In vitro and numerical simulation of blood removal from cerebrospinal fluid: comparison of lumbar drain to Neurapheresis therapy

Cerebrospinal fluid volume as an early radiological factor for clinical course prediction after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. A pilot study

BACKGROUND

The pathological mechanisms following aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) are poorly understood. Limited clinical evidence exists on the association between cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) volume and the risk of delayed cerebral ischemia (DCI) or cerebral vasospasm (CV). In this study, we raised the hypothesis that the amount of CSF or its ratio to hemorrhage blood volume, as determined from non-contrast Computed Tomography (NCCT) images taken on admission, could be a significant predictor for CV and DCI.

METHODS

The pilot study included a retrospective analysis of NCCT scans of 49 SAH patients taken shortly after an aneurysm rupture (33 males, 16 females, mean age 56.4 ± 15 years). The SynthStrip and Slicer3D software tools were used to extract radiological factors - CSF, brain, and hemorrhage volumes from the NCCT images. The "pure" CSF volume (VCSF) was estimated in the range of [-15, 15] Hounsfield units (HU).

RESULTS

VCSF was negatively associated with the risk of CV occurrence (p = 0.0049) and DCI (p = 0.0069), but was not associated with patients' outcomes. The hemorrhage volume (VSAH) was positively associated with an unfavorable outcome (p = 0.0032) but was not associated with CV/DCI. The ratio VSAH/VCSF was positively associated with, both, DCI (p = 0.031) and unfavorable outcome (p = 0.002). The CSF volume normalized by the brain volume showed the highest characteristics for DCI prediction (AUC = 0.791, sensitivity = 0.80, specificity = 0.812) and CV prediction (AUC = 0.769, sensitivity = 0.812, specificity = 0.70).

CONCLUSION

It was demonstrated that "pure" CSF volume retrieved from the initial NCCT images of SAH patients (including CV, Non-CV, DCI, Non-DCI groups) is a more significant predictor of DCI and CV compared to other routinely used radiological biomarkers. VCSF could be used to predict clinical course as well as to personalize the management of SAH patients. Larger multicenter clinical trials should be performed to test the added value of the proposed methodology.

Cerebrospinal fluid flushing as a means of neuroprotection

Central nervous system (CNS) injury or disease states are often difficult to treat due to the closed system of the dura mater/blood-brain barrier and the bony skull and vertebrae. The closed system results in at least partial containment of any pro-inflammatory molecules, pathogens, or toxic byproducts in the case of brain or spinal cord lesions, which can result in a destructive feedback loop. Cervical-approach access techniques (lateral C1-C2, suboccipital and lateral atlanto-occipital space punctures) are less-common methods of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) sampling due to the relative ease and safety of lumbar spinal taps. However, with improved image-guidance, these cervical-level CSF access points are still useful when there are certain contraindications and difficulties when attempting to sample the CSF via the typical lumbar spinal approach. With the advent of microcatheters and minimally invasive techniques, combined with body fluid filtration technology, the question arises: could dual microcatheters be introduced for inflow and outflow of purified or artificial CSF to break the destructive feedback loop and thus diminish CNS damage?. We hypothesize that intrathecal spinal catheters could be placed in 2 positions (e.g., via a cervical route and the typical lumbar spinal route) to allow for both an input and output to more effectively filter or "flush" the CSF. This could have broad implications in the treatment of strokes, traumatic brain or spinal cord injury, infections, autoimmune diseases, and even malignancies within the CNS-in short, any disease with abnormalities detectable in the CSF.

Stationary flow driven by non-sinusoidal time-periodic pressure gradients in wavy-walled channels

The classical problem of secondary flow driven by a sinusoidally varying pressure gradient is extended here to address periodic pressure gradients of complex waveform, which are present in many oscillatory physiological flows. A slender two-dimensional wavy-walled channel is selected as a canonical model problem. Following standard steady-streaming analyses, valid for small values of the ratio ε of the stroke length of the pulsatile motion to the channel wavelength, the spatially periodic flow is described in terms of power-law expansions of ε , with the Womersley number assumed to be of order unity. The solution found at leading order involves a time-periodic velocity with a zero time-averaged value at any given point. As in the case of a sinusoidal pressure gradient, effects of inertia enter at the following order to induce a steady flow in the form of recirculating vortices with zero net flow rate. An improved two-term asymptotic description of this secondary flow is sought by carrying the analysis to the following order. It is found that, when the pressure gradient has a waveform with multiple harmonics, the resulting velocity corrections display a nonzero flow rate, not present in the single-frequency case, which enables stationary convective transport along the channel. Direct numerical simulations for values of ε of order unity are used to investigate effects of inertia and delineate the range of validity of the asymptotic limit ε ≪ 1 . The comparisons of the time-averaged velocity obtained numerically with the two-term asymptotic description reveals that the latter remains remarkably accurate for values of ε exceeding 0.5. As an illustrative example, the results of the model problem are used to investigate the cerebrospinal-fluid flow driven along the spinal canal by the cardiac and respiratory cycles, characterized by markedly non-sinusoidal waveforms.

Mechanical filtration of the cerebrospinal fluid: procedures, systems, and applications

INTRODUCTION

Mechanical methods aimed at the filtration of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) are a group of therapies that have been proposed to treat neurological conditions where pathogens are present in the CSF. Even though the industry of medical devices has not been very active in this field, there is a lack of systematization of the different systems and procedures that can be applied.

AREAS COVERED

First, we systematize the classification and definitions of procedures and systems for mechanical filtration of the CSF. Then, we made a literature review in search of clinical or preclinical studies where any system of mechanical CSF clearance was proposed or applied.

EXPERT OPINION

We found mechanical filtration of the CSF has been explored in subarachnoid hemorrhage, CNS infections (bacterial, viral, and fungal), meningeal carcinomatosis, multiple sclerosis, autoimmune encephalitis, and polyradiculomyelitis. Brain aging and neurodegenerative diseases are additional potential conditions of interest. While there is some preliminary positive evidence for many of these conditions, more advanced systems, detailed descriptions of procedures, and rigorous validations are needed to make these therapies a reality in the next decades.

Filtered Cerebrospinal Fluid From Patients With Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Displays an Altered Proteome and Affects Motor Phenotype in a Mouse Model

INTRODUCTION

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) has been implicated in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) due to its ability to spread inflammatory proteins throughout the nervous system. We hypothesized that filtration of the CSF could remove pathogenic proteins and prevent them from altering motor phenotypes in a mouse model.

METHODS

We filtered the CSF from 11 ALS patients via 100 kilodaltons (kD) molecular weight cut-off filters. We used mass spectrometry-based discovery proteomics workflows to compare protein abundances before and after filtration. To test the effects of CSF filtration on motor function, we injected groups of mice with saline, filtered ALS-CSF, or unfiltered ALS-CSF (n=12 per group) and assessed motor function via pole descent and open field tests.

RESULTS

We identified proteins implicated in ALS pathogenesis and showed that these were removed in significant amounts in our workflow. Key filtered proteins included complement proteins, chitinases, serine protease inhibitors, and neuro-inflammatory proteins such as amyloid precursor protein, chromogranin A, and glial fibrillary acidic protein. Compared to the filtered ALS-CSF mice, unfiltered ALS-CSF mice took longer to descend a pole (10 days post-injection, 11.14 seconds vs 14.25 seconds, p = 0.02) and explored less on an open field (one day post-injection, 21.81 m vs 16.83 m, p = 0.0004).

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the ability to filter proteins from the CSF of ALS patients and identified potentially pathologic proteins that were reduced in quantity. Additionally, we demonstrated the ability of unfiltered ALS-CSF to induce motor deficits in mice on the pole descent and open field tests and showed that filtration could prevent this deficit. Given the lack of effective treatments for ALS, this could be a novel solution for patients suffering from this deadly and irreversible condition.

CSF Dynamics: Implications for Hydrocephalus and Glymphatic Clearance

Beyond its neuroprotective role, CSF functions to rid the brain of toxic waste products through glymphatic clearance. Disturbances in the circulation of CSF and glymphatic exchange are common among those experiencing HCP syndrome, which often results from SAH. Normally, the secretion of CSF follows a two-step process, including filtration of plasma followed by the introduction of ions, bicarbonate, and water. Arachnoid granulations are the main site of CSF absorption, although there are other influencing factors that affect this process. The pathway through which CSF is through to flow is from its site of secretion, at the choroid plexus, to its site of absorption. However, the CSF flow dynamics are influenced by the cardiovascular system and interactions between CSF and CNS anatomy. One, two, and three-dimensional models are currently methods researchers use to predict and describe CSF flow, both under normal and pathological conditions. They are, however, not without their limitations. "Rest-of-body" models, which consider whole-body compartments, may be more effective for understanding the disruption to CSF flow due to hemorrhages and hydrocephalus. Specifically, SAH is thought to prevent CSF flow into the basal cistern and paravascular spaces. It is also more subject to backflow, caused by the presence of coagulation cascade products. In regard to the fluid dynamics of CSF, scar tissue, red blood cells, and protein content resulting from SAH may contribute to increased viscosity, decreased vessel diameter, and increased vessel resistance. Outside of its direct influence on CSF flow, SAH may result in one or both forms of hydrocephalus, including noncommunicating (obstructive) and communicating (nonobstructive) HCP. Imaging modalities such as PC-MRI, Time-SLIP, and CFD model, a mathematical model relying on PC-MRI data, are commonly used to better understand CSF flow. While PC-MRI utilizes phase shift data to ultimately determine CSF speed and flow, Time-SLIP compares signals generated by CSF to background signals to characterizes complex fluid dynamics. Currently, there are gaps in sufficient CSF flow models and imaging modalities. A prospective area of study includes generation of models that consider "rest-of-body" compartments and elements like arterial pulse waves, respiratory waves, posture, and jugular venous posture. Going forward, imaging modalities should work to focus more on patients in nature in order to appropriately assess how CSF flow is disrupted in SAH and HCP.

Computational fluid dynamics model to predict the dynamical behavior of the cerebrospinal fluid through implementation of physiological boundary conditions

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) dynamics play an important role in maintaining a stable central nervous system environment and are influenced by different physiological processes. Multiple studies have investigated these processes but the impact of each of them on CSF flow is not well understood. A deeper insight into the CSF dynamics and the processes impacting them is crucial to better understand neurological disorders such as hydrocephalus, Chiari malformation, and intracranial hypertension. This study presents a 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model which incorporates physiological processes as boundary conditions. CSF production and pulsatile arterial and venous volume changes are implemented as inlet boundary conditions. At the outlets, 2-element windkessel models are imposed to simulate CSF compliance and absorption. The total compliance is first tuned using a 0D model to obtain physiological pressure pulsations. Then, simulation results are compared with in vivo flow measurements in the spinal subarachnoid space (SAS) and cerebral aqueduct, and intracranial pressure values reported in the literature. Finally, the impact of the distribution of and total compliance on CSF pressures and velocities is evaluated. Without respiration effects, compliance of 0.17 ml/mmHg yielded pressure pulsations with an amplitude of 5 mmHg and an average value within the physiological range of 7-15 mmHg. Also, model flow rates were found to be in good agreement with reported values. However, when adding respiration effects, similar pressure amplitudes required an increase of compliance value to 0.51 ml/mmHg, which is within the range of 0.4-1.2 ml/mmHg measured in vivo. Moreover, altering the distribution of compliance over the four different outlets impacted the local flow, including the flow through the foramen magnum. The contribution of compliance to each outlet was directly proportional to the outflow at that outlet. Meanwhile, the value of total compliance impacted intracranial pressure. In conclusion, a computational model of the CSF has been developed that can simulate CSF pressures and velocities by incorporating boundary conditions based on physiological processes. By tuning these boundary conditions, we were able to obtain CSF pressures and flows within the physiological range.

Targeting Hemoglobin to Reduce Delayed Cerebral Ischemia After Subarachnoid Hemorrhage

Delayed cerebral ischemia (DCI) continues to be a sequela of aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH) that carries significant morbidity and mortality. Aside from nimodipine, no therapeutic agents are available to reduce the incidence of DCI. Pathophysiologic mechanisms contributing to DCI are poorly understood, but accumulating evidence over the years implicates several factors. Those have included microvessel vasoconstriction, microthrombosis, oxidative tissue damage, and cortical spreading depolarization as well as large vessel vasospasm. Common to these processes is red blood cell leakage into the cerebrospinal fluids (CSF) and subsequent lysis which releases hemoglobin, a central instigator in these events. This has led to the hypothesis that early blood removal may improve clinical outcome and reduce DCI. This paper will provide a narrative review of the evidence of hemoglobin as an instigator of DCI. It will also elaborate on available human data that discuss blood clearance and CSF drainage as a treatment of DCI. Finally, we will address a recent novel device that is currently being tested, the Neurapheresis CSF Management System™. This is an automated dual-lumen lumbar drainage system that has an option to filter CSF and return it to the patient.

Investigation of Human Intrathecal Solute Transport Dynamics Using a Novel in vitro Cerebrospinal Fluid System Analog

BACKGROUND

Understanding the relationship between cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) dynamics and intrathecal drug delivery (ITDD) injection parameters is essential to improve treatment of central nervous system (CNS) disorders.

METHODS

An anatomically detailed in vitro model of the complete CSF system was constructed. Patient-specific cardiac- and respiratory-induced CSF oscillations were input to the model in the subarachnoid space and within the ventricles. CSF production was input at the lateral ventricles and CSF absorption at the superior sagittal sinus. A model small molecule simulated drug product containing fluorescein was imaged within the system over a period of 3-h post-lumbar ITDD injections and used to quantify the impact of (a) bolus injection volume and rate, (b) post-injection flush volume, rate, and timing, (c) injection location, and (d) type of injection device. For each experiment, neuraxial distribution of fluorescein in terms of spatial temporal concentration, area-under-the-curve (AUC), and percent of injected dose (%ID) to the brain was quantified at a time point 3-h post-injection.

RESULTS

For all experiments conducted with ITDD administration in the lumbar spine, %ID to the brain did not exceed 11.6% at a time point 3-h post-injection. Addition of a 12 mL flush slightly increased solute transport to the brain up to +3.9%ID compared to without a flush (p < 0.01). Implantation of a lumbar catheter with the tip at an equivalent location to the lumbar placed needle, but with rostral tip orientation, resulted in a small improvement of 1.5%ID to the brain (p < 0.05). An increase of bolus volume from 5 to 20 mL improved solute transport to the brain from 5.0 to 6.3%ID, but this improvement was not statistically significant. Increasing bolus injection rate from 5 to 13.3 mL/min lacked improvement of solute transport to the brain, with a value of 6.3 compared to 5.7%ID.

CONCLUSION

The in vitro modeling approach allowed precisely controlled and repeatable parametric investigation of ITDD injection protocols and devices. In combination, the results predict that parametric changes in lumbar spine ITDD-injection related parameters and devices can alter %ID to the brain and be tuned to optimize therapeutic benefit to CNS targets.

Human in silico trials for parametric computational fluid dynamics investigation of cerebrospinal fluid drug delivery: impact of injection location, injection protocol, and physiology

Background

Intrathecal drug delivery has a significant role in pain management and central nervous system (CNS) disease therapeutics. A fluid-physics based tool to assist clinicians in choosing specific drug doses to the spine or brain may help improve treatment schedules.

Methods

This study applied computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and in vitro model verification to assess intrathecal drug delivery in an anatomically idealized model of the human CSF system with key anatomic features of the CNS. Key parameters analyzed included the role of (a) injection location including lumbar puncture (LP), cisterna magna (CM) and intracerebroventricular (ICV), (b) LP injection rate, injection volume, and flush volume, (c) physiologic factors including cardiac-induced and deep respiration-induced CSF stroke volume increase. Simulations were conducted for 3-h post-injection and used to quantify spatial–temporal tracer concentration, regional area under the curve (AUC), time to maximum concentration (T_max), and maximum concentration (C_max), for each case.

Results

CM and ICV increased AUC to brain regions by ~ 2 logs compared to all other simulations. A 3X increase in bolus volume and addition of a 5 mL flush both increased intracranial AUC to the brain up to 2X compared to a baseline 5 mL LP injection. In contrast, a 5X increase in bolus rate (25 mL/min) did not improve tracer exposure to the brain. An increase in cardiac and respiratory CSF movement improved tracer spread to the brain, basal cistern, and cerebellum up to ~ 2 logs compared to the baseline LP injection.

Conclusion

The computational modeling approach provides ability to conduct in silico trials representative of CSF injection protocols. Taken together, the findings indicate a strong potential for delivery protocols to be optimized to reach a target region(s) of the spine and/or brain with a needed therapeutic dose. Parametric modification of bolus rate/volume and flush volume was found to have impact on tracer distribution; albeit to a smaller degree than injection location, with CM and ICV injections resulting in greater therapeutic dose to brain regions compared to LP. CSF stroke volume and frequency both played an important role and may potentially have a greater impact than the modest changes in LP injection protocols analyzed such as bolus rate, volume, and flush.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12987-022-00304-4.

Translational approaches for brain delivery of biologics via cerebrospinal fluid

Delivery of biologics via cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) has demonstrated potential to access the tissues of the central nervous system (CNS) by circumventing the blood‐brain barrier and blood‐CSF barrier. Developing an effective CSF drug delivery strategy requires optimization of multiple parameters, including choice of CSF access point, delivery device technology, and delivery kinetics to achieve effective therapeutic concentrations in the target brain region, whereas also considering the biologic modality, mechanism of action, disease indication, and patient population. This review discusses key preclinical and clinical examples of CSF delivery for different biologic modalities (antibodies, nucleic acid‐based therapeutics, and gene therapy) to the brain via CSF or CNS access routes (intracerebroventricular, intrathecal‐cisterna magna, intrathecal‐lumbar, intraparenchymal, and intranasal), including the use of novel device technologies. This review also discusses quantitative models of CSF flow that provide insight into the effect of fluid dynamics in CSF on drug delivery and CNS distribution. Such models can facilitate delivery device design and pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic translation from preclinical species to humans in order to optimize CSF drug delivery to brain regions of interest.

Hydrodynamic comparison of shunt and endoscopic third ventriculostomy in adult hydrocephalus using in vitro models and fluid-structure interaction simulation

OBJECTIVE

The comparison of the efficiency of shunt placement and endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV) in treating of adult hydrocephalus patients with various intensities and different obstruction intensities in the aqueduct of Sylvius (AS).

METHODS

In vitro models with separated ventricles were simulated and implemented for modeling shunt and ETV surgeries in one healthy subject and hydrocephalus patients with various intensities, as well as three different obstruction intensities in AS and under two cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) dynamic conditions. The fluid-structure interaction simulation was also carried out to validate in vitro results.

RESULTS

The efficiency of both methods in reducing the maximum CSF pressure in the subarachnoid space (MCPS) decreased by an increase in the patient's intensities. Contrary to shunting, the efficiency of ETV in reducing MCPS demonstrated a decline (8.3-16.4%) by an increase in obstruction levels in AS. Based on the findings, shunt efficiency in decreasing MCPS in patients with low intensity was more remarkable compared to ETV. However, ETV was more efficient than shunt in the patient with intracranial hypertension. Further, shunt placement and ETV led to a significant reduction in the amplitude of CSF pressure in the SAS (ACPS) in patients with sneezing, coughing, Valsalva maneuver, and exercising effects in contrast to other patients. Moreover, ACPS reduction was not related to the intensity of the disease in both treatment methods. In contrast to shunt, an increase in the obstruction level in AS led to a reduction in ACPS in ETV in both CSF dynamic conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

The noises from irregular disorders increased the discharging of CSF after shunt placement, and activities such as sneezing, coughing, Valsalva maneuvers, and exercising increased the risk of shunt overdrainage by 10.4~47.8%, especially in the patient with intracranial hypertension. Based on the proposed in vitro ETV and shunt models, an increase of head compliance was higher in ETV compared to the shunt. Eventually, an increase in the obstruction level of AS after ETV led to a decline in head compliance in contrast to shunt.

When the Blood Hits Your Brain: The Neurotoxicity of Extravasated Blood

Hemorrhage in the central nervous system (CNS), including intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH), intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH), and aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH), remains highly morbid. Trials of medical management for these conditions over recent decades have been largely unsuccessful in improving outcome and reducing mortality. Beyond its role in creating mass effect, the presence of extravasated blood in patients with CNS hemorrhage is generally overlooked. Since trials of surgical intervention to remove CNS hemorrhage have been generally unsuccessful, the potent neurotoxicity of blood is generally viewed as a basic scientific curiosity rather than a clinically meaningful factor. In this review, we evaluate the direct role of blood as a neurotoxin and its subsequent clinical relevance. We first describe the molecular mechanisms of blood neurotoxicity. We then evaluate the clinical literature that directly relates to the evacuation of CNS hemorrhage. We posit that the efficacy of clot removal is a critical factor in outcome following surgical intervention. Future interventions for CNS hemorrhage should be guided by the principle that blood is exquisitely toxic to the brain.