Karnofsky memorial lecture. The oncologic end game

One more chemo or one too many? Defining the limits of treatment and innovation in medical oncology

During the past few years, debates have frequently erupted in oncology journals regarding the question of whether to prolong or end treatment. These debates have been informed by developments from both within and outside the field. Within Bioethics, some writers have put forward a number of principles for judging the legitimacy of medical interventions, notably that of patient autonomy. Broad social and political developments have also profoundly affected medical practices at the end of life. Though therapeutic options have evolved, whether to stop or to pursue treatment in the face of certain death has been a central issue in medical oncology since the early 1950s. A critical appraisal of the history of this issue can help us to better understand the tangled relationship(s) between innovation, "cure," death, and the symptoms and subjective experiences of sufferers. This paper addresses an aspect of this complex problem, namely how limits are established regarding both treatment and therapeutic innovation near the end of life. Utilizing a grounded theory and situational analysis approach it traces how the issues at stake were defined and the ways in which the dilemma was progressively transformed as a result of the combined effects of a proliferating number of stakeholders, molecules, instruments, and techniques. It discusses three different moments, as they epitomize how the links between chemotherapy and palliation were construed through the evolving forms of clinical research and innovative therapies.

In vivo 31P NMR spectroscopy of human musculoskeletal tumors as a measure of response to chemotherapy

The value of in vivo 31P NMR spectroscopy to provide indicators of response to cytostatic chemotherapy was studied in patients with malignant musculoskeletal tumors. Characteristics of untreated cancers were strong signals of PME and PDE, moderately increased Pi and low PCr. The intracellular pH was slightly alkaline. The intracellular concentration of free magnesium was 70% of that in muscle. Spectroscopic findings at different times of therapy were compared with the percentage of tumor necrosis after surgical resection in 28 patients. In follow-up studies, energy-rich phosphates declined in nonresponders, while PME, Pi and frequently PDE increased. Treatment response appeared to involve the reversal of these trends. In five responders, a biphasic pattern was observed, i.e. initially the spectrum changed into that of severely ischemic cell injury followed by a successive phase of apparent 'tumor activation'. Pretreatment levels of (PCr+Pi)/total phosphate > or = 0.35 and PCr/ alpha-NTP > or = 1.5, an accelerated increase in total low-energy phosphates/total high-energy phosphates (> or = 3.0%/day) after the initial drug application, and a long-term decrease (< or = -0.4%/day) during later therapy were highly indicative of tumor response to chemotherapy. Such spectroscopic predictors for treatment response proved to be superior to currently used indices such as tumor size.

Chemosensitivity of head and neck squamous carcinoma cell lines is not primarily correlated with glutathione level but is modified by glutathione depletion

Glutathione has a variety of important physiological functions in cellular metabolism and defense, including protection from radicals, oxidative stress, and electrophilic compounds. On the basis of this interaction with both endogenous and synthetic substances, glutathione and the key enzyme for its conjugation, glutathione S-transferase, appear to be critical determinants in tumor cell resistance to several antineoplastic drugs, e.g. platinum analogs. In ten established head and neck cancer cell lines (UM-SCC 10A, 10B, 11B, 14A, 14B, 14C, and 22B, HLac79, 8029NA, and 8029DDP4) chemosensitivity to cisplatin, carboplatin, 5-fluorouracil, and bleomycin, as well as cellular glutathione content and activity of glutathione S-transferase were determined. The results revealed no correlation between the sensitivity of tumor cells to any of the drugs tested and the level of glutathione or the activity of glutathione S-transferase. However, the cisplatin-resistant subpopulation 8029DDP4 showed the highest glutathione level and marked cross-resistance to bleomycin. Glutathione depletion with buthionine sulfoximine led to moderately increased sensitivity towards cisplatin and carboplatin in all cell lines, but did not affect their response to 5-fluorouracil or bleomycin. These results suggest that the level of glutathione or the activity of glutathione S-transferase is not a suitable parameter for the assessment of chemosensitivity in head and neck squamous-cell carcinoma lines. However, response to platinum analogs is influenced by alterations of the initial intracellular glutathione concentration.

Use of internally controlled reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction for absolute quantitation of individual multidrug resistant gene transcripts in tissue samples

Research into the relative importance of P-glycoprotein (pgp) overexpression, in comparison to other mechanisms of multidrug resistance (mdr) phenotype development, has been hampered by difficulties of measurement in clinical samples. The small size, heterogeneity and often poor quality of clinical specimens renders the quantitation of mdr mRNA species by Northern analysis or RNAse protection difficult. The reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assay has both the sensitivity and specificity to make it suitable for the analysis of mdr mRNA levels in clinical samples. It also has a significant speed advantage over Northern and RNAse protection analysis. Unfortunately the variable nature of the reactions involved have made it difficult to obtain accurate and reproducible quantitative data. To overcome this difficulty we constructed internal RNA standards to each human and rat mdr mRNA species. When included in the RT-PCR reaction these internal standards allow both comparative and absolute quantitation of individual mdr family mRNA levels.

Chemotherapeutic drug resistance in the management of head and neck cancer

Considerable progress has been made in the development of more effective chemotherapy regimens for squamous cell head and neck carcinomas. Unfortunately, increased response rates have not been translated into marked improvements in survival since durations of response have been brief, and the natural history of the disease has ultimately remained unaltered. Since the development of drug resistance is a major obstacle to successful antineoplastic chemotherapy, comprehensive efforts have been focused on understanding the underlying mechanisms. In this review, general and specific aspects of drug resistance related to head and neck cancer are addressed. In particular, mechanisms of resistance towards the most widely used antineoplastic drugs in head and neck malignancies--methotrexate, cisplatin, 5-fluorouracil, bleomycin, and vincristine--are discussed.

Differing patterns of cross-resistance resulting from exposures to specific antitumour drugs or to radiation in vitro

This article reviews the patterns of cross-resistance identified in various P-glycoprotein-mediated and non-P-glycoprotein-mediated drug resistant mammalian tumour cell lines. The differing patterns of cross-resistance and the variable levels of resistance expressed are summarised and discussed. Although the mechanism by which P-glycoprotein can recognise and transport a large group of structurally-unrelated substrates remains to be defined, the recent evidence indicating that membrane associated domains participate in substrate recognition and binding is summarised, and other possible explanations for these variable cross-resistance patterns are considered. Amongst the non-P-glycoprotein-overexpressing multidrug resistant cell lines, two subsets are clearly identifiable, one lacking and the other expressing cross-resistance to the Vinca alkaloids. Resistance mechanisms implicated in these various sublines and possible explanations for their differing levels and patterns of cross-resistance are summarised. Clinical resistance is identified in patients following treatment not only with antitumour drugs, but also after radiotherapy. Experimental data providing a biological basis for this observation are summarised. A distinctive multiple drug resistance phenotype has been identified in tumour cells following exposure in vitro to fractionated X-irradiation characterised by: the expression of resistance to the Vinca alkaloids and the epipodophyllotoxins but not the anthracyclines and overexpression of P-glycoprotein which is post-translationally regulated, but without any concomitant overexpression of P-glycoprotein mRNA. Finally, the possible clinical relevance of these variable patterns of cross-resistance to the antitumour drugs commonly used in the clinic is considered.

Flow cytometric analysis of multidrug-resistance-associated antigen (P-glycoprotein) and DNA ploidy in human colon cancer

In many cell systems, resistance to cytotoxic drugs is acquired by the amplification and/or overexpression of the multidrug resistance (mdr) gene, which codes for the glycoprotein, p170 (P-glycoprotein). Moreover, in a variety of malignant tumours there is increasing evidence of the relationship between the DNA ploidy pattern of patients and their prognosis. In this study we aimed to evaluate these two potential indicators of constitutive drug resistance in human colorectal tumours. We employed a method to quantify simultaneously, on a per cell basis, mdr gene expression (using the C219 monoclonal antibody for P-glycoprotein) and nuclear DNA content with high-resolution bivariate flow cytometry. The study was performed on a human colon-carcinoma-derived cell line (LoVo) and its doxorubicin-resistant variant (LoVo/Dx) and on tumour samples and adjacent normal mucosa from 35 untreated patients with colon cancer. The P-glycoprotein was found in both LoVo and LoVo/Dx cells with levels slightly lower in the parental than in the resistant subline (P, NS). A multi-drug-resistant specific probe for mRNA expression and Western blot assay confirmed the specificity of p170 expression. All of the colon cancer with unimodal diploid DNA distribution and all the normal colonic mucosa samples showed P-glycoprotein expression, without a statistically significant difference in median values between tumours and normal samples. Tumours with bimodal DNA distribution showed median values of P-glycoprotein expression of their hyperdiploid cell clones significantly higher than those of their diploid clones and of the tumours with unimodal DNA distribution (P less than 0.005). Our results show the feasibility of bivariate flow-cytometric analysis of P-glycoprotein expression and DNA content on clinical material and support the hypothesis that the MDR phenotype and DNA ploidy together may influence the biological behaviour of colon cancer in vivo.

The effects of cyclosporin A on the lysis of ovarian cancer cells by cisplatin or adriamycin

The major limitation to curative therapy for ovarian cancer is the development of drug resistance. Cyclosporin A (CsA), an immunosuppressive agent that has been used extensively in organ transplantation, also has been shown to decrease the resistance of cancer cells to some chemotherapeutic agents. Since cisplatin (CDDP) is the most common drug used for the treatment of ovarian cancer, we evaluated the potential of CsA to decrease resistance to CDDP in ovarian cancer cells selected for resistance to CDDP (A2780-CDDP). Although CsA significantly increased the sensitivity of A2780-CDDP cells to cytolysis by CDDP it did not increase CDDP sensitivity in the CDDP-sensitive parent cells (A2780), that is, CsA did not decrease basal resistance to CDDP. Both A2780-CDDP and A2780 are sensitive to cytolysis by Adriamycin (ADR). CsA significantly decreased the basal resistance of both cell lines to ADR. Interestingly, the effect of the protein synthesis inhibitors, emetine and cycloheximide, was similar to that of CsA, suggesting that CsA decreased selected resistance to CDDP and decreased basal resistance to ADR by affecting a protein synthesis-dependent resistance mechanism(s). In contrast to CsA and protein synthesis inhibitors, buthionine sulfoximine, an inhibitor of glutathione synthesis, decreased basal resistance of both cell lines to cytolysis by CDDP but not ADR, while verapamil, an inhibitor of P-glycoprotein, had no effect on cytolysis in either cell line. These results suggest that CsA may not decrease resistance to CDDP or ADR-mediated cytolysis by reducing glutathione or by inhibiting P-glycoprotein.

SDZ PSC 833, A non-immunosuppressive cyclosporine: Its potency in overcoming P-glycoprotein-mediated multidrug resistance of murine leukemia

Cyclosporin A (CsA, Sandimmune) is known to reverse P-glycoprotein (P-gp170)-mediated multidrug resistance as efficiently as other prototype compounds of resistance modifiers. The immunosuppressive activity and nephrotoxicity of CsA, however, may limit its clinical use. PSC-833, a new cyclosporine, exerts a similar resistance-modifying activity but lacks toxicity or immunosuppressive activity. We have tested its potency in vitro and in vivo on the L1210 leukemia cell line transfected with a full-length cDNA copy of the human mdr I gene, which showed a stable 30-fold resistance towards adriamycin as compared to the parental cell line. In vitro growth of the transfected cell was unchanged. In vivo growth was less aggressive; the survival time of inoculated mice was prolonged. In vitro, PSC-833 was at least as potent as CsA or verapamil in reversing multidrug resistance. In vivo, the drug-resistant L1210 leukemia was completely unresponsive to i.v. monotherapy with adriamycin at its maximum tolerated dose (MTD). PSC-833 enhanced the activity and toxicity of adriamycin. The MTD of adriamycin was about 3 times lower than when given alone. On this basis, the MTD of i.v. adriamycin in combination with oral PSC-833 successfully overcame refractoriness to treatment. Survival times of the mice were considerably prolonged and even some cures of leukemic mice occurred.

Keynote address: the influence of microenvironmental factors on the activity of radiation and drugs

The inherent radio- and chemosensitivity of tumor cells clearly affects their response to treatment. Accumulating evidence, however, suggests that the biochemical and physiological status of the cell during treatment is at least as important. In this review, a critique of the current evidence for, and extent of, microenvironmental heterogeneity in tumors is presented, emphasizing human tumor cells in situ. The expected consequences of those changes on cellular response to radiation and chemotherapy is then briefly reviewed. Finally, the continuing interest in developing new therapeutic strategies for which the tumor microenvironment is an asset (as opposed to a liability) is discussed in the context of the dynamic nature of tumors, and the complexity of adequately analyzing combination treatments.

Chemical enhancement of cisplatin cytotoxicity in a human ovarian and cervical cancer cell line

While many advances have been made in the chemotherapy of gynecologic cancers, treatment failures remain a major clinical problem. A growing understanding of the mechanisms of tumor cell resistance to antineoplastic drugs provides a framework for the development of chemotherapy regimens containing agents capable of modulating tumor response. Using a short-term ATP bioluminescence assay we studied the ability of two methylxanthines (caffeine, pentoxifylline) and an inhibitor of ADP-ribosyl transferase (3-aminobenzamide) to enhance cisplatin cytotoxicity in gynecologic cancer cell lines. Our findings of significantly enhanced cisplatin-induced cytotoxicity with two different analysis techniques confirms the effectiveness of these agents. These results may have future clinical significance.

Radiation and chemotherapy sensitizers and protectors

Radiosensitizers and radioprotectors are part of the chemical modifier approach to cancer therapy whereby the state of the tumor cells and/or normal tissues are modified such that a therapeutic gain is achieved using conventional radiation or chemotherapy. Radiosensitization can be achieved by the use of oxygen-mimetic compounds, agents that alter DNA sensitivity to irradiation, maneuvers that alter DNA repair processes, and manipulation of tissue oxygenation. Standard chemotherapeutic agents such as cisplatin can be utilized in a manner that optimizes the radiosensitization properties. Protection and sensitization can occur by altering the thiol status of the cell. The chemical modifiers field is both developing novel approaches to cancer treatment and increasing the understanding of basic cancer biology.

Oestrogen potentiates topoisomerase-II-mediated cytotoxicity in an activated subpopulation of human breast cancer cells: implications for cytotoxic drug resistance in solid tumours

Primary resistance to chemotherapeutic agents is a major problem in the management of advanced cancer. By using oestrogen to modulate the topoisomerase II content of T-47D human breast cancer cells, we show here that cell subpopulations resistant to the topoisomerase-II-interactive drug VPI6 (etoposide) can be identified and quantified using single-cell analytical techniques. Immunohistochemical studies reveal topoisomerase II to be present in approximately 10% of control cells compared with 30% of oestrogen-stimulated cells, and this difference is reflected in the proportions of cells exhibiting VPI6-induced cell-cycle delay. This moderate increase in overall cell sensitivity is accompanied by massive enhancement of clonogenic cell kill, suggesting that oestrogen enhances VPI6 cytotoxicity by recruiting a clonogenic cell subpopulation characterized by increased topoisomerase II content. Flow cytometry confirms that the increase in topoisomerase II is localized to an activated G1-phase cell subset. We conclude that (i) single-cell analysis of cellular topoisomerase II content is predictive of VPI6 chemosensitivity; (ii) the existence of resistant tumour-cell subpopulations does not necessarily indicate the presence of phenotypically divergent subclones; and (iii) rational strategies for eliminating tumour resistance may be based on biological manipulation of specific cytotoxic drug targets.

Drug-related chromosomal changes in chemoresistant human ovarian carcinoma cells

Four resistant sublines were derived from the sensitive human ovarian carcinoma IGROV 1 (OV1-P) cell line by exposure to increasing concentrations of vincristine, doxorubicin, and cisplatinum. The vincristine-resistant sublines expressed the MDR phenotype associated with a complete reversion of malignant properties. Cytogenetic studies of sensitive and resistant cells have been repeatedly performed over a 1-year period. Consistent and stable drug-related chromosomal structural rearrangements have been observed in each resistant population affecting chromosomes 3, 4, 6, 8, 11, 22, and X. The most significant result was the presence in OV1/P cells of a minor subclone with a del(11)(p13) marker that represented the whole OV1/VCR population. This result suggests a possible role of this deletion either in the drug-selection process, or in the malignant reversion.

Chemosensitivity testing of fresh leukaemia cells using the MTT colorimetric assay

We have determined the feasibility of using the MTT colorimetric assay for measuring the sensitivity of fresh leukaemia cells to cytotoxic agents. A linear relationship was seen between the number of leukaemic cells plated and the resulting absorbance in the MTT assay at day 4. For 2 X 10(5) cells/well from CLL peripheral lymphocytes, the mean absorbance (measured at 540 nm) was 0.41. Similar curves were obtained with the assay carried out between days 3 and 7. ID50 values for CLL lymphocytes exposed to adriamycin (ADM) were in the range of 0.02-0.29 micrograms/ml, a similar range to that given by the DiSC dye exclusion assay. Sensitization of leukaemia cells to ADM by verapamil or cyclosporin A could be demonstrated in some patients but not in others. The lymphocytes from one patient with prolymphocytic leukaemia were abnormally resistant to ionizing radiation. These cells also showed resistance to melphalan and adriamycin but not to vincristine. The MTT assay appears to offer an attractive option for in vitro chemosensitivity testing in leukaemia, determination of cross-resistance profiles and studies of resistance modifiers.

Identification of anthracyclines and related agents that retain preferential activity over adriamycin in multidrug-resistant cell lines, and further resistance modification by verapamil and cyclosporin A

A range of anthracyclines and related compounds were evaluated for activity against murine and human cell lines exhibiting multidrug resistance (MDR). Cell lines used were the NCI-H69 human small-cell lung cancer line and the EMT6 murine mammary tumour line, together with their multidrug-resistant counterparts produced by in vitro exposure to Adriamycin (ADM). Chemosensitivity testing was carried out using the tetrazolium (MTT) dye assay. Results were expressed as the ratio of the ID50 for the resistant line to that obtained in the parent, i.e. the resistance factor (RF). Compounds exhibiting much lower RF values than ADM in both resistant cell lines were identified as those anthracyclines with 9-alkyl substituents and those with certain changes to the amino sugar residue at position 3' and 4', together with the anthracenedione mitoxantrone (MIT). In a further attempt to overcome resistance, we used four of these compounds, Ro 31-1215, 4'-deoxy-4'-iodo-ADM (iodo-ADM), aclacinomycin A (ACL) and MIT (all yielding low RF values), in combination with the resistance modifiers verapamil (VRP) and cyclosporin A (CYA). Additional enhancement of chemosensitivity was achieved in the ADM-resistant sublines, as shown by the further decrease in RF values. At the concentrations used, the largest effects were generally seen with CYA, and the combination of this modifier with ACL and MIT was particularly effective. For the H69/LX4 resistant line, the latter combinations gave RF values approaching unity. These findings point to the use of analogues with the 9-alkyl substituent and/or specific changes to the sugar residue in combination with resistance modifiers as a therapeutic strategy for circumvention of the MDR phenotype.

Systemic treatment of cancer in the elderly

The goal of this review is to provide a readable and exhaustive reference in three major areas of geriatric oncology: complications of chemotherapy and radiotherapy, responsiveness of cancer to systemic treatment, social issues in the care of elderly patients with terminal illnesses. The conclusions of this study are: 1. Progressive deterioration of renal function is the most consistent change of aging. Adjustment of doses of renally excreted drugs to individual creatinine clearance may prevent life-threatening myelotoxicity in the elderly. 2. Intensive chemotherapy regimens (acute leukemia, non Hodgkin's lymphoma) cause more serious and prolonged myelotoxicity in the elderly. Elderly are more susceptible than younger patients to cardiotoxicity and central and peripheral neurotoxicity. Age is a poor predictor of complications in other organs or systems. 3. The prognosis of patients with Hodgkin's disease worsens with aging, possibly due to increased prevalence of mixed cellularity histology. It is controversial whether the prognosis of other neoplasias is poorer. Prognosis is not age-related in multiple myeloma. In general, elderly in good performance status may benefit from systemic cancer treatment to the same extent as younger patients, except for Hodgkin's disease. 4. The Informal Support Network, epitomized by the family, appears the most suitable environment to care for the elderly with cancer.

Localization of the human multiple drug resistance gene, MDR1, to 7q21.1

Multiple drug resistance has been shown to be associated with amplification/increased expression of a gene designated MDR. The localization of one member of the MDR gene family, MDR1, to the long arm of chromosome 7 by in situ hybridization is reported.