Antibodies to porcine eye muscle in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy: identification of serum immunoglobulins directed against unique determinants by immunoblotting and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

Update Thyroid-Associated Ophthalmopathy

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is one of the most vexing problems in endocrinology but its relationship to thyroid autoimmunity is becoming more clear with the realisation that almost all patients with Graves' disease have this condition and almost all patients with ophthalmopathy have some form of thyroid involvement. This suggests cross reactivity between thyroid and retrobulbar antigens, of which one potential candidate has recently been cloned. Together with new information on predisposing factors and the important role of the retrobulbar fibroblasts, these developments shed new light on the aetiology and pathogenesis of this enigmatic disorder.

Current perspective on the pathogenesis of Graves' disease and ophthalmopathy

Graves' disease (GD) is a very common autoimmune disorder of the thyroid in which stimulatory antibodies bind to the thyrotropin receptor and activate glandular function, resulting in hyperthyroidism. In addition, some patients with GD develop localized manifestations including ophthalmopathy (GO) and dermopathy. Since the cloning of the receptor cDNA, significant progress has been made in understanding the structure-function relationship of the receptor, which has been discussed in a number of earlier reviews. In this paper, we have focused our discussion on studies related to the molecular mechanisms of the disease pathogenesis and the development of animal models for GD. It has become apparent that multiple factors contribute to the etiology of GD, including host genetic as well as environmental factors. Studies in experimental animals indicate that GD is a slowly progressing disease that involves activation and recruitment of thyrotropin receptor-specific T and B cells. This activation eventually results in the production of stimulatory antibodies that can cause hyperthyroidism. Similarly, significant new insights have been gained in our understanding of GO that occurs in a subset of patients with GD. As in GD, both environmental and genetic factors play important roles in the development of GO. Although a number of putative ocular autoantigens have been identified, their role in the pathogenesis of GO awaits confirmation. Extensive analyses of orbital tissues obtained from patients with GO have provided a clearer understanding of the roles of T and B cells, cytokines and chemokines, and various ocular tissues including ocular muscles and fibroblasts. Equally impressive is the progress made in understanding why connective tissues of the orbit and the skin in GO are singled out for activation and undergo extensive remodeling. Results to date indicate that fibroblasts can act as sentinel cells and initiate lymphocyte recruitment and tissue remodeling. Moreover, these fibroblasts can be readily activated by Ig in the sera of patients with GD, suggesting a central role for them in the pathogenesis. Collectively, recent studies have led to a better understanding of the pathogenesis of GD and GO and have opened up potential new avenues for developing novel treatments for GD and GO.

Susceptibility of Ocular Tissues to Autoimmune Diseases

The orbital tissues may form a unique immunological environment, as evidenced by autoimmune disorders that specifically target orbital tissues, particularly myasthenia gravis (MG) and Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO). The reasons for the preferential susceptibility are likely to be multiple, based on the interplay of molecular and physiological properties of extraocular muscles (EOM), the unique requirements of the ocular motor system, and the specific autoimmune pathology. Of general importance, even a minor loss of EOM force generation will sufficiently misalign the visual axes to produce dramatic symptoms, and proprioceptive feedback is limited to overcome such a deficit. Particular to MG, EOM synapses appear susceptible to neuromuscular blockade, the autoimmune pathology differs between ocular and generalized MG patients, and the influence of complement regulatory factors may be less prominent in preventing damage at EOM neuromuscular junctions. GO pathogenesis is poorly understood, but shared epitopes of orbital fibroblasts, EOM, and thyroid could lead to specific autoimmune targeting of these tissues. The differential response of orbital fibroblasts to cytokines may be a key factor in disease development. Greater appreciation of the immunologic environment of orbital tissues may lead to therapies specifically designed for orbital autoimmune diseases.

Differential susceptibility of the ocular motor system to disease

This review summarizes an alternative approach to the understanding of neuromuscular disease. By contrasting disease susceptibility of extraocular muscle and ocular motor neurons, it is hoped that unique insights into disease mechanisms may be identified. Disorder of eye movements leads to dramatic symptoms for patients and the ocular motor system is relatively limited in its ability to compensate rapidly for such disruptions. However, more profound reasons exist as to why myasthenia gravis compromises neuromuscular transmission at ocular muscle synapses as well as why Graves' ophthalmopathy exists. In contrast, muscular dystrophies spare the eye muscles while devastating all other skeletal muscles; the same is true for motor neuron diseases. It is hoped that this review will encourage others to view the world of neuromuscular diseases as delineated into those that spare the ocular motor system and those that do not.

Thyroid eye disease

Thyroid eye disease is the most common cause of unilateral and bilateral proptosis in adults. It occurs most frequently in women aged 30 to 50 years. Clinical features include eyelid retraction, periorbital edema, conjunctival injection and chemosis, proptosis, extraocular muscle restriction, exposure keratopathy, and optic nerve compromise. Thyroid eye disease differs from idiopathic orbital myositis in that the latter is characterized by a more acute onset, more severe pain, and a rapid response to systemic corticosteroid therapy. Echography and computed tomography in thyroid eye disease reveal enlarged extraocular muscle bellies with relative sparing of the tendons. Despite evidence of an immune-mediated cause, the precise pathophysiologic mechanisms of thyroid eye disease remain unknown.

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy in black South African patients with Graves' disease: relationship to antiflavoprotein antibodies

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is a progressive eye disorder associated with Graves' hyperthyroidism, which is generally considered to have an autoimmune etiology. Eye muscle membrane proteins of 64 kd are good markers of ophthalmopathy in patients with thyroid autoimmunity. The 64-kd protein is now shown from a partial sequence to be the flavoprotein subunit (Fp) of mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase. Hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease is increasing in incidence among urban black female Africans, possibly because of exposure to environmental risk factors such as increased dietary iodine ingestion and stress. Ophthalmopathy is frequently observed in this clinical context, but its association with serum autoantibodies reactive with Fp has not been examined. We studied 19 black South African patients with Graves' disease during the course of prolonged antithyroid drug administration, of whom 10 had congestive ophthalmopathy, but no clinical evidence for eye muscle damage at the onset. Anti-Fp antibodies were detected in 2 of these patients, as well as in 2 of the 9 patients who did not have overt eye disease. Additionally, the antibodies became positive in 3 patients with ophthalmopathy in whom tests were negative initially, remained positive in 1 patient throughout the study period and became negative in 1 patient with positive tests initially. Ophthalmopathy did not develop in any of the 9 patients who lacked this complication on presentation. The reasons why we failed to demonstrate a close relationship between anti-Fp antibodies and the eye muscle component of ophthalmopathy are unclear although one possibility is that ocular myopathy is an uncommon manifestation in African thyrotoxic patients compared with those of Caucasian origin. The relationship between anti-Fp antibodies and eye muscle inflammation in patients with thyroid autoimmunity of different ethnic origins and environmental settings, needs to be addressed in a large prospective study.

Role of Eye Muscle Antibody Measurement in Diagnosis of Thyroid-Associated Ophthalmopathy: A Laboratory Update

OBJECTIVE

To review the current role of measurement of serum eye muscle antibodies in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO).

METHODS

We conducted laboratory studies to determine the prevalences of serum autoantibodies reactive with eye muscle antigens in patients with active and inactive TAO, Graves' hyperthyroidism, and Hashimoto's thyroiditis as well as in normal subjects.

RESULTS

The two antigens most often recognized in immunoblotting with crude human or porcine eye muscle membranes by serum autoantibodies in patients with TAO are eye muscle membrane proteins of 55 and 64 kd. One 64-kd eye muscle protein has recently been cloned by screening a human eye muscle expression library with two different antibody probes and identified from a computer gene bank search as the calcium-binding protein calsequestrin. A fragment of a 220-kd eye muscle protein, called G2s, has also been cloned by screening the eye muscle library with affinity-purified antibodies reactive with a 55-kd eye muscle membrane protein. The prevalences of autoantibodies reactive with these two antigens in our study groups were as follows. Antibodies against calsequestrin were detected in 38% of patients with TAO for <1 year, in 17% of those with TAO for >3 years, in 17% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism without ophthalmopathy, in 12% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis without ophthalmopathy, and in 21% of normal subjects. Antibodies reactive with the 64-kd protein were demonstrated in 62% of patients with recent-onset active TAO, in 33% with eye disease for >3 years, in 39% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism without ophthalmopathy, in 25% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and in 16% of normal control subjects. Antibodies reactive with G2s fusion protein were detected in 67% of patients with recent-onset active TAO, in 46% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism, and in 20% of normal subjects. Antibodies reactive with the parent protein, of which G2s is a fragment, may be markers of early eye muscle swelling and inflammation, whereas those reactive with the 64-kd protein and, less often, calsequestrin are associated with established eye disease.

CONCLUSION

Measurement of serum eye muscle antibodies is recommended as an aid to the early diagnosis of ophthalmopathy in predisposed patients and first-degree relatives of patients with TAO as well as to monitor active or progressive eye disease.

The 64-kilodalton eye muscle protein is the flavoprotein subunit of mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase: the corresponding serum antibodies are good markers of an immune-mediated damage to the eye muscle in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is a progressive eye disorder associated with thyroid autoimmunity, particularly Graves' hyperthyroidism, which is generally considered to have an autoimmune etiology. Eye muscle membrane proteins reportedly of 55 and 64 kDa are the best markers of the ophthalmopathy. The main focus of our recent studies has been to purify the pertinent proteins from porcine eye muscle membranes and characterize them. The 64-kDa protein is now shown from a partial sequence and by Western blotting using specific antibody probes to be the flavoprotein (Fp) subunit of succinate dehydrogenase and to have a correct molecular mass of 67 kDa. The protein was purified and cleaved with cyanogen bromide, and the N-terminal region of an immunoreactive partial peptide was determined. The 20-amino acid porcine sequence so obtained matched one within the Fp subunits of human and bovine succinate dehydrogenases in 20 and 18 of these positions, respectively. Succinate dehydrogenase is both a citric acid cycle enzyme and a component (complex II) of the mitochondrial respiratory chain. It is thus essential for aerobic energy production and is highly conserved. The mature human and bovine Fp subunits are 92% homologous and have a molecular mass of approximately 67 kDa, the same as our redetermined value for the 64-kDa marker protein. Sera from patients with TAO and from those with Graves' hyperthyroidism without evident ophthalmopathy highlighted the 64-kDa marker protein in crude porcine eye muscle membranes and the Fp subunit of highly purified bovine succinate dehydrogenase at the identical position on Western blots. Anti-beef Fp antibodies were detected in sera from 67% of patients with active TAO of more than 1-yr duration, in 30% with stable TAO of more than 3-yr duration, and in 30% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism without ophthalmopathy, but in only 7% of age- and sex-matched normal subjects. As succinate dehydrogenase is bound to the matrix (inside) surface of the mitochondrial inner membrane, it is unlikely to be accessible to circulating autoantibodies. We would postulate that eye muscle damage in ophthalmopathy is probably caused by cytotoxic antibodies or CD+ T lymphocytes targeting a cell membrane antigen, such as the thyroid and eye muscle shared protein G2s, and that presentation of succinate dehydrogenase is secondary. On the other hand, an autoantibody response to succinate dehydrogenase may be a good marker of immune-mediated damage to the eye muscle fiber and may support the idea that the extraocular muscles are targets of the autoimmune reactions of TAO.

Reevaluation of the prevalences of serum autoantibodies reactive with "64-kd eye muscle proteins" in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

Serum autoantibodies reactive with eye muscle proteins of "64 kilodaltons (kd)" are frequently found in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism and thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO). Earlier, we cloned a 64-kd protein that was identified as calsequestrin, a calcium-binding protein localized in the sarcoplasmic reticulum of striated muscle and extensively studied another cloned 64-kd protein, called 1D, which is expressed in thyroid and eye muscle, and some other tissues. Using a monoclonal antibody against calsequestrin, a polyclonal antibody against 1D and a TAO patient serum reactive with the "64-kd protein," as probes, we performed Western blots of porcine eye muscle membrane. We identified three different proteins in the 63 to 67 kd molecular weight range that were targeted by antibodies in sera from patients with TAO. It was not possible to differentiate antibodies reactive with calsequestrin and 1D because these two proteins have very similar molecular weights--63 to 64 kd--and band appearance in Western blotting. A 67-kd protein was most frequently recognized by TAO patients' sera. Serum antibodies reactive with the 67-kd protein were detected in 73% of patients with active TAO of 1 year duration or less, in 37% of patients with TAO of more than 3 years' duration, in 35% with Graves' hyperthyroidism without evident ophthalmopathy, in 30% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and in 16% of normal subjects. Serum antibodies reactive with calsequestrin/1D were detected in 47% of patients with active TAO of less than 1 year, in 22% of patients with TAO longer than 3 years, 17% with Graves' hyperthyroidism without evident ophthalmopathy, in 10% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and in 21% of normal subjects. The prevalence of anti-67-kd protein antibodies in TAO patients corresponded to those reactive with the so called "64-kd protein" that we have reported previously. In conclusion, we were able to improve the accuracy of the Western blots by comparing the molecular weight of positive bands using specific antibodies reactive with eye muscle antigens as probes. The previously recognized, and extensively studied, "64-kd protein" is now shown to have a molecular weight of 67 kd. The role of the various eye muscle antibodies in the diagnosis and management of the ophthalmopathy associated with Graves' hyperthyroidism needs to be addressed in prospective studies using purified or recombinant full-length proteins.

Involvement of the orbital fibroblast and TSH receptor in the pathogenesis of Graves' ophthalmopathy

Our concepts and understanding of the etiology, evolution, and propagation of Graves' ophthalmopathy have become much more sophisticated that they were 10 years ago. Given our current state of knowledge, the following scheme for the pathogenesis of Graves' ophthalmopathy can be proposed. Circulating T cells in patients with Graves' disease, directed against an antigen on thyroid follicular cells, recognize antigenic epitopes that are shared by tissues contained in the retroorbital space. Of the cell types residing in these tissues, fibroblasts are most likely to act as both target and effector cells of the retroorbital immune process. This includes those fibroblasts present in the perimysium of extraocular muscles, which do not appear to be immunologically different from fibroblasts located in the retroorbital connective tissue. By contrast, convincing evidence implicating the human extraocular myocyte itself (rather than the tissue conglomerate of extraocular muscle) as a primary target in GO remains to be demonstrated. Together with adipocytes, fibroblasts may also serve as target and effector cells in pretibial myxedema. How autoreactive T cells escape deletion by the immune system and come to be directed against a self-antigen presented by cells residing in the thyroid gland and extrathyroidal locations is unknown. T cells are recruited to and infiltrate the orbit via certain adhesion receptors, which may also play a costimulatory role in T cell activation and facilitate antigen recognition. Analysis of variable region gene usage of the T cell antigen receptors in retroorbital T cells of patients with active GO reveals limited variability, suggesting that antigen-driven selection and/or expansion of specific T cells may occur early in the evolution of GO.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

New assays for the measurement of serum antibodies reactive with eye muscle membrane antigens confirm their significance in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

Although sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and Western blotting are widely used to detect serum antibodies in patients with autoimmune disorders, this procedure unfolds and denatures proteins and may alter antibody binding sites. We have used nondenaturing methods for the purification of a 64-kDa eye muscle (EM) membrane antigen associated with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO). Pig EM membrane proteins were prepared from crude homogenates by high-speed centrifugation and solubilized by hand homogenization. The 64-kDa protein was further purified by isoelectric focusing performed in the absence of SDS, detergents, reducing agents, and urea. Sera from patients with active TAO of recent onset and thyroid autoimmunity without ophthalmopathy were tested for reactivity against purified native 64-kDa protein in immunoblotting. Tests were positive in 64% of patients with TAO, in 37.5% of those with Graves' hyperthyroidism without eye disease, in 11% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis without eye disease, and in 13% of normal subjects. Many of the same sera were also tested for cytotoxic activity against human EM cells in an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) assay. ADCC tests were positive in 69% of patients with TAO but in no normal subject. The specificity and sensitivity of these two tests in TAO surpass those for all other published results for orbital tissue reactive autoantibodies. Although there was a tendency for a relationship between reactivity to the 64-kDa protein and cytotoxic activity against EM cells in ADCC there were many exceptions and overall the relationship between the two tests was not significant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy: pathogenesis and clinical management

The pathogenesis of thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy is autoimmune. The questions to which answers are eagerly awaited are the identification of the autoantigen(s) and the definition of the autoimmune processes (cellular or humoral) responsible. Cellular and humoral immune responses and modulation by cytokines, against orbital tissues have been described. A link between the thyroid and the orbit seems inevitable, possibly in the form of a cross-reactive antigen, and top of the list of candidate antigens is the TSH receptor. Optimal treatment of TAO necessitates careful assessment. Thoughtful planning and timing and choice of intervention with conventional therapies, can lead to satisfactory results in the majority of cases. In addition to treating the severe complications, such as optic neuropathy, corneal exposure and muscle misalignment, corrective surgery to reconstruct the appearance of the patient's eyes should be made available.

Immunoglobulin class and subclass distribution of eye muscle and fibroblast antibodies in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

OBJECTIVE

The investigation of the antibody response in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) using different antigens and assays has given inconsistent results. We have analysed antibodies against eye muscle and control antigens in a large group of TAO patients to assess whether specific eye muscle antibodies exist in TAO. We have also evaluated the presence of IgA and IgM class antibodies and examined IgG subclass distribution.

DESIGN

Sera were obtained from all patients (TAO, Graves' disease without ophthalmopathy and Hashimoto's thyroiditis) within one year of diagnosis. Sera were also collected from healthy controls, with no family history of autoimmune thyroid disease.

PATIENTS

Thirty-eight patients had Graves' disease with Grade III or greater TAO; 15 patients had Graves' disease without ophthalmopathy and nine had Hashimoto's thyroiditis without any eye signs. The control group consisted of 14 subjects.

MEASUREMENTS

Antibodies against porcine eye and skeletal muscle, human eye (membrane and soluble antigen) and skeletal muscle, human thyroid microsomal and thyroglobulin antigens and dermal and orbital fibroblast antigens were assessed using ELISA. Antibody isotypes and IgG subclasses were studied for porcine and human eye muscle antibodies. Eye muscle (porcine and human) and orbital fibroblast antibodies were further analysed by immunoblotting.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in the ability of either IgG or IgA in sera from the different groups to bind porcine and human eye muscle antigens. There was a significant correlation (P < 0.0001) between the binding to porcine eye muscle and skeletal muscle antigens (for both IgG and IgA). There was no difference between sera from TAO patients and control subjects in their binding to eye muscle fibroblasts for both IgG and IgA antibodies. However, IgA antibody activity against dermal fibroblasts differed significantly between TAO patients and controls (P < 0.05). By immunoblotting, the frequency of IgA antibodies recognizing 21 kDa (40% of patients) and 62 kDa (52%) bands in porcine eye muscle blots and 20, 24 and 38 kDa bands in blots of human eye muscle (soluble) antigen differed significantly between patients with TAO and controls (P < 0.05 in all cases). IgG antibodies recognizing 80 and 92 kDa bands in blots of the subcellular membrane antigen prepared from orbital fibroblasts were found more frequently in patients with TAO compared with controls (P < 0.05 in both cases).

CONCLUSIONS

We found no evidence that eye muscle membrane or fibroblast antibodies are present in a significant proportion of TAO patients, using ELISAs based on antigens prepared from several sources. We have also failed to demonstrate the presence of previously described specific, TAO-associated antibodies, including those directed against a 64 kDa protein in eye muscle and a 23 kDa protein in fibroblasts. IgA class antibodies reactive with orbital components appeared to be more strongly associated with TAO than those of the IgG class, though even this relationship is weak. These results suggest that antibodies are of secondary importance in the pathogenesis of TAO, which is most likely a T cell-mediated disorder.

Cross-reactive antibodies in the serum of balb/c mice immunized with thyroid or eye muscle membranes

During the course of immunizing balb/c mice with eye muscle (EM) or thyroid (THY) membranes for monoclonal antibody (MCAB) production their sera frequently contain antibodies which react against both EM and THY membranes in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and Western blotting. In order to further study this phenomenon we have analyzed sera from 27 balb/c mice, including 10 that were studied serially, and their tissues examined histologically at sacrifice. Following immunization serum and, in some cases, the corresponding MCAB produced by fusion of the mouse spleen cells with a mouse myeloma cell line, were tested for EM and THY cross-reactivity in an ELISA and by immunoblotting. The number of antibodies demonstrated in Western blotting identified as bands of reactivity, and ELISA levels, expressed as optical density--increased with time, each peaking at around 10-12 weeks. THY and EM antibody cross-reactivity was demonstrated in the majority of mice, serum from mice immunized with THY membranes reacting with these membranes as well as with pig EM membranes in both ELISA and immunoblotting and, conversely, sera from mice immunized with pig EM membranes also reacting with THY membranes in the two tests. In Western blotting a variety of THY and EM-reactive antibodies were demonstrated including those directed against a 64 kDa protein, shown to be an important autoantigen in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy. There was also some cross-reactivity with brain membranes, used as control antigen in both tests and in immunization, although to a lesser degree, but very little to liver and orbital connective tissue membrane.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Two dimensional gel electrophoresis identifies minor differences in immunologically cross-reactive 64 KDa autoantigens in the thyroid and eye muscle

Among the candidate eye muscle autoantigens proposed as being relevant to the pathogenesis of thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO), a 64 kDa membrane autoantigen appears to be most closely associated with the eye disorder. We have examined the tissue localization and some of the physicochemical properties of this molecule in 3 human tissues, namely thyroid (THY), eye muscle (EM) and skeletal muscle (SKE), and in pig eye muscle (PEM), by two-dimensional (2-D) [isoelectric focusing (IEF)/sodium dodecyl polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE)] gel electrophoresis followed by Western blotting. Antibody probes used were whole sera from patients with TAO and antibodies affinity purified from TAO sera by binding to, and elution from, a sepharose-4B column conjugated with D1, a 98 amino acid peptide fragment of a recombinant 64 kDa thyroid autoantigen. Soluble membrane proteins eluted from a slice of SDS-PAGE gel containing 60-70 kDa material was prepared from the four tissues and used as antigen for 2-D gel separation. The presence of a 64 kDa antigen in THY and EM recognized by sera from patients with TAO, but only rarely by those from normal individuals, was confirmed. Pretreatment of the eluted 60-70 kDa material with N-Glycosidase F to eliminate charge heterogeneity resulting from glycosylation differences, changed the pI and MW of molecules recognized by TAO sera, in THY and EM. This suggests that the 64 kDa molecule(s) in EM and THY targeted by sera from patients with TAO are glycoproteins and that they are different in the two tissues.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Antibodies reactive with an intracellular epitope of a recombinant 64 kDa thyroid and eye muscle protein in patients with thyroid autoimmunity and ophthalmopathy

We have developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the measurement of antibodies reactive with a 98 amino acid fragment, called D1, of a recombinant thyroid and eye muscle membrane protein corresponding to a MW of 64 kDa (called 1D) in the serum of patients with thyroid autoimmunity with and without ophthalmopathy. Antibodies against the D1 fragment expressed as a fusion protein with beta galactosidase, were detected in 29% of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) of < 1 yr duration, in 33% of those with disease of > 3 yr duration, in 40% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism (GH) without evident eye disease, in 31% of patients with lid lag and retraction but no other signs of progressive ophthalmopathy, in 25% of patients with euthyroid Graves' disease and in 43% of patients with untreated Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), but in none of 14 patients with other (non-immunological) thyroid disorders. Although tests were positive in 6 out of the 15 patients with ophthalmopathy and no overt thyroid autoimmunity overall there was no close association of the antibodies with clinical features of the eye disease or its course. In those sera in which Western blotting for antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane protein and ELISA were both carried out there was no close correlation between the two tests.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Repertoires of natural autoantibodies against muscle tissue are independent of age or gender in normal human adults. A western blot study

Sera from 69 healthy blood donors were screened for autoantibodies using Western blots of human muscle fractions to assess whether prevalence and repertoires of autoantibodies against muscle tissue would change with age. Each serum contained immunoglobulins binding to a broad spectrum of antigens. Their molecular masses ranged from 20 to more than 200 kDa. Although each staining pattern appeared to be a singular combination of detected bands and staining intensities, the patterns were not different in men and women. When sera were grouped according to age (decades between 10 and over 70 years) age-dependent changes were not found. Individual repertoires of natural autoantibodies against muscle tissue are complex when examined by Western blotting. Mature normal repertoires of low-affinity autoantibodies are found at the age of 10 years which is the lower cut-off in this study. The repertoires remain stable throughout a normal lifespan.

Muscle autoantigens in thyroid associated ophthalmopathy: the limits of molecular genetics

Unlike autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD) in which a number of autoantigens have been identified and characterized, the situation in thyroid associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is far from clear. A number of candidate antigens have been identified by probing Western blots of orbital tissue (OT) with sera from TAO patients, the most frequently cited being proteins of molecular weight 23, 28, 55, 64, 78 and 120 kilodaltons. In an attempt to identify autoantigens in TAO we have produced a lambda gt11 human eye muscle expression library. This has been screened with sera from four patients with severe TAO whose antibodies bind to one or more of the aforementioned candidate antigens or to a thyroglobulin/acetylcholinesterase (Tg/Ache) shared epitope. Four clones were isolated and characterized; clone R14 encodes the carboxyl terminal 193 amino acids of an IgE binding protein, clones R10 and R13 encode unknown proteins having significant similarity with heat shock protein 27 and the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein respectively. Clone R1 encodes an unknown peptide of 347 amino acids having no similarity with proteins in available data banks. R1 clone affinity purified autoantibodies bind to a protein of Mr 78 kD in a Western blot of porcine eye muscle tissue. Autoantibodies to the R1 recombinant lysogen were clearly demonstrated in 5 of 20 sera from Graves disease patients, its role merits further investigation. The possible relevance of these clones to the pathogenesis of TAO is discussed as well as the limitations of this type of approach in the identification of unknown autoantigens.

Nature of 64 kDa eye muscle and thyroid membrane proteins and their significance in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy--an hypothesis

Although a variety of eye muscle antigens are recognized by autoantibodies in the serum from patients with thyroid associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) 64 kDa membrane proteins, which are also expressed in the thyroid, are most closely linked to the development of ophthalmopathy in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease. A cloned 64 kDa protein called 1D, which shares homology with tropomodulin, appears to be closely related to a 64 kDa eye muscle protein identified in immunoblotting and both may be members of a family of cytostructural proteins. The relationship between 64 kDa proteins in eye muscle and thyroid, and its equivalent in somatic skeletal muscle, will only be understood when the various proteins are cloned from expression libraries, sequenced and their consensual and unique domains identified. Since these 64 kDa antigens are expressed in both thyroid and eye muscle, a possible mechanism for the association of ophthalmopathy with autoimmune thyroid disease is immunological cross-reactivity by autoantibodies and sensitized T lymphocytes. Autoantibodies reactive with 64 kDa eye muscle proteins are associated with ophthalmopathy in patients with autoimmune thyroid disorders and predictive of the development of ophthalmopathy in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism.

Significance of anti-eye muscle antibody in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy by quantitative western blot

To investigate the prevalence of antibody against rat eye muscle membrane antigen, as determined from SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and western blotting, in sera from patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO), we quantitatively analyzed the binding activity with a rat eye muscle membrane 64 kDa protein using chromato-scanner. Eye muscle antibody activity was expressed as ratio of density of the 64 kDa band to that at 66 kDa found with all normal sera and phosphate buffered saline. The mean (+/- SD) eye muscle antibody activity was 2.7 +/- 2.7 in TAO (P < 0.01 v.s. normal), 1.5 +/- 1.7 in Graves' disease without evident eye disease, 1.6 +/- 2.5 in Hashimoto's thyroiditis and 0.45 +/- 0.26 in normal subjects. A positive band at 64 kDa was found in 71% of patients with TAO, 36% of those of Graves' disease without evident eye disease and in 35% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis without eye disease. The prevalence of this antibody activity tended to correlate to the severity of ophthalmopathy. Furthermore, the level of eye muscle antibody activity decreased in parallel with the improvement of eye signs in two patients. Sera reactive with rat eye muscle membrane 64 kDa protein reacted also with a human eye muscle membrane 64 kDa protein but not with human thyroid, liver, spleen or pancreas membrane preparations. In conclusion, antibody to rat eye muscle membrane 64 kDa protein is present in TAO and may be a useful clinical marker of ophthalmopathy.

Identification of autoantigen recognized by autoimmune ophthalmopathy sera with immunoblotting correlated with orbital computed tomography

We have demonstrated that there is an antibody related to extraocular muscle enlargement in autoimmune ophthalmopathy (Graves' ophthalmopathy, thyroid-associated correlated with orbital computed tomography (CT). This study was designed to identify the autoantigen and to determine whether there are common antigens among the extraocular muscle, the lacrimal gland, and the thyroid. We prepared a 100,000g sediment fraction of porcine extraocular muscle, lacrimal gland, thyroid, and human thyroid, followed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and immunoblotting with sera from patients with Graves' disease, with or without ophthalmopathy, classified by symptoms and signs combined with orbital CT and normal controls. The results showed there was an approximately 55-kDa protein band which was recognized by the sera in 32.1% (9/28) of patients with autoimmune ophthalmopathy and in 47.3% (9/19) of patients with extraocular muscle enlargement demonstrated by orbital CT. It was significantly higher than the positive rates in patients without autoimmune ophthalmopathy and normal controls (15.8 and 11.1%, respectively, P < 0.025). However, there was no common antigen among the extraocular muscles, the lacrimal gland, and the thyroid. To further confirm this eye muscle-specific antigen, the approximately 55-kDa protein band was cut and solubilized from the nitrocellulose paper after SDS-PAGE, and electrophoretically transferred and used as an antigen in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The absorbance was significantly higher in patients with autoimmune ophthalmopathy than patients without ophthalmopathy (P < 0.005), and normal controls (P < 0.01). Our findings suggest that an approximately 55-kDa protein may be a possible antigen in the eye muscle related to autoimmune ophthalmopathy.

Restricted tissue reactivity of autoantibodies to a 64-kDa eye muscle membrane antigen in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

We studied the tissue specificity of eye muscle (EM) membrane-reactive autoantibodies detected in the serum of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO). In preliminary studies, such antibodies were shown to react, in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blotting, with human thyroid (THY) and other human skeletal muscle (HSM) membrane antigens. We carried out absorption with human EM (HEM), THY, and HSM membranes of sera from patients with TAO and autoimmune thyroid disease without ophthalmopathy which reacted with one or more of 55-, 64-, and 95-kDa antigens in pig eye muscle (PEM) membrane in immunoblotting, the majority of which were also cytotoxic to HEM cells in an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity assay. In Western blotting, serum antibodies reactive with PEM membrane antigens of 55, 64, and 95 kDa were cross-absorbed by HEM, THY, and HSM but not by spleen or brain membranes and showed some species specificity, being absorbed by pig and human, but not bovine, EM membranes. When incubated with cultured HEM, THY, and HSM cells in vitro, autoantibodies in TAO sera immunoprecipitated a 64-kDa antigen from the first two tissues, but not from HSM, suggesting a specific binding to autoantigenic epitopes in HEM and THY. Sera from patients with TAO as well as those from patients with thyroid autoimmunity without ophthalmopathy immunoprecipitated a approximately 66-kDa protein, shown to be distinct from the 64-kDa antigen. The restricted immunological cross-reactivity of antibodies to a THY and HEM 64-kDa membrane antigen is discussed in the context of the association of ophthalmopathy with thyroid autoimmunity. Further experiments are needed to show whether autoantibodies to the 64-kDa eye muscle and thyroid shared antigen are cytotoxic, and thus likely to play a major role in the pathogenesis of the eye disease, or just markers of the orbital autoimmune process.

Antibodies in the serum of patients with autoimmune thyroid disorders react with a recombinant 98 amino acid fragment of a full length 64 kDa eye muscle membrane protein which is also expressed in the thyroid

We have tested sera from patients with autoimmune thyroid disorders with or without ophthalmopathy for immunoreactivity, in a dot blot assay, against a recombinant 98 amino acid fragment of a cloned 64 kDa protein, D1, which is expressed in human eye muscle and thyroid, in the form of a Lac Z fusion protein. Tests were positive in 19 out of 40 patients with established thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO), in 12 out of 21 patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism (GH) without clinically evident ophthalmopathy, in 5 out of 10 patients with thyroid autoimmunity and lid retraction but no other signs of ophthalmopathy, in 4 out of 23 patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) without evident ophthalmopathy and in 2 out of 18 patients with benign adenoma or multinodular goitre, but in only 2 out of 37 normal subjects tested. SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blotting for an antibody reactive with a 64 kDa antigen in pig eye muscle membranes was also carried out on sera from patients with TAO and GH. While immunoblotting for antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa protein was more often positive in patients with TAO, in whom 58% had serum antibodies which reacted with a 64 kDa protein, this was not the case in patients with GH without eye signs in whom the prevalence of positive immunoblot tests was 35%. Overall there was a fairly close correlation between the two tests although there were many exceptions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Nature and significance of orbital autoantigens and their corresponding autoantibodies in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

There is now considerable evidence that the pathogenesis of thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy is closely linked to the presence of a shared autoantigen(s) in the thyroid and the eye muscle, against which cytotoxic mechanisms are directed. Although the orbital connective tissue is certainly involved in the orbital inflammatory process, a 64 kDa membrane protein expressed by both the eye muscle and the thyroid and recognized consistently by antibodies in the sera of TAO patients, seems to be the most likely target candidate. While its presence in non ocular skeletal muscle is not as well established, more recent data tend to suggest the existence of a 64 kDa molecule in the three tissues. The availability of a cDNA encoding a 572 amino acid protein corresponding to a MW of 63-64 kDa, which may be the same molecule, will allow us to determine more clearly the structural characteristics of the different molecules proposed as targets. The role of the corresponding autoantibodies in the pathogenesis of the eye disease is far less well defined. Whether they play a role in the induction of the ophthalmopathy or only represent helpful markers remains to be clarified.

Significance of antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane antigen in patients with thyroid autoimmunity

SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blotting for antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa protein in pig eye muscle membrane was carried out in patients with lid lag and retraction, but no other signs of ophthalmopathy, associated with thyroid disease or nonimmunologic goiter and in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism without ophthalmopathy who were studied prospectively to determine the relationship of eye muscle antibodies to clinical features of the ophthalmopathy as they appeared in this group of predisposed patients. Seventy-one percent of euthyroid patients with lid lag and retraction but no established ophthalmopathy had detectable serum antibodies to a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane protein. Much smaller proportions had antibodies to proteins of other MW. In normal subjects with previously detectable antibodies to a 64 kDa protein, serum titers, determined by carrying out immunoblotting at serum dilutions of 1:25-1:6400, were low (< or = 1:100) in all cases tested. On the other hand, titers were higher (1:200-1:6400) in 16 of 22 patients with established ophthalmopathy and in 5 of 7 patients with lid lag and retraction tested. Titers tended to be lower in patients with ophthalmopathy of > or = 3 years duration than in those of < or = 1 year duration. Antibody titers were low (1:25) in 6 of 7 patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism without evident eye disease tested. Antibodies to a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane protein were predictive of the development of ophthalmopathy in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism studied prospectively for periods of 8-42 months.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Relationship of eye muscle antibodies with HLA phenotypes and thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulins in endocrine orbitopathy

The relationship between endocrine orbitopathy and Graves' hyperthyroidism is still not clarified. The purpose of this study was to elucidate the incidence of eye muscle antibodies and the relationship with HLA phenotypes and thyroid antibodies in 65 patients with endocrine orbitopathy classes 1-5. Both bovine and abdominal muscles were used as antigens in ELISA systems in which IgG and IgM antibodies were assayed. Before starting the immunosuppressant therapy, 46/65 patients (71%) showed a positive result for eye muscle antibodies. Those patients with an active disease had such antibodies more frequently. Where the ophthalmopathy was of recent onset IgM antibodies were found, whereas patients with chronic disease were mostly IgG-Ab positive. No association was found either with HLA phenotypes (B8, DR3) or with antibodies directed against thyroglobulin, thyroid microsomes, and the TSH receptor measured as thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulins. Furthermore, there was no correlation between ophthalmopathy class and optic muscle antibody-binding activity. There was no relation between the degree of exophthalmos and eye muscle, thyroid-stimulating, antithyroglobulin, or antithyroid microsomal antibodies. These results suggest that, although very closely related, endocrine orbitopathy and Graves' hyperthyroidism are separate, organ-specific autoimmune diseases.

A 64 kDa membrane antigen is a recurrent epitope for natural autoantibodies in patients with Graves' thyroid and ophthalmic diseases

OBJECTIVE

We have explored the recently described 64 kDa extraocular muscle antigen that is associated with autoantibodies in the serum of patients with severe Grave's ophthalmopathy. The localization of the antigen and the specificity of autoantibodies for both eye muscle antigens and ophthalmopathy patients were investigated.

DESIGN

Western blotting and immunoprecipitation of metabolically labelled antigen from eye muscle and control tissues with sera from ophthalmopathy, Graves' without ophthalmopathy, and normals were used.

PATIENTS

Sera from normals (n = 9), patients with recent onset Graves' ophthalmopathy (n = 23), and patients with Graves' disease without ophthalmopathy (n = 8) were utilized.

MEASUREMENTS

Immunoblots using detergent phase separated (amphiphilic) antigen preparations from fetal eye muscle, skeletal muscle and control tissues were quantitated. Metabolically labelled eye muscle and skeletal muscle antigens were immunoprecipitated using patient and control IgG.

RESULTS

In the eye muscle detergent phase, immunoreactivity around 64 kDa was detected in 30% of the patients with ophthalmopathy (n = 23) as well as 38% of patients with Graves' disease and no ophthalmopathy (n = 8) and in 30% of normal sera (n = 9). There was significantly more of this anti-64 kDa reactivity in sera from the ophthalmopathy patients compared with the normals (P less than 0.01). 64 kDa reactivity to detergent phase antigens prepared from human thyroid, skeletal muscle, brain, and liver was also observed with these positive sera indicating the polyreactivity of the IgG interactions to conserved antigens in this region.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that IgG antibodies binding to a recurrent 64 kDa antigen are present in many normal human sera, with increased concentrations detectable in sera from Graves' ophthalmopathy patients. Such 'specificity-crossover' with similar molecular weight transmembrane antigens is likely to be caused by natural autoantibodies reacting with recurrent autoepitopes rather than a factor aetiological in the disease process.

Immunoblotting for the detection of TSH receptor autoantibodies

Immunoblotting was optimized to detect autoantibodies to TSH receptors from human and porcine thyroid tissue and to determine their epitope specificity. Autoantibodies to putative TSH receptor proteins in thyroid particulate membranes were detected in approximately 35% of sera from patients with Graves' disease. However, despite modifications to increase immunoblotting sensitivity and specificity, only a minority (less than 15%) of Graves' disease sera contained autoantibodies that identified epitopes within TSH affinity-purified human or porcine receptor proteins. In these sera there was no correlation between the TSH receptor antibody titre, determined by radioreceptor assay, and receptor epitope reactivity. The sensitivity of immunoblotting was limited by reduced transfer of purified receptor from the gel. However, in addition, the inability to immunoblot the purified receptor with a majority of Graves' sera, under conditions designed to enhance receptor renaturation, appears to reflect a strict conformational requirement for immunoreactivity. Immunoblotting of purified receptors therefore has a limited application in detecting, and defining the epitope reactivity of, TSH receptor autoantibodies.

Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy--a model for the association of organ-specific autoimmune disorders

The development of a characteristic ophthalmopathy is a feature of autoimmune diseases of the thyroid. The link between the conditions has not yet been discovered, but here Jack Wall and colleagues develop the theory that an autoimmune response to a 64 kDa antigen expressed on both thyroid and eye muscle membranes is responsible for this thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy.

Muscle and species reactivity of mouse monoclonal antibodies to human eye muscle membrane antigens

We studied the tissue and species reactivity of mouse monoclonal antibodies (MCAB) produced by immunizing mice with a 100,000g ultracentrifuged preparation of human eye muscle (HEM) membranes. Twenty-three MCABs, 20 of which reacted in an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) with HEM membrane, 2 with human thyroid membrane, and 1 nonreactive negative control, were selected for the study. The muscle and species specificity of 6 of the most reactive and more restrictively reactive MCAB were studied in more detail. All reacted in ELISA with human skeletal muscle membrane and, to a lesser extent, with human cardiac muscle membrane, but not with human brain membrane. The 6 MCAB cross-reacted with eye muscle membrane prepared from pig but not rat, although reactivity with human tissue was greatest for all MCAB tested. When tested in immunoblotting with HEM and thyroid membranes, 3 of 6 MCAB reacted with a 64-kDa protein in HEM, 2 of which also reacted with an antigen of the same molecular weight in thyroid membrane. In a complement-mediated antibody-dependent cytotoxicity assay, 5 of 19 MCAB lysed HEM cells, 6 of 21 lysed human skeletal muscle cells, and 10 of 22 lysed human thyroid cells. These findings support results from earlier clinical studies which showed that eye muscle membrane reactive autoantibodies in the serum of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy cross-react with membrane prepared from other striated muscle. The significance of eye muscle, skeletal muscle, and thyroid cross-reactivity of MCAB is discussed in the context of autoimmune thyroid disease and ophthalmopathy.

Prevalence of antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane antigen in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

We have determined the prevalences of antibodies reactive with certain pig eye muscle membrane antigens, as determined from SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and western blotting, in patients with autoimmune thyroid disorders with or without associated ophthalmopathy. The most frequently detected antibody was that directed against a protein of 64 kDa. Antibodies against this antigen were detected in 33% of unselected patients with ophthalmopathy and in 75% of those with severe, active, orbital inflammation of less than 12 months duration. Such antibodies were detected also in 33% of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism with no apparent eye disease and in 17% of patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis with no eye disease but were not detected in patients with nonautoimmune thyroid disorders in 25 normal subjects tested. In the majority of sera showing reactivity with this protein, reactivity with membrane antigens of 55 and 95 kDa also were observed, suggesting that the three proteins were conformationally associated. Cytotoxic antibodies against human eye muscle cells, measured in antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC), were demonstrated in 37% of patients with ophthalmopathy. There was no significant correlation, in patients with eye disease, between positive ADCC tests and antibodies to the 64 kDa protein, the 64 kDa reactive antibody being found in 50% of patients with positive ADCC and in 35% of those with negative tests. In this study, a clear association has been shown between thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy and the detection, in immunoblotting, of antibodies reactive with a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane antigen.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Correlation of orbital computed tomography and antibodies in patients with hyperthyroid Graves' disease

The purpose of this study was to elucidate the incidence of orbital changes in computed tomography, and the relationships of orbital changes with eye-muscle antibody (EMAb), thyrotrophin-binding inhibitor immunoglobulin (TBII), antithyroglobulin antibody (TgAb) and anti-thyroid microsomal antibody (MsAb), in 55 consecutive patients with hyperthyroid Graves' disease. EMAb was demonstrated by an immunoperoxidase technique. The results showed that the prevalence of orbital fat increase, extraocular muscle enlargement, lacrimal gland enlargement and optic nerve swelling were 54.5, 41.8, 21.8 and 16.5% respectively. There were 32.7% of patients without any orbital changes. The patients with extraocular muscle enlargement, lacrimal gland enlargement and optic nerve swelling had higher titres of EMAb than the patients without these orbital changes. The patients with lacrimal gland enlargement had a lower TBII index than those without. There was no difference in TgAb or MsAb between the patients with extraocular muscle enlargement, lacrimal gland enlargement, optic nerve swelling or orbital fat increase and those patients without these orbital changes. The patients with extraocular muscle enlargement, optic nerve swelling and orbital fat increase had a higher degree of exophthalmos than the patients without these orbital changes. EMAb was negatively correlated with TBII. However, there was no correlation between EMAb and TgAb or MsAb. The degree of exophthalmos was positively correlated with EMAb and negatively correlated with age. There was no correlation between exophthalmos and TBII, TgAb or MsAb. In conclusion, although the pathogenesis of orbital changes and hyperthyroidism is different, a close link between these two entities is suggested by the high incidence of orbital changes in hyperthyroid Graves' disease.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Eye muscle membrane reactive antibodies are not detected in the serum or immunoglobulin fraction of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy using an ELISA and crude membranes

We tested sera and purified immunoglobulin (Ig) fractions from patients with autoimmune thyroid disorders (AITD), with and without ophthalmopathy, and normal subjects, for the presence of antibodies reactive with eye muscle membrane antigens in an optimized enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). We found no correlation between ELISA results and the presence or severity of ophthalmopathy in patients with AITD for either serum or Ig, and there were no significant differences between the mean values (+/- SE) for the three groups (AITD with ophthalmopathy, AITD without ophthalmopathy and normals) for either serum or Ig. In contrast Ig from 8 of 19 (45%) patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy reacted with a 64 kDa eye muscle membrane antigen in SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blotting, while tests were positive in only one of the 8 patients with AITD without eye disease and in none of the 8 normal subjects. The presence of antibodies to a 64 kDa antigen in immunoblotting did not correlate with the levels of antibodies measured in ELISA. We conclude that the ELISA, incorporating a crude membrane fractions as antigen, is not useful as a clinical test for eye muscle autoantibodies.

Graves' ophthalmopathy: what is the evidence for extraocular muscle specific autoantibodies

Graves' ophthalmopathy is thought to be an autoimmune disease. Whether this disease is organ specific or one of the manifestations of the closely linked Graves' thyroid disease is still a matter of speculation. Many papers describe autoimmunity to orbital antigens, in particular to extraocular muscles, in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy. In this paper we have tried to give an overview of the evidence for circulating antibodies against extraocular muscle antigens and to discuss their significance in relation to the immunopathogenesis of the disease.

The diagnostic value of serum autoantibodies in endocrine orbitopathy and idiopathic ocular myositis

Sera of patients with Graves' orbitopathy (GOP) often contain antibodies against retroorbital tissue components. The presence of such autoantibodies has been considered to indicate an autoimmune pathogenesis of the disease. However, their specificity has not been conclusively tested, because studies demonstrating autoantibodies used controls with no lesion in the extraocular eye muscles. Although ocular myositis (OM) is clinically distinct from GOP, damage to the retroorbital muscles is a common histopathological finding in both conditions. Using an immunoblot technique, reactions of sera from patients suffering from either disease were compared. Sera from both groups contained antibodies against a variety of antigenic determinants recognized by both sera. These autoantibodies may have been induced secondary to tissue damage and should be considered to be nonspecific. Because the role of tissue damage was not accounted for in previous studies, evidence concerning antigens supposedly specific for GOP should be reevaluated. The reaction patterns of OM and GOP sera were slightly different. These differences were specific enough to suggest that sera from patients with GOP contain antibodies against eye muscle components that are not present in the sera of patients with idiopathic OM. These findings support the assumption that GOP is an autoimmune disease. However, the major autoimmune targets remain to be identified and their pathogenic relevance is still unclear.

T and B cell reactivity to extraocular and skeletal muscle in Graves' ophthalmopathy

We have sought human eye muscle membrane binding antibodies in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy using an enzyme-linked immunoassay. Antibodies were found in patients with thyroid autoimmunity irrespective of eye signs, and binding correlated closely (r = 0.94) with binding to skeletal muscle, showing that these antibodies are not site-specific. T cells from patients with thyroid autoimmunity proliferated in response to eye muscle, but again this was not specific for eye muscle or the presence of ophthalmopathy. No single antigen was responsible for inducing proliferation. These results fail to confirm a recent report of eye muscle membrane binding antibodies in a high proportion of patients with ophthalmopathy, and suggest instead that T and B cell autoreactivity to striated muscle antigens is a frequent feature of autoimmune thyroid disease, unlikely to be directly related to eye disease.

Autoimmunity in Graves' ophthalmopathy: a review

Images

Clinical studies of the reactivity of serum IgG from patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy with porcine orbital tissue preparations

The clinical utility of ELISA assays for antibodies reactive with a variety of porcine orbital tissue antigen preparations is described using sera from large numbers of patients. Use of such assays does not allow reliable identification of patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO) due to the overlap between patients with and without eye involvement and normal individuals. In 5/6 patients showing high levels of reactivity with porcine eye muscle membrane antigen, a considerable but variable proportion of the binding was found to be species, rather than tissue, specific. No consistent pattern of change in ELISA reactivity with time was seen in studies of serum samples from patients treated medically for hyperthyroidism and patients who received immunosuppressive therapy with cyclosporin A for active, severe ophthalmopathy. Use of previously published ELISA methods using the crude antigen preparations described is therefore not likely to be of use in the routine clinical management of GO patients.

A study of the binding of Graves' immunoglobulins to orbital antigens

The binding of Graves' immunoglobulins to membranes of human eye muscle (HEM) and guinea pig Harderian gland (HG) were studied. The membrane fraction of 100,000 X g sediment was used for ELISA. Serum samples from 55 patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy were evaluated for binding to the membrane preparation. There was a higher binding to HG with the sera from the patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy than in the control group (p less than 0.01), but there was no difference in binding to HEM. Purification of IgG from sera improved binding to HG in both patients' (p less than 0.001) and control group (p less than 0.005). There was also an increase in percentage of positive responses obtained with IgG 48% vs serum samples 37%. In 23 out of 24 patients we found the thickening of extraocular muscles by A-scan ultrasonography. In these groups of patients and 3 others with malignant ophthalmopathy the binding of IgG preparation to HG was similar to control group. In all assays there was an overlap between patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy and control subjects, and a lack of relationship between the responses in ELISA and clinical or severity of ophthalmopathy.

Human orbital tissue and thyroid membranes express a 64 kDa protein which is recognized by autoantibodies in the serum of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

A 64 kDa protein has been identified in the membrane fraction of human eye muscle, orbital connective tissue and thyroid, by testing sera of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy in SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Western blotting. Antibodies to this membrane antigen seem characteristic of the early stage of ophthalmopathy. In the thyroid this newly recognized protein seems different from previously known membrane antigens. A thyroid antibody reactive with a 64 kDa membrane antigen in eye muscle could explain the very frequent association of ophthalmopathy with autoimmune thyroid disease.

Immunological responses in the eyelid and orbit

Immunological responses in the eyelid and the orbit are reviewed: (1) A local immune response is dependent on the presence of lymphoid tissue in an organ. Lymphoid tissue is found in the conjunctival fornices and in the lacrimal gland but not in the orbit. The eyelids also have lymphatic drainage into the local lymph nodes. A local immune response is found in the palpebral conjunctiva and in the lacrimal gland, measureable both as immunoglobulin or specific antibody levels in tears or as immunoglobulin producing cells within the tissue. No local immunity has been demonstrated in the orbit. (2) The other type of immune response found in the eyelids, the lacrimal gland and the orbit is the involvement of these tissues in systemic diseases. Systemic diseases with an immunological basis, which affect the above mentioned tissues are: atopic diseases of the skin, autoimmune diseases, immunodeficiency diseases and lymphoproliferative diseases. (3) Finally, it is possible that the extraocular muscles and the lacrimal gland have tissue specific antigens and therefore may be target tissues for organ specific autoimmune processes.