The Influence of Allogeneic Red Blood Cell Transfusion Compared with 100% Oxygen Ventilation on Systemic Oxygen Transport and Skeletal Muscle Oxygen Tension After Cardiac Surgery: Retracted

Blood Conservation in Cardiac Surgery

Blood transfusion is the most common procedure in cardiac surgery. Increasing evidence exists that excess transfusions are harmful to patients. Transfusion reactions and complications, including infection, immune modulation, and lung injury, are known complications but underreported; hence, their significance is often disregarded. Furthermore, a number of randomized trials have shown that a restrictive transfusion strategy is equal to if not better than a liberal transfusion strategy. Despite the evidence for the use of restrictive transfusion triggers, its dissemination in the cardiac surgical community has met with resistance. In this review, we outline the risks of transfusion, compare restrictive and liberal transfusion strategies in cardiac surgery, and finally outline perioperative interventions to minimize transfusion in the cardiac surgical patient.

Transfusion triggers for guiding RBC transfusion for cardiovascular surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis*

OBJECTIVE

Restrictive red cell transfusion is recommended to minimize risk associated with exposure to allogeneic blood. However, perioperative anemia is an independent risk factor for adverse outcomes after cardiovascular surgery. The purpose of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to determine whether perioperative restrictive transfusion thresholds are associated with inferior clinical outcomes in randomized trials of cardiovascular surgery patients.

DATA SOURCES

The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, and EMBASE from inception to October 2013; reference lists of published guidelines, reviews, and associated articles, as well as conference proceedings. No language restrictions were applied.

STUDY SELECTION

We included controlled trials in which adult patients undergoing cardiac or vascular surgery were randomized to different transfusion thresholds, described as a hemoglobin or hematocrit level below which RBCs were transfused.

DATA EXTRACTION

Two authors independently extracted data from included trials. We pooled risk ratios of dichotomous outcomes and mean differences of continuous outcomes across trials using random-effects models.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Seven studies (enrolling 1,262 participants) met inclusion criteria with restrictive and liberal transfusion thresholds most commonly differing by a hemoglobin of 1 g/dL or hematocrit of 6-7%, resulting in decreased transfusions by 0.71 units of RBCs (95% CI, 0.31-1.09, p = 0.0002) without an associated change in adverse events: mortality (risk ratio, 1.12; 95% CI, 0.65-1.95; p = 0.60), myocardial infarction (risk ratio, 0.94; 95% CI, 0.30-2.99; p = 0.92), stroke (risk ratio, 1.15; 95% CI, 0.57-2.32; p = 0.70), acute renal failure (risk ratio, 0.98; 95% CI, 0.64-1.49; p = 0.91), infections (risk ratio, 1.23; 95% CI, 0.85-1.78; p = 0.27), or length of stay. There was no between-trial heterogeneity for any pooled analysis. Including four pediatric trials (456 participants) and 10 trials utilizing only intraoperative acute normovolemic hemodilution (872 participants) did not substantially change the results except that unlike the transfusion threshold trials, the hemodilution trials did not reduce the proportion of patients transfused (interaction p = 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Further randomized controlled trials are necessary to determine the optimal transfusion strategy for patients undergoing cardiovascular surgery.

Intraoperative blood transfusion of one or two units of packed red blood cells is associated with a fivefold risk of stroke in patients undergoing elective carotid endarterectomy

OBJECTIVE

Transfused blood can disrupt the coagulation cascade. We postulated that packed red blood cell (PRBC) transfusion may be associated with thromboembolic phenomena. We used propensity matching to examine the relationship between intraoperative PRBC transfusion and stroke during carotid endarterectomy (CEA).

METHODS

We selected CEA procedures from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program database from 2005-2009. We excluded bilateral, redo, and emergent procedures. We used multivariate logistic regression to identify independent risk factors for stroke. We then calculated a transfusion propensity score to match patients who received one or two units of transfused PRBC intraoperatively with patients of similar risk profiles who had not been transfused.

RESULTS

Our criteria resulted in 12,786 elective CEA patients. Of these, 82 (0.6%) received a one- to two-unit intraoperative transfusion. Thirty-day stroke rates were 1.4% (179/12,704) in the nontransfused group and 6.1% (5/82) in the transfused group (Fisher exact test, P = .007). In forward stepwise multivariable regression of risk factors, only hemiplegia, stroke history, and transient ischemic attacks were predictive of 30-day stroke. We used these same variables to calculate transfusion propensity. We matched 80 transfused patients with 160 controls, thus, creating two groups with very similar risk profiles differing only by their transfusion status. In the matched groups, there was a fivefold increase in the risk of stroke in transfused patients (Fisher exact test, P = .043)

CONCLUSIONS

Intraoperative transfusion of one to two units of PRBCs is associated with a fivefold increase in stroke risk. This holds true after consideration of stroke risk variables and operative duration as a surrogate for technical difficulty. The increased risk may be related to several effects of transfused blood on the coagulation inflammation cascade.

Intraoperative transfusion threshold and tissue oxygenation: a randomised trial

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Transfusion with allogeneic red blood cells (RBCs) may be needed to maintain oxygen delivery during major surgery, but the appropriate haemoglobin (Hb) concentration threshold has not been well established. We hypothesised that a higher level of Hb would be associated with improved subcutaneous oxygen tension during major spinal surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty patients aged 18 years or older scheduled for spinal fusion with instrumentation were included and randomised to receive RBCs at either a Hb concentration of 7·3 g dL(-1) (restrictive group) or a Hb concentration of 8·9 g dL(-1) (liberal group) (Registration no.: H-C-2009-072). Oxygen tension was measured with a polarographic electrode placed subcutaneously over the left deltoid muscle. The primary endpoint was subcutaneous oxygen tension at the time most patients were still undergoing surgery.

RESULTS

Forty-eight patients were included in the intention-to-treat analysis; 25 patients in the restrictive group and 23 patients in the liberal group. The median change in subcutaneous oxygen tension 60 min after surgical incision was -0·79 and -0·75 kPa in the restrictive and the liberal groups, respectively (P = 0·78). No significant difference was found in the lowest subcutaneous oxygen tension; -2·07 vs. -1·95 kPa in the restrictive and the liberal groups, respectively (P = 0·85).

CONCLUSION

A Hb concentration transfusion threshold of 8·9 g dL(-1) was not associated with a higher subcutaneous oxygen tension during major spinal surgery than a threshold of 7·3 g dL(-1), but the trial was compromised by methodological difficulties.

Retracted publications in the drug literature

Recent studies have suggested an increase in the number of retracted scientific publications. It is unclear how broadly the issue of misleading and fraudulent publications pertains to retractions of drug therapy studies. Therefore, we sought to determine the trends and factors associated with retracted publications in drug therapy literature. A PubMed search was conducted to identify retracted drug therapy articles published from 2000-2011. Articles were grouped according to reason for retraction, which was classified as scientific misconduct or error. Scientific misconduct was further divided into data fabrication, data falsification, questions of data veracity, unethical author conduct, and plagiarism. Error was defined as duplicate publication, scientific mistake, journal error, or unstated reasons. Additional data were extracted from the retracted articles, including type of article, funding source, author information, therapeutic area, and retraction issue. A total of 742 retractions were identified from 2000-2011 in the general biomedical literature, and 102 drug studies met our inclusion criteria. Of these, 73 articles (72%) were retracted for a reason classified as scientific misconduct, whereas 29 articles (28%) were retracted for error. Among the 73 articles classified as scientific misconduct, those classified as unethical author conduct (32 articles [44%]) and data fabrication (24 articles [33%]) constituted the majority. The median time from publication of the original article to retraction was 31 months (range 1-130). Fifty percent of retracted articles did not state a funding source, whereas pharmaceutical manufacturer funding accounted for only 13 articles (13%) analyzed. Many retractions were due to repeat offenses by a small number of authors, with nearly 40% of the retracted studies associated with two individuals. We found that a greater proportion of drug therapy articles were retracted for reasons of misconduct and fraud compared with other biomedical studies. It is important for health care practitioners to monitor the literature for retractions so that recommendations for drug therapy and patient management may be modified accordingly.

Hyperoxia may be beneficial

The current practice of mechanical ventilation comprises the use of the least inspiratory O2 fraction associated with an arterial O2 tension of 55 to 80 mm Hg or an arterial hemoglobin O2 saturation of 88% to 95%. Early goal-directed therapy for septic shock, however, attempts to balance O2 delivery and demand by optimizing cardiac function and hemoglobin concentration, without making use of hyperoxia. Clearly, it has been well-established for more than a century that long-term exposure to pure O2 results in pulmonary and, under hyperbaric conditions, central nervous O2 toxicity. Nevertheless, several arguments support the use of ventilation with 100% O2 as a supportive measure during the first 12 to 24 hrs of septic shock. In contrast to patients without lung disease undergoing anesthesia, ventilation with 100% O2 does not worsen intrapulmonary shunt under conditions of hyperinflammation, particularly when low tidal volume-high positive end-expiratory pressure ventilation is used. In healthy volunteers and experimental animals, exposure to hyperoxia may cause pulmonary inflammation, enhanced oxidative stress, and tissue apoptosis. This, however, requires long-term exposure or injurious tidal volumes. In contrast, within the timeframe of a perioperative administration, direct O2 toxicity only plays a negligible role. Pure O2 ventilation induces peripheral vasoconstriction and thus may counteract shock-induced hypotension and reduce vasopressor requirements. Furthermore, in experimental animals, a redistribution of cardiac output toward the kidney and the hepato-splanchnic organs was observed. Hyperoxia not only reverses the anesthesia-related impairment of the host defense but also is an antibiotic. In fact, perioperative hyperoxia significantly reduced wound infections, and this effect was directly related to the tissue O2 tension. Therefore, we advocate mechanical ventilation with 100% O2 during the first 12 to 24 hrs of septic shock. However, controlled clinical trials are mandatory to test the safety and efficacy of this approach.

Relationship between intraoperative fluid administration and perioperative outcome after pancreaticoduodenectomy: results of a prospective randomized trial of acute normovolemic hemodilution compared with standard intraoperative management

BACKGROUND

Pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) can be associated with significant blood loss and transfusion requirements, with potential adverse short- and long-term consequences. The aim of this study was to determine whether acute normovolemic hemodilution (ANH), an established blood conservation technique, reduces perioperative allogeneic transfusions in patients undergoing PD.

METHODS

One hundred thirty patients undergoing PD were randomized to ANH or standard management (STDM). In the ANH group, intraoperative blood collection was performed to a target hemoglobin of 8.0 g/dL; crystalloid and colloid were used for volume replacement. Strict transfusion triggers were applied during and after operation. Perioperative complications were prospectively assessed and graded for severity.

RESULTS

From July 2005 to May 2009, 209 patients were registered, 79 excluded, 65 were randomized to ANH, and 65 to STD. The groups were well matched for demographic, operative, and histopathologic variables. Patients undergoing ANH received over 2 L more fluid intraoperatively (6250 mL, range 2000-11850) compared with patients undergoing STD (3900 mL, range 2000-9000) (P < 0.001). Transfusion rates were similar (ANH = 16.9%, 30 units vs STD = 18.5%, 33 units; P = 0.82), as was overall perioperative morbidity (ANH = 49.2% vs STD = 47%, P = 0.86). There was, however, a trend toward more grade-3 complications in patients undergoing ANH (32% vs 23.1% STD, P = 0.17), and complications related to the pancreatic anastomosis (leak/fistula/abscess) were significantly higher in the ANH group (21.5% vs 7.7%, P = 0.045). The intraoperative fluid volume was higher for all patients with pancreatic anastomotic complications (n = 19), regardless of randomization arm (ANH 6000 mL, range 2800-11350 mL vs STD 5000 mL, range 2000-11850 mL, P < 0.042).

CONCLUSION

In this randomized trial of patients undergoing PD, ANH did not reduce allogeneic transfusions and resulted in more pancreatic anastomotic complications, likely related to greater intraoperative fluid administration. The benefits of ANH do not necessarily extend to all procedures, and restrictive intravenous fluid management during PD may help improve postoperative outcome.

The optimal hematocrit

Nearly 15 million units of packed red blood cells and whole blood are transfused annually in the United States alone. Until recently, the major risks from blood transfusion were thought to be transmission of viral infections, and overall, blood transfusion was believed by most providers to be safe. A safe hemoglobin threshold above which red cell transfusion is clearly unnecessary has not been established. This article addresses the numerous problems that surround the use and consequences of blood transfusion, such as hemoglobin and hematocrit levels, oxygenation, storage time, immunomodulation, infection, and anemia. The relevant literature is comprehensively reviewed.

[Perioperative management of Jehovah's Witness patients. Special consideration of religiously motivated refusal of allogeneic blood transfusion]

The religious organization of Jehovah's Witnesses numbers more than 7 million members worldwide, including 165,000 members in Germany. Although Jehovah's Witnesses strictly refuse the transfusion of allogeneic red blood cells, platelets and plasma, Jehovah's Witness patients may nevertheless benefit from modern therapeutic concepts including major surgical procedures without facing an excessive risk of death. The present review describes the perioperative management of surgical Jehovah's Witness patients aiming to prevent fatal anemia and coagulopathy. The cornerstones of this concept are 1) education of the patient about blood conservation techniques generally accepted by Jehovah's Witnesses, 2) preoperative optimization of the cardiopulmonary status and correction of preoperative anemia and coagulopathy, 3) perioperative collection of autologous blood, 4) minimization of perioperative blood loss and 5) utilization of the organism's natural anemia tolerance and its acute accentuation in the case of life-threatening anemia.

Early goal-directed therapy: on terminal life support?

Early goal-directed therapy (EGDT) has become regarded as the standard of care for the management of patients with severe sepsis and septic shock. The elements of EGDT have been bundled together as the "Sepsis Bundle," and compliance with the elements of the bundle is frequently used as an indicator of the quality of care delivered. The major elements of EGDT include fluid resuscitation to achieve a central venous pressure of 8 to 12 cm of water, followed by the transfusion of packed red cells or an inotropic agent to maintain the central venous oxygen saturation higher than 70%. Although the concept of early resuscitation is a scientifically sound concept, we believe that the major elements of the sepsis bundle are fatally flawed.

Anemia and red blood cell transfusion in neurocritical care

INTRODUCTION

Anemia is one of the most common medical complications to be encountered in critically ill patients. Based on the results of clinical trials, transfusion practices across the world have generally become more restrictive. However, because reduced oxygen delivery contributes to 'secondary' cerebral injury, anemia may not be as well tolerated among neurocritical care patients.

METHODS

The first portion of this paper is a narrative review of the physiologic implications of anemia, hemodilution, and transfusion in the setting of brain-injury and stroke. The second portion is a systematic review to identify studies assessing the association between anemia or the use of red blood cell transfusions and relevant clinical outcomes in various neurocritical care populations.

RESULTS

There have been no randomized controlled trials that have adequately assessed optimal transfusion thresholds specifically among brain-injured patients. The importance of ischemia and the implications of anemia are not necessarily the same for all neurocritical care conditions. Nevertheless, there exists an extensive body of experimental work, as well as human observational and physiologic studies, which have advanced knowledge in this area and provide some guidance to clinicians. Lower hemoglobin concentrations are consistently associated with worse physiologic parameters and clinical outcomes; however, this relationship may not be altered by more aggressive use of red blood cell transfusions.

CONCLUSIONS

Although hemoglobin concentrations as low as 7 g/dl are well tolerated in most critical care patients, such a severe degree of anemia could be harmful in brain-injured patients. Randomized controlled trials of different transfusion thresholds, specifically in neurocritical care settings, are required. The impact of the duration of blood storage on the neurologic implications of transfusion also requires further investigation.

Bench-to-bedside review: oxygen as a drug

Oxygen is one of the most commonly used therapeutic agents. Injudicious use of oxygen at high partial pressures (hyperoxia) for unproven indications, its known toxic potential, and the acknowledged roles of reactive oxygen species in tissue injury led to skepticism regarding its use. A large body of data indicates that hyperoxia exerts an extensive profile of physiologic and pharmacologic effects that improve tissue oxygenation, exert anti-inflammatory and antibacterial effects, and augment tissue repair mechanisms. These data set the rationale for the use of hyperoxia in a list of clinical conditions characterized by tissue hypoxia, infection, and consequential impaired tissue repair. Data on regional hemodynamic effects of hyperoxia and recent compelling evidence on its anti-inflammatory actions incited a surge of interest in the potential therapeutic effects of hyperoxia in myocardial revascularization and protection, in traumatic and nontraumatic ischemicanoxic brain insults, and in prevention of surgical site infections and in alleviation of septic and nonseptic local and systemic inflammatory responses. Although the margin of safety between effective and potentially toxic doses of oxygen is relatively narrow, the ability to carefully control its dose, meticulous adherence to currently accepted therapeutic protocols, and individually tailored treatment regimens make it a cost-effective safe drug.

Anemia of Inflammation in Critically Ill Patients

Anemia is seen frequently in critically ill patients and has several etiologies. This article reviews the causes with an emphasis on the effects of inflammation, examines the risks and benefits of current therapies, and discusses novel treatment options.

Blood management: a primer for clinicians

Blood transfusions are common in the hospital setting. Despite the large commitment of resources to the delivery of blood components, many clinicians have only a vague understanding of the complexities associated with blood management and transfusion therapy. The purpose of this primer is to broaden the awareness of health care practitioners in terms of the risks versus benefits of blood transfusions, their economics, and alternative treatments. By developing and implementing comprehensive blood management programs, hospitals can promote safe and clinically effective blood utilization practices. The cornerstones of blood management programs are the implementation of evidence-based transfusion guidelines to reduce variability in transfusion practice, and the employment of multidisciplinary teams to study, implement, and monitor local blood management strategies. Pharmacists can play a key role in blood management programs by providing technical expertise as well as oversight and monitoring of pharmaceutical agents used to reduce the need for allogeneic blood.

Efficacy of allogeneic red blood cell transfusions

The majority of intensive care unit (ICU) patients will receive a blood transfusion at some point during the course of their ICU stay, generally in an attempt to increase oxygen delivery and hence tissue oxygenation. The efficacy of red blood cell (RBC) transfusion can be evaluated through its effects on patient mortality or morbidity, or more simply by its effects on tissue oxygenation. Review of the available literature shows controversial results, with some studies showing that RBC transfusion may be efficacious while others do not. The true challenge lies in determining which patients will benefit from transfusion and those in whom it may be safe to delay or withhold transfusion. In this article, several key factors influencing the systemic and regional efficacy of blood transfusion will be reviewed.

[Tolerance to perioperative anemia. Mechanisms, influencing factors and limits]

Die zu erwartende Kostensteigerung im Transfusionswesen (steigender Fremdblutbedarf bei gleichzeitig rückläufiger Spendebereitschaft, Behandlungspflicht transfusionsassoziierter Folgeerkrankungen) erhöht den sozioökonomischen Stellenwert der Entwicklung institutionsspezifischer Transfusionsprogramme. Ein wesentlicher Bestandteil hierbei ist – neben einer schonenden Operationstechnik und der konsequenten perioperativen Anwendung fremdblutsparender Maßnahmen – die Ausschöpfung der natürlicherweise vorhandenen „Anämietoleranz“ des menschlichen Organismus (Toleranz größerer Blutverluste durch Verlust von „verdünntem“ Blut, Hinauszögern des Transfusionsbeginns bis nach chirurgischer Blutstillung, Gewinnung von autologem Blut). In der vorliegenden Übersicht werden die Mechanismen, Einflussgrößen und Grenzen dieser natürlichen Anämietoleranz für den Gesamtorganismus und für einzelne Organsysteme zusammengefasst und die sich daraus ergebende Indikation zur Erythrozytentransfusion abgeleitet. Unter kontrollierten Bedingungen (Narkose, strikte Aufrechterhaltung von Normovolämie, komplette Muskelrelaxierung, Hyperoxämie, Hypothermie) werden von kardiopulmonal gesunden Individuen kurzzeitig auch extreme Grade der Verdünnungsanämie [Hämoglobin- (Hb-)Wert <3 g/dl (<1,86 mmol/l)] ohne Transfusion toleriert. In der klinischen Routine bleibt diese Situation – nicht zuletzt in Ermangelung eines adäquaten Monitorings – jedoch auf spezielle Sonderfälle beschränkt (z. B. unerwartete große Blutverluste bei Zeugen Jehovahs, unerwarteter Engpass bei der Bereitstellung von Fremdblut). Die derzeit geltenden Empfehlungen verschiedener Expertenkommissionen decken sich dahingehend, dass perioperativ (1) bis zu einer Hb-Konzentration von 10 g/dl (6,21 mmol/l) auch bei alten Patienten und Patienten mit kardiopulmonalen Begleiterkrankungen eine Transfusion von Erythrozyten in der Regel nicht notwendig ist und (2) eine Transfusion bei jungen, gesunden Patienten ohne kardiopulmonale Vorerkrankungen (einschließlich Schwangeren und Kindern) erst ab einer Hb-Konzentration von <6 g/dl (<3,72 mmol/l) notwendig wird. Auch beatmete Intensivpatienten mit Polytrauma und Sepsis scheinen nicht von einer Transfusion auf Hb-Konzentration >9 g/dl (>5,59 mmol/l) zu profitieren. Bei massiven Blutverlusten und diffuser Blutungsneigung scheint ein Hb von 10 g/dl (6,21 mmol/l) zur Stabilisierung der Blutgerinnung beizutragen.

Microvascular response to red blood cell transfusion in patients with severe sepsis

OBJECTIVES

Microvascular alterations may play a role in the development of multiple organ failure in severe sepsis. The effects of red blood cell transfusions on microvascular perfusion are not well defined. We investigated the effects of red blood cell transfusion on sublingual microvascular perfusion in patients with sepsis.

DESIGN

Prospective, observational study.

SETTING

A 31-bed, medical-surgical intensive care unit of a university hospital.

PATIENTS

Thirty-five patients with severe sepsis requiring red blood cell transfusions.

INTERVENTIONS

Transfusion of one to two units of leukocyte-reduced red blood cells.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The sublingual microcirculation was assessed with an Orthogonal Polarization Spectral device before and 1 hr after red blood cell transfusion. Red blood cell transfusions increased hemoglobin concentration from 7.1 (25th-75th percentile, 6.7-7.6) to 8.1 (7.5-8.6) g/dL (p < .01), mean arterial pressure from 75 (69-89) to 82 (75-90) mm Hg (p < .01), and oxygen delivery from 349 (278-392) to 391 (273-473) mL/min.M (p < .001). Microvascular perfusion was not significantly altered by transfusion, but there was considerable interindividual variation. The change in capillary perfusion after transfusion correlated with baseline capillary perfusion (Spearman-rho = -.49; p = .003). Capillary perfusion was significantly lower at baseline in patients who increased their capillary perfusion by >8% compared with those who did not (57 [52-64] vs. 75 [70-79]; p < .01), while hemodynamic and global oxygen transport variables were similar in the two groups. Red blood cell storage time had no influence on the microvascular response to red blood cell transfusion.

CONCLUSIONS

The sublingual microcirculation is globally unaltered by red blood cell transfusion in septic patients; however, it can improve in patients with altered capillary perfusion at baseline.

Blood tranfusion in critically ill patients: state of the art

Anemia is one of the most common abnormal findings in critically ill patients, and many of these patients will receive a blood transfusion during their intensive care unit stay. However, the determinants of exactly which patients do receive transfusions remains to be defined and have been the subject of considerable debate in recent years. Concerns and doubts have emerged regarding the benefits and safety of blood transfusion, in part due to the lack of evidence of better outcomes resulting from randomized studies and in part related to the observations that transfusion may increase the risk of infection. As a result of these concerns and of several studies suggesting better or similar outcomes with a lower transfusion trigger, there has been a general tendency to decrease the transfusion threshold from the classic 10 g/dL to lower values. In this review, we focus on some of the key studies providing insight into current transfusion practices and fueling the current debate on the ideal transfusion trigger.

Perioperative blood transfusion and blood conservation in cardiac surgery: the Society of Thoracic Surgeons and The Society of Cardiovascular Anesthesiologists clinical practice guideline

BACKGROUND

A minority of patients having cardiac procedures (15% to 20%) consume more than 80% of the blood products transfused at operation. Blood must be viewed as a scarce resource that carries risks and benefits. A careful review of available evidence can provide guidelines to allocate this valuable resource and improve patient outcomes.

METHODS

We reviewed all available published evidence related to blood conservation during cardiac operations, including randomized controlled trials, published observational information, and case reports. Conventional methods identified the level of evidence available for each of the blood conservation interventions. After considering the level of evidence, recommendations were made regarding each intervention using the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology classification scheme.

RESULTS

Review of published reports identified a high-risk profile associated with increased postoperative blood transfusion. Six variables stand out as important indicators of risk: (1) advanced age, (2) low preoperative red blood cell volume (preoperative anemia or small body size), (3) preoperative antiplatelet or antithrombotic drugs, (4) reoperative or complex procedures, (5) emergency operations, and (6) noncardiac patient comorbidities. Careful review revealed preoperative and perioperative interventions that are likely to reduce bleeding and postoperative blood transfusion. Preoperative interventions that are likely to reduce blood transfusion include identification of high-risk patients who should receive all available preoperative and perioperative blood conservation interventions and limitation of antithrombotic drugs. Perioperative blood conservation interventions include use of antifibrinolytic drugs, selective use of off-pump coronary artery bypass graft surgery, routine use of a cell-saving device, and implementation of appropriate transfusion indications. An important intervention is application of a multimodality blood conservation program that is institution based, accepted by all health care providers, and that involves well thought out transfusion algorithms to guide transfusion decisions.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on available evidence, institution-specific protocols should screen for high-risk patients, as blood conservation interventions are likely to be most productive for this high-risk subset. Available evidence-based blood conservation techniques include (1) drugs that increase preoperative blood volume (eg, erythropoietin) or decrease postoperative bleeding (eg, antifibrinolytics), (2) devices that conserve blood (eg, intraoperative blood salvage and blood sparing interventions), (3) interventions that protect the patient's own blood from the stress of operation (eg, autologous predonation and normovolemic hemodilution), (4) consensus, institution-specific blood transfusion algorithms supplemented with point-of-care testing, and most importantly, (5) a multimodality approach to blood conservation combining all of the above.

Allogeneic red blood cell transfusion: Physiology of oxygen transport

Allogeneic red blood cell (RBC) transfusions have been shown to be associated with considerable risks. While their efficiency in many clinical situations has not been proven, the number of studies finding adverse outcomes in terms of morbidity (e.g. postoperative infections) and mortality continues to rise. In view of these facts, physicians involved in transfusion medicine have to be as restrictive as possible with RBC transfusions. Only a thorough knowledge of the physiology and pathophysiology of oxygen transport can be a solid base for meaningful transfusion decisions. Therefore, the goal of this article is to review the basics of oxygen transport and normovolaemic anaemia.

[Tolerance to perioperative anemia. Mechanisms, influencing factors and limits]

Die zu erwartende Kostensteigerung im Transfusionswesen erhöht den sozioökonomischen Stellenwert der Entwicklung institutionsspezifischer Transfusionsprogramme. Ein wesentlicher Bestandteil hierbei ist – neben einer schonenden Operationstechnik und der konsequenten perioperativen Anwendung fremdblutsparender Maßnahmen – die Ausschöpfung der natürlichen „Anämietoleranz“ des menschlichen Organismus. Im vorliegenden Beitrag werden die Mechanismen, Einflussgrößen und Grenzen dieser Anämietoleranz für den Gesamtorganismus und für einzelne Organsysteme zusammengefasst und die sich daraus ergebende Indikation zur Erythrozytentransfusion abgeleitet. Die derzeit geltenden Empfehlungen decken sich dahingehend, dass bis zu einer Hämoglobinkonzentration von 10 g/dl (6,21 mmol/l) auch bei alten Patienten oder kardiopulmonalen Begleiterkrankungen eine perioperative Transfusion in der Regel nicht notwendig ist und bei jungen, gesunden Patienten ohne kardiopulmonale Vorerkrankungen (einschließlich Schwangeren und Kindern) erst ab <6 g/dl (<3,72 mmol/l) notwendig wird. Auch beatmete Intensivpatienten mit Polytrauma und Sepsis scheinen nicht von einer Transfusion auf eine Hämoglobinkonzentration >9 g/dl (>5,59 mmol/l) zu profitieren. Bei massiven Blutverlusten und diffuser Blutungsneigung scheint ein Wert von 10 g/dl (6,21 mmol/l) zur Stabilisierung der Blutgerinnung beizutragen.

Red cell transfusions and guidelines: a work in progress

Blood transfusion utilization continues to rise, yet it has never undergone prospective safety and efficacy testing. Recent data regarding oxygen delivery, microcirculation, and inflammation all point toward potential problems with allogeneic transfusion. Outcome data from retrospective data bases are sobering, calling to question the present practices of red cell transfusion.

New technology for transfusion safety

Hemovigilance programs from around the world document that the greatest risk to recipients of blood transfusion is human error, resulting in transfusion of the incorrect blood component. Errors in transfusion care have strong parallels with errors in medication administration. Errors often result from 'lapse' or 'slip' mistakes in which details of patient identification are overlooked. Three areas of transfusion are focal points for improved care: the labelling of the patient's pre-transfusion sample, the decision to transfuse and the final bedside check designed to prevent mis-transfusion. Both barcodes and radio-frequency identification technology, each ideally suited to matching alpha-numeric identifiers, are being implemented in order to improve performance sample labelling and the bedside check. The decision to transfuse should ultimately be enhanced through the use of nanotechnology sensors, computerised order entry and decision support systems. Obstacles to the deployment of new technology include resistance to change, confusion regarding the best technology, and uncertainty regarding the return-on-investment. By focusing on overall transfusion safety, deploying validated systems appropriate for both medication and blood administration, thoughtful integration of technology into bedside practice and demonstration of improved performance, the application of new technologies will improve care for patients in need of transfusion therapy.

Clinical consequences of red cell storage in the critically ill

Red cell (RBC) transfusions are a potentially life-saving therapy employed during the care of many critically ill patients to replace losses in hemoglobin to maintain oxygen delivery to vital organs. During storage, RBCs undergo a series of biochemical and biomechanical changes that reduce their survival and function. Additionally, accumulation of other biologic by-products of RBC preservation may be detrimental to recipients of blood transfusions. Laboratory studies and an increasing number of observational studies have raised the possibility that prolonged RBC storage adversely affects clinical outcomes. In this article, the laboratory and animal experiments evaluating changes to RBCs during prolonged storage are reviewed. Subsequently, the clinical studies that have evaluated the clinical consequences of prolonged RBC storage are reviewed. These data suggest a possible detrimental clinical effect associated with the transfusion of stored RBCs; randomized clinical trials further evaluating the clinical consequences of transfusing older stored RBCs are required.

Indications for Blood Transfusion in Cardiac Surgery

In addition to its life-saving effect in hemorrhagic shock, transfusion of allogenic packed red blood cells can be beneficial in situations where a critically low hematocrit is contributing to a state of oxygen-supply dependency. These benefits are countered by the risks of transfusion-associated lung injury, transfusion-associated immunomodulation, and cellular hypoxia after RBC transfusion. The critical hematocrit is patient and organ specific, and varies intraoperatively according to the duration and temperature of bypass, as well as for a variable postoperative period. Future randomized studies must prospectively evaluate regional indicators of tissue oxygenation in transfusion algorithms.

The impact of an hematocrit of 20% during normothermic cardiopulmonary bypass for elective low risk coronary artery bypass graft surgery on oxygen delivery and clinical outcome--a randomized controlled study [ISRCTN35655335]

Introduction

Cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) induces hemodilutional anemia, which frequently requires the transfusion of blood products. The objective of this study was to evaluate oxygen delivery and consumption and clinical outcome in low risk patients who were allocated to an hematocrit (Hct) of 20% versus 25% during normothermic CPB for elective coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery.

Methods

This study was a prospective, randomized and controlled trial. Patients were subjected to normothermic CPB (35 to 36°C) and were observed until discharge from the intensive care unit (ICU). Outcome measures were calculated whole body oxygen delivery, oxygen consumption and clinical outcome. A nonparametric multivariate analysis of variance for repeated measurements and small sample sizes was performed.

Results

In a total of 54 patients (25% Hct, n = 28; 20% Hct, n = 26), calculated oxygen delivery (p = 0.11), oxygen consumption (p = 0.06) and blood lactate (p = 0.60) were not significantly different between groups. Clinical outcomes were not different between groups.

Conclusion

These data indicate that an Hct of 20% during normothermic CPB maintained calculated whole body oxygen delivery above a critical level after elective CABG surgery in low risk patients. The question of whether a transfusion trigger in excess of 20% Hct during normothermic CPB is still supported requires a larger prospective and randomized trial.

Transfusion of erythrocyte concentrates produces a variable increment on cerebral oxygenation in patients with severe traumatic brain injury: a preliminary study

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the long-term influence of erythrocyte transfusion on cerebral oxygenation in patients with severe traumatic brain injury.

DESIGN

Prospective and observational study.

SETTING

Neurotrauma intensive care unit of trauma center level I.

PATIENTS

Sixty consecutive, hemodynamically stable patients with severe traumatic brain injury, pretransfusion hemoglobin<100g/l, non-bleeding and monitored through intracranial pressure and brain tissue partial pressure of oxygen (PtiO(2)) catheters were included.

INTERVENTIONS

Transfusion of 1-2 units of red blood cells.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

Ten sets of variables (pretransfusion, end of transfusion, and 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 12 and 24h after transfusion) were recorded, including: PtiO(2), cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP), end-tidal CO(2), peripheral saturation of oxygen, temperature, hemoglobin, lactate and PaO(2)/FiO(2) ratio. Transfusion was associated with an increase in PtiO(2) during a 6-h period, with a peak at 3h (26.2%; p=0.0001) in 78.3% of the patients. No relationship was observed between PtiO(2), CPP and hemoglobin increments. The relative increment in PtiO(2) at hour 3 was only correlated with baseline PtiO(2) (r(2) 0.166; p=0.001). All of the patients with basal PtiO(2)<15mmHg showed an increment in PtiO(2) versus 74.5% of patients with basal PtiO(2)>or=15mmHg (p<0.01, hour 3).

CONCLUSIONS

Erythrocyte transfusion is associated with a variable and prolonged increment of cerebral tissue oxygenation in anemic patients with severe traumatic brain injury. Low baseline PtiO(2) levels (<15mmHg) could define those patients who benefit the most from erythrocyte transfusion.

Significant reduction in blood loss in patients undergoing minimal extracorporeal circulation

Several recent studies have shown differences in blood loss and allogeneic transfusion requirements between on-pump and off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). Recently a new concept, the mini-extracorporeal circulation, was introduced to minimize the side effects of extracorporeal circulation. Therefore, there are no data comparing the three techniques with special emphasis to blood loss and transfusion requirements. Two hundred and eighty-five patients undergoing first-time coronary artery bypass grafting were retrospectively matched for number of grafts, age and sex. Ninety-five patients underwent surgery with the off-pump CABG (OPCAB) technique, 97 patients using conventional CABG with cold cardioplegia (CCABG) and 93 patients with the mini-extracorporeal circuit with warm blood cardioplegia (MCABG). Blood loss for the CCABG group with a mean loss of 819 +/- 557 mL and the OPCAB group with a mean loss of 870 +/- 768 mL was significant different compared to the MCABG group with a mean loss of 679 +/- 290 mL. The use of units red blood cell units was significantly higher for CCABG group and OPCAB group compared to the MCABG group. On the day of operation the use of platelet concentrate was significantly higher for the CCABG group compared to MCABG group. As a consequence of improvements of several components of the mini heart lung machine, significantly less blood products are needed in MCABG patients. The expected reduced need for transfusion when the pump was completely avoided could not be confirmed in this single retrospective cohort study.

Transfusion vs. alternative treatment modalities in acute bleeding: a systematic review

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

The practice of transfusion varies a great deal between countries and hospitals. Therefore, a systematic literature review was performed to evaluate the evidence underlying practice of transfusion and alternative treatment modalities in acute bleeding. After a stepwise evaluation, 79 out of 2438 abstracts were approved as the evidence base.

RESULTS

Albumin for volume therapy is not better than artificial colloids or crystalloids and may be detrimental in trauma patients. No outcome difference has been proved between artificial colloids and crystalloids. Use of hypertonic solutions remains controversial, as do the concepts of delayed and hypotensive resuscitation. Healthy individuals tolerate acute, normovolaemic anaemia at 5 g haemoglobin/dl, but pre-operative haemoglobin < 6 g/dl gives increased mortality from surgical interventions. Keeping haemoglobin higher than 8-9 g/dl has not been associated with any positive effect on mortality or morbidity, even in patients with cardiovascular disease. The changes induced in erythrocytes by storage may be clinically insignificant. No alternative to erythrocyte transfusion was established. Evidence underlying the practice of thrombocyte and plasma transfusion is scarce. Available evidence on recombinant coagulation factor VIIa is insufficient to define its future role in acute bleedings. Antifibrinolytic drugs in general seem to reduce the need for transfusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Intravenous volume replacement and transfusion policies seem largely based on local tradition and expert opinions. As a result of the difficulties in performing controlled studies in patients with acute bleeding and the large number of patients needed to prove effects, other scientific evidence should be sought to better define best practice in this important field.

Influence of hematocrit and pump prime on cerebral oxygen saturation in on-pump coronary revascularization

BACKGROUND

The couplings between cerebral oxygenation (rSO2), on-pump hematocrit and circuit prime are explored in this study.

METHODS

Thirty-eight consecutive patients undergoing coronary revascularization with cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) were matched on preoperative hematocrit < 40% and > 40% (n = 16). Similarly, six blood prime patients were matched with six crystalloid prime patients. Hematocrit and rSO2 levels were then compared on CPB.

RESULTS

The preoperative hematocrit > 40% group retained higher levels on pump run (p < 0.01) and significantly higher rSO2 prior to CPB (64.8 +/- 9.6 versus 73.2 +/- 7.3), and on and off CPB (61.1 +/- 8.8 versus 67.4 +/- 6.4). Blood priming increased absolute rSO2 (2.3 +/- 6.3 versus -10.9 +/- 5.9) and % rSO2 (4.7 +/- 11.8 versus -14.2 +/- 7.4%) in the low hematocrit group.

CONCLUSION

Blood primes are instrumental in high-risk and low preoperative hematocrit patients in preventing cerebral oxygen desaturation during initiation and maintenance of CPB.

Hyperoxia in lethal methemoglobinemia: effects on oxygen transport, tissue oxygenation, and survival in pigs

BACKGROUND

Treatment of severe methemoglobinemia includes the avoidance of methemoglobin-inducing drugs, the application of methylene blue, and the administration of supplementary oxygen. However, the efficacy of the latter on oxygen transport, tissue oxygenation, and survival in the treatment of extreme methemoglobinemia is ambiguous. The objective was to assess whether using hyperoxic ventilation as the sole therapeutic intervention (i.e., ventilation with pure oxygen, Fio2 1.0) improves the short-term (6-hr) survival rate during otherwise lethal methemoglobinemia.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, controlled study.

SETTING

Experimental animal laboratory of a university hospital.

SUBJECTS

Fourteen anesthetized, mechanically ventilated pigs.

INTERVENTIONS

After induction of profound methemoglobinemia (60 +/- 2%) by the injection of 15 mg/kg 4-dimethylaminophenol, artificial ventilation either was continued with room air (G 0.21, n = 7) or was changed over to hyperoxic ventilation (G 1.0, n = 7). A constant level of methemoglobinemia was maintained by continuous infusion of 4-dimethylaminophenol throughout a 6-hr follow-up period.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

All animals died within the 6-hr follow-up period, but survival time was prolonged in animals ventilated with pure oxygen (G 0.21, 105 +/- 30 mins; G 1.0, 210 +/- 64 mins, p < .05). No differences were encountered between G 0.21 and G 1.0 with respect to the investigated variables of macrohemodynamics, oxygen transport, and tissue oxygenation.

CONCLUSIONS

Hyperoxic ventilation has negligible effects on oxygen transport and tissue oxygenation during lethal methemoglobinemia; nevertheless, survival was increased without severe adverse reactions provoked by hyperoxic ventilation.