups and 20 healthy subjects underwent PC-MRI. Ten morphometric and three volumetric parameters were calculated. The CSF hydrodynamic parameters were also analyzed through computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulation. The maximum CSF pressure was identified as a new hydrodynamic parameter to assess the CM-I patients’ conditions. This parameter was similar in patients with the same symptoms regardless of the group to which they belonged. The result showed a weak correlation between the maximum CSF pressure and the morphometric parameters in the patients. Among the volumetric parameters, PCF volume had the highest correlation with the maximum CSF pressure, which its value being higher in patients with CM-I/SM/scoliosis (R² = 65.6%, P = 0.0022) than in the other patients. PCF volume was the more relevant volumetric parameter to assess the patients’ symptoms. The values of PCF volume were greater in patients that headache symptom was more obvious than other symptoms, as compared to the other patients.

Clinical utility of 2-D anatomic measurements in predicting cough-associated headache in Chiari I malformation

PURPOSE

Cough-associated headache (CAH) is the most distinctive symptom of patients with Chiari I malformation (CMI) and indicates clinically significant disease. We determined the clinical utility of simple 2D anatomic measurements performed on a PACS workstation by assessing their diagnostic accuracy in predicting CAH in CMI patients.

METHODS

Seventy-two consecutive CMI patients (cerebellar tonsillar herniation > 5 mm) with headache seen by neurosurgeons over 6 years were included. Sagittal T1 images were used by two readers to measure: extent of tonsillar herniation, lengths of the clivus and supra-occiput, McRae and pB-C2 lines, as well as clivus-canal, odontoid retroversion, and skull base angles. Neurosurgery notes were reviewed to determine presence of CAH. Mann-Whitney test was used to compare measurements between patients with and without CAH. Predictive accuracy was assessed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.

RESULTS

47/72 (65.3%) CMI patients reported CAH. Tonsillar herniation with CAH (10.2 mm, 7-14 mm; median, interquartile range) was significantly greater than those without CAH (7.9 mm, 6.3-10.9 mm; p = 0.02). Tonsillar herniation ≥ 10 mm showed sensitivity and specificity of 51% and 68%, and tonsillar herniation > 14 mm showed sensitivity and specificity of 30% and 100%, respectively, for predicting CAH. Other 2D measurements showed no statistically significant differences.

CONCLUSIONS

Among the 2D measurements used, only the extent of tonsillar herniation is different between CMI patients with and without CAH. Although CMI is diagnosed with tonsillar herniation of only 5 mm, we found that a much higher extent of herniation is needed to be predictive of CAH.