Recurrent Supplementary Motor Area Syndrome Following Repeat Brain Tumor Resection Involving Supplementary Motor Cortex

Persistent hemiplegia with normal intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring in supratentorial neurosurgery: a case report and review of literature

Intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring (IONM) is needed for evaluating and demonstrating the integrity of the central and peripheral nervous system during surgical manoeuvres that take place in proximity to eloquent motor and somatosensory nervous structures. The integrity of the monitored motor pathways is not always followed by consistent clinical normality, particularly in the first hours/days following surgery, when surgical resection involves brain structures such as the supplementary motor areas (SMA). We report the case of a patient who underwent surgical excision of a right frontal glioblastoma with normal preoperative, intraoperative (IONM), and postoperative central motor conduction, but with persistent postoperative hemiplegia (> 6 months). The literature regarding SMA syndrome and its diagnosis and prognosis is reviewed.

Detection of Subclinical Motor Speech Deficits after Presumed Low-Grade Glioma Surgery

Motor speech performance was compared before and after surgical resection of presumed low-grade gliomas. This pre- and post-surgery study was conducted on 15 patients (mean age = 41) with low-grade glioma classified based on anatomic features. Repetitions of /pa/, /ta/, /ka/, and /pataka/ recorded before and 3 months after surgery were analyzed regarding rate and regularity. A significant reduction (6 to 5.6 syllables/s) pre- vs. post-surgery was found in the rate for /ka/, which is comparable to the approximate average decline over 10-15 years of natural aging reported previously. For all other syllable types, rates were within normal age-adjusted ranges in both preoperative and postoperative sessions. The decline in /ka/ rate might reflect a subtle reduction in motor speech production, but the effects were not severe. All but one patient continued to perform within normal ranges post-surgery; one performed two standard deviations below age-appropriate norms pre- and post-surgery in all syllable tasks. The patient experienced motor speech difficulties, which may be related to the tumor's location in an area important for speech. Low-grade glioma may reduce maximum speech-motor performance in individual patients, but larger samples are needed to elucidate how often the effect occurs.

Deconvoluting human Brodmann area 8 based on its unique structural and functional connectivity

Brodmann area 8 (BA8) is traditionally defined as the prefrontal region of the human cerebrum just anterior to the premotor cortices and enveloping most of the superior frontal gyrus. Early studies have suggested the frontal eye fields are situated at its most caudal aspect, causing many to consider BA8 as primarily an ocular center which controls contralateral gaze and attention. However, years of refinement in cytoarchitectural studies have challenged this traditional anatomical definition, providing a refined definition of its boundaries with neighboring cortical areas and the presence of meaningful subdivisions. Furthermore, functional imaging studies have suggested its involvement in a diverse number of higher-order functions, such as motor, cognition, and language. Thus, our traditional working definition of BA8 has likely been insufficient to truly understand the complex structural and functional significance of this area. Recently, large-scale multi-modal neuroimaging approaches have allowed for improved mapping of the neural connectivity of the human brain. Insight into the structural and functional connectivity of the brain connectome, comprised of large-scale brain networks, has allowed for greater understanding of complex neurological functioning and pathophysiological diseases states. Simultaneously, the structural and functional connectivity of BA8 has recently been highlighted in various neuroimaging studies and detailed anatomic dissections. However, while Brodmann's nomenclature is still widely used today, such as for clinical discussions and the communication of research findings, the importance of the underlying connectivity of BA8 requires further review.

Frontal lobe low-grade tumors seizure outcome: a pooled analysis of clinical predictors

OBJECTIVE

Seizures present in 50-90 % of cases with low-grade brain tumors. Frontal lobe epilepsy is associated with dismal seizure outcomes compared to temporal lobe epilepsy. Our objective is to conduct a systematic review, report our case series, and perform a pooled analysis of clinical predictors of seizure outcomes in frontal lobe low-grade brain tumors.

METHODS

Searches of five electronic databases from January 1990 to June 2022 were reviewed following PRISMA guidelines. Individual patient data was extracted from 22 articles that fit the inclusion criteria. A single-surgeon case series from our institution was also retrospectively reviewed and analyzed through a pooled cohort of 127 surgically treated patients with frontal lobe low-grade brain tumors.

RESULTS

The mean age at surgery was 30.8 years, with 50.4 % of patients diagnosed as oligodendrogliomas. The majority of patients (81.1 %) were seizure-free after surgery (Engel I). On the multivariate analysis, gross total resection (GTR) (OR = 8.77, 95 % CI: 1.99-47.91, p = 0.006) and awake resection (OR = 9.94, 95 % CI: 1.93-87.81, p = 0.015) were associated with seizure-free outcome. A Kaplan-Meier curve showed that the probability of seizure freedom fell to 92.6 % at 3 months, and to 85.5 % at 27.3 months after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Epilepsy from tumor origin demands a balance between oncological management and epilepsy cure. Our pooled analysis suggests that GTR and awake resections are positive predictive factors for an Engel I at more than 6 months follow-up. To validate these findings, a longer-term follow-up and larger cohorts are needed.

Supplementary Motor Area Syndrome after Brain Tumor Surgery: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Supplementary motor area syndrome (SMAS) may occur after frontal tumor surgery, with variable presentation and outcomes. We reviewed the literature on postoperative SMAS following brain tumor resection.

METHODS

PubMed, Web-of-Science, Scopus, and Cochrane were searched following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines to include studies reporting SMAS after brain tumor resection.

RESULTS

We included 31 studies encompassing 236 patients. Most tumors were gliomas (94.5%), frequently of low-grade (61.4%). Most lesions were located on the left hemisphere (64.4%), involving the supplementary motor area (61.4%) and the cingulate gyrus (20.8%). Tractography and functional MRI evaluation were completed in 45 (19.1%) and 26 (11%) patients. Gross total resection was achieved in 46.3% cases and complete SMA resection in 69.4%. 215 procedures (91.1%) utilized intraoperative neuromonitoring mostly consisting of direct cortical/subcortical stimulation (56.4%), motor (33.9%), and somatosensory (25.4%) evoked potentials. Postoperative SMAS symptoms occurred within 24 hours after surgery, characterized by motor deficits (97%) including paresis (68.6%) and hemiplegia (16.1%), and speech disorders (53%) including hesitancy (24.2%) and mutism (22%). Average SMAS duration was 45 days (range, 1-365), with total resolution occurring in 188 patients (79.7%) and partial improvement in 46 (19.5%). 48 patients (20.3%) had persisting symptoms, mostly speech hesitancy (60.4%) and fine motor disorders (45.8%).

CONCLUSION

Postoperative SMAS may occur within the first 24 hours after mesial frontal tumor surgery. Preoperative mapping and intraoperative neuromonitoring may assist resection and predict outcomes. Neuroplasticity and interhemispheric connectivity play a major role in resolution.

Dexmedetomidine inhibits unstable motor network in patients with primary motor area gliomas

Background: Sedative agents such as dexmedetomidine have been found to transiently exacerbate or unmask limb motor dysfunction in patients with eloquent area brain gliomas. The present study aims to investigate whether dexmedetomidine can inhibit motor plasticity in patients with glioma via fMRI.

Methods: 21 patients with brain glioma were prospectively recruited between September 2017 and December 2018. Patients were classified into pre-M1 (primary motor cortex) group (n=9), post-M1 group (n=6), and non-eloquent group (control group) (n=6) according to the tumor position related to M1. The hand movement task-fMRI and resting state fMRI (rs-fMRI) were performed before and after sedation using dexmedetomidine. The lateralization index (LI) of activation voxels and magnitude and the functional connectivity (FC) of motor network were compared before and after sedation and among different groups.

Results: Permanent postoperative motor deficit of the upper limb was found in 5 of 6 patients in the pre-M1 group, and none in other groups (P < .01). Task-fMRI showed the LI of activation volume and activation magnitude at M1 significantly increased only in the pre-M1 group after sedation (P < .05). Rs-fMRI showed 60.0% (27 of 45) FCs of motor network decreased in pre-M1 group after sedation (p[FDR] < .05); whereas there was no FC reduction in post-M1 and control groups (p[FDR] > .05).

Conclusions: In patients with eloquent area gliomas, dexmedetomidine can inhibit the unstable compensative motor plasticity on both task- and rs-fMRI. fMRI may be a promising method for elucidating the effect of sedative agents on motor plasticity.

The Frontal Aslant Tract and Supplementary Motor Area Syndrome: Moving towards a Connectomic Initiation Axis

Simple Summary

Connectomics enables us to map whole brain networks that can be applied to operative neurosurgery to improve neuro-oncological outcomes. Damage to the superior frontal gyrus during frontal lobe surgery is thought to induce supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome in patients. However, network-based modeling may provide a more accurate cortical model of SMA syndrome, including the Frontal Aslant Tract (FAT). The aim of our study was to retrospectively assess if surgical tractography with diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) decreases the likelihood of SMA syndrome. Compared to patients who underwent surgery preserving the SFG (n = 23), patients who had their FAT and SMA networks mapped through DTI and subsequently preserved were less likely to experience transient SMA syndrome. Preserving the FAT and SMA improves functional outcomes in patients following medial frontal glioma surgery and demonstrates how network-based approaches can improve surgical outcomes.

Abstract

Connectomics is the use of big data to map the brain’s neural infrastructure; employing such technology to improve surgical planning may improve neuro-oncological outcomes. Supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome is a well-known complication of medial frontal lobe surgery. The ‘localizationist’ view posits that damage to the posteromedial bank of the superior frontal gyrus (SFG) is the basis of SMA syndrome. However, surgical experience within the frontal lobe suggests that this is not entirely true. In a study on n = 45 patients undergoing frontal lobe glioma surgery, we sought to determine if a ‘connectomic’ or network-based approach can decrease the likelihood of SMA syndrome. The control group (n = 23) underwent surgery avoiding the posterior bank of the SFG while the treatment group (n = 22) underwent mapping of the SMA network and Frontal Aslant Tract (FAT) using network analysis and DTI tractography. Patient outcomes were assessed post operatively and in subsequent follow-ups. Fewer patients (8.3%) in the treatment group experienced transient SMA syndrome compared to the control group (47%) (p = 0.003). There was no statistically significant difference found between the occurrence of permanent SMA syndrome between control and treatment groups. We demonstrate how utilizing tractography and a network-based approach decreases the likelihood of transient SMA syndrome during medial frontal glioma surgery. We found that not transecting the FAT and the SMA system improved outcomes which may be important for functional outcomes and patient quality of life.

Recovery time from supplementary motor area syndrome: relationship to postoperative day 7 paralysis and damage of the cingulum

OBJECTIVE

Supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome is defined as temporary paralysis after the resection of brain tumor localized in the SMA. Although in most cases paralysis induced by SMA resection resolves within a short period, the time until complete recovery varies and has not been precisely analyzed to date. In this study, the authors investigated factors for predicting the time required for recovery from paralysis after SMA resection.

METHODS

Data from 20 cases were analyzed. All 20 patients (mean age 54.9 ± 12.6 years) had undergone resection of frontal lobe glioma involving the SMA. The severity of postoperative paralysis was recorded until complete recovery using the Brunnstrom recovery stage index. To investigate factors associated with recovery time, the authors performed multivariate analysis with the following potentially explanatory variables: age, severity of paralysis after the surgery, resected volume of the SMA, and probability of disconnection of fibers running through or near the SMA. Moreover, voxel-based lesion symptom analysis was performed to clarify the resected regions related to prolonged recovery.

RESULTS

In most cases of severe to moderate paralysis, there was substantial improvement within the 1st postoperative week, but 2-9 weeks were required for complete recovery. Significantly delayed recovery from paralysis was associated with resection of the cingulate cortex and its deep regions. The factors found to influence recovery time from paralysis were stage of paralysis at postoperative day 7 and disconnection probability of the cingulum (adjusted R2 = 0.63, p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Recovery time from paralysis due to SMA syndrome can be predicted by the severity of paralysis at postoperative day 7 and degree of damage to the cingulum.

Postoperative isolated lower extremity supplementary motor area syndrome: case report and review of the literature

The supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome is characterized by transient weakness and akinesia contralateral to the side of the affected hemisphere. The underlying pathology of the syndrome is not fully understood but is thought to be related to lesions in the SMA, residing principally in the mesial superior frontal gyrus (Broadmann's area 6c). Although the SMA syndrome a well-characterized clinical entity, we report herein, to our knowledge, the first case of isolated lower extremity SMA syndrome in the literature. This case highlights the importance of considering this rare clinical entity in the context of new or worsening postoperative neurologic deficits. Moreover, early studies did not support somatotopic organization of the SMA as in the primary motor cortex; emerging evidence suggests that delicate somatotopic representation may underlie distinct presentations like that reported in the present case.

Postoperative supplementary motor area syndrome: clinical evolution and prognosis in nine patients after left hemispheric tumor resection

BACKGROUND

The postoperative supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome may complicate unilateral surgery involving the SMA cortex and manifests as contralateral or global akinesia, mutism, or speech deficit, with complete or major recovery in weeks to months.

CASE SERIES

We observed retrospectively nine patients (median age 47 years, range 27-60, five female) who underwent surgery for left premotor area tumors (six intra-axial and three extra-axial). Volumetric microsurgical resection was performed with neuro-navigational assistance (Vector Vision-BrainLab™ or SonoWand Invite™). We achieved gross or near gross total resection in all cases. The patients were followed clinically for one year, with control computed tomography scan within 24-48 hours from the operation and control magnetic resonance imaging three months and one year postoperatively. Five patients had only akinesia of the contralateral limbs, two had akinesia and mutism, and the remaining two had mutism only. All recovered within three months. The severity and duration were related to the location of resection rather than the volume removed. Cortical excision closer to the premotor area was related to more prominent SMA syndrome, while the cingular gyrus' involvement related to mutism.

CONCLUSION

Prevention of SMA syndrome is not always possible in resective surgery. Given its favorable prognosis, it should be well known to the health professionals of different specialties engaged in such patients' postoperative care. The possibility of SMA should be preoperatively discussed with the patients and caregivers. HIPPOKRATIA 2020, 24(1): 38-42.

Neuropsychological assessment of patients undergoing surgery due to low-grade glioma involving the supplementary motor area

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study was to establish the usefulness of various neuropsychological tests in patients undergoing surgery due to low-grade glioma (LGG) involving supplementary motor area (SMA).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

21 patients diagnosed with LGG involving the SMA underwent, before and after surgery, screening tests (Mini Mental State Examination - MMSE, Montreal Cognitive Assessment - MoCA and Frontal Assessment Battery - FAB), tests to assess language functions (Addenbrook's Cognitive Examination-III - ACE-III, phonetic fluency tests and semantic fluency tests), tests to assess memory functions (Rey's 15-word test - RAVLT and Diagnostic Test for Brain Damage by Hillers- DCS), tests to assess executive functions (Wisconsin Card Sorting Test - WCST, Ruff Figural Fluency Test - RFFT and Trail Making Test).

RESULTS

Before surgery, in the screening tests the patients obtained below normal scores in the MoCA test only. After surgery, the scores of such tests were significantly worse than the scores before surgery, while the MMSE test scores continued to be within the normal range. In phonetic and semantic fluency tests, the patients obtained worse scores, both before and after surgery. The differences in the test scores between the two periods, i.e. before and after surgery, were statistically significant. Although the patients obtained worse scores both before and after surgery in the ACE III test, the differences in the test scores were not statistically significant. The scores obtained in all tests assessing the executive and memory functions before and after surgery were within the normal range. The scores in such tests (except the WCCT) dropped significantly after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients diagnosed with LGG involving the SMA reveal the impairment of cognitive functions, in particular language functions. After surgery, a significant impairment of all elementary cognitive functions, such as attention, memory, language and executive functions and complex cognitive functions, occurs. The most sensitive tests to detect cognitive disorders, executive dysfunctions and speech disturbances in patients undergoing surgery due to glioma include the MoCA, FAB and Phonetic and Semantic Fluency Tests.

Working Memory Deficits After Lesions Involving the Supplementary Motor Area

The Supplementary Motor Area (SMA)—located in the superior and medial aspects of the superior frontal gyrus—is a preferential site of certain brain tumors and arteriovenous malformations, which often provoke the so-called SMA syndrome. The bulk of the literature studying this syndrome has focused on two of its most apparent symptoms: contralateral motor and speech deficits. Surprisingly, little attention has been given to working memory (WM) even though neuroimaging studies have implicated the SMA in this cognitive process. Given its relevance for higher-order functions, our main goal was to examine whether WM is compromised in SMA lesions. We also asked whether WM deficits might be reducible to processing speed (PS) difficulties. Given the connectivity of the SMA with prefrontal regions related to executive control (EC), as a secondary goal we examined whether SMA lesions also hampered EC. To this end, we tested 12 patients with lesions involving the left (i.e., the dominant) SMA. We also tested 12 healthy controls matched with patients for socio-demographic variables. To ensure that the results of this study can be easily transferred and implemented in clinical practice, we used widely-known clinical neuropsychological tests: WM and PS were measured with their respective Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale indexes, and EC was tested with phonemic and semantic verbal fluency tasks. Non-parametric statistical methods revealed that patients showed deficits in the executive component of WM: they were able to sustain information temporarily but not to mentally manipulate this information. Such WM deficits were not subject to patients' marginal PS impairment. Patients also showed reduced phonemic fluency, which disappeared after controlling for the influence of WM. This observation suggests that SMA damage does not seem to affect cognitive processes engaged by verbal fluency other than WM. In conclusion, WM impairment needs to be considered as part of the SMA syndrome. These findings represent the first evidence about the cognitive consequences (other than language) of damage to the SMA. Further research is needed to establish a more specific profile of WM impairment in SMA patients and determine the consequences of SMA damage for other cognitive functions.

High-field intraoperative MRI in glioma surgery: A prospective study with volumetric analysis of extent of resection and functional outcome

BACKGROUND

High-field intraoperative MRI (IoMRI) is a useful tool to improve the extent of glioma resection (EOR).

OBJECTIVE

To compare the interest of 1.5T IoMRI in glioma surgery between enhancing and non-enhancing tumors, based on volumetric analysis.

METHODS

A prospective single-center study included consecutive adult patients undergoing glioma surgery with IoMRI. Volumetric evaluation was based on FLAIR hypersignal after gadolinium injection in non-enhancing tumors and T1 hypersignal after gadolinium injection in enhancing tumors. Endpoints comprised: residual tumor volume (RTV), EOR, workflow and clinical outcome on Karnofsky performance score (KPS).

RESULTS

Fifty-three surgeries were performed from July 2014 to January 2016. Thirty-four patients underwent one IoMRI, and 19 two IoMRIs. In non-enhancing tumors, intraoperative RTV on 1st IoMRI T2/FLAIR was higher than in enhancing tumors on T1 sequences (7.25cm³ vs. 0.74cm³, respectively; P=0.008), whereas the RTV on 2nd IoMRIs and final RTV were no longer significantly different. After IoMRI, 72% of patients underwent additional resection. In non-enhancing tumors, EOR increased from 77.3% on 1st IoMRI to 97.4% on last MRI (P<0.001). Taking all tumors together, final RTV values were: median=0cm³, mean=3.9cm³. Mean final EOR was 94%. In 25% of patients, KPS was reduced during early postoperative course; at 3 and 6 months postoperatively, median KPS was 90.

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative MRI guidance significantly enhanced the extent of glioma resection, especially for non- or minimally enhancing tumors, while preserving patient autonomy.

The crossed frontal aslant tract: A possible pathway involved in the recovery of supplementary motor area syndrome

INTRODUCTION

Supplementary motor area (SMA) syndrome is a constellation of temporary symptoms that may occur following tumors of the frontal lobe. Affected patients develop akinesia and mutism but often recover within weeks to months. With our own case examples and with correlations to fiber tracking validated by gross anatomical dissection as ground truth, we describe a white matter pathway through which recovery may occur.

METHODS

Diffusion spectrum imaging from the Human Connectome Project was used for tractography analysis. SMA outflow tracts were mapped in both hemispheres using a predefined seeding region. Postmortem dissections of 10 cadaveric brains were performed using a modified Klingler technique to verify the tractography results.

RESULTS

Two cases were identified in our clinical records in which patients sustained permanent SMA syndrome after complete disconnection of the SMA and corpus callosum (CC). After investigating the postoperative anatomy of these resections, we identified a pattern of nonhomologous connections through the CC connecting the premotor area to the contralateral premotor and SMAs. The transcallosal fibers have projections from the previously described frontal aslant tract (FAT) and thus, we have termed this path the "crossed FAT."

CONCLUSIONS

We hypothesize that this newly described tract may facilitate recovery from SMA syndrome by maintaining interhemispheric connectivity through the supplementary motor and premotor areas.

Supplementary motor area syndrome after surgery for parasagittal meningiomas

BACKGROUND

Resection within the supplementary motor area (SMA) may be accompanied by dramatic motor deficits and speech arrest when the dominant hemisphere is involved, termed the SMA syndrome. Typically, the muscle tone of the paralyzed extremities is preserved, and in most cases, a complete or near complete recovery is seen within a few months. The SMA syndrome has not been recognized for extra-axial tumor surgery in approximation of the SMA.

METHODS

We observed the SMA syndrome in a patient operated for a parasagittal meningioma in the posterior frontal region, and this observation intrigued us to prospectively collect similar cases.

RESULTS

In the period from January 2010 to December 2015, we observed five patients who developed a partial SMA syndrome after surgery for frontal parasagittal meningiomas. The muscle tone was preserved in the affected extremities. All patients experienced improvement in motor function within a few days, and on follow-up, three out of five patients had recovered completely. Three of the patients had meningioma WHO grade II.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgically induced SMA syndrome can easily be confused with pyramidal weakness. This series of cases demonstrate that the syndrome may also develop after removal of extra-axial tumors and is probably underdiagnosed and underreported. The good functional prognosis is helpful in the preoperative counseling and follow-up of these patients.

Cerebellar Mutism Syndrome and Other Complications After Surgery in the Posterior Fossa in Adults: A Prospective Study

BACKGROUND

Cerebellar mutism syndrome (CMS) is rarely described in adults; however, data on self-assessed linguistic complications after posterior fossa surgery do not exist.

METHODS

Through a prospective single-center study, data on 59 tumor operations in the posterior fossa were collected preoperatively as well as 1 week and 1 month postoperatively. Data on self-assessed problems in 5 CMS-related domains, CMS scores, and neurology as well as surgical procedure and complications were obtained.

RESULTS

Data on CMS-related complications were obtained on 56 of the 59 operations. None was found to have CMS according to the CMS score. Within each of the 5 domains, at least 9 operations (16%) were followed by development or worsening of self-assessed CMS-related complications. Self-assessed complications were found to be most frequent after primary tumor surgeries, although they were significant only for speech and motor complications (P value = 0.01 and 0.02). Speech and language complications occurred more frequently in midline tumors compared with lateral tumors (40% vs. 7%; P = 0.004). Surgical complications were similar to other studies.

CONCLUSIONS

We propose that speech and language problems in adults undergoing surgery in the posterior fossa occur more frequently than previously assumed. Some of the self-assessed complications might reflect components of the cerebellar cognitive affective syndrome. Our findings are consistent with the fact that midline location of the tumor is one of the few known risk factors for CMS in children. Thus, the cerebellar midline seems to be a vulnerable region for speech and language complications also in adults.