Isolated growth hormone deficiency: analysis of the growth hormone (GH)-releasing hormone gene and the GH gene cluster

Genomics in pediatric endocrinology-genetic disorders and new techniques

In the last few years, there have been remarkable advances in the development of new and more sophisticated genetic techniques. These have allowed a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms of genetically determined pediatric endocrine disorders and are paving the way for a radical change in diagnosis and treatment. This article introduces some of these concepts and some of the genetic techniques being used.

Genetics of GHRH, GHRH-receptor, GH and GH-receptor: its impact on pharmacogenetics

When a child is not following the normal, predicted growth curve, an evaluation for underlying illnesses and central nervous system abnormalities is required and, appropriate consideration should be given to genetic defects causing GH deficiency (GHD). Because Insulin-like-Growth Factor-I (IGF-I) plays a pivotal role, GHD could also be considered as a form of IGF-I deficiency (IGFD). Although IGFD can develop at any level of the GHRH-GH-IGF axis, a differentiation should be made between GHD (absent to low GH in circulation) and IGFD (normal to high GH in circulation). The main focus of this review is on the GH-gene, the various gene alterations and their possible impact on the pituitary gland. However, although transcription factors regulating the pituitary gland development may cause multiple pituitary hormone deficiency they may present initially as GHD. These defects are discussed in various different chapters within this book, whereas, the impact of alterations of the GHRH-, GHRH-receptor- --as well as the GH-receptor (GHR) gene--will be discussed here.

Genetic defects causing functional and structural isolated growth hormone deficiency

Normal somatic growth requires the integrated function of many of the hormonal, metabolic, and other growth factors involved in the hypothalamo-pituitary-somatotrope axis. Human growth hormone (hGH) causes a variety of physiological and metabolic effects in humans and its pivotal role in postnatal growth is undisputed. Disturbances that occur during this process often cause subnormal GH secretion and/or subnormal GH sensitivity/responsiveness resulting in short stature. Despite the complexity of this linear growth process, the growth pattern of children, if evaluated in the context of normal standards, is rather predictable. Children presenting with short stature (i.e out of normal standards) are treated with daily injections of recombinant human GH (rhGH), which leads in almost all cases to an increase of height velocity. Although it is becoming more and more evident that many genes are involved in controlling the regulation of growth, the main aim of this review is to focus on the GH-1 gene, the various gene alterations and their important physiological and pathophysiological role in growth.

Genetics of isolated growth hormone deficiency

When a child is not following the normal, predicted growth curve, an evaluation for underlying illnesses and central nervous system abnormalities is required, and appropriate consideration should be given to genetic defects causing growth hormone (GH) deficiency (GHD). Because Insulin-like Growth Factor-I (IGF-I) plays a pivotal role, GHD could also be considered as a form of IGF-I deficiency (IGFD). Although IGFD can develop at any level of the GH-releasing hormone (GHRH)-GH-IGF axis, a differentiation should be made between GHD (absent to low GH in circulation) and IGFD (normal to high GH in circulation). The main focus of this review is on the GH gene, the various gene alterations and their possible impact on the pituitary gland. However, although transcription factors regulating the pituitary gland development may cause multiple pituitary hormone deficiency, they may present initially as GHD.

Genomics in pediatric endocrinology--genetic disorders and new techniques

In the last few years, there have been remarkable advances in the development of new and more sophisticated genetic techniques. These have allowed a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms of genetically determined pediatric endocrine disorders and are paving the way for a radical change in diagnosis and treatment. This article introduces some of these concepts and some of the genetic techniques being used.

Comparative genomics reveals functional transcriptional control sequences in the Prop1 gene

Mutations in PROP1 are a common genetic cause of multiple pituitary hormone deficiency (MPHD). We used a comparative genomics approach to predict the transcriptional regulatory domains of Prop1 and tested them in cell culture and mice. A BAC transgene containing Prop1 completely rescues the Prop1 mutant phenotype, demonstrating that the regulatory elements necessary for proper PROP1 transcription are contained within the BAC. We generated DNA sequences from the PROP1 genes in lemur, pig, and five different primate species. Comparison of these with available human and mouse PROP1 sequences identified three putative regulatory sequences that are highly conserved. These are located in the PROP1 promoter proximal region, within the first intron of PROP1, and downstream of PROP1. Each of the conserved elements elicited orientation-specific enhancer activity in the context of the Drosophila alcohol dehydrogenase minimal promoter in both heterologous and pituitary-derived cells lines. The intronic element is sufficient to confer dorsal expansion of the pituitary expression domain of a transgene, suggesting that this element is important for the normal spatial expression of endogenous Prop1 during pituitary development. This study illustrates the usefulness of a comparative genomics approach in the identification of regulatory elements that may be the site of mutations responsible for some cases of MPHD.

Genetics of growth hormone deficiency

When a child is not following the normal, predicted growth curve, an evaluation for underlying illness and central nervous system abnormalities is required and appropriate consideration should be given to genetic defects causing growth hormone (GH) deficiency. This article focuses on the GH gene, the various gene alterations, and their possible impact on the pituitary gland. Transcription factors regulating pituitary gland development may cause multiple pituitary hormone deficiency but may present initially as GH deficiency. The role of two most important transcription factors, POU1F1 (Pit-1) and PROP 1, is discussed.

Genetic control of growth

The application of the powerful tool molecular biology has made it possible to ask questions not only about hormone production and action but also to characterize many of the receptor molecules that initiate responses to the hormones. We are beginning to understand how cells may regulate the expression of genes and how hormones intervene in regulatory processes to adjust the expression of individual genes. In addition, great strides have been made in understanding how individual cells talk to each other through locally released factors to coordinate growth, differentiation, secretion, and other responses within a tissue. In this review I (1) focus on developmental aspects of the pituitary gland, (2) focus on the different components of the growth hormone axis and (3) examine the different altered genes and their related growth factors and/or regulatory systems that play an important physiological and pathophysiological role in growth. Further, as we have already entered the 'post-genomic' area, in which not only a defect at the molecular level becomes important but also its functional impact at the cellular level, I concentrate in the last part on some of the most important aspects of cell biology and secretion.

Role of PROP1 in pituitary gland growth

Mutations in the PROP1 transcription factor gene lead to reduced production of thyrotropin, GH, prolactin, and gonadotropins as well as to pituitary hypoplasia in adult humans and mice. Some PROP1-deficient patients initially exhibit pituitary hyperplasia that resolves to hypoplasia. To understand this feature and to explore the mechanism whereby PROP1 regulates anterior pituitary gland growth, we carried out longitudinal studies in normal and Prop1-deficient dwarf mice from early embryogenesis through adulthood, examining the volume of Rathke's pouch and its derivatives, the position and number of dividing cells, the rate of apoptosis, and cell migration by pulse labeling. The results suggest that anterior pituitary progenitors normally leave the perilumenal region of Rathke's pouch and migrate to form the anterior lobe as they differentiate. Some of the cells that seed the anterior lobe during organogenesis have proliferative potential, supporting the expansion of the anterior lobe after birth. Prop1-deficient fetal pituitaries are dysmorphic because mutant cells are retained in the perilumenal area and fail to differentiate. After birth, mutant pituitaries exhibit enhanced apoptosis and reduced proliferation, apparently because the mutant anterior lobe is not seeded with progenitors. These studies suggest a mechanism for Prop1 action and an explanation for some of the clinical findings in human patients.

Isolated growth hormone deficiency in Chilean patients: clinical and molecular analysis

Isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) is a disorder that leads to short stature. It has been classified into types IA, IB, II and III. GH gene mutations and growth hormone releasing hormone (GHRH) receptor gene mutations have been described in patients with IGHD. We report here a clinical and molecular study of 27 Chilean patients with IGHD. We performed GH stimulation tests with GHRH and GHRP, and segregation and molecular analysis of the GH, GHRH and GHRH receptor genes. We describe four patients with IGHD IA bearing a 7 kb mutation (13%), and two IGHD II patients who showed two different splice site point mutations (6.8%). In 21 patients, we did not find a mutation in any of the three genes examined. These results led us to conclude that the molecular causes of IGHD involve other genes besides those analyzed in this report, as has been reported previously in patients of different ethnic origins.

Congenital secondary hypothyroidism due to a mutation C105Vfs114X thyrotropin-beta mutation: genetic study of five unrelated families from Switzerland and Argentina

We identified five patients with congenital secondary hypothyroidism with isolated thyrotropin (TSH) deficiency originating from three and two unrelated Argentinean and Swiss families, respectively. The affected patients presented with both low TSH as well as low thyroid hormone levels. Further, TSH-releasing hormone (TRH) stimulation failed to increase serum TSH, whereas prolactin increased adequately. These affected children were homozygous for a 1-bp deletion (822delT) in the TSH-beta subunit gene leading to a cysteine 105 to valine conversion (C105V) and to a frameshift with a premature stop codon at position 114 (C105Vfs114X). In a total of 22 families five different mutations located within the coding region of the TSH-beta subunit gene responsible for congenital secondary hypothyroidism have been reported so far (E12X; G29R; Q49X; IVS2 +5, G --> A; C105Vfs114X). Importantly, out of 13 families, including our five families, the C105Vfs114X mutation has been described in 12 unrelated and non-consanguineous families, whereas the remaining four TSH-beta subunit gene mutations have been described in consanguineous families only. Therefore the C105Vfs114X mutation within the TSH-beta subunit gene is the most frequent alteration causing congenital secondary hypothyroidism (13 of 22; 59%) and occurs mainly in unrelated and non-consanguineous families (12 of 13; 92%). As we could exclude a common ancestry by microsatellite marker analysis in our five independent families we concluded that the codon 105 in the TSH-beta subunit gene might be a "hot spot," although a founder effect has been reported in certain cases clustered in a highly specific and restricted geographical area.

Aromatase deficiency caused by a novel P450arom gene mutation: impact of absent estrogen production on serum gonadotropin concentration in a boy

We identified a new point mutation in the CYP19 gene responsible for aromatase (P450arom) deficiency in a 46,XY male infant with unremarkable clinical findings at birth. This boy is homozygote for a 1-bp (C) deletion in exon 5 of the aromatase gene causing a frame-shift mutation. The frame-shift results in a prematurely terminated protein that is inactive due to the absence of the functional regions of the enzyme. Aromatase deficiency was suspected prenatally because of the severe virilization of the mother during the early pregnancy, and the diagnosis was confirmed shortly after birth. Four weeks after birth, the baby boy showed extremely low levels of serum estrogens, but had a normal level of serum free testosterone; in comparison with the high serum concentration of androstenedione at birth, a striking decrease occurred by 4 weeks postnatally. We previously reported elevated basal and stimulated FSH levels in a female infant with aromatase deficiency in the first year of life. In contrast, in the male infant, basal FSH and peak FSH levels after standard GnRH stimulation tests were normal. This finding suggests that the contribution of estrogen to the hypothalamic-pituitary gonadotropin-gonadal feedback mechanism is different in boys and girls during infancy and early childhood. In normal girls, serum estradiol concentrations strongly correlate with circulating inhibin levels, and thus, low inhibin levels may contribute to the striking elevation of FSH in young girls with aromatase deficiency. In contrast, estradiol levels are physiologically about a 7-fold lower in boys than in girls, and serum inhibin levels remain elevated even though levels of FSH, LH, and testosterone are decreased.

Phenotypic variability in familial combined pituitary hormone deficiency caused by a PROP1 gene mutation resulting in the substitution of Arg-->Cys at codon 120 (R120C)

As pituitary function depends on the integrity of the hypothalamic-pituitary axis, any defect in the development and organogenesis of this gland may account for a form of combined pituitary hormone deficiency (CPHD). A mutation in a novel, tissue-specific, paired-like homeodomain transcription factor, termed Prophet of Pit-1 (PROP1), has been identified as causing the Ames dwarf (df) mouse phenotype, and thereafter, different PROP1 gene alterations have been found in humans with CPHD. We report on the follow-up of two consanguineous families (n = 12), with five subjects affected with CPHD (three males and two females) caused by the same nucleotide C to T transition, resulting in the substitution of Arg-->Cys in PROP1 at codon 120. Importantly, there is a variability of phenotype, even among patients with the same mutation. The age at diagnosis was dependent on the severity of symptoms, ranging from 9 months to 8 yr. Although in one patient TSH deficiency was the first symptom of the disorder, all patients became symptomatic by exhibiting severe growth retardation and failure to thrive, which was mainly caused by GH deficiency (n = 4). The secretion of the pituitary-derived hormones (GH, PRL, TSH, LH, and FSH) declined gradually with age, following a different pattern in each individual; therefore, the deficiencies developed over a variable period of time. All of the subjects entered puberty spontaneously, and the two females also experienced menarche and periods before a replacement therapy was necessary.

Prevalence of human GH-1 gene alterations in patients with isolated growth hormone deficiency

Human GH is encoded by the GH-1 gene which belongs to the GH gene cluster encompassing a distance of about 65 kb on the long arm of chromosome 17. Familial isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) is associated with at least four Mendelian disorders. These include two forms that have autosomal recessive inheritance (IGHD types IA and IB) as well as autosomal dominant (IGHD type II) and X-linked (IGHD III) forms. The aim of our study was to evaluate the prevalence of all GH-1 gene alterations by sequencing the whole GH-1 gene after PCR amplification among 151 affected subjects from 83 families with severe IGHD (height: <-4.5 SD score). A high frequency of GH-1 gene alterations was found in families with IGHD type IA (8/12, 66.7%), whereas only a low frequency of GH-1 gene defects was present in all the other GH-deficient families (7/71, 9.9%). The absolute frequency of GH-1 gene deletions was 8.7% (6/69), 11.8% (4/34), and 18.7% (9/48) in Northern Europeans, Mediterraneans, and Asians, respectively, giving an overall frequency of 12.5% (19/151). The sizes of the deletions were heterogeneous with the most frequent (78%) being 6.7 kb. In addition, 6% (9/151) of the patients presented GH-1 gene mutations such as frameshift, stop codon and splicing error. Furthermore, total GH-1 gene abnormalities varied among different populations from 11.6% in Northern Europe, 14.7% in Mediterranean countries and 31.2% in Asia. Most striking, however, was the low frequency rate of 1.7% (2/119) of GH-1 gene mutations responsible for the most common phenotype of IGHD, namely type IB, among the subjects characterized by the production of deficient but detectable amounts of GH after provocative stimuli. This finding underlines the necessity to focus rather on the promoter region of the GH-1 gene (cis-acting elements and trans-acting factors), and on other candidate genes specific for the GH axis than the GH-1 gene itself to define genetically the IGHD type IB phenotype in more detail.

Aromatase deficiency in a female who is compound heterozygote for two new point mutations in the P450arom gene: impact of estrogens on hypergonadotropic hypogonadism, multicystic ovaries, and bone densitometry in childhood

We report on a female who is compound heterozygote for two new point mutations in the CYP19 gene. The allele inherited from her mother presented a base pair deletion (C) occurring at P408 (CCC, exon 9), causing a frameshift that results in a nonsense codon 111 bp (37 aa) further down in the CYP19 gene. The allele inherited from her father showed a point mutation from G-->A at the splicing point (canonical GT to mutational AT) between exon and intron 3. This mutation ignores the splice site and a stop codon 3 bp downstream occurs. Aromatase deficiency was already suspected because of the marked virilization occurring prepartum in the mother, and the diagnosis was confirmed shortly after birth. Extremely low levels of serum estrogens were found in contrast to high levels of androgens. Ultrasonographic follow-up studies revealed persistently enlarged ovaries (19.5-22 mL) during early childhood (2 to 4 yr) which contained numerous large cysts up to 4.8 x 3.7 cm and normal-appearing large tertiary follicles already at the age of 2 yr. In addition, both basal and GnRH-induced FSH levels remained consistently strikingly elevated. Low-dose estradiol (E2) (0.4 mg/day) given for 50 days at the age of 3 6/12 yr resulted in normalization of serum gonadotropin levels, regression of ovarian size, and increase of whole body and lumbar spine (L1-L4) bone mineral density. The FSH concentration and ovarian size returned to pretreatment levels shortly (150 days) after cessation of E2 therapy. Therefore, we recommend that affected females be treated with low-dose E2 in amounts sufficient to result in physiological prepubertal E2 concentrations using an ultrasensitive estrogen assay. However, E2 replacement needs to be adjusted throughout childhood and puberty to ensure normal skeletal maturation and adequate adolescent growth spurt, normal accretion of bone mineral density, and, at the appropriate age, female secondary sex maturation.

Two brothers with a 7.0 kb gene deletion associated with isolated growth hormone deficiency type 1A

Familial growth hormone deficiency type 1A is an autosomal recessive disease, caused by various homogenous deletions of both alleles of growth hormone gene 1 (hGH1). The hGH1 gene deletion is an event occurring between the 5' and the 3' flanking regions by unequal recombination, which causes a deletion in the hGH1 gene, mostly of 6.7 kb and rarely 7.6 or 7.0 kb in size. Two brothers diagnosed with GH deficiency syndrome were sent to our hospital for further evaluation. DNA samples of the probands and controls were amplified by PCR; restriction endonuclease analysis was done with Sma I enzyme and the patterns were evaluated. Gel electrophoresis results showed that the two brothers had a 7.0 kb deletion. These are the third and fourth cases reported with a 7.0 kb deletion. Both patients responded well to replacement therapy and did not develop antibodies against rGH. No other relatives presented with macro deletions in the hGH1 gene.

The molecular pathology of pituitary hormone deficiency and resistance

In this chapter, we have reviewed the fast-moving area of the molecular pathology of pituitary hormone deficiencies and resistance. Examples have been described affecting all levels of pituitary function, i.e. the releasing hormone, its receptor, the pituitary hormone and its receptor, and the development of the pituitary gland. Other examples in these genes, and in those in which no mutation has yet been found, will undoubtedly be discovered in the next few years, throwing light on the structural basis of the gene product's function and allowing a greater understanding of endocrine physiology and pathophysiology. The main reason for this rapid progress in knowledge is the recent technological advances in mutation detection, which bring this activity within the grasp of the majority of reasonably equipped laboratories. Technological advancement, however is not all that it takes to carry out this work. The conditions caused by genetic damage such as we have described are rare, and there is clearly a requirement for great awareness on the part of the clinical endocrinologist. Patients in whom it is suspected that mutations such as these may occur require careful clinical and biochemical work-up. Indeed, in many instances, careful thought has to go into deciding what the phenotype of a particular mutation might be. Thus, the requirement for close collaboration between clinical and molecular endocrinologists has to be the important message for the future in this area of research.

Genetic and molecular analysis of familial isolated growth hormone deficiency

Familial isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) has been associated with complete deletions of the hGH-N gene encoding the pituitary growth hormone (GH) in a large number of cases. However, there is still no alternative empirical explanation for the remaining familial or non-familial IGHD cases. We studied a large kindred including five IGHD-affected first cousins to determine possible IGHD inheritance and whether the hGH-N gene was the cause of IGHD in this pedigree. Sex-linked and autosomal recessive transmission of IGHD in this kindred was rejected. Autosomal dominant inheritance was the most probable explanation according to a model of one locus with two alleles, one being dominant for IGHD, under genetic modifiers or epistasis. Southern blotting analysis (BamHI and HindIII digestions) was used to determine whether the hGH-N gene was present in the patients and their family members. Because we found that the hGH-N gene was present, five restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs; HincII, MspI-A and B, and BglII-A and B) linked to the hGH-N gene were used to try to identify the possible RFLP haplotypes in the pedigree that could be markers or associated with the abnormal hGH-N alleles responsible for IGHD. From the haplotype analysis, it appeared that other genes not linked to the hGH-N gene cluster were the cause of the IGHD phenotype in this kindred. An alternative conclusion could be that the hGH-N gene was responsible for IGHD in this kindred, if a mutation (gene conversion) at the MspI-B site or a reciprocal recombination event between the HincII and MspI-B sites occurred from generation P to F1 and a similar event took place from generation F1 to F2. The non-significant GH responses of patients to the growth releasing factor test confirmed that the hGH-N gene structural product or some step in its regulation was responsible for causing IGHD in this kindred. We suggest that genetic micromutations in the hGH-N gene are present and are responsible for IGHD. We developed a method using the polymerase chain reaction to amplify a 790-bp fragment of the hGH-N gene. The fragment spanned from the second part of the dyad symmetry region in the non-transcribed 5' end of the hGH-N gene to 9 bp before the alternative splice-acceptor site in exon 3. The expected fragment was verified by its digestion with seven diagnostic restriction endonucleases (BamHI, FspI, PstI, NdeI, BssHII, BglII and HincII).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The use of the polymerase chain reaction in prenatal diagnosis of growth hormone gene deletions

OBJECTIVE

Familial isolated growth hormone deficiency (IGHD) type IA is characterized by a complete absence of human growth hormone (hGH) resulting in most cases from either a 6.7 or 7.7 kb deletion of DNA containing the hGH-1 gene. These patients have a strong initial anabolic response to exogenous recombinant hGH (r-hGH) therapy, frequently associated with the development of immune intolerance to r-hGH which causes an arrest of response to r-hGH replacement. This disorder is inherited as an autosomal recessive trait.

PATIENTS AND DESIGN

In two pregnancies at risk, the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was applied as a method for identifying hGH-1 gene deletions in DNA obtained by chorionic villus sampling (CVS) in the first trimester.

RESULTS

Homozygotes for the 6.7kb deletion of DNA containing the hGH-1 gene were easily and conclusively detected by the absence of 1900, 761 and 712bp fragments after SmaI digestion of the polymerase chain reaction products. In contrast, the pattern found in heterozygotes for the hGH-1 gene deletion was difficult to distinguish from the pattern found in normal homozygotes.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the polymerase chain reaction method is valuable for diagnosing individuals who are homozygous for hGH-1 gene deletions, while heterozygotes and normal individuals may be difficult to distinguish from each other. We suggest that, in these cases, Southern blotting remains the analysis to perform.

Diagnosis of growth hormone deficiency

Many ways of evaluating the physiological state of hGH secretion exist, some of which have been touched upon and none of which has as yet proven infallible. Apart from important clinical features like history, physical data and growth rate, the diagnosis of altered pituitary function is based on tests and their interpretation. The physician responsible has to be informed on their effectiveness and pitfalls. Results should be interpreted in relation to developmental age (bone age) rather than chronological age. Research is under way to try to facilitate the diagnosis of varying degrees of alterations of hGH secretion. Reliability in predicting the effect of therapy with hGH is the ultimate aim in order to prevent unnecessary cost and disappointment for the patients. With the help of doctors involved in child care, such as physicians at kindergarten or school, it should be possible to start the slow process of investigating growth disorders at an early age.