Characterization of polyclonal antibodies to preselected domains of the human estrogen receptor

Immunodetection of nmt55/p54nrb isoforms in human breast cancer

BACKGROUND

We previously identified and characterized a novel 55 kDa nuclear protein, termed nmt55/p54nrb, whose expression was decreased in a subset of human breast tumors. The objective of this study was to determine if this reduced expression in human breast tumors was attributed to the regulation of mRNA transcription or the presence of altered forms of this protein.

RESULTS

Northern blot analysis and ribonuclease protection assay indicated that nmt55/p54nrb mRNA is expressed at varying levels in estrogen receptor positive (ER+) and estrogen receptor negative (ER-) human breast tumors suggesting that reduced expression of nmt55/p54nrb protein in ER- tumors was not due to transcriptional regulation. To determine if multiple protein isoforms are expressed in breast cancer, we utilized Western blot and immunohistochemical analyses, which revealed the expression of an nmt55/p54nrb protein isoform in a subset of ER+ tumors. This subset of ER+ human breast tumors expressed an altered form of nmt55/p54nrb that was undetectable with an amino-terminal specific antibody suggesting that this isoform contains alterations or modifications within the amino terminal domain.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study indicates that nmt55/p54nrb protein is post-transcriptionally regulated in human breast tumors leading to reduced expression in ER- tumors and the expression of an amino terminal altered isoform in a subset of ER+ tumors. The potential involvement of nmt55/p54nrb in RNA binding and pre-mRNA splicing may be important for normal cell growth and function; thus, loss or alteration of protein structure may contribute to tumor growth and progression.

Estrogen receptor antibodies: specificity and utility in detection, localization and analyses of estrogen receptor alpha and beta

The role of estrogens in regulating cellular metabolism in many tissues is well documented. Estrogens regulate cellular activity by interacting with specific intracellular receptor proteins. Two estrogen receptor (ER) isoforms have been isolated, cloned and characterized. Estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) and beta (ERbeta) are ligand dependent transcriptional activators, which regulate gene expression via complex mechanisms requiring ligand binding, transformation, dimerization, and interaction with specific unique cis DNA hormone response elements (EREs) and co-activators and co-repressors. Studies of ER structure and function have been tremendously facilitated by the development of molecular and biologic probes. Cloning and functional studies of the ERalpha and ERbeta have delineated some of the structural requirements involved in receptor function. Immunochemical analyses together with biochemical and molecular approaches have contributed to our understanding of ER structure and function. Although antibodies to ER have been developed and utilized for the past two decades, there has yet to be a comprehensive review that discusses the utility and usefulness of these antibodies in receptor detection and analysis. In this review, we summarize a plethora of information concerning the development and characterization of site-directed monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies to the ERalpha and ERbeta. We provide critical discussion on the characteristics and utility of ER antibodies in analyses, characterization and localization of ER isoforms in various tissues. We also provide a comparison of the potential utility of the available antibodies in various immunochemical assays. An epitope map detailing the specific sites of antibody-receptor interactions is constructed based on the available information. The advent of antibodies with high specificity and titer had facilitated detection of ER isoforms in normal and neoplastic tissues. The advent of new antibodies remains a powerful tool for assessment of ER expression and post-translational modification and receptor function in many experimental systems.

Selectivity of antibodies to estrogen receptors alpha and beta (ERalpha and ERbeta) for detecting DNA-bound ERalpha and ERbeta in vitro

Antibodies are widely used to detect estrogen receptor (ER) in ER-DNA complexes in electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA). We compared the specificity of antibodies raised to different regions of ERalpha or ERbeta for detecting recombinant human ERalpha (rhERalpha) and recombinant rat ERbeta (rrERbeta) when bound to a consensus estrogen response element (ERE). ERalpha-specific antibodies specifically slowed the migration of the ER-ERE complex by 32 to 84% and inhibited rhERalpha-ERE binding by 17 to 75%. None of antibodies to ERbeta supershifted rhERalpha-ERE complex. Some ERalpha-specific antibodies increased whereas some decreased rrERbeta-ERE binding. Anti-ERbeta antibodies supershifted different amounts of the rrERbeta-ERE complex. Our results indicate that supershift and inhibition of ER-ERE interaction with a specific antibody are equally reliable in the detection of rhERalpha and rrERbeta. ERalpha antibody Ab10, antisera G20 and AT3B, and ERbeta-antiserum Y19 offered the best discrimination between ERalpha and ERbeta. Comparison of the peptide sequences against which various antibodies were raised indicate directions for new ERalpha and ERbeta- specific antibody development. We conclude that a cognate ER antibody that retards the migration of the ER-ERE complex by at least 40% or inhibits ER-ERE interaction by at least 8% provides a reliable detection of a specific ER isoform in EMSA.

Chicken ovalbumin upstream promoter-transcription factor interacts with estrogen receptor, binds to estrogen response elements and half-sites, and inhibits estrogen-induced gene expression

Chicken ovalbumin upstream promoter-transcription factor (COUP-TF) was identified as a low abundance protein in bovine uterus that co-purified with estrogen receptor (ER) in a ligand-independent manner and was separated from the ER by its lower retention on estrogen response element (ERE)-Sepharose. In gel mobility shift assays, COUP-TF bound as an apparent dimer to ERE and ERE half-sites. COUP-TF bound to an ERE half-site with high affinity, Kd = 1.24 nM. In contrast, ER did not bind a single ERE half-site. None of the class II nuclear receptors analyzed, i.e. retinoic acid receptor, retinoid X receptor, thyroid receptor, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor, or vitamin D receptor, were constituents of the COUP-TF.DNA binding complex detected in gel mobility shift assays. Direct interaction of COUP-TF with ER was indicated by GST "pull-down" and co-immunoprecipitation assays. The nature of the ER ligand influenced COUP-TF-ERE half-site binding. When ER was liganded by the antiestrogen 4-hydroxytamoxifen (4-OHT), COUP-TF-half-site interaction decreased. Conversely, COUP-TF transcribed and translated in vitro enhanced the ERE binding of purified estradiol (E2)-liganded ER but not 4-OHT-liganded ER. Co-transfection of ER-expressing MCF-7 human breast cancer cells with an expression vector for COUP-TFI resulted in a dose-dependent inhibition of E2-induced expression of a luciferase reporter gene under the control of three tandem copies of EREc38. The ability of COUP-TF to bind specifically to EREs and half-sites, to interact with ER, and to inhibit E2-induced gene expression suggests COUP-TF regulates ER action by both direct DNA binding competition and through protein-protein interactions.

Binding of site-directed monoclonal antibodies to an epitope located in the A/B region (amino acids 140-154) of human estrogen receptor-induced conformational changes in an epitope in the DNA-binding domain

The interactions of estrogen receptor (ER) with monoclonal antibody (Mab) F9, developed against a synthetic 30-mer hybrid oligopeptide, were determined in the presence or absence of Mab NMT-1, raised against 15-mer peptide from the N-terminal A/B region (amino acids 140- 154) or Mab 213, raised to a peptide AT3 in the DNA-binding domain (amino acids 247-263). Mab F9 bound ER and formed a complex sedimenting at the approximately 11S region of the gradients. Mabs 213 and NMT-1 bound ER and formed complexes sedimenting at approximately 7S and 9S, respectively. Preincubation of ER with Mab 213, followed by reincubation with Mab F9, resulted in a complex sedimenting at the approximately 11S region of the gradients. Similarly, preincubation of ER with Mab NMT-1 followed by reincubation with Mab F9 also produced an approximately 11S complex on the gradients. These observations suggest that binding of Mab F9 to ER induced conformational changes causing the release of Mab 213 and Mab NMT-1 from ER. Furthermore, binding of Mab NMT-1 to the A/B region of ER also produced conformational changes causing the release of Mab 213 from its epitope in the DNA-binding region. These results indicate that binding of Mab F9 and Mab NMT-1, with epitopes located within amino acids 140-154 of the A/B region of ER, induced conformational changes in the DNA-binding domain, as determined by the inability of Mab 213 to remain bound to its epitope. These data further suggest that the DNA-binding region is sensitive to conformational changes induced in the native protein.

Site-directed estrogen receptor antibodies stabilize 4-hydroxytamoxifen ligand, but not estradiol, and indicate ligand-specific differences in the recognition of estrogen response element DNA in vitro

Conformational differences between type I antiestrogen-liganded estrogen receptor and estradiol (E2)-liganded estrogen receptor (ER) are thought to be responsible for differentiating agonist versus antagonist ER activity at individual genes. To examine the impact of ER ligand on estrogen-response element (ERE) binding kinetics and receptor conformation, we quantitated the effect of site-directed, ER-specific antibodies raised against synthetic peptides corresponding to the DNA-binding domain of human ER on ER-ERE binding in vitro. Although 4-hydroxytamoxifen-liganded-ER (4-OHT-ER) and E2-ER bind a consensus ERE with equal high affinity, the stoichiometry of 4-OHT-ER-ERE binding at saturation is approximately 50% lower than that of E2-ER binding to all ERE sequences tested. In contrast, the ERE binding stoichiometry of tamoxifen aziridine-liganded ER (TAz-ER) is identical to that of E2-ER: one receptor dimer bound per ERE. The difference in binding stoichiometry is caused by dissociation of one molecule of 4-OHT from the ER as the dimeric receptor binds DNA. Addition of low concentrations of ER-specific polyclonal antibodies AT3A or AT3B prevented 4-OHT ligand dissociation, yielding an increase in specific 4-OHT-ER-ERE binding to a level equal to that of E2-ER- or TAz-ER-ERE binding. However, higher amounts of AT3A or AT3B inhibited specific ERE binding of both 4-OHT- and E2-ER. We conclude that differences in ER conformation when liganded with 4-OHT versus E2 are revealed by these antibodies and that such differences in receptor conformation may influence subsequent interaction of the receptor with other proteins necessary for transactivation.

Identification of structurally altered estrogen receptors in human breast cancer by site-directed monoclonal antibodies

We have developed and characterized site-directed monoclonal (MAb) and polyclonal antibodies to a specific domain in the N-terminal A/B region in order to assess estrogen receptor (ER) structural integrity in human breast tumor samples. The antibodies (Abs) reacted specifically with the native (undenatured) ER from various species. The synthetic peptides competed effectively for ER binding to the Abs, suggesting site-specificity. The Abs recognized the activated (4S) and transformed (5S) but not the unactivated, untransformed, molybdate-stabilized (8S) ER, suggesting that the epitope is inaccessible in the 8S form. Some of these Abs reacted with ER bound to its responsive elements, as determined by gel mobility shift assay. To evaluate the structural integrity of ER in breast cancer, we have utilized a) ligand binding analysis for the hormone binding domain; b) site-directed MAb to the DNA-binding domain; and c) site-directed MAb to the N-terminal transactivation domain. Analysis of ER from 29 human breast tumors revealed that 10 out of 29 tumors (35%) contained ER with intact hormone-, DNA-, and N-terminal domains. Thirteen out of 29 tumors (approximately 45%) contained ER with intact hormone binding and N-terminal domains but were defective only in the DNA-binding domain. Three out of 29 tumors (approximately 10%) contained ER defective only in the N-terminal domain. Another subgroup of tumors (3/29; approximately 10%) had ER with normal hormone binding domain but were defective in both the DNA-binding and the N-terminal activation domains.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Monoclonal antibodies to human endothelin-1: characterization and utilization in radioimmunoassay and immunocytochemistry

A host of monoclonal antibodies directed against human endothelin-1 (ET-1) has been developed and characterized. The antibodies reacted with ET-1 specifically and with high affinity, as determined by competition analysis and sucrose density gradients. The antibodies did not cross-react with neuropeptide YY, beta-endorphin, calcitonin gene-related peptide, secretin or somatostatin. The antibodies cross-reacted with big endothelin (B-ET), endothelin-2 (ET-2), vasointestinal constrictor peptide (VIC), and endothelin-3 (ET-3) albeit with varying affinity but did not cross-react with sarafotoxin (SRTX-6b). None of the antibodies reacted with the C-terminal hexapeptide (HXPT) of ET-1, indicating that the epitopes are not located within this region of ET-1. The monoclonal antibodies exhibited binding activity in dilutions ranging from 1:1000, to 1:10(6). The isotypes of the monoclonal antibodies were determined by competition binding assay. Six of the monoclonal antibodies were of the IgG gamma 1, two were IgM and one of the IgG gamma 2a subclass. The antibodies detected immunoreactive ETs by radioimmunoassay and in immunocytochemical localization, suggesting the potential use of these antibodies as tools to determine the concentration of ETs in biological fluids and in immunocytochemical localization of ETs in specific cell types in various tissues.

Site-specific antibodies to the DNA-binding domain of estrogen receptor distinguish this protein from the 3H-estradiol-binding protein in pancreas

The estradiol-binding protein (EBP) in extracts of rat and rabbit pancreata was characterized by sucrose density gradient analysis, immunoaffinity adsorption and Western blot (immunoblot) analysis using polyclonal antibodies raised against EBP. Rat pancreatic extracts labeled with 3H-estradiol contained a readily resolvable peak of steroid-binding activity that sedimented as a 4S complex on sucrose density gradients in the presence or absence of 0.4 M KCl. Estrogen receptor (ER) from calf uterine cytosols sedimented as a 4S complex on gradients containing 0.4 M KCl and as an 8S entity on gradients without KCl. Incubation of cytosol fractions from rat pancreas and calf uterus with benzoyl-DL-arginyl-p-nitroanilide (BAN) increased specific binding of 3H-estradiol to EBP but not to ER. Furthermore, two distinct site-specific antibodies to the DNA-binding domain of ER caused a marked increase in sedimentation rate of 3H-estradiol-labeled ER while normal rabbit serum and antibodies against EBP were ineffective in this regard. These data suggest that a significant portion, if not all, of the DNA-binding domain of ER is absent from EBP. Examination of the amino acid sequence of the DNA-binding domain of ER revealed a region of 10 amino acids that is significantly homologous to somatostatin, a tetradecapeptide that is a co-ligand in the binding of 3H-estradiol to EBP. Based on this observation, a possible mode of action of EBP in pancreatic acinar cells is proposed.

Immunoelectron microscopic localization of estrogen receptor on pre-mRNA containing constituents of rat uterine cell nuclei

The localization and quantitative changes of estradiol receptor (ER) were studied by means of immunogold-electron microscope methods using a polyclonal antibody directed against an amino acid sequence representing the DNA binding site of ER, a monoclonal antibody against hnRNP core protein, and anti-DNA antibody. The uteri of normal rats in estrus and those of ovariectomized females were used. Ovariectomized rats were studied 21 days after surgery at different times after the injection of normal saline or estradiol-17 beta. The density of labeling was measured in interchromatin space, compact chromatin, nucleolus, cytoplasm, and background of epithelial cells, muscle cells, and fibroblasts. In the three types of cells ER was found mainly on extranucleolar ribonucleoprotein (RNP) fibrils. In epithelial and muscle cells the nucleolus was labeled but compact chromatin was not labeled. In epithelial cells there was a low but significant labeling of the cytoplasm. Fibroblasts exhibited a low labeling of the compact chromatin. Ovariectomy did not change these distributions. The estradiol injection increased labeling in all compartments of epithelial and muscle cells but decreased the labeling of compact chromatin of fibroblasts. These results show: (a) that ER is mainly nuclear but it is also present in the cytoplasm, (b) that ER binds to the nuclear particles containing newly synthesized RNA, and (c) that the binding to RNPs does not block the DNA binding domain of the ER.

Mechanism of estrogen receptor-dependent transcription in a cell-free system

RNA synthesis was stimulated directly in a cell-free expression system by crude preparations of recombinant mouse estrogen receptor (ER). Receptor-stimulated transcription required the presence of estrogen response elements (EREs) in the test template and could be specifically inhibited by addition of competitor oligonucleotides containing EREs. Moreover, polyclonal antibodies directed against the DNA-binding region of ER inhibited ER-dependent transcription. In our cell-free expression system, hormone-free ER induced transcription in a hormone-independent manner. Evidence is presented suggesting that ER acts by facilitating the formation of a stable preinitiation complex at the target gene promoter and thus augments the initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase II. These observations lend support to our current understanding of the mechanism of steroid receptor-regulated gene expression and suggest strong conservation of function among members of the steroid receptor superfamily.

Steroid hormone receptors

In the three decades since the original discovery of receptors for steroid hormones, much has been learned about the biochemical processes by which these regulatory agents exert their effects in target tissues. The intracellular receptor proteins are potential transcription factors, needed for optimal gene expression in hormone-dependent cells. They are present in an inactive form until association with the hormone converts them to a functional state that can react with target genes. Transformation of the receptor protein to the nuclear binding form appears to involve the removal of both macromolecular and micromolecular factors that act to keep the receptor form reacting with DNA. Much of the native receptor is present in the nucleus, loosely bound and readily extractable, but for some and possibly all steroid hormones, some receptor is in the cytoplasm, perhaps in equilibrium with a nuclear pool. Methods have been developed for the stabilization, purification, and characterization of receptor proteins, and through cloning and sequencing of their cDNAs, primary structures for these receptors are now known. This has led to the recognition of structural similarities among the family of receptors for the different steroid hormones and to the identification of regions in the protein molecule responsible for the various aspects of their function. Monoclonal antibodies recognizing specific molecular domains are available for most receptors. Despite the knowledge that has been acquired, many important questions remain unsolved. How does association with the steroid remove factors keeping the receptor protein in its native state, and how does binding of the transformed receptor to the response element in the promoter region enhance gene transcription? Once it has converted the receptor to the nuclear binding state, is there a further role for the steroid in modulating transcription? Still not entirely clear is the involvement of phosphorylation and/or dephosphorylation in hormone binding, receptor transformation, and transcriptional activation. Less vital to basic understanding but important in the overall picture is whether the native receptors for gonadal hormones are entirely confined to the nucleus or whether there is an intracellular distribution equilibrium. With the effort now being devoted to this field, and with the application of new experimental techniques, especially those of molecular biology, our understanding of receptor function is progressing rapidly. The precise mechanism of steroid hormone action should soon be completely established.

Site-directed polyclonal antibodies inhibit binding of activated estrogen receptor to DNA

We have generated three polyclonal antisera to the DNA-binding domain of the human estrogen receptor (hER). Antiserum AT2A was generated against a peptide spanning amino acids 231-245 of hER, while antisera AT3A and AT3B were generated against a peptide spanning amino acids 247-261 of hER. The interaction of these three antisera with ER has been characterized by sucrose density gradient analysis. The antisera bound to the unactivated (8S), salt-activated (4S), and heat transformed (5S) ER complex. All the antisera appeared to be site-specific since binding of salt-activated ER to the antisera was blocked by the presence of excess free synthetic peptides. Antisera AT3A and AT3B inhibited the binding to DNA of the KCl-activated 4S ER and the heat-transformed 5S ER. Although antiserum AT2A bound to ER, it did not inhibit DNA binding of activated ER complexes. The ability of antisera AT3A and AT3B to inhibit ER binding to DNA was concentration dependent. Once bound to the DNA, ER complexes were not significantly affected by incubation with the antisera, suggesting that binding of DNA to ER inhibits antibody ER interaction and renders that domain inaccessible to the antibodies. These results demonstrate that site-directed antibodies to ER inhibit binding of activated ER complexes to DNA in vitro.

Mechanism of estrogen receptor-dependent transcription in a cell-free system

RNA synthesis was stimulated directly in a cell-free expression system by crude preparations of recombinant mouse estrogen receptor (ER). Receptor-stimulated transcription required the presence of estrogen response elements (EREs) in the test template and could be specifically inhibited by addition of competitor oligonucleotides containing EREs. Moreover, polyclonal antibodies directed against the DNA-binding region of ER inhibited ER-dependent transcription. In our cell-free expression system, hormone-free ER induced transcription in a hormone-independent manner. Evidence is presented suggesting that ER acts by facilitating the formation of a stable preinitiation complex at the target gene promoter and thus augments the initiation of transcription by RNA polymerase II. These observations lend support to our current understanding of the mechanism of steroid receptor-regulated gene expression and suggest strong conservation of function among members of the steroid receptor superfamily.

Characterization of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors in human penile corpus cavernosum: studies on whole tissue and cultured endothelium

The binding characteristics of the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor antagonist, [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate, to isolated membranes of human corpus cavernosum and endothelial cells, cultured from this tissue, were investigated. [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate bound to membranes of human corpus cavernosum and endothelial cells with high affinity and limited capacity. Analysis of the binding data by Scatchard plot revealed the presence of one class of binding sites. The ligand binding specificity was determined by competitive binding assay. The data obtained show that [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate was displaced by unlabeled competitors in the following order of efficacy in both membrane preparations: quinuclidinyl benzilate greater than scopolamine greater than atropine greater than 4-diphenylacetoxy-N-methyl-piperidine methiodide, M3 antagonist greater than pirenzepine, M1 antagonist greater than oxotremorine greater than (4-hydroxy-2-butynyl)trimethylammonium chloride m-chlorocarbanilate, M1 agonist greater than carbachol greater than hexamethonium. Solubilization of the muscarinic acetylcholine receptors from human corpus cavernosum and endothelial cells, with 1% digitonin and 0.02% cholate and subsequent analysis on sucrose density gradients, demonstrated the presence of a macromolecule specifically bound to [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate sedimenting at the 6.2 S region of the gradient. These results demonstrate the presence of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors in human corpus cavernosum and in endothelial cells cultured from this tissue.

Development and characterization of monoclonal antibodies to a specific domain of human estrogen receptor

We have synthesized three peptides with amino acid sequences identical to those spanning amino acids 201-215, 231-245, and 247-261 of the human estrogen receptor (hER). These peptides were conjugated to keyhole limpet hemocyanin and used as immunogens to develop monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) to hER. Antibody responses were only elicited by the peptide with amino acid sequence 247-261. Splenocytes from immunized mice were used for hybridoma production. Of the seven MoAbs that recognized the native (functional) form of the ER, four (MoAbs 16, 33, 114, and 213) recognized the ER with high affinity, as demonstrated by the increased sedimentation coefficient of the antibody-complexed ER in sucrose density gradients. Antibodies 318, 35, and 36 bound to ER with low affinity since they immunoprecipitated ER, but the ER-antibody complex appeared to dissociate on sucrose density gradients. The high-affinity MoAbs appear to be site-specific since the peptide competed effectively for binding of the receptor by the antibody. The fact that they reacted with ER from human breast cancer and calf, rat, and mouse uterine tissues suggests that this epitope of the receptor is conserved in these species. Although the DNA-binding region appears to be conserved among the various steroid receptors, these MoAbs did not recognize the native forms of progesterone, androgen, or glucocorticoid receptors. These MoAbs bound to the KCl-activated 4S ER and heat-transformed 5S ER, suggesting that the antibody-binding site is accessible in the monomeric and dimeric forms of ER. The antibodies did not recognize the untransformed 8S ER in the presence of molybdate and without KCl, suggesting that the antibody-binding site in the oligomeric form of ER is inaccessible. The fact that the antibodies did bind to the unoccupied 4S ER was demonstrated by the data obtained with sucrose density gradient analysis followed by postlabeling of ER with [3H]estradiol. The antibodies bound to ERs with high affinity (KD = 0.4 to 1.8 nM). At a fixed concentration of antibody, ERs ranging from 20 to 1,000 fmol were detectable. These MoAbs did not inhibit nuclear or DNA binding of ER in vitro. This can be attributed to the dissociation of the antibodies from ER when the latter interacts with its acceptor site. These results demonstrate the development of site-specific MoAbs to the native form of the hER using synthetic peptides as immunogens.