Comparative Analysis of Antigen Specificities in the Monomeric and Dimeric Fractions of Intravenous Immunoglobulin

Dissecting the mechanism of action of intravenous immunoglobulin in human autoimmune disease: Lessons from therapeutic modalities targeting Fcγ receptors

Since the first description of the administration of high doses of pooled serum IgG, also referred to as intravenous IgG (IVIg) therapy, as being able to ameliorate various autoimmune diseases, researchers have been investigating which molecular and cellular pathways underlie IVIg activity. Apart from trying to understand the obvious conundrum that IgG can trigger both autoimmune pathology and resolution of inflammation, the rapidly expanding use of IVIg has led to a lack of availability of this primary blood product, providing a strong rationale for developing recombinant alternatives. During the last decade, a tremendous number of novel insights into IVIg activity brought the goal of replacing IVIg within reach, at least in select indications, and has led to the initiation of several clinical trials. At the forefront of this effort is the modulation of autoantibody half-life and blocking access of autoantibodies to fragment cystallizable γ receptors (Fcγ receptors). In this rostrum article, we will briefly discuss current models of IVIg activity, followed by a more specific focus on novel therapeutic avenues that are entering the clinic and may replace IVIg in the future.

Engineered hexavalent Fc proteins with enhanced Fc-gamma receptor avidity provide insights into immune-complex interactions

Autoantibody-mediated diseases are currently treated with intravenous immunoglobulin, which is thought to act in part via blockade of Fc gamma receptors, thereby inhibiting autoantibody effector functions and subsequent pathology. We aimed to develop recombinant molecules with enhanced Fc receptor avidity and thus increased potency over intravenous immunoglobulin. Here we describe the molecular engineering of human Fc hexamers and explore their therapeutic and safety profiles. We show Fc hexamers were more potent than IVIG in phagocytosis blockade and disease models. However, in human whole-blood safety assays incubation with IgG1 isotype Fc hexamers resulted in cytokine release, platelet and complement activation, whereas the IgG4 version did not. We used a statistically designed mutagenesis approach to identify the key Fc residues involved in these processes. Cytokine release was found to be dependent on neutrophil FcγRIIIb interactions with L234 and A327 in the Fc. Therefore, Fc hexamers provide unique insights into Fc receptor biology.

Tania Rowley et al. present multivalent Fc molecules with enhanced avidity for Fc gamma receptors in order to improve the treatment of autoantibody-mediated human diseases. They found several key amino acids involved in Fc receptor binding interactions.

Identification and characterization of natural antibodies against tau protein in an intravenous immunoglobulin product

The latest therapeutic approaches to Alzheimer disease are using intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) products. Therefore, the detailed characterization of target-specific antibodies naturally occurring in IVIG products is beneficial. We have focused on characterization of antibodies isolated against tau protein, a biomarker of Alzheimer's disease, from Flebogamma IVIG product. The analysis of IgG subclass distribution indicated skewing toward IgG3 in anti-tau-enriched IgG fraction. The evaluation of their reactivity and avidity with several recombinant tau forms was performed by ELISA and blotting techniques. Truncated non-phosphorylated tau protein (amino acids 155-421) demonstrated the highest reactivity and avidity index. We provide the first detailed insight into the reactivity of isolated natural antibodies against tau protein.

Intravenous IgG (IVIG) and subcutaneous IgG (SCIG) preparations have comparable inhibitory effect on T cell activation, which is not dependent on IgG sialylation, monocytes or B cells

IVIG modulates T cell activation in vitro and inflammatory-autoimmune conditions in vivo. Sialylation of IgG, Fc receptor interactions, modulation of monocyte/macrophage/B cell functions have been implicated in IVIG effects. Subcutaneous IgG (SCIG) therapy is increasingly used for IgG replacement but whether these preparations share the effects of IVIG on T cell modulation is not documented. We compared the potency of SCIG-Hizentra™ (20% IgG preparation) with IVIG-Privigen® (10% IgG) for T cell inhibition, and assessed the involvement of IgG sialylation, monocytes and B cells in this process. Human PBMCs or sorted cells were cultured 3-7 days, and T cells were stimulated with immobilized anti-CD3 mAb or Candida antigen. Thymidine incorporation into DNA was quantitated and cytokines assayed by ELISA/Luminex® assay. IVIG and SCIG both dose-dependently (1-20mg/ml) inhibited (up to >80%) T cell proliferation to anti-CD3 mAb. Response to Candida albicans was comparably inhibited by IVIG and SCIG by 50-80% at 10mg/ml with inhibition even at 3mg/ml (P<0.05). These effects were not affected by depletion of sialic acid containing IgG using neuraminidase treatment or lectin affinity chromatography. With anti-CD3 or Candida stimulation, IL-1β, IL-2, IL-5, IL-6, IL-13, GMCSF, TNF-α, interferon-γ (with anti-CD3) and IL-17 (with Candida) levels were suppressed by IVIG or SCIG, with no effect on IL-4, IL-10, IL-12, IL-15 or TGFβ. Monocytes or B cells were not required for IgG-induced suppression of proliferation, in fact depletion of monocytes potentiated the IgG-induced inhibition. Reconstitution with monocytes restored the original inhibitory effect. These data show that IVIG (Privigen®) and SCIG (Hizentra™) have comparable inhibitory effects on T cell activation, which do not require sialylation of IgG. Inhibition is independent of monocytes or B cells. There is a potent suppression of multiple effector cytokines. Like IVIG, SCIG therapy is expected to show immunomodulatory activity.

On the dark side of therapies with immunoglobulin concentrates: the adverse events

Therapy by human immunoglobulin G (IgG) concentrates is a success story ongoing for decades with an ever increasing demand for this plasma product. The success of IgG concentrates on a clinical level is documented by the slowly increasing number of registered indication and the more rapid increase of the off-label uses, a topic dealt with in another contribution to this special issue of Frontiers in Immunology. A part of the success is the adverse event (AE) profile of IgG concentrates which is, even at life-long need for therapy, excellent. Transmission of pathogens in the last decade could be entirely controlled through the antecedent introduction by authorities of a regulatory network and installing quality standards by the plasma fractionation industry. The cornerstone of the regulatory network is current good manufacturing practice. Non-infectious AEs occur rarely and mainly are mild to moderate. However, in recent times, the increase in frequency of hemolytic and thrombotic AEs raised worrying questions on the possible background for these AEs. Below, we review elements of non-infectious AEs, and particularly focus on hemolysis and thrombosis. We discuss how the introduction of plasma fractionation by ion-exchange chromatography and polishing by immunoaffinity chromatographic steps might alter repertoire of specificities and influence AE profiles and efficacy of IgG concentrates.

Monomeric and dimeric IgG fractions show differential reactivity against pathogen-derived antigens

Polyvalent Ig preparations, derived from the pooled plasma of thousands of healthy donors, contain a complex mix of both 'acquired' and natural antibodies directed against pathogens as well as foreign and self/auto antigens (Ag). Depending on their formulation, donor pool size, etc., liquid Ig preparations contain monomeric and dimeric IgG. The dimeric IgG fraction is thought to represent mainly idiotype-antiidiotype Ab pairs. Treatment of all IgG fractions at pH 4 effectively monomerizes the IgG dimers resulting in separated idiotype-antiidiotype Ab pairs and thus in a comparable F(ab')(2) binding site availability of the different IgG fractions. Previously, we identified an increased anti-self-reactivity within the monomerized dimer fraction. This study addressed if, among the different IgG fractions, an analogous preferential reactivity was evident in the response against different pathogen-derived protein and carbohydrate antigens. Therefore, we assessed the activity of total unseparated IgG, the monomeric and dimeric IgG fractions against antigenic structures of bacterial and viral antigens/virulence factors. All fractions showed similar reactivity to protein antigens except for exotoxin A of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, where the dimeric fraction, especially when monomerized, showed a marked increase in reactivity. This suggests that the production of antiidiotypic IgG antibodies contributes to controlling the immune response to certain categories of pathogens. In contrast, the monomeric IgG fractions showed increased reactivity towards pathogen-associated polysaccharides, classically regarded as T-independent antigens. Taken together, the differential reactivity of the IgG fractions seems to indicate a preferential segregation of antibody reactivities according to the nature of the antigen.

Polyreactive antibodies in multidonor-derived immunoglobulin G: theory and conclusions drawn from experiments

Multidonor-derived (md) preparations of IgG antibodies, agents of therapeutic potential, contain molecules interacting at clonal concentrations (concns) and with affinities recently estimated to cover a considerable range. Here we demonstrate that polyreactivity of the monomeric molecules represents the essential driving force of formation of the main reaction product, the IgG-dimers. This conclusion is obtained by applying the principles of the law of mass action to dimer formation by polyreactive monomeric reactants. In addition, general interrelationships involving the mean number of reactants per reactor, the experimental dimer portion (w/w) and the mean concentrations of monomers in a polyreactive and monoreactive antibody system are derived. These interrelationships, together with quantitative results obtained from simplified computational kinetic models of polyreactive antibodies, allow to estimate a remarkably high value for the mean number of reactants per reactor, exceeding 60 for the underlying IgG preparation obtained from pooled human plasma units of 5000 donors. Moreover, the potential origin and other consequences of polyreactivity are outlined.

Self-Reactivity in the Dimeric Intravenous Immunoglobulin Fraction

Therapeutic intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) preparations contain antibodies reflecting the cumulative antigen experience of the donor population. IVIg contains variable amounts of monomeric and dimeric IgG, but there is little information available on their comparative antibody specificities. We have isolated highly purified fractions of monomeric and dimeric IgG by size-exclusion chromatography. Following treatment of all fractions at pH4, analyses by immunodot and immunocytology on human cell lines showed a preferential recognition of autoantigens in the dimeric IgG fraction. Investigation of the HEp-2 cytoplasmic proteome by 2D-PAGE, Western blot, and subsequent identification of IVIg reactive spots by mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) showed that IVIg recognized only a restricted set of the total proteins. Similar experiments showed that more antigens were recognized by the dimeric IgG fraction, especially when the dissociated dimer fraction was used, as compared to its monomeric counterpart. These observations are consistent with idiotype-anti-idiotype masking of auto-specific Abs in the dimeric fraction of IVIg.

Purification of intravenous immunoglobulin G from human plasma – aspects of yield and virus safety

Plasma-derived intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) preparations have been successfully applied for the prophylactic prevention of infectious diseases in immunodeficient patients. In addition to its replacement therapy of primary and secondary antibody deficiencies, IVIG has found increased use in autoimmune and inflammatory diseases. IVIG has become the major plasma product on the global blood product market. The world wide consumption nearly tripled between 1992 and 2003, from 19.4 to 52.6 tons. Classical manufacturing processes of IVIG, but also new strategies for purification are discussed with respect to practicability and yield. Ethanol fractionation is still the basis for most IVIG processes, although isolation and purification of immunoglobulin G (IgG) by chromatography has gained ground. The efficiency of virus inactivation methods and virus removal techniques in terms of logarithmic reduction factors are analyzed, but also the IgG losses are taken into consideration. Some of these methods also have the ability to separate prions. High pathogen safety and high yields have become the dominant goals of the plasma fractionation industry.